CATEGORY: INGREDIENTSThe Next Frontier: Values-BasedCommunicationsIt has always been difficult to translate scientific informationfor the public, but new challenges—including increased adoptionof the precautionary principle, the proliferation of socialmedia, as well as the release of popular books and movies onfood-related issues—have added to the complexity, as society reactsto images and hypothetical scenarios that spur fear of theunknown, including what we don’t know about our food. 3With never-ending communications taking place in the blogosphereand online communities, we have seen an increase ininformation on all fronts, including misinformation, whichcontributes to conflicting and inconsistent information that isdifficult for consumers to interpret. When communicating withconsumers about food ingredients, the facts are important, butperhaps equally important these days is the consideration ofconsumers’ values, lifestyles and beliefs. <strong>Food</strong> is a very personalthing for consumers, and is usually connected to family andtradition. In particular, moms—who tend to do the majority ofthe grocery shopping for their households—are concerned withproviding safe and nutritious meals for their families.“...the benefits of food ingredients for food safety, nutrition and healthare often overlooked, or aren’t even considered.”aware that both natural and artificial food colors must be labeledon food packages and nearly half agree that food colorsmust be reviewed and approved by the U.S. government beforebeing added to food products. However, fewer than one in fiveconsumers thinks that most government and health authoritiessay there is no link between food colors and hyperactivity inchildren. This general lack of awareness indicates an opportunityto provide education about the roles, regulation and potentialbenefits of food ingredients.Despite concerns and negative sentiments about ingredientsand processed foods, when it comes to food and beverage purchasedecisions, taste prevails, with 87 percent of consumersranking taste as an important factor. <strong>Food</strong>s with a more healthfulnutrition profile must still taste good to make it into consumers’shopping carts. <strong>Food</strong> ingredients such as low-caloriesweeteners, fat replacers and other ingredients have helpedmake possible the availability of foods with lower fat, sugar andsodium content to improve the healthfulness of favorite foods,while maintaining the taste consumers expect. Healthfulness isincreasing in importance as a factor in consumers’ food purchasingdecisions, with 66 percent ranking it as having an impacton their decisions. In addition, these safe ingredients arecost-effective, helping keep food affordable for consumers, 79percent of whom say price is important in their food and beveragepurchases, a 15 percent increase over the past 6 years.The food label provides information on ingredients for consumers’use. Nearly half of all consumers say they look at theingredients list on food packaging when making food and beveragechoices. However, they are primarily looking for foodcomponents such as sodium, type of fat/oil and sugars. Lessthan half (44 percent) of those consumers who are looking atthe ingredients list report looking for “artificial ingredients,”and only 21 percent look for food colors. Just 18 percent areconcerned with being able to pronounce the ingredient names. 2It is important to make the public aware of the availabilityof information about food ingredients, whether it is on thelabel or through science-based information on the Internet andin doctors’ offices, or through contacting the U.S. <strong>Food</strong> andDrug Administration (FDA) or the product manufacturer, all ofwhich can provide information to help consumers make informeddecisions.<strong>Food</strong>s containing ingredients commonly consumed by childrencan create anxiety for moms, who want to protect theirchildren and themselves and may not be exposed to both sidesof the issue when reading about food ingredients in the media.For example, there has been renewed interest in the perceivedlink between consumption of artificial food colors and hyperactivityin children among media and advocacy groups, and inturn, some moms and mommy bloggers. The most recent studyto indicate a link 4 has been the basis for the voluntary removalof select artificial food colors in Europe and petitions to removeartificial food colors from the food supply in the UnitedStates, despite decades of safe use and significant limitations ofthe study identified by scientists, academics and regulatoryagencies such as the FDA and the European <strong>Food</strong> <strong>Safety</strong> Authority(EFSA). 5FDA revisits ingredient approvals as necessary and if a concernis raised, as evidenced by its recent review of all existing researchon food colors and hyperactivity, in which it upheld itsconclusion that food colors do not cause hyperactivity in children.6 In addition, FDA and EFSA found the study by Mc-Cann et al. (i.e., the Southampton study) 4 to be limited by themethodology used, as well as the combination of colors andadditives and the use of anecdotal reports from parents andteachers. 5 In addition, a study of Irish children showed thatdaily consumption of food colors did not reach the amountstested in the Southampton study and that the combination ofcolors tested would not exist in the real world. 3,7The public hears about risks and wants to take action. However,it is important to put studies and perceived risks into contextfor consumers to avoid unintended consequences, such aseliminating foods and food groups that offer important sourcesof nutrients, or taking on comparably greater food safety risks.In the case of food colors, some children who have been diagnosedwith attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder may be sensitiveto certain foods and food ingredients, including food52 F O O D S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E
