Adaptive goal-oriented finite element computation ... - FEniCS Project

!©"§#$ %§¢¡¤£¦¥¨§©£©§¡$ ¥(')§£*§+© -,.§+/01234 56£879:9£;§&@56AB§+/CEDGF0H0DJILKMONMSR

¡ ¢¤£¦¥¨§©£ "!#$%"& '( *)+# ,.-/"021-436587:9¨/?>?/:@A;B5DCE5D;GFI J ! & K &MLMN O P Q & RO O P # S T "M O S O ¤H

¥¢¡¤£S§©¥¡v&] O* K K jH "!q bdL & v# c " R MU §¦ "| #©Ẍ Ik f U O "!& Q v'a ) " Y[ W O f LXS Oo K < O*%& # pTM! f ¦¤ fML U LM&& S f¤ OLM%L& Q " & ! 4 " Y LM f‘ PU #c&se 'a *) 'SM * t O!!e 'a L!fl! ) )^"ff *ƒ&„eTf | U O I%Lf &seK"fMR v! "¨M"&sL ! " 4 "!& ^[ —q! & j# L "& f¨ " *L: R I b.L fL U– j fnQv!t "s"! " f s & f L 6• YA LMs "!f &M! & % O P *L Q – o ^ ' !!~ "! ' WeX YA )d#$LM!8Q|%Lf z–< f ) "* P O„ §K < "|%& #pTM! f ¦¤ „# qM!t U "!nf N !Q6•e :• "& r‡T Y[ O K < "|%& #JpTM! f ¦¤ y# ¦ U L f< Q "* *T 4 K "*& # p ! f ¦¤ ' r:• ¨ RO "!L< O U % "N)i "% "& * 'S & ^S P LM! f OK Mz f #\ K k fnQ!Ẍ t "!A ). §ƒ ¦¢" !! (# a M !"*o& LX PrE' N)"!L! O P Q &se]W & &se "* V ^s )¨&se H p M # ]! R f*L *fL U–< $# Q&%se " O' "!& QIR

S S " *% #ƒ M # !! E' U "X * p† | R :'¨ #. w "! ) & fv# m &LM U " W• k¡£¢¥¤§¦©¨R *R :' #ƒ P f f U % O! &LX f ' I –ˆ— ¦ Q M –ˆ— &! & N O P fr! o#$ & L!I%Q¡£¢¥¤§¦©¨ " !L P ¡£¢¥¤§¦©¨¦©¦!"$#©%'& < O f f K #~ T› k= " L U "! \ R Q &] O R !LX " "| "! Š t O![—qbdL< O P aL U ' P M L !e & "!Q MŒ bdL< O P #[! "_ f P ! " !t"| =es " # *&jL! O fnQ‘p % fL: P "f"M IR & f¤ f ¤ P % ! Y e¡£¢¥¤§¦©¨ !R MU r * P f U fL "!ˆ PY ! &¤Q W "!_#$ "& '( )l# UP "!’k fl "f< OM IR I=e fnQlp f M P… #T M "f"M IR "! UP I & L f &LXk¡£¢¥¤§¦©¨O P Q %m^ % fLM P $P Om—q!t "| ˆ– "L ¦l ƒ—\– ¦ Q¡£¢¥¤§¦©¨f IR" 4 "z # › " U eg ! " O f f RO O Pg #A SUP "! ‚ f U ey ! " % 4 QR

¤ % "¦ ¨ ¢ # #¥¤§¦©¨ %¥% ¨-, ©.¡£¢ £ ¡ ¢ £+¢¨ ¤©¨ ¨ % %¥¤§¦ ¤©¨ % Q M "S—q!t O* I=eQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQcQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q Q ‚ Uj' w "! *) ¦¤ f QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q Q P ! OS—\! "* =exQJQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQcQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q !£¢¥#"%$¥¤© &'¤§ ( Q ^=f h f L< O! =epT U L& % QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q # Qw "! f¤—\* ¦l "*L ‘Q„QJQcQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q *) Q ‚ U M$ L "! PY ! & Q„QJQcQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q *+MQ ¨. a P f¤^ f W 4 * Q„QJQcQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q MQ/SH

%XQ# &LM% O P "! /Œ L!I%‘QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQcQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q< )%XQ# Q › k P L^ U % "! Q„QJQ„QJQcQ„QJQJQ„QJQ„QJQJQ„QJQcQ„QJQ„Q

"! ) x& f { bdL !R "| t O! Š "!j—qbdL< O P w — oP M # & fML IH JK MLON §¢¡ £ ¡ ¥ £¤ §¦¥ ¡ ¥¨§© ¢ ¢ ¡ £ ¡ Q T f IŠ t "! O T f S f< ON g M PY ! &lQ 'S &! M f Y ey ) MU "M W• & O !LX " H f & P "!"" *< f Y e† x # Y " z#$L : P "!$#%'&)(:Q L Y X* k*

– U L Q w % O "! !!L|%% 4 " # Q Q : §¦ , ©¨f & & YA g O 'a #$L P f O l * PUPP "! ' QQQ DGF k& I#T M DGF k=*W "!"z fLM g‚ Q L ) M 'S #$L P ' !! Y[W• & O f Y ey–ˆ— ¦ "M Q# ¡ . 8 Q&% '( * LS " W• &] 4 !LM P . Q% I MUP S p¡./£¢ 8 Q) "! ) ‘ * PUP" "! I=e E' 6• M * f LM O fL< "! ¢ w"UPP "! V ' QQWQ DGFM & V R *e+#$L P ¦ Lj " ?V | – U Q Q ¢ LON ¤ , 8 Q H J OS L !LM P O H< z|% "UP | "UPP "! =e P f P J¥¢ LON ¤ , Q+ H ¢¦ . Q #X#$L P 'SM \'( ) Lƒ " W• &] 4 " m # * f uRR(V_h)u_h¦+# & ¨ , ! V k L ) E'S !LM P 3V k M "M W• IkO !LM P YA &MLM f ' I –ˆ— ¦ ¨ Q ¢&Q "M W• & O P ¢, k /S fL< O!afL "„ ;G365G/"0\=@M/N7 f¦ *< " y #o#$L : " jL f+# J * MPUPP O! =eP f I " \ # f O\ ;€7N:; =@M/N7:Q % "!< f *( " f Š 'S

¡0 , ¢; . 8 Q – f O R !R U" *f f RO O R V M w "! ) J * MPUPP O! =e\ ^`#X¥¤¦ H J F2¨§© §FLON . P N¡! Q ( ! — R !IR U M "M!t" v % O V # SW lY[c6• M * f ‡ . ) UPM % O! ‚ fr!t ' ,EFHGIG"J%? > LK F %? %@? Q 8 2 f K " "& !t"| =e " *% % V4'S RO "|e *< " I#d & O "!E PUPM L Y LM " L P |N I#. q !"* ˆ& O "! & PUP LQ|%% Œf H< f $U ! : MU & "! Š :% "Q& PUP LM Y[ L f< "|e P f I P " M WQ w "! *) & f"nV z &< OS*=e.! "V %? |e.&gk r'(g fu& # & O P ! M *e.* & # bdL< 4 " Qjp |k&U % !"* c& O t O!n ! O PrY[ 'a M |% €kŒ f¤*% *L&F %? Q # 8 %;:? 2 8 ?A:% 8

