Protecting a tropical treasure – the Banana - Bayer CropScience

Protecting a tropical treasure – the Banana - Bayer CropScience Protecting a tropical treasure – the Banana - Bayer CropScience

bayercropscience.bg
from bayercropscience.bg More from this publisher
11.07.2015 Views

COURIERThe Bayer CropScience Magazine for Modern Agriculture 1/07Setting the Standard inProduct StewardshipDiverse Herbicides forDiverse Rice CulturesProtecting atropical treasurethe Banana

COURIERThe <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> Magazine for Modern Agriculture 1/07Setting <strong>the</strong> Standard inProduct StewardshipDiverse Herbicides forDiverse Rice Cultures<strong>Protecting</strong> a<strong>tropical</strong> <strong>treasure</strong>– <strong>the</strong> <strong>Banana</strong>


Contents2 <strong>Protecting</strong> a <strong>tropical</strong><strong>treasure</strong> – <strong>the</strong> <strong>Banana</strong>8 Setting <strong>the</strong> Standard inProduct Stewardship12 We’ve got it in <strong>the</strong> can!15 Managing insecticideresistant whiteflies18 Shifting <strong>the</strong> View on Water24 Curbix – <strong>the</strong> long-lastingsolution againstbrown plant hoppers28 Diverse Herbicides forDiverse Rice Cultures<strong>Protecting</strong>a <strong>tropical</strong><strong>treasure</strong> –<strong>the</strong> <strong>Banana</strong>The banana might well have been foundgrowing in <strong>the</strong> Garden of Eden. After all, itshistory does go back to <strong>the</strong> earliest days ofmankind. Some scientists consider <strong>the</strong> bananaas being mankind’s first domesticated crop.Published by: <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> AG, Monheim / Editor:Bernhard Grupp / With contributions from: A. Dollacker, K.Doughty, M. Haas, A. Holl (free lance journalist), K. Kirsch /Design and Layout: Xpertise, Langenfeld / Lithography:LSD GmbH & Co. KG, Düsseldorf / Printed by: DynevoGmbH, Leverkusen / Reproduction of contents is permissibleproviding <strong>Bayer</strong> is acknowledged and advised byspecimen copy / Editor’s address: <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> AG,Corporate Communications, Alfred-Nobel-Str. 50, 40789Monheim am Rhein, Germany, FAX: 0049-2173-383454 /Website: www.bayercropscience.comForward-Looking StatementsThis news release contains forward-looking statementsbased on current assumptions and forecasts made by<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> AG management. Various known andunknown risks, uncertainties and o<strong>the</strong>r factors could leadto material differences between <strong>the</strong> actual future results,financial situation, development or performance of <strong>the</strong><strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> AG or our parent company, <strong>Bayer</strong> AG,and <strong>the</strong> estimates given here. These factors include thosediscussed in <strong>Bayer</strong> AG's public reports filed with <strong>the</strong> FrankfurtStock Exchange and with <strong>the</strong> U.S. Securities and ExchangeCommission (including <strong>Bayer</strong> AG's Form 20-F).Nei<strong>the</strong>r <strong>Bayer</strong> AG nor <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> AG assumes anyliability whatsoever to update <strong>the</strong>se forward-looking statementsor to conform <strong>the</strong>m to future events or developments.2 COURIER 1/07


Although <strong>the</strong> plant that bears this age-old fruit appearstree-like, it is actually a herbaceous perennial of <strong>the</strong>genus Musa (family Musaceae) that grows in humid <strong>tropical</strong>and sub<strong>tropical</strong> climates. The jungles of Malaysiahave been identified as <strong>the</strong> center of origin of this genus.The fruit is rich in carbohydrates, fibers, vitamins andminerals. Its nutritional properties are recognized as beingsuperior to those of rice, yucca, potatoes and maize.In o<strong>the</strong>r words, it can be considered in many ways as <strong>the</strong>perfect fruit.A crop conquers <strong>the</strong> world<strong>Banana</strong>s vary in <strong>the</strong>ir taste and texture. Depending on <strong>the</strong>variety and <strong>the</strong> stage of ripeness, <strong>the</strong> flesh can be starchyor sweet, firm or mushy. Plantains and cooking bananasare <strong>the</strong> staple foods of many Latin American, Asian andAfrican populations, whereas in temperate countries, it ismainly <strong>the</strong> dessert or sweet varieties that are eaten.The banana is <strong>the</strong> world’s most widely – produced and– exported fruit, second only to citrus fruit in value terms,and globally <strong>the</strong> fourth most important export crop afterwheat, rice and corn. The biggest banana-producingcountries are India, Brazil and China, but <strong>the</strong>se countriesare not of major importance for trade, as <strong>the</strong>ir productionis predominantly for local consumption. Only a fifth oftotal banana production is traded internationally. Accordingto <strong>the</strong> FAO, total world exports amount to 13 milliontonnes, worth US$ 4.3 billion a year. Production for exportis concentrated in Ecuador, Philippines, Colombia,Central America and West Africa. The biggest consumersare <strong>the</strong> Europe, USA and Japan.Natural diversityThe banana originally contained ra<strong>the</strong>r large seeds, butover <strong>the</strong> millennia, <strong>the</strong> fruit’s popularity undoubtedly increasedwith <strong>the</strong> availability of seedless varieties. Today,bananas come in a variety of shapes, sizes, colours andflavours. Gros Michel, Gran Nain, Valery, Williams,Dwarf Cavendish, Cuban Red, Lady Finger, Blue Java,Orinoco, Popoulu – <strong>the</strong> list of varieties is as long as it isexotic. However, breeding modifications in <strong>the</strong> banana,brought about to improve edibility, have also increased itsgenetic vulnerability. The seedless banana cannot reproducesexually, but has been able to survive for some10,000 years through vegetative propagation by sideshoots (suckers).This genetic vulnerability is illustrated by <strong>the</strong> fact that40 years ago, Panama Disease, caused by a soil fungus(Fusarium oxysporum) that attacks banana roots, wipedout <strong>the</strong> world’s <strong>the</strong>n-favorite export variety, Gros Michel.Plantations switched to <strong>the</strong> Cavendish subgroup of varieties,which now play <strong>the</strong> major role in trade. Crop protection(especially disease control) is still an essentialcontribution to yield and quality production.1/07 COURIER 3


Distribution of World Gross Exports in 2004 (mio tonnes)Ecuador4.537O<strong>the</strong>rs2.259Guatemala1.05817.6%35.3%8.2%Source: <strong>Banana</strong> statistics 2005 FAO, May 200614.0%10.9%14.0%Philippines1.797Costa Rica1.793Colombia1.395Total 12.839 = 100%Black Sigatoka, caused by <strong>the</strong> fungus Mycoshaerella fijinesis is one of <strong>the</strong> most important leafdisease of industrially-grown bananas.The Threat of DiseasesNowadays, <strong>the</strong> most important leaf disease of industrially-grownbananas is Black Sigatoka. This leaf spotdisease is caused by <strong>the</strong> fungus Mycosphaerella fijiensis.Black Sigatoka was first described in Fiji in 1963,and subsequently reported throughout <strong>the</strong> Pacific regionand Asia. In 1972, it reached Honduras and wenton to spread across Central America, <strong>the</strong> nor<strong>the</strong>rn partof South America, to Peru and Bolivia, and to <strong>the</strong>Caribbean. It was first detected in <strong>the</strong> Amazon regionof Brazil in 1998, and in <strong>the</strong> sou<strong>the</strong>rn state of SaoPaulo in 2004.The first detection of Black Sigatoka in Africa occurredin Zambia in 1973. The disease <strong>the</strong>n spreadalong <strong>the</strong> western African coast, reaching Cameroonand <strong>the</strong> Ivory Coast, and eastward, across <strong>the</strong> Congo,reaching as far as Kenya.Mycosphaerella fijiensis belongs to <strong>the</strong> ascomycetefamily of fungi. The first symptoms of <strong>the</strong> disease aredark brown, 1 - 2 mm long streaks on <strong>the</strong> lower leafsurface. These streaks later develop into necrotic lesionswith yellow haloes and light-grey centers. Thelesions can eventually coalesce and destroy large areasof <strong>the</strong> leaf tissue, leading to earlier ripening of <strong>the</strong>fruit, and reduced yield.The pathogen has a life-cycle involving both asexualand sexual reproduction (see figure). Sexualreproduction occurs through <strong>the</strong> development of ascospores,which are disseminated over long distancesby wind; this is considered to be most important stagein disease development. During asexual reproduction,conidia are produced and <strong>the</strong>n disseminated short distancesacross <strong>the</strong> plant surface by water movement.After germination of ascospores or conidia, <strong>the</strong>pathogen may grow across <strong>the</strong> leaf surface for sometime before penetrating into <strong>the</strong> leaf via stomata. Underoptimal conditions, M. fijiensis can undergo <strong>the</strong>complete cycle from germination to secondary sporeproductionin 21 days.The highly damaging effect of Black Sigatoka diseaseon banana yield and quality means that sophisticatedcrop protection programs have to be implementedin <strong>the</strong> banana plantations. These programs include diseasemonitoring, good soil drainage, cultural practicessuch as <strong>the</strong> removal of infected leaves, and fungicidetreatment programs.Controlling Black SigatokaQuality check of banana bunches after harvesting.Chemical control of Black Sigatoka began in <strong>the</strong>1930s with <strong>the</strong> application of Bordeaux mixture andmineral oil. Today, mineral oil is still an importantcornerstone of Black Sigatoka control. It is usuallyapplied at 5 to 10 l/ha, often in tank-mixes with conventionalfungicides.Over <strong>the</strong> years, intensive research by crop protectioncompanies such as <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> has producednew, more effective fungicides from variousfungicide classes, such as <strong>the</strong> dithiocarbamates,morpholines, benzimidazoles, triazoles and strobilurines.4 COURIER 1/07


Development of Black Sigatoka disease caused byMycosphaerella fijiensis87Release ofascospores1Developmentof peri<strong>the</strong>ciawith asciBlack SigatokaSexual CycleAscosporesland on <strong>the</strong>leaf surface6Fertilization ofhyphee (female) byspermatia (male)AGerm-tubedevelopmenton <strong>the</strong> leafsurface25Development ofspermogonia andrelease of spermatiaDLocal disseminationof conidiaBlack SigatokaAsexual CyclePenetration into<strong>the</strong> leaf throughstomataB3Penetration into <strong>the</strong>leaf through stomataDevelopment of conidiophoresand production of conidiaMassivemycelium growthCMicroscopic detailsLeaf symptoms4112 3Stage I Stage II Stage III2Stage IV 4 Stage V 7 Stage VI 71/07 COURIER 5


