March
Edition 2
Edition 2
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>March</strong><br />
Early Summer 2015
Dear Readers,<br />
One month ago today, we took in nine female doves. These nine doves symbolize<br />
the gestation of our humble zine. From a dream we had, to an idea we shared, to<br />
a tangible witness to our feminisms held in communion with the world, these<br />
doves represent the zine’s journey from conception to birth. For the past month, we<br />
have bottle fed these doves to prepare for our one-month anniversary and their<br />
journey out of the nest and into the world, much like our zine itself. Last<br />
tHERsday, we gathered with our closest sisters and released the doves as part of a<br />
beautiful ceremony. The event was almost ruined by some cross talk during the<br />
drum circle, but thankfully a friend improvised a talking stick out of personal copy<br />
of I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings. What a beautiful day.<br />
We’d like to thank all of our readers who have contributed such positive feedback.<br />
You set our hearts aglow. On a more serious note, we have received some<br />
troubling criticism from the editors of our sister zine, She-Wolf. They claim to have<br />
undertaken a close read of our first edition and have called us out for our stance<br />
on Miley Cyrus. We have been accused of denying a young woman’s exploration<br />
of her sexuality. This upsets us to our core. We spent the last week journaling<br />
about this. We just took sex positivity as a given and we can’t believe that our<br />
sister zine, a zine that claims to hold sex positivity as its highest ideal, would fail<br />
to see that in our work. We have launched an internal investigation on ourselves<br />
and our sex positive privilege. We are now trained and available for on-site<br />
workshops for any of you who are experiencing this same struggle in your<br />
workplaces. This is not a problem that can be solved with one workshop or in one<br />
day but as Miley herself reminds us, “it’s the climb.”<br />
The Leo Sisters<br />
Yours in friendship, feminisms,and fun
Mailbag<br />
We’d like to thank our loyal readers who let us know that<br />
last issue’s “Missing Feminist Icon,” Tracy Chapman, is in<br />
fact alive and well. Thanks to<br />
@fastcarbutwecantakeitslow, we learned that Tracy has a<br />
lively website and is still creating consciousness raising<br />
music. If anyone would like to provide us with a copy of<br />
Letters to Tracy for our archives, we would consider it a<br />
powerful act of sisterhood.<br />
Intern Update<br />
We just want to put it out into the universe that our interns,<br />
Tegan and Sara, are working out super great. They have<br />
introduced us to so many inspiring things: the music of Lorde,<br />
the meaning of “mom” among young people - especially in a<br />
Kim Kardashian context, and the “cronut.” To quote a powerful<br />
intersectional feminist who died too soon, if our interns are<br />
any indication, we truly “believe the children are the future.”<br />
#greatestloveofall.
Protest Update<br />
1. Our preferred tote bag provider recently moved away from its commitment to all<br />
female hemp plants.<br />
2. The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Last year, the Hall inducted Nirvana. This is an<br />
outrage. We all love Nirvana, but also know that Bikini Kill should already be in the Hall.<br />
Kathleen Hanna coined “Smells Like Teen Spirit,” and her group’s continued absence<br />
from the hall smells like capitalist sexist bullshit.<br />
3. We’re protesting all those still protesting the Dixie Chicks. The rest of the world may<br />
have forgotten, but we’re still not ready to make nice. #Won’tBackDown<br />
4. Our public offer still stands to serve as impartial mediators in the ongoing Tara<br />
Lipinski/Michelle Kwan feud.<br />
5. Wikipedia. It should be a source of public outrage that Sean Wilentz has a wikipedia<br />
page and Christine Stansell does not. We need to build a city of women on the internet.<br />
[Interns: do you know how to make wikipedia pages? we want to empower you to solve<br />
this problem! The Enlightenment is not over. We can still contribute to how we<br />
categorize knowledge!]<br />
6. Time Magazine. We have a few words that you might want to include on your<br />
“banned” list: patriarchy,. . . . that’s pretty much it. We also don’t understand the<br />
meaning of the other words on your list. What is a “bae?” (Interns please advise)<br />
7. We want to notify the public that a male friend of ours is officially on watch for<br />
seemingly innocuous comments about beets, the root vegetable. We all know that the<br />
male gaze on vegetable shapes is nothing more than a thinly veiled critique of women’s<br />
bodies. Furthermore, for any of you who have followed our journey from intentional<br />
living to intentional zining, you know how important beets were to our survival in the<br />
tender days of S.C.U.M.
