I had no incentive to increase my financialresults because any production underthe minimum threshold was the same asdoing no production!I should point out that my numbersfor P&C were always really good for newproduction, retention, and pr<strong>of</strong>itability.Once again, the wall in my <strong>of</strong>fice isadorned with plaques that confirm thisand I was also designated as a PremierService Agency in 2009.As a small scratch agency, cash flowmeans everything and my goal was tobuild a good P&C base, so I could hiresomeone and focus more energy on financialservices, commercial insurance,and specialty items. I believe these addedservices are important and would makemy agency more complete. However,with Allstate’s cost-shifting, extreme rateincreases, and constant general alienation<strong>of</strong> its customer base, I spend most<strong>of</strong> my time trying to save my home/autocustomer base.The setupEach year I’ve struggled to producethe minimum $1,000 in variable productioncredit. In fact, most years it seemsthat I’ve had to purchase products just tokeep my affiliation with Allstate – andlast year was no different.Knowing I needed to meet my minimumsecurities requirement before theJune 30th deadline, I decided to increase aVUL I had on myself. Since I’ve receivedlittle to no training on financial services,I wanted to make sure what I was doingwas correct. Furthermore, since Iwas paying for the coverage increase out<strong>of</strong> my pocket, I needed to ensure I wasincreasing the policy by enough to meetmy minimum requirement without goingoverboard. So I decided to contactAllstate Financial Services for assistance.AFS told me that I could increase myVUL and that it would provide me withthe credit needed to go towards my minimumsecurities production requirement.However, they could not tell me howmuch coverage I needed sell myself to getthe production amount I needed. Theytold me I would have to contact AF comp,which turned out to be another dead end.They told me that they could only calculateproduction credit after the changewas made and the policy was issued.As a last resort, I contacted my AllstateField Sales Leader, who had onlybeen my FSL for a few weeks. She saidshe could assist me in calculating theamount I needed to increase my policy.She also gave me a good talking to aboutneeding to work towards my ExpectedResults and that I shouldn’t put myselfin this position. I agreed and tried to explainthat I would like to do more, but mycustomers – who were being battered byhuge homeowner rate increases <strong>of</strong> 35%to 100% – were taking up a large amount<strong>of</strong> time. Of course, I also explained thatnew production is much easier when youhave decent products to sell.At this point, I informed her that Ihad been trying to sell my agency for ayear or so. But because there were virtuallyno qualified buyers in my area andsince about half <strong>of</strong> the agencies in myarea are listed for sale on Allstate’s website,I hadn’t had much luck getting out. Ialso explained that due to a business loanon my agency, I didn’t want to take TPPbecause the first 6 payments would go tothe bank, leaving me no income while Isearched for a new job in a hard market.I told her all I needed was to make sureI hit my required FS numbers so that Icould either sell my agency or see if Allstatewould revamp its pricing so I wouldhave competitive products to sell.She showed me how to increase myVUL and calculated out how much Ineeded to increase my policy by to producejust over the required $1,000 productionlimit. I did as she instructed andsubmitted the paperwork. Because wewere getting close to the deadline, I wasdiligent in following up on everything.When I was told by AFS, shortly beforethe deadline, that everything had completed;I breathed a little sigh <strong>of</strong> relief.It was around this time that I receiveda letter from Allstate saying I had notbeen hitting my Expected Results andthat I was on the naughty list. I was toldthat I needed to make improvementsover the next 6 months and that the letterwas simply a warning.Where things become crookedShortly after my new production reportcame out, I noticed that the variableproduction credit amount was justbelow the $1,000 yearly requirement,even though I increased my VUL as instructedby my FSL.I contacted my FSL immediately andshe stated she didn’t understand what theproblem was and that she would investigateit for me. She also told me I shouldcontact AF Comp. Here is where thingsgot really strange. AF Comp emailedme and told me I had hit my productionamount for the year. However, some <strong>of</strong>the other reports showed I did not. MyFSL told me that she was double checkingeverything and told me not to worry.A few weeks went by and I hadn’theard anything from my FSL. WhatI did receive was a certified letter fromAllstate Financial stating that my contractwith them had been terminated forfailing to meet my minimum productionrequirements. My stomach immediatelyturned sour. The first thing I did waspick up the phone to call the FSL andwhen I received no answer, I left messagefor her to call me back. Then I decidedto email her and when I opened my InboxI saw there was an email stating thatshe had been promoted and that we nowhad a new