Fungicides from different classes inhibitdifferent cell functionsMSIDMIMulti-Site Inhibitors (MSI) suchas propineb, mancozeb orchlorothalonil interfere with anumber of cellular functions.DMIs are Class I SBIs acting as C 14-DeMethylationInhibitors of fungal sterol biosyn<strong>the</strong>sis.SBIAmines are Class II SterolBiosyn<strong>the</strong>sis Inhibitors that donot block C 14 demethylation butra<strong>the</strong>r two o<strong>the</strong>r steps in sterolbiosyn<strong>the</strong>sis.ASIQolAnilino-Pyrimidines are Aminoacid Syn<strong>the</strong>sis Inhibitors thatblock <strong>the</strong> syn<strong>the</strong>sis of methionine,which is needed in allproteins.Quinoline outside Inhibitors (QoI), such asstrobilurins, block fungal respiration at <strong>the</strong>outer site of mitochondrial complex III.Established productsBaycor ® and Folicur ® are two well-known<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> triazole fungicides thathave been used successfully for BlackSigatoka control for many years.Baycor shows loco-systemic actionagainst Black Sigatoka. It penetrates into<strong>the</strong> leaf tissue and stays where it is neededmost for disease control.Baycor is more lipophilic than o<strong>the</strong>rtriazoles: it binds strongly to <strong>the</strong> surfacewaxes and <strong>the</strong> cuticle of <strong>the</strong> leaf, ensuringexcellent rain-fastness. Once bound to <strong>the</strong>leaf surface, <strong>the</strong> active ingredient is in <strong>the</strong>right place when <strong>the</strong> pathogen starts to infect.If applied with mineral oil, Baycormoves across <strong>the</strong> leaf surface and remainsselectively close to areas of sap flow, <strong>the</strong>rebyproviding enhanced protection of <strong>the</strong>leaf rib and veins.Folicur penetrates rapidly into <strong>the</strong> deeperleaf tissues. Its systemic properties allow itto move easily through <strong>the</strong> sap, so that itquickly spreads within <strong>the</strong> leaf. It movestransversally and becomes evenly-distributedwithin <strong>the</strong> leaf, thus giving protectionof <strong>the</strong> whole leaf blade.Baycor and Folicur complement eacho<strong>the</strong>r ideally, facilitating disease control atall phases of disease development, andchecking <strong>the</strong> pathogen’s development bothon, and within, <strong>the</strong> leaf.Growing portfolioMore recently, <strong>the</strong> strobilurin class of fungicideshas been introduced. Tega ® , one of<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’s strobilurins, is a highlyeffective compound of this class availablefor Black Sigatoka control in bananas.Tega shows mesostemic action, and exhibitsan excellent combination of chemodynamic properties. It has a great affinityfor <strong>the</strong> waxy layer on <strong>the</strong> surface of <strong>the</strong> bananaleaf. Once applied, it soon forms awea<strong>the</strong>r-protected depot, from whence itgradually penetrates into <strong>the</strong> mesophyll of<strong>the</strong> leaf. Tega is also redistributed across<strong>the</strong> leaf surface in water; along with super-ficial vapor movement, this protects partsof <strong>the</strong> plant surface that did not receive <strong>the</strong>product directly during spraying. The consequenceof <strong>the</strong> product’s translaminaractivity and its excellent rain-fastness is along-lasting residual effect. This combinationof properties makes Tega an excellentsolution for Black Sigatoka control.<strong>Bayer</strong> Cropscience has recently complementedits range of banana fungicidesfur<strong>the</strong>r with Siganex ® , <strong>the</strong> only anilinopyrimidineavailable for Black Sigatoka control,and Impulse ® , which belongs to a newchemical group, <strong>the</strong> spiroketalamines.Both products show excellent phytocompatibilitywith banana plants; no leaf or fruitspeckling is observed when <strong>the</strong> productsare applied as instructed on <strong>the</strong> labels.The mode of action of Siganex is new.Siganex inhibits <strong>the</strong> pathogen primarily byinhibiting germ-tube extension andmycelial growth. Fungal secretion of enzymesrequired for <strong>the</strong> infection process isalso disrupted, and nutrient acquisition by<strong>the</strong> pathogen is blocked. As a consequence,plant cell destruction is prevented.6 COURIER 1/07


We have all it takes to fight BlackSigatoka effectivelyMaximize efficacy – minimize resistance riskMSI DMI Qol SBI ASI40 sprays/season 8 8 3 15 630 sprays/season 7 7 3 8 520 sprays/season 4 5 2 5 410 sprays/season 3 2 1 2 2LegendAbbreviation Target Group nameMSI Multi-site Inhibitor Contact fungicidesDMI Demethylation Inhibitor TriazolesQoI Quinoline outside Inhibitor StrobilurinsSBI Sterol Biosyn<strong>the</strong>sis Inhibitor AminesASI Amino Acid Syn<strong>the</strong>sis Inhibitor AnilinopyrimidinesSustainability through diversityIntelligent use of all available modes of action minimizes <strong>the</strong> resistance risk and allows more stableprotection against Black Sigatoka. <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> offers a broad fungicide portfolio for managingBlack Sigatoka effectively and efficiently, helping you to grow a healthy crop.Golden rules of astable anti-resistancemanagement• Fully implement FungicideResistance Action Committee(FRAC) guidelines.• Don’t exceed <strong>the</strong> maximumnumber of alloted number ofsprays/year for each specificmode of action.• Use <strong>the</strong> full range of modesof action available.• Consider <strong>the</strong> regular use ofmixtures of specific fungicideswith multi-site compounds.• Don’t under-dose <strong>the</strong> mixingpartners. They are of little usein resistance management if<strong>the</strong>y can’t stand on <strong>the</strong>ir ownat <strong>the</strong> rate used in <strong>the</strong> mixture!The greater <strong>the</strong> number of differentfungicide classes used,<strong>the</strong> more stable <strong>the</strong> system!Sustainability through diversity!Siganex shows excellent spread, distributionand uptake into <strong>the</strong> leaf. These characteristics,and <strong>the</strong> nature of <strong>the</strong> product’sinteraction with <strong>the</strong> leaf wax structures,lead to an excellent rain fastness and verygood efficacy. No cross-resistance hasbeen observed with o<strong>the</strong>r fungicide classes,so Siganex is an ideal tool for avoidingor managing fungicide resistance in a Sigatokacontrol program. All in all, Siganexrepresents a real innovation in Sigatokacontrol.Impulse is a systemic compound thatpenetrates <strong>the</strong> leaf quickly and spreads uniformlythrough <strong>the</strong> plant tissue, givingboth preventive and curative control ofBlack Sigatoka. It is an ideal fungicide foralternating with, or using in mixtures with,triazoles such as Baycor or Folicur, or withstrobilurins such as Tega, in order to managepotential or existing resistance risks.Impulse is a modern fungicide that is idealfor enhancing Black Sigatoka control programsfor quality production.<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> offers what can trulybe described as one of <strong>the</strong> most comprehensive,innovative and technologicallyadvancedfungicide portfolio for BlackSigatoka control. This gives banana growersa tool-box that allows <strong>the</strong>m to manage <strong>the</strong>disease, according to local climatic conditionsand disease pressure.Resistance Management –A continuous challengeThe Black Sigatoka pathogen has an exceptionalability to develop fungicide resistance,especially in areas where temperatureand high rainfall favor reproduction.Fungicide spray programs must be highlysophisticated, based on resistance monitoringinformation, product rotation, and applyingspecific fungicides toge<strong>the</strong>r withmulti-site fungicides and mineral oil.With its strong product portfolio, <strong>Bayer</strong><strong>CropScience</strong> has developed an approach toresistance management that is based on researchspecialists’ knowledge and practicalexperience, gained over many years.The fundamental priniple is that <strong>the</strong>more modes of action you use, <strong>the</strong> morestable <strong>the</strong> cultivation program is – sustainabilitythrough diversity. Certain “GoldenRules” need to be followed in order toachieve <strong>the</strong> right balance between <strong>the</strong> variousmodes of action for <strong>the</strong> respectivenumber of applications per year (see box).This concept is illustrated by <strong>the</strong> “DiamondModel”, developed by <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>:here, <strong>the</strong> modes of action available for controllingBlack Sigatoka are shown across<strong>the</strong> top of <strong>the</strong> diamond; below each modeof action is an alloted maximum number ofapplications of that mode of action, dependingon <strong>the</strong> anticipated total number ofapplications to be made within a season.The number of applications by mode of actionin <strong>the</strong> top row reflects <strong>the</strong> maximumnumbers recommended by <strong>the</strong> internationalFungicide Resistance Action Committee(FRAC).<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> offers a <strong>treasure</strong> ofdiversity in terms of fungicide modes ofaction for <strong>the</strong> control of Black Sigatoka. Theintelligent use of all available modes of actionallows <strong>the</strong> grower to minimize <strong>the</strong> resistancerisk, and to maximize efficacy. ■1/07 COURIER 7


Setting <strong>the</strong> Standard inProduct StewardshipFor <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>, taking care that ourproducts are used safely and responsibly iscertainly not a matter of paying lip service tooutside expectations. Product stewardship livesas a corporate philosophy and is expressedthrough a multitude of projects sponsored byour country organizations.8 COURIER 1/07


Although crop protection products are abeneficial technology, essential to securing<strong>the</strong> world’s food supply, <strong>the</strong>y regularly hit<strong>the</strong> headlines under suspicion of harminghuman health and <strong>the</strong> environment. However,<strong>the</strong> incidents that are reported mostlyinvolve inappropriate use or handling of<strong>the</strong>se chemical substances. In order to preventsuch product abuses, and to avoid accidents,<strong>the</strong> major crop protection companiesare committed to providing extensiveproduct stewardship. <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> isat <strong>the</strong> cutting edge of promoting <strong>the</strong> responsiblemanagement of our products,within <strong>the</strong> company, in <strong>the</strong> field, and beyond.Product stewardship starts with <strong>the</strong> inventionof an active substance and continuesthroughout <strong>the</strong> product life-cycle, up toand including <strong>the</strong> disposal of empty containersor obsolete stock. Every year, <strong>Bayer</strong><strong>CropScience</strong> evaluates its activities and assesses<strong>the</strong> level of compliance with its productstewardship policy. This policy and <strong>the</strong>key requirements derived from it, arebased on <strong>the</strong> International Code of Conducton <strong>the</strong> Distribution and Use of Pesticides,set up by <strong>the</strong> Food and AgricultureOrganization (FAO) of <strong>the</strong> United Nations.The Product Stewardship Program of<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> has its roots in ResponsibleCare – a program sponsored by <strong>the</strong>Chemical Manufacturers Association. Thefeatures of <strong>the</strong> principles include in particular<strong>the</strong> consistent application of productstewardship across <strong>the</strong> entire value-addedchain, and a management system approachto all aspects of safety, health protectionand environmental protection. <strong>Bayer</strong> Crop-Science goes an extra mile with ProductStewardship as will be shown in <strong>the</strong> followingexamples.Paper does not blush but <strong>Bayer</strong> Crop-Science product stewards would if one of<strong>the</strong>ir substances posed a danger if handledand applied properly. We have 88 stewardsworking around <strong>the</strong> globe, each of whom iscommitted to <strong>the</strong> cause of ensuring <strong>the</strong> safeuse of our products.The annual assessment produces somereassuring figures. Take one example: <strong>the</strong>2006 <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> safe seed-treatmentcampaign in <strong>the</strong> Ukraine, whichreached 4,000 farms via direct contacts,and some 18,000 farms through <strong>the</strong> media.Dr. Peter Ohs, Senior Safe Use Manager at<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>, is pleased with <strong>the</strong>success of this project: “The campaign significantlyincreased <strong>the</strong> percentage ofusers wearing protective equipment to a remarkableextend. But this was not our onlyconcern. Above all, we wanted to raise operators’awareness and convey <strong>the</strong> benefitsof safe product use.”One Philosophy, two targetsThe safe-use campaign in <strong>the</strong> Ukraine isonly one of many country- and productspecificprojects in progress, all of whichadd toge<strong>the</strong>r to form a well-rounded policy.“Within <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>, product stewardshipis a philosophy that influences allcompany operations”, Peter Ohs underlines.He makes it clear that stewardshipimplies more than just rescue work wherehazards arise for health and <strong>the</strong> environment:“product stewardship has two maintargets: minimizing potential risk, andmaximizing <strong>the</strong> benefits derived fromproduct use, both for farmers and for ourcompany”.To ensure <strong>the</strong> successful implementationand monitoring of its product stewardshipapproach, <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> has fixedtwelve stewardship principles, each ofwhich leads to concrete instructions. Thecompany guidelines comply fully with <strong>the</strong>FAO Code of Conduct on <strong>the</strong> Distributionand Use of Pesticides. One of <strong>the</strong> twelve<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> principles focuses onObsolete StockManagementICM & UsersTraining<strong>the</strong> training of staff and customers in all aspectsof responsible product use. The companyruns training programs for users in allcontinents; <strong>the</strong> project in <strong>the</strong> Ukraine isjust one example.“In <strong>the</strong> Ukraine, we aim to advancesafety standards when applying <strong>Bayer</strong><strong>CropScience</strong> products through two parallelstrategies: <strong>the</strong> instruction of farm workers;and winning <strong>the</strong>ir belief in product stewardship”explains Evgenia Ustimenko, <strong>the</strong>project leader. The safe-use campaign preceded<strong>the</strong> launch of Lamardor ® , a fungicidalseed treatment product based on prothioconazole.The campaign comprised educationaladvertising in <strong>the</strong> national media,public discussion meetings, and trainingevents for retailers, farmers and farmworkers. The participation of <strong>the</strong> latter twogroups was fur<strong>the</strong>r encouraged by settingup a competition for <strong>the</strong> best on-farm implementationof product stewardship.As <strong>the</strong> Ukrainian project scored so wellin <strong>the</strong> company-internal annual assessmentof product stewardship projects, it is nowbeing expanded into Moldavia and Romaniain 2007. However, project activities alwayshave to be adapted to local conditions,because different countries vary insize and agrarian structure. The annual as-Product Stewardshipis a Life Cycle ApproachProductStewardshipRegistration, MarketingResearch andDevelopmentContainerManagementManufacturingWarehousing1/07 COURIER 9


