shut down for several weeks in May <strong>and</strong>June, 2003, including portions <strong>of</strong> theparking area near the top <strong>of</strong> the ramp.They will also occupy marina docks <strong>and</strong>boats on moorings. Working with federal<strong>and</strong> state personnel, experiments thatseemed to work included gently hosing<strong>of</strong>f the docks near the sea lions, jinglingcar keys on a key chain, <strong>and</strong> spinningbuoys on the docks in front <strong>of</strong> theanimals.It was also learned that the sea lions arehighly intelligent <strong>and</strong> are able toaccommodate new experiences(spinning buoys) once they realize thatthey will not be harmed or undulyinconvenienced. So, what worked thisweek may not work next week, or nextyear. It is a ongoing problem that mustbe addressed as a moving target. Thiscan be a seasonal problem to someextent, <strong>and</strong> some years seem to beworse than others. The population <strong>of</strong> sealions is declining worldwide, but isgrowing in the Monterey/Central<strong>California</strong> coastline areas.Sea Lions on Boarding FloatsSea Lions at Pier 39 Marina - San FranciscoThe sea lions are notorious for fouling any area that they stay in for any length <strong>of</strong>time. They can occupy a dock or large boat(s) for days or weeks, <strong>and</strong> leave behindserious cleanup chores. Therefore, harbor staff must clean the boat ramp, docks,boat slips, etc. in preparation for allowing public use to resume when the sea lionsmigrate to other locations as their available food resources change.......................................................................C3.1 Minimum <strong>and</strong> Maximum Freeboard under DL only.Commentary:The minimum freeboard is to be sufficient to prevent walers, fender boards <strong>and</strong>utility lines from being in direct contact with the water surface under still-waterconditions. It is advisable to provide a minimum 4 inch freeboard to the bottom <strong>of</strong> allwalers <strong>and</strong> fender boards. This will extend the service life <strong>of</strong> these dockcomponents that are so exposed to intermittent wet <strong>and</strong> dry conditions in the splashzone just above the waterline.It is to be understood that these freeboard guidelines are general, <strong>and</strong> are intendedto address typical recreational boat/berth needs <strong>and</strong> conditions found in <strong>California</strong>marinas. Where unique needs <strong>and</strong> conditions exist, freeboard specifications mayAppendix A -- Section C Commentary - Page 77
need to be altered accordingly. The users should always be kept in mind as well asthe types <strong>and</strong> sizes <strong>of</strong> boats that will be berthed in a given marina. A freeboard <strong>of</strong>24 inches is impracticable at a lake marina that primarily berths only low-pr<strong>of</strong>ilealuminum fishing boats. 24 inches is too large a step down from the marina deckinto such fishing boats, particularly for senior citizen boaters, but may be perfectlysuited for large yachts <strong>and</strong> cruisers berthed in urban coastal marinas. The term“freeboard” addresses the vertical distance from the water surface to the marinadeck. However, it also addresses the practical aspects <strong>of</strong> enabling boaters to be“free” to “board” their boats in consideration <strong>of</strong> boat type, size, <strong>and</strong> dock freeboard.......................................................................C3.2 DL + ULLCommentary:Using the DL only minimum freeboard <strong>of</strong> 14" as a baseline, a dock designer has 4"<strong>of</strong> freeboard reduction within which to pick up the ULL applied throughout the docksystem without going below a 10" freeboard. This can be addressed throughselection <strong>of</strong> the flotation pontoon shape, wall thickness, weight, length, width, depth,number <strong>and</strong> distribution. A cubic foot <strong>of</strong> fresh water weighs about 62.5#, <strong>and</strong> a cubicfoot <strong>of</strong> flotation pontoon weighs about 2.5 pounds. Therefore, each cubic foot <strong>of</strong>pontoon displacement will support about 60#. This provides a practical rule-<strong>of</strong>thumbthat every 1" <strong>of</strong> displacement <strong>of</strong> a 1 ft cube <strong>of</strong> pontoon flotation will support aload <strong>of</strong> about 5 pounds.[62.5 #/ft 3 - 2.5 #/ft 3 ] ÷ 12 in/ft = 5# per inch <strong>of</strong> displacement <strong>of</strong> a 12"x12"x12" cubeIn coastal marina applications, use 64 #/ft 3 for the weight <strong>of</strong> salt water.A word <strong>of</strong> caution is in order here. In some dock designs, the pontoons areattached to the bottom <strong>of</strong> an open frame such as a steel truss. The decking isattached to the top side <strong>of</strong> the frame, <strong>and</strong> the utilities are run through the frame. Thebuoyancy capacity <strong>of</strong> the pontoons may be entirely adequate to carry 100% <strong>of</strong> thedesign dead <strong>and</strong> live loads <strong>and</strong> fully meet the freeboard requirements. However, ifthe pontoons are fully immersed under full design load, they have no reserveflotation capacity for emergencies. Additional loads can sink the pontoons all theway to the bottom but no additional pontoon buoyancy capacity will be realized.In contrast, some other types <strong>of</strong> dock systems, such as those built on enclosedpontoons that extend well above the waterline, not only provide the necessaryfreeboard <strong>and</strong> fully meet the dem<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> dead <strong>and</strong> live loads, but also providereserve buoyancy capacity should an emergency need arise.Thus, there are trade<strong>of</strong>fs between the various types <strong>of</strong> dock systems, <strong>and</strong> theconditions under which they will be expected to perform. Consideration <strong>of</strong> all <strong>of</strong> theabove elements is essential to good design <strong>and</strong> construction <strong>of</strong> safe <strong>and</strong> longlasting marina docks.......................................................................Appendix A -- Section C Commentary - Page 78