2003; baxter - Supplements - Haematologica
2003; baxter - Supplements - Haematologica 2003; baxter - Supplements - Haematologica
[Acquired Inhibitors in Non-Hemophiliacs]review paperModified Bonn-Malmö Protocol(MBM-P)haematologica 2003; 88(suppl. n. 12):78-85http://www.haematologica.org/free/immunotolerance2001.pdfL. HESS, H. ZEITLER, CH. UNKRIG, W. NETTEKOVEN,T. ALBERT, R. SCHWAAB, W. EFFENBERGER, J. OLDENBURG,H. VETTER, P. HANFLAND, H.H. BRACKMANNInstitute for Experimental Hematology and Transfusion Medicine,Bonn University Hospital, Hemophilia Center, Bonn,GermanyInhibitor formation against clotting factor VIII is alife-threatening condition with a mortality rate of upto 22 %. We treated 24 patients between 30 and 89years of age, all with high-titer factor VIII inhibitorand life-threatening bleeding, using conventionaltherapies and MBM Protocol, respectively. Fivepatients were treated using conventional treatmentmethods, i.e. immunosuppression or immunomodulation(prednisolone, cyclophosphamide, vincristine,IgG). Two of these patients received additionalimmune tolerance therapy according to the BonnProtocol. Permanent inhibitor elimination wasachieved in only one of the five conventionally treatedpatients. One patient had inhibitor remission fora duration of 12 months, followed by another lifethreateningevent. Thus, a total of four patients wereunsuccessfully treated with conventional therapiesfor nine to 86 months. In three patients, conventionaltherapy was discontinued, and treatmentaccording to the Modified Bonn-Malmö Protocol wasinitiated (successfully in two patients; one had todiscontinue treatment despite good response dueto secondary diseases).In total, we treated 22 patients diagnosed withacquired inhibitor and acute life-threatening bleedingwith the Bonn-Malmö Protocol (MPM-P). MBM-P consists of four treatment elements (immunoadsorption,antigen stimulation (factor VIII), immunoglobulinsubstitution and immunosuppression). Seventeenpatients had completely overcome theinhibitor after a median of 16 apheresis treatmentsand showed normal factor VIII plasma activity. A furtherfour patients had to discontinue treatment dueto secondary diseases. Treatment was unsuccessfulin only 1 patient. Median factor VIII consumptionwas 384,000 units. At the end of July 2001, themedian follow-up period for the 17 patients successfullytreated according to the MBM Protocol wasCorrespondence: Dr. Lothar Hess, Institute for ExperimentalHematology and Transfusion Medicine, Bonn University Hospital,Hemophilia Center, Bonn, Germany.31 months, without any indication of new inhibitoractivities. The follow-up period of conventionallytreated patients was between 13 months and nineyears. Factor consumption in patients treated conventionallywas 56,000 to 4.3 million factor VIII unitsand 777,000 to 15 million FEIBA units. The MBMProtocol offers an economical alternative to conventionalinhibitor treatment. The advantages of theMBM Protocol are rapid control of bleeding withinone or two aphereses (24 to 48 hours), quickinhibitor elimination (median of 16 apheresis treatments),stability of successful outcome (median follow-upof 31 months) and a success rate of 94 %(17 successful vs. 1 failure). Early application of factorVIII using apheresis treatment had an earlyimmunomodulatory effect as well as an early hemostaticeffect. This results in the prevention of secondarybleeding complications and the causal treatmentof existing bleedings.©2003, Ferrata Storti FoundationKey words: hemophilia A, factor VIII,catalytic antibodies, factor VIII inhibitors.Modified Bonn-Malmö Protocol (MBMProtocol)Acquired inhibitors, which are mostly directedagainst Factor VIII of the coagulation system, arean extremely rare disease, with an incidence of0.2 to 1/million/year, 1,2 They are usually oligoorpolyclonal autoantibodies type IgG I and IV;however, IgA and IgM inhibitors against factorVIII have been described as well. 3-5Inhibitor occurrence leads to a decompensationof the coagulation system, resulting in mostly lifethreateningsoft-tissue bleeding. Lethality used tobe 22%. 6,7 The fact that according to recent studieslethality is reduced to 7.5% may be attributableto the availability of coagulative APCC and factorVIIa concentrates. 8 The treatment regimensdirected against autoantibodies are based onimmunosuppression by cyclophosphamide, prednisolone,azathiophrine, vincristine and others.haematologica vol. 88(supplement n. 12):september 2003