Q * f Q e !f cR : bdL< 4 " # q M L ) M 'S f M!t " k H< !f Q & Q O iYA L f< "*e… " f P Of Y[ YA f YA L f< "*e…& R k*2- 13'0# .0 2! 4. *% +"# ' 2!"! -$# # .%&(' E 2 K¥ 8 G : G :% 2 K 8 %;: G : G DB %8 Q % S X ¡ Œ " " *% Q % MUP S ^`# "& K 8 G : E K 2 8 %;: G G,B %8G% 2 Q *) bdL< O P # !t"| =ev " & O & O W "!"*=e.! (:• f V "UP ' (L f "*ey P f I P V " YA,E ¨§ 2 LK© N Q ¢ ¤£¦¥¢ N Q *+ ¡ £¦¥ N¡ Q P ¥ P N 8 Q ¢ Q f Q + " bdL RO "! J Q f Q Qr—qbdL< O P Q f & %Œ fl% ": " * R !e"Q!e w O! *) & fy Q *+ *L! p U¡ £¦¥ ¢ +¥ L N 3H J ¥ LON 8 Q J*) H U % 4 "lY ey "*Se !f^ ¢ ¥,£ L N ¡H.-0/ ) ¢ ¥ +¥ L21 IH J ¥ L N 8 Q J H MU *e.&& *e # ¢ f Q '(PY N # !! E' U'( O) # & #3c !t O* I=e b.L O P Q Q H J ¢ )54 © LON H J ¥ L N 2 HJ2/ ¥ L21 8 ‡ ẍ e. W "!!ex % "!q|%% { U e 'S ! 3/ ‡ ¨ M k % 'a )f "„Y er O! f YA fXedka f YA L f< "*e]# Q

& Q q " " ‚ f Y ej M ! " U" *\ f S #~ g ! & & nV V —q )d PnV—\| V‡ Y[V›"P P Q ¥¤ ¤ ¦ }9 D , Q – ff §¤ ¦ 0,¤ }9 D , 8 Q , 0 –f ! O(# *&¡ fr! "(# & D O¢u H< MJY H J ¢ )54 © LON Q # H J ¥ L N 2 HJ2/ ¥ L 1 8 Q % D " O P "!4# &jLM!t O P £¢4/ f„ M P f U –ˆ— ¦ " Y *% "RO ' " *& # ¥¤ ¤ ¦ D , Q;) , 0 f – §¤ ¤ ¦ D , 8 Q – f 0 , f H fi " " f H 2¨§© §FLON . P N¡.! Q;+ J F "QnQ' Q ,©¨ , !O8 Q N ¨ O P L LJ :' !e & t "! #o&] • &jL& f U f H< fP, G6• M!t f YA ! E' QI ! & ƒf * ‚W O P L L Y *< " a # f H f P f &gk\H< \ I P ! # N 'S ! Œ # P R ! " U ! & % * & • * ! 'S * f t O& :V 8Q Q V !t " UP |c f #( ! k& V – U Q Q Q M & ‚ * #D L f g n O!e. 'S ! & UJYA WR #ƒ M f ‚ O P 6• M * f & #_ c:• " !LM P Qp & O & O W "!!e f¨ "M " w "! ) J& M f¦ fu ] LXk& W O!P !LM P —qƒL U ' !e & t "!P " E• &] O P m# L f! " & ! +"2!$#&%('*),+"% - .02134.65Mj O P v " zMP ! OŒ zY ! "# & Q # MUP v & Ik^`#\ bdL

¡¡¡¡¦¦KKdiam(K)– U L Q q^=!!LM*% O P # f "& :V !t " UP |S f c # ! & zQ P f UP ! " w "! ) y * MPUPP O! =e o# &jL! O fyL U W Œ# *& # } f H

§¢¡ £ ¡ ¥¡ ¡ ¢ £ §¦¥ ¥ ¡ ¡ ¥ ¡¥¤L< O! =e„ " U L& %\ fg "f

!!L*% O f #_fL"! I=e Y ey " f U M # !! E' U PY ! &¢u8 f ©l " f< O% MQ "f¥¤ % 4 ¢ f H

H

U" V f¤L *e.&& %|e M M PY ! & gPY % N ¢ ¢ ¢ ¢ }¨¢ 8 Q 9. ¢ WR © I¡ E © ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡D¡ ¡ ¡ D © §@E § 4 §3D ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¦ 1 @ 2 1§©~Q 'S f< O& % "!~ & # W O!LM!L – ! Ofo M *L!#$L ¤ 9 }© ¤ 9 ¡ ¤ 9. ¤ 9. 8 Q *+ U 'a W "!!~ M # *& #ƒ M M & "![ PY ! & Q 6V f– R P f U fL< O! Y ! "(# *&¡ ¢ }£¢ 9 *L O :H< f}¨¢ ¢ }9 8 Q ¢ 9. " t O P O!A# *&] 4 #ƒ fL< O!m PY ! & f :H< fi ""SRO *% Y , ¢ ¤ ¤ 9. } , 8 Q – f 9 } „'( " f "! U' I ! M " !"* =e '( W L ! " I=e ¨ f M 'a ! "f U & ‡ ¨ # Q :V M b.L "!~ ẌL&& U LM V # !! E' Uu:• ": N O P !f 'S x'a¤ }© ¢ © }© }}©9 ¡ ¡ 9 Q 8 9 zH< "! bdL< O! =e PY N f Y exL U gU "! ) i * PUPP "! I=e Q ) *Œ !t ¡ O YA ! "U o Q3 U – Q + :V¥ Q f Q ) ('(cPY % 4 8 Q § Q # MJ6• " * S % O P OŒ ¤YA f * ‚ fl # *&jL! O o fy "f

¤ 8 8 } H (¦F ¦© 8 F ¦ F¡ 8 F L N 2 J H 8 2 1 @L21 L N & ¦L21 !LM P & "!aM PY ! & Q;) 6V f '( &jL| MX {*L Y # # " W• &] 4 "z #~ fML< "!< PY ! &Z JYA *< f Y e J! " U" 8¢¡¤£¦¥¨§©P f Œ zW O!t " ! — ' I iUP "!nbdL< I=e 8 ¢ J 8F L N 8 Q % H "!’k=bdL< & "LM ¥¤ 8 8 o M f H

¦¦¦ OS "f ! &f , –B f ‚ U fL< "!qM PY ! & g:• ": v % O P UP ¢ D ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ p *% UP # ' "*f ' Wë . j L rPM f U l UPM z !e?k & "! ' O¤L f 'S f * ‚ MU & "!T PY ! & r ¨ H< f t U L! O Pi' "& f Q M J& fc f J !IR U fL "![M PY ! & + f] M f & *a U jPY % O YA k! PU & R f¤*< " Q¨ # *% PV "* P # Sf R ! & f P Qr RO "!L< O P+ #Œ fL< O!o "Y ! & Q JH **g bdL ! " ‚ O P #v #$L P "! ¤ }9 BQ Q‰ M f< O% u PY ! &lQ " U" "!bdL< LM! #$L P O!a OSf . R !IR c:• "Œ !LM P~V f „M f# J! " ‚W O P Q P ! " * \& "*L ( Y[Œ fM! fY eyL U M 3%7 :;8/"9.,"07 8 :V ;G3*/:@?/"0 8 ( ¢z5G>:@