The product stewardship campaign of <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> in <strong>the</strong> Ukraine led to anincreased percentage of users wearing protective clo<strong>the</strong>s.The product stewardship project in Southand Latin America is called “Agrovida”. Theproject logo is widely used and draws <strong>the</strong>attention to this project.sessment of all product stewardship projectsserves a double purpose, as Dr. Ohspoints out: “The evaluation gives immediatefeedback to our country organizationsas to how <strong>the</strong>y can fur<strong>the</strong>r improve <strong>the</strong>iractivities. Fur<strong>the</strong>rmore, experience from<strong>the</strong> countries provides <strong>the</strong> basis for formulatingglobal product stewardship strategiesand developing global projects.”Projects are making an impactFor instance, <strong>the</strong> “Safe Use in Seed Treatment”is a global campaign, which issteered from <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> Headquartersin Monheim, Germany. A CD-ROM “Guide to responsible seed treatment”has been produced and is availablein various languages; it is aimed at differenttarget groups, i.e. for both farm and industrialuse. This resource is used in extensionand training. Ano<strong>the</strong>r training kit targetsresponsible product use in greenhouses.An example of <strong>the</strong> use of <strong>the</strong>se materialsis a pilot project in Turkey, which willbe transferred to o<strong>the</strong>r countries around <strong>the</strong>Mediterranean area after it has been evaluated.“We have to target our resources to alimited number of projects. But <strong>the</strong>se areprojects that make an impact”, reasonsPeter Ohs.In line with this prioritization approach,<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> is currently concentratingon offering training for crop protectiontraders and extension officers, because<strong>the</strong>se people act as knowledge multipliersin <strong>the</strong>ir regions. In Brazil for example - <strong>the</strong>company has started a certification schemefor retailers who are capable of providing<strong>the</strong> appropriate product stewardship knowhow.Distributors who have been awarded acertificate are audited regularly. Ano<strong>the</strong>rexample is <strong>the</strong> training of retailers by <strong>Bayer</strong><strong>CropScience</strong> China, under <strong>the</strong> <strong>Bayer</strong>Key Retailer project. Projects like thiscomply with ano<strong>the</strong>r principle of <strong>the</strong> productstewardship policy that relates to ourbusiness partners: <strong>the</strong>y are expected to apply<strong>the</strong> same level of responsibility as isdemanded within <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> as acompany.These product stewardship principles(and indeed all of <strong>the</strong> twelve) accompany<strong>the</strong> full life-cycle of a crop protectionproduct. They start right at <strong>the</strong> time of selectingand testing new substances, andcontinue to apply to product registration,labeling, and formulation. “You can pack alot of safety into <strong>the</strong> formulation of an activeingredient”, explains Andreas Stork,Team Leader of Insecticide FormulationTechnology at <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>. “Forexample, improved adhesion and penetrationof a substance reduces <strong>the</strong> necessaryapplication rate.” In ano<strong>the</strong>r project, <strong>Bayer</strong><strong>CropScience</strong> researchers have developed astem-injection system for palm trees thatminimizes <strong>the</strong> product exposure of usersand <strong>the</strong> environment. Closely connectedwith this stewardship principle is <strong>the</strong> developmentof innovative product packaging,for example, with a built-in measuringcup.10 COURIER 1/07


Dialogue and discussion are <strong>the</strong> best means of promoting <strong>the</strong> safe use of crop protectionproducts.The optimal protective outfit for working with crop protectionproducts was promoted in a safe use project in Turkey.Responsible care atall product stagesIn cooperation with o<strong>the</strong>r stakeholders,<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> runs projects on <strong>the</strong>disposal or recycling of empty containers –by far not in each country an industry organizationor <strong>the</strong> state takes care of thistask. The company is also involved in <strong>the</strong>safe disposal of obsolete pesticide stocks,especially in developing countries. Expertsestimate that this is a problem on a largescale – 500,000 tons of product, oftenstored under poor conditions and sometimesinvolving older, more hazardous substances.But even before a product is sold to retailersor users, its safe development andmanufacturing on <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> sitesmust be ensured. A “Quality, Health, Safetyand Environment Policy” (QHSE) andQHSE Management Systems govern <strong>the</strong>handling of chemical substances at all ofour sites. The transport and storage ofproducts is organized in accordance withlegal requirements. <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> alsomaintains up-to-date Material Safety DataSheets for each commercial product andmakes <strong>the</strong>m available to all stakeholders.<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> does not tolerateany unapproved use of its products. “Dependingon <strong>the</strong> particular circumstances,we have <strong>the</strong> option of applying for a labelextension by providing <strong>the</strong> necessary studiesin order to enable <strong>the</strong> farmer to use <strong>the</strong>product legally; o<strong>the</strong>rwise, we try to persuade<strong>the</strong> farmers to use alternatives”, PeterOhs explains. When <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>learns of a health hazard or an ecologicalrisk posed by one of its products, additionalproduct stewardship efforts are made, or,if <strong>the</strong> risk cannot be thus excluded, marketingof <strong>the</strong> product may be stopped, andsubstitutes are sought. “Take <strong>the</strong> insecticidealdicarb, graded class I by <strong>the</strong> WorldHealth Organization but authorized forspecified uses in United States. In cooperationwith <strong>the</strong> national authority, we haveset up strict rules for farmers intending toapply aldicarb-containing products safely,”Peter Ohs adds.Dialogue promotesproduct stewardship<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> has initiated a projectcalled “AgroVida” in a number of countriesin South and Latin America. This is aPublic Private Partnership used as an instrumentto support Sustainable Developmentin rural areas, which involves localauthorities, unions, industry and farmers’associations. “In so-called ‘farmer clubs’,opinion leaders in a certain micro-regionmeet to discuss agricultural problems, but<strong>the</strong> topics are not necessarily restricted tosafe product use”, reports Margot Börgartz,Safe Use Assurance Manager at<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>. Latin America is hermain region of activity, and she is very familiarwith <strong>the</strong> “Agrovida” campaign<strong>the</strong>re.Peter Ohs is convinced that dialogueand discussion are <strong>the</strong> best means of promoting<strong>the</strong> safe use of crop protectionproducts. “Whe<strong>the</strong>r fostering <strong>the</strong> philosophyof product stewardship within ourcompany or passing it on to farmers, ourexperience is <strong>the</strong> same: Responsible Care,in <strong>the</strong> majority of cases, is realised throughan exchange of thoughts, by listening to ar-guments, and by reflecting on <strong>the</strong>m.”Moreover, product stewardship needsconcerted action. So <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>tends not to organize projects by itself, butra<strong>the</strong>r brings various stakeholders toge<strong>the</strong>r.For example, a project on safe use ingreenhouses in Turkey brought toge<strong>the</strong>rmanufacturers of protective clothing, aproducer of spraying devices, regional authorities,and retailers.Stakeholders are unified by a commongoal: and this refers not only to minimize<strong>the</strong> risks associated with a product; butalso to maximize its benefits. “Productstewardship is not a matter of charitableactivity: it must fulfil criteria for sustainabilityfor our company”, points out PeterOhs. “We want to set <strong>the</strong> standard in productstewardship towards <strong>the</strong> safe use of ourproducts and <strong>the</strong>ir compatibility to <strong>the</strong> environment.But for us, product stewardshipis also connected with economic sustainability.Product stewardship yields a profit,not only in terms of reputation, but also interms of money.” ■Links to Product Stewardship• www.bayercropscience.com• www.croplife.org• www.fao.org1/07 COURIER 11


We’ve got itFranz-Peter Schueller, Headof <strong>the</strong> Packaging Technology at<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>Ventilating cap for bubble-free filling12 COURIER 1/07


in <strong>the</strong> can!The modern crop protection market not only makeshigh demands of active substances and <strong>the</strong>ir formulations:it also presents significant challenges in terms ofpackaging design. The materials that are used mustprotect <strong>the</strong> product from <strong>the</strong> effects of external factors;but at <strong>the</strong> same time, <strong>the</strong>y must also protect <strong>the</strong> user,and <strong>the</strong> environment, from <strong>the</strong> product itself.Franz-Peter Schueller, Head of <strong>the</strong> PackagingTechnology Department at <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>,answers our questions about <strong>the</strong> best approachesto packaging crop protection products.Courier: What are <strong>the</strong> challenges that packagingfor crop protection product must meet?Schueller: Crop protection products are usedseasonally, so <strong>the</strong>y must sometimes be stored forprolonged periods, and <strong>the</strong> packaging materialmust not change during this time. On <strong>the</strong> onehand, it must protect <strong>the</strong> environment and <strong>the</strong>user from <strong>the</strong> crop protection product, so it is essentialthat <strong>the</strong>re are no leaks (for example ofsolvents). On <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r hand, <strong>the</strong> crop protectionproduct must retain its quality over long periodsof storage, in spite of <strong>the</strong> various environmentalfactors that could degrade it, such as light, temperatureand moisture.The stability of our packaging is proven instringent, specially-designed tests that closely relateto practical conditions. Among <strong>the</strong>se aresimulations of <strong>the</strong> type of accidents that can happenduring transport or storage; <strong>the</strong>se are verysevere tests of <strong>the</strong> packaging! We need to be ableto show that our packaging can withstand severecompression or extreme environmental conditions.Besides durability and stability, ecologicaland economic considerations are also particularlyimportant. We do our best to develop packagingwith <strong>the</strong> smallest possible volume and <strong>the</strong> lowestpossible weight in order to optimise transportcosts. Here, modern materials offer us many possibilitiesfor innovation. Our packaging is alsodesigned to be stacked easily, fitting as well aspossible onto palettes – <strong>the</strong>se are important criteriafor <strong>the</strong> trade.One very important consideration is that ourpackaging must be easy to empty and to rinseout. Here, <strong>the</strong> requirements are particularly demanding:every new container that is designedmust be capable of almost complete emptying -less than 0.01 % of <strong>the</strong> original contents shouldremain after a standard rinsing action done underpractical conditions.The user has expectations too. Containersmust be as light as possible, and easy to emptyand rinse; easy opening and secure re-closing of<strong>the</strong> packaging are also considered to be particularlyimportant.Courier: Which materials are used forpackaging?Schueller: Because every container must be suitedto its particular contents and use, various differentmaterials are used. The most common types ofcontainer are cans and bottles, which are generallymade of “High Density Poly-Ethylene“ (HDPE).Some crop protection products contain certainsubstances that are capable of penetrating throughHDPE. For <strong>the</strong>se products, an additional protectivelayer of polyamide or Ethylene Vinyl alcohol(EVOH) is used inside <strong>the</strong> standard HDPE containers.These plastic coatings are in fact relativelyexpensive.Courier: Where do you get your ideas fornew types of packaging?1/07 COURIER 13