IV International Workshop on Immune Tolerance in Hemophilia 79Another treatment option is referred to as immunomodulationusing immunoglobulin substitutionin order to trigger inhibitor elimination. 9 Thepotential to treat acquired hemophilia with FVIIIand cyclophosphamide has been apparent for 30years. 10 In a randomized trial various immunosuppressiveregimens with prednisone and cyclophosphamidereduced inhibitor titers to undetectablelevels in 68% of patients. 11 However theseresults have been partially attributable to concomitanttherapy with coagulation factor concentrates.Furthermore, a complete response toimmunosuppressive therapy in acquired inhibitorpatients may require weeks or months. 11-14Assessment of the current data available is difficultgiven the small number of cases as well asthe inconsistent description of the differenttreatment protocols and experiences with respectto end point definitions of a successful therapy,treatment duration, undesirable effects and especiallythe occurrence of secondary bleedingevents and the amount of activated prothrombincomplex concentrate (aPCC) and recombinantfactor VIIa (rFVIIa) concentrate required. Thesame applies to cost aspects as far as they havebeen considered in publications so far.Availability of immunoadsorption and thus thepossibility of automated antibody reduction inthe patient´s plasma paved the way for the developmentof new treatment cycles. 15,16Based on our experience in the treatment ofpatients both with congenital and with acquiredinhibitors we at the Hemophilia Center in Bonndeveloped a new so-called Modified Bonn-Malmö Protocol (MBM Protocol) from a combinationof the Bonn Protocol (also referred to asImmune Tolerance Therapy, ITT) for the permanentelimination of FVIII inhibitor in patientswith congenital hemophilia A or B, 17-19 and amodified Malmö Protocol (with additional immunoadsorption,oral cyclophosphamide and IgGapplication). 15,20,22 The main focus is on antibodyreduction by means of immunoglobulin columnswhich allow adsorption of all IgG classes, as wellas on immunomodulatory treatment by antigenexposition using factor VIII concentrates 22,23 andapplication of foreign immunoglobulins undersimultaneous immunosuppressive treatmentwith corticosteroids and cyclophosphamide.Medicinal immunosuppression seemed indispensablegiven the experience in the history ofthe treatment of acquired inhibitor diseases.In the following, we will for the first time presentour therapy results achieved in patients withacquired factor VIII inhibitor, treated using conventionalimmunosuppressive or immunomodulatoryregimens as well as the MBM Protocol.MethodsThe MBM ProtocolThe treatment cycle consists of four componentswhich are applied during the course of one week.1. From day 1 to 5 long-term immunoadsorptionwith daily processing of 2.5 times thepatient’s plasma volume.2. Application of factor VIII concentrates,depending on the extent of inhibitor titer andbleeding situation, at a dosage of 100 units/kgbody weight every six hours (in exceptionalcases up to 200 units/kg). Standard dosereduction upon exceeding 100% factor VIIIplasma activity within a six or twelve hourrecovery under consideration of the clinicalrequirements.3. On day 5, 6 and optionally on day 7 applicationof immunoglobulins at a dosage of 0.4mg/kg body weight/day.4. From day 1 to 7 application of cyclophosphamide(2 mg/kg/BW) in combination withprednisolone (1 mg/kg/BW).Upon achieving inhibitor elimination immunosuppressionwas gradually reduced over a periodof six weeks.The treatment cycle is repeated in accordancewith clinical requirements and laboratory results.Application of rFVIIa or aPCC was usually performedprior to transportation to our hospital orprior to the placement of central venous cathetersunder difficult anatomical conditions.Immunoadsorption was accomplished byapheresis with a dual-column system (Ig-Thera-Sorb ® , PlasmaSelect AG, Teterow, Germany) ofsheep-derived polyvalent anti-human immunoglobulinbound to Sepharose CL 4B (AmershamPharmacia Biotech AB, Uppsala, Sweden).Conventional treatment strategies 1986 to 1997Prior to the development of the MBM Protocolour treatment of patients with acquiredinhibitors