MILITARY PHARMACY AND MEDICINE

MILITARY PHARMACY AND MEDICINE MILITARY PHARMACY AND MEDICINE

wbc.poznan.pl
from wbc.poznan.pl More from this publisher
11.07.2015 Views

© Military Pharmacy and Medicine • 2012 • 4 • 116 – 118Skulls containing trepanation holes constitute asubject of scientific studies since 19th century.Literature cites, that the most frequent bodilyinjuries are head traumas, which involve 60% ofgeneral population [24]. In the prehistorical andmedieval periods head traumas were probablyalso very common, which was likely related tobattles, fights and hunting.Often, due to poor skull condition, it is difficultto establish the indications for trepanation,particularly when the skull does not containany external signs of trauma. Also, illnessdoes not always leave marks on the skeleton.However, most trepanation procedures wereprobably performed for therapeutic reasons,in order to remove the fractured bone. Suchprocedures were often performed intuitively.Leverage and removal of fractured bone fragmentor fragments, as well as polishing of sharpwound edges could bring immediate effectssuch as regression of neurological disorders orreturn of consciousness, as fragments of thedamaged bone ceased to exert pressure againstbrain tissue.Therefore, procedures were repeated in subsequentcases. First of all, treatment was aimed atremoving the source of pain, which could havebeen caused by various pathological changes.Medieval skulls bear the signs of trauma particularlyoften. Such procedure was not easyto perform. It must have been done by a medicexperienced in this field and equipped withappropriate tools. Indications for skull trepanationalso included: pericerebral hematomas,inflammatory lesions or brain tumors.Several skulls described in Polish anthropologicaland archeological literature as trepanned,are not such. Holes present on those skullscould have been made during excavations (skulldamage by a probe), as a result of processes takingplace in the soil, traumatic injuries, gunshotwounds or post mortem examinations (ifthe hole involves the entire or almost entireskull cap). Therefore, not all skull aperturesshould be considered purposeful therapeuticprocedures. Particularly, very small openings,2-3 mm in diameter [25], or very large onesinvolving several skull bones indicate that theyhave not been made during an intentional surgicalprocedure.Review articleAnother interesting issue concerns the problemof patient survival following trepanation. Manypublications indicate that the fraction of successfulprocedures was high. Data on trepanationskulls from South America point to osteal reactions(signs of obliteration) in 55% to 70% of trepannedskulls [26]. In cases of trepanation fromthe area of Poland, Czech Republic and Slovakia,professor Adam Paluch states that the successrate amounted to about 81.7% [27].Authors of publications on trepanations fromthe neolithic times performed in Denmark andGermany report 80% (Denmark) and 88% (Germany)survival following trepanation [28]. Possibly,such high survival rates were related topatient care following the procedure, wounddressing and use of newly made flint and stonetools, which constituted sterile medical instruments.The reasons for this include strong immunologicalsystems of individuals subjected to theprocedure (weaker individuals died in childhood).Survival after surgery also depended onpatient’s general condition, extent of injury ordisorder constituting an indication for trepanation.Smaller openings certainly posed a smallerrisk of wound infection. It is also possible thathigh survival rates following these proceduresare associated with the fact that most of historicaltrepanations were epidural. Complicationsof this procedure included wound infection, butalso intraoperative bleeding and meningeal orbrain injury. They resulted from unskillful tooluse and poor surgical technique. In the 19th andat the beginning of the 20th century trepanationswere carried out in hospitals, which were characterizedby poor hygienic and sanitary conditions.Therefore, mortality among patients undergoingthis procedure was high.One could also ask, who performed such proceduresin the prehistorical and historical times?In large societies, knowledge of medicine andsurgical procedures was passed from one generationto another. Experiences gained in performingsuch kinds of surgeries allowed foravoiding brain and meningeal injuries or infections.During the Iron Age (La Tene period)trepanations were most likely performed by“warrior surgeons,” as evidenced by their funeraryitems, which included medical tools, besidearmament. They were probably able to performother minor surgical procedures. In the La Tene116 http://military.isl-journals.com