Schueller: Most of <strong>the</strong> time, we receivesuggestions from our colleagues in <strong>the</strong>Marketing Departments and Field Services.They know what <strong>the</strong> trade demandsand what <strong>the</strong> users prefer, and are able toprovide us with suggestions as to how weshould be packing our new crop protectionproducts. But we also obtain ideas for improvements,or even entirely new concepts,from our network of partners, includingcontainer- and packaging-material suppliers,production sites, and Research andDevelopment departments.Courier: How do you keep track of <strong>the</strong>many types of packaging you deal withand <strong>the</strong> concepts underlying <strong>the</strong>m?Schueller: In order to manage our packagingsand <strong>the</strong>ir associated concepts, we usean SAP-application that has been specially-adaptedto meet our requirements. It offersa good platform to be able to exchangeand balance <strong>the</strong> large amount of data wehave to handle. Our European databasealone currently contains around 30,000items of information. This is a lot of dataof course – but <strong>the</strong>re is a separate entry foreach of <strong>the</strong> different containers, whe<strong>the</strong>r itbe a 1 l bottle, a 10 l can or a 200 l drum,and for each of <strong>the</strong> various labels for <strong>the</strong>different crop protection products.Courier: What are <strong>the</strong> steps involved indeveloping a new packaging?Schueller: The development of a new packagingtakes roughly six to twelve monthsfrom <strong>the</strong> original order to final production. Itis a process that involves many partners,from <strong>the</strong> original requester to <strong>the</strong> various expertfunctions. The process can be dividedinto five phases. First, <strong>the</strong> innovation/creativityphase, during which our team’s pre-liminary ideas and solutions are collected. In<strong>the</strong> second phase, we identify <strong>the</strong> suggestionsthat promise rapid realisation, and determineprovisional time-plans and cost-estimatesfor <strong>the</strong>m. In phase 3, we select <strong>the</strong> bestof <strong>the</strong>se suggestions, after having checkedthat certain legal and practical requirementshave been met. Phase 4 involves applying forofficial approval, holding negotiations withsuppliers and production sites, and producingtest batches. If <strong>the</strong> test batches lookgood, we proceed with phase 5 – productionlinemanufacture of <strong>the</strong> packaging.But before a new packaging can enter<strong>the</strong> market, it has to undergo certain teststhat are stipulated by <strong>the</strong> registration process.These are run in partnership with FormulationTechnology. We test <strong>the</strong> performanceof <strong>the</strong> packaging per se, but we alsoinvestigate its suitability in connection witha particular plant protection product. Thelegally-required dangerous goods validationis <strong>the</strong>n done by an accredited Institute.Courier: What is <strong>the</strong> philosophyunderlying your work?Schueller: Packaging means thinking <strong>the</strong>process through to its end! We understand<strong>the</strong> packaging process as a closed concept.When developing a new packaging, a balancemust be made between <strong>the</strong> numerousdemands made of it. We aim to achieve thisbalance, and at <strong>the</strong> same time to take <strong>the</strong>user’s preferences into consideration. I amconfident that PacTec – as my Function isoften called – will always continue to respondrapidly and creatively to <strong>the</strong> everchangingneeds of our market through itscustomary combination of excellent packaging-and manufacturing-concepts.Courier: Herr Schueller, thank you fortalking to us. ■ManagresistaFungicide Herbicide Insecticide Seed treatment O<strong>the</strong>rsClear and unambiguous labelingBesides carrying <strong>the</strong> legally-required dangerous goods identification, <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’sproducts carry easily-readable labels on pallettes and cartons. Every individual containerhas a strongly-fixed label that gives advice on <strong>the</strong> safe use of <strong>the</strong> product, and providesuseful information on its application.Standardized colour-coding is used to mark <strong>the</strong> labels of different types of productsin order to allow <strong>the</strong>m to be recognised easily. All of <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’s labels have acharacteristic lay-out: we use a standard color-scheme that is readily recognized by ourcustomers.14 COURIER 1/07


Whiteflies are small homopterans (familyAleyrodidae) that are typically foundfeeding on <strong>the</strong> undersides of plant leaves.Sucking damage by whiteflies can reduceyields directly, but it is <strong>the</strong>ir ability totransmit viruses that makes <strong>the</strong>m a majorcause of losses in food production. In <strong>the</strong>tropics and subtropics, whiteflies have becomeone of <strong>the</strong> most serious agriculturalpests. Their biological properties – highreproductive rates, multiple generationsper year, and <strong>the</strong> ability to attack a largenumber of different crops – mean thatwhiteflies such as Bemisia tabaci havebeen able to develop a high degree of resistanceto several classes of conventionalinsecticides. Affected chemical groups include<strong>the</strong> organophosphates, carbamates,pyrethroids, insect growth regulators andchlorinated hydrocarbons. Where resistanceexists, new, efficient tools are neededin <strong>the</strong> form of innovative insecticides withing insecticident whitefliesalternative modes of action. Only <strong>the</strong> intelligentuse of such products will prevent <strong>the</strong>development of multiple-resistant whiteflypopulations, with <strong>the</strong>ir potential to causedisastrous problems for farmers all over<strong>the</strong> world.The tobacco whiteflyThe problem of resistance development inwhiteflies can be overcome through intelligentmanagement practices – includinga block spray approach using neonicotinoidand ketoenole insecticides. Examplesfrom <strong>the</strong> USA and Guatemala show howeffective <strong>the</strong>se systems can be.The species complexes of whiteflies under<strong>the</strong> genus Bemisia are important transmittersof plant diseases. The tobacco whiteflyBemisia tabaci and <strong>the</strong> closely-related silverleafwhitefly Bemisia argentifolii transmitmore than 60 different phytopathogenicviruses, including African cassava mosaic,bean golden mosaic, bean dwarf mosaic,bean calico mosaic, tomato yellow leafcurl,tomato mottle, and o<strong>the</strong>r Begomoviruses.Bemisia argentifolii is an emergingspecies that has been spreading around<strong>the</strong> world, increasingly causing severe croplosses. To make things worse, Bemisiatabaci has developed high levels of resistanceto <strong>the</strong> conventional insecticides usedin many agricultural systems around <strong>the</strong>world.1/07 COURIER 15


The greenhouse whiteflyThe greenhouse whitefly Trialeurodes vaporariorumis endemic to <strong>the</strong> world’s temperateregions. It is a primary insect pest ofmany fruit, vegetable and ornamentalcrops, and is frequently found in glasshousesand o<strong>the</strong>r protected horticulturalenvironments.Crop damage occurs mainly through directfeeding; but honeydew, <strong>the</strong> excretedby-product of feeding, can also be a majorsource of damage. The adult whitefly alsotransmits several plant viruses. The principalcrops attacked by this species are vegetablessuch as cucurbits, potatoes andtomatoes; but a range of o<strong>the</strong>r crop andnon-crop plants (including certain weedspecies) are susceptible, and can <strong>the</strong>reforeharbor whitefly populations.Neonicotinoids – a powerfultool for controlling whitefliesThe chemical class of <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoids –with its prominent representative imidacloprid(in products such as Confidor ® ,Admire ® , and Gaucho ® ) – is particularlyactive against a range of homopteran pestspecies, including whiteflies. Imidaclopridis used in seed treatments and soil or foliarapplications; its systemic properties allowextensive uptake and distribution within<strong>the</strong> plant, resulting in an excellent protectionof <strong>the</strong> young, growing plant. Like o<strong>the</strong>rneonicotinoids, imidacloprid acts agonisticallyat <strong>the</strong> insect nicotinic acetylcholinereceptor. Insect populations that have developedresistance to conventional insecticidesare controlled very effectively byneonicotinoid-containing products.Resistance development in whitefliesoccurs through genetic changes that arisein <strong>the</strong> pest population. Variations in <strong>the</strong>structure of <strong>the</strong> target site (which make itimpossible for <strong>the</strong> active substance moleculeto bind to its receptor in <strong>the</strong> insect)have been detected for many classes of insecticides,but not so far for <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoids;where resistance to neonicotinoidsdoes occur, it is based on <strong>the</strong> enhancedproduction of enzymes (e.g. microsomalmonooxygenases) that are able to detoxify<strong>the</strong> insecticides.1 E. g. Pflanzenschutz Nachrichten <strong>Bayer</strong>, Volume, 58,2005. This issue is also available for download at ourwebsite www.pflanzenschutz-nachrichten.com2 Source: J Palumbo, C Ellsworth, TJ Dennehy. CrosscommodityGuidelines for Neonicotinoids in Arizona.The University of Arizona. . A Cooperative Extension.IPM Series No 17, 2/2003 (modified)Sustaining <strong>the</strong> efficacyof neonicotinoidsApplying <strong>the</strong> resistance-management strategiespublished in <strong>the</strong> <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>resistance-management guidelines 1 alongsideintensive resistance monitoring programshas helped to maintain <strong>the</strong> excellentfield performance of neonicotinoids againstwhiteflies and various o<strong>the</strong>r pests in manycountries of <strong>the</strong> world. The cornerstones ofour resistance-management recommendationsare as follows:• Limit <strong>the</strong> number of neonicotinoidapplications against a particular pestspecies to a maximum of three per croppingcycle• Make <strong>the</strong> three applications in a singleblock, in order to limit to one pest generationonly <strong>the</strong> selection pressure forresistance to neonicotinoids• For any additional treatments, use productswith modes of action different fromthat of <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoids• Use all products according to <strong>the</strong> instructionson <strong>the</strong> manufacturer’s label• Apply products such that beneficial organismsare not harmed• Apply any relevant Integrated PestManagement measures (appropriatecultivation, resistant varieties, physicalcontrol measures etc.)Two recent examples of efficient whiteflyresistance management – from <strong>the</strong> USAand Guatemala – are given below.Sustainable InsecticideUse in GuatemalaIn some areas of <strong>the</strong> world our field monitoringhas revealed a localized reduction in<strong>the</strong> sensitivity of whiteflies to neonicotinoids.This is <strong>the</strong> case in Guatemala, where<strong>the</strong> lack of effective chemical alternativeshas led to <strong>the</strong> development of whitefly resistanceafter multiple neonicotinoid use incertain tomato- and melon-growing areas.Moreover, increased problems with <strong>the</strong>Resistance management in a multi-crop CommunityYuma, Arizona, USAThe following resistance-management recommendations were followed by growersin a multiple crop community (melon, vegetables, cotton and alfalfa):a) Invest in crop sanitation (e.g. removal of post-harvest residues) and crop sequencing.b) Use only recommended CNIs (neonicotinoids) at <strong>the</strong> stipulated rates.c) Use action thresholds that have been determined through research.d) Do not apply CNIs in alfalfa or cotton stands grown as escape crops (refuges).e) Do not use more than one particular CNI product per crop.f) Do not apply a foliar CNI spray after a soil CNI application has already been made.Independent researchers acknowledged that sustainable and effective multi-yearuse of imidacloprid is possible if <strong>the</strong> farmer complies with <strong>the</strong> above described typeof resistance management strategy.Resistance management – whiteflies 2Preserve a neonicotinoid-free period in multi-crop communities (e.g. Yuma-recommended)MelonsVegetablesCottonRelative WhiteflyPopulation AbundanceNeonicotinoidF13 F1 F2IGRs andConventionalF3 F4 F5 F6Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov DecF7F8F9F10 F11F1216 COURIER 1/07