FSL. Somehow, I was gettingthe feeling I had been had. To this dateI’m not sure if the FSL was just that incompetentor if I was being setup, but itseemed a lot like sabotage to me. In caseyou are wondering, I never heard fromher again, ever.For the next few weeks, I contactedeveryone I could think <strong>of</strong> to get helpwith my predicament. During this time Ireceived another certified letter, this onefrom Allstate Insurance stating that dueto losing my FS contract they were terminatingme, effective November 30th.My new FSL told me there was nothingshe could do, but she would help metry and find a buyer for my agency. Shenever sent any buyers my way.For five months I asked various peopleto please review my termination. I informedeach <strong>of</strong> them that I had documentationshowing I had enough credit,and that everything I did was at my manager’sdirection. I received no assistancefrom any <strong>of</strong> the departments I reachedout to, or from any <strong>of</strong> the dozen or sopeople I contacted about the problem. In50 — <strong>Exclusivefocus</strong> <strong>Summer</strong> 2012
fact, few <strong>of</strong> them even bothered to returnmy voicemails or respond to my emails.I even asked if perhaps they would considerpostponing termination a month orso in order to make it through the Holidaysfor my family’s sake. But once again,I was greeted with either no response ortold nothing could be done.In short, I was being terminated, andunless I hired a lawyer, which I could notafford, November 30th would be my lastday as an Allstate agent. By September Ihad resigned myself to the fact that therewas no hope for my business. Meanwhile,my business partner was destroyingmy livelihood and was all set to stealthe customer base I had built up. Theyhad tarnished my name by placing a terminationfor cause on my U5, which anyfuture employer could access. In short,my business experienced corporate sabotagedelivered at the hand <strong>of</strong> my businesspartner.Facing seemingly insurmountableodds, I started to look for a new job. Thisdidn’t go well considering the hard jobmarket and the fact I had to disclose t<strong>of</strong>uture employers that I was being terminatedfrom Allstate due to poor production.I also started the process <strong>of</strong> shuttingdown my agency and began liquidatingsome assets. Ironically, I terminated theVUL that I just increased because I knewI would no longer be able to make thepayments. Moreover, my policy as wellas my other variable business had alreadybeen transferred to another agent. Ofcourse, by cancelling the policy, I lost everythingI had paid into the VUL overthe years due to the surrender charge. Iguess this worked out to be a little extra“bonus money” for Allstate!Like any good agent, I had built astrong relationship with many <strong>of</strong> my customers.Because Allstate does such a badjob <strong>of</strong> integrating customers with newagents, I wanted to give my customers aheads up that I would no longer be withAllstate come November 30th. I didn’twant them coming to my <strong>of</strong>fice and beingsurprised to find my doors locked. Idid this as a courtesy to my customers,who I love and respect, unlike my greedybusiness partner who only sees them asdollar signs. I also destroyed or gave away$500 to $1000 worth <strong>of</strong> Allstate promoitems – everything form c<strong>of</strong>fee mugs tobusiness cards – which I had purchasedover the years. But Allstate had a trick upits sleeve and these two acts would comeback to haunt me…Allstate’s new trick….ReaffiliationAbout 15 days before I was to be terminated,I had a discussion about mysituation with a woman from Allstatewho was responsible for collecting mycustomer files. I told her what happenedand she sounded a little alarmed. Sheasked me to send her the “documentation”I had about my case, so I did. Thenext day I received a frantic phone callfrom Allstate Financial asking me to signand return the “reaffiliation” paperworkthey would send overnight to me.Reaffiliation? I was shocked at firstbecause this wasn’t something I was expecting.Then my surprise turned to anger.For months I asked dozens <strong>of</strong> peoplefor help, but no one bothered to take thetime to review my situation. Then byhappenstance and in the final moments<strong>of</strong> my career, someone finally takes aninterest and reviews my documentationand suddenly, they wanted me backagain. Apparently what they saw was socut-and-dried wrong, they had to reversetheir initial decision and get me to reaffiliateimmediately. It’s obvious theyweren’t doing this out <strong>of</strong> the goodness <strong>of</strong>their hearts, but to cover their own asses!Since, I had already started the process<strong>of</strong> moving on with my life, I told themI needed to think about it. After mullingit over for a day, I made some minorrequests to resolve the situation for bothparties. Here were my requests:1. That Allstate correct my U-5.2. That Allstate pay me the fair marketvalue for my agency – as determined by athird party – and paid in a lump sum.3. That Allstate pay the pre-paymentpenalty on my loan.After being wrongfully terminatedand having my business practice dis-<strong>Summer</strong> 2012 <strong>Exclusivefocus</strong> — 51