Perversion the Social Relation
Perversion the Social Relation Perversion the Social Relation
20 Dennis Fosterwhich humankind has fallen. The distant past of the Cities of the RedNight was as corrupt as any modern time in its greed, racism, and violence.Nor, on the level of individual history, is childhood a place ofinnocence: at the conclusion of Cities, the narrator recalls a dream: "I remembera dream of my childhood. I am in a beautiful garden. As I reachout to touch the flowers they wither under my hands. A nightmare feelingof foreboding and desolation comes over me as a great mushroomshapedcloud darkens the earth. A few may get through the gate in time.Like Spain, I am bound to the past" (332). An ambiguity in the first lineleaves us uncertain whether he dreamed about his childhood or duringhis childhood, diminishing the difference between ordinary time and thetimeless space of dreams. Within this dream he dreams a second dream,a nightmare of the future. Something happened, we feel, to cast us fromthe garden into the realm of time and death, into reality. Dreams "[blow]a hole in time" (332), leading us to imagine when we awaken that atimeless, deathless realm must once have existed, before or beyond thetrauma, the fall from infant bliss, that marks all historical life. But at notime, even in the dream of a garden, can we touch the flower.Sublime America, the edenic garden, was from the beginning a denialof every constraint of European history. This founding fantasy imaginedAmerica as a land without difference, "a fresh, green breast of the newworld," as the final page of The Great Gatsby describes it, where everychild is whole and not riven by fantasies of race, religion, wealth, andclass. False from the start, the fantasy has nevertheless found embodimentin numerous icons of American life. The astonishing thing aboutthe people of this land is how readily an image of ourselves as uncorruptedcan be evoked in us. Despite the venal motives behind almost allof America's founding adventures that led to the decimation of nativepopulations and the importation of African slaves, we repeatedly affirmour commitment to the propositions of non-difference: that Americansaspire to a color-blind, classless, pluralistic society with many religions,but one god.Burroughs opens Cities with a version of the American story, whereinpiracy is neither the nascent form of early capitalism nor, in a perversionof big business, the eventual outcome of wild capital's pillaging everyweak spot in the financial field. Rather, it is an originating impulse ofliberty. Piracy, rejecting the cover of a national flag, declares the absence
Fatal West 21of limiting, castrating authority, claiming the right to take all wealth forits own. 6 It expresses, that is, the dream that it is possible to win absolute,stable command of the world's wealth. But wealth under capital iswealth only when it is fluid, endlessly circulated and allowed to functionas a signifier. All modern capitalists must, consequently, work with adouble consciousness: they recognize that capital, as a signifier, is emptydespite its profound effects; at the same time they derive the meaninglessenjoyment from money that only a fetish can command, even though thefetishized object is often no more than a fleeting electronic transaction.Piracy, then, embodies the enjoyment of a monetary fetish that legitimatecapitalism takes as the incidental consequence of its enterprise, butwhich is in fact a primary inducement for its labors.Don C. Seitz, whose story of the pirate Captain Mission Burroughsquotes, recognizes an ambiguity of motivations in idealists: Mission's"career was based upon an initial desire to better adjust the affairs ofmankind, which ended as is quite usual in the more liberal adjustment ofhis own fortunes" (xi). The problem with such a desire to elevate others,as Conrad displayed in Heart of Darknesses fortune-hunting "gang ofvirtue," is that in remaining ignorant of where they derive their enjoyment,the "benefactors" of mankind need not question what they attainmerely in passing. In saving the less fortunate peoples of the world, thepowerful stage master-servant/sado-masochist fantasies that "incidentally"exploit and destroy those who come in contact with them. Burroughsseizes this story of the pirate Mission for its sublime potential,seeing in it an American liberty that might have effectively put an endto the history of industry and capitalism by eliminating need, wealth,and class. But unlike the young Marx who imagines that the eliminationof "exchange value" will produce some authentic existence, Burroughs'simagined community evades the tyranny of authenticity by producing adeliberately and literally staged enjoyment.Burroughs's characters parody our activities, showing how social,economic, and political motives conceal some more fundamental need.Farnsworth, for example, is the District Health Officer, but he is uninterestedin typical ideas of health: he has "very little use for doctors"because they interfere with the function of his office, which is to alleviatesuffering, whether it arises from illness or desire: "The treatmentfor cholera was simple: each patient was assigned to a straw pallet on
