10.07.2015 Views

Erbil summit sends strong message to Baghdad - Kurdish Globe

Erbil summit sends strong message to Baghdad - Kurdish Globe

Erbil summit sends strong message to Baghdad - Kurdish Globe

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 2National politics or Minority politics: Decisive moments <strong>to</strong> decide<strong>Globe</strong> Edi<strong>to</strong>rialDivided in<strong>to</strong> four parts according<strong>to</strong> the imperial power interestsfollowing the First World War,Kurdistan has come <strong>to</strong> a criticaljuncture and the <strong>Kurdish</strong> nationalliberation movements have <strong>to</strong>make his<strong>to</strong>rical decisions <strong>to</strong> follloweither a policy of national poliiticsor that of minority politics.Radical political developmentsthat are unfolding in the MiddleEast and internal political crisis ofthe four states that occupy parts ofKurdistan have brought the Kurdiishnational question <strong>to</strong> an internnationalarena and provide opporttunitiesas well as challenges <strong>to</strong>the entire <strong>Kurdish</strong> movement.It is important <strong>to</strong> differentiateand underline the political persspectivesof national politics andminority politics in assessing the<strong>Kurdish</strong> position. National politticsrefers <strong>to</strong> the <strong>Kurdish</strong> questionas a national/political questionand aims <strong>to</strong> resolve this questionwithin the framework of terri<strong>to</strong>rrialand sovereign rights. In otherwords national politics suggest thesolution as the sovereign rights ofthe Kurds over the terri<strong>to</strong>ry and inturn the control and exploitationof natural resources of this terri<strong>to</strong>rryfor the benefit and utility of thepeople residing on the terri<strong>to</strong>ry.Sovereign rights over the territ<strong>to</strong>ryand possession of the naturralresources of and over the terrri<strong>to</strong>ryrefer <strong>to</strong> the formation of astate. The solution of the <strong>Kurdish</strong>question within the frameworkof national politics thus signifiesa political program and objective<strong>to</strong>ward establishment of an indeppendentKurdistan and a <strong>Kurdish</strong>state.Minority politics on the otherhand refers <strong>to</strong> the solution of the<strong>Kurdish</strong> question as a culturaland individual right of the Kurdswithin each state that control therespective part of Kurdistan. Minnoritypolitics seeks the solutionwithin the concept of democratizzationof the occupied state andwithin the legal framework of thatstate. In other words the <strong>Kurdish</strong>question is stripped from its terrri<strong>to</strong>rialcontext and reduces the<strong>Kurdish</strong> nation <strong>to</strong> a minority stattus.Majority <strong>Kurdish</strong> politicalgroups within the four parts ofKurdistan from the mid-20th centturyonwards mostly followed aminority politics course. One funddamentalreason for such minoritypolitics was the climate affordedby the Cold War period. The globaalstatus quo between the capitaliistand socialist blocs could notaccept radical changes <strong>to</strong> politicalborders in a strategic region of theMiddle East.However, the collapse of the SovvietUnion and subsequent politiccaldevelopments obliterated theCold War status quo, thus reformattionand reconstruction of the exiistingpolitical arrangements andborders particularly in the MiddleEast became more tangible.As a matter of fact, the first waveof such radical alterations and bordderchanges <strong>to</strong>ok place in formerSoviet Union itself, particularlyin the Balkan region. After all thebloody wars and internal conflicts,the Balkan question was ultimatellyresolved by the formation ofnew political entities and the reddrawingof political borders.It is crucial <strong>to</strong> note here that forthe advent of stability and democrracy,the solution for a MiddleEast that is currently facing tremmendouspolitical challenges andturmoil is a second Balkanization.Existing political orders and borddersthat served global capitalismthroughout the 20th century is nolonger in parallel with the globalcapitalist development. Balkkanizationof the Middle East isgradually becoming a prerequisitefor a proper and just solution <strong>to</strong>the chaotic and chronic problemsof the Middle East.As one of the most criticalproblems of the Middle East, the<strong>Kurdish</strong> question has <strong>to</strong> be dealtdecisively at this period. At thiscritical period that the MiddleEast is passing through, the Kurdiishpolitical ac<strong>to</strong>rs must switchdirection from minority politics<strong>to</strong> national politics. This politicalswitch has already happened inIraqi Kurdistan. By demandingfederalism and insistence on thecontrol of Kurdistan oil and gasresources the dominant politicalculture is now a national orientedpolitics. This needs <strong>to</strong> be followedby other parts of Kurdistan.Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki speaks <strong>to</strong> <strong>Kurdish</strong> leader Massud Barzani during the 2010 congress of thelatter's Kurdistan Democratic Party in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>.Currently the <strong>Kurdish</strong> politticsin north Kurdistan (Turkey)dominated by Partiya KarkeranKurdistan (PKK) and its legalarm, Peace and Democracy Party(BDP) is under the influence ofminority politics. This presentsa serious challenge <strong>to</strong> the entire<strong>Kurdish</strong> national movement. Theminority politics of PKK alsoreflects itself in Syrian Kurdisttan.The PKK’s affiliated group,Democratic Union Party (PYD),contrary <strong>to</strong> other <strong>Kurdish</strong> organizzationsis collaborating with theSyrian regime and insists on theresolution of the <strong>Kurdish</strong> nationalquestion within the paradigm ofcultural and individual rights.Because of the political turmoilin Syria and potential collapseof the Syrian regime, the Kurdiishnational question in SyrianKurdistan assumed the utmost impportancefor the <strong>Kurdish</strong> nationalmovement. It seems that amongthe <strong>Kurdish</strong> political groups thereis a lack of united position or nattionalstrategy.The conglomeration of variousSyrian Kurds under the name of<strong>Kurdish</strong> National Council (KNC)initially demanded federal rightsin a post-Assad Syria. The dominnantSyrian opposition group,Syrian National Council (SNC),denounced this right and suggesteedthat the Kurds be content withsome basic cultural and individualrights. The way the SNC accommmodatesthe <strong>Kurdish</strong> question isexactly what was earlier outlinedabout minority politics.KNC should not step back fromtheir demand of federalism. Theissue cannot be postponed <strong>to</strong> apost-Assad period. According <strong>to</strong>some <strong>Kurdish</strong> online news outllets,the KNC in a meeting in Qammishlu,a <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>to</strong>wn in SyrianKurdistan, has prepared <strong>to</strong> stepdown from their demand of federaalism.If this is true it indicates aworrying development and a hugesetback for the <strong>Kurdish</strong> nationaliism.Should the Syrian Kurds giveup their demand now at such aninfant stage, how they are going<strong>to</strong> get their national rights afterAssad’s collapse?Syrian <strong>Kurdish</strong> political organizzationsand ac<strong>to</strong>rs should differeentiatethe notion of national politticsfrom that of minority politics.The SNC position regarding <strong>to</strong>the <strong>Kurdish</strong> question in Syria isnot far from that of Baathist Arabnationalism. The opportunitythat the Syrian Kurds have <strong>to</strong>dayshould not be wasted with pettypolitics.Despite all the developmentsin four parts of Kurdistan themomentum now lies in southernKurdistan. The bold and nationalorientedpolicy and strategy of theKurdistan President should conttinuewithout any compromise.The Maliki government should notbe allowed <strong>to</strong> run until its term<<strong>strong</strong>>sends</<strong>strong</strong>> in 2014 as suggested by inffluentialShiite leader, MuqtaderSadr. The deadline set by MasssoudBarzani of September for areal solution should be observedand implemented. Either the Iraqipolitical ac<strong>to</strong>rs should muster atangible solution <strong>to</strong> resolve thepending issues between <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> and<strong>Baghdad</strong> according <strong>to</strong> the Iraqiconstitution or the Kurds shouldgo for referendum <strong>to</strong> decide theirown destiny.Time is running short and the reggionalconflicts continue <strong>to</strong> gathermomentum. The <strong>Kurdish</strong> politicalac<strong>to</strong>rs should be able <strong>to</strong> developconcrete national/political strateegyand put it in<strong>to</strong> effect withoutany delay.Any failure <strong>to</strong> respond <strong>to</strong> theconditions and challenges of thetime will mean the Kurds cannotbreak their century long chains.The path <strong>to</strong>wards a better future isfor the Kurds <strong>to</strong> differentiate nattionalpolitics from minority politticsand act accordingly in theirnational interest no matter whatthe challenges may be.Azad AminGLOBE PHOTO/Safin HamedWeekly paper printed in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>First published in 2005www.kurdishglobe.netinfo.kurdishglobe@gmail.comAddress:<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>, Bakhtiyari QuarterEXECUTIVE EDITORJawad QadirEDITORAzad Aminazad.kurdishglobe@gmail.comSenior U.S. Edi<strong>to</strong>rSuzanne DeRouensuzi.kurdishglobe@yahoo.comSenior U.K. Edi<strong>to</strong>rBashdar Pusho Ismaeelbashdar@hotmail.comAko Muhammed+964 750 4661936ako.kurdishglobe@gmail.comAiyob Mawloodi+964 750 4776905aiyob.kurdishglobe@gmail.comQassim Khidhir+964 750 4823081qassim.kurdishglobe@gmail.comSTAFF WRITERSSazan M. Mandalawisazan.kurdishglobe@gmail.comZakaria Muhammed+964 750 475 3897zakaria.kurdishglobe@gmail.comRawaz Koyee+964 750 1163296rawaz26.kurdishglobe@gmail.comARTS EDITORDiyaco Qayoumy +964 750 4036252diyaco.kurdishglobe@gmail.comAdvertisementFor information and prices of ad spots, please contact<strong>Globe</strong>’s Advertisement section: Rizgar Yahyarizgar.kurdishglobe@gmail.comCell: +964 750 4055888You can also check prices and packages by loggingon <strong>to</strong>: kurdishglobe.net/adSubscriptionThe <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> can be delivered <strong>to</strong> your office orhome address, whether in Kurdistan or abroad.To subscribe: Please contact the <strong>Globe</strong> DistributionSection: Rauf Aspindarairauf.kurdishglobe@gmail.com+964 750 4497976You can also subscribe by logging on<strong>to</strong>:kurdishglobe.net/subscription


