Medical Tourism in Developing Countries
Medical Tourism in Developing Countries Medical Tourism in Developing Countries
Inequalities in Health Care ● 181to understanding the arguments for and against linking medical tourism topublic health improvements.Tax RevenueIn many developing countries, tourism plays a crucial economic role andhas a large potential in public sector finance. 40 Indeed, through taxation,developing countries’ governments can benefit from the lucrative touristindustry by increasing their revenue, as the UNWTO clearly pointed out. 41The potential of medical tourism is even greater since the prices of tradedservices are higher and the price elasticity of demand is lower.Tax income is generated by medical and nonmedical tourism becauserelated businesses and individuals are subject to direct taxation, like in anyother economic activity. Direct financial benefit to the government comesfrom three types of taxes. Business taxes are those imposed on private sectorentities such as hospitals, clinics, and rehabilitation facilities, as well asaccommodations, gas stations, and airports (these are easy to tax since theyare highly visible and usually well regulated). Consumer taxes include thesales tax imposed on each transaction involving goods and services. Incometaxes are paid by the population employed in the medical and nonmedicaltourist sector. Together, these three types of taxes account for most revenueearned by governments.In addition to the above direct forms of taxation, governments alsobenefit indirectly as medical tourism develops and the concomitantincreased economic activity diffuses throughout the economy and providesnew sources for taxation. Moreover, increased private economic activitymight stimulate the domestic production of goods that otherwise mighthave to be provided by the public sector, leaving more revenue for otherexpenditures. Also, foreign visitors pay indirect taxes on goods and servicesthey consume. They also pay customs duties, which in some places are thegreatest source of revenue (in the Bahamas, for example, authorities collectmost of their tourist revenues through import duties). Finally, many countrieshave introduced taxes aimed specifically at the tourist sector (for example,in Tunisia, a 1 percent tax is imposed on hotel revenues 42 ).In promoting medical tourism, governments can provide tax incentivesto steer investment in a particular direction. Funding subsidies and grantsand giving tax relief can promote supply in a targeted sector. 43 For example,in an effort to develop a cardiology center where one previously didn’t exist,authorities might make capital inputs free from importation sales tax.Alternatively, they might allow the losses incurred during the first year or
182 ● Medical Tourism in Developing Countriestwo of operation to be carried forward into subsequent years, or they mightomit taxing dividends and capital gains, and so forth.At the same time, taxes can also stifle medical tourism. If they are toohigh, potential investors will not invest, and patients and tourists will goelsewhere. Taxes are part of the cost of doing business and part of the priceof the medical and travel experiences, and as such they are negatively relatedto demand. Authorities grapple with the question of tax limits by estimatingelasticity. With respect to foreign investment, a World Bank study ontourism in Africa claims that investors are willing to pay taxes since theydeem other factors to be more important (such as “appropriate and stablepolicy, legislative and regulatory frameworks for tourism” 44 ). Still, governmentstread carefully where taxes on foreign investments are concerned.Their trepidation extends to foreign tourist consumers also, as a recentdilemma faced by Mexican authorities attests. (In 2004, a proposal wasmade to levy a tariff on cruise passengers because they hardly spend anymoney on their land visits, yet their ships bring pollution and congestion.However, such a tariff would put Mexico at a disadvantage relative to otherCaribbean resorts, and so its implementation was delayed. 45 ) A further dragon tax revenue comes from competition among rival destinations thatcauses a spiraling downward pressure on prices.It is also possible that taxes have no effect on medical tourism (or publichealth) simply because they cannot be collected. In many developing countries,evasion of taxes and the corruption that accompanies it are simplypart of the economy and they keep governments from dealing with thepublic health issues. In cases like these, Janos Kornai suggested that governmentsshould simply integrate tax evasion into their thinking about budgetrevenues. 46Public ExpenditureAssuming that there is tax revenue earned from medical tourism, with noharm to future prospects of the industry, then the capacity to deal withpublic health issues exists. However, that does not mean that there will beimprovements in public health. There are two conditions that must be metfor that to occur.First, there must be a mechanism through which public expenditure onhealth can reach those who need it. In other words, government revenue mustbe channeled into appropriate government expenditure, and there must befacilities and personnel in place. The role of the Ministry of Health must beclearly defined, especially with respect to its cooperation with other governmentbodies and the private sector. The role of public health insurance must
- Page 143 and 144: 130 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 145 and 146: 132 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 147 and 148: 134 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 149 and 150: 136 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 151 and 152: This page intentionally left blank