© Military Pharmacy and Medicine • 2012 • 4 • 117 – 118Magdalena Cybulska at al.: Anthropological and archeological sources …period, the wounded and sick warriors werealso cared for by their companions. Based onarcheological findings, we may conclude thata “warrior-surgeon” was equipped with medicalinstruments, including the following tools:bone knives, exploration probes and hooks. Inancient civilizations, with development of theart of war and formation of armies, comes thegradual progress in the areas of medicine relatedto military actions and frequent injuries, particularlysurgery. Surgical skills and treatment ofinjuries and wounds were especially importantin carrying for wounded warriors. During theRoman period, trepanations were performed bymilitary doctors (specially trained) that accompaniedthe legions.Military surgery went through many stages ofdevelopment. In the Roman army, a qualifiedmilitary doctor replaced a warrior-surgeon ofthe La Tene period. When it comes to the RomanEmpire, we are able to identify the doctor or amedic based on archeological studies and funeraryequipment. However, in the Barbarian regionidentification is very difficult. Three burial sitesfrom the Iron Age were identified in Poland,which contained tools described by the archeologistsas medicine-related. Two graves belongedto warriors and one is thought to be a burial sitebelonging to a midwife [29, 30]. There was probablyalso folk knowledge regarding trepanationsand other surgical procedures. People involvedin the surgical craft benefited from this knowledge.In the Middle Ages, as a result of separatingsurgery from medicine, surgical occupationcould be undertaken by people without medicaleducation, who only possessed some practicalskills. However, it is emphasized that barbersperformed mainly minor surgical procedures,healed wounds, reduced dislocations and fracturesor opened abscesses. They could also learnabout medicine from the clergy, as their work alsoincluded shaving tonsures. In the Middle Ages,demand for surgeons was high. They workedin the cities and princes’ courts. Ethnographicsources inform us that some occupations werealso predestined to performing therapeutic oreven surgical procedures, including: blacksmiths,shepherds, carpenters and beekeepers [31].People who cared for animals could use theirmedical knowledge to perform certain procedureson men. The tools used by the mentionedhttp://military.isl-journals.comcraftsmen for their everyday work could also beuseful for various medical procedures. In case ofa blacksmith, the transformation of metals intospecific items was particularly important, as itwas attributed somewhat mystical properties, asin the case of transition from illness to health.Trepanation skulls, dated back to 11th and 14thcenturies, were also found in the medieval Cracowarea. In case of a 14th century skull, theprocedure could have been performed by eitheran experienced surgeon or a craftsman. Betweenthe 16th and 18th century, guild surgeons werefamiliar with the trepanation technique, butrarely used it. It probably resulted from fear ofpatient’s death. The only indication for trepanationincluded severe head injuries [32]. It was away to decrease intracranial pressure or removean epidural hematoma. In case of trepanationskulls from the turn of medieval and moderntimes, we may suspect that a guild surgeon or acraftsman performed that procedure.Skeletons bearing signs of amputations alsocome from medieval cities: Wroclaw andGdansk. Amputations performed by guild surgeonswere also considered dangerous and wererarely performed.The picture of medicine in Poland, which maybe reconstructed on the basis of archeologicaland anthropological material indicates that,since Neolithic period, people tried to use everythingfrom human environment for medicalpurposes: curative water springs (votive offeringsfound there indicate that contemporary societiesascribed the springs healing and magical properties),medical plants. They also made the first flintand stone tools for trepanation and other minorprocedures. Therefore, we may note the evidencethat surgery, herbal medicine and hydrotherapyhave been shaping since prehistoric times. Archeologicalrelics and skeletal material certainlygive only a fragmentary picture of medicine inPoland in the prehistoric and medieval times.Despite that, they constitute an important sourcein the studies of medical historians. Knowledgeof medicine was passed from one generation toanother in small, often isolated, societies. Medicine,magic and religion coexisted throughoutthe ages and some magical/therapeutic practiceswere still popular among rural populations at thebeginning of 20th century.117

