Status Report on Global Neem Usage - Gtz

Status Report on Global Neem Usage - Gtz Status Report on Global Neem Usage - Gtz

12.07.2015 Views

3. NEEM AS A NON-SYNTHETIC PESTICIDEAs mentioned above more economical in depth investigation are necessary and all criteriahas to be taken into consideration to get a more precise picture about the economy of neembased pesticide application.Given the above figures there is still the perception that neem pesticides are too expensiveand can only compete under the given frame conditions in niche markets. Therefore thefollowing questions are of importance:• Are the current prices determined by the technology, management skills or form ofmarketing or• if all the factors are optimised – are the current product prices reflecting the laboriousprovision of raw material.Additionally it would be of interest which frame conditions must be changed to enable neempesticides a higher market share. Details of the study are presented elsewhere (34, 37):Based on the one step extraction technology the following results were gained:• The scale of production costs decreases when a greater quantity of pesticide is produced.• Marketing and distribution system of the present neem products are underdevelopedBoth factors alone would enable a price reduction of 25%-30%, which would make the neempesticides much more competitive with standard synthetic pesticides. Precondition would behigher investments in machinery and most of all in effective marketing and distributionsystems. A constraint might be in the long term a shortage of high quality raw material.Concerning the frame conditions main recommendations where:• Governmental research and extension systems should work out integrated croppingsystems which make use of neem products (e.g. IPM, organic farming systems) and• demonstrate and train farmers to use these systems.• The import of neem raw material and products should be free of tax (as it is currently thecase with synthetic pesticides in many DC)• Environmental and forestry departments should consider the planting of neem trees forfruit production in their programmes (planting space)One great handicap is the poor marketing and the resulting limited access that farmers haveto neem pesticides, particularly in those developing countries where neem products aremanufactured. The manufacturers are generally NGOs or small scale businesses withcomparatively small capital available to be invested in the marketing the products. Inaddition, most of them are not integrated into the existing structures for distributingpesticides. India is the one exception, since here there is a series of small, medium-sizedand larger enterprises manufacturing neem pesticides (of varying quality) and other neemproducts. The marketing is professionally organised and demonstration and training of IPMsystems which are integrating neem products are supported by the government.31

3. NEEM AS A NON-SYNTHETIC PESTICIDEComparing the economic aspects of a biological neem pesticide with synthetic pesticides issomething that needs to be considered separately for each country concerned, since theprices of synthetic pesticides and neem seeds differ from country to country. Although thereis a general tendency to abolish subsidies in many DC based on the pressure of the WorldBank and other donors, yet cheap synthetic pesticides are one decisive factor inhibiting thespread of neem pesticides. Chemical pesticides are still often subsidised by governments oreven made available by them, to encourage the growers to use pesticides in the first place.However, even in countries where pesticides are not subsidised, neem products have to datebeen relatively expensive and are offered at prices 30%-40% higher than such standard productsas Karate, Decis etc. (34, 36,37) since it is more promising for the small manufacturersto go for the high-quality, high-priced niche markets (35, 36).Still, a potential market already exists for neem pesticides in niche markets where neemcompetes more with other high-priced conventional and biological pesticides such as IGR, Btproducts etc.Niche markets served include organic farming, cases of pest resistance where conventionalpesticides have failed, and crops where pesticide residue cannot be allowed due to consumersensitivity. The latter case is of increasing significance due to the recently enforcedEU regulation and the Consumer Act in the US.Additionally, neem pesticides have a good future potential application as a standard in certaincash crops, and there might also be the possibility of moving into mass markets, reducingthe price and competing with conventional pesticides. This however bears a risk forsmall neem manufacturers who do not have sufficient capital to offer pesticides at low ratesto establish themselves on a particular market, as the huge supra-national agro-chemicalsuppliers do.It is also doubtful whether such a way of marketing is necessary, since there are severalexamples of neem being applied less frequently and therefore working out cheaper in themedium-term than conventional pesticides. This is due to the fact that the agro-system ismore stable when neem is used than when conventional pesticides are applied, and favoursnatural antagonists. In addition neem is also strengthen the physiology of the plants.It should not be forgotten that until now the long-term costs of synthetic products have notbeen considered – that is, their lasting effects on the natural environment. For example,synthetic pesticides may contaminate water or cause poisoning or allergies, which in turnmay incur immense costs for society in general. The authorities should cover the long timecosts by taxes on pesticides according to their toxicity. Indeed we can find that governmentsin DC often subsidise or permit the import of pesticides free of taxes (in contrast to otherinvestment goods) because they want to promote local agricultural production with the importof production factors such as agrochemical (High External Input Agriculture, “GreenRevolution”)However, when assessing the economic efficiency of neem, it is important to remember thatother secondary products can be obtained from the tree, which not only constitute additionalpotential forms of usage but also forms that can be marketed in their own right. Another32