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 4Children go unobservedafter parents divorceFathers complain they are not allowed adequatevisitation rights with their childrenRegion’s civilstatus law regardingchild cus<strong>to</strong>dyand parentalvisiting rightsunder scrutiny.Rahim Mohammed, 35,claims that perjury andinterference by relattiveswas the cause forhis not having seen his4-year-old son since hisestranged wife, Sana, leftwithout filing for divorce."It has been two years!"he exclaimed, becomiingemotional about thenight he separated fromhis family.He works as a barber ina small shop and runs asandwich shop at nightsin Bnaslawa, an <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>suburb. Mohammed wasyoung when his familyimmigrated <strong>to</strong> Iran. Hewas married in an Iraniancourt. Since his family>sreturn from Iran in 2009,he has lived in Bnaslawwa.Mainly because ofMohammed>s low inccome,sisters and brotheersof his estranged wife,Sana, insist their sisterget divorced and staynear them in Khanaqin,both spouses’ home<strong>to</strong>wn."I want my family back,"said Mohammed, blamiingthe Khanaqin courtfor cheating him withtestimonies by two witnnesseswho he says perjjuredthemselves withfalse testimony that Mohhammadhad abandonedhis family. Thus, the caseremains suspended."I might not knowhim…he must be growiingand changing a lot,"said Mohammed of hisson. His estranged wife>sbrothers <strong>to</strong>ld him that hebetter not visit his son,said Mohammed, whofeels helpless becausehis case is in Khanaqin,which is currently outssideKurdistan Region’slegal authority.Inside the region, thesituation is different. Theparent with cus<strong>to</strong>dy mus<strong>to</strong>bey rules that allow forthe noncus<strong>to</strong>dial parent <strong>to</strong>visit his or her children.However, the process isquestioned, mostly by fatthers,because of the shorttime periods of meetingsand lack of an observattionsystem <strong>to</strong> reveal thepsychological and econnomicstatus of childrenafter divorce.Since his divorce ayear ago, Ahmed KhalidNajm, 34, is allowed byhis employer a few hourson two days a month <strong>to</strong>leave his work and visithis 2-year-old son. Thissame rule applies <strong>to</strong> 160other divorced parents in<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>. But the most recentvisitation was spoiled forNajm because his childwas ill and cried for 30minutes. "All <strong>to</strong>ys I tried<strong>to</strong> use were broken; thisis not fair. How can Ishow my paternal feeliingsthis way?" he said,demanding cus<strong>to</strong>dy forat least one complete dayper month.Children legally gowith their mothers postdivorce,except whenthe mother refuses. Fattherscan see or accomppanytheir children whenthe mother agrees, butwhen the mother rejectsthe visitation, the courtinterferes based on thefather>s demands <strong>to</strong> arrrangeregular meetings.The government doesn’thave a place <strong>to</strong> hold thesessions; instead, <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>’sexecutive court uses itsown yard <strong>to</strong> strictly obsserve70 cases, fearingquarrels between the divvorcedcouples.The Social Institute ofthe Kurdistan Women’sUnion, an NGO linked <strong>to</strong>the Kurdistan DemocraticParty, arranges sessionsfor some 91 other friendlliercases. The instituteopened its department ofBroken Family>s ChildCare in March 2011 with26 cases at the time. Caseeshave multiplied nearlyfour times since. Theunion general secretary,Viyan Haji, said they aredoing work that is thegovernment>s duty. "Weinitiated this project aswe noticed sessions innarrow spaces inside thecourt>s rooms or gardden,"she explained. “Allwe do is <strong>to</strong> serve the happpinessof the family andbuilding healthy individuualsin society."The union set aside aceremony hall for sesssions.The big room issupplied with six sets oftables and chairs as wellas a number of slidingboards and car <strong>to</strong>ys thatare mostly broken. Thesecretary said that theyare working on buildingsunshades in their garden<strong>to</strong> create "more comfortaable"sitting spaces.A small staff of threeresearchers looks after all91 cases at the institute.Pishko Jabari, a social ressearcherand head of thesession department, saidthey used <strong>to</strong> study thechildren>s conditions eveeryweek in the beginningmonths when their staffincluded six researchers.Now the cases have inccreasedand the staff hasbeen reduced, he said,resulting in a cutback oftime spent on each case.Narmin Jaff was thelone researcher observing18 sessions in one day ona Sunday. "Sundays arealways like this," she noteed.But on most days theysee no more than five orsix cases. Court employeeesand researchers arepresent only during a fewhours of the meeting, andcases are never observedafter regular meetings.Cus<strong>to</strong>dial parent ArazuHassan>s insistence onkeeping her four schoolagedchildren caused her"life difficulties" sinceshe is unemployed andher only income is IQD320,000, paid by herex-husband, as the legalfamily expense.After divorce, the cour<strong>to</strong>bliges one-fifth of afather>s monthly income<strong>to</strong> be given <strong>to</strong> childrenin the mother>s cus<strong>to</strong>dy.Fathers must also payfor travel expenditure forboth sides during meetiings.Father of 5-year-oldNasim, Sanar Aali, hasno economic worriesA court employee marks name of a visi<strong>to</strong>r woman out of Kurdistan Women Union office, erbil.but cannot know enoughabout his daughter in amere two hours. Oncemeeting his daughter aftertwo missed sessions, Aalifound a scar on Nasim>sleg while putting her in<strong>to</strong>a new dress he bought herfrom his <strong>to</strong>wn in Soran.Another time, Nassimcollected every cellphone she could findat her mother>s houseand deposited them allin the <strong>to</strong>ilet, Aali said."She had asked <strong>to</strong> callme but her request wasrejected; this is how sheacted out. I never receivecalls from her." Aali alsocondemned the meeting’slimits and said that Nassimneeds also <strong>to</strong> meether paternal relatives, notjust the father.<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> executive judgeAhmed Farzi agreed thatthe rules are cruel, buttheir "authority is only<strong>to</strong> fulfill" what the courtsdecide on in divorce triaals."Like in Britain,fathers should have theright <strong>to</strong> live with theirkids for days," Farzi said,reminding that he hadseveral times asked expperts<strong>to</strong> be employed <strong>to</strong>watch the children andfor a special building <strong>to</strong>be built for the sessions.Kurdistan Parliament isworking <strong>to</strong> amend an itemof the region>s civil stattuslaw relative <strong>to</strong> parenttalcus<strong>to</strong>dy. The bill commmitsboth parents <strong>to</strong> takeresponsibility for raisingand educating the childuntil he turns 18; the pareentwithout cus<strong>to</strong>dy cantake the child home oncea month for no less than24 hours. The child couldalso go <strong>to</strong> the other homewhenever he/she wants<strong>to</strong>. But the bill still lacksan item obliging any sor<strong>to</strong>f observation for childdrenafter divorce.Ako Muhammed<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>ako.kurdishglobe@gmail.comGLOBE PHOTO/Ako Muhammed


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 5Dokan’s fish fight for their survivalKurdistan’s rivers quickly emptying out in part due <strong>to</strong> illegal fishingTourists count forthe majority of fishconsumers in DokanJust as springtime arrrived—theseason whenfish reproduce--the goveernmentbanned fishingthroughout Kurdistan Reggionfrom April 1 till June15.Najad Sabir, a fish venddoron Dokan’s mainstreet between <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> andSuleimaniya, argues thatrivers and lakes. To comppoundthat, the numberof domestic fish is verylow compared <strong>to</strong> marketdemand. According <strong>to</strong>Sabir, 80 percent of theRegion’s fish is importedfrom neighboring counttries,especially Iran andTurkey. “Our domesticfish resources are about10 percent <strong>to</strong> 15 percent,and the remaining 5 perccentcomes from southernIraq,” explained Sabir.Despite Kurdistan’s limi-Sabir. “Although the goveernmentpunishes thosewho violate the laws andregulations, still there areofficials and influentialpeople who harm the fishand other fishermen. Thereare people who hunt fishwith guns in the [Dokan]dam, where hunting is prohhibited.”Karim and Sabir bothargued that many huntershave been fined for violattions;the maximum finewas about three millionsamong fish hunters in Dokkan,according <strong>to</strong> Sabir, isdividing the dam’s waterin<strong>to</strong> terri<strong>to</strong>ries among fisheermen,by which hunterswill gain exclusive fishingrights in a specific area ofthe water.“The dam is a publicproperty and the fish liviingin the water belong <strong>to</strong>the whole region, but onlya number of people havemonopolized this resourceand they make unbelievaablemoney out of this,”fish wealth in the region.Also posing a threat <strong>to</strong>fish in Dokan Dam andelsewhere in Kurdistanis the fish eggs incubatedin<strong>to</strong> the water by the goveernment.Abdulla arguesthat these eggs grow in<strong>to</strong>two fish species that eatthe eggs of the other fishnaturally living in the watter,something that significcantlyharms the reproducttionof the good species offish.Considering the state ofpassing by. “For instance,we sell the largest amoun<strong>to</strong>f fish during Fridays andpicnic seasons, when largeestnumber of <strong>to</strong>urists andtravelers are around.”“On a summer Friday, wewould sell 300-400 kilosof fish,” argued Abdullaas a number of cus<strong>to</strong>mersexamined the dozen diffferenttypes of fish showccasedin front of his shopon the street. “Generallyfish market is higher insummer than winter dueGLOBE PHOTO/Aiyob MawloodiA traveler buying fish at Najat Sabir's shop in Dokan, north of Suleimaniya, March 16, 2012.the timing is not ideal.“In fact, the ban shouldhave been applied fromMay 1 until July 15,” hesaid while cleaning fishcus<strong>to</strong>mers. “This is the repproductionseason--not theone set by the government.I have seen fish in mid-July still not laying eggs.”Sabir <strong>to</strong>ld the <strong>Globe</strong> thatthose making decisionsin the government are notspecialized in this fieldand sometimes make uninfformeddecisions.Lacking a sea, Kurdisttan’sfish live only in theited fish resources andthe regulations set by theKurdistan Regional Goveernment’sauthorities <strong>to</strong>protect these resources,the Region’s fish still facethreats. According <strong>to</strong> AbddulrahmanKarim, anotherfish vendor, fishermenwith influence and power,or those who are related<strong>to</strong> officials in one way oranother, are the biggestthreat, as they are“The majority of theviolations are made bythe officials,” explainedIraqi Dinars (approximmatelyUS$2,500). Karim,however, believes that thefines are <strong>to</strong>o small for thosewho are already extremelywealthy and powerful andearn “10 times more thanthis” by fishing.Taking this in<strong>to</strong> consideeration,fish retailers inDokan prefer penalties beyyondmere financial fines.Witnesses claim that themajority of illegal fishingoccurred during the springban period.Another phenomenonsaid Aras Abdulla, a fishvendor since 1998. “Withooutany legal ownershipdocuments, those peopleuse various illegal waysfor fishing in their “excclusiveterri<strong>to</strong>ry” such aselectric shock, dynamiteor nets.”While claiming that thereis no control over this act,Abdulla argues that thegovernment should put anend <strong>to</strong> it and rent fishingterri<strong>to</strong>ries <strong>to</strong> fishermen;they should then use therevenues <strong>to</strong> improve thefishing in the Region, thedemand for fish has beenon a steady increase in thepast few years. Thanks <strong>to</strong>its location on the mainroad connecting <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> andSuleimaniya and the <strong>to</strong>uriistattractions around it,Dokan is always crowdedwith local and foreign<strong>to</strong>urists attracted <strong>to</strong> thoussandsof fish showcasedon the sides of the street indozens of shops.As Karim said, the majjorityof their cus<strong>to</strong>mersare <strong>to</strong>urists and travelers<strong>to</strong> huge number of <strong>to</strong>uristscoming from inside andoutside the region.”Although fish prices arevery high—with the pricesof some fish exceeding25,000 <strong>to</strong> 30,000 IraqiDinars, (approximatelyUS$20 <strong>to</strong> US$25) per killogram,the fish market remmainshot in Dokan.Aiyob Mawloodi<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>aiyob.kurdishglobe@gmail.com


