Analysis Techniques For Man-Machine Systems Design

Analysis Techniques For Man-Machine Systems Design Analysis Techniques For Man-Machine Systems Design

ai.eecs.umich.edu
from ai.eecs.umich.edu More from this publisher
11.07.2015 Views

NATO UNCLASSIFIEDAC/243(Panel 8)TR/7 - 78 -Volume 24.4 INFORMATION/ACTION OR ACTION/INFORMATION TABULATIONSWhat the technique doesMasSfunThese are comparatively simple techniques for conducting a task analysis which emphasizes the informarion requiredby the operator to perform his or her task. Both analyses are hierarchical: they are based on those functions whichhave been allocated to the operator(s). Each function is analysed in turn to identify the operator's tasks. The 5.4.information/action analysis starts by analysing the information related to each function in sequence and defining theoperator's tasks, and the actions associated with each item of information (see Drury et. al., 1987; Meister, 1985;Woodson, 1981). The actionfinformation analysis is conducted by analysing an operator's tasks and actions insequence, as a series of discrete steps, to identify the information required for each action.Inputs to the techniquesThe analyst/user requires information on the actions tobe taken by the operator, or, conversely, the informationwhich the operator will be given by a specific systemstate.Outputs of the techniquesThe techniques produce tabulations of the informationprovided to the operator, the action taken upon receipt ofthe information, and optionally, the feedback to theoperator.5.4When to useThe techniques are of use in concept development, and particularly, in preliminary design. They may be preceded byone of several types of function analysis: Function Flow Diagrams (2.1), Sequence And Timing (SAT) analysis(2.2), Information Flow and Processing Analysis (2.4). They may be incorporated into Requirements AllocationSheets (3.5). Information/Action, or Action/Information analyses produce information which can be used either formore detailed task analyses (4.5), for display concept development or analysis of Critical Design Requirements (6.2),for Error Analysis (5.7), or for Link Analysis (6.3).MiFL1lRelatedtechniquesThe techniques are two of several tabular task-analysis techniques all of which analyse the operator's tasks as a seriesof actions in response to information inputs.Resources requiredThe analyst requires the information identified under "inputs." No technical resources are necessary, but a computersystem is recommended to keep track of the many details that are created, and to facilitate modification.tNATO UNCLASSIFIED- 78 -

NATO UNCLASSIFIED- 79 AC/243(Panel-8)TR/7Volume 2Table 4.2:Example of information/action analysis- Mission segment: Aircraft approach to sonar dip positionFunction: 5.4.7 Engage /Monitor Automatic Flight Control System (AFCS) for Automatic Approachc, Task No. & Task Initiating Action response(s)lstimulus/information5.4.7.1 (a) Engage AFCS for automatic Pre-approach checks completed. Adjust AFCS for approach to dip.e approach Aircraft within automatic approach "Approach to dip" mode indication.profile criteria.Required approach profile. Actuate AFCS engage.AFCS operating status.AFCS "Approach to dip enabled"Proceduresindication.5.4.7.2 (b) Monitor a/c during automatic AFCS approach to dip. Monitor (visuaIaircraftapproachperformance.Aircraft flight parameters (transition).AFCS operating status.Aircraft movement rclative to desiredhover poinLTable 4.3:Example of action/information requirements analysisYMission segment: Aircraft approach to base.Function: 1.0 Initiate pre-approach proceduresAction requirements Information requirements Related information,sources. and problems1.0.1 Review approach information 1.0.1.1 Approach orientation. Position data1.0.1.2 Approach constraints: Approach path data:RequirementsCourse & path dataObstaclesObstacle locations-izardsTerrain characteristicses Weather Minimum decision altitudes1.0.2 Coordinate approach with 1.0.2.1 Communication: Coordination & confirmation ofcontrol Path dcsienation approach clearance.Limitations & constraints Altimeter settingEnvironmental conditionsAdvantagesUsers report the techniques to be fast and easy, providedthat the level of detail does not become excessive. It hasbeen found useful for deriving test criteria for mockupreviews and for some test & evaluation (T&E) activities.DisadvantagesThe analysis can become time-consuming if the level ofdetail is not controlled. Standardization of terms for tasksand information is recommended to avoid confusion.NATO UNCLASSIFIED- 79 -

NATO UNCLASSIFIEDAC/243(Panel 8)TR/7 - 78 -Volume 24.4 INFORMATION/ACTION OR ACTION/INFORMATION TABULATIONSWhat the technique doesMasSfunThese are comparatively simple techniques for conducting a task analysis which emphasizes the informarion requiredby the operator to perform his or her task. Both analyses are hierarchical: they are based on those functions whichhave been allocated to the operator(s). Each function is analysed in turn to identify the operator's tasks. The 5.4.information/action analysis starts by analysing the information related to each function in sequence and defining theoperator's tasks, and the actions associated with each item of information (see Drury et. al., 1987; Meister, 1985;Woodson, 1981). The actionfinformation analysis is conducted by analysing an operator's tasks and actions insequence, as a series of discrete steps, to identify the information required for each action.Inputs to the techniquesThe analyst/user requires information on the actions tobe taken by the operator, or, conversely, the informationwhich the operator will be given by a specific systemstate.Outputs of the techniquesThe techniques produce tabulations of the informationprovided to the operator, the action taken upon receipt ofthe information, and optionally, the feedback to theoperator.5.4When to useThe techniques are of use in concept development, and particularly, in preliminary design. They may be preceded byone of several types of function analysis: Function Flow Diagrams (2.1), Sequence And Timing (SAT) analysis(2.2), Information Flow and Processing <strong>Analysis</strong> (2.4). They may be incorporated into Requirements AllocationSheets (3.5). Information/Action, or Action/Information analyses produce information which can be used either formore detailed task analyses (4.5), for display concept development or analysis of Critical <strong>Design</strong> Requirements (6.2),for Error <strong>Analysis</strong> (5.7), or for Link <strong>Analysis</strong> (6.3).MiFL1lRelatedtechniquesThe techniques are two of several tabular task-analysis techniques all of which analyse the operator's tasks as a seriesof actions in response to information inputs.Resources requiredThe analyst requires the information identified under "inputs." No technical resources are necessary, but a computersystem is recommended to keep track of the many details that are created, and to facilitate modification.tNATO UNCLASSIFIED- 78 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!