ATLANTIS RISING - Getthatmag.com
ATLANTIS RISING - Getthatmag.com
ATLANTIS RISING - Getthatmag.com
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
The Magazine for Leading European Architects No.13 • 2012<br />
<strong>ATLANTIS</strong><br />
<strong>RISING</strong><br />
Aqua architecture pushes<br />
back the tide<br />
Delayed memory<br />
Snøhetta and DBB on the 9/11 Memorial<br />
Museum and developments at Ground Zero<br />
PLUS: The impact of the mega practice<br />
■ Double-skin façades ■ Designing for adidas<br />
Agenda architecture<br />
David Adjaye talks Africa, public service<br />
and building in the political heart of the US
Reaching<br />
new heights<br />
through design<br />
A good user experience is the sum of<br />
many parts: aesthetics, <strong>com</strong>fort, safety,<br />
accessibility and reliability. KONE takes<br />
this experience to new heights through<br />
design. KONE is the first elevator and<br />
escalator <strong>com</strong>pany to be awarded the<br />
GOOD DESIGN award.<br />
KONE is proud to be one of the main<br />
corporate partners of World Design<br />
Capital Helsinki 2012. The WDC<br />
partnership provides KONE an<br />
opportunity to use design as a way to<br />
create better urban environments.<br />
To learn more about KONE’s design<br />
solutions, please visit www.kone.<strong>com</strong>
Combining<br />
innovative<br />
technologies and<br />
cutting-edge design<br />
KONE designed and installed an<br />
elevator to the Finnish pavilion,<br />
Kirnu, at the 2010 World Expo in<br />
Shanghai. The custom-design Expo<br />
elevator resembled a Chinese<br />
lantern and was an integral part of<br />
the pavilion’s state-of-the-art look<br />
and feel.<br />
Read more about KONE’s design<br />
capabilities inside the magazine.
Set an example!<br />
Office work couldn‘t be more attractive.<br />
The TRILUX Neximo LED.<br />
www.trilux.co.uk
LEA011_Cover_Final.indd 1 02/09/2011 10:41<br />
LEA012_Cover_FINAL.indd 1 13/12/2011 15:42<br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
The Magazine for Leading European Architects No.13 • 2012<br />
The Magazine for Leading European Architects No.12 • 2011<br />
Changing weather patterns and rising sea<br />
levels are forcing architects to learn how<br />
best to embrace water as well as escape it.<br />
At the same time, many city planners either have to<br />
extend conurbations further into the hinterland, or<br />
break out beyond their seafronts in order to address<br />
the issue of rising urban density.<br />
<strong>ATLANTIS</strong><br />
<strong>RISING</strong><br />
Aqua architecture pushes<br />
back the tide<br />
DelayeD memory<br />
Snøhetta and DBB on the 9/11 Memorial<br />
Museum and developments at Ground Zero<br />
Head in the<br />
cloud<br />
Fuksas on Berlusconi, hypocrisy and<br />
his most important project to date<br />
SchoolS of thought<br />
Can architecture really improve the quality of education?<br />
In this issue, we meet a number of practitioners<br />
addressing this challenge, including Waterstudio’s<br />
Koen Olthuis, and discover why the real difficulty<br />
may <strong>com</strong>e in convincing the general public<br />
that such structures offer real social benefits,<br />
as opposed to mere novelty factor and<br />
architectural grandstanding.<br />
PluS: The impact of the mega practice<br />
■ Double-skin façades ■ Designing for adidas<br />
No. 13 • 2012<br />
The Magazine for Leading European Architects<br />
No.11 • 2011<br />
agenDa architecture<br />
David Adjaye talks Africa, public service<br />
and building in the political heart of the US<br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
No. 12 • 2011<br />
Sprawl to enthral<br />
A new generation of Brazilian architects on<br />
transforming the nation’s cities<br />
pluS: The future of skyscrapers,<br />
Steven Holl in Biarritz, BIPV focus<br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
The Magazine for Leading European Architects No.10 • 2011<br />
David Adjaye is an architect for whom such<br />
grandstanding is an anathema. As work starts on his<br />
$500 million National Museum of African American<br />
History and Culture, the final piece in Washington<br />
DC’s Mall master plan, he discusses the political<br />
and social nature of his work and the pressures of<br />
leading a project more than 200 years in the making.<br />
Reimagining the urban landscape<br />
Another development charged with emotional<br />
and political resonance continues to take shape at<br />
Ground Zero. Problems with financing have caused<br />
delays and controversies, but the 9/11 Memorial<br />
Museum is now on course for a 2013 opening.<br />
Partners from principal architects Davis Brody Bond<br />