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 6Dollar price fluctuations push prices upPrice of U.S. dollar up from 1190 Iraqi dinars <strong>to</strong> 1280 Iraqi dinars since MarchThe dollar exchangerate has risensignificantly in Iraqand Kurdistanrecently,due <strong>to</strong> scarcity ofU.S. dollarson the market.GLOBE PHOTO/Safin HamedFor the past week, the excchangemarket in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> hasbeen overcrowded--evenat lunchtime--as tradersall seek USD while pricesfluctuate on an hourly bassis.Although the exchangerate at the Central Bankof Iraq (CBI) is still 1179IQD:1 USD, according<strong>to</strong> the owner of KurdistanMoney Exchange, SiamandMawlood, the amount ofdollars injected in<strong>to</strong> themarket every day is notsufficient for the volumeof trade happening in themarkets throughout Iraq.“Therefore, the official valuueof U.S. dollars and theactual market value have10,000 ID difference [pereach US$100],” arguedMawlood.According <strong>to</strong> Mawlood,in the past the CBI used<strong>to</strong> sell 400 <strong>to</strong> 500 millionUSD every day, but thisnumber has fallen <strong>to</strong> only50 million USD.“Now the CBI has setnew regulations for selliingUSD, and the buyersshould disclose the purpposeof buying dollars andshould have proof for this;otherwise, they cannot buyfrom the CBI,” Mawloodiexplained <strong>to</strong> the <strong>Globe</strong>.Apparently the new procceduresby the CBI areaimed at preventing dollarsfrom channeling in<strong>to</strong> thehands of terrorist groups,but Mawlood describes thisA money trader counts US Dollar notes in Sheikhall market in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> Down<strong>to</strong>wn in January 19, 2012.as an effort <strong>to</strong> sell it unoffficially<strong>to</strong> some traders ata higher price and make acouple of million dollars aday out of that.The impact of the excchangerate fluctuationsdoes not stay inside theexchange market, but asKurdistan is virtually impportingeverything fromabroad, the <strong>Kurdish</strong> econoomyhas become dollar-deppendent.Hence, as dollar pricesfluctuate, the cost of doiingbusiness fluctuatesproportionately. Cross-borddertraders have <strong>to</strong> changetheir profits in<strong>to</strong> dollars <strong>to</strong>pay their international supppliers.The volume of thistrade, according <strong>to</strong> Mawllood,reaches 25 milliondollars per day only at the<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> exchange market.Aiyob Maghdid, a foodand cleaning materialwholesaler at the SheikhalllaMarket in down<strong>to</strong>wn<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>, has visited the excchangemarket for manyyears now. He buys hisproducts from abroad withdollars, and now as the dolllarprice has increased, hehas <strong>to</strong> pay more dinars <strong>to</strong>buy the dollar amounts heneeds <strong>to</strong> pay his suppliers.“Whenever dollar valueincreases, we will increaseour prices as well,” admitsMaghdid. Although by thishe is trying <strong>to</strong> avoid losses,“the higher our prices beccome,the emptier my shopwill become.”A returning client ofMaghdid breaks the silenceof his shop, but hearing thenew “shocking” prices, heimmediately decides <strong>to</strong> buyless stuff.Maghdid’s client, who isa retailer, says that everyitem now costs 250 <strong>to</strong> 500dinars more than before,and when cus<strong>to</strong>mers realiizethat, they think they arebeing misused and leavethe shops while complainiing.Maghdid Mohammed, anootherretailer at SheikhallaMarket, believes that inaddition <strong>to</strong> dollar prices,there is another fac<strong>to</strong>r behhindthe price increases.“Traders have bought someof their products at a lowerprice before the exchangerate fluctuations, but someare selling them at <strong>to</strong>day’sprices,” explains Maghdid.As buyers continue <strong>to</strong>complain, s<strong>to</strong>re owneerslike Saman Salim, aclothes seller at the NishtimmanMarket, has poured allhis clothes on the floor andis trying <strong>to</strong> change the dessignof his shop. “I haven’tsold anything since yesterdday,”a bored Salim said.“I have nothing <strong>to</strong> do here;that is why I want <strong>to</strong> busymyself with redesigningthe s<strong>to</strong>re.” He believes thatIraqi Prime Minister Nurial-Maliki is trying <strong>to</strong> createproblems for Kurdistan,but it seems that without a<strong>strong</strong> domestic productionsec<strong>to</strong>r, Salim’s job and thewhole market will stay vulnnerable<strong>to</strong> such shocks.Mountain vegetable market growsWalking around downt<strong>to</strong>wnSoran on the lateafternoons, it’s easy <strong>to</strong>find most of the commonspring mountain vegetabbles,which are gatheredfrom the surroundingmountains by local peopple,being sold in smallgrocery shops or on thestreet.A large number of loccalsset out <strong>to</strong> mountainoousareas in Balakayaty,Mergasoor and Sidakanearly in the mornings <strong>to</strong>collect the vegetablesand return <strong>to</strong> Soran latein the afternoon <strong>to</strong> sellthem and earn their dailylivelihood.Hayat Mustafa, a midddle-agedwoman fromSidakan, said, “We sellthe vegetables at a lowprice and earn a modestliving. As spring arrives,we go <strong>to</strong> the mountainsat 5 a.m. and return at 7p.m. for 45 days, collectiingany kind of ediblevegetables; we bring ourharvest every other day<strong>to</strong> Soran <strong>to</strong> sell it.”According <strong>to</strong> her, eachperson earns around20,000 <strong>to</strong> 30,000 IraqiDinars (approximatelyUS$18 <strong>to</strong> US$25).Haidar Khurshid, 45,who was selling mounttainvegetables in a Soranmarket, shouted, “Comehere; we have all mounttainvegetables, especciallymedicine for yours<strong>to</strong>mach.” He’s been doiingthis for 10 years, hesaid. “All natural mounttainvegetables are goodfor the health,” saidKhurshid. “Thank Godthis year we had plentyof rain, the spring seasonwas longer and hence themarket for mountain vegeetablesis very good.”In the heart of Soran’smarket, Uncle Siddiq hasvirtually all mountainvegetables available inthe area; he sells each ata different price.“I no longer have theenergy <strong>to</strong> do any job or<strong>to</strong> go <strong>to</strong> the mountains,”Uncle Siddiq <strong>to</strong>ld the<strong>Globe</strong> as he organized hisvegetables. “As springarrives I call some peopplein Balakayati and askthem <strong>to</strong> bring me thesemountain vegetables andbuy them at a reasonableprice.”Uncle Siddiq says thathe receives a pickup fullof vegetables every dayand “if I make 500 Dinnars[approximately 40cents] profit per each killogram,”he sells them.


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 7<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> doc<strong>to</strong>r treats bed-wetting <strong>to</strong>ddlersRetired doc<strong>to</strong>r making headway on an issue he takes personallyA form of Chineseelectro-puncturelooks promisingin alleviatingbed-wettingissues often seenin childhood.GLOBE PHOTO/Ako MuhammedDr. Tareq Anwer Wali shows his special medic apparatus at his office in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>.In the 1980s, psychologgistand neurologist Dr.Tareq Anwar Wali beganresearching nontraditionaltreatments for childrenwho wet their beds atnight. The main drivingforce behind his researchwas that his own child suffferedfrom the same issue.The direction of Dr. Walli’sresearch changed conssiderablyin the mid 1990swhen he met Dr. SarbastKakayee at an <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> hosppital.Dr. Kakayee treatedsuch children with electricvibrations.Dr. Kakayee passedaway, leaving Dr. Tareqsorry that he never learnedenough from his collleague.But Dr. Tareq nowpractices a Chinese scieencecalled electro-punctture,which consists ofapplying low electric vibbrations<strong>to</strong> affected partsof the body.Dr. Tareq graduated fromMosul University MedicalCollege in 1970. He wasthe first <strong>to</strong> supply <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>’smain hospital with a muscclelever measuring apparratus,he claimed. And hewas one of a group of doct<strong>to</strong>rs<strong>to</strong> establish the firstintensive care unit in thesame hospital.Beginning his practicewith his new knowleedgewas expensive. "Atthat time the <strong>to</strong>ol costUS$1,700 and I was notable <strong>to</strong> afford it," he stated.So he and a friend whowas an electronics expertinvented an apparatususing parts of a radio recceiverthat produced lowlevelelectric vibrations."The <strong>to</strong>ol was covered ina can….I used it for manyyears." His invention no<strong>to</strong>nly resulted in positivetreatment of bedwettingcases, but also in removiingpain in certain parts ofthe body.He no longer utilizes thehandmade <strong>to</strong>ol. Instead,he now uses two white appparatuses;each is as big asa large-size cellphone andconnected <strong>to</strong> wires. Anyof these <strong>to</strong>ols, which arebasically used for measuriingmuscle lever, now caneasily be found in the markketand cost only US$170.Dr. Tareq said that childdrenwet their bed at nightdue <strong>to</strong> either psychologiccalor physical issued withthe nervous system or inthe spine – but he saidpsychological issues aremost common.Applying electric vibrattion<strong>to</strong> the bladder andother body parts can s<strong>to</strong>pbedwetting, promised Dr.Tareq, noting that at leastthree sessions are needed."Even if this method doesnot s<strong>to</strong>p the problem,there are no negative sideeffects," he assured. Theelectric vibration tightenscells and activates bloodcirculation.Regarding medications<strong>to</strong> s<strong>to</strong>p bed-wetting, Dr.Tareq said, "Medicationhasn’t become a treatmentfor this disease. They arelike headache pills." Hesuggested vitamins, calcciumor honey <strong>to</strong> alleviatebed-wetting.Dr. Tareq retired in 2007and soon after closed hisprivate clinic. But he neverquite s<strong>to</strong>pped working all<strong>to</strong>gether. "I would like <strong>to</strong>continue serving people,"he said. He now receivespatients for three hours inthe evening at the Zanyaripublic clinic in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>.He said he has treatednumerous children forbed-wetting, but his arcchivesvanished after heclosed his clinic so he hasno records.Still, he claims <strong>to</strong> be the"only doc<strong>to</strong>r in Iraq whouses this treatment” and isready <strong>to</strong> teach other doct<strong>to</strong>rshis methods.He would like <strong>to</strong> attendelectro-puncturing courseesin China, but he alsorealizes it will be difficult<strong>to</strong> make such a wish cometrue. He also said regionalhealth authorities nevertried <strong>to</strong> assist him with hisinvention.American teachers of Media Private School leave SuleimaniyaNalia TV interview ratchets up American teachers’ fears at Media Private SchoolAfter the shootingof an Americanteacher in theclassroom lastmonth, Americanteachers at thisprivate school opt<strong>to</strong> leave for good.All American teachersworking at the MediaPrivate School have leftSuleimaniya, and parentsof the students are conccernedabout their childdren’sstudies. The eventfollows the death of anAmerican teacher lastmonth by the hands of astudent who also killedhimself.Kamal Noori Gharib,the direc<strong>to</strong>r of SuleimmaniyaEducation, says,“it is correct that the deppartureof those teachershas created a gap, but wehave solved this issueand classes continue normmallyin the school.”The school has still notreturned <strong>to</strong> normal sincethe deaths last month,and on April 20. One ofthe local teachers of theschool <strong>to</strong>ld the <strong>Globe</strong> onthe condition of anonymiitythat the Americanteachers were lecturing atthe school with fear thatanother such event mighthappen again. “The fearincreased after the NalliaTV interview withthe parents of the studdentwho committed thecrime,” said the teacher.Parents of other studentswarned that instead ofcalming the situation, thestatements by the criminnal’sstudent who killedthe teacher worsened thesituation.Nihayat Ali, the motherof one of the students ofthe school, <strong>to</strong>ld the <strong>Globe</strong>that after the incident,students began attendingclasses intermittently;parents requested thatthis problem be solvedso that students’ studiesdon’t suffer.Gharib admits thatthere is a problem in theschool. “The reappearaanceof the issue and thedecision of the Americanteachers <strong>to</strong> leave cameafter some statements bythe parent of the criminnalstudent in an NRTchannel interview, whichraised concern among theAmerican teachers.”In an interview withNRT two weeks ago, theparents of the student argguedthat the Americanteachers at the schoolwere acting more likeChristian missionariesmaking propaganda forthe Christian religionamong the students,something that createdsensitivity among studdentsand resulted in viollence.Gharib stated that theyhave assigned replacemmentteachers and allclasses will resume thisweek.There are currently dozeensof private schools inKurdistan, which someexperts believe havefailed <strong>to</strong> perform theiroriginal duties. KameranKhalid, an educationalexpert, argues that due <strong>to</strong>the large number of privvateschools, moni<strong>to</strong>ringtheir performances hasbecome more difficult. “Ibelieve it is now time <strong>to</strong>review all these foreignprivate schools,” arguesKhalid.Gharib agrees with theidea that the contractsof the private schoolsshould be revised. “Thereare plans <strong>to</strong> organize aconference this summer<strong>to</strong> revise all the contractsthat the Ministry of Educcationhas signed withprivate schools,” saidGharib. “Preparationsfor the conference havealready started.”