H fnQ "f

¡ ¡§D ¡ ¡ D +¥¡¦ : ¡ ¡ 4 ¥¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡¡'S ! SL ƒ H< fJ ! #X \ * Q \H ** * &MLM & "!n !LX " ., Q M„6• K* &LM fL< "! !LM P M ¡ ,Q !LM P ƒ M &] "!X fgfL "! PY ! & " L f P !'S q | g P _#$L! H !! f M WQ ^`# V"'( L ! & f O H< & " f U & *% O U e $' !! YA„6• !t fl!t 4 :V f|N "| R S#$ & cYAU U Q ¢ .&¤£ ¥ ' 4. #&' & ! %(! ' § ! ' "13% .& ' -"* U #$ & 8 # # !! E' MU * &] 4 #q Mj * W xYA L f ¨.%f< "M R =e "! UP & p §@E © § § 4 § MQ § MQ ¥ 4 MQ# 8O P 8 f I=ePQq^ 68 t U ! bdL< "! I=e & I%a !! 4k—qbdL< PxYA '( f IŠ ! & %Qz^ MQ# U % 4 " Y ex< "|% V o "L e?kẌ ?' "‚ M bdL< "! =e V f¦ * & O P P g ! & c! R ! WR Y[ L f l RO "!L< 4 '(lYA L f U P *% % x R |e ! & WQg— • "&! z #\ v! "* bdL< "! =eW lYA # L f 8V f #MV h N) V / " M Q—\ "! '( *). .V "* P~V )d!t "* P 4 '( L XQ "a „* Xk U z f XQ " UP :H< & f O a c ! & % Q 4%L "!< S ! & % ' ! " UP P % Y LM P ˆ MQ &jL*YA P % !! fnQ „'( UP %KLM f MQ# YA L f &LM f O f V

": Q M%Q¡¤S7:0I/";G5DC"7 63*/:;B58-49"5:;B365©¨Ž.;B58-49VM'S a c LM& Y[ # ! & % vH< "!~& Q ¨ L ) E'S _ && P % ": . § NV"'S "Y ! & f f c*% O U e{& UP c! "fx L I# & :H< & P Q Q¡ q5£¢X7>y>.78,"3N7N7Ng- 63%7N7>.-L¢zQ f Œ !!Œ" f U f O # % O P & v ! S P *N QI@A;G5 ¢z5I47> ¢]7NB.Qvp f * T M N 4 " !Lf U ]*& . %.QQ¡ q5£¢X7> 63*/:;B58-49

' We+ f f ”< U{P r ! & Y e+L U M # !! ' UY ! J'S ¢ & • 8Q Q !t" UP | ! & f W 4 % Q &Y ! MQ M *% O U eg LM ” U P ! & 'S ¢Q¡ i5£¢X7>y3N7£¢\9~7¢]7:9

! ¥© . . 2! 4. %(+2+ ¦ & # .$# 'f & P |%% 4 M & O "!aM f #G" Y ë P f MU x P ! ¢u |%% y' zf * Y LM fl! "f V – U Q MQ Q!YT=[0,−1]¢¡¢4¢¡¢¢¡¢¢¡¢¢¡¢¢¡¢¢¡¢13tn2X¢¡¢¢¡¢¢¡¢¢¡¢¢¡¢– U L MQp " ! ! |%% Q ! #D Y[ L f< "|e WR Y[ ff ! " & % 8 % Q f " v *&] "!’kq fyN U" *k8R : *Œ# a UP YA L f "*e §Q¤£ ¡ o ! Of P #ƒ " ! QbdL< O P #q! " !t O* I=e PU" M ' I ¤Y[ L f< "|e¤ P f I P Œf kj &] O!~ PY ! & H

¥¤ ¤ ¦ D , MQ – ff §¤ ¦ 0,¤ D , 8 MQ , 0 –¢ § ¤ §}9 9 .¡¡w ) & fl! "fMS '( O)# & OŒ P fMŒ "!¢ )54 © LON H J ¥ L N 2 H J / ¥ L21 8J H MQ 'a :H< cY ! M " # & fl! "a# *& D "^`# f H J ¢ )54 © LON MQ H J ¥ L N 2 HJ2/ ¥ L 1 MQ D * * " f MU ¢ –… fl–ˆ— ¦ "f f :H< fL "!~ PY ! & '( . KUP "!Ik`b.L =ez "( & R | W "!ƒ! " & % R Œ U" YA L f< "*e §f MQ # H - ¥ L 1 'S § T ! U x # YA L f< "*e §Q K! "fK # !! E' MU f |k ‚ flfL< PY ! & "!m ¤ ¤ 9 }9 , MQ % , f –'S MQ *) H - ¥ L21 8U L XQ# E' T "f

Wed Aug 29 16:38:22 2001u_magnitude100 1U L MQ# ˆp f< "M fy& ~VPY % f ' M ! % # ( !t O R * –¢¡¤£ ¤ Q M ! "!~ H

Q1.51Effectivity index0.500 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000Number of elements£¢.¦– U L MQ) \—ˆŠ IR =e f :• f H

¨ 3H -¡¡ 8 ¦% ( L21¢% F L§¢¡ £ ¡ ¥¡ ¢ ¥G© ¢ ¡ § ¥ ¢ ¥_§ ¢i£¨©ˆ© £ ¥¨§©£ £ ¥¢¡¡© § ¢ ©ˆ©‰¢ ¡ O & elf R ! f 'S " L K# ŒRO " LS=eX # P k "a& O "! YA ER #$"L & Q ¦¤ | # & " v6• P ! M " —q!t"| S– "L ¦¤ — – ¦ Q?p ! f Y "N) U L f — – ¦ L "!M L f *% f& OfMRO fz P X%Qq^ _ "M q & #$L f< "& N "!s Y[ LXs M ‹.1 N-49

