Gotovina et al Judgement Volume I - ICTY

Gotovina et al Judgement Volume I - ICTY Gotovina et al Judgement Volume I - ICTY

12.07.2015 Views

39277other administrations or departments when required in exceptional circumstances or inwar time. 14571. According to the Croatian regulations of the armed forces that were in force in1995, the Croatian armed forces, i.e. HV, were constituted by the National Guard andthe Home Guard. 146 Theunens testified in his expert report that the National GuardsCorps existed prior to the establishment of the HV and was replaced by the HV. 147 TheCroatian regulations of the armed forces further stated that the members of the armedforces were either standing personnel, which comprised soldiers, cadets, active militarypersonnel (guard members, active NCOs and active officers) and civilians, or reservepersonnel, which comprised reserve soldiers, reserve NCOs and reserve officers. 148Among the duties of members of the armed forces were to wear a uniform, regularinsignia of the armed forces, and carry a military ID. 149 Commanders were responsible,among other things, for military discipline and compliance with the international law ofwar. 150 Commanders were responsible for calling to account those members of thearmed forces who did not act according to the behaviour prescribed for militarypersonnel. 151 Members of armed forces had to carry out orders by superiorsunquestionably, to the letter and promptly, or else be called to account. 152 However,military personnel were not obliged to carry out criminal orders, and instead had toinform the superior of the commanding officer of the illegal order, and refuse to executeit. 15372. The Trial Chamber now turns to Gotovina’s position and the structure of theSplit MD. Marko Rajčić, the chief of artillery of the Split MD from April 1993 to June1996, 154 testified that under Croatian law, the highest operational commander inOperation Storm was the president of the state, as the commander-in-chief of the armed145 P2639 (Decision on the basis of organization of the Ministry of Defence, 13 November 1991), para.XVII.146 Ljiljana Botteri, T. 10926; D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 5(provision 1).147 P1113 (Reynaud Theunens, Expert Report, December 2007), pp. 18, 43, 52.148 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 5 (provision 2).149 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 5 (provision 3).150 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), pp. 5-6 (provision 4).151 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 7 (provision 10).152 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 9 (provisions 25 and 31).153 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 9 (provision 26).154 D1425 (Marko Rajčić, witness statement, 13 February 2009), para. 1; Marko Rajčić, T. 16236, 16275;P2323 (Military Police official note of Rajčić interview, 11 July 2008), p. 1.38Case No.: IT-06-90-T 15 April 2011 `

39276forces. 155 Gotovina was the operational commander during Operation Storm andcontinued as such during Operations Mistral and Southern Movement, commanding theHV and elements of the HVO who joined the HV after they moved into Bosnia-Herzegovina. 156 According to Rajčić, Gotovina was held in high esteem by HV officersand troops. 157 General Červenko, the Chief of the Main Staff, was Gotovina’simmediate superior. 158 The Special Police units of the MUP operated in between the twoMDs of Gospić and Split, under the command of Markač. 15973. With regard to the Split MD, Ljiljana Botteri, Assistant Commander for LegalAffairs of the Split MD during and after Operation Storm, 160 testified that sometime atthe end of 1992, General Ante Gotovina took over the command of what was then theSplit Operative Zone and later in 1993 became the Split MD. 161 To Botteri’s knowledgethere was no transfer of power from Gotovina to any other military authority duringOperation Storm and its aftermath. 162 Botteri listed Gotovina’s command staff, whichincluded the Chief of Staff, Rahim Ademi. 163 The Chief of Staff’s assistants included:Joško Bonacin (Intelligence); Rajčić (Artillery); and Jure Šundov (Home Guard). 164According to Botteri, it was common practice in the Split MD Command that themembers of the command staff or the Chief of Staff’s assistants would write orders intheir respective area of expertise which Gotovina would review and sign. 165 Botteri alsotestified that at other times individuals were authorized to sign on Gotovina’s behalf ifnecessary. 16674. Botteri testified that the Split MD consisted of the 4th Guards Brigade thoughduring Operation Storm a number of additional military units were subordinated to the155 Marko Rajčić, T. 16454-16455.156 Marko Rajčić, T. 16560-16561; D1429 (Protocol of meeting of 25 September 1999).157 Marko Rajčić, T. 16454.158 Marko Rajčić, T. 16564.159 Marko Rajčić, T. 16563-16564.160 P1005 (Ljiljana Botteri, witness statement, 20 January 2004), paras 11, 30-31; P1006 (Ljiljana Botteri,witness statement, 8 November 2007), para. 15; P1017 (Report on disciplinary measures and penalties forthe third quarter of 1995, signed by Ljiljana Botteri), p. 1.161 P1005 (Ljiljana Botteri, witness statement, 20 January 2004), paras 15, 28, 46.162 P1005 (Ljiljana Botteri, witness statement, 20 January 2004), para. 46; P1006 (Ljiljana Botteri,witness statement, 8 November 2007), para. 23.163 P1005 (Ljiljana Botteri, witness statement, 20 January 2004), paras 29, 46.164 P1005 (Ljiljana Botteri, witness statement, 20 January 2004), para. 29.165 Ljiljana Botteri, T. 10931.166 Ljiljana Botteri, T. 10931-10932.39Case No.: IT-06-90-T 15 April 2011 `