© Military Pharmacy and Medicine • 2012 • 4 • 117 – 118Magdalena Cybulska at al.: Anthropological and archeological sources …period, the wounded and sick warriors werealso cared for by their companions. Based onarcheological findings, we may conclude thata “warrior-surgeon” was equipped with medicalinstruments, including the following tools:bone knives, exploration probes and hooks. Inancient civilizations, with development of theart of war and formation of armies, comes thegradual progress in the areas of medicine relatedto military actions and frequent injuries, particularlysurgery. Surgical skills and treatment ofinjuries and wounds were especially importantin carrying for wounded warriors. During theRoman period, trepanations were performed bymilitary doctors (specially trained) that accompaniedthe legions.Military surgery went through many stages ofdevelopment. In the Roman army, a qualifiedmilitary doctor replaced a warrior-surgeon ofthe La Tene period. When it comes to the RomanEmpire, we are able to identify the doctor or amedic based on archeological studies and funeraryequipment. However, in the Barbarian regionidentification is very difficult. Three burial sitesfrom the Iron Age were identified in Poland,which contained tools described by the archeologistsas medicine-related. Two graves belongedto warriors and one is thought to be a burial sitebelonging to a midwife [29, 30]. There was probablyalso folk knowledge regarding trepanationsand other surgical procedures. People involvedin the surgical craft benefited from this knowledge.In the Middle Ages, as a result of separatingsurgery from medicine, surgical occupationcould be undertaken by people without medicaleducation, who only possessed some practicalskills. However, it is emphasized that barbersperformed mainly minor surgical procedures,healed wounds, reduced dislocations and fracturesor opened abscesses. They could also learnabout medicine from the clergy, as their work alsoincluded shaving tonsures. In the Middle Ages,demand for surgeons was high. They workedin the cities and princes’ courts. Ethnographicsources inform us that some occupations werealso predestined to performing therapeutic oreven surgical procedures, including: blacksmiths,shepherds, carpenters and beekeepers [31].People who cared for animals could use theirmedical knowledge to perform certain procedureson men. The tools used by the mentionedhttp://military.isl-journals.comcraftsmen for their everyday work could also beuseful for various medical procedures. In case ofa blacksmith, the transformation of metals intospecific items was particularly important, as itwas attributed somewhat mystical properties, asin the case of transition from illness to health.Trepanation skulls, dated back to 11th and 14thcenturies, were also found in the medieval Cracowarea. In case of a 14th century skull, theprocedure could have been performed by eitheran experienced surgeon or a craftsman. Betweenthe 16th and 18th century, guild surgeons werefamiliar with the trepanation technique, butrarely used it. It probably resulted from fear ofpatient’s death. The only indication for trepanationincluded severe head injuries [32]. It was away to decrease intracranial pressure or removean epidural hematoma. In case of trepanationskulls from the turn of medieval and moderntimes, we may suspect that a guild surgeon or acraftsman performed that procedure.Skeletons bearing signs of amputations alsocome from medieval cities: Wroclaw andGdansk. Amputations performed by guild surgeonswere also considered dangerous and wererarely performed.The picture of medicine in Poland, which maybe reconstructed on the basis of archeologicaland anthropological material indicates that,since Neolithic period, people tried to use everythingfrom human environment for medicalpurposes: curative water springs (votive offeringsfound there indicate that contemporary societiesascribed the springs healing and magical properties),medical plants. They also made the first flintand stone tools for trepanation and other minorprocedures. Therefore, we may note the evidencethat surgery, herbal medicine and hydrotherapyhave been shaping since prehistoric times. Archeologicalrelics and skeletal material certainlygive only a fragmentary picture of medicine inPoland in the prehistoric and medieval times.Despite that, they constitute an important sourcein the studies of medical historians. Knowledgeof medicine was passed from one generation toanother in small, often isolated, societies. Medicine,magic and religion coexisted throughoutthe ages and some magical/therapeutic practiceswere still popular among rural populations at thebeginning of 20th century.117

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!