The Efficacy and Effectiveness of Online CBT - Jeroen Ruwaard

The Efficacy and Effectiveness of Online CBT - Jeroen Ruwaard The Efficacy and Effectiveness of Online CBT - Jeroen Ruwaard

10.07.2015 Views

88 Chapter 5. Online CBT of Bulimic Symptomstoo greatly from the intended pace.The treatment is structured into five phases and defines 24 scheduled therapistfeedback moments (phase 1-4: five feedback texts; phase 4: four feedback texts). Fulltreatment requires approximately 13 hours of therapist time.Phase 1 serves to raise client awareness and defines the goals for treatment. Clientsreceive psycho-education on causes and maintaining factors of BN, and engage in selfmonitoringand structured writing exercises to gain insight into their eating problems.Next, they are introduced to a generic set of self-control procedures designed to reducethe probability of binge eating and compensatory behavior. With therapist assistance,clients learn how to prepare a personal self-control plan by tailoring these genericprocedures to their specific situation. In the early phase of treatment, the clientsreceive psycho-education with regard to the differences in dynamics between bingeeating and compensatory behavior. While binge eating is considered to be triggeredby a loss of impulse control, compensatory behavior is considered to be a deliberate,voluntary and ’rational’ response to reduce weight increase after binge eating episodes(Lange et al., 1994). Accordingly, clients are requested to sign an agreement to quitcompensatory behavior.In phase 2, clients begin to apply their personalized self-control plan and postregular reports of successes and difficulties in executing the plan. Clients evaluate theirplan based upon their experiences and make adjustments, if needed. Self-monitoringis intensified by planning meals and daily activities ahead of time, to gain betterinsight in the pattern of binge eating and compensatory behaviors, and to learn howto prevent these behaviors. In this phase, clients are also encouraged to disclose theireating problems to a trusted person.In phase 3, cognitive restructuring techniques are introduced. Clients compose alist of short statements reflecting dysfunctional attitudes and opinions, and challengethese statements by formulating alternative interpretations. In addition, clientsconduct several behavioral experiments to challenge key attitudes and opinions inreal-life situations. They carefully prepare these experiments and anticipate onpossible outcomes. Before the client actually conducts the experiment, the therapistensures that the experiments are practicable and realistic, and have a good chance ofsuccess. As in phase 2, experiences are used to evaluate and adjust the self-control

5.2. Method 89plan. Phase 4 targets body image disturbance and self-esteem. The phase starts withan exposure exercise. Clients are asked to look at their body in the mirror, and toprovide a detailed description of their body (Delinsky & Wilson, 2006). Next, theychange perspective in a structured writing exercise. They write a supporting letterto an imaginary friend, who has similar concerns about body shape and weight. Ina third exercise, clients write down a number of traits or features that they value ina person, apart from physical appearance. They rate both themselves and someonewhom they admire on these traits, compare these ratings, and reflect on the results.Finally, they compose a list of positive self-statements from the material that theygenerated so far, which they read aloud a couple of times a day (Lange et al., 1997).In the last phase, clients finalize their self-control plan and write a personal relapseprevention plan containing self-directed instructions on how to recognize signals thatmight predict a relapse, or how to deal with relapse, should it occur. Next, clientsenter a ’test period’ of two weeks in which they have no contact with the therapist.After this period, final adjustments to the relapse prevention plan are considered andtreatment is ended.5.2 Method5.2.1 DesignThe study was a randomised controlled trial with measurements at baseline, immediatelyafter treatment, and one year after treatment (controlled trials registry:ISRCTN06477195). Through computerised permuted block randomisation (Beller,Gebski, & Keech, 2002), participants were allocated to online CBT, unsupportedbibliotherapy or a waiting-list/delayed treatment control group. This randomisationmethod guaranteed an allocation ratio of 1:1:1.5.2.2 ParticipantsParticipants were recruited from the general Dutch community between August 2006and September 2007. Since we aimed to generalize findings to a population withvarying levels of bulimic symptoms, a formal diagnosis of BN was not an inclusion

88 Chapter 5. <strong>Online</strong> <strong>CBT</strong> <strong>of</strong> Bulimic Symptomstoo greatly from the intended pace.<strong>The</strong> treatment is structured into five phases <strong>and</strong> defines 24 scheduled therapistfeedback moments (phase 1-4: five feedback texts; phase 4: four feedback texts). Fulltreatment requires approximately 13 hours <strong>of</strong> therapist time.Phase 1 serves to raise client awareness <strong>and</strong> defines the goals for treatment. Clientsreceive psycho-education on causes <strong>and</strong> maintaining factors <strong>of</strong> BN, <strong>and</strong> engage in selfmonitoring<strong>and</strong> structured writing exercises to gain insight into their eating problems.Next, they are introduced to a generic set <strong>of</strong> self-control procedures designed to reducethe probability <strong>of</strong> binge eating <strong>and</strong> compensatory behavior. With therapist assistance,clients learn how to prepare a personal self-control plan by tailoring these genericprocedures to their specific situation. In the early phase <strong>of</strong> treatment, the clientsreceive psycho-education with regard to the differences in dynamics between bingeeating <strong>and</strong> compensatory behavior. While binge eating is considered to be triggeredby a loss <strong>of</strong> impulse control, compensatory behavior is considered to be a deliberate,voluntary <strong>and</strong> ’rational’ response to reduce weight increase after binge eating episodes(Lange et al., 1994). Accordingly, clients are requested to sign an agreement to quitcompensatory behavior.In phase 2, clients begin to apply their personalized self-control plan <strong>and</strong> postregular reports <strong>of</strong> successes <strong>and</strong> difficulties in executing the plan. Clients evaluate theirplan based upon their experiences <strong>and</strong> make adjustments, if needed. Self-monitoringis intensified by planning meals <strong>and</strong> daily activities ahead <strong>of</strong> time, to gain betterinsight in the pattern <strong>of</strong> binge eating <strong>and</strong> compensatory behaviors, <strong>and</strong> to learn howto prevent these behaviors. In this phase, clients are also encouraged to disclose theireating problems to a trusted person.In phase 3, cognitive restructuring techniques are introduced. Clients compose alist <strong>of</strong> short statements reflecting dysfunctional attitudes <strong>and</strong> opinions, <strong>and</strong> challengethese statements by formulating alternative interpretations. In addition, clientsconduct several behavioral experiments to challenge key attitudes <strong>and</strong> opinions inreal-life situations. <strong>The</strong>y carefully prepare these experiments <strong>and</strong> anticipate onpossible outcomes. Before the client actually conducts the experiment, the therapistensures that the experiments are practicable <strong>and</strong> realistic, <strong>and</strong> have a good chance <strong>of</strong>success. As in phase 2, experiences are used to evaluate <strong>and</strong> adjust the self-control

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!