Munson's Bariatric Surgery Program - Munson Healthcare
Munson's Bariatric Surgery Program - Munson Healthcare
Munson's Bariatric Surgery Program - Munson Healthcare
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Munson</strong>’s <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong>:<br />
Excellent Outcomes, Few Complications<br />
<strong>Munson</strong><strong>Healthcare</strong>.org<br />
A2 Reason to Celebrate<br />
Physicians and patients from outlying<br />
areas are seeing long-term success<br />
A3 Going Full Tilt<br />
Patient gets second chance to<br />
‘live life right’; asks physicians to<br />
keep an open mind<br />
A4 Who’s It For?<br />
Primary care physicians play key role<br />
in identifying, following up with<br />
surgical patients<br />
A5 The Diabetes Connection<br />
<strong>Bariatric</strong> surgery is having a significant<br />
impact on type 2 diabetes and other<br />
life-threatening diseases<br />
A6 National Recognition<br />
<strong>Munson</strong> named a <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong><br />
Center of Excellence by exceeding<br />
national standards<br />
A7 Meet the Surgeons<br />
The procedures and the surgeons<br />
who perform them
Canadian Perspective: ‘Not One Patient<br />
Says They Wouldn’t Do It Again’<br />
Three years ago, Linda Benedek, a family physician by<br />
training and a former Air Force flight surgeon, decided to<br />
focus her practice exclusively on weight management and<br />
the co-morbidities of obesity.<br />
Her own struggle with weight led her to seek additional medical<br />
training to become a diplomate of the American Board of<br />
<strong>Bariatric</strong> Medicine (ABBM).<br />
After becoming credentialed, she opened Celebration Medical<br />
Weight Management in Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario, and offers<br />
a six-month weight management program that, for some<br />
patients, dovetails with the <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong> offered<br />
at <strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center. In the past 18 months, Benedek<br />
has referred 25 of her 300 patients to bariatric surgeons at<br />
Grand Traverse <strong>Surgery</strong>, PC.<br />
Her program uses a three-pronged approach to tackling<br />
obesity: behavior modification, diet, and exercise, with the<br />
goal of achieving a 5 - 10 percent weight loss within six<br />
months. She is her own walking testimonial, having lost 40<br />
pounds and kept it off for three years.<br />
“I don’t refer anyone for bariatric surgery until they have<br />
completed the program,” she said. “Some patients, despite best<br />
behavior modification and diet changes, are unable to lose<br />
weight. We will look at bariatric surgery as an option, but the<br />
intent of my program is not just to prepare people for surgery.<br />
Mental and emotional issues with respect to food need to be<br />
properly addressed, as the surgery does not eliminate those.”<br />
Benedek makes it clear to patients that bariatric procedures<br />
are only for “rule followers.” She screens out patients unlikely<br />
to succeed because they are non-compliant in other areas –<br />
such as treatment for diabetes. So far, that approach has<br />
been highly successful.<br />
A2<br />
“I’m seeing excellent results. Typical weight loss is 100 pounds in the first year.”<br />
Linda Benedek, MD, CCFP, FCFP<br />
Diplomate of American Board of <strong>Bariatric</strong> Medicine<br />
Celebration Medical Weight Management<br />
Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario<br />
“I’m seeing excellent results,” she said. “Typical weight<br />
loss is 100 pounds in the first year. My patients have been<br />
very compliant. I take a lot of time teaching them about<br />
protein intake – it’s essential that they do what they’re<br />
supposed to do.”<br />
Benedek has observed improvement in all co-morbidities<br />
in her post-op patients.<br />
“Most of my patients are able to discontinue<br />
their blood pressure, cholesterol, and diabetic<br />
medications,” she said. “Even insulin is often<br />
discontinued or markedly reduced.<br />
The symptoms of osteoarthritis in their<br />
knees and hips are significantly improved<br />
with much less discomfort.<br />
They’re all delighted – the ones with<br />
complications and the ones without.<br />
I have not had one patient say they<br />
wouldn’t do it again.”<br />
Support for Physicians and Patients<br />
in Outlying Areas<br />
Physicians and patients from outside of the Traverse City<br />
area can expect a high level of service from the team at<br />
<strong>Munson</strong>.<br />
“I’m three hours from Traverse City,” Benedek said. “I’m<br />
very pleased with the service I get from Traverse City.<br />
They really do their best to minimize travel for my patients.<br />
They’re very courteous, flexible, and amenable.”<br />
continued on A4<br />
Benedek’s <strong>Program</strong>: Behavior Modification | Diet | Exercise > 5 - 10% Weight Loss in Six Months
<strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> Gives Patient<br />
‘A Second Opportunity to Live Life Right’<br />
