violence against children WORLD REPORT ON - CRIN
violence against children WORLD REPORT ON - CRIN violence against children WORLD REPORT ON - CRIN
“Cops are really aggressive with kids. They slam kids on the groundand when they strip search you they are rough.”Girl, 16, North America VI5punishment, ranging from beatings, beingforced to crawl, sitting in the sun, and havingmeals withheld. 118 In Yemen, more than onethirdof detained children reported beatingsand other cruel treatment; more than half of astudy sample said that they had been sexuallyabused, usually by guards and teachers. 119 Insome juvenile detention centres in Brazil, beatingsare a daily occurrence; children reportedthat guards verbally abused them, punchedthem with their fists, kicked them, and hitthem with wooden sticks. 120Violent practices are found in both industrializedand developing countries. Childrenmay be confined to cramped cells for weeksor even months, subjected to painful restraintsas a “disciplinary” measure, or forced to holduncomfortable physical positions for hours ata time. In the UK, information obtained inNovember 2005 revealed frequent use of painfulrestraints in four privately-run ‘secure trainingcentres’, in which children aged between12 and 17 were detained. Painful restrainingholds involving pressure to noses, thumbs andribs were used 768 times in the year, causinginjuries in 51 cases. 121Violence while in custody of policeand security forcesPolice and other security forces are oftenresponsible for violence against children. Childrenliving or working on the street are particularlyvulnerable to violence by police, includingharassment, beatings, sexual assault, andkillings. This is discussed at greater length inthe chapter on violence against children in thecommunity. However, it is important to notethat a significant part of this violence occursto children formally in the custody of policeand security forces, for example, during arrest,interrogation, or in police lock-ups. In Egypt,for example, children detained in police lockupsreported beatings with batons, whips,rubber hoses, and belts, and sexual abuse. 122In Nepal, 85% of children and young peopleinterviewed in prisons reported abusive treatmentwhile in the custody of police or securityforces, and 58.6% reported torture withmethods such as electric shocks, beatings withhard objects, beatings with their hands tied,and beatings while blindfolded. 123It is well documented that some police forcesroutinely use violence, including torture, toextract information and confessions from children.In Pakistan, the National Commissionfor Child Welfare and Development foundthat of juvenile detainees, 68% of respondentsreported having been forced to admit theirguilt. 124 In Papua New Guinea, children havebeen burned, cut with scissors, whipped whilenaked, and humiliated during interrogationsby police in order to get them to confess to acrime. 125 In some states, children have died asa result of police torture. 126In many countries, laws require children tobe transferred quickly from police custody toan appropriate children’s facility or broughtbefore a judge within 24 to 48 hours or less.However, in practice, children may remain inpolice lock-ups for long periods of time, oftenwithout notification to their parents or guardians.For example, in the Philippines, lawsrequiring police to inform the Department of197Violence against Children in care and justice institutions
“It was like being crucified on an iron bed. I tried to resist, but seven or eight guards pushed me downon my back onto a hard iron frame. They stretched out my arms and legs and chained them to the fourcorners of the bed. I had to lie there like that from the evening till the next morning.”Girl, 16, Middle East, 2003 VII198Violence against Children in care and justice institutionsSocial Welfare and Development within eighthours of a child’s arrest are frequently notobserved, and children may remain detainedin police cells for up to a month. 127 In Jamaica,an investigation in the late 1990s found thatmany children who were abused, neglectedor accused of only petty offences remainedin filthy and overcrowded police lock-ups forperiods of eight months or more. 128Similarly, violence may be used against childrenin the custody of security and militaryforces in occupied or disputed territories. InIsrael and the Occupied Palestinian Territory,over 1,400 Palestinian children were arrestedby Israeli military authorities between 2000and 2004. Affidavits by Palestinian childdetainees indicated that most were subjectedto one or more forms of mistreatment duringtheir period of arrest and interrogation includingsexual harassment, and physical and psychologicalthreats. 