¦ x2x1ndSU # Q ]› k= P LM U % "!BQ ( F " ! W "!ˆ X f O • J O*k– L fr "N)] nQ c & "![R Uj LM#$ & % "N)% "nQ ¦ o *% r U elf =e V % " & PM % # % " P'S Œ f 8 % o M f M!t " & SR : QR ¦ H > %? L F %? # Q % > %?¢¡? # Q › k` P L U "! " YA‘' f !Ie†L f‰ O ¦#$% O%LM "%": ‚ UO% "& o# " ! " !t O* v&] 4 t "!Q< );+ % / M '( fy Oo RO "!L T #m U % "! VM› K U e k^! " % 4 MP ! O !t "| YA fMe Oa "N) U E' 6V L!f Y[ ' * "o< 4 f f T! M U % "! pT f •§ Q —\! "* 6k=! "* K& O "!# !! E' S g! M "oL ! Of Uz' I *! c bdL< "!m ¤£ L MUS& fML!L V'S ! " ! " ! "* (&] O t "!dL ! "fˆ "! PMU M % "& < 4 " I ' "q! "f f V !!L€k% O f – U Q # Q Q LMS O!e. ( O "*L& P ! " !t "| & O "!& We YA RO "! f# S l !t "| :k=M!t "| &] 4 t "! V M R f f L ! "f Uj LQ < 4 f f R M pT f •§:V ¨ !t O* ]& O "! V& ") r Y ! … RO "!L< 4 M+› k` P L U % "!K O¤ † & P LWR f U U L! " I=e]‚ P Œ! "N)] nQ

p f • # f IR" 4 " f¤ "f¨ H¢¡¡Nonlinear ElasticMaterialStressElastic−PlasticMaterialStrainU L # Q * *|k`*% !t O P z# P ! " !"* & O "! f– !"* z! "* z& O "!8Q &] 4 t "! YA WR bdL< O!(fLM MU ! "f UyY LML ! Of Uz LS M e# !! E' f Š Œ< O Q'S¦ $# ),!$# '%5 & %(2! § ! . # '0%(+¤$ # &sL!t O P #[ SM U eg ! " % O O!ej " U % O P¦¤# PY ! &Œ f zR !L& U "!n# "Y ! &Q & !e# *&jL! O fr7:9~7:3B,"Fc>.-L¢/"5D9g5D9 %@?p LM& U ¦ ¦¤£ & ") bdL IR" O! 4/ ;ˆ< O k f f › P L U "!8Q #$L P :• !t f pTM f • Q

¢ %XQ ¤F§¢¡ £ ¡ ¥£ © ¢ ©m£ ¡ ¢ ¥ ¡¥¤ ¡ ¢ £ ¡ ¤ ¡ ¥ ¡¥¤ ¡ ¢ £¦§ £¨© ¡£¢ !IR Mq bdL< O P #M! " !t"| =e ' oM * YA f Y[ L f< "|eK%" P¢u!t |% K# T Y[ fMe ' ] %% O!ˆ "N) V – U Q %.Q Q z"Y N f! " & H< !f qL f &LX S U eg ! O % O O\ "N) U E' f' I „› k` P LŒ fy c U erf & U % "!BQ * I=e]#G ": £¢ RO "!L< O frL U "*e.&M vf M!t " k& r "M O O M "N)… $:• !t f !t O Q ¤¢ RO "!L< O f "y L OT zPY N f U e ! " O c " :WQ *% * k =e #G ": V # v "N)d ¦¤ fMLc^ V – U Q %XQ :V v !t O f{ M U e ! " O L UP %XQ Q¨ % BV + f + # ! O PrY[ 'a s U el ! " O fl ¨ I=e#G ": *L f f IŠ S& fLS! OfQ|%

2h2a2bU L %.Q % "!~%"N)g! "f f & fLM(^NQ % "N)g! U nV * \ –UP #ƒ MJYA fMer f ¡ o Mc' fM QMode I(Opening)Mode II(In−Plane Shear)Mode III(Out−of−Plane Shear)U L %XQ KH< I Py # & fL^ V & fML^^a fl& fL^*^^ ! "f U OSW –"! f % "N) Q YA

¦ $# ' %(+ '%& +"# f M f Y e f¤£T * IR !ePQ" U *e.&& %*ez fL M PY ! & „P b.L "f% o– U Q %XQ :V?'a331A*rc2aU %XQ & "!Œ PY ! &lQ § l P L 'S › k– L L U % "! RO "!L< O fnQ ¢ V f H f Y e¢¡ V %\ " 'S PU erf & U % "! RO "!L O fnQa‡ "!#ƒ M ! U f ' fM ¤ # % "N) !R ,E ¨§ 2 LK© N %XQ ¢ ¤£¦¥¥ ¢ N %XQ £ ¡( P § ( %XQ# 8 P § F %XQ&% F 8¢ ¥ ¢¦¥ P § %XQ) ' I cH< I c ! & Œ& f¤LM MU ! " . fibdL< "f O Y " P Q MU L!t O =e ' " PY N f L UP rYA L f "*ë P f I P #$Lfl % ON) ' fM £ ' " "L< "!!e S ‚ Q '( !LM PH< !f '( L fi "f< O% z fL< "!~ PY ! &lQ@

Q¢¤£¦¥¤£¨§ © £¦©© ¥ ! "#$%'&!# )( £¦© ( L 1¢¢ ©¡E(¡¡ ¦ ¡¦K 2 F( F F F¡ ( 2 ¦¢ © F¡ ( K ¡ F8 (¦8 (¦ (¡ E K¥8 2¡ F ( F¡ (¡¦ ¡ 8 ( F¢ FK¥ © F¥ © ( 2¦ 8 ¡ E HK¥ F 2¢F F¢¥ © F¥ © ( 2¦ $# ©$%(+ '%& +4# L '( f Š fML< "!Œ PY ! & Y[ W "L i'(i' !! RO "!L O lY[ x› k¢u P L] f† ¤ U e†f & U "!# &LM U ¤ U e† ! " O OK% "N) U E' Q 3 U ! " I=ey f *e.&& %*e M PY ! & "!m ! & H< " "Y f f fL ¤ ¤ 9. } , 8 %XQ , f – / ‡ ¨ ' !!ƒ UP f f UP M s # UP "!m#$L P Q # *& RO "!L< O f ' I & f LM! Q L U 'a &] O!? !LM P . f Q S! M " ‚W 4 "' !! YAc:• " 'S . ¡ . U MJU" "!nbdL< =er " „› k= " L U "!¢ H -¡¦ L F ¡ % 8 % %XQ+ WR '(c ¤ H J H ( 9 ¢ ¦ © +¥ L+*ELON %XQ 'S 8 F8 (8 F ( E 2 K¥¡ ¦¢ ¢8 (8 F (¡ (¡ %XQ ¡ ¡ ¦ ¦ (¡ F¢ ¢¡ ¦8 ( (¡ ( E 2¡ %XQ E 2 LK¥¡ ¦ ¦ 8 F #