“I feel fantastic. The other day a co-worker<br />
said, ‘Oh, you’re sitting in a chair with sides –<br />
I’ve never seen you do that.’ I’ve discovered<br />
I actually have a tailbone – I can feel it.”<br />
Lesley Sawchyn, Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario<br />
Lesley Sawchyn was a chubby child ballerina who grew into<br />
a chunky teen basketball player. Despite being physically<br />
active, by the time Lesley was a 37-year-old mother, she<br />
weighed 330 pounds.<br />
She has a plea for primary care physicians: “Be open minded<br />
and open hearted. If you are a thin physician and you’ve<br />
never been overweight, you do not truly understand what<br />
it is like to be obese and how cruel society is to people who<br />
are. Really try to understand where your patient is coming<br />
from.”<br />
Secondly: “Be fully supportive, but put the onus back on the<br />
patient. There is no going back after making the decision for<br />
surgery. You basically have one chance – the patient has to<br />
be responsible for their own success.”<br />
Lesley, a sign language interpreter for the Canadian<br />
Hearing Society, completed a six-month weight management<br />
program in Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario. She lost 32<br />
pounds. When she gained it all back, she had a heart-toheart<br />
with her physician, Linda Benedek, MD, in November<br />
2008. “Nothing, nothing, nothing was working for me,”<br />
she said. “I decided I’m too vibrant to be weighed down<br />
by this weight.”<br />
Lesley had a Roux-en-Y procedure<br />
at <strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center<br />
in March 2009, weighing 321<br />
pounds. Ten months post-op,<br />
she weighed 193 pounds.<br />
Lesley had no co-morbidities.<br />
While complication rates for<br />
bariatric surgery at <strong>Munson</strong><br />
Medical Center are well<br />
Roux-en-Y Procedure<br />
<strong>Munson</strong><strong>Healthcare</strong>.org<br />
Lesley before<br />
(above) and<br />
after (right)<br />
below national averages,<br />
they can happen. The wellestablished<br />
collaboration<br />
between her primary care<br />
physician and her surgeon<br />
became paramount when<br />
Lesley developed an ulcer<br />
and a stricture. Benedek<br />
referred her back to<br />
<strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center<br />
for immediate care.<br />
Despite complications, Lesley says she is extremely<br />
pleased with her results, grateful to her local primary care<br />
physician, and she’s highly complimentary of the team at<br />
Grand Traverse <strong>Surgery</strong>. Lesley helps lead a lively bariatric<br />
support group in Sault Ste. Marie, encouraging others to<br />
adhere to the life-long dietary and exercise requirements.<br />
“I’d do it again in a heartbeat,” Lesley said. “I was always<br />
an active person, but now I can go full tilt. I’m in such<br />
good hands. I’ve been given a gift – a second opportunity<br />
to live again and do it right. Once you have the surgery,<br />
you have an obligation to take care of yourself.”<br />
A3
A4<br />
continued from A2<br />
Patients are seen for an initial consultation, again for one<br />
pre-op visit that covers everything in a half-day appointment,<br />
and then they return for surgery. Patients who live<br />
more than three hours away are asked to stay in Traverse<br />
City until seven days post-op, when their drain is removed<br />
and they are sent home. Patients are usually hospitalized<br />
for three days, depending on their procedure. Follow-up<br />
care begins immediately with the primary care physician.<br />
“<strong>Surgery</strong> notes are transcribed and faxed immediately,”<br />
Benedek said. “I have them in hand well before I see my<br />
patient – I’m really kept in the loop. It’s a very smooth<br />
process for my patients.”<br />
“The back up support is excellent – one of the four surgeons<br />
is always on call. If my patient runs into a problem<br />
at midnight, a surgeon is available for telephone advice.<br />
We have had some complications, such as a post-op leak<br />
and a bowel obstruction, both of which required surgery<br />
and those were promptly dealt with.”<br />
Four Tips for Primary Care Physicians<br />
Based on her experience, Benedek offers<br />
the following advice:<br />
Evaluate all behavioral aspects before considering<br />
bariatric surgery – if those issues aren’t dealt with first,<br />
the surgery is less likely to be successful.<br />
Develop a rapport with a <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> Center so<br />
you are familiar with the process and the required<br />
follow-up for patients.<br />
Don’t consider surgery for anyone who can’t quit<br />
smoking. Patients must be non-smokers for at least<br />
two months before a referral should be considered.<br />
Make sure patients fully understand life-long nutrition<br />
and lifestyle requirements after surgery. Rule followers do<br />
well – the non-compliant patient is not going to do well.<br />
A Guide for Primary Physicians<br />