Whiteflies (Bemisia tabaci)Whiteflies (Trialeurodes vaporariorum)virus diseases (e.g. geminivirus, TYLCV)spread by mixed whitefly infestations ofBemisia sp. and Trialeurodes sp. have beenreported. Hence at <strong>the</strong> beginning of 2005,a locally-tailored integrated crop managementconcept was established, which includesrecommendations in terms of cropsanitation, keeping periods free of hostplants, applying good agricultural practice,and practicing science-based resistancemanagement:• The melon-producing companies allagreed to plant and harvest simultaneously,thus limiting <strong>the</strong> availability ofhost plants for <strong>the</strong> pest in <strong>the</strong> inter-croppingperiod and <strong>the</strong>reby reducing <strong>the</strong>need to use insecticides.• Almost 100% of <strong>the</strong> producing companiesuse Agribon ®1 nets (a screen tocover <strong>the</strong> crop) for <strong>the</strong> first 25-30 daysafter transplanting, as an effectivemeans of protecting against early whiteflyinfestations.• Neonicotinoid applications are restrictedto one Confidor ® soil-drench through<strong>the</strong> irrigation system before <strong>the</strong> screensare set up, or to 2 foliar spray applicationsonly, in rotation with applicationsof o<strong>the</strong>r chemistries (e.g. Oberon ® .)This integrated resistance-managementapproach was developed in close collaborationwith local experts, including <strong>the</strong>Whitefly National Commission and <strong>the</strong>vegetable-producing companies. By <strong>the</strong>®1 = registered trademark of Polymer Group Inc.,Charleston, USAsecond half of 2005, it had already led to<strong>the</strong> recovery of full neonicotinoid sensitivityin <strong>the</strong> whitefly populations, and an outstandinglevel of success in terms of whiteflycontrol.Oberon – support for<strong>the</strong> neonicotinoidsOberon (spiromesifen) is a new and powerfultool for <strong>the</strong> control of whiteflies. Itsmarket introduction has been just at <strong>the</strong>right time, allowing it to fulfill a valuablerole in resistance management. It is amember of <strong>the</strong> new <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>exclusiveclass of ketoenoles, with a totallynew mode of action. Oberon provides asolid basis for preserving not only imidacloprid,but also our newer neonicotinoidsCalypso ® (thiacloprid), and Poncho ® (clothianidin)for seed treatment.ConclusionsFarmers in Guatemalause Agribon nets to protectcrops against earlywhitefly infestations.Cultivation system formelons and tomatoes inGuatemalaDespite <strong>the</strong> use of Confidor for whiteflycontrol for over 15 years, resistance toimidacloprid and o<strong>the</strong>r neonicotinoidsremains quite localized in field-derivedpopulations of Bemisia spp. This success isbased on <strong>the</strong> proactive exercise of resistancemanagement, e.g. limiting <strong>the</strong> numberof neonicotinoid applications to a maximumof three, and on applying an additionalrange of effective Integrated PestManagement tactics.<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> continues to workwith local affiliates and independent researchersto develop and promote effectiveregional resistance-management conceptsfor neonicotinoids, as well as for <strong>the</strong> rest ofour portfolio. This will ensure <strong>the</strong> sustainableuse of valuable agrochemicals as <strong>the</strong>basis for high-quality food production into<strong>the</strong> future. ■1/07 COURIER 17


Shifting<strong>the</strong> Viewon WaterWater as a basicnecessity in farming,as in life, is self-evident.To different people,however, water canmean many differentthings – and have manydifferent meanings.


Kofi Annan, <strong>the</strong> recently retired SecretaryGeneral of <strong>the</strong> UN, agreed and pushedhard to get water on <strong>the</strong> international political,economic and development agenda.“We shall not finally defeat AIDS, tuberculosis,malaria, or any of <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r infectiousdiseases that plague <strong>the</strong> developingworld until we have also won <strong>the</strong> battle forsafe drinking-water, sanitation and basichealth care,” he said.For 1.1 billion people lacking access tosafe drinking water and <strong>the</strong> 2.6 billionlacking safe sanitation – toilets – <strong>the</strong> perspectiveis completely different. For <strong>the</strong>m,lack of access to what some call a basic humanright impedes <strong>the</strong>ir ability to come outof poverty and live healthy and productivelives.“I do wish that I get married in a familywhich has <strong>the</strong> facility of toilet and separatewater tap,” said Barkha, age 12, of <strong>the</strong>Sanjay Amar Colony, Delhi, India. “It is adream for me.”A Watershed YearIn many ways, 2006 was a watershed yearfor water, pardon <strong>the</strong> pun. The United Nationssystem increased its focus on waterrelatedissues through publication of twomajor reports, <strong>the</strong> World Water DevelopmentReport and <strong>the</strong> Human DevelopmentReport.Diverse organisations such as <strong>the</strong> WorldWildlife Fund and <strong>the</strong> World BusinessCouncil for Sustainable Development followedsuit with reports which didn’t alwayspaint rosy pictures for both developing anddeveloped countries.The Comprehensive Assessment ofWater Management in Agriculture (CA)released a landmark assessment of 50years of water management practices in orderto find ways to end hunger and protect<strong>the</strong> environment over <strong>the</strong> next 50 years.And, attendance has soared at “expert”meetings like <strong>the</strong> annual World WaterWeek in Stockholm, <strong>the</strong> tri-annual WorldWater Forum, and countless specialisedmeetings in all sectors having to do withwater in one way or <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r.Clearly, something is going on with water.Why? Let’s take a step back to look atsome fundamental facts about water onPlanet Earth in <strong>the</strong> year 2007.The World Water SituationWater is <strong>the</strong> integral fabric in <strong>the</strong> quilt oflife. The Earth’s ecosystems, societies andindividuals need it. Without it, food securityand human health, energy supplies andindustrial production would be unobtainable.Plants and wildlife and <strong>the</strong>ir ecosystemsneed water. Shortages and poor managementcan lead to loss of biodiversity andagricultural production, increase in malnutritionand disease, reduced economic growth,social instability and conflict. Water helpsregulate <strong>the</strong> global climate – and as we arecontinuing to see, water resources <strong>the</strong>mselvesare affected by global climatechange. Losses (human and financial) fromgreat natural catastrophes (flooding, hurricanes)were seven times as high in <strong>the</strong> tenyears from 1996 to 2005 than in <strong>the</strong> 1960s.Water is, for better or for worse, <strong>the</strong> linkbetween climate and human society.Clearly, reliable and clean water supplyis fundamental for agricultural productivity.Partly or fully irrigated agriculture claims70% of <strong>the</strong> world’s developed water supplies.Industrial agriculture, however, isconstantly under pressure to produce morefood with less water, due to water demandsfor increased domestic and industrial needs,and for servicing essential ecosystems.SIWI, <strong>the</strong> Stockholm InternationalWater Institute, says that “water is<strong>the</strong> key to socio-economic developmentand quality of life.” To SIWI,problems of poverty, hunger, disease,illiteracy, environmental degradationand gender inequality can in largemeasure be solved with water andsanitation as <strong>the</strong> key entry points.Unfortunately, while <strong>the</strong> above-mentionedreports said <strong>the</strong> “water crisis” is acrisis of “governance” (management) andnot true water scarcity, it is only partiallytrue. There is physical water scarcity, sincewater resources are not uniform in <strong>the</strong>irglobal distribution. In many of <strong>the</strong> world’sfastest growing areas, particularly in <strong>the</strong>developing world, water is indeed physicallyscarce or will soon become so.Fur<strong>the</strong>r, water demand is outpacingsupply in many countries, and <strong>the</strong> qualityof that supply is rapidly declining. Fourhundred and fifty million people in 31countries already face serious shortages ofwater. By 2025, <strong>the</strong> UN projects that onethirdof <strong>the</strong> world’s population is expectedto face severe and chronic water shortages.This is partly due to physical scarcity, butalso due to economic or managementscarcity – lack of infrastructure, lack ofproper management and lack of planning.Though it is a blue planet, water is alimited and finite resource. Really, lessthan 2.5% of <strong>the</strong> water can be used andreused as freshwater. Less than half of thatis readily – or with some effort – accessible.Unfortunately, <strong>the</strong> water which is accessibleis often being contaminated beyonduse – a “water hydrocide” in <strong>the</strong> eyesof some – making it unavailable for fur<strong>the</strong>r1/07 COURIER 19


human use and threatening <strong>the</strong> health ofpeople, not to mention lakes, rivers, andwetland ecosystems <strong>the</strong>y support. Coastaland ocean systems are also under threatfrom <strong>the</strong> impact of a broad range of humanactivities.Water for FoodDrip irrigation is a water-saving irrigation method that applies water slowly to <strong>the</strong> roots of plants.A rainwater harvesting system in India thatachieves “supply from <strong>the</strong> sky”.A challenge of modern agriculture: makingwater use more efficient.So, per person, <strong>the</strong> amount of water to beavailable will continue to diminish while<strong>the</strong> food needs will continue to increase –and food consumption is moving towardsmore water-intensive items. Daily humanneeds for water are around 50 to 100 litres.Unless you count food. Then it is 3,500 litres.A Big Mac itself is, essentially, 1,000 litresof water.In addition, irrigation possibilities whichfuelled <strong>the</strong> initial “Green Revolution” in<strong>the</strong> 1960s are limited, and agricultural landis shrinking. Much of <strong>the</strong> latter may, infact, be converted to producing crops ultimatelyintended for use in biofuel gastanks, not human mouths. Unless steps aretaken to improve <strong>the</strong> way water is managed,twice <strong>the</strong> world’s current water consumptionmay be needed by 2050 to feed aglobal population of some 9 billion.The demand for food will increase with50% every generation. How big <strong>the</strong> increaseultimately will be depends in largepart on <strong>the</strong> purchasing power of consumersand on <strong>the</strong> number of people that will inevitablyinhabit this planet. According toprognoses of <strong>the</strong> Food and Agricultural Organisationof <strong>the</strong> United Nations, averagedemand will be 3,000 kcal per person perday. Even considering wastage, if a highcalorie intake becomes <strong>the</strong> social norm forall of humanity – particularly in fast-growingplaces like India and China – <strong>the</strong> increasedpressure on natural resources –above all, water, will be dramatic. An additionalvolume of water equal in size to allof <strong>the</strong> water used in households, industryand agriculture today (5,600 km 3 ) wouldbe required by 2050.This is because production of food is ahighly water-consuming activity. It takes550 litres of water to produce enough flourfor one loaf of bread – a fraction of <strong>the</strong>roughly 1,500 litres used to produce 100grams of grain-fed beef. Already in large20 COURIER 1/07