39277other administrations or departments when required in exception<strong>al</strong> circumstances or inwar time. 14571. According to the Croatian regulations of the armed forces that were in force in1995, the Croatian armed forces, i.e. HV, were constituted by the Nation<strong>al</strong> Guard andthe Home Guard. 146 Theunens testified in his expert report that the Nation<strong>al</strong> GuardsCorps existed prior to the establishment of the HV and was replaced by the HV. 147 TheCroatian regulations of the armed forces further stated that the members of the armedforces were either standing personnel, which comprised soldiers, cad<strong>et</strong>s, active militarypersonnel (guard members, active NCOs and active officers) and civilians, or reservepersonnel, which comprised reserve soldiers, reserve NCOs and reserve officers. 148Among the duties of members of the armed forces were to wear a uniform, regularinsignia of the armed forces, and carry a military ID. 149 Commanders were responsible,among other things, for military discipline and compliance with the internation<strong>al</strong> law ofwar. 150 Commanders were responsible for c<strong>al</strong>ling to account those members of thearmed forces who did not act according to the behaviour prescribed for militarypersonnel. 151 Members of armed forces had to carry out orders by superiorsunquestionably, to the l<strong>et</strong>ter and promptly, or else be c<strong>al</strong>led to account. 152 However,military personnel were not obliged to carry out crimin<strong>al</strong> orders, and instead had toinform the superior of the commanding officer of the illeg<strong>al</strong> order, and refuse to executeit. 15372. The Tri<strong>al</strong> Chamber now turns to <strong>Gotovina</strong>’s position and the structure of theSplit MD. Marko Rajčić, the chief of artillery of the Split MD from April 1993 to June1996, 154 testified that under Croatian law, the highest operation<strong>al</strong> commander inOperation Storm was the president of the state, as the commander-in-chief of the armed145 P2639 (Decision on the basis of organization of the Ministry of Defence, 13 November 1991), para.XVII.146 Ljiljana Botteri, T. 10926; D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 5(provision 1).147 P1113 (Reynaud Theunens, Expert Report, December 2007), pp. 18, 43, 52.148 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 5 (provision 2).149 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 5 (provision 3).150 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), pp. 5-6 (provision 4).151 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 7 (provision 10).152 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 9 (provisions 25 and 31).153 D32 (Croatian Regulations of the Armed Forces, 20 May 1992), p. 9 (provision 26).154 D1425 (Marko Rajčić, witness statement, 13 February 2009), para. 1; Marko Rajčić, T. 16236, 16275;P2323 (Military Police offici<strong>al</strong> note of Rajčić interview, 11 July 2008), p. 1.38Case No.: IT-06-90-T 15 April 2011 `

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!