Winter - Australian Institute of Architects

CommendationNorth Fremantle ResidenceArchitecture PracticeGrounds Kent ArchitectsBuilderCordoba ConstructionsPhotographerJohn ChisholmJury CommentsA well composed and volumetrically beautiful home with fluid connectionsbetween inside and outside. Contributed to the idiosyncratic nature of theneighbourhood. Dealt with an imposing scale of Ford Factory and existingstreetscape well. Large volumes were masterfully dealt with for a domesticproject. A good understanding of the clients needs moving through theproject at varying levels of public and private opportunities. Unique use ofindustrial materials internally whilst still maintaining its elegant form. Anamazing light quality moving through the space but unfortunately to thedetriment of solar efficiency and internal environment comfort. The jury feltthat restraint could have been used here.CommendationMelvista House22 Melvista Avenue, ClaremontArchitecture PracticeChindarsi ArchitectsBuilderAlliance BuildersPhotographerEmma Van DordrechtJury CommentsAn imaginative approach to dealing with existing house is demonstratedsetting up multiple connection points at a lowered level making cleardistinction of old and new. This also created a unique sense of existingcentral ‘island’ space experienced in an almost theatrical arrangement.The most overt arm of this extension locates kitchen and study spacesboldly on the lot corner, providing a distinct alternative to surrounding fabric.Though doing so with exquisite composition of volumes, heralded by anarresting billboard of artfully perforated, weathered steel, which might havebeen connected to the structure more seamlessly. Pool area felt somewhatcompromised within a high level context of finish and materials, whichgenerally utilised a comfortable budget well. Giving the clients a fine projectwith attention to detail amongst moments of creative delight.43THE ARCHITECT 2012 ISSUE 002