129Violence as a sentenceCorporal punishment as a sentence for childrenconvicted of offences has been prohibited in177 States and territories, and a series of humanrights judgments have condemned the practice.However, some 31 States and territories stillpermit corporal punishment as a court sentenceagainst children. 130 For example, Malaysia’sChild Act allows the whipping of children foundguilty of an offence. 131 In Tonga, the CriminalOffences Act stipulates that boys under the ageof 16 can be whipped up to 20 times.In certain countries, children who are judgedto have reached puberty may be sentenced topunishments of extreme violence, includingflogging, stoning, and amputation. For example,the CRC has expressed concern aboutsuch sentencing of children to States includingBrunei Darrussalam, the Islamic Republicof Iran, Nigeria, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, andYemen, and has recommended that these countriesamend existing laws to make these practicesunlawful. 132Although universally condemned and prohibitedby international law (ICCPR, article 6,CRC, article 37a), some States still demandcapital punishment for crimes committedby children. Since 1990, Amnesty Internationalhas recorded 39 reported executionsof child offenders in eight countries – China,the Democratic Republic of the Congo, theIslamic Republic of Iran, Nigeria, Pakistan,Saudi Arabia, the USA, and Yemen. 133 InMarch 2005, however, the US Supreme Courtruled that the death penalty could no longerbe imposed on individuals for crimes committedbefore the age of 18, and the remaining72 persons who had been sentenced to deathfor crimes committed as juveniles were thenremoved from death row. 134A life sentence without the possibility of releasefor offences committed by children is alsoproscribed by international law (CRC, article37a). However, at least 15 countries have lawsallowing this, although only a handful imposethe sentence in practice. Outside the USA,there are only about a dozen child offendersknown to be serving life sentences. In the USA,however, by 2005 some 2,225 individuals hadbeen sentenced to serve the rest of their lives
- Page 167 and 168: 146Violence against children in sch
- Page 169 and 170: 148Violence against children in sch
- Page 171 and 172: “Curriculum is far more than what
- Page 173 and 174: “When children grow up they keep
- Page 175 and 176: 154Violence against children in sch
- Page 177 and 178: dents are considered along with tho
- Page 179 and 180: 158Violence against children in sch
- Page 181 and 182: 160Violence against children in sch
- Page 183 and 184: 162Violence against children in sch
- Page 185 and 186: 164Violence against children in sch
- Page 187 and 188: 166Violence against children in sch
- Page 189 and 190: 168Violence against children in sch
- Page 191 and 192: UNICEF/HQ99-0638. Giacomo PirozziIR
- Page 193 and 194: 172Violence against Children in car
- Page 195 and 196: 174Violence against Children in car
- Page 197 and 198: 176Violence against Children in car
- Page 199 and 200: Human rights instrumentsThe Interna
- Page 201 and 202: “There were teachers [at the ‘o
- Page 203 and 204: 182Violence against Children in car
- Page 205 and 206: 184Violence against Children in car
- Page 207 and 208: 186Violence against Children in car
- Page 209 and 210: 188Violence against Children in car
- Page 211 and 212: 190Violence against Children in car
- Page 213 and 214: 192Violence against Children in car
- Page 215 and 216: 194Violence against Children in car
- Page 217: “Ninety percent of the kids that
- Page 221 and 222: “When I went to prison, I was aro
- Page 223 and 224: “I was tortured in prison and mal
- Page 225 and 226: 204Violence against Children in car
- Page 227 and 228: “We are beaten by security forces
- Page 229 and 230: 208Violence against Children in car
- Page 231 and 232: Case study: diversion pilot project
- Page 233 and 234: “We feel our juvenile justice sys
- Page 235 and 236: Case study: de-institutionalisation
- Page 237 and 238: 216Violence against Children in car
- Page 239 and 240: 218Violence against Children in car