and Snøhetta discuss why the extra time taken may<br />
serve to benefit the whole.<br />
Elsewhere, a host of names from practices big and<br />
small, including Renzo Piano, discuss the growth<br />
of the super studio; we investigate the growing use<br />
of double-skin façades, take a tour of the new adidas<br />
headquarters and profile the latest developments in<br />
the use of exterior lighting.<br />
Finally, I would also like to take this opportunity to<br />
draw readers’ attention to the fact that registration<br />
has opened for LEAF International, taking place on<br />
12–14 September in Amsterdam. Entries are now<br />
closed for the LEAF Awards, which will be presented<br />
during a gala dinner the following week in London’s<br />
Four Seasons Park Lane. Shortlists are to be<br />
announced imminently – we hope to see you there.<br />
Phin Foster, editor<br />
Cover image: Waterstudio’s Sea Tree.<br />
No. 11 • 2011<br />
Wel<strong>com</strong>e to LEAF<br />
The LEAF Review is a biannual publication that blends in-depth articles, case studies, interviews and industry profiles to create an<br />
intelligent forum for the best ideas and developments in the architectural industry. A series of LEAF executive events and the annual<br />
Emirates Glass LEAF Awards bring decision-makers and top practitioners together throughout the year.<br />
For everyone in building design and construction<br />
For further <strong>com</strong>ment, news and information, visit our website: www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
Editorial<br />
Editor<br />
Phin Foster<br />
phinfoster@<br />
progressivedigitalmedia.<strong>com</strong><br />
Chief sub-editor<br />
Gemma Smelt<br />
Sub-editor<br />
Laura Cook<br />
Features writers<br />
Ross Davies, Rod James,<br />
Philip Kleinfeld, Abi Millar<br />
Production<br />
Production manager<br />
Dave Stanford<br />
Design<br />
Group art director<br />
Henrik Williams<br />
Designers<br />
Carolyn Jones<br />
Gennaro Draisci<br />
in-key construction<br />
Harpa and the making of beautiful music<br />
Design takes flight<br />
Fentress and Calatrava on the airport city<br />
Plus: The office of the future,<br />
Jürgen Mayer, Konstantin Grcic<br />
Circulation<br />
Circulation manager<br />
Danielle Tickner<br />
Client services<br />
Derek Deschamps<br />
Alan Bailey<br />
Divisonal sales manager<br />
Ebony Lyon<br />
ebonylyon@globaltrademedia.<strong>com</strong><br />
Sales manager<br />
Joseph Bexon<br />
joseph.bexon@globaltrademedia.<strong>com</strong><br />
Subscriptions<br />
Subscriptions marketing manager<br />
Kamyar Jannati<br />
General<br />
Publisher<br />
William Crocker<br />
Editor-in-chief<br />
John Lawrence<br />
johnlawrence@globaltrademedia.<strong>com</strong><br />
The LEAF Review is published by<br />
Global Trade Media, a trading division of<br />
Cornhill Publications Ltd<br />
Registered Address:<br />
John Carpenter House,<br />
John Carpenter Street,<br />
London, EC4Y 0AN, UK.<br />
Registered in England No. 01564127<br />
Tel: +44 20 7936 6400<br />
Fax: +44 20 7724 2089<br />
Email: info@globaltrademedia.<strong>com</strong><br />
Website: www.globaltrademedia.<strong>com</strong><br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
ISSN 1747-3764<br />
© 2012 Global Trade Media, a trading<br />
division of Cornhill Publications Ltd<br />
SUBSCRIPTIONS<br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
Marc newson<br />
The urban designer hits the waves<br />
The greaTesT design<br />
school in The world?<br />
When OMA met Strelka<br />
PlUs: New Lebanese architecture,<br />
“eating designer” Marije Vogelzang<br />
LEA010_Cover FINAL.indd 1 28/1/11 09:26:50<br />
No. 10 • 2011<br />
All rights reserved. No part of this<br />
publication may be reproduced, stored in a<br />
retrieval system or transmitted in any form<br />
or by any means, electronic, photocopying<br />
or otherwise, without prior permission of<br />
the publisher and copyright owner. The<br />
publisher accepts no responsibility for<br />
errors or omissions in the publication.<br />
The products and services advertised are<br />
those of individual authors and are not<br />
necessarily endorsed by or connected<br />
with the publisher. The editorial opinions<br />
expressed in this publication are not<br />
necessarily those of the publisher.<br />
Member of the Audit<br />
Bureau of Circulations<br />
Printed by Williams Press<br />
Single issue price: UK £25 EU €47.50 US $58 ROW $74.50<br />
One year: UK £39 EU €84.50 US $102 ROW $126.50<br />
Two year: UK £70 EU €152 US $183.50 ROW $227<br />
Customer services: cs@progressiveintelligence.<strong>com</strong><br />
Subscription hotline: +44 845 155 1845 (local rate)<br />
Subscription fax: +44 20 8269 7877<br />