- Page 1 and 2: PerversiontheSocial RelationMolly A
- Page 3: AcknowledgmentsixMolly Anne Rothenb
- Page 9 and 10: Molly Anne Rothenbergand Dennis Fos
- Page 11 and 12: Introduction 3necessary passage thr
- Page 13 and 14: Introduction 5jectivity, where enco
- Page 15 and 16: Introduction 7The Potential of Perv
- Page 17 and 18: Introduction 9fact, they are necess
- Page 19 and 20: Introductionnoperate in both desire
- Page 21 and 22: Introduction 13the individual or, b
- Page 23 and 24: W.S.Dennis FosterShortly before the
- Page 25 and 26: Fatal West 17Like Poe's perverse un
- Page 27: Fatal West 19cost is no reliable gu
- Page 31 and 32: Fatal West 23out in the next paragr
- Page 33 and 34: Fatal West 25Burroughs does not sug
- Page 35 and 36: Fatal West 27is associated with Ame
- Page 37 and 38: Fatal West 2,9tiginous sensation of
- Page 39 and 40: Fatal West 31his characters from bo
- Page 41 and 42: Fatal West 33We should not be surpr
- Page 43 and 44: Fatal West 35Burroughs's curious pr
- Page 45 and 46: Fatal West 377 For a good summary o
- Page 47 and 48: Perversion 39The Core of Human Sexu
- Page 49 and 50: Perversion 41tions two examples of
- Page 51 and 52: Perversion 43related symptoms that
- Page 53 and 54: Perversion 45result of the fright o
- Page 55 and 56: Perversion 47To return to the quest
- Page 57 and 58: Perversion 49Lacan tells us, we com
- Page 59 and 60: Perversion 51tern. Lacan's often-re
- Page 61 and 62: Perversion 53Father's "No!"Mother a
- Page 63 and 64: Perversion 55the pervert's sexualit
- Page 65 and 66: Perversion 57power when a judge all
- Page 67 and 68: Perversion 59sions—when allowed t
- Page 69 and 70: Perversion 61in their detailed disc
- Page 71 and 72: Perversion 63simultaneously a recog
- Page 73 and 74: Perversion 6$31 Consider, in the fo
- Page 75 and 76: Perversion6jto all cases); but mora
- Page 77 and 78: "I Know Well, but All the Same ..."
20 Dennis Fosterwhich humankind has fallen. The distant past of <strong>the</strong> Cities of <strong>the</strong> RedNight was as corrupt as any modern time in its greed, racism, and violence.Nor, on <strong>the</strong> level of individual history, is childhood a place ofinnocence: at <strong>the</strong> conclusion of Cities, <strong>the</strong> narrator recalls a dream: "I remembera dream of my childhood. I am in a beautiful garden. As I reachout to touch <strong>the</strong> flowers <strong>the</strong>y wi<strong>the</strong>r under my hands. A nightmare feelingof foreboding and desolation comes over me as a great mushroomshapedcloud darkens <strong>the</strong> earth. A few may get through <strong>the</strong> gate in time.Like Spain, I am bound to <strong>the</strong> past" (332). An ambiguity in <strong>the</strong> first lineleaves us uncertain whe<strong>the</strong>r he dreamed about his childhood or duringhis childhood, diminishing <strong>the</strong> difference between ordinary time and <strong>the</strong>timeless space of dreams. Within this dream he dreams a second dream,a nightmare of <strong>the</strong> future. Something happened, we feel, to cast us from<strong>the</strong> garden into <strong>the</strong> realm of time and death, into reality. Dreams "[blow]a hole in time" (332), leading us to imagine when we awaken that atimeless, deathless realm must once have existed, before or beyond <strong>the</strong>trauma, <strong>the</strong> fall from infant bliss, that marks all historical life. But at notime, even in <strong>the</strong> dream of a garden, can we touch <strong>the</strong> flower.Sublime America, <strong>the</strong> edenic garden, was from <strong>the</strong> beginning a denialof every constraint of European history. This founding fantasy imaginedAmerica as a land without difference, "a fresh, green breast of <strong>the</strong> newworld," as <strong>the</strong> final page of The Great Gatsby describes it, where everychild is whole and not riven by fantasies of race, religion, wealth, andclass. False from <strong>the</strong> start, <strong>the</strong> fantasy has never<strong>the</strong>less found embodimentin numerous icons of American life. The astonishing thing about<strong>the</strong> people of this land is how readily an image of ourselves as uncorruptedcan be evoked in us. Despite <strong>the</strong> venal motives behind almost allof America's founding adventures that led to <strong>the</strong> decimation of nativepopulations and <strong>the</strong> importation of African slaves, we repeatedly affirmour commitment to <strong>the</strong> propositions of non-difference: that Americansaspire to a color-blind, classless, pluralistic society with many religions,but one god.Burroughs opens Cities with a version of <strong>the</strong> American story, whereinpiracy is nei<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong> nascent form of early capitalism nor, in a perversionof big business, <strong>the</strong> eventual outcome of wild capital's pillaging everyweak spot in <strong>the</strong> financial field. Ra<strong>the</strong>r, it is an originating impulse ofliberty. Piracy, rejecting <strong>the</strong> cover of a national flag, declares <strong>the</strong> absence