27.11.2012 Views

indonesia arbitration - Bani

indonesia arbitration - Bani

indonesia arbitration - Bani

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Court Interventions In International Arbitration -<br />

Indonesia Experience<br />

The view of the Indonesian Supreme Court in this regard is in line with the<br />

view of the Supreme Court of India (in the case of Oil and Natural Gas Commission<br />

vs. Western Company of North America, Decision of January 1 , 1987), and<br />

the Decision of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York (in<br />

the case of American Construction Machinery & Equipment Corporation Ltd. vs.<br />

Mechanized Construction of Pakistan, No. 85 Civil 7 5, March 2 , 1987) with<br />

respect to the interpretation of “under the law of which that award was made” as<br />

provided in Article V (1)(e) of the New York Convention as the procedural law<br />

(lex arbitri) of the <strong>arbitration</strong> process.<br />

The Decision of the Supreme Court on the above matter is in line with the<br />

view and the fact that Law No. 0/1999, as far as international <strong>arbitration</strong> award<br />

is concerned, only deals with the aspects of recognition and enforcement of the<br />

award. Public policy argument seems to be the only significant criteria for refusing<br />

the enforcement of international <strong>arbitration</strong> award. However, a wide interpretation<br />

of public policy may in practice also deal with matters or provisions in<br />

particular pertaining to the principles of due process of law as stipulated in the<br />

whole Article V of the New York Convention.<br />

M. Husseyn Umar<br />

Vice Chairman of BANI Arbitration Centre<br />

and partner in Ali Budiardjo, Nugroho, Reksodiputro, Jakarta, Indonesia.<br />

INDONESIA ARBITRATION - Quarterly Newsletter No. 4/2008

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!