- Page 241 and 242: 220Violence against Children in car
- Page 243 and 244: 222Violence against Children in car
- Page 245 and 246: 224Violence against Children in car
- Page 247 and 248: 226Violence against Children in car
- Page 249 and 250: 228Violence against Children in car
- Page 251 and 252: UNICEF/HQ06-0343. Giacomo PirozziPA
- Page 253 and 254: 232Violence against children in pla
- Page 255 and 256: “Raids are conducted on our work
- Page 257 and 258: “Preventive action against violen
- Page 259 and 260: ‘We all come from the same villag
- Page 261 and 262: “Bihari ustads (masters) punish t
- Page 263 and 264: 242Violence against children in pla
- Page 265 and 266: “If I broke something or did some
- Page 267 and 268: “In the seven years I was working
“Cops are really aggressive with kids. They slam kids on the groundand when they strip search you they are rough.”Girl, 16, North America VI5punishment, ranging from beatings, beingforced to crawl, sitting in the sun, and havingmeals withheld. 118 In Yemen, more than onethirdof detained <strong>children</strong> reported beatingsand other cruel treatment; more than half of astudy sample said that they had been sexuallyabused, usually by guards and teachers. 119 Insome juvenile detention centres in Brazil, beatingsare a daily occurrence; <strong>children</strong> reportedthat guards verbally abused them, punchedthem with their fists, kicked them, and hitthem with wooden sticks. 120Violent practices are found in both industrializedand developing countries. Childrenmay be confined to cramped cells for weeksor even months, subjected to painful restraintsas a “disciplinary” measure, or forced to holduncomfortable physical positions for hours ata time. In the UK, information obtained inNovember 2005 revealed frequent use of painfulrestraints in four privately-run ‘secure trainingcentres’, in which <strong>children</strong> aged between12 and 17 were detained. Painful restrainingholds involving pressure to noses, thumbs andribs were used 768 times in the year, causinginjuries in 51 cases. 121Violence while in custody of policeand security forcesPolice and other security forces are oftenresponsible for <strong>violence</strong> <strong>against</strong> <strong>children</strong>. Childrenliving or working on the street are particularlyvulnerable to <strong>violence</strong> by police, includingharassment, beatings, sexual assault, andkillings. This is discussed at greater length inthe chapter on <strong>violence</strong> <strong>against</strong> <strong>children</strong> in thecommunity. However, it is important to notethat a significant part of this <strong>violence</strong> occursto <strong>children</strong> formally in the custody of policeand security forces, for example, during arrest,interrogation, or in police lock-ups. In Egypt,for example, <strong>children</strong> detained in police lockupsreported beatings with batons, whips,rubber hoses, and belts, and sexual abuse. 122In Nepal, 85% of <strong>children</strong> and young peopleinterviewed in prisons reported abusive treatmentwhile in the custody of police or securityforces, and 58.6% reported torture withmethods such as electric shocks, beatings withhard objects, beatings with their hands tied,and beatings while blindfolded. 123It is well documented that some police forcesroutinely use <strong>violence</strong>, including torture, toextract information and confessions from <strong>children</strong>.In Pakistan, the National Commissionfor Child Welfare and Development foundthat of juvenile detainees, 68% of respondentsreported having been forced to admit theirguilt. 124 In Papua New Guinea, <strong>children</strong> havebeen burned, cut with scissors, whipped whilenaked, and humiliated during interrogationsby police in order to get them to confess to acrime. 125 In some states, <strong>children</strong> have died asa result of police torture. 126In many countries, laws require <strong>children</strong> tobe transferred quickly from police custody toan appropriate <strong>children</strong>’s facility or broughtbefore a judge within 24 to 48 hours or less.However, in practice, <strong>children</strong> may remain inpolice lock-ups for long periods of time, oftenwithout notification to their parents or guardians.For example, in the Philippines, lawsrequiring police to inform the Department of197Violence <strong>against</strong> Children in care and justice institutions