Doubling WATER needs in agriculture by 2050Km 3 /year15,000Today 2050The challenge12,40010,0006,8005,0001,8003,3001,5008001,800improved efficiencyin rain-fed ag, expansionirrigation efficiencyirrigatedAdditionalneed of Water(+5,600 km 3 )5,0005,000rain-fed0Source: SIWI: Stockholm International Water InstituteBlue Water = irrigated agricultureGreen Water = rain-fed agricultureGreen and blue water flowPRECIPITATION– THE BASIC WATERRESOURCERAINSOIL MOISTUREGROUNDWATERWATER DIVI DECITYSource: SIWI: Stockholm International Water InstituteTERRESTRIALECOSYSTEMSINDUSTRYGREENWATERFLOWRAINFED CROPSIRRIGATIONRETURNFLOWSAQUATICECOSYSTEMSFISHERIESBLUEWATER FLOWdoubling of production in large parts ofAfrica. Also, better use of <strong>the</strong> rainwater in<strong>the</strong> soil – so-called “green water” can helpfuel <strong>the</strong> agricultural revolution needed toend hunger.One place where this is happening is inIndia. Ms. Sunita Narain, whose Centre forScience and Environment won <strong>the</strong> 2005Stockholm Water Prize, has promoted rainwaterharvesting, often using traditional“kundi” catchment systems. Such smallscale,local systems, has been and will continueto be critical to helping 300 millionpoor people to feed <strong>the</strong>mselves and improve<strong>the</strong>ir lives. “The supply is in <strong>the</strong> sky,”says Ms. Narain.Double Sided Dilemmaparts of <strong>the</strong> world, water is <strong>the</strong> most limitedand most uncertain resource, both infood production and for different ecosystems.A fundamental consequence forcrops grown in <strong>the</strong> open landscape is thatlarge quantities of water evaporate back to<strong>the</strong> atmosphere from vegetation and soil,particularly in hot climate regions.Reduced RiversAlthough <strong>the</strong> world produces more foodthan ever, it has come at a cost: <strong>the</strong> drasticreduction of water in a number of riversand sinking groundwater levels around <strong>the</strong>world. There is no water flowing in <strong>the</strong> Yellow,Colorado and Indus rivers in largeparts of <strong>the</strong> year. Previously large lakes,like <strong>the</strong> Aral Sea and <strong>the</strong> Lake Chad, arenow mere shadows of <strong>the</strong>ir former selvesalthough climate also plays its role here.O<strong>the</strong>r uncertainties exist: some predict that<strong>the</strong> 40 poorest countries, with a total populationof some 1-3 billion, will lose on averageup to a fifth of <strong>the</strong>ir cereal productionpotential in <strong>the</strong> 2080s because of climatechange.These factors, combined with <strong>the</strong> growingneeds of cities and industries for water,will minimise <strong>the</strong> food gains resultingfrom increased or more effective use of irrigatedwater in agriculture. The mostpromising solutions identified come fromrain-fed agriculture. Using rain more efficiently,“rainwater harvesting,” is a timetestedpractice in some parts of <strong>the</strong> worldthat improved land management needsstrong support to come into wider use. Amore effective use of precipitation in combinationwith land care has already led to aThe nature of <strong>the</strong> problem, unfortunately,is double-sided. In some parts of <strong>the</strong> world,supermarkets are overflowing with producefrom all over <strong>the</strong> world. Literally, <strong>the</strong>shortage of food is a distant problem in thiscontext. Yet, interestingly enough, <strong>the</strong> overconsumptionof <strong>the</strong> developed world leadsto <strong>the</strong> same problem as <strong>the</strong> under- and malnourishmentin <strong>the</strong> developing world: <strong>the</strong>yreduce <strong>the</strong> chances of “productive andhealthy lives”.Deservedly, <strong>the</strong> attention to <strong>the</strong> causesand consequences of obesity and hungerhas been growing toge<strong>the</strong>r with <strong>the</strong> will of<strong>the</strong> international community to tackle <strong>the</strong>problem. But behind <strong>the</strong> question of sufficientand healthy food lies ano<strong>the</strong>r reality:<strong>the</strong> way it is produced, distributed and consumedundermines a cornerstone of sustainabledevelopment.1/07 COURIER 21


Green water accounts for 80% of crop use,irrigated water 20%, with big regional variationsAreas in green:agriculture mainlyunder rain-fedAreas in blue:agriculture mainlyunder irrigationCircles depict totalcrop depletion (IET)Status: August 2006Source: SIWI; StockholmInternational Water InstituteThe Critical ConsumerThe old and fundamental questionabout how to produce more and betterfood without fur<strong>the</strong>r undermining ourenvironment still lingers. But a newcrucial question begs for an answer;how can food demand and intake beequitable, sound and within <strong>the</strong>earth’s biological production potential.Though farmers, governments andtechnicians can puzzle on technical solutionsforever, it is <strong>the</strong> consumer who facesfundamental choices: for good and healthyfoods and for food that is produced in asustainable manner. Factual information on<strong>the</strong> way food is produced and what societaland environmental costs it brings can helpraise consumer awareness. Choices in <strong>the</strong>supermarket each day are not only choicesfor a healthy or unhealthy lifestyle, butalso have profound impacts on <strong>the</strong> lives ofpoor communities and on <strong>the</strong>ir environmentfar away.Not All Gloom and DoomDespite <strong>the</strong> above, <strong>the</strong>re should never<strong>the</strong>lessbe enough water – in 2025, 2050 andbeyond, for everyone, including water forfood. Research shows that better governanceand management of water, morecrop per drop, improved technologies and ahost of o<strong>the</strong>r tools, techniques and strategiescan make it happen.Moving back to Barkha, in search of hiswater tap and toilet, it has been shown that<strong>the</strong> returns on investment in water and sanitationare tremendous. Countries with itgrow faster. Think where ourWestern countries would be if wehadn’t invested in sanitation! In fact,<strong>the</strong> British Journal of Medicine inJanuary of this year called <strong>the</strong> improvementin sanitation as <strong>the</strong> greatesthuman accomplishment of <strong>the</strong> last 170years – ahead of <strong>the</strong> development of antibiotics,<strong>the</strong> invention of <strong>the</strong> computer and<strong>the</strong> discovery of <strong>the</strong> structure of DNA. Oras his Royal Highness Crown PrinceAlexander of <strong>the</strong> Ne<strong>the</strong>rlands said in hiskeynote presentation at <strong>the</strong> 2006 WorldWater Week in Stockholm, quoting WHAuden, “Thousands have lived withoutlove, not one without water.”Reducing by half <strong>the</strong> number of peoplewithout access to water and sanitation is atarget of <strong>the</strong> global development agendaknown as <strong>the</strong> UN Millennium DevelopmentGoals (MDG). Health is indeedwealth, as meeting <strong>the</strong> MDG target couldyield benefits of USD 3 to USD 34 for everdollar invested, or USD 65 billion annually.The benefits are tangible: health turns towealth, poor people move from poverty toproductivity, better lives for women areachieved, and increased educational possibilitiescreated literate young peoplewhose livelihood opportunities are improved.Industry is taking a more pro-active rolefor it knows that without water, businessesfail, and where it is, investment occurs.And when industry invests – as manymultinational corporations are doing increasinglyin developing countries – itlooks to secure water for its operations.Sometimes, securing a safe water supplyfor facilities also means securing it forthose living around <strong>the</strong>m – not least to secure<strong>the</strong> health of <strong>the</strong>ir employees.Technological advancements will continueto make water use more efficient,with closed industrial loops and more waterreuse. Desalinisation will continue tobecome a more viable option for drinkingwater, though it will always only be a marginalcomponent. As agriculture withdrawsaround 70% of global average fresh water,improved agricultural water managementmust, <strong>the</strong>refore, be a top priority. While <strong>the</strong>efficiency of irrigation water use merits<strong>the</strong> highest attention for action in agriculture,water collecting technologies in rainfedagriculture and improved land managementsystems should also help to maximize<strong>the</strong> “crop per drop”.22 COURIER 1/07


And clear signs of a water-deficit drivenimport of cereals – so called virtual waterflow – and intensifying water stress in <strong>the</strong>semi-arid <strong>tropical</strong> regions of <strong>the</strong> world maybring about a major switch in global foodtrade. Food production in water rich regionsmay come to play an increasing roleto alleviate hunger in water-short countries.The concept, which links food availabilityin water rich regions with <strong>the</strong> ameliorationof water deficits in water shortregions via trade, offers great possibilities.The water issue will be one which continuesto affect, in one way or <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r,everyone from <strong>the</strong> smallest farmer inKenya to <strong>the</strong> biggest European agribusinesses.■For fur<strong>the</strong>r information please visit <strong>the</strong>following websites:www.bayercropscience.com · www.siwi.orgwww.unep.org · www.worldwaterweek.orgwww.watergovernance.orgDave Trouba, StockholmInternational Water Institute,SwedenThe contribution of <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>to water use efficiency and protectionThe focus of <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’s research and development activities is cropprotection and enhanced seeds, which contribute to improved agricultural productivity.An integral element of this is seeking to contribute simultaneously to waterprotection and, where possible, water use efficiency improvements for farmers.Although much smaller in scale, efficient water use in our manufacturing sitesand o<strong>the</strong>r facilities will continue to be achieved through systematic “in house”reviews. Improved water management approaches and <strong>the</strong> growing co-operationthroughout <strong>the</strong> agricultural value-chain will also complement <strong>the</strong> many achievementsso far.<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> contributes to water use efficiency and protection by:• Developing stress tolerant and drought resistant crops;• Providing solutions for healthy plants as <strong>the</strong>se use water more efficiently;• Providing weed management tools to prevent competition with crops for water;• <strong>Protecting</strong> water through integrated Research & Development and productstewardship activities;• Promoting land management approaches which support improved watermanagement;• Enhancing water-saving schemes at our manufacturing and o<strong>the</strong>r sites.By <strong>the</strong>se and o<strong>the</strong>r means, <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> will continue to develop and implementpractical water use efficiency and protection solutions to ensure sustainedand enhanced agricultural production into <strong>the</strong> future.1/07 COURIER 23


<strong>the</strong>long-lasting solution againstbrown plant hoppersAfter its introduction to <strong>the</strong> Thai rice market in mid-2005, Curbix ®was soon accepted by Thai rice farmers as a new tool for controlling<strong>the</strong> outbreak of <strong>the</strong> “brown plant hopper” pest – <strong>the</strong> cause of“hopper burn”, and a vector for viral diseases. Farmers particularlyappreciate <strong>the</strong> consistent and long-lasting efficacy this new productprovides, even against pest populations that have become lesssensitive to more established chemistries.24 COURIER 1/07