Hello Fair Readers, I am writing to fill you in on the trying days of the past few months. First, please know that I am<br />
still as committed as ever to finishing my master’s exam thesis project in which I recreate the original Lilith Fair<br />
tour. My first stop in George, Washington was full of fellowship, great music, and some wonderful interactions with<br />
passing strangers whom I now consider friends. I had some painful flashbacks to my days with my former band<br />
mates in the Spinsters; the beauty of our music and the acrimony of our civil war. Now, before you say, “sisterhood<br />
is powerful,” please know that I acknowledge that I am at fault for the break-up of our band. The night before our<br />
audition for the first Lilith Fair tour (yes, we had the chance to play the third stage lobby performance space), I<br />
wandered into a local Republican meeting. I used to relax by losing myself in spaces that might normally make me<br />
uncomfortable. If I could make friends there, and spread the powerful lessons of feminism in hostile waters, than<br />
what else might I be able to do? I went to the meeting and stood in the corner sipping on some proffered lemonade. I<br />
was plotting how to enter the polo-clad fray, when my eyes locked with a prep across the room. I looked at the floor<br />
and when I looked up he was beside me. His name was Todd and we spoke all night long. He was leaving the next<br />
day for med school and after many hours of coffee I agreed spontaneously to accompany him. Did I betray my sister<br />
Spinsters? Yes. Do I regret it? Yes. Todd ended up dumping me after I worked odd jobs to support us until he started<br />
his residency. What’s important to remember is that when I was young and full of passion I believed that my time<br />
with Todd could be an experiment in consciousness raising. I wish my band mates would understand. Maybe they<br />
did. Maybe that morning when they noticed I was gone, they would understand that only a higher feminist goal<br />
would keep me from them, and from my bass. Alas, I know that they do not. How do I know this? Well, en route to<br />
my second stop on my Lilith Fair 1997 homage, I was pulled over for speeding. I was just so excited to get to Irvine!<br />
The officer told me that I had to get out of my car since I didn’t have my license. I saw a powerful documentary<br />
about identity and surveillance before I began this journey, and left my identification in the arms of an oak tree. I<br />
don’t want to insult <strong>March</strong>’s readers, so I’ll assume its obvious that this is a protest of both the corporatization of<br />
nature by the state and of the coopting of identity politics by the mainstream. I next found myself in jail with the<br />
chance to call for help. I could not call my parents because they did not believe in my master’s thesis project. They<br />
don’t understand the importance of my work. I could not call my advisors at Columbia because they’d stopped<br />
returning my calls a few weeks ago. I trust they are challenging me to honor the solitude of this experience. With<br />
few other options, I called the former manager/zodiac counselor Stevie Gold. She told me that she could not bail me<br />
out due to her loyalty to the other Spinsters. I asked for their contact information so that we might reconcile and<br />
was denied. Without a friend to bail me out, I had to wait until the local police released me on my own<br />
recognizance. As it turns out, chanting, “People have the Power” for eight-hours straight is compelling activist<br />
practice. All I can say now as I prepare to reach Phoenix and the Desert Sky Pavilion is that I feel like this arrest was<br />
the universe reorienting me to another project for which there is no degree: reconciliation. I know that the <strong>March</strong><br />
issue of <strong>March</strong> is focused on friendship. I want to take this opportunity to reach out to my bandmates. Please contact<br />
the editors of <strong>March</strong> and get in touch with me. I would love to share this journey with you. We can heal! These<br />
hands are still my own, but they are still reaching out to you Spinsters!<br />
Vanessa
Sisterhood Shoutouts!<br />
1. We want to take this opportunity to thank our<br />
sisterfem (sister in feminism) Taylor for inviting us<br />
to her birthday/consciousness raising rave. WE<br />
LEARNED SO MUCH! Your proud display of Punky<br />
Brewster DVDs is a powerful feminist act that we<br />
hope will inspire every visitor to your home. We<br />
too believe in Punky Power! We’re looking forward<br />
to our future collaboration on A Starr is Born.<br />
2. We want to commend the filmmakers of “The<br />
Beckies: Greatness Defined” (Available on<br />
YouTube). We’re longtime fans of the band. We saw<br />
them play in Portland in ‘86, and our lives have not<br />
been the same sense. We can’t even begin to<br />
articulate the artistic influence of “The Beckies” on<br />
our very own correspondent Vanessa’s musical<br />
maturation. We don’t need tell you how big an<br />
influence “The Beckies” had on the Spinsters’<br />
unreleased demo of which there are only 5 known<br />
cassette copies.<br />
Future Movie<br />
Reviews<br />
This past week we had the honor to view an<br />
advanced screening of “A Starr is Born,” the latest<br />
film from <strong>March</strong> Media productions. This powerful<br />
and evocative documentary examines the life of a<br />
brave soul who is engaged in an important<br />
exploration of the gender identity Ringo Starr. Not<br />
only was this film a tour de force of feminist cinema<br />
but since we haven’t listened to male-produced<br />
music in fifteen years, the film also allowed us to<br />
enjoy the music of the Beatles in a safe space. Ringo:<br />
we gotta get you into our lives. It won’t be long until<br />
A Starr is Born comes to a theatre near you.