¥ © £¦© © ¥ # ( ¡ ¥ £¢¨# &!#¤ ¢¤£¦¥¤££¦© (¢ H¡K¡K¡¦¦ ( K E 8 2 2 F¦ ( 8 ¡ ( F F ( EM2 K¥ 2 ¦8 F ( EM2 HK¥ ¡K¦ 8 ( ¢ ¡EF ( 2 ¦¦ 8 FF ( EM2 ¦¥ © F ( ¦¥ © ( 2¢¥ © ( 2¥ © %XQ % F*§¦ £$% 1 !IŠ~< ON) r ¨!t "*l! Y "*e 2 2 P N MÜ Y L !f MU+Y ! N)dy# y !IR U8 ?J ¦ (C% ¡ ( ¢L %XQ % . U MJU" "!nbdL< =er " c U eyf &] U "! > %?WR '(c ¤ H JH ( 9 %XQ ¢ ¦ © +¥ L+*ELON ¢ © ¡ ( F ( ¢ 'S ( ¦ 8 ¡ F8 ( %XQ # 2¡ F ¢ ¢¢ © ¡ FF ¦ 8 ¡ (8 F F E 2 HK (K 8 F¢ ¡ ¦ 8 ¡ ( ( 8 F F E 2 HK¥ ¦2¡ ¢ ¢ #$L : "¥¤¦' "sf :H< f¨ "J r J#$L P O bdL< "!cL =e P % "N)] l fl‚ O MJ LM Œ "f 8Q Q\ z PM Q! — &LMN 4 " "!\ Q L ] # Š[< "N)x& ") „ Y ! WR UP f U #c Y *% ": " "U % "&& U f Q M UP "!’k f{ "f "M IR =e ' O v*L * f GYA # Œ Y e IŠ~< ON)¤ Ofi Y[ &! & fnQ " & Y !Iel V % O R !R V :H< & LM _ fsR L< "! ‚ O Pv'a W O f LM ' I IŠ~ "N) PY ¤ :%Q ! — PY N fg#$ & &] O!< ffL< "! PY ! & " &! & f cRO " t O P O!|=eX! ! M & O & O W "!ƒ# &sL!t O P Q ƒ ! O 2 2 f Š[< "N) V'( # 8V f Q %

U LM %XQ# ¨.% "* U f# o &LM% O P Q– ! % 'a L r Š R =e f 6• f WR % U" ‚ l #Œ ^¢ (' " PY % ¢¡ M fy#$ & z # !LM£¡ PnV ¡BQ Q\ z P R UP f &LXN O¤¡ P QTue Oct 9 09:51:28 2001Dataset=SIMULATION_m01 ¤ ¥ & £© . % .0& !$% + § # - © +4.0- & fM„# J &LM U U eu ! " % O Os% ON) U E' ¦'( hR" O!L< O fnQ ^ xY[ & fMT I "! U f ' "c" E'S – U Q %XQ# Q f ' " UP % O f Y e t MU ! #$ ' " Q t MU ! c y& UP % O U Q ¢¦ # *) # o PU % O&¤Qequiv_stress0.50.40.30.20.100 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 ! & ¦H " fi *rf ¢ ¡ ¢ .¦¢ ¡ ¢ * . 8 %XQ *) )

¢¤£¡ £¨§ ! "#$% &!# ( £¦©Fri Oct 12 00:14:33 2001Sun Oct 14 12:45:56 2001s› k= P LM ¡ U % "! ' " RO "!L< O f R S# LSf ¡Š Œ P LS ¡ R *¤¡IkU 4 ¡I%ƒ< O ¡ f f f E' f ¡Š ˆ O ˆ OŠ fj M "f< OM f U ¤¡fnQ Of< "M f U ¤¡fv " # L f ¡ – ¡ U Q %XQ&% Qc– ¡ U L %.Q) – ¡ U Q %XQ+ " #$ &0.5intPhi_magnitude0.5equiv_stress &LMN 4£¡ " P < O # Q Y ! %XQ E' E' P R UP f+ !LM¤¡ P UP fr# f ¡IŠ Œ< 4 Q0.40.40.30.30.2Sun Oct 14 14:30:33 20010.2Thu Oct 11 22:41:00 20010.10.100 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.50.5equiv_stress00 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.50.5intPhi_magnitude0.40.40.30.30.20.20.10.100 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.500 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5¡ U L %XQ&% M "f

10 0 hbarAdaptive refinementUniform refinement10 −1rel.error10 −210 −310 −3 10 −2 10 −1 10 0¡ U L %XQ) P R UP # ƒ !t O¤¡R * L¤¡ U Of< "M¤¡R fjL ¡# *&–H< & %Q 10.90.80.7Effectivity index0.60.50.40.30.20.100 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5Number of elementsx 10 4– ¡ U L %XQ J Š :£¡R ¡I=e ¡ f :• # o „› k= P L ¡ U % "!BQ +

¤ ¨ ¢ ¢¡ Linear ElementsQuadratic Elements10 0 hbar10 −1rel.error10 −210 −310 −410 −3 10 −2 10 −1 10 0 10 1– ¡ U LM %XQ+ " R UP # ! ¡ " f¤bdL< "fM% O¤¡ ! & %Q Y ! %XQ P R UP f !LM¤¡ Py R" O!L< O f P < O "V XV g f # Q ¤ '¤ ¨ % 2 ¢£ @+ 8 8 % # 8) 8 % + # 8;+ 8@+ 8# 8 %#

¢¤£¡ £ ¥ # ( ¡ ¥¨£¢¨# &!#¤ ( £¦©Thu Oct 11 10:21:05 2001U O ¡I%s" ¡ f f f E' "f

10 0 hbarAdaptive refinementUniform refinement10 −1rel.error10 −210 −310 −3 10 −2 10 −1 10 0¡ U L %XQ P R UP # T ! O£¡IR s vL¤¡ U "f< OM£¡IR fxL ¡# *&–H< & %Q 10.90.80.7Effectivity index0.60.50.40.30.20.100 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000Number of elements– ¡ U LM %XQ \—ˆŠ :£¡R ¡I=e ¡ f :• # o c U ef & ¢¡ ¡ U "!8Q#

Linear ElementsQuadratic Elements10 0 hbar10 −1rel.error10 −210 −310 −410 −3 10 −2 10 −1 10 0 10 1– ¡ U L %XQ P R U" # ! ¡ " flbdL< "f O£¡ ! & %Y ! %.Q &LX f M U er ! " % O # f ¡Š " "Q¤ '¤ ¨ % 2 ¤§#$%' ( ¢¡¤¢£8 % @) 8&% + 8 %8# + 8# # 8 8 + ) 8 8 8 +@) 8&% @+ 8 % 8 + % 8*+ 8#

¢¤£¡ £¡ ¢¤£ ¡ ¥ § $ ¢¦¥ ¢ £ §©£§¥ ¥¨)# £¡© % ¡! "$#&%('*),+-.0/1'234*35 ¡6+7"98!"+*:;+5+3+¨+5

" 3H£¢!+£¡"=W+5

3)§+

€ z „ …§¦©¨ ~ ‡£¢v€ €‚ z†… „[‡Cˆwyx8z¥¤

./u/ / I( $'/C 5 7:(£¢ ¤¥¢+7 !%$&§¦ &6$h1¡1¤+DGE1@C.¨ WV ¨ GR1X:5?6[:09'@9:0I:7459766I9'@69 KTA96215C6B/9?6-09>?6O:G?:6970I:HG I66DV7:7976*:M6§88H6.VAU6B1(>DG269>B>745/ l2]TfZ _`S bd^ _ j K E 02976`C5667'71 ~N: x 9O6I15CWa451P'569O88TGE15C9?6-09>O6I1(>§/-0;1:0I:HGJ6I1(>N\6. 8D6a0I:DGE15CHA+6dGE12:976*A5976§>7612:0I:HGJ6I1%GR1U:

K E 09>Y8E6§'):@6U:5NR8J:S0;1MGA54P8T0I:DGD6I1X69Fc:09'@9:0I:DGE/G6§8E6*:M6B1:>=WKGD>0 x 0M8E96QGD'G:5A\6/6GT098XA@4595A 65>7668R6=:'612:@> K E :6M08R6-09'(>:6'0G:X6I976©¨56.VKGN(8R6!021('ZCI61@69:0I8c>658 I69 F6I9 :X6I9?6 /6:GA(8R6.VYA@96N(8R6=:X> Kx :< 029?6@N>09>?6'6I1 TGE9T:4>098`/9702/= = \W\]`F? K ¦ ^>1pGJ:6M68R6=:'612:021>0I8teCI9O6GD>4A\69OF6295:'6'/F6I9[:098J/9702/=< /6I1^>CI45970I:HGJ6I1F021('/:O:79:0dGR1A6B1569?C388>DGJ>09'50"P:HG6%TGJ:74)LG?: : 6>T:970dGE1]61@697C]09>C56a09898P450212:HGJ:7 K@ 6!::769LGE1('pGE/-0E:@6I9O>A'IGRC :2\662P:=0dGR156' K156L/-0;1098D>O6 KGR6 x : 0I> 4(>DGR15C[:?4(8J:6IF :51@69§A59@G:M098>K E ‚GJ>/§8E6-0;9880:X6I9?6G02/B/45970I:6e:0;1`:76B9A59@G:M0986N54P: :26H1(6I: 09>/6I9?976/!: 6979O6I9bN+62451('Z09> 03N 6 26 K0* -09;, £ -09;&‹* (¢¡1£FV9:0;/§:4@9767:'6/021pGE/>[:509>4N\661>:)4@/L0 2669F021= \w`F?GE1a629'56B9e:6¡976*A5976§>7612:[:5?69f:M6§>5 N@4P::?6AU6B/‹GE098& "%$'"#/C- / 7 (£¢ £ -W¦ -056I!# -8( $:'6§:50I:76' K E :63:M6'MGE9?6/!:HGD6218021('#:T:9:0oGE1]6156B97C GD>02CI0dGE1 /098E/B4(8T0I:76' K 6H6B1569?C 9?68E609>76!970I:6 GD>: 61 * 3 K! 4 6#"@96$" 65>76§'809'&%;0212:=0;CI6;69F : GD>(''6§: 6'#GD>: 0I:[: 6)/B9:02/=?4(8J:>LGE1G: 6 GRC 6§>O:%;098E4@6Y69F KGJ>''6§: 67'.'56+'M021('(>C: 0E:B: 6>T::9:0oGE1 6B1569?C‰GD>J/6$',"54P:76')6-:976.'M6§8/02/B/4§0970I:6 K1 6©'X65>O:6/§6I1(6$' GE/021('S9768JGT02P8E63'M6!: 6'`> 6I4(8J'42\6:6)4(>76GC56a09850 6I9@GE612:76' 6 GE12:769:" 658E0212:=>?4;2P:79:02/!:6'GE1 : 6F69?96I9]976."5976§>76B1:0I:HGJ6I1 /021 : 6>DGJ>¡4 :6;: 6>= "59O6??6/!:HGD621 GE12:@6 "%$ KBDC

66I9?6+' :6.6$27:=0dGR1021S0;976-0 GE12:76CI97098(>DG/'IGJ8T029C:@6Y: 6 C26156B9:098JG 6§'M6B1569?C%2697C2615/B6:GE12:6BCI9:0I8 K'(6'S0dGR16X6979O6I9S9?6+"59?6>?612:=0I:DGD6I1 /-021 2\6a:027612:0I:HGJ6I1=621#: 6YF6I9:'KC3 %4 3 ¡ 1£¢ ¢ P4 V 24;',"^:769 'b> FV96'H: 66§8E6.'M6B1:32 6I451P'>029DGR6> K 3 K 246 ): 6 ">0I:HGE098 ??4;',"G:6B9:'X> > 6I4P8D' 2U6 >O:HGJ8D8U451('56B9e'pGD>7/B4(>>@GD6I1 K¤%I6B1 : 6I45C : 6 0 /§6I12:@6I459†GR1:76CI97098$)Y09> >?45//B6>>TFV4(8P62156/021.:79 Y:6G0"&"(8/Y: 6 'pG60¥B§¦

0I: ¤ 6‹GJ'568/2U6B97CI J§ ¦ ¦I K0I: ¤ 6GD'56§82\69?CI Q#6R6R§ K_d8ag^HagX[Z _ edfJ*9‹]MedZ _cVYX K W:74('5612:8PGJ:O:6B9:0I:7459! V§ ¦ ¦I KcK . K B1(69:O: K^ ]KX j edl agX[Zcedf Vfe ^@eTUgZ ]T^Ha/§aWUpedX[_cU K @ 4P::769¢)6I9T: >` "§ ¦a6A K=Co?&%¢¡ ¤£ ¨ ¢¤£ ¡¦¥K© K 1('56B9>621 K ^@eTUgZ ]T^Ha§aWUpedX[_cU S ]TX j edl agX[Z edf edX j f_cUDedZ _cVYX K=¨§‹?9?6>O>! "§ ¦ ¦§ K =$#Y?&% K% K @ 029O:6I1 021P'© K KJ^ 02/=< 'M021 K(' Ug_cagX[Z _) U edX j+*}XTbd_`XhaWag^ _`XTb-,./. S0AX_`X[Z ^HV‹jd] UgZ _cVYX21_`Z34 j65YedXhUWaDj87 aWUTX[_09‹][a edX j:*¢; edl< fPa K= '('MGD>O6I1§0?>[6§>8E6 @¦ ¦B K § K @ 6/=T:HG?:4P:GFC 459 15CI6 ) 0;1('P:6EDX0E: 6.'S0I:DGE@GJ:HC=Bd? K @ 6B/=O:DGJ:74P:SFNC459 15CI6.)Y021('7:6LDX0I: 6+'M0I:HGRDG?:PC?&% K 029O8D>O>6I1 KS ^HVYZ Z l aTdedX[_UT K . GE15C29:0IF @ V§ ¦$C PK=o? © K \ 6+25150I: 021(' K DnGE@GE1(>?< G KW X[Z ^HV‹jd][UgZ _cVYX#Z\VYX8_`f[Zgag^ Z ' peTUWa\1_`Z]^ S=f_cUDedZ _cVYX K_ /09'56+' GE/ 9?6>>` "§ ¦ ¦ ¦ KK ¥ 9DGRO>6I1b \ K ¥ >T:6."V K ¤ 0;1(>:2 6I !021(' K %96 1(>O6I1 K ,}VYl< ]KZcedZ _cVYX edf=$aY?‰B¦o? ¤ K Kg© 0215CI:=02156B1 K ,}VYl< ]TZcedZ _cVYX edfih ed^gZ _ edfic _d8ag^HagX[Z _ edfj*9‹]MedZ _cVYX K=k§ ¦ ¦ ¦ K W§"@9DGE1@CI69`Kl© 029O>6I1S021('m% K^ GE>621 Kb " 65>O:769DGJ6I9DG>6B979O6I9§6>O:DG'M0I:HGJ6I1 69F FV4@15/§:DGD6I1>0I8D>=¨§HRo?&D6§8D8JG"P:DGE/,"596$2P8E6+'X>!n ¥ -§"\69@G''612:@> K 6B/ 1MGE/098L976."+629O:M 098/'M6B9> . GE1MG?:6GR18E6.'M6B12: 6B12:69` J#6R@R§ K o ¥ p K ^ #6R@R§ 0fRB K¥R

