violence against children WORLD REPORT ON - CRIN
violence against children WORLD REPORT ON - CRIN violence against children WORLD REPORT ON - CRIN
“I left home because my brother made me go out at two or three in the morning to do thingsI didn’t like doing. He offered me to his friends, to our uncles, to strangers.Then, the day my father tried to abuse me, I left.”Homeless adolescent girl, East Asia and the Pacific, 2005 VIII6tions, even having an abortion in the morningand receiving a customer in the afternoon. InMongolia, 33% of girls exploited in prostitutionindicated that they had been raped. 73 InJamaica, boys in prostitution reported thatthey were “at risk of violence from individualswho abhor homosexuals and think they shouldbe eradicated.” 74In recent years, unknown individuals in Hondurasmade a practice of abducting sexuallyexploited children, torturing and sometimesmurdering the victims. Surviving victimsdescribed how the perpetrators pretended tobe prospective ‘clients’ for sex, then took thevictims to lonely places where they were sexuallyassaulted, tortured, insulted and humiliated.The aggression had the characteristicsof ‘moral’ punishment or collective revengeagainst the bodies of children who weresocially abandoned and excluded – as if thegirls or boys represented the social evil to beeliminated. The abductors taunted their victims:“If you disappeared, nobody would askafter you.” 75Social condemnation is another critical aspectof the violence children in prostitution suffer.Even where deception has been practisedand the work awaiting the child falsely portrayed,the stigma of having been sexuallyactive makes it impossible for the child toreturn home. Young people exploited in thesex industry are often ashamed and are notaware that they are victims of abuse, believingthemselves to blame. An underlying sense ofguilt makes it difficult for them to talk abouttheir exploitation. 76,77Forced and bonded labourChildren in forced and bonded labour representtwo-thirds of children in the unconditionalworst forms of child labour, which by a conservativeestimate amount to 5.7 million childrenworld-wide according to ILO. 78,79 An unknownbut significant proportion are victims of trafficking;most cases are in Asia, but the practiceexists in all regions. Forced and bonded labourare classified as slavery according to the 1956Supplementary Convention on Slavery, andalthough they are universally regarded as criminal,these cases are very rarely prosecuted.The definition of forced labour comprises twobasic elements: work or service exacted underthe menace of a penalty, and work undertakeninvoluntarily. The menace or penalty can takemany forms; its most extreme form involvesphysical violence or restraint, or even deaththreats addressed to the victim or relatives.There can also be a subtler form of menace,for example, threats to denounce illegal workersto the police, or tell village elders aboutgirls forced to prostitute themselves in distantcities. 80Bonded servitudeA bonded child works in conditions of servitudeto pay off debts, which may have beenpassed down through generations. Normally, achild worker is bound to an employer or proprietorin return for a ‘loan’. In areas where thepractice is common, workers are from sociallyinferior groups or castes, have no say overterms of any employment, and their familiesare excruciatingly poor. In this situation the247Violence against children in places of work
248Violence against children in places of workchild is a commodity, and works in conditionstantamount to slavery.Though bonded labour survives elsewhere,much of the problem is concentrated in SouthAsia. India, with its vast population, has thelargest number of children in bonded labour(some estimates suggest that the figure may beas high as 15 million, 81 mostly from the dalitor scheduled caste community). This practicehas long been illegal, and since 1997, undera new Supreme Court injunction, there havebeen efforts to regulate it, bring perpetratorsto justice, and rescue children from servitude.These actions were inspired by strong localactivism. Sector-specific surveys have foundbonded child labour in small-scale mining,brick making, fish processing, gem cutting,carpet weaving, tanneries and fireworks production.Carpet-weaving manufacturers employchildren in conditions of severe bondage, andcoercion is often used for discipline and to curbprotests. 82 According to Human Rights Watchsurveys conducted in the silk industry in UttarPradesh in 1996 and 2003, the level of violencesuffered by children is high. They report thatloom owners abuse the children on a routinebasis; the children are often locked up, andtheir food is far from adequate. 83A similar picture emerges in Pakistan. 84 Feudalsocial structures give landowners power toexact labour from indebted families, and may‘gift’ a bonded servant to another landlord.In Sindh, documentary evidence of murder,sexual assault, kidnapping and physical assaulthas been collected by human rights groups. 85In Nepal, bonded labour involves minoritygroups in the now outlawed kamaiya systemin agriculture. A study which looked into thispractice found that 30% of the children whohad left their employer had done so becauseof ‘harassment or punishment’. 86 In all suchfeudal settings, the writ of law or the assertionof rights are absent. Intimidation, physicalpunishment and verbal humiliation reinforcea deep sense of inferiority and powerlessness.Indigenous groupsIn Latin America, as elsewhere, high levels offorced labour are endured by indigenous peoplesand their children, who typically also facehigh rates of poverty, discrimination and exclusion.People in remote areas are particularlysusceptible to coercive recruitment and debtbondage due to the weak presence of the State.In remote parts of Brazil, children are cheaperto hire and considered more docile. They workin tree-logging, wood-cutting, sugar cane plantations,mining, distilleries, and coal production,all of which are dangerous. 87 Since theyhave been invariably hired deceitfully, theyare indebted and have no chance of returninghome. The intolerable situation of childrenin small-scale gold mining in Madre de Dios,Peru, is well-known to human rights organisationsand the authorities. Around 20% of theminers are 11–18 years old. 88Vulnerability is enhanced by lack of officialidentity. Since they do not register births, indigenouspeople are invisible to national authoritiesand are therefore unable to denounceforced labour or seek redress. In Peru’s remotelabour camps in the Amazon basin, 20,000workers may be in forced labour, many accom-