Hopper control over<strong>the</strong> last 15 yearsIf you leave Bangkok by one of <strong>the</strong> roadsto <strong>the</strong> north, you soon find yourself drivingthrough endless rice fields, with <strong>the</strong>ir freshgreen colors. Here, you are at <strong>the</strong> center of<strong>the</strong> nation’s intensive rice farming. Along<strong>the</strong> Chao Phraya River, <strong>the</strong> area under ricepaddies stretches about 400 km from northto south and 150 km from west to east.Numerous dams collect water during<strong>the</strong> rainy season (May to October) and <strong>the</strong>nrelease it into <strong>the</strong> well-developed system ofrivers and canals for irrigation during <strong>the</strong>dry season (November to April). Without<strong>the</strong> constant availability of water, farmerswould be unable to grow rice so intensively– with an average frequency of 2.5 crops ayear (or 5 crop cycles every two years), andan average yield of approximately 6 t/hafrom each crop. A total harvest of 15 t/harice a year allows farmers to make a goodliving from rice, making <strong>the</strong>m comparativelywealthier than farmers growing o<strong>the</strong>rcrops.But <strong>the</strong> intensity of rice farming alsoleads to <strong>the</strong> development of a high insectpest pressure, which can significantly reduce<strong>the</strong> yield potential if left unchecked.Brown plant hopper isa serious concernThree major insect pests are of economicsignificance in intensive rice farming inThailand. Rice is often attacked by riceThe launch activities of Curbix received a very good farmer feedback.thrips (Stenchaetothrips biformis) from <strong>the</strong>seedling stage to approximately two weeksafter sowing. The larvae and adults lacerate<strong>the</strong> plant tissue, causing leaf discolorationand rolling.Rice leaf folders (Cnaphalocrocis medinalis)typically attack rice plants beyond30 days after sowing. The larvae removeplant tissue, folding <strong>the</strong> leaf and sealing<strong>the</strong> edges toge<strong>the</strong>r with silk strands. Theinsect <strong>the</strong>n feeds inside <strong>the</strong> folded leaf,causing white or transparent streaks on <strong>the</strong>leaf blade.Both <strong>the</strong> nymphs and adults of <strong>the</strong>brown plant hopper (Nilaparvata lugens)insert <strong>the</strong>ir sucking mouthparts into planttissue to remove plant sap from phloemcells. The removal of plant sap, combinedwith <strong>the</strong> blockage of phloem vessels by <strong>the</strong>insects’ feeding sheaths, cause <strong>the</strong> tillers todry out and turn brown. This condition iscalled “hopper burn”, and it can coverlarge patches in rice fields under heavypest pressure. The brown plant hopper canalso transmit <strong>the</strong> ragged stunt and grassystunt viruses.For <strong>the</strong>se reasons, <strong>the</strong> brown plant hopperis <strong>the</strong> pest problem foremost in <strong>the</strong> ricefarmer’s mind. In a survey run in 2004, arepresentative farmer group ranked <strong>the</strong>brown plant hopper as being by far <strong>the</strong>most severe rice pest in intensive ricefarming in Thailand.Until <strong>the</strong> 1990s, Thailand used to experiencea brown plant hopper outbreak onceevery five years on average. With <strong>the</strong> introductionof new, high-yielding rice varietiesthat are susceptible to brown planthopper, this pest soon started to become aproblem every year. O<strong>the</strong>r factors contributingto this trend included <strong>the</strong> increaseduse of fertilizer to support <strong>the</strong>higher-yielding varieties, and <strong>the</strong> overlappingof rice growth stages in crops grownall year round. In Thailand’s <strong>tropical</strong> climate,farmers can sow, grow and harvestrice at any time during <strong>the</strong> year. As a consequence,rice can be found at all growthstages simultaneously, i.e. from just sownto ready for harvest, at any time during <strong>the</strong>year. The now widespread use of machineharvesters has also shortened <strong>the</strong> time betweensuccessive rice-growing seasons, increasing<strong>the</strong> amount of overlap of differentrice growth stages even fur<strong>the</strong>r.At about <strong>the</strong> time this intensificationbegan, <strong>Bayer</strong> developed and introducedimidacloprid, which was first launched inThailand in 1991 as Admire ® EC 050, for<strong>the</strong> control of brown plant hopper in rice.The product was quickly accepted by Thairice farmers because of its strong systemicactivity and fast knock-down effect, aswell as for its long-lasting efficacy. Withina few years, Admire had become <strong>the</strong> standardcrop protection solution againstbrown plant hopper.During <strong>the</strong> early 2000s, new productswere launched into <strong>the</strong> brown plant hoppermarket – all of <strong>the</strong>m from <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoidfamily. By 2002, an estimated 80% ormore of all insecticide applications againstbrown plant hopper were being carried outwith neonicotinoid products.In 2003, <strong>the</strong> first observations were madeof reduced efficacy of Admire – and o<strong>the</strong>rproducts from <strong>the</strong> same chemical class –against brown plant hopper. After <strong>the</strong> initialreports, <strong>the</strong> phenomenon quickly spread,and in 2004, all of <strong>the</strong> intensive rice-growingareas reported reduced efficacy ofneonicotinoid products.CurbixAs soon as <strong>the</strong> first reports of reducedefficacy of neonicotinoid products arrived,<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> started to intensifylocal development activities in Thailand.Continuous monitoring of <strong>the</strong> activitylevels of neonicotinoids under field conditionsaccompanied <strong>the</strong>se development ef-1/07 COURIER 25


Brown plant hopper (Nilaparvata lugens)forts. Trials were carried out at regular intervals,at several locations, in order to assess<strong>the</strong> extent and speed of spread of <strong>the</strong>loss of efficacy. It soon became evidentthat <strong>the</strong> initial trend was going to intensify.It had to be expected that within a fewyears, neonicotinoid products would nolonger be effective against brown planthopper.At <strong>the</strong> time, only a few non-nicotinoidproducts were available for <strong>the</strong> control ofbrown plant hopper. None of <strong>the</strong>se alternativeswere as effective as <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoidswith respect to overall efficacy levels,and particularly, in terms of <strong>the</strong> durationof control provided.This opened up an opportunity for anew insecticide from a different chemicalclass than <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoids: Curbix. Thisproduct contains <strong>the</strong> active ingredientethiprole, from <strong>the</strong> chemical class of fiproles.Ethiprole’s chemical properties andmode of action are entirely different fromthose of <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoids.Curbix blocks <strong>the</strong> gamma-aminobutyricacid (GABA)-regulated chloride channelin <strong>the</strong> insects’ central nervous system(whereas <strong>the</strong> neonicotinoids bind at <strong>the</strong>post-synaptic nicotinic acetylcholine receptor).Thus it was to be expected thatCurbix would give good control of brownplant hopper even where neonicotinoidproducts were no longer effective. Extensivelocal trials confirmed this assumption(see figure): Curbix showed a very highlevel of efficacy against both adults andnymphs of brown plant hopper. The outstandingfeature of this product, however,is its remarkably long-lasting efficacy.When applied at <strong>the</strong> right time (during <strong>the</strong>early phase of infestation), Curbix can providecontrol for as long as three weeks.Understanding<strong>the</strong> farmer’s needsEven though <strong>the</strong> conditions already appearedfavourable for a market launch ofCurbix in Thailand, some critical factorshad to be considered in order to succeed, asin any launch of a new product.First of all, it is necessary to understandcurrent market conditions, especially <strong>the</strong>dynamics of change in <strong>the</strong> market. Althougha lot was known already, pre-launchmarket research consolidated <strong>the</strong> understandingof <strong>the</strong> current market. Brownplant hopper was <strong>the</strong> number one rice pestfor almost 100% of <strong>the</strong> farmers interviewedin <strong>the</strong> pre-launch market survey.Fur<strong>the</strong>rmore, about 75% believed thatbrown plant hopper would actually gain inseverity as a rice pest over <strong>the</strong> course of <strong>the</strong>coming years. It was thus confirmed thatrice farmers clearly recognized <strong>the</strong> need fora new, high-quality hopper-control product.In this context, Curbix promised to bean excellent solution to farmers’ needs,with its high level of efficacy, and especiallythrough <strong>the</strong> long-lasting control itprovides. However, fur<strong>the</strong>r investigation ofexisting farming practice revealed that itwould be necessary to educate farmers in<strong>the</strong> correct use of <strong>the</strong> product. For example,with regard to <strong>the</strong> timing of application:farmers were used to applying insecticidesat a late stage of infestation. Butwith Curbix, <strong>the</strong>y needed to apply at anearly stage of <strong>the</strong> infestation in order to realise<strong>the</strong> product’s potential for long-lastingcontrol.The brand communication for Curbixcentered on two main messages. The firstwas <strong>the</strong> fact that Curbix presented <strong>the</strong>farmer with a new mode of action for <strong>the</strong>control of brown plant hopper; <strong>the</strong> secondwas that <strong>the</strong> product could provide longlastingefficacy. Here, care was taken toemphasize <strong>the</strong> importance of timing <strong>the</strong>application correctly.Farmer feedbackOne of <strong>the</strong> most important steps during <strong>the</strong>launch period was <strong>the</strong> measurement offarmer perception of <strong>the</strong> new product after<strong>the</strong> first season of use. Representative mar-A farmer shows riceplants assaulted by atroop of brown planthoppers.Hopper burn on rice breaks out.26 COURIER 1/07


ket research done among rice farmers whohad used Curbix showed a high degree ofsatisfaction with <strong>the</strong> product. Almost100% responded with scores of 1 or 2 on ascale of 1 (very good) to 5 (unsatisfied).The market research also revealed thatfarmers’ experience of Curbix’s efficacyexactly matched estimates of its potentialmade prior to launch. The great majoritygave positive feedback on both <strong>the</strong> level ofcontrol, and <strong>the</strong> duration of efficacy.However, an analysis of <strong>the</strong> usage behaviorof farmers made it clear that despiteall communication to <strong>the</strong> contrary, about40% of <strong>the</strong> farmers preferred to use <strong>the</strong>product at <strong>the</strong> peak of infestation, ra<strong>the</strong>rthan at its onset. This information indicated<strong>the</strong> need to reinforce <strong>the</strong> application timingrecommendations in future promotionalcampaigns.Conclusion and outlookCurbix was launched in Thailand in mid-2005. It received very good farmer feedbackand continues to enjoy increasingbrand awareness. With its consistently highlevel of efficacy and good longevity ofprotection, Curbix is an valuable tool for<strong>the</strong> control of brown plant hopper in <strong>the</strong> intensiverice-growing regions of Thailand.Fur<strong>the</strong>rmore, Curbix is a good exampleof <strong>the</strong> innovative strength of <strong>Bayer</strong> Crop-Science; it also illustrates <strong>the</strong> consistentneed for continuous research and developmentin <strong>the</strong> field of agrochemicals. ■Rice in ThailandThailand is <strong>the</strong>world’s largestexporter of rice.Today, rice is <strong>the</strong> major agricultural crop grown in Thailand. The rice-growing areacovers a total of ca. 10 Mio. ha, of which about 2.5 Mio. ha are located in centralThailand along <strong>the</strong> Chao Phraya river. This region is often referred to as <strong>the</strong> “ricebowl of Asia” for its intensive cultivation of pre-germinated, direct-seeded rice.The complex irrigation system developed for wet-rice agriculture has provided <strong>the</strong>means to generate wealth enough to sustain <strong>the</strong> development of <strong>the</strong> Thai statethroughout its history, from <strong>the</strong> 13th century Sukhothai kingdom, right up tomodern times.Farmers grow an average of 5 crops every two years. They can achieve yields ofca. 6 t/ha per crop, with a total of ca. 15 t/year.Rice farmers in central Thailand can achieve a turnover of approximately 33,000Baht (660 EUR) per ha and crop. With an average farm size of 3 ha, this leads toan average turnover of ca. 250,000 Baht, or 5,000 EUR per year.Beyond central Thailand, <strong>the</strong> majority of rice is grown in <strong>the</strong> North-Eastern provinces.However, <strong>the</strong> lack of an irrigation system <strong>the</strong>re means that farmers can onlygrow one crop per year. The crop is dependent on natural rainfall; overall inputsare low, but so are yield levels.In total, Thailand produces about 20 Mio. tonnes of rice every year. The kingdom is<strong>the</strong> world’s largest exporter of rice, with an annual export volume of between 5and 7 Mio. tonnes.Trial result using Curbix (ethiprole) for BPH control in Thailand (June 2004, Nakhonnayok)% control10080604020Hopper burn on rice, close up.03 DAA 7 DAA 11 DAA 15 DAADAA = Days after applicationImidacloprid Rate 1 Imidacloprid Rate 2 Competitor CNI 1 Competitor CNI 2 Curbix1/07 COURIER 27