459 1@CI6.)Y021('P:76(DX0I: 6+'M0I:DGE@GJ:PC0E: ¤ 6‹GD'@682\69?CI:79658 GE1K>1MGJ:76H6§8E6.'M6B1:('M6!: 6'(>`nL0";"(8JGE/0I:HGJ6I1G:@6U8JGE15602968T0I>O:HGR/‹G?:7 K ,}VYl< ]TS¦ ¦I K §K W< 021P> 658/' K ,./. jd_`^HaTYZ K W:74('5612:8PGJ:O:6B9:0I:7459! F# R@R@R K=¨§PaY?&%. K © 0;9>>O6I1 K ¡ V‹edfSDVY^ _cagX[Z\aDj ag^ ^HVY^ l aDe g]K^HaedX j e j e Z _35da )CX[_`Z\a%agfPagl agX[Z=¨§@§‹?^HVUWaDjd]T^Wa‰_`XVYf_ jIl aWUpedX[_cU K 8PGR/ K : 6§>DGD>` 098/'M6B9>! Q#6R@R§ K\ K K% K >()61 0;1(' K% K . 0 ) K *}XTbd_`XhaWag^ _`XTb ^@eTUgZ ]T^Ha aWUpedX[_cU S=¨§P#Y?ag^ _cUDedfb agZ][V‹j edX jL f_cUDedZ _cVYX K GE156B9DGD'@CI6 976§>> © G/'IG?:6'b J§ ¦C@A K¢A]Kl=¨§HAo? K 02151502/ 69 K ¥ 9?96I9/6I12:79658 GE1 K>1MG?:668E6.'M6B12: /6' "547:=0I:DGD6I1(> K 6B/ 1MGR/-0989?6+" 6I9O:! K 1(>O:DGJ:47:bFCK #6R6R@RBd? K 02151>02/ 69 021(' . K0 K W47:: ''6‹GR69 K FV66§'§072>0;/=< 0";"59O6a02/ :@669?96I9L/§6I1§0=¨§_cVYX edfb aWUpedX[_cU 3 § ¦24 nBAB¤£ B$Ba O§ ¦ ¦@a KZcedZ?&% K K GR/6 Ki ">0I: GR1('56."U6B1('5612:GR1:76CI97098021('=¨§: 680";"59O6¥-KG/'S0I:760215098/D0>@GD>M69Fe>O:79:0dGR1 /6I1@/612:79:0I:DGD6I1 2D 1(6I:/ 6§>M0;1('/9:0;/= K R[VY]K^ X edfLVfeY^ f_caDjaWUpedX[_cU QA nAa ¦¥£ A$CI J§ ¦I $C Ko?&% K K W 6 )Y/ 45< K 7M^ _ edXTbdfPa§¦ ©¨6c¦9‹]Medf_`Z i+l a+bTagXhag^@edZ VY^ edX j jTagfOed]TX edi=¨§Z ^ _ edXTbd]KfOedZ\VY^ K :O: "Vn))) K /> K /.')4 K 6'548P4502O:79HCK X0edX jZgVHT VU e)VY^gl agf‹edl2f_`XTb _X edf`fe6e gZ3[agZ]gf§6$'ed^@e K . GE1@CI9:0IF @ \WVC65'56B9O:HC098??6 V§ ¦ ¦$C K§

£ £ ¦ ¡ £¢GRCI459?6 %0£/6I12:6I459'GR1:76CI970986 %269 0 /§8D65>?6')/§6I12:@6I4@9§¦©¨ K1 6 1P6I9:'M098 %I6/!:@6I9. §@n 6FV9O6$'H: 6!/9:0;/=/§6I12:@6I459¦ ¨ !#" ¨ ! *%$'& 1 3 a547?612:6§'¤§ GR/6? @ 6.%;098R4>0I:DGE15CU: 64%0 /621:6I459 GE12:76CI97098 098J6I15C]0 /8J65>76§'2Dk=nA**#

6B976 ¡ *%$ K @ )0";"(8/TGR15C: 6'MG6%I69?CI61@/6: 66I9?6+' 3 a94J/-0;1#2U6/6I1D%I6B9O:76')GE12:76CI97098:6M0;1Q0;976-0¥¤!!**) 6B976 ¨LGD>: 60297606B15/8J65>76§' 2D¦©¨! %>?66 . GEC K 3 §,4 K @ 3 B( #54 )6 0¥%26! !! * ¦ ¤! ¤£!§* ! *!#" !¥¤&¤V ¨ ¦ ¤ ! ! * !#" ! & !¥¤! !#" 1 3 §HR24! *&>@GE15/B6 ¦ ¤¦ ¤K ]6+8N4MGJ8PG/259DGR4;' R#)Y6 0 %26@ !¦ ¤¥¤!#" ¦ ¤! *& !¥¤! !#" 1 3! *& §@§ 4 !! GR/ GD>8GJ'5612:HGR/-098C:@6G: 6;: 6M>?6/621(' :769 'GE1 3 C24 K 4(> R;F6I9021D]/8J65>76§'Z/§6I12:@6I4@9 K 6I1(>@GD'56B9 1(6¥) :7) 6 029 2MGJ:79:029¢ /621:6I459O>!§¦ *0;1('¦ 029O6I451('[0Z/B9:02/=70'M6 %;098R456£69F:%P %kGD> pedZ3TS\_`X jTa [agX jTagX[Z K W66. GRC3 #54 K K ¨ ¢ £! 3§¦ ¤ !#" 4©¨ 1 3 C24! 3 ¦24! * ! ! ¤! ¤! *^ 69:6 : 0E: 3 ¦24 0";"(8JGE6§>R621(8/ ) 61 09>R: 6 "596$"\69T:HGR6>R69F 021M68E09>O:DGE/" 69:6B1:DGT098 K ";"(8/TGR15C;: 6T:9:0oGE1§0R'MGJ>:"(8E02/6.'M6B12:9768E0I:HGJ6I1(> G"U:6 3 ¦24YCQG6%I6>#¦ ¤! /§6I12:9DG/254P:DGD6I1(>0;1('^>74;'X> :@6 69O6 3??4(>O:3"@96¥%I6B1%GE1G: 602+6¥%26.>?6/§:DGD6I1%4V DBV V RP 3 §P#543 §HA24* DA