was guided by our own experience withthe Bonn Protocol as well as the guidelines andtherapy recommendations of current literatureand the clinical requirements.We used cyclophosphamide, prednisolone, vincristine,immunoglobulins, factor VIII concentratesand FEIBA in mono and in combinationtherapies. We also tried induction of immunetolerance by high-dose factor VIII application intwo patients, following therapeutic experiencewith hemophilia patients according to the BonnProtocol. Treatment was modified after sixmonths of unsuccessful therapy at the earliest.DiagnosisAcquired inhibitors were diagnosed by singlefactoranalysis in combination with a plasmaexchange and the Bethesda assay (BU) using theNijmegen method modification.In all patients and for the entire treatmentcycle, factor VIII was invariably determined usingone-stage clotting assay (Immuno) and chromogenicassay (Baxter). Lupus was excluded bymeans of lupus APTT and dRVVT (diluted RussellViper Venom Test).All treatment decisions were based on theresults of the one-stage clotting assay as due tothe high degree of dilution of the plasma samplehaematologica vol. 88(supplement n. 12):september 2003
- Page 31 and 32: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 33 and 34: [Round Table on Immune Tolerance Tr
- Page 35 and 36: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 37 and 38: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 39 and 40: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 41 and 42: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 43 and 44: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 45 and 46: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 47 and 48: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 49 and 50: [Round Table on Immune Tolerance Tr
- Page 51 and 52: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 53 and 54: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 55 and 56: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 57 and 58: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 59 and 60: [Immunobiology of Tolerance Inducti
- Page 61 and 62: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 63 and 64: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 65 and 66: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 67 and 68: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 69 and 70: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 71 and 72: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 73 and 74: [New Aspects in Treatment of Hemoph
- Page 75 and 76: [New Aspects in Treatment of Hemoph
- Page 77 and 78: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 79 and 80: [New Aspects in Treatment of Hemoph
- Page 81: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 85 and 86: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 87 and 88: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 89 and 90: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 91 and 92: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 93 and 94: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 95 and 96: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 97 and 98: [Acquired Inhibitors in Non-Hemophi
- Page 99 and 100: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 101 and 102: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 103 and 104: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 105 and 106: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 107 and 108: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 109 and 110: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 111 and 112: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 113 and 114: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 115 and 116: [Gene Therapy]review paperThe host
- Page 117 and 118: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 119 and 120: [Gene Therapy]review paperGene ther
- Page 121 and 122: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 123 and 124: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 125 and 126: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 127 and 128: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 129 and 130: IV International Workshop on Immune
- Page 131 and 132: Index of authorsAhmad, R.U., 56Albe