- Page 153 and 154: 140 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 155 and 156: 142 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 157 and 158: 144 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 159 and 160: 146 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 161 and 162: 148 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 163 and 164: 150 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 165 and 166: 152 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 167 and 168: 154 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 169 and 170: 156 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 171 and 172: 158 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 173 and 174: 160 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 175 and 176: 162 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 177 and 178: 164 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 179 and 180: 166 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 181 and 182: 168 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 183 and 184: 170 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 185 and 186: 172 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 187 and 188: 174 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 189 and 190: 176 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 191 and 192: 178 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 193: 180 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 197 and 198: 184 ● Medical Tourism in Developi
- Page 199 and 200: This page intentionally left blank
- Page 201 and 202: 188 ● NotesTreatment Abroad Could
- Page 203 and 204: 190 ● Notes60. Emerging markets i
- Page 205 and 206: 192 ● Notes21. Woodward et al.,
- Page 207 and 208: 194 ● Notes57. Economist, July 31
- Page 209 and 210: 196 ● Notes25. New York Times, De
- Page 211 and 212: 198 ● Notes73. Rupa Chanda, “Tr
- Page 213 and 214: 200 ● Notes16. Peter Schofield,
- Page 215 and 216: 202 ● Notes56. Thomas Friedman, T
- Page 217 and 218: 204 ● Notes99. Chanda, “Trade i
- Page 219 and 220: 206 ● Notes21. Marvin Cetron, Fre
- Page 221 and 222: 208 ● Notes71. Chanda, “Trade i
- Page 223 and 224: 210 ● Notes116. Cited in Rashmi B
- Page 225 and 226: 212 ● Notes2. Simonetta Zarrilli,
- Page 227 and 228: 214 ● Notes30. Joint Commission I
- Page 229 and 230: 216 ● Notes65. Mattoo and Rathind
- Page 231 and 232: 218 ● Notes102. It is a problem i
- Page 233 and 234: 220 ● Notes29. Larry Solomon, “
- Page 235 and 236: This page intentionally left blank
- Page 237 and 238: 224 ● Selected BibliographyBower,
- Page 239 and 240: 226 ● Selected BibliographyJohans
- Page 241 and 242: 228 ● Selected BibliographyRoffe,
- Page 243 and 244: This page intentionally left blank
Inequalities <strong>in</strong> Health Care ● 181to understand<strong>in</strong>g the arguments for and aga<strong>in</strong>st l<strong>in</strong>k<strong>in</strong>g medical tourism topublic health improvements.Tax RevenueIn many develop<strong>in</strong>g countries, tourism plays a crucial economic role andhas a large potential <strong>in</strong> public sector f<strong>in</strong>ance. 40 Indeed, through taxation,develop<strong>in</strong>g countries’ governments can benefit from the lucrative tourist<strong>in</strong>dustry by <strong>in</strong>creas<strong>in</strong>g their revenue, as the UNWTO clearly po<strong>in</strong>ted out. 41The potential of medical tourism is even greater s<strong>in</strong>ce the prices of tradedservices are higher and the price elasticity of demand is lower.Tax <strong>in</strong>come is generated by medical and nonmedical tourism becauserelated bus<strong>in</strong>esses and <strong>in</strong>dividuals are subject to direct taxation, like <strong>in</strong> anyother economic activity. Direct f<strong>in</strong>ancial benefit to the government comesfrom three types of taxes. Bus<strong>in</strong>ess taxes are those imposed on private sectorentities such as hospitals, cl<strong>in</strong>ics, and rehabilitation facilities, as well asaccommodations, gas stations, and airports (these are easy to tax s<strong>in</strong>ce theyare highly visible and usually well regulated). Consumer taxes <strong>in</strong>clude thesales tax imposed on each transaction <strong>in</strong>volv<strong>in</strong>g goods and services. Incometaxes are paid by the population employed <strong>in</strong> the medical and nonmedicaltourist sector. Together, these three types of taxes account for most revenueearned by governments.In addition to the above direct forms of taxation, governments alsobenefit <strong>in</strong>directly as medical tourism develops and the concomitant<strong>in</strong>creased economic activity diffuses throughout the economy and providesnew sources for taxation. Moreover, <strong>in</strong>creased private economic activitymight stimulate the domestic production of goods that otherwise mighthave to be provided by the public sector, leav<strong>in</strong>g more revenue for otherexpenditures. Also, foreign visitors pay <strong>in</strong>direct taxes on goods and servicesthey consume. They also pay customs duties, which <strong>in</strong> some places are thegreatest source of revenue (<strong>in</strong> the Bahamas, for example, authorities collectmost of their tourist revenues through import duties). F<strong>in</strong>ally, many countrieshave <strong>in</strong>troduced taxes aimed specifically at the tourist sector (for example,<strong>in</strong> Tunisia, a 1 percent tax is imposed on hotel revenues 42 ).In promot<strong>in</strong>g medical tourism, governments can provide tax <strong>in</strong>centivesto steer <strong>in</strong>vestment <strong>in</strong> a particular direction. Fund<strong>in</strong>g subsidies and grantsand giv<strong>in</strong>g tax relief can promote supply <strong>in</strong> a targeted sector. 43 For example,<strong>in</strong> an effort to develop a cardiology center where one previously didn’t exist,authorities might make capital <strong>in</strong>puts free from importation sales tax.Alternatively, they might allow the losses <strong>in</strong>curred dur<strong>in</strong>g the first year or