CATEGORY: INGREDIENTScolors. However, this unique intolerancedoes not indicate a food safety issue andrepresents a very small portion of thepopulation. 6 Information about the specificpopulation that may be affected isimportant for consumers to be able todetermine whether there is a risk to themor their family, and if that risk outweighsother risks they may be taking on bychanging their consumption. 8Telling consumers how they can takecontrol—for example, by reading labelsand providing more fruits and vegetables—ishelpful, while also preservingchoice for those consumers who are notconcerned and do not wish to reducetheir consumption of food ingredients.Explaining the similarities and differencesbetween food ingredients andfoods that are perceived to be more familiarand therefore safer in consumers’minds can also be effective. For example,every food we eat—even those that arenaturally occurring—is made up of chemicalcompounds that determine flavor,color, texture and nutrient value. 9 Freshfruits and vegetables are not required tolist nutrition and ingredient information,but if they were, the list of chemicalscomposing them would rival foods containingadded ingredients.Is the Latest Always theGreatest?<strong>Food</strong> additives and “generally recognizedas safe” (GRAS) ingredients aresome of the most studied componentsof our food supply. However, new studiesthat dispute the larger body of researchare often deemed more crediblebecause they are the latest research onthe topic. It is important when lookingat food ingredient research to emphasizethat, while it may be tempting to viewthe most recent study as the best andmost reliable, this is not always the case.When communicating a study’s findings,it should be placed into the propercontext, including acknowledging thelimitations of the study, such as:• The study’s original purpose• Shortcomings in the study’smethodology• Ingredient amounts used• Sample size• Application of the findings to a specific subsegment of the populationIt is also important to acknowledge what the weight of the evidence tells us, and torecognize past research when a study disputes previous findings. 8For example, recent epidemiological studies showing greater overweight or obesityin consumers of low-calorie sweeteners do not demonstrate a cause-and-effect relationship.Other factors that could be contributing to the results should be considered, aswell as the original hypothesis/purpose of the study. Many well-done studies conductedhave found that consuming low-calorie sweeteners (continued on page 66)<strong>Food</strong> <strong>Safety</strong> RegulationCompliance ResourcesMETTLER TOLEDO has long been the product inspection industry leader in foodsafety education with our Safeline metal detection and x-ray inspection brand.We have launched a year-long initiative to provide you with the right training,educational materials and product solutions that will enable you to navigate the foodVisit www.mt.com/PINA-<strong>Food</strong><strong>Safety</strong>Resourcesto learn more!Contact us for more information at 800-221-2624or visit www.mt.com/piSAFELINEMetal Detection & X-ray InspectionHI-SPEEDCheckweighingCI-VISIONVision InspectionF E B R U A R Y n M A R C H 2 0 1 2 53
- Page 6 and 7:
Editor’s LetterAntibiotic Resista
- Page 8 and 9:
News BitesFDA Sued Over Nanotechnol
- Page 10 and 11:
7Entende-se, no entanto, que há ob
- Page 14 and 15:
TESTINGsites for Listeria growth, t
- Page 16:
REGULATORY REPORTBy Markus Lipp, Ph
- Page 19 and 20: REGULATORY REPORTIn a globalized fo
- Page 21 and 22: INTERNATIONAL FOOD SAFETYbe to haul
- Page 24 and 25: PACKAGINGto commercial sterility) o
- Page 26 and 27: PACKAGINGfor sale, and income to bu
- Page 28 and 29: WELCOMEWHO ATTENDS THE SUMMITSoluti
- Page 30: Providing the highestquality educat
- Page 34 and 35: ®®EXHIBITOR SHOWCASETHEATRESThe E
- Page 38 and 39: CONFERENCE SESSIONS THURSDAY, APRIL
- Page 40 and 41: EXHIBITION HALLWhere Solutions Are
- Page 42 and 43: 155 N. Pfingsten Rd., Suite 205Deer
- Page 44: FOOD SAFETY INSIDERNovel Developmen
- Page 47 and 48: Chris CelustaFood Processing Manage
- Page 49 and 50: Discover a million reasonsTotal Pla
- Page 51 and 52: control yourWOrLdwith LIGHTNING MVP
- Page 53 and 54: community, which is heralding more
- Page 55 and 56: For the first time, a vaccine can h
- Page 57 and 58: What GFI 152 has done is pave thewa
- Page 59 and 60: major species to treat or control a
- Page 61 and 62: Friday, October 21, 1977).5. Federa
- Page 63 and 64: Complex threatsA simple sandwich re
- Page 65 and 66: SPOTLIGHT: MEAT AND POULTRYUnlike r
- Page 67: Solutions for TodayPlanning for Tom
- Page 71 and 72: MORESAFETY. RESEARCH. TRENDS.MANAGE
- Page 73 and 74: MICROBIOLOGYtial sources can be det
- Page 75 and 76: MICROBIOLOGYficient to adequately c
- Page 77 and 78: MICROBIOLOGYProcess step or areaLik
- Page 79 and 80: Sample Prep InstrumentInnovaPrep LL
- Page 81 and 82: SPOTLIGHT: MEAT AND POULTRY(continu
- Page 83 and 84: Advertisers IndexAdvanced Instrumen