HUNGARIAN STUDIES 11. No. 1. Nemzetközi Magyar ... - EPA

HUNGARIAN STUDIES 11. No. 1. Nemzetközi Magyar ... - EPA HUNGARIAN STUDIES 11. No. 1. Nemzetközi Magyar ... - EPA

12.07.2015 Views

152 LÁSZLÓ K. GÉFINThe intertext at first appears to underline the "liberation-theological"impatience with doctrine and no action. "Peace is no remedy for poison"alludes to the great 17th century poet and warrior, Count Miklós Zrínyi andhis tract on military strategy, A török áfium ellen való orvosság [A remedy forthe Turkish poison], and its famous motto proclaiming the antidote: "Fegyver,fegyver, fegyver kívántatik és jó vitézi resolutio" [We need arms, arms, arms,and strong military resolve]. But the resolution of Vitéz cannot advocate aresorting to arms: our very weapons would turn on us if we tried to use themon others. Zrínyi 's example is also an ironic reminder of the kind of resolvethat is no longer possible, for such a stance is part and parcel of that wholeand "rounded world" available solely to the "naive", undivided consciousness,the world the ironist had renounced the moment he knew he did not know.With the ground of the satire becoming itself groundless - in any event, theexample and teaching of Jesus are enclosed within "scripture," a writing - thenarrative returns to irony, but just as satiric parabases had earlier on invadedand perhaps "toned down" ironic poliphony, so in the final parts of the poem anew component enters, what may paradoxically be termed "post-ironic irony",somewhat analogous to what Paul de Man had named the "stance of wisdom." 7The ending of the Agnus Dei quoted above, but more explicitly the final part. Itemissa est, no longer harbor a nostalgia for lost wholeness, for a recuperation ofthe mode of being Kierkegaard had called "the knight of faith." The "postironicironic" consciousness cannot and will not renounce irony, but it moves toadjust it to make visible the ultimate end of its play, and all play, through therestful contemplation of death. The Ite missa est begins with a pun, or rather theliteral translation of "Tridentine" ("three-toothed") - "Menjetek: vége aháromfogú misének" [Go, the three-toothed mass is over] - and it continues tosustain the metaphor of the three teeth sinking into different substances. But theplay is also a recapitulation of the entire agnostic mass, the effects of the Latinmass on itself, and through it, the effect of Christianity on the narrative subject.The progression of the actions of the "teeth" - "Az első fog valódi húsbatépett"; "Lelket őröl a második fog"; "A harmadik fog bölcsességfog" [The firsttooth tore into real flesh; The second tooth grinds the soul; The third tooth iswisdom tooth] - is not fortuitous, but recalls, first, the psychology of the churchfathers and the units making up the total human being (somatic, psychic,pneumatic) and closely allied with it, the levels or layers of interpretationapplicable to scripture. According to Origen, "Just as the human being consistsof body, soul, and spirit, so does Holy Scripture, which God had inspired forman's salvation." 8 In spite of adhering to the order of the (submerged) religiousintertext, which being a parody, still invites an ironic reading, the final lines turnthe play against itself and affirms an order that contains both gnosis and agnosis:

THE AGON OF IRONY AND SATIREA harmadik fog bölcsességfogállkapcsunkban későn virágzik(fogósdit játszunk acélfogóval)és zsibbadunk. Elegáns injekcióvalmár az örökös fájdalom partja se látszik.[The third tooth is wisdom toothit blooms late in our jaw(we play catch with steel pliers)and go numb. An elegant needlemakes invisible the shores of eternal pain].The figurai language is very compact, but it is not needlessly cryptic, nor is it afull return to irony. The play of catch is the play of life and death; only wehumans know what is at stake in this play, yet we still play on. The "elegantneedle" is properly both literal and allegorical: the former is the needle of goodand easy death; the latter, the injection of some artful evasion of death such asgood writing that momentarily dissolves the true world of pain and sorrow. Butbeing in the "stance of wisdom," the post-ironic subject now knows literal andfigurai to be one, and is able to stand both inside and outside, for it, as de Manwrites, "however painful, sees things as they actually are." 9 If Missa agnostica isan "orphan" text, as postulated above, it is because its narrating subject acceptshis own orphanhood, acknowledging as distant kin only the Kierkegaardian"knight of infinite resignation." But orphans, like the Jesus Anguillos of theworld with whom the narrator has shown solidarity, can also play; thewhimpering picture is not the whole picture. Play is available to the adult orphanas well, especially as he had orphaned himself when he chose to follow the roadof his docta ignorantia wherever it took him. The entry of post-ironic irony doesnot inject a lugubrious tone into Vitéz' text; quite the contrary: as in Yeats'Lapis Lazuli, the gaiety and enormous tragic fun of free play still transfigures allthat dread. And the agnostic mass still remains a mass, celebrating the rites ofplay against ennui and bad faith, while quietly acknowledging the "shores ofeternal pain" as its ultimately impassable bounderies.Notes1. References throughout this paper are to Missa agnostica (Paris: Magyar Műhely, 1979). Thepoem also appears in Vitéz's collected poems, Az ájtatos manó imája (Szombathely: Életünkkönyvek, 1991) 125-164.2. Jacques Derrida, "Living on/Border Lines" in Harold Bloom, Deconstruction and Criticism(New York, 1979), 83.

152 LÁSZLÓ K. GÉFINThe intertext at first appears to underline the "liberation-theological"impatience with doctrine and no action. "Peace is no remedy for poison"alludes to the great 17th century poet and warrior, Count Miklós Zrínyi andhis tract on military strategy, A török áfium ellen való orvosság [A remedy forthe Turkish poison], and its famous motto proclaiming the antidote: "Fegyver,fegyver, fegyver kívántatik és jó vitézi resolutio" [We need arms, arms, arms,and strong military resolve]. But the resolution of Vitéz cannot advocate aresorting to arms: our very weapons would turn on us if we tried to use themon others. Zrínyi 's example is also an ironic reminder of the kind of resolvethat is no longer possible, for such a stance is part and parcel of that wholeand "rounded world" available solely to the "naive", undivided consciousness,the world the ironist had renounced the moment he knew he did not know.With the ground of the satire becoming itself groundless - in any event, theexample and teaching of Jesus are enclosed within "scripture," a writing - thenarrative returns to irony, but just as satiric parabases had earlier on invadedand perhaps "toned down" ironic poliphony, so in the final parts of the poem anew component enters, what may paradoxically be termed "post-ironic irony",somewhat analogous to what Paul de Man had named the "stance of wisdom." 7The ending of the Agnus Dei quoted above, but more explicitly the final part. Itemissa est, no longer harbor a nostalgia for lost wholeness, for a recuperation ofthe mode of being Kierkegaard had called "the knight of faith." The "postironicironic" consciousness cannot and will not renounce irony, but it moves toadjust it to make visible the ultimate end of its play, and all play, through therestful contemplation of death. The Ite missa est begins with a pun, or rather theliteral translation of "Tridentine" ("three-toothed") - "Menjetek: vége aháromfogú misének" [Go, the three-toothed mass is over] - and it continues tosustain the metaphor of the three teeth sinking into different substances. But theplay is also a recapitulation of the entire agnostic mass, the effects of the Latinmass on itself, and through it, the effect of Christianity on the narrative subject.The progression of the actions of the "teeth" - "Az első fog valódi húsbatépett"; "Lelket őröl a második fog"; "A harmadik fog bölcsességfog" [The firsttooth tore into real flesh; The second tooth grinds the soul; The third tooth iswisdom tooth] - is not fortuitous, but recalls, first, the psychology of the churchfathers and the units making up the total human being (somatic, psychic,pneumatic) and closely allied with it, the levels or layers of interpretationapplicable to scripture. According to Origen, "Just as the human being consistsof body, soul, and spirit, so does Holy Scripture, which God had inspired forman's salvation." 8 In spite of adhering to the order of the (submerged) religiousintertext, which being a parody, still invites an ironic reading, the final lines turnthe play against itself and affirms an order that contains both gnosis and agnosis:

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!