As the first providers who can help improve or save a patient’s life<br />
through bariatric care, primary care physicians are the gatekeepers<br />
for the <strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center (MMC) <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong>.<br />
MMC has taken definitive steps to provide the best opportunity for<br />
patient success. The following criteria and steps can help physicians<br />
determine if patients are eligible, and what to expect.<br />
<strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> Criteria<br />
MMC bariatric surgeons follow the National Institute of Health<br />
(NIH) guidelines for weight-loss surgery candidates to include one<br />
of the following:<br />
• Body mass index (BMI) of 40 or greater (100 pounds or more<br />
above normal weight)<br />
• BMI of 35 to 40 (50 to 100 pounds above normal weight)<br />
with two or more co-morbidities<br />
• Patient age: 18 - 65 years<br />
• Patient record of unsuccessful attempts to lose weight in<br />
a medically-supervised program<br />
• Patient obesity-associated co-morbidities under medical care<br />
Educational Seminar<br />
Patients who meet criteria must attend a two-hour educational<br />
seminar. “The seminar is offered once a month and is an important<br />
opportunity to teach patients about the lifelong commitment to<br />
proper nutrition, exercise, smoking cessation, and other behavioral<br />
modifications,” said Mary Kay Williams, MSN, FNP-C, Coordinator<br />
of the <strong>Munson</strong> <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong>.<br />
Next Steps<br />
Once a patient makes the commitment, has the recommendation of<br />
their primary physician, and the support of their family, they enter<br />
the <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong>. The next steps are consultation,<br />
psychological evaluation, preoperative classes, and the surgery.<br />
Long-term Care Management<br />
Comprehensive care is a critical component of MMC’s <strong>Bariatric</strong><br />
<strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong>. By focusing on medical management, nutrition,<br />
exercise, nursing care, and psychological needs of each patient, the<br />
support staff offers patients the optimum opportunity to succeed.<br />
Post-op follow-up care occurs at one week, three weeks, six weeks,<br />
three months, six months, nine months, 12 months, 18 months, 24<br />
months, then yearly thereafter. A lifelong connection to patients has<br />
proven to be essential to success.<br />
Support groups also offer information and encouragement to<br />
patients after surgery. “Meeting with other patients who have undergone<br />
the surgery is vital to our patients’ success,” said Williams.<br />
“They share in each others’ struggles and victories, and that brings<br />
them comfort and strength.”
<strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong>:<br />
A Cure for Diabetes?<br />
Mounting evidence suggests bariatric surgery may be among<br />
the most effective treatments for conditions including type<br />
2 diabetes, hypertension, high cholesterol, non-alcoholic<br />
fatty liver disease, and obstructive sleep apnea, according to<br />
the American Society for Metabolic and <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong><br />
(ASMBS).<br />
“<strong>Surgery</strong> for severe obesity goes way beyond weight loss,”<br />
said Kelvin Higa, MD, President of ASMBS. “This surgery<br />
results in the complete remission or significant improvement<br />
of type 2 diabetes and other life-threatening diseases in most<br />
patients.”<br />
Surgeons at Grand Traverse <strong>Surgery</strong>, PC, who participate in<br />
<strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center’s (MMC) <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong>,<br />
are optimistic about use of gastrointestinal surgery as a treatment<br />
for diabetes.<br />
“We are seeing evidence that bariatric<br />
surgery results in type 2 diabetes remission.<br />
A high percentage of our patients have<br />
normalization of their hemoglobin AIC<br />
within two months of gastric bypass.”<br />
Michael Nizzi, DO, Medical Director<br />
MMC <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> <strong>Program</strong><br />
“Gastric bypass and other malabsorption procedures<br />
(intestinal bypass) will become the procedure of choice for<br />
type 2 diabetes mellitus remission,” Nizzi said. “This is still<br />
investigational, but consensus is growing to decrease the BMI<br />
threshold of which patients are candidates for surgery.”<br />
New research indicates metabolic surgery may improve<br />
insulin resistance and secretion by mechanisms independent<br />
of weight loss – most likely involving changes in gastro<br />
intestinal hormones. Many patients with type 2 diabetes<br />
experience complete remission within days of surgery,<br />
long before significant weight comes off. This has led to new<br />
thinking that surgery may be appropriate for diabetic patients<br />
who are of normal weight or only slightly overweight.<br />
<strong>Munson</strong><strong>Healthcare</strong>.org<br />