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 8Bands lose business <strong>to</strong> disc jockeysDJs rock out wedding parties and other celebra<strong>to</strong>ry eventsPeople are not sokeen on hiringbands anymore asDJs cost less anddeliver a largervariety of music.GLOBE PHOTO Zakaria MuhammedThis picture shows a singer and a music band during a party.In the 1990s, hiring musicbands for wedding partieswas the grooms’ responssibility.Live concerts,musical instruments andsongs were very popularamong <strong>Kurdish</strong> people.But <strong>to</strong>day, when someoonewants <strong>to</strong> arrange awedding, engagement,birthday or even an annniversaryparty in Kurdiistan,he hires a discjockey.A disc jockey, alsoknown as a DJ, selectsand plays recorded musicfor an audience. Originnally,"disc" referred <strong>to</strong> aphonographic record. Todday,the term includes allforms of music playback,no matter the medium.Although there are seveeraltypes of disc jockeys,club DJs who select andplay music in nightclubsand at wedding partiesor raves are the mostcommon in Kurdistan.Hall direc<strong>to</strong>rs used DJsin ceremonies in Kurdiistana few years agowhere wedding partieswere held, and the trendquickly flourished. Altthoughmost of the wedddinghalls and clubs havetheir own DJs, peoplesometimes prefer <strong>to</strong> hiresomeone in the marketwhere all DJ offices arelocated.Amanj Askander Qader,DG Hawler Office direct<strong>to</strong>r,said, "Our business isvery good as people nowaadaysuse DJs for wedddingparties. Our job isvery simple. The deviceswe use are a recorder anda computer with four bigmicrophones. We play allkinds of music and songsdepending on the typesof the parties."Since <strong>Kurdish</strong> peopleusually dance duringwedding parties, Qadersaid the DJs play musicthat suits dancing. Kurdiishdance is a group oftraditional handholdingdances similar <strong>to</strong> thosefrom the Balkans, Lebannonand Iraq. It is a formof round dancing, witha single or a couple ofdancers often added <strong>to</strong>the center of the dancingcircle.Asked why people prefferDJs for parties inssteadof bands with singeers,Qader said, "Hiringa simple music band forthree hours costs morethan $500. But $100 isenough for hiring a DJfor the same purposeand time. A music bandhas usually one singer <strong>to</strong>sing, but a DJ can playany music and select anysongs by any singer.”There are only threemusic band offices in<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>>s Saidwa Marketwhere some 30 musicbands used <strong>to</strong> work. TahaHaji, who started singingin 1990, still has an officeand sings in wedding partties.Haji said, "We haveno job because of DJs;until five years ago myband had a party everyday; nowadays we onlyhave it once a week."Another thing weakeniingthe music business,according <strong>to</strong> Haji, is thatpeople nowadays are notgetting married like befforedue <strong>to</strong> financial isssues.Although many musicbands closed their officesin the past five years beccauseof weak business,Nuri Garmiyani, a wellknown<strong>Kurdish</strong> singer,doesn>t subscribe <strong>to</strong> theview that DJs have afffectedsingers> business."I have been in manycountries and I have notticedthat DJs and bandsare available everywwhere.Each one practticeshis or her job. Thesingers who say DJs afffectedtheir business arenot real singers," notedGarmiyani.Garmiyani disbandedhis band and quit singiingat wedding parties afew years ago because ofthe haphazard increase ofsingers in Kurdistan. Heruns a studio and sings inspecial concerts and TVprograms. "People stillask me <strong>to</strong> go and sing intheir wedding parties butI won>t go. I am sure thereal singers can>t be afffectedby DJs," he conccluded.Zakaria Muhammed<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>zakaria.kurdishglobe@gmail.com<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> ceremony honors Syrian <strong>Kurdish</strong> artistsThe Syrian <strong>Kurdish</strong> YouthMovement and the GeladtBadrakhan Associationin <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> <strong>to</strong>day organizeda ceremony in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> <strong>to</strong>honor artists Saeed Kabaareand Mahmoud Azizfor their work.Member of the youthmovement Sipan Zubairsaid it was decided <strong>to</strong>hold the ceremony on theoccasion of <strong>Kurdish</strong> pressday in Kabare's house <strong>to</strong>make it a folkloric event."The other reason thatmade us evaluate these[artists] is that we foundin our society that theimportant <strong>Kurdish</strong> artiistsare not honored andno one cares for themexcept after their death,for example the great artiistMohammed Shekhuwhere he was honoredafter his death," addedZubair.Kabare said: "This honooris very important forme especially because nogreat importance is given<strong>to</strong> the <strong>Kurdish</strong> artists. Irespect the <strong>Kurdish</strong> peoppleand respect the youngpeople who honored meand thank them for theirefforts."On the other side, theKurds will not have acomplete state until theyhave their technical insstitutesand universities.I fought for my nationalissue in southern Kurdiistan.I was a memberof the Peshmarga and anartist <strong>to</strong>o and I will workuntil the last day for the<strong>Kurdish</strong> issue in all partsof Kurdistan. The Kurdiishmovement in Syriais uniting and working<strong>to</strong>gether <strong>to</strong> resolve the<strong>Kurdish</strong> issue in Syria."The ceremony was atttendedby Silva Jakrakoouhin,the granddaughterof the great poet Jakrakoouhin,in addition <strong>to</strong>members of the youthmovement, members ofthe Geladt BadrakhanAssociation, <strong>Kurdish</strong>political figures and SyriianKurds resident in theregion. The artists pressentedfolk and nationalsongs.AKnews


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 9Kirkuk Citadel remains in state of ruinPeople “turn their backs” on the archaeological treasureThe citadel fallsin<strong>to</strong> furtherdisrepair after itsdestruction in 1991.GLOBE PHOTO/Aiyob MawloodiThis pho<strong>to</strong> depicts a view of a ruined part of Kirkuk Citadel, March 13, 2012Ayad Tariq, direc<strong>to</strong>r ofKirkuk Archaeology,states that out of 800houses inside the KirkukCitadel, which is situaatedin the city’s center,only 50 remain. The resthave been destroyed.“We need 25 <strong>to</strong> 30 billlionIraqi Dinars [appproximatelyUS$20 <strong>to</strong>25 million] <strong>to</strong> renovateall the destroyed parts ofthe citadel,” Tariq said <strong>to</strong>the <strong>Globe</strong>. “It is becauseof the huge damage inthe citadel that no <strong>to</strong>uriistsvisit there.”The priceless archaeollogicalKirkuk Citadelloses one piece of itswalls daily while eveeryonehas their backsturned on it. The houseswere destroyed duriingSaddam Hussein’sreign.“In the late 1970s, theIraqi Archaeology Commmissionrenovated 15 <strong>to</strong>20 folklore houses of thecitadel, and there wasa plan <strong>to</strong> renovate thewhole citadel and makeit a modern <strong>to</strong>urist arcchaeological<strong>to</strong>urist atttraction,”said Tariq.In 1991, the governoraateof Kirkuk forced thecitadel’s inhabitants ou<strong>to</strong>f their old homes andcompensated them withmoney and plots of landas part of a project <strong>to</strong>renovate the citadel.The plan was <strong>to</strong> desstroythe houses and rebbuildthem in their oldshapes, but the projectwas partly implementedand never completed.Only the destruction<strong>to</strong>ok place, which resulteedin the leveling of 750houses.Since 2003, the goveernmenthas allocatedbudgets <strong>to</strong> renovate theremaining 50 housesthree times, but theywere insufficient. “Twoyears ago, UNESCOalso promised <strong>to</strong> renovvatedthe citadel, but thisis not clear yet.”Walking through thecitadel, one sees ancientwritings and pictures onwalls and doors, somedepicting the citadel’shis<strong>to</strong>ry. It has four maingates three neighborhhoods,Maidan, Qalaand Hammam. There arefour mosques inside aswell as a bazaar with 34shops.It is completely negglectedand suffers fromdirt and barking dogs, allof which give an eeriefeeling <strong>to</strong> the scene.Saad Abdulkarim, dirrec<strong>to</strong>rof Kirkuk Touriism,says the citadel is areligious and his<strong>to</strong>ricalattraction. “Now a verysmall number of thecity’s inhabitants visitthe place; no foreign<strong>to</strong>urists do,” explainsAbdulkarim. “If attenttionis paid <strong>to</strong> it, it willhave millions of dollarsin revenue every yearfrom <strong>to</strong>urists in addition<strong>to</strong> creating a large numbberof jobs for locals.”According <strong>to</strong> Abddulkarim,the citadel isthe city’s most importantarchaeological site. It is18 meters high with dimmensionsof 450 and 500meters. “The his<strong>to</strong>ry ofthe citadel goes back <strong>to</strong>2600 B.C., which wasbuilt during the SumerrianCivilization Era,”Abulkarim noted.