GRCI459?6\# 8D65>?6'X/§6I12:@6I4@9G029O6I451('^: 6/B9:02/=DG?:6 'MGR976/!:HGJ6I1'09>R: 6 /6I4512:769¢0 ¦)LGJ>76 GE12:76CI97098 6¥%I6B9 /§8D6P/=§ ¢ " %$ 3 § 24FV9702/§:DGD6I1(> '@456Y:@6M: 6YF 02/!: : 0I: : 6. 02976 GE1P'56+"\61('@612:W6IF1 Kn43n122 67'§ . GRC K 3 A24 K 6C58D6$25098U/§67629'MGR1>0I:6 0-KGD> 3¥¤1¦¤ 4 0;9769:0;1('(6$' 021('G: 6>?6'809>* H ** ¤1 3 § B4 ¤* 3 § 41('569 8P4509>DG50 >O:0I:HGR/ 3 1(6 < GE156!:HGE/G6156B97C`'561(>@GJ:7P4/§6I1('MG?:HGD621(> 021P' GE1U: 602(>?615/B6G67'&bF6I97/B6>` 0: 6 "+6I:612:DGT098 6B1569?C GJ>LCQG/%261 2 69F2^ 69:6 n 6/6I12:6I4590GE12:76CI97098 6¥%I6B9 ¦kGJ> 69O6GF6I9©"59?6>7/B9DG/2U6§''MGJ>:"(8E02/6.'M6B12:@>021P'§ ! ¢ !#" 3 §Pa54! %$ ! ! !B

8R615C9: K *1 02976.: 6.8D6P/-098 /66I9O'MGE1>0E:6H0-KGD>W8J6/0I:6§' 0I:: 6H/9:0;/=0I>EGR1 3 ¦24L021P'3 §HR24 )6.62P:=0dGR1! ¦ ¤ ! 6 "59@GE15/6G"(8R6[69F %TGE9O:74>0989) 6I9?< CQG/%26>! ! ! ¤! ¤¥¤!#" 3#6R24 & ! !! $

0215/6§8D> 6I4P: 0;1(' )6H02976Y8R6§F :)LGJ: ! ¢ V* ! " 3 #@#54 *%$ ! ! ! ¡ * ! " ! *& %$ !#" 3 #6A24! *& !: 6 '56B9DG/%;0I:DGD6I1 K 6CI6B15697098PG 6§'6B1569?C 9?68E609>76L970I:6sGR1D%56586%I6>)6976§FV6B9S:@6I=¨§‹?(F6I9%;021MGJ> GR15C58/b>:'M098J8 /621:6I459¦_ 021(' GD> '56 K>156§'09>0* !¨§ ¦ ¤ © ¤ 1 3 # 4 GJ>R: 6[>O:79:0dGR1S6B1569?C`'@61(>@GJ:7M021(' mGJ>R: 6G< GE1@6§:HGR/G6B1569?CX'561(>@GJ:7b'56`K5156']09>¥ 8N4>0I:DGD6I1 3 #B42GD>#%;098JGD'F6I9X:DG''6 0H021P' GD>T:@6I9¢D0 '56."U6B1('5612:4'S0I:769@GT0982\6 0 %TGD629 K!#" !! " #¦ ¤© ¤ 1 3 #@a546I4P:0I: >6$''6U'MGJ>O:0215/6S R#FV96$' : 6S/9:0;/=< :HG/" K)K=K 6 RaF6I9: 6/02979@GE6'"@96$2(8R6+' KbK 1 >6'M6 :6-7:2+66I = §‹?: GD> "59O6$" 65>76§' 'MG M/B4(8J:7 09>8E6'/§6I12:HGE1N4(624(>G >DGE1@C 3 #6R24 021P' 3 # § 4hGR1 3 § ¦24 )6 F6I451('Y: 0I:c: 6 8R6-09'MGR15C:6B9:'GR1>2+6I: ">029?612: 6§>DGJ>!§ ";"(8/TGR15C;: 6 6B1X0";"(8/TGR15C 3 #B4 :6M:HG''6 0 '56+"\61P'5612:3'M0I:6B9DGT0I8 /021 2U6!6 -§"59?6>O>76'09> /§6I12:@6I459 ¦ KX^ 4;'M6B9DGR/-098J8/a: GD>‰GD>H1(69: 0"59O6$2(8E6.' >DGR15/6X: 6IGE12:6BCI9:0I:DGD6I1F/-0;1 2U6© ¤ GJ> : 6O:79:0dGR1]9:0I:76 K 676§']/6I12:@62459! /621(>O:79745/!:6'X09>LGD8J8E4(>T:9:0E:6' GR1 . GEC K 3 B24 K1 6

GRCI459?6(BIn /§8D65>?6']/6I12:6I459F6I9 'M6§'*2 . 021P' ¦*) 6B1Q/§6I15156B/§:6§' 2D ¦021P'¦¡ K£¢ GD>: 6!/6I4@1:769 0 /8J6/=76%;021MGJ> GD8R6 GR15C586a> 'S098J8 K %Z/§6I4(8J' 2\66.%;098E450I:6§' 6I1 2 69: ¦ GD>/K>1MG?:6#)021P'*254P: 621(8/ ¦ ) 6I4(8J'¡CQG/%26: 6 /6297976B/§:A%;098R456e69F=% GE1X: 6CI6156B9:098U/-09>?6 K . 6I98N4>09>@Gc>O:0I:HGR//6I1('pGJ:HGJ6I1(>A) 6B976¦ ¦R 3 #B24Y/-021 2U6>)9@GJ::761 ¦ '£V¤¦! *¤!#" * ¨ ¥¤ ¦Z '¦ §¤¦* ! ¤!#"¨ ¦*¦: FV4515/!:HGJ6I1 :0I:'GJ> 6.8P450987:6 451MG?:7.621 021(' )6‹GRC 69O6Y6I1 ¦* K¡¢ GD>C: 6/6I4512:769¢0/§8D6P/=< )LGJ>76X6I4P:7)Y029'A1(6I9 'S098621¦ ^ 69:6M: 0I: ¢ 6I1 K ¦ K ¤*RQ021P' ¦ ¨¦¦0;1(' ¦¡ 029?6M4&";"U6B9)021P' 8D6¥)69 /B9:02/= K GD>H021[029:2MG?:97029 2547: > 'b669: ¤ ©¨ §.6I1¦021('¦¡ K¤¦! *¤!#" £ £¢ !¤!"¤¦* ! nmx2x1+m− 0A*1 ¦ 13 #C24) 6B976V ¦¡ S¦ , 3 # ¦24>O>74;' GE1@Cb:9702/§:DGD6I1 0 FV976B6!/9:0;/= 3 : 6 >?6/§6I1('+GR1:76CI97098GE1 3 #C54A%;021pGD> 6>¡4021P'Q0";"(8/TGR15CM:674(8?:@>LGE1 ¢ ! * ¨ & !3 A@R24 * ¨V 3 A§ 4a& !

G K 6 K ¢ ££ ¤V ¦¢ ¤!#" ! *& ! ! *! ! ¤¦! *¤!#" ¨¡£¢ ¤3 A@A24 & !! 1 3 A#54¥¦¨§© * ¨ GJ> 029760'0";"596I02/ 09>32U6B61 G',"(8E6.'M6B1:76' GR1^: GD>: 6>@GD> KC