In the American Diabetes Association’s (ADA) 2009<br />
Standards of Care Clinical Guidelines, the ADA bolstered<br />
its section on bariatric surgery and its effect on type 2<br />
diabetes and said “bariatric surgery should be considered<br />
for adults with BMI greater than 35 and type 2 diabetes.<br />
ASMBS and many other national medical organizations<br />
also support using bariatric and metabolic surgery in type 2<br />
diabetes patients with BMIs of less than 35 under a research<br />
protocol.”<br />
An article in the January 2008 issue of the Journal of the<br />
American Medical Association (JAMA), written by<br />
David Cummings, MD, and David Flum, MD, MPH,<br />
both from the University of Washington in Seattle, reported<br />
on a two-year randomized controlled trial involving type 2<br />
diabetes patients with a BMI of 30 to 40:<br />
• “Complete remission of diabetes at two years was achieved<br />
in 73 percent of the patients in the laparoscopic adjustable<br />
gastric banding group versus only 13 percent in the<br />
medical/behavioral therapy group. The surgical group<br />
experienced larger reductions in blood glucose levels,<br />
glycated hemoglobin levels, estimated insulin resistance,<br />
use of diabetes medication, and several features of the<br />
metabolic syndrome.”<br />
• “Among the 84 percent of patients with diabetes whose<br />
disease remits entirely after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass,<br />
one-third have blood glucose levels within reference range<br />
without use of anti-diabetes medications before discharge<br />
from their surgical hospitalization, at an average of less<br />
than three post-operative days.”<br />
A5
<strong>Munson</strong> <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Program</strong><br />
Nationally Recognized<br />
for Excellent Outcomes<br />
The Agency for <strong>Healthcare</strong> Research and Quality<br />
reports that the number of bariatric surgeries<br />
increased 400 percent from 1998 to 2004.<br />
More than 1,500 bariatric surgeries have been<br />
performed at <strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center (MMC)<br />
since the program began in 2003. <strong>Munson</strong><br />
and surgeons from Grand Traverse <strong>Surgery</strong>,<br />
PC, were named a <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> Center of<br />
Excellence based on demonstrated short- and<br />
long-term outcomes and advanced treatment that<br />
exceeds national standards for bariatric surgical care.<br />
In addition, MMC was designated a Blue Distinction<br />
Center for <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong> by Blue Cross Blue Shield of<br />
Michigan and is an approved provider for the Ontario<br />
Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) for Canadian patients.<br />
A6<br />
Total surgeries by type | 2009<br />
RNY Open 10<br />
RNY Lap 193<br />
Lap-Band 172<br />
Lap Sleeve 36<br />
Open Sleeve 1<br />
Revisions 1<br />
About 400 bariatric procedures are performed annually at<br />
MMC. <strong>Bariatric</strong> surgery is successful if the patient achieves<br />
a 50 percent loss of excess body weight within 18 months<br />
following surgery. With comprehensive support provided<br />
by <strong>Munson</strong>’s bariatric team, patients consistently exceed<br />
that average – most reach a 75 percent excess weight loss<br />
within 12 to 18 months post-surgery.<br />
“<strong>Munson</strong>’s weight loss program includes experienced<br />
surgeons who perform an average of eight bariatric procedures<br />
each week,” said Roche J. Featherstone, MD, bariatric<br />
surgeon. “We practice extensive patient screening, education,<br />
and follow-up, which leads to our patients’ success, as well as<br />
our recognized success as a team.”<br />
Low Complication Rates<br />
Nationally, bariatric surgery complication rates declined<br />
21 percent between 2002 and 2006. Complication rates at<br />
<strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center were 2.51 percent in 2008, well<br />
below national rates. “With the exception of gastric banding,<br />
all other primary and revisional bariatric procedures are<br />
performed by two surgeons, rather than being assisted by<br />
a physician extender or surgical assistant,” said Michael A.<br />
Nizzi, DO, Medical Director of <strong>Munson</strong>’s <strong>Bariatric</strong> <strong>Surgery</strong><br />
<strong>Program</strong>. “The clinical pathway at <strong>Munson</strong> ensures that all<br />
patients receive equal evidence-based therapies that limit<br />
omissions in the care plan that could possibly lead to<br />
sub-optimal results.”<br />
Additionally, “laparoscopic procedures now account<br />
for more than 90 percent of our cases,” Nizzi said.<br />
“Physicians considering making a referral for bariatric<br />
surgery at <strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center should feel very<br />
confident that their patient will be safe and successful<br />
because we have established a program that is achieving<br />
or exceeding all national benchmarks.”