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 10Universities; less practice, more theoryLearning “theoretical information by heart” not enough, students sayEngineering studdentsneed moredrive <strong>to</strong> improvetheir studies, saysSalahaddinUniversitypresident.Some students of SalahadddinUniversity’s engineeriingcollege argue that theircollege is not so differentthan others where one studiiesonly for a degree. Studdentssay the college doesnot force or even encouragethem <strong>to</strong> become good enginneeringpractitioners in thefuture. The president of theuniversity blames studentfor that.A different CollegeOne gets a different feeliingwhen entering the colllegebuilding when comppared<strong>to</strong> other collegesat the university. Widerstreets, bigger gardens anda large number of trees givea sense of peace and quiet<strong>to</strong> this educational center.The sound of singing birdsoverwhelms the voices ofhundreds of students walkiingin the streets.It is a few minutes past 11and civil engineering studdentsexit the study hall <strong>to</strong>take their 15-minute break;a few remain inside theclass discussing the <strong>to</strong>pic ofthe last lecture.Hoshmand Sahand andMohammed Amir, twosecond-year civil engineeriingstudents, explain thatin their department there isa need for practical learniingrather than theoreticalcourses.“We’ve been here twoyears now, but we have notdone anything in practiceand everything has beeninside the classrooms,” expplainedSahand as he andAmir head <strong>to</strong> the college’scafé.Sahand and Amir say thata majority of their classmmatesare concerned thatthey might not be able <strong>to</strong>pass the courses successfulllyand might need <strong>to</strong> studyone or more years than therest. This very fear forcesthe students <strong>to</strong> only think oftheir grades and "spend alltheir time and effort learniingthe theoretical part ofthe science."According <strong>to</strong> Amir, thestudents share the complaintthat the education system atthe university is wrong, andthey are not encouraged orhelped <strong>to</strong> become good andsuccessful engineers in thefuture but rather forced <strong>to</strong>learn theoretical informattionby heart, pass the exaamsand get their degrees.Salam Eshaq, a fourthyearstudent, says that hehas done practical workonly twice during this fouryears. “I will graduate thisyear but I don’t have theself-confidence <strong>to</strong> supervisea small project,” argues Eshhaq.A majority of the studentsbelieve that they have verygood facilities and equipmment,and argue if the systtemis changed, they couldbe better engineers.One student having teain the café said that somecourses are given more impportancethan other courses;they don’t know its practicalbenefit, but there are veryimportant courses neglectedor devalued by teachers.Dr. Shukri Qarani, a civilengineering professor witha Ph.D. from Malaysia,says in an interview withthe <strong>Globe</strong> that the coursestaught here are almost simillar<strong>to</strong> those taught in otheruniversities around theworld, and Kurdistan’s studdentsare even "cleverer".The different student“The difference is that studdentsin other parts of theworld feel more responsibleand work harder than Kurdiishstudents <strong>to</strong> get the bes<strong>to</strong>ut of the courses and theirstudies,” argues Dr. Qarani.Yousif Ismael, also an insstruc<strong>to</strong>r,says that studentsare provided with all reqquired<strong>to</strong>ols and means forlearning, and that practicalwork comes after graduattion“in the same way thatphysicians become practittionersat a specific stage.”Dr. Ahmed Dizayee, presiiden<strong>to</strong>f the university, <strong>to</strong>ldthe <strong>Globe</strong> that nowhere inthe world are fresh graduaatesassigned <strong>to</strong> supervisea project, but they will havethe chance <strong>to</strong> get trained forpractical work.There are plans <strong>to</strong> connectuniversities with the privatesec<strong>to</strong>r <strong>to</strong> send fresh graduaates<strong>to</strong> companies wherethey can be trained whileworking for the companies.The first such effort is theestablishment of a trainingcenter by the Swedish ScanniaCompany in associationwith the Kurdistan RegionaalGovernment’s Ministryof Labor and Social Affairs,which is aimed at admittingfresh graduates and enginneersand training them fortheir next jobs.Dizayee believes that ifKurdistan’s engineers havegood English, computerskills and theoretical knowleedge,the companies woulddefinitely welcome them,and with a short period oftraining and probation, theycould very well turn theirtheoretical knowledge in<strong>to</strong>practical work.“Graduates should notwait for the government <strong>to</strong>employ them,” argues Dizayyee.“The era has changedand students should devvelopthemselves duriingtheir studies. We haveopened summer courses forthird- and fourth-stage studdents,and have made somechanges in the system andthe curriculums. Still, if thestudent does not have thecapacity for learning, onecan’t force him <strong>to</strong> learn.”Publishers concerned as sales drop precipi<strong>to</strong>uslyThere arecurrently morethan 133newspapersand magazinespublished insideKurdistan.Newspaper sellers in theregion’s markets claim thatdemand for newspapers hassignificantly dropped thisyear, and with the excepttionof a few publications,"90 percent of the papers"sent <strong>to</strong> the market for purcchasingare eventually sentback <strong>to</strong> publishers.In the down<strong>to</strong>wnAree Mohammed, 19,who is reading a newspapperat a kiosk in downtwon<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>, says his interest insports news compels him<strong>to</strong> buy a couple of sportsnewspapers and even magaazinesevery week.But for Aso Hasan, 26,most <strong>Kurdish</strong> newspapersare waste of money."All the newspapers writeabout the same thing thatviewers see on TV at night,so there is no reason for allof the publication <strong>to</strong> exist,"Aso says.In the mean timeNow, 114 years afterthe publication of the first<strong>Kurdish</strong> newspaper, newsppapersellers are concernedabout the situation of theirpublications.A newspaper kiosk owneerwho has been sellingpublications for 21 yearsand introduced himself asAshti, says that newspappermarkets have passedthrough different stages,and despite the fact that<strong>Kurdish</strong> journalism enttereda new era after 2003,starting early last year thesituation worsened.Ashti argues, “Magazinesthat used <strong>to</strong> be very popularand were sold out the sameday, arrived at the marketnow and stay in kiosks inbulks,” he tells the <strong>Globe</strong>.“All kiosk owners sharethe idea that the numberof the publications shoulddecrease while quality andauthenticity must improveso that people have moretrust in the newspapers.”Ako Mohammed, edi<strong>to</strong>rin chief of Rudaw, a weekllynewspaper, believes thatthe market and readersshould be able <strong>to</strong> decidewhich publications shouldcontinue and which shoulds<strong>to</strong>p, and some publicattionsshould make the decission<strong>to</strong> close on their own,A number of men browse headlines in a newpaper kiosk in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> Down<strong>to</strong>wn in this file pho<strong>to</strong>.especially those that arefunded by a specific entityand think that they don’thave the desired impact orsales volume.Kurdistan Region’s newsppaperssuffer from a shortaagein financial resourcesand don’t have the charactteristicsthat newspapers inother countries have. Forinstance, Mohammed argguesthat <strong>Kurdish</strong> newspapperslack legal advisors <strong>to</strong>support the interests of thepublic.“Media organizationsshould try <strong>to</strong> reach thisstage of comprehensivennessand should considerthe public interest whilepublishing important andgood quality news articcles,”explained Mohammmedin a <strong>Globe</strong> interview.Addressing the weaknewspaper market in Kurdiistan,Rudaw’s edi<strong>to</strong>r saidthat the market of printedmedia is decreasing globaallyexcept in some counttriessuch as India and Turkkey.Shwan Dawoodi, DeputyChairman of the JournaliistsSyndicate of Kurdisttan,believes that lack ofsubscriptions, specializeddistribution companies,newspaper shops outsidecity centers, and managemmen<strong>to</strong>f some newspapersby unspecialized and ineexperiencedmanagers, thetransference of politicalconflicts in<strong>to</strong> the mediaorganizations, and widesspreadInternet use by thepublic are among majorreasons for the weakeningmarket of print journalism.Dawoodi, however, argguedthat there are still 15<strong>to</strong> 20 publications that havemaintained their place inthe market and have tanggibleimpact on decisionmakingcenters.According <strong>to</strong> a report bythe Media Network, currrentlythere are more than133 magazines and newsppapers,and kiosk ownerssee decreasing quality andintegrity of the publicattionsand most importantllywide use of Internet asource of information andnews have weakened themarket for newspapers andmagazines.GLOBE PHOTO/Safin Hamed


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 11Pro-<strong>Kurdish</strong> BDPdelegation visits U.S.By Mehmed Sabri AkgönülThe pro-<strong>Kurdish</strong> Peaceand Democracy Party(BDP) delegation, consistiingof Selahattin Demirtasand Gultan Kisanak, cochairsof the party, AhmetTurk , the DemocraticSociety Congress (DTK)chairman and member ofthe Turkish Parliamentfrom Mardin, as well asVan MP Nazmi Gur, visiitedthe U.S. on Monday,April 23.The delegation>s visitiingprogram started witha meeting with QubadTalabani, the KurdistanRegional Government’srepresentative in the U.S.The meeting with Talabbaniwas about the recentpolitical developments inthe Middle East, Syriancrises and the situation ofSyrian Kurds. They alsodiscussed the Grand KurdiishNational Conference<strong>to</strong> be organized in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>with the participation of<strong>Kurdish</strong> parties, instituttionsand organizationsfrom all parts of Kurdiistan.Although the dateof national conference isnot certain, the main purpposeof this conference is<strong>to</strong> contribute actively <strong>to</strong> ademocratic solution of the<strong>Kurdish</strong> issue.The BDP delegation metwith Namik Tan, TurkishAmbassador <strong>to</strong> the US.The meeting with Tan adddressedAmerican foreignpolicy and Turkish foreignaffairs. They also visitedthe Assistant Secretary ofState for European andEurasian Affairs, PhilipGordon.The BDP delegation metwith Turkish journalistsand spoke about the armedstruggle of the KurdistanWorkers Party and militaryoperations of the TurkishState, events in Syria aswell as a possible referenddumfor independence inKurdistan Region. Journnalistsasked questionsabout the recent statemen<strong>to</strong>f Turkish Prime MinisterRecep Tayyip Erdogan,who said Turkish militaryoperations would cease ifPKK laid down its armsduring his official visit inQubad Talabani, KRG Representative in the US meets with the BDP delegation in Washing<strong>to</strong>n DC, Monday, April 23, 2012.Qatar. Selahattin Demirtasanswered: "Of course, we[the BDP] desire <strong>to</strong> endthis violence. If the PKKshows a positive stance,we support it. But if PMErdogan calls for a ceasefire,he should make cleareerstatements." He alsomentioned Turkey>s Syriianpolicy by saying thatTurkey aims <strong>to</strong> preventthe au<strong>to</strong>nomy of Kurds inpost-Assad Syria. "Turkeyinsists upon the Syrian NattionalCouncil in order <strong>to</strong>avoid promising a certainpolitical status for Kurds,"he added.Asked about the currentpolitical crises in Iraq andKRG President MassoudBarzani>s statements conccerningthe right of selfdeterminationfor Kurds,Demirtas answered: "TheIraqi people>s demand fora new political status istheir right, but this shouldbe realized through peaceffulways. If this new situattionwould bring about therisk of bloody wars at aregional level and ethnicalconflicts, it should be morecareful. In this regard, ifthe last developments inSyria, Iraq and Iran aretaken in<strong>to</strong> consideration,there is such a risk."The delegation also atttendeda press conferenceat Brookings Institute onThursday. In this confereence,Demirtas defined the<strong>Kurdish</strong> issue in Turkey asan economic and politicalmatter. He argued that the<strong>Kurdish</strong> issue should betaken in<strong>to</strong> considerationas a question of the righ<strong>to</strong>f self-government aswell. "From our perspecttive,<strong>Kurdish</strong> conflict inTurkey is not a problembetween Turkish peopleand <strong>Kurdish</strong> people; it isa conflict between a stateand <strong>Kurdish</strong> people whohave been subject <strong>to</strong> asssimilationand denial oftheir identity," he said. Heunderlined two principlesfor solving <strong>Kurdish</strong> issue,adding that "our first andforemost principle is thatthese matters should betaken in<strong>to</strong> considerationwithout any elements ofviolence in this sense.This matter has <strong>to</strong> be commmunicatedwith dialogue,collective and constructtivedialogue. And thesecond principle will be <strong>to</strong>look at the <strong>Kurdish</strong> confflictin the Middle East, inthe respective countries,without bringing the stateintegrity, their terri<strong>to</strong>rialintegrity, in<strong>to</strong> the questtions.So, in that sense,their terri<strong>to</strong>rial integritywill be out of discussion."In his speech, he alsopointed out that the PKKis a reality of the <strong>Kurdish</strong>issue; because of this, theTurkish State has <strong>to</strong> accceptthe PKK as an ac<strong>to</strong>r<strong>to</strong> solve the problem.Speaking after Demirtas,Ahmet Turk emphasizedthat violence is not a wayof resolving the <strong>Kurdish</strong>issue, adding that this isssuewill be solved withnegotiation and dialogue.Turk also indicated thatKurds want <strong>to</strong> solve thisquestion in unity the TurkiishState and frameworkof democratic rights. GulttanKısanak also said thatthe BDP is against anykind of violence and theyhave supported peaceffulmethods <strong>to</strong> solve the<strong>Kurdish</strong> issue. She spokeabout tensions betweenSyria and Turkey by sayiingthat the "Turkish PMmay call every day on thegovernment of Syria askiingthem not <strong>to</strong> use viollence,oppression, and allother measures <strong>to</strong> oppresspeople <strong>to</strong> try <strong>to</strong> maintaintheir status quo. He saysthat if you use measure ofoppression and extrememeasures <strong>to</strong> justify this,your authority on thesepeople, you will lose yourlegitimacy. We applaudthat, we agree with that.These are great words, butwe call on PM Erdogan <strong>to</strong>employ the same measuresin Turkey as well."After the BDP delegattion’svisit, some Turkishopinion-makers stated thatthe BDP wants <strong>to</strong> movethe <strong>Kurdish</strong> issue <strong>to</strong> an intternationalplatform. ButTurkish President AbdulllahGul rejected these intterpretations.He evaluateedthe delegation>s trip inthe U.S. as ordinary event,adding, "the BDP is nottrying <strong>to</strong> carry the issue <strong>to</strong>an international platform,but the world public opiniionwatches Turkey veryclosely. This kind of visitshouldn>t be evaluated asextraordinary activities."Pho<strong>to</strong> from knowkurdistan.com


