STF na Mídia - MyClipp

that students do not leave their constitutional rights at
the schoolhouse gate,” Shear said. He said that any
policy that required students to give access to
“password-protected electronic content” was “a clear
violation of their student’s First and Fourth Amendment
Constitutional rights.”
He added of companies that monitor athletes’ online
activities: “These companies are selling snake oil that
contains a major legal liability time bomb. To me,
there’s no difference in having to Facebook-friend a
coach than turning over user name and
Oklahoma’s athletic director, Joe Castiglione, said the
university required its athletes to friend coaches on
Facebook. He said that when athletes were questioned
about something that appeared on their Facebook
pages, they often responded, “Hey, you’re not
supposed to see that.” He said his answer was, “Well,
everyone else in the world can.”
Jeremy Foley, the athletic director at Florida, said his
department contracted with UDiligence to monitor only
the Gators’ football players.
“I’m not a big believer that it’s our responsibility to
monitor that 24-7,” Foley said. “If there’s an issue, we’ll
deal with it. We’re trying to run a business here. We’re
not trying to be Big Brother.”
Varsity Monitor’s Carnahan said that by allowing the
universities to determine how much access his
company gets, it leaves a “white space” for colleges to
make their own decisions. But Kevin DeShazo, the
founder of Fieldhouse Media, another company in the
expanding online monitoring field, said that his
company does not access private information and that
he is opposed to monitoring Facebook and forcing
athletes to download applications or give access to
The New York Times/ - Politics, Sáb, 31 de Março de 2012
CLIPPING INTERNACIONAL (Supreme Court)
password-protected content.
“To be forced to give you access, passwords or let
them be friends with you on Facebook — I get why
coaches feel like it’s necessary, but there has to be
some level of respect and trust with these kids,”
DeShazo said, adding that his company has focused
on educating athletes about the perils of social media.
At North Carolina, where a message on Twitter from
the former football player Marvin Austin in 2010
revealed that he was receiving impermissible benefits
and was a factor in his being suspended for the
season, the social media policy is strict.
Steve Kirschner, a spokesman for North Carolina’s
athletic department, said each of the university’s sports
teams had a coach or a staff member assigned to
monitor Twitter messages sent by its players.
Roy Williams, the men’s basketball coach, said he
recognized that social media were simply a fact of life.
His players are permitted to use social media sites,
though not without a warning.
“I tell the guys, ‘It’s America, you have freedom of
speech,’ ” Williams said. “If you say something and it
embarrasses me or the basketball program or your
family, I’m going to be disappointed.”
The legal questions are not as simple, however, and
the answers may not come from campuses but from
courtrooms and legislatures.
“These are murky waters,” Voth said, “and it’s a
problem that’s not going to be answered today or in a
few months or a year.”
103