[Acquired Inhibitors in Non-Hemophiliacs]review paperModified Bonn-Malmö Protocol(MBM-P)haematologica <strong>2003</strong>; 88(suppl. n. 12):78-85http://www.haematologica.org/free/immunotolerance2001.pdfL. HESS, H. ZEITLER, CH. UNKRIG, W. NETTEKOVEN,T. ALBERT, R. SCHWAAB, W. EFFENBERGER, J. OLDENBURG,H. VETTER, P. HANFLAND, H.H. BRACKMANNInstitute for Experimental Hematology and Transfusion Medicine,Bonn University Hospital, Hemophilia Center, Bonn,GermanyInhibitor formation against clotting factor VIII is alife-threatening condition with a mortality rate of upto 22 %. We treated 24 patients between 30 and 89years of age, all with high-titer factor VIII inhibitorand life-threatening bleeding, using conventionaltherapies and MBM Protocol, respectively. Fivepatients were treated using conventional treatmentmethods, i.e. immunosuppression or immunomodulation(prednisolone, cyclophosphamide, vincristine,IgG). Two of these patients received additionalimmune tolerance therapy according to the BonnProtocol. Permanent inhibitor elimination wasachieved in only one of the five conventionally treatedpatients. One patient had inhibitor remission fora duration of 12 months, followed by another lifethreateningevent. Thus, a total of four patients wereunsuccessfully treated with conventional therapiesfor nine to 86 months. In three patients, conventionaltherapy was discontinued, and treatmentaccording to the Modified Bonn-Malmö Protocol wasinitiated (successfully in two patients; one had todiscontinue treatment despite good response dueto secondary diseases).In total, we treated 22 patients diagnosed withacquired inhibitor and acute life-threatening bleedingwith the Bonn-Malmö Protocol (MPM-P). MBM-P consists of four treatment elements (immunoadsorption,antigen stimulation (factor VIII), immunoglobulinsubstitution and immunosuppression). Seventeenpatients had completely overcome theinhibitor after a median of 16 apheresis treatmentsand showed normal factor VIII plasma activity. A furtherfour patients had to discontinue treatment dueto secondary diseases. Treatment was unsuccessfulin only 1 patient. Median factor VIII consumptionwas 384,000 units. At the end of July 2001, themedian follow-up period for the 17 patients successfullytreated according to the MBM Protocol wasCorrespondence: Dr. Lothar Hess, Institute for ExperimentalHematology and Transfusion Medicine, Bonn University Hospital,Hemophilia Center, Bonn, Germany.31 months, without any indication of new inhibitoractivities. The follow-up period of conventionallytreated patients was between 13 months and nineyears. Factor consumption in patients treated conventionallywas 56,000 to 4.3 million factor VIII unitsand 777,000 to 15 million FEIBA units. The MBMProtocol offers an economical alternative to conventionalinhibitor treatment. The advantages of theMBM Protocol are rapid control of bleeding withinone or two aphereses (24 to 48 hours), quickinhibitor elimination (median of 16 apheresis treatments),stability of successful outcome (median follow-upof 31 months) and a success rate of 94 %(17 successful vs. 1 failure). Early application of factorVIII using apheresis treatment had an earlyimmunomodulatory effect as well as an early hemostaticeffect. This results in the prevention of secondarybleeding complications and the causal treatmentof existing bleedings.©<strong>2003</strong>, Ferrata Storti FoundationKey words: hemophilia A, factor VIII,catalytic antibodies, factor VIII inhibitors.Modified Bonn-Malmö Protocol (MBMProtocol)Acquired inhibitors, which are mostly directedagainst Factor VIII of the coagulation system, arean extremely rare disease, with an incidence of0.2 to 1/million/year, 1,2 They are usually oligoorpolyclonal autoantibodies type IgG I and IV;however, IgA and IgM inhibitors against factorVIII have been described as well. 3-5Inhibitor occurrence leads to a decompensationof the coagulation system, resulting in mostly lifethreateningsoft-tissue bleeding. Lethality used tobe 22%. 6,7 The fact that according to recent studieslethality is reduced to 7.5% may be attributableto the availability of coagulative APCC and factorVIIa concentrates. 8 The treatment regimensdirected against autoantibodies are based onimmunosuppression by cyclophosphamide, prednisolone,azathiophrine, vincristine and others.haematologica vol. 88(supplement n. 12):september <strong>2003</strong>