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 12Syrian Kurdistan andBy Mir MengiNIKOLAY DOYCHINOV/AFP/Getty ImagesA Syrian immigrant waves a <strong>Kurdish</strong> flag for the Kurd minority living in northeastern Syria during a protest on January 8, 2012 in Sofia against the regime of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.There is still lack of an intternationalconsensus overhow <strong>to</strong> handle the ongoingSyrian crisis. Kofi Annan’sinitiative <strong>to</strong> find a peacefulsolution seems not <strong>to</strong> beworking properly, and this isnot surprising. As many obsserversand analysts argued,the initiative was exploitedby Assad’s regime <strong>to</strong> buymore time against mountinginternational pressure.Neither the regime nor thedisunited Syrian oppositionprepared <strong>to</strong> accommodateeach other. Existence ofone depends on the removalof the other. Syria’s BaathParty, like that of the formerIraqi Baath Regime, doesnot have an economical, soccialor political background,and it lacks essential experieenceand socio-political acccumulation<strong>to</strong> be graduallytransformed in<strong>to</strong> a plural,democratic political entity.There are three main reassonsthat can explain thesurvival of the Syrian reggime,despite the fact that ithas faced serious oppositionwith a certain amount of intternationalsupport. First,the regime has unquestionaablesupport from Iran,Russia and China. Russianand Chinese support is partticularlystrategic as thesetwo powers are obstacles <strong>to</strong>any decisive action the UNmay take. All the draft resollutions<strong>to</strong> deal with Assad’sregime so far have fallenshort mainly thanks <strong>to</strong> theRussian and Chinese ve<strong>to</strong>.The second reason is thelack of international conssensusamong those globaland regional powers apartfrom Russia and China. TheU.S. and EU have not comeup with a common policy <strong>to</strong>deal with the Syrian regime.This global discontent wascombined with the regionalpowers’ contradic<strong>to</strong>ry policciesagainst the regime andmost crucially the politicalstatus of post-Assad Syria.As Turkey tries <strong>to</strong> play aleading regional role inSyria, neither Saudi Arabianor Israel will be content <strong>to</strong>see a dominant Turkish inffluencein Syria and be sidellinedby her. The timing ofthe upcoming presidentialelection in the U.S. and theongoing election in Francealso contribute greatly <strong>to</strong> aneffective international policcyagainst the regime.The third reason is thelack of a united oppositionagainst the regime. Varioousethnic, religious anddenominational groupshave sometimes opposiingaims and expectationsof what would be a post-Assad Syria. While non-Muslim groups fears thatradical Islam may prevail inpost-Assad Syria, thus appprehensiveof their social,economic and political stattus,non-Arabs such as theKurds have legitimate conccernabout the pro-Arab nattureand chauvinistic charaacterof the leading Syrianopposition. The main Syrianopposition, Syrian NationalCouncil (SNC), has failed<strong>to</strong> reduce all these concernsand apprehensions.For the subject matter ofthis article, I emphasise the<strong>Kurdish</strong> concern regardiingthe Syrian oppositionagainst the regime. It is safe<strong>to</strong> note here that without<strong>Kurdish</strong> participation in theopposition against the reggime,the Syrian oppositionwould not have either legitiimacyor sufficient power <strong>to</strong>overthrow the Baathist Reggime.Because of this fact,the SNC and other powersbehind the Syrian opposittionare forcing and presssuringthe Kurds <strong>to</strong> join theSNC.It is also essential <strong>to</strong> makecomparisons with the experrienceof a post-Saddam Iraqand approach the thorny isssueof relations between theKurds and the Syrian opppositionwithin the concepttualframework of the Iraqiexperience. In other words,the Iraqi <strong>Kurdish</strong> experieencewith the Iraqi groupsin pre- and post-SaddamIraq could be utilized bythe Syrian Kurds in order<strong>to</strong> develop concrete policiesand a substantial road map<strong>to</strong> secure their position inpost-Assad Syria.SNC and <strong>Kurdish</strong> opposittionThe SNC without doubt isthe most recognized and orgganizedopposition gatheriingagainst Assad’s regime.Its status was further sollidifiedwith the two SyrianFriends meetings held inTunis and Turkey. While atthe first meeting in Tunis theSNC had relatively positivediscourse on the <strong>Kurdish</strong>national question, its disccoursecompletely altered atthe Istanbul meeting. Thischange of discourse rightlyattributed <strong>to</strong> the Turkishinfluence over the SNC. Inwhat was called a ‘NationalPact’ that highlighted thevision and objectives ofSNC post-Assad, there wasno clear reference <strong>to</strong> remeddy<strong>Kurdish</strong> concerns or any<strong>Kurdish</strong> demands. In a cleardemonstration of sideliningthe <strong>Kurdish</strong> question, reprresentativeof Kurds withddrewfrom the meeting andabstained from the pact.The SNC’s position reggardingthe <strong>Kurdish</strong> nationaalquestion was further expposedby Burhan Ghalioun,the head of SNC, in an intterviewby a <strong>Kurdish</strong> newswebsite on April 17. Duriingthe interview, Ghaliounclearly denounced even theexistence of ‘Kurdistan’in Syria: “There is no suchthing as Syrian Kurdistan.This is duplicating Iraq’sexperience. In Syria, thereis an area where the majjorityof the population is<strong>Kurdish</strong>. In some cities,Kurds constitute the majoriity,but there is no regionor area called ‘Kurdistan.’Syria is Syria. As an>>