3. NEEM AS A NON-SYNTHETIC PESTICIDEAs menti<strong>on</strong>ed above more ec<strong>on</strong>omical in depth investigati<strong>on</strong> are necessary and all criteriahas to be taken into c<strong>on</strong>siderati<strong>on</strong> to get a more precise picture about the ec<strong>on</strong>omy of neembased pesticide applicati<strong>on</strong>.Given the above figures there is still the percepti<strong>on</strong> that neem pesticides are too expensiveand can <strong>on</strong>ly compete under the given frame c<strong>on</strong>diti<strong>on</strong>s in niche markets. Therefore thefollowing questi<strong>on</strong>s are of importance:• Are the current prices determined by the technology, management skills or form ofmarketing or• if all the factors are optimised – are the current product prices reflecting the laboriousprovisi<strong>on</strong> of raw material.Additi<strong>on</strong>ally it would be of interest which frame c<strong>on</strong>diti<strong>on</strong>s must be changed to enable neempesticides a higher market share. Details of the study are presented elsewhere (34, 37):Based <strong>on</strong> the <strong>on</strong>e step extracti<strong>on</strong> technology the following results were gained:• The scale of producti<strong>on</strong> costs decreases when a greater quantity of pesticide is produced.• Marketing and distributi<strong>on</strong> system of the present neem products are underdevelopedBoth factors al<strong>on</strong>e would enable a price reducti<strong>on</strong> of 25%-30%, which would make the neempesticides much more competitive with standard synthetic pesticides. Prec<strong>on</strong>diti<strong>on</strong> would behigher investments in machinery and most of all in effective marketing and distributi<strong>on</strong>systems. A c<strong>on</strong>straint might be in the l<strong>on</strong>g term a shortage of high quality raw material.C<strong>on</strong>cerning the frame c<strong>on</strong>diti<strong>on</strong>s main recommendati<strong>on</strong>s where:• Governmental research and extensi<strong>on</strong> systems should work out integrated croppingsystems which make use of neem products (e.g. IPM, organic farming systems) and• dem<strong>on</strong>strate and train farmers to use these systems.• The import of neem raw material and products should be free of tax (as it is currently thecase with synthetic pesticides in many DC)• Envir<strong>on</strong>mental and forestry departments should c<strong>on</strong>sider the planting of neem trees forfruit producti<strong>on</strong> in their programmes (planting space)One great handicap is the poor marketing and the resulting limited access that farmers haveto neem pesticides, particularly in those developing countries where neem products aremanufactured. The manufacturers are generally NGOs or small scale businesses withcomparatively small capital available to be invested in the marketing the products. Inadditi<strong>on</strong>, most of them are not integrated into the existing structures for distributingpesticides. India is the <strong>on</strong>e excepti<strong>on</strong>, since here there is a series of small, medium-sizedand larger enterprises manufacturing neem pesticides (of varying quality) and other neemproducts. The marketing is professi<strong>on</strong>ally organised and dem<strong>on</strong>strati<strong>on</strong> and training of IPMsystems which are integrating neem products are supported by the government.31

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!