28 COURIER 1/07


Diverse Herbicides forDiverse Rice CulturesOver <strong>the</strong> millenia, different techniques for cultivating rice haveevolved around <strong>the</strong> globe. When it comes to weed control, <strong>the</strong>sevarious agronomic methods require customized solutions. <strong>Bayer</strong><strong>CropScience</strong>’s broad product range of rice herbicides meets <strong>the</strong>challenge presented by <strong>the</strong> diversity of farming techniques andfarmer preferences in different regions.Echinochloa crus-galli – wherever <strong>the</strong>y grow, <strong>the</strong> rice plants can’t get enough nutrients and just wilt away.Cyperus is a typical example of wide spread weeds that <strong>the</strong> highly effective herbicides from <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>combat before <strong>the</strong>y can reduce crop yields.Most herbicide markets are dominatedby a few top-selling products. This is not<strong>the</strong> case for rice. Although it is <strong>the</strong> world’sthird most important cereal, and <strong>the</strong> mainstaple food for half of <strong>the</strong> world’s population,rice is produced in a diversity of culturaland natural environments. First of all,<strong>the</strong> rice-producing regions have differentfarming systems, with ei<strong>the</strong>r rain-fed or irrigatedfields being <strong>the</strong> major distinguishingfeature. Secondly, we find a multitudeof different rice varieties being cultivated,accompanied by region-specific weed floras.Finally, local cultural traditions and attitudesresult in diverse weeding practices.The universal herbicide – able to meet allof <strong>the</strong>se different needs – has yet to be developed!All over <strong>the</strong> world, however, rice farmersare able to find effective herbicides from<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’s portfolio to suit <strong>the</strong>irparticular situation. The company offers 15different active ingredients marketed undera range of brand names, and in various formulations.The herbicides differ in <strong>the</strong>irmode of action, <strong>the</strong> spectrum of weeds <strong>the</strong>ycontrol, <strong>the</strong>ir time of application, and <strong>the</strong>irsuitability for different rice managementsystems. The versatility of <strong>Bayer</strong> Crop-Science’s portfolio also means that toolsare available for combating herbicide resistancein rice weeds. An exciting new substancethat promises to tackle herbicide resistancehead-on is currently under developmentin our laboratories.According to FAO statistics, 618 millionmetric tons of rice were harvested frommore than 150 million hectares of land worldwidein 2005. In terms of global cerealproduction, rice is topped only by corn andwheat. Considered in terms of <strong>the</strong> globalherbicide market, <strong>the</strong> white grain has a peculiarity:“In rice we face a highly fragmentedmarket”, reports Juergen Echle,Product Manager for Rice Herbicides at<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>. “There is no realblockbuster; a multitude of products combineto give total global herbicide sales ofnearly 1.3 billion US Dollars”, Echle adds.Herbicide market mirrorscultural diversity<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong> is <strong>the</strong> leading companyin this market. Products such as Ricestar ® ,TillerGold ® , Nominee ® , Zark ® , Innova ® andRonstar ® make up our successful range ofrice herbicides. But none of <strong>the</strong> products inour portfolio is sold in all rice-growingcountries.“The heterogeneous herbicide marketmirrors <strong>the</strong> diversity of cultivation tech-1/07 COURIER 29


niques in <strong>the</strong> countries, or even within ‘ricecultures’”, <strong>the</strong> Product Manager explains.Juergen Echle had <strong>the</strong> opportunity to experience<strong>the</strong> rice culture in Japan first-handwhilst working <strong>the</strong>re for <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>for two years. “The Japanese grower lovesa lush, green field and is willing to spend alot of money on technology”, Echle says.In Japan, all rice is grown in paddies; <strong>the</strong>rice is transplanted with machines, eventhough <strong>the</strong> fields are small. The temperateclimate allows only one rice harvest per year.Over <strong>the</strong> past decades, protectionist policieshave shielded <strong>the</strong> home market fromglobal pressure on prices. So Japan – withroughly 1.7 million hectares of planted rice– has developed into <strong>the</strong> most attractiveherbicide market for <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>.The situation elsewhere is totally different.For example in India, where 42 millionhectares of land are planted with rice –more than in any o<strong>the</strong>r country – transplantedrice dominates, and in <strong>the</strong> fields,most operations are done through manuallabor. “We estimate that only about ten percentof <strong>the</strong> Indian rice area is chemicallytreated”, says Juergen Echle. Farmers ino<strong>the</strong>r rice-growing regions of <strong>the</strong> world, forexample Latin America, are confrontedwith severe water shortages, so <strong>the</strong>y haveadapted <strong>the</strong>ir cultivation systems to <strong>the</strong>local conditions.Transplanted anddirect-seeded riceWhen categorizing <strong>the</strong> diversity of ricecultivation techniques, experts distinguishbetween transplanted and seeded rice, andirrigated and rain-fed fields. For transplantedrice, seedlings are first grown in anursery, ei<strong>the</strong>r on a field, or in a greenhouse.The seedlings are generally transplantedto <strong>the</strong> leveled and puddled fieldbetween 15 and 30 days after sowing –ei<strong>the</strong>r by hand, or with a transplantingmachine. Transplanted rice yields <strong>the</strong> largestharvest, but it also requires more water – asfields are irrigated most of <strong>the</strong> time – aswell as o<strong>the</strong>r inputs. Transplanting is commonpractice in Japan, Korea and India,whereas in South-East Asia, North and LatinAmerica, Sou<strong>the</strong>rn Europe, most of China,and <strong>the</strong> Middle East, rice grains are sowndirectly, into ei<strong>the</strong>r wet or dry soil.Above all, it is <strong>the</strong> timing of rice establishmentin <strong>the</strong> fields that determines weedcontrol strategies. Rice transplanted into<strong>the</strong> field has a growth lead over competingweeds; it is more robust and thus easilydistinguishable from <strong>the</strong> smaller wildplants. In this cultivation system, herbicidessuch as Innova and Zark ® are typicallyapplied at one shot, shortly aftertransplanting, ei<strong>the</strong>r before or after <strong>the</strong>weeds have emerged. Residual herbicides(e.g. Ronstar) are used to control weedsbefore <strong>the</strong>y emerge, so <strong>the</strong>y are applied to<strong>the</strong> field before <strong>the</strong> rice is seeded or transplanted.Foliar herbicides act selectivelyand serve as “rescue” applications at laterrice growth stages.Generally speaking, <strong>the</strong> more water isavailable for irrigation, <strong>the</strong> less <strong>the</strong> needfor chemical herbicides to control weeds.“Water itself acts as herbicide – this is actuallyone of <strong>the</strong> reasons why rice is grownin paddies”, explains Juergen Echle. Over<strong>the</strong> millennia, <strong>the</strong> rice plant has developeda tolerance for water.But water management is not <strong>the</strong> onlyfactor affecting <strong>the</strong> choice of herbicidestrategy and product. Farmers must alsotake <strong>the</strong>ir rice variety and weed flora intoaccount. According to <strong>the</strong> InternationalRice Research Institute, at least 120,000different rice cultivars are known to exist.Most of <strong>the</strong>m belong to <strong>the</strong> species Oryzasativa, with <strong>the</strong> two major varieties beingjaponica and indica. “Japonica rice cultivatedin North-East Asia, China and o<strong>the</strong>rtemperate climates is much more sensitiveto herbicides than indica”, says Dr. BernhardSchreiber, Head of Portfolio-ManagementRice Herbicides at <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>.Weed competition and controlMany weeds compete with rice in <strong>the</strong> field.The strongest competitors belong to <strong>the</strong>same botanical family as Oryza. “Wild redrice and Echinochloa species pose <strong>the</strong>greatest economic threat to <strong>the</strong> ricefarmer”, says Juergen Echle, “because of<strong>the</strong>ir abundance, and <strong>the</strong> difficulty in controlling<strong>the</strong>m.”Grasses are not <strong>the</strong> only weeds that interferewith rice cultivation. “Take Japan,<strong>the</strong>re perennial sedges are particularlyfierce competitors. You will find sedges inLatin America too, but also a considerablenumber of broadleaved annual weeds”,points out Bernhard Schreiber. Because<strong>the</strong>y differ physiologically, sedges andbroadleaves are best controlled with differentactive ingredients. Most rice farmerswork with tank mixes containing up tothree components.<strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’s particular strengthlies in controlling grassy weeds: ten of our■ Rice producing countries30 COURIER 1/07


A real innovation for Japanese farmers: applicationwith a granule-applicator at transplanting allowsproducts to be applied more uniformly than <strong>the</strong>conventional application method.15 rice herbicides work excellentlyagainst grasses.O<strong>the</strong>r products, such asTiller ® Gold, Nominee and Ronstar,act as all-rounders, controlling<strong>the</strong> major weeds in <strong>the</strong> fields. Tiller Gold,for example, bundles fenoxaprop-P-ethyl’sstrength in controlling grasses with <strong>the</strong>power of ethoxysulfuron against sedgesand broadleaved weeds; a safener is alsoincluded, to shield <strong>the</strong> rice plant from <strong>the</strong>effects of <strong>the</strong> herbicide.When combining active substances in asingle product, <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’s researchershave to find <strong>the</strong> right formulation,one that shows optimum activityagainst weeds. Typically, mixtures are formulatedas liquids, e.g. as a suspension oran emulsifiable concentrate. However, regionalpreferences also shape formulationand application methods: “In Japan, wecould never succeed with suspension concentrates,although for technological reasonsand handiness we would prefer<strong>the</strong>m”, says product manager Echle. “Butrice farmers <strong>the</strong>re continue to demandbulky granule herbicides, just as <strong>the</strong>y haveknown <strong>the</strong>m for decades”, he adds.Trends and innovationsIn 2001, whilst working in Japan, JuergenEchle witnessed a real innovation for farmers:<strong>the</strong> launch of <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>’s Innovagranules. Innova, based on <strong>the</strong> activesubstance fentrazamide, can be appliedright at <strong>the</strong> time of transplanting. Transplantingmeans stress for rice seedlings, soherbicides are usually spread onto <strong>the</strong>fields a few days later. “An applicationzero days after transplanting eases farmers’workload”, says Echle and shows picturesof a granule-applicator fixed to atransplanting machine.However, this type of equipment cannotbe transferred to countries less technologicallydeveloped than Japan, says JuergenEchle: “This machinery needs to be investedin by <strong>the</strong> individual farmer.” In South-East Asia and some Latin American countries,applying rice herbicides with simpleback-sprayers is <strong>the</strong> most common technique.In o<strong>the</strong>r parts of <strong>the</strong> world, especiallyin <strong>the</strong> Americas, aero planes spray tankmixtures onto <strong>the</strong> fields.Though tightly connected with regionalcultural backgrounds, rice cultivation systemsare also subject to change. “In thissegment, nothing is carved in stone”, observesproduct manager Echle. “Herbicidestrategies undergo constant change.” Forinstance, considered at global level, <strong>the</strong>trend is moving towards direct-seeded rice,because it consumes less water. In contrast,Thailand, <strong>the</strong> world’s biggest exporter ofrice, is currently moving in <strong>the</strong> opposite direction:transplanting is on <strong>the</strong> rise. “Theexport orientation certainly drives this development;and so does <strong>the</strong> spread of redrice, which is easier to control in transplantedrice”, explains Juergen Echle.Changing rice management strategies alsorequire novel and adaptive solutions from<strong>the</strong> herbicide supplier. Scientists at <strong>Bayer</strong><strong>CropScience</strong> are currently busy developinga new substance. “Many hopes are pinnedon this active ingredient because it possessesa new mode of action”, Dr.Schreiber explains. The substance is intendedto replace sulfonylurea-based herbicides,against which weeds are reportedto have developed resistance, after decadesof application at high product rates. Thenew product is scheduled for launch in2010.“The rice herbicide market needs heterogeneity”,Jürgen Echle concludes. Regionalpreferences, natural environments, <strong>the</strong> requirementsof rice cultivation, and economicconditions – all of <strong>the</strong>se influence <strong>the</strong>approach to weed control. And within thishighly dynamic market, <strong>Bayer</strong> <strong>CropScience</strong>is driving at constant innovation. ■1/07 COURIER 31


Nature and technologyWhen a ladybird is sitting on a leaf, itsmembranous wings remain hidden under<strong>the</strong> red elytra (wing-covers). The wings areonly really seen when <strong>the</strong> ladybird takes offin flight. On landing again, <strong>the</strong> beetle neatlyfolds <strong>the</strong>m toge<strong>the</strong>r and tucks <strong>the</strong>m under<strong>the</strong> elytra, which are actually smaller than<strong>the</strong> wings.Technology is also able to provide similarlyingenious folding techniques. The solar panelsof satellites and space stations unfold as soonas <strong>the</strong> spacecraft reach <strong>the</strong>ir orbit. They are<strong>the</strong>n ready to orient <strong>the</strong>mselves towards <strong>the</strong>sun’s rays, in order to provide <strong>the</strong> satellitesand space stations with energy. ■www.bayercropscience.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!