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 13exclusive Arab nationalism>>area, [the <strong>Kurdish</strong> area] itis called Jezira. It has beencalled the same throughouthis<strong>to</strong>ry … Kurds do no<strong>to</strong>nly exist in Jezira, but alsoin Damascus, where thereis a significant number ofthem. They are present inAleppo and Afrin as well.So, Kurds are everywhere.The term [Kurdistan] thatis now being talked aboutdid not exist in his<strong>to</strong>ry andhas not been mentioned inthe literature of the <strong>Kurdish</strong>parties. This is all duplicatiingthe experience of Iraq inSyria. The <strong>Kurdish</strong> partiesin Syria have some viewsthat do not match the realiityof Syria. The <strong>Kurdish</strong>his<strong>to</strong>ry in the pre-Baath erawas different from that ofthe Baath era. Kurds were amain component of the stateand were partners in buildiingthe new state of Syria.There were <strong>Kurdish</strong> his<strong>to</strong>rrians,intellectuals, a primeminister and a renownedmilitary commander inSyria. Kurds do not live inghet<strong>to</strong>s. Kurds are not separratefrom the Syrian peoplein general. They are not diffferentfrom other citizens inSyria. This feeling emergedunder the Baath, becausethe Baath Party really purssueda discrimina<strong>to</strong>ry, racistand marginalizing policyagainst the Kurds. But thatis not the real his<strong>to</strong>ry ofKurds in Syria. Kurds occcupya great position withinthe real his<strong>to</strong>ry of Syria.”One does not need <strong>to</strong> learnhis<strong>to</strong>ry from Ghalioun, buta few quick glances at anyprimary sources or scholaarlyworks on the MiddleEast and Syrian his<strong>to</strong>ryand one can clearly see ifthere is a Kurdistan or not.Ghalion sounds like that ofnow-outdated, typical Turkiishofficial ideology tha<strong>to</strong>nce claimed that there isno Kurd or Kurdistan. Thisoutdated ideology has longtaken <strong>to</strong> the dusty shelf.The determinant rationalebehind Ghalioun’s such riddiculousclaim in fact relates<strong>to</strong> the issue of decentralismand the <strong>Kurdish</strong> demand offederal political structurein post-Assad period. TheSNC refrains from committting<strong>to</strong> the <strong>Kurdish</strong> demandof federalism and aims <strong>to</strong>postpone it <strong>to</strong> the post-Assad era. Ghalioun makesthis very explicit in the intterview:“It is not our right<strong>to</strong> decide on federalismbecause we would be viollatingthe right of the Syriianpeople. Only an electedparliament can decide onfederalism or au<strong>to</strong>nomy. Itwould be wrong <strong>to</strong> makesuch a decision now. We arenot the representatives ofthe Syrian people. We onlyrepresent their wish <strong>to</strong> getrid of the current regime.We cannot confiscate thewill of the Syrian peopleabout the country’s future.In the future, <strong>Kurdish</strong> parttiesin Syria will have theright <strong>to</strong> demand what theywant. But the deep feeling Iget from Syrian youth is thewish <strong>to</strong> be <strong>to</strong>gether and disccovertheir Syrian identity.Before being Turkish, Iraqior <strong>Kurdish</strong>, they are Syrian.The issues of federalismand au<strong>to</strong>nomy should notbe talked about right now inany way.”These two long quotesevidently expose the framewworkof the SNC’s perspecttive<strong>to</strong>ward the <strong>Kurdish</strong>national question. This persspectiveplainly indicatesdegrading the <strong>Kurdish</strong> nattionalquestion <strong>to</strong> a minoriityquestion, thus allowingthe Kurds only some sor<strong>to</strong>f minority and individualrights. By rejecting terri<strong>to</strong>rrialrights of the Kurds andstripping them from theirland, Ghalioun reduces theKurds <strong>to</strong> a minority groupentitled only <strong>to</strong> minorityrights.If the Kurds are part ofthe Syrian people and iffederalism is what theKurds demand, then it isnot understandable why theSyrian opposition thinksthat recognizing federalrights of the Kurds wouldbe “violating the right ofthe Syrian people.” If theKurds are part of the Syriianpeople, then their demmands,whatever they maybe, should count as legitimmateand rightful demandsof the Syrian people. If the<strong>Kurdish</strong> demands seem <strong>to</strong>be “violating” the right ofthe Syrian people, then the<strong>Kurdish</strong> people are not par<strong>to</strong>f the Syrian people andthus should separate fromthem.Ghalioun makes repeatedreferences that the Iraqi expperiencecannot be repeatedin Syria. It is not logical.The two Baathist Regimeshad more similarities andcommon points than disssimilaritiesand differences.They both run the countryas a single party systembased on a small group ofinterests through exclusiveArab nationalism. Both reggimesdenied the basic nattionalrights of the Kurds.The only difference is thatthe Iraqi Kurds had develoopeda formidable armedresistance against Saddam’sregime while the SyrianKurds, due <strong>to</strong> their geoggraphicconditions, failed <strong>to</strong>establish an armed struggleagainst the regime. In otherwords, the Iraqi Kurds wereorganized while the SyriianKurds were not. This,however, does not meanthat the Syrian Kurds havenot developed any resisttanceagainst the regime.Contrarily, the <strong>Kurdish</strong> ressistanceagainst the regimeoutdates the SNC. In 2004,the <strong>Kurdish</strong> oppositionagainst the regime was bruttallyoppressed and therewas not any solidarity bythe Arab groups <strong>to</strong>ward theKurds.It is therefore inevitablethat the Syrian Kurds shouldfollow the Iraqi experienceand develop a vision accordiingly.The Iraqi experiencealso indicates how difficultit is <strong>to</strong> alter relations bettweenthe Kurds and Arabsfrom dominant-dominatedposition <strong>to</strong> equal partners.Despite all those agreemmentsand contracts signedbetween the Iraqi Kurds andthe Iraqi Arab oppositionsbefore and after the fall ofSaddam’s regime, the IraqiArab political groups haveyet <strong>to</strong> implement what theyagreed upon and promised<strong>to</strong> do. Relations betweenKurdistan and Iraq havealmost reached a breakingpoint.What has <strong>to</strong> be done?It is now very clear thatthe Syrian opposition doesnot have any perspective <strong>to</strong>accommodate the <strong>Kurdish</strong>national question. This inddicatesa difficult road thatawaits the Kurds in SyrianKurdistan. Their national/democratic struggle is no<strong>to</strong>nly against the regime butalso against the exclusiveArab nationalism that prevvailsin the SNC. Assad’sregime has no future and itwill go down sooner or lateer.The Syrian Kurds shouldorganize themselves anddevelop a coherent nationalstrategic policy <strong>to</strong> defendtheir rights and get their asppirations.Without a unitedposition the Syrian Kurdscould not repeat the successthat their brethren and sisttersin Iraqi Kurdistan didupon the fall of Saddam’sregime.Equally crucial, the SyriianKurds should not bow<strong>to</strong> any pressure, global, reggionalor internal, <strong>to</strong> giveup on their demand of fedeeralism.Compromising onthis legitimate/national demmandwould be detrimenttalnot only <strong>to</strong> the future ofSyrian Kurds but also <strong>to</strong> thefuture of the entire <strong>Kurdish</strong>Kurds hold up Syri's pre-Baath and <strong>Kurdish</strong> flags, chanting slogans against the Syrian regime as theycelebrate Noruz spring festival in the lebanese capital Beirut on March 21, 2012.nation. As has been repeateedlysaid, a federal politicalstructure in Syrian Kurdisttanwould not only consoliddatethe Kurdistan region ofIraq, but more importantlyit would rescue the <strong>Kurdish</strong>question from the narrowdiscourse of a minority isssue.Federalism then wouldbe the minimum standardfor any solution <strong>to</strong> the<strong>Kurdish</strong> question, whetherin Turkey or Iran.It is thus absolutely crucialfor all the <strong>Kurdish</strong> politiccalgroups, institutions andcivil society organizations<strong>to</strong> support the Syrian Kurdsin their struggle against theregime and Arab nationaliism.The most crucial roleand responsibility lies uponthe shoulders of the KRGand all the institutions in theKurdistan region. The inittiativetaken by KurdistanPresident Massoud Barzanishould continue, and strateggicalignments and contactswith the Syrian Kurdistanshould be established much<strong>strong</strong>er.It is imperative <strong>to</strong> repeathere again that, due <strong>to</strong> thenegative role that the PKKand its affiliated groups inSyria play, gathering of a<strong>Kurdish</strong> national confereenceof four parts of Kurdiistanwould not be fruitfuland meaningful. Instead,the Kurdistan presidentalong with other <strong>Kurdish</strong>political groups in Kurdisttanregion should work on anational conference of Iraqiand Syrian Kurdistan.There is no luxury <strong>to</strong>waste time and energy onissues that have no prosppect.Convention of a Kurdiishnational convention offour parts at this stage is exaactlysuch a waste time andenergy. Unless PKK makesradical policy changes andgives up its guerrilla warffarestrategy and denounceits dark relations with theKemalist circle in Turkey,with the Baathist Syrian reggimeand with the Islamicregime of Iran, such a confferencewould not produceanything apart from disapppointmentand disillusion.Under existing conditions,any national conference offour parts can easily be hijjackedor manipulated bythe regional powers.At this stage, close andstrategic contacts and colllaborationshave <strong>to</strong> be establlishedbetween Kurdistanregion and Syrian Kurdisttaninstead. These contactsand solidarity should no<strong>to</strong>nly be limited <strong>to</strong> the polliticalgroups, but must bedisseminated through thepopulation and all sorts ofsegments and layers of socciety.Such a foundationthen can be served <strong>to</strong> establlisha united common frontamong the entire <strong>Kurdish</strong>nation <strong>to</strong>ward a united andindependent Kurdistan.JOSEPH EID/AFP/Getty Images


