12.07.2015 Views

Boston - American Association for Thoracic Surgery

Boston - American Association for Thoracic Surgery

Boston - American Association for Thoracic Surgery

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS
  • No tags were found...

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

89 TH ANNUAL MEETING MAY 9–MAY 13, 2009BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS36. Surgical Management of Secondary Tricuspid Valve Regurgitation:Anulus, Commissure, or Leaflet Procedure?Jose L. Navia, * Edward R. Nowicki, Eugene H. Blackstone, * Daniel E. Nento,Jeevanantham Rajeswaran, A. Marc Gillinov, * Lars G. Svensson, * Sharif Al-Ruzzeh,Bruce W. Lytle *Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USAInvited Discussant: Farzan FilsoufiOBJECTIVE: Anuloplasty has been the main technique used to manage tricuspidvalve (TV) regurgitation (TR) accompanying left-sided heart valve disease, buttechniques at the commissure or leaflet level may also be useful. This study soughtto compare early and long-term success of procedures per<strong>for</strong>med at anular, commissural,leaflet, and combined levels.METHODS: From 1990 to 2008, 2,277 patients underwent TV procedures <strong>for</strong>secondary TR concomitantly with mitral (n = 1,527, 67%), aortic (n = 180, 8.0%), orcombined (n = 570, 25%) valve surgery. These included anulus (rigid prosthesis[n = 584, 26%], flexible prosthesis [n = 1,052, 46%], DeVega suture [129, 5.7%], andPeri-Guard [n = 185, 8.1%] anuloplasty), commissure (Kay [n = 248, 11%]),and leaflet (edge-to-edge suture [n = 79, 3.5%]) procedures. 4,745 postoperativetransthoracic echocardiograms in 1,965 patients were analyzed (median follow-up20 days) and TV reoperations identified at follow-up (median 1.2 years).RESULTS: At 3 months, prevalence of 3+/4+ TR was least <strong>for</strong> combined Kay andleaflet procedures (2.4%) and Peri-Guard anuloplasty (3.8%), and similar (8.7% to11%) <strong>for</strong> other procedures (Figure). However, by 5 years, 3+/4+ TR had increasedonly slightly to 12% <strong>for</strong> isolated rigid prothesis anuloplasty. It was progressivelygreater <strong>for</strong> all other anular procedures (flexible prosthesis [16%], DeVega [24%],and Peri-Guard [44%]), and 19% <strong>for</strong> the Kay procedure. Freedom from TV reoperationwas 98% at 5 years, similar <strong>for</strong> all procedures (P = .3).CONCLUSION: Early success of treatment <strong>for</strong> TR secondary to left-sided heartvalve disease is best sustained over time by rigid prosthesis anuloplasty alone. Theprotracted failure pattern after Peri-Guard anuloplasty suggests abandoning thisprocedure.* AATS Member164

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!