- Page 217 and 218: “Ninety percent of the kids that
- Page 219 and 220: “It was like being crucified on a
- Page 221 and 222: “When I went to prison, I was aro
- Page 223 and 224: “I was tortured in prison and mal
- Page 225 and 226: 204Violence against Children in car
- Page 227 and 228: “We are beaten by security forces
- Page 229 and 230: 208Violence against Children in car
- Page 231 and 232: Case study: diversion pilot project
- Page 233 and 234: “We feel our juvenile justice sys
- Page 235 and 236: Case study: de-institutionalisation
- Page 237 and 238: 216Violence against Children in car
- Page 239 and 240: 218Violence against Children in car
- Page 241 and 242: 220Violence against Children in car
- Page 243 and 244: 222Violence against Children in car
- Page 245 and 246: 224Violence against Children in car
- Page 247 and 248: 226Violence against Children in car
- Page 249 and 250: 228Violence against Children in car
- Page 251 and 252: UNICEF/HQ06-0343. Giacomo PirozziPA
- Page 253 and 254: 232Violence against children in pla
- Page 255 and 256: “Raids are conducted on our work
- Page 257 and 258: “Preventive action against violen
- Page 259 and 260: ‘We all come from the same villag
- Page 261 and 262: “Bihari ustads (masters) punish t
- Page 263 and 264: 242Violence against children in pla
- Page 265 and 266: “If I broke something or did some
- Page 267: “In the seven years I was working
- Page 271 and 272: 250Violence against children in pla
- Page 273 and 274: “No child should have to fight a
- Page 275 and 276: 254Violence against children in pla
- Page 277 and 278: 256Violence against children in pla
- Page 279 and 280: The long struggle to end the use of
- Page 281 and 282: 260Violence against children in pla
- Page 283 and 284: “We have reduced the heavy work t
- Page 285 and 286: 264Violence against children in pla
- Page 287 and 288: 266Violence against children in pla
- Page 289 and 290: “The protection of children invol
- Page 291 and 292: 270Violence against children in pla
- Page 293 and 294: 272Violence against children in pla
- Page 295 and 296: 274Violence against children in pla
- Page 297 and 298: 276Violence against children in pla
- Page 299 and 300: 278Violence against children in pla
- Page 301 and 302: 280Violence against children in pla
- Page 303 and 304: KEYSTONE/AP- Photo/Dolores OchoaECU
- Page 305 and 306: 284Violence against children in the
- Page 307 and 308: “A paradigm shift is needed. We h
- Page 309 and 310: 288Violence against children in the
- Page 311 and 312: same age group. Preliminary data fr
- Page 313 and 314: 292Violence against children in the
- Page 315 and 316: “In all countries children with d
- Page 317 and 318: “They treat you badly. You don’
“I left home because my brother made me go out at two or three in the morning to do thingsI didn’t like doing. He offered me to his friends, to our uncles, to strangers.Then, the day my father tried to abuse me, I left.”Homeless adolescent girl, East Asia and the Pacific, 2005 VIII6tions, even having an abortion in the morningand receiving a customer in the afternoon. InMongolia, 33% of girls exploited in prostitutionindicated that they had been raped. 73 InJamaica, boys in prostitution reported thatthey were “at risk of <strong>violence</strong> from individualswho abhor homosexuals and think they shouldbe eradicated.” 74In recent years, unknown individuals in Hondurasmade a practice of abducting sexuallyexploited <strong>children</strong>, torturing and sometimesmurdering the victims. Surviving victimsdescribed how the perpetrators pretended tobe prospective ‘clients’ for sex, then took thevictims to lonely places where they were sexuallyassaulted, tortured, insulted and humiliated.The aggression had the characteristicsof ‘moral’ punishment or collective revenge<strong>against</strong> the bodies of <strong>children</strong> who weresocially abandoned and excluded – as if thegirls or boys represented the social evil to beeliminated. The abductors taunted their victims:“If you disappeared, nobody would askafter you.” 75Social condemnation is another critical aspectof the <strong>violence</strong> <strong>children</strong> in prostitution suffer.Even where deception has been practisedand the work awaiting the child falsely portrayed,the stigma of having been sexuallyactive makes it impossible for the child toreturn home. Young people exploited in thesex industry are often ashamed and are notaware that they are victims of abuse, believingthemselves to blame. An underlying sense ofguilt makes it difficult for them to talk abouttheir exploitation. 76,77Forced and bonded labourChildren in forced and bonded labour representtwo-thirds of <strong>children</strong> in the unconditionalworst forms of child labour, which by a conservativeestimate amount to 5.7 million <strong>children</strong>world-wide according to ILO. 78,79 An unknownbut significant proportion are victims of trafficking;most cases are in Asia, but the practiceexists in all regions. Forced and bonded labourare classified as slavery according to the 1956Supplementary Convention on Slavery, andalthough they are universally regarded as criminal,these cases are very rarely prosecuted.The definition of forced labour comprises twobasic elements: work or service exacted underthe menace of a penalty, and work undertakeninvoluntarily. The menace or penalty can takemany forms; its most extreme form involvesphysical <strong>violence</strong> or restraint, or even deaththreats addressed to the victim or relatives.There can also be a subtler form of menace,for example, threats to denounce illegal workersto the police, or tell village elders aboutgirls forced to prostitute themselves in distantcities. 80Bonded servitudeA bonded child works in conditions of servitudeto pay off debts, which may have beenpassed down through generations. Normally, achild worker is bound to an employer or proprietorin return for a ‘loan’. In areas where thepractice is common, workers are from sociallyinferior groups or castes, have no say overterms of any employment, and their familiesare excruciatingly poor. In this situation the247Violence <strong>against</strong> <strong>children</strong> in places of work