"Bonnets and Bayonets"<br />
In the strange little hobby, or hobbies, of reenacting, women play many different rolls. They<br />
portray everyone from nurses and cooks to grenadiers and generals. While some women are<br />
welcomed into the community of reenactors others, especially women who portray combat roles,<br />
face confusion and dislike. Freddy Lawrence, a historian and reenactor, reports from the field.<br />
Reenacting, the recreation of historical events in period clothing, is a performance art<br />
practiced by many different people. While most reenactors are friendly and welcoming folk,<br />
the hobby remains bitterly divided between “authentic” and “main stream” reenactors. The<br />
claim of “farbyness,” or inauthenticity, is one of the worst labels that can be applied to a<br />
reenactor or her unit.<br />
Most reenactors in the US recreate military campaigns, and among both authentic and<br />
mainstream reenactors, some have a problem with women portraying combat roles. While<br />
this may be due to the social conservatism of individual reenactors, it is claims of authenticity<br />
that are most often deployed to keep women from portraying soldiers. For the sake of sacred<br />
authenticity they’ll say no women should be allowed to portray men of the 4th armored<br />
division in 2015 because no women served in the 4th armored division in 1944. Too many<br />
reenactors forget they are acting. Since we all know that gender is performative, and<br />
reenacting is a performance, why shouldn’t women be able to portray men and men portray<br />
women?<br />
Thankfully there are some exemplary women reenactors out there who are doing this work,<br />
and I was able to speak to three different sisters in arms about this issue. Let’s call them<br />
Christabel, Sylvia, and Adela. All three women portray civilian and military roles and<br />
depending on the event choose to wear either dresses or uniforms or both. Christabel often<br />
plays the part of a musician in a British regiment during the American War of Independence.<br />
Her uniform is correct for that roll (British musicians wore tunics of reversed coloring from<br />
the rest of the regiment, so a regiment with red tunics and green facings would have<br />
musicians with green tunics and red facings), and she can play the fife.<br />
"why shouldn’t<br />
women be able to<br />
portray men and men<br />
portray women?"
In sun, wind, and rain she dons the<br />
fearsome bearskin cap and broad shoulder<br />
boards of a British grenadier c. 1776.<br />
When invited to join the ranks of a group of other reenactor musicians, one member<br />
protested, arguing that women in the 18th century did not play that type of instrument.<br />
Sylvia told me another story. While she has not received any negative comments to her<br />
face, other reenactors have challenged the male members of her unit about her<br />
impressions, further reinforcing the trope that reenacting is a world for men. Adela is the<br />
one woman of the three who most often portrays a frontline soldier. In sun, wind, and rain<br />
she dons the fearsome bearskin cap and broad shoulder boards of a British grenadier c.<br />
1776. While Adela knows of women who have been verbally and physically harassed by<br />
other reenactors, she remains undaunted. Being a member of the right kind of unit made<br />
all the difference: a unit which judges its members on their brains and hearts instead of<br />
their chosen gender identity. Adela explained, “I take care of my kit, I know my drill, and I<br />
fight just as hard as anyone else.” She desires to meet the standards of her unit and to be<br />
treated like the rest of the grenadiers. While she chooses to portray a male soldier on the<br />
field of battle, she also engages spectators with the stories of real women who have fought<br />
in combat. Adela also stresses that she is not making a statement by portraying a<br />
grenadier. She does not look for comments on her gender or historical impressions or<br />
desire to comment on the gender or impressions of others. Instead she is fulfilling a<br />
personal life-long dream to bring the American War of Independence to life.<br />
Instead she is fulfilling a personal life-long<br />
dream to bring the American War of<br />
Independence to life.<br />
Christabel, Sylvia, and Adela all delight in portraying civilians and soldiers equally. They<br />
do not believe one role is more crucial to the hobby than the other. Hopefully more<br />
reenactors will come around to this way of thinking. It will be best to remember that<br />
reenacting is not one hobby. It is a whole host of hobbies carried out by individual<br />
hobbyists. At times these diverse hobbyists come together and decide on rules and<br />
regulations, but even in those cases reenacting cannot be considered a monolith.<br />
Reenactors need to embrace differences if they want to be taken seriously as historians<br />
and educators.
We recently received this call for participants which we<br />
were asked to share with our readers. Please contact us if<br />
interested and we will pass your information along:<br />
REENACT<br />
TO<br />
Revolutionize<br />
Hi <strong>March</strong> Readers,<br />
We thought this might be the perfect space to put out a call for<br />
new members for our feminist-reenacting troupe Reenact<br />
Grrls.<br />
We are a group of feminists who honor various feminisms by<br />
reenacting moments in feminist history. Our current focus is<br />
on scenes from riot grrl history. We are seeking rowdy,<br />
righteous and brave women to help us reenact early concerts<br />
of Bikini Kill, Bratmobile, and other foundational moments in<br />
this history. We will meet up at bowling alleys and basements<br />
where the original bands played and rock out all night long. No<br />
rules, just riot grrl.<br />
If interested in joining us, or forming your own chapter. Please<br />
contact the editors of <strong>March</strong>.