Lap Band ®<br />
The LAP-BAND ® System<br />
This minimally-invasive adjustable<br />
gastric banding procedure<br />
is the only reversible, FDAapproved<br />
surgical obesity treatment.<br />
A silicone band is placed around the upper part of<br />
the stomach to create a new, smaller stomach pouch. The<br />
band also narrows the stomach outlet, limiting the flow of<br />
food. It reduces appetite and slows digestion. LAP-BAND®<br />
is appropriate for patients who have a lower BMI and<br />
limited co-morbidities.<br />
Although current procedures yield above-average success<br />
for MMC patients, the bariatric team looks to advancements<br />
that include genetic therapy, gastric pacemaker,<br />
and intragastric balloons, all of which provide options<br />
to widen the bariatric care MMC provides.<br />
Roux-en-Y<br />
Surgeons perform this laparoscopic<br />
procedure through tiny incisions,<br />
during which the stomach is made<br />
into a small pouch that restricts<br />
food intake. The duodenum and<br />
first portion of the jejunum are<br />
bypassed, thereby reducing calorie<br />
Roux-en-Y<br />
and nutrient absorption, so careful<br />
attention is placed on patient education and dietary<br />
evaluation post-surgery.<br />
Vertical Sleeve Gastrectomy<br />
Vertical sleeve gastrectomy surgery<br />
involves only the stomach, and<br />
consists of reshaping it from a<br />
pouch into a long narrow tube<br />
and removing two-thirds of the<br />
stomach. The narrower stomach<br />
restricts food intake by allowing<br />
Vertical Sleeve<br />
only a small amount of food at<br />
one time. New connections are not made between the<br />
stomach and small intestine, and there is no re-routing<br />
of the intestine, or reduced absorption of nutrients.<br />
Meet the <strong>Bariatric</strong> Surgeons<br />
Total Surgeries Performed at <strong>Munson</strong> Medical Center<br />
Roche Featherstone, MD<br />
RNY Open RNY Lap Lap-Band VSG<br />
111 211 130 23<br />
Medical School:<br />
Wayne State University School of Medicine, Detroit, Mich.<br />
Residency: St. John Hospital, Detroit, Mich.<br />
Joined MMC Staff: 1996<br />
David Kam, MD<br />
RNY Open RNY Lap Lap-Band VSG<br />
2 74 82 8<br />
Medical School:<br />
Wayne State University School of Medicine, Detroit, Mich.<br />
Residency:<br />
Butterworth Hospital, Spectrum Health, Grand Rapids, Mich.<br />
Fellowship: University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pa.<br />
Joined MMC Staff: 2008<br />
Michael Nizzi, DO<br />
RNY Open RNY Lap Lap-Band VSG<br />
95 253 148 29<br />
Medical School: DesMoines University Osteopathic Medical<br />
Center, Des Moines, Iowa<br />
Residency: Michigan State University College of Osteopathic<br />
Medicine, East Lansing, Mich.<br />
Joined MMC Staff: 1999<br />
Steven Slikkers, MD<br />
RNY Open RNY Lap Lap-Band VSG<br />
27 203 191 19<br />
Medical School:<br />
Loma Linda School of Medicine, Loma Linda, Calif.<br />
Residency: Mayo Graduate School of Medicine, Rochester, Minn.<br />
Joined MMC Staff: 2004<br />
Referrals and Consults<br />
To refer patients for a consultation or specialized care,<br />
or for a surgical consult, please call (231) 935-8900.<br />
For 24/7 hospital transfers, please call 1-800-468-6766.<br />
A7