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong> No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 14Enjoy your natural right <strong>to</strong> statehood orprolong agony with an unrepentant <strong>Baghdad</strong>?The current crisis in Iraqis anything but new. Thepast nine years have beenshrouded in sectarianism,civil war, political bickeriing,shaky unity governmments,animosity, distrustand agreements that werenot worth the paper theywere written on.The United States helpedmask some of the realitiesby acting as the crutches<strong>to</strong> support an Iraq that wasbroken and could not standon its own two feet.On the other hand, theKurds chose <strong>to</strong> rejoin thenew Iraq after years of isollationon the premise of apartnership based on a voluuntaryunion.The <strong>Kurdish</strong> leadershipon many occasions was thekey intermediary in a bittercycle of violence betweenthe newly empowered Shiiitesand disenfranchisedSunnis. Key negotiations,initiatives and interventtionsfrom the Kurds oftenresulted in pivotal breaktthroughs,notwithstandiingthe important role that<strong>Kurdish</strong> security forcespaid in res<strong>to</strong>ring stabilityin the south.The Kurds, owed <strong>to</strong> theirkingmaker role, were thebeneficiaries of a numberof concessions and countllesspromises from Baghddad.Here is the problem:What good is a compprehensiveconstitution,democratic frameworks,concessions and promisesif the end product is failedimplementation, by-passedlegislature, half-heartedunity and empty gestures?The Kurds find themsselvesin a position of deepmistrust with a <strong>Baghdad</strong>that continues policies thatare detriment <strong>to</strong> the develoopmen<strong>to</strong>f Kurdistan, ofreconciliation and brotherhhood.The centralist tenanciesof al-Maliki are not new;this was a frequent criticcismof his first term incharge.Despite reservations andwidespread mistrust of hisparty, somewhat regretttablyal-Maliki was givena lifeline and a brittle coaalitionwith al-Iraqiya andthe Kurds broke a worldrecord for the formation ofa government.Ironically, as al-Mallikihas come under moreBy Bashdar Pusho Ismaeelpressure from Sunnis andKurds, he has converselygrown in power. He hassuccessfully monopolisedpower, combined severalpowerful posts under thedisguise of temporary coveerand all but broken thecoalition beyond repair.Barzani’s ultimatumThe Kurds, after playiingthe patient game andseeing a lack of changein <strong>Baghdad</strong>, are now at acritical juncture were theydare not stay idle.Do the Kurds continue <strong>to</strong>exhaust energy in the newIraq, when clearly the bassisfor a new Iraq is nonexistent?After nine yearsof effort and perseverance,the Kurds cannot continue<strong>to</strong> ignore the writing onthe wall. Iraq is not united;it’s not democratic, consstitutionalarticles are nobinding, and parties suchas Maliki’s clearly do notbelieve in a true partnersshipwith the Kurds.Kurdistan President MasssoudBarzani has made anumber of bold remarksaround the plight of Iraqand the critical politicalcrisis, and has warned thatthe Kurds will not <strong>to</strong>leratea return <strong>to</strong> centralisation ordicta<strong>to</strong>rship.He repeated his stancein an interview with AP,where he warned that if apositive breakthrough wasnot achieved by local electtionsin September then hewould turn <strong>to</strong> the <strong>Kurdish</strong>people for a decision andthus a referendum on indeppendence.Barzani has been criticalof al-Maliki and <strong>Baghdad</strong>in the past, but simultaneoousevents have pushedthe <strong>Kurdish</strong> leadershipwell beyond the limits ofpassive observation or <strong>to</strong>leerance.Barzani’s visit <strong>to</strong> Turkeyin recent weeks followed akeynote visit <strong>to</strong> Washingt<strong>to</strong>nwhere met with U.S.President Barack Obamaand Vice President JoeBiden. No doubt at the <strong>to</strong>pof the agenda was Barzzani’sgrowing worry overthe consolidation of powerin Baghda,d and his messsage<strong>to</strong> his counterparts inTurkey and the U.S. wasthat the Kurds had reachedbreaking point and wereserious about threats <strong>to</strong>secede if the foundationsthat were a proviso for rejjoiningthe new Iraq werecontinually disregarded.Some critics viewed Barzzani’sremarks as a mereploy <strong>to</strong> extract concessionfrom al-Maliki rather thanany real threat <strong>to</strong> secede.Such views are narrowmindedand lack conjectture.The Kurds have alreadyreceived countless conccessionsand have alreadyhad many promises aroundpower-sharing, resolutionof disputed terri<strong>to</strong>ries andhydrocarbon laws. Moreconcessions alone are infact just the <strong>to</strong>nic that theKurds should avoid.Empty promises areworthless as are positiveagreements that are noadopted. What the Kurdsmust demand of al-Malikiand <strong>Baghdad</strong> in the keyweeks and months ahead isreal action, practical stepsand tangible outcomes.The visit of influentialShiite cleric Moqtada al-Sadr <strong>to</strong> <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> and growingdisillusionment of someShiite factions on <strong>to</strong>p ofan already marginalisedand bitter Sunni populattionshows that the currentcrisis is more deep-rootedthan ever before.Rewriting the wrongsof his<strong>to</strong>ryKurdistan has a fundammentaland unmolestedright <strong>to</strong> two clear options:either a truly democratic,federal and balanced Iraq,or outright independence.As the largest ethnicgroup in the world withoouta state, subject <strong>to</strong> acruel and selfish partitionof their lands and decadesof repression, if any nationhad a right <strong>to</strong> determineits destiny it would be theKurds.While other countries,some with populationsnumbering in the thoussandsand others grippedwith immense poverty anda lack of infrastructure,dot the global horizon, theKurds are warned <strong>to</strong> treadcarefully or that their timehas not come.After the end of the FirstWorld War, the concep<strong>to</strong>f self-determination wasthe overriding principle ofU.S. President WoodrowWilson that he imposed onthe League of Nations andthe Middle East.<strong>Kurdish</strong> President Massoud Barzani has been an outspoken critic of Nouri Maliki's policies.For imperial interests atthe time, Kurdistan wasthe only major nation not<strong>to</strong> be granted statehood.Self-determination is oneof the key internationalcharters and by which reppression,imperialism andsubjugation is eradicatedand free will is attained.Some claim that Kurdisttandoes not have the inffrastructureor conditionsfor statehood, but just howmuch infrastructure doesPalestine or Kosovo havecompared <strong>to</strong> the Kurds?Kurdistan is washed withimmense amounts of oil,with a booming economy,a vibrant population andall the trappings of anystate. It is a key strategichub of the Middle Eastand with the influenceand standing <strong>to</strong> play a keypart in the evolution of theMiddle East.However, double standdardsare something thatthe Kurds can no longgeraccept. Kosovo wasgranted independence as aspecial case where foreignpowers had ruled that Serbbiahad forfeited the righ<strong>to</strong>f sovereignty due <strong>to</strong> theirtreatment of the Kosovars.If anyone has forfeitedthe right <strong>to</strong> have any sayon Kurdistan, it is is Arabsand Iraq. After decadesof brutal Arabisation, desstructionand systematicrepression, the Kurds desserve<strong>to</strong> be applauded forsingle-handedly standingup <strong>to</strong> one of the most poweerfuldicta<strong>to</strong>rs of recenttimes.Have the Kurds spilledcountless blood, tears andtragedy <strong>to</strong> now return <strong>to</strong>centralist rule in Iraq or <strong>to</strong>have terms dictated uponthem by other groups?No Turk, Persian or Arabcan intimidate the Kurdsany longer. In reality, evenTurkey has accepted that<strong>Kurdish</strong> statehood is no<strong>to</strong>nly a natural and inevittablereality, but that Turkkeyitself may benefit fromsuch a development.The Middle East is in turmmoilas governments jostlefor power and influence.Turkey’s rapid decline ofrelations with Syria, Iranand ever increasingly Iraq,puts the Kurds in a <strong>strong</strong>position <strong>to</strong> be at forefron<strong>to</strong>f shaping the Middle Eastsocially, politically andeconomically.At the first seismic shiftiingof the Middle East aftterthe fall of the Ot<strong>to</strong>manEmpire, the Kurds weresidelined and had <strong>to</strong> painffullyendure decades ofsuffering for their chance<strong>to</strong> rewrite the wrongs ofhis<strong>to</strong>ry. They can ill-afford<strong>to</strong> be passengers as theevolutionary trains dartspast this time around.Way ahead in IraqBarzani has warned Mallikibefore, but it was thefirst time that a real timettablewas set for action.If Maliki is sincere aboutpower-sharing and partnersshipwith the Kurds, thenhe doesn’t need weeks <strong>to</strong>show his intentions.However, even if Malikidoes change his tune, itwill be temporary at best.Arab nationalists such asMaliki will never wantwhat’s best for Kurdistan,only what is best for himsselfand their party.There is no threat of Iraq’sdisintegration when it hasalready happened. A crissisbetween Kurdistan and<strong>Baghdad</strong> is just tip of theiceberg. Deadly bombingsserve as a daily reminderthat bloody sectarianismis not a thing of the past,with Sunnis digging theirheels in and ready <strong>to</strong> battlefor their slice of the cake,it begs the question of justwhat part of the new Iraqwould any Kurd want?Regional powers havecontinually served theirinterests at the expense ofKurdistan. It is time forKurdistan <strong>to</strong> be selfish andsolely focus on motionsthat exclusively serve theirnational interests.GLOBE PHOTO/Safin Hamed


The <strong>Kurdish</strong> <strong>Globe</strong>No. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012 15Sadr visits <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>, meets with Talabani and BarzaniIraqi leaders reiterate <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>agreement should becomebasis for solving the issuesGLOBE PHOTO/Safin HamedOne day after MuqtaddaSadr, leader of SadrMovement arrived in<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>; he met with IraqiPresident Jalal Talabaniand Kurdistan Region’sPresident Massoud Barzzanias well as a numberof high ranking <strong>Kurdish</strong>officials in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> on Fridday,April 27th.Talabani, who hosted themeeting, welcomed Sadr<strong>to</strong> Kurdistan and hopedthat his meetings with the<strong>Kurdish</strong> and Iraqi leaderswould become a fac<strong>to</strong>rfor finding a solution <strong>to</strong>the current political situaation.Participants of the meetiingreiterated the need fora national program thatserves the national interees<strong>to</strong>f the whole countryaiming at res<strong>to</strong>ring peaceand <strong>to</strong>lerance among allIraqis.In the same day, anothermeeting was held amonga number of Iraqi politiccalfigures <strong>to</strong> discuss thesame issues.The meeting was organnizedin the PUK’s pollitbureauoffice in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>and was led by PresidentTalabani.President Barzani, Sadr,Usama Mujaifi, Headof the Iraqi Council ofRepresentatives, andIyad Allawi, head of theIraqia Bloc attended themeeting, where they excchangedideas about theways <strong>to</strong> gather all efforts<strong>to</strong> find a solution <strong>to</strong> putan end <strong>to</strong> the crisis facedby the Iraqi political proccess.In the meeting, it wasargued that if the currentsituation stays unresolvedfor a longer period, itwould have significantnegative impacts andwould threaten the highernational interest.All participating partiesreiterated that the <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>Agreement of 2010 is thebest basis for overcomiingall the difficulties andsolving all the disagreemmentsand tensions amongpolitical groups in Iraq.The leaders were suppposed<strong>to</strong> hold a pressconference following themeeting, but the pressconference was canceledand Chief of Staff Husseinannounced a press releaseregarding the meeting.The press release statedthat "the meeting "as reiteeratedthat the basic servvicesshould be resumed<strong>to</strong> all the Iraqi citizensin the shortest period oftime, as well as settingsome mechanisms for thedelivery of these servicesin the most efficient mannner."Kurdistan Region President Massoud Barzani welcomes Muqtada Sadr as the latter arrives at the <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> International Airport on a visit,Thursday, April 26, 2012.According <strong>to</strong> the pressrelease, "the Iraqi leadersparticipating in the meetiinghave all shared theidea that <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> Agreementshould become the basisfor solving the problems,and Sadr has emphasizedon the constitutional basees,which determine themechanism of decisionmaking process."Another point of discusssionwas "improving demmocracyand paving theway <strong>to</strong>wards its realizattionin governance issues."It was also emphassizedthat all the politicalgroups should work handin hands <strong>to</strong> overcome thedifficulties and that eveeryoneshould refer back<strong>to</strong> the national alliancesand power sharing princciples.The meeting, which<strong>to</strong>ok more than threehours, was also attendedby KRG Vice PresidentKosrat Rasul Ali, PUKDeputy Secretary GeneralBarham Salih and IraqiDeputy Prime MinisterDr. Rozh Noori Shawais.National Alliance BlocLeader Ibrahim Jaafari,on the other hands, annnouncedin a statement onFriday, April 28th, that allthe political groups leadeers,except the Iraqia List,agree <strong>to</strong> hold the nationalconference in the firstweek of May in <strong>Baghdad</strong>.Jaffari, who has beentrying <strong>to</strong> collect the ideasof other political leadersin the country about thenational meeting, saidin the statement that inphone conversations withPresident Talabani, PrimeMinister Maliki, PresidentBarzani, Head of HigherIslamic Council Ammar alHakim, Head of NationalCongress Party AhmedChalabi, and Ahrar Blocleader Baha al Aaraji, theyhave all agreed <strong>to</strong> held thecongress in the first weekof May in the capital.Jaafari requested all thepolitical groups <strong>to</strong> priorittizethe national goals duriingthe dialogues, whilereiterating the importanceof "face-<strong>to</strong>-face meetingsand direct and positivedialogue <strong>to</strong> protect the nattionalunity and uprootingthe problems and overccomingthe obstacles andthreats <strong>to</strong> national unity."US <strong>to</strong> give visas <strong>to</strong> KRG citizens in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>U.S. Consul General in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>,Alex Lascars, stated in an intervviewwith Hawler newspaperthat his consulate would start isssuingall types of visas <strong>to</strong> KurdiistanRegion citizens before theend of 2012.Attending an exhibition of 11American universities in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> onApril 22, Lascars said that one ofthe policies of U.S. Secretary ofState Hillary Clin<strong>to</strong>n, U.S. Ambbassador<strong>to</strong> Iraq James Jeffreyand the U.S. Consulate in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> is<strong>to</strong> increase the number of Kurdiishand Iraqi students in Americcanuniversities.“During the past few years thenumber of Iraqi students studyiingat American universities waslow,” said Lascars. “But our goalis <strong>to</strong> increase this number.”The U.S. Consul <strong>to</strong>ld Hawlerthat they are planning <strong>to</strong> start isssuingdifferent kinds of visas in<<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> before end of 2012 <strong>to</strong> Kurdiistancitizens.“We will grant all kinds of visasincluding study, medical, <strong>to</strong>uriism,business and others,” saidLascars. “We only don’t grantvisas <strong>to</strong> those who seek asylum.”Although there doesn’t seem <strong>to</strong>be a specific limit for the numberof visas issued per day, Lascarssaid adding they will see howmany applications they receive.Ambassador Jeffrey and Under-Secretary of State Thomas Nidesopened the U.S. Consulate Geneeralin <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>> on July 10, 2011.GLOBE PHOTO/Safin HamidU.S. Consul General in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>, Alex Lascars speaks <strong>to</strong> reporters at a press confernce in <<strong>strong</strong>>Erbil</<strong>strong</strong>>, July 10, 2011.


Last pageNo. 350, Monday, April 30, 2012

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!