www.getthatmag.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
3
1010 BINA<br />
3000 NJORD<br />
7750 FJOLA<br />
www.kusch.<strong>com</strong>
Contents<br />
10<br />
24<br />
COVER STORY<br />
Atlantis rising<br />
Increasing urban density and rising sea levels lend<br />
weight to the argument of building on water as an<br />
alternative to free up vital urban space. But how feasible<br />
is the concept, in terms of design and sustainability?<br />
Leading experts in the field tell Ross Davies how cities<br />
could well extend beyond their levees in years to <strong>com</strong>e.<br />
The intelligence<br />
8 Blueprints<br />
Keep your eyes peeled for this<br />
exciting selection of up<strong>com</strong>ing<br />
architectural projects.<br />
Big interview<br />
10 The visible man<br />
As work starts on the National<br />
Museum of African American<br />
History and Culture, Phin<br />
Foster meets David Adjaye to<br />
discuss the importance of<br />
social agenda, architecture<br />
as a political act and the<br />
art of disappearance..<br />
Construction<br />
18 Foundations for<br />
remembrance<br />
Despite chronic delays, the<br />
National September 11 Memorial<br />
is now open and work is<br />
progressing on the museum.<br />
Bill Millard meets Carl Krebs,<br />
Anne Lewison and Joseph Grant<br />
from Davis Brody Bond and<br />
Snøhetta principal Craig Dykers,<br />
among others, to hear why this<br />
high-profile public site calls for<br />
long-range thinking.<br />
Sustainability<br />
38 Two-faced architecture<br />
Double-skin façades are at<br />
the heart of many of today’s<br />
greenest and most visually<br />
striking projects. Rod James<br />
speaks to Louisa Hutton,<br />
Gordon Gill and Jim Olon<br />
about new technological<br />
approaches, their aesthetic<br />
possibilities, and winning a<br />
building’s occupants over to<br />
a new way of thinking.<br />
Materials<br />
44 Healthy reflection<br />
Traditionally questioned over<br />
their sustainable credentials,<br />
attitudes towards all-glass<br />
buildings are changing. Elly Earls<br />
meets Design Embassy Europe<br />
CEO Brent Richards, KPF’s<br />
Robert Whitlock, and RMJM’s<br />
Jonathan Knight and Chris Jones<br />
to discover how the clever use of<br />
the material is driving a<br />
sustainable agenda and<br />
improving general well-being.<br />
Design<br />
56 In good shape<br />
adidas Laces, the sportswear<br />
brand’s new headquarters, is<br />
designed to promote a fluid,<br />
collaborative work culture, thanks<br />
to the limitless assembly<br />
possibilities of the WORKOUT<br />
modular furniture system.<br />
Kada Wittfeld’s Dirk Zweering<br />
and Karim El-Ishmawi of<br />
KINZO describe how<br />
architectural and interior<br />
innovation can best enhance a<br />
<strong>com</strong>pany’s working practices.<br />
62 The elements of surprise<br />
With <strong>com</strong>missions ranging<br />
from converted textile mills<br />
to the Playboy Club, awardwinning<br />
international practice<br />
Jestico + Whiles is celebrated<br />
for its playful take on<br />
architectural and interior<br />
design. Abi Millar meets the<br />
firm’s John Whiles and James<br />
Dilley to discuss how it is<br />
successfully marrying<br />
theatricality and understatement<br />
– with unexpected results.<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
5
72<br />
77<br />
Special report<br />
68 Size vs creativity<br />
As multinational practices grow<br />
ever larger, to what extent are<br />
we witnessing a flight towards<br />
safety at the expense of<br />
ambition? Does scale stifle<br />
style? Renzo Piano of RPBW,<br />
Aedas CEO David Roberts, and<br />
partners from boutique firms<br />
DGT and Plasma Studio discuss<br />
whether size truly matters.<br />
Technology<br />
72 Light show<br />
As prices drop and efficiency<br />
increases, increasing numbers<br />
of architects are incorporating<br />
cutting-edge lighting technologies<br />
into the very core of their projects.<br />
Partners from IBA, Arup Lighting<br />
and Cinimod Design Studio reveal<br />
how architects and lighting<br />
designers are balancing new<br />
technical possibilities against a<br />
taste for restraint.<br />
77 Lower the tone<br />
Using discreet lighting to strike<br />
a balance between style and<br />
sustainability is no easy task.<br />
Elly Earls meets Lighting Design<br />
International’s Ellie Greisen to<br />
find out how a concealed LED<br />
lighting scheme exceeds today’s<br />
stringent energy-efficiency<br />
standards to create the desired<br />
client experience at London’s<br />
Corinthia Hotel’s ESPA Life spa.<br />
Innovations<br />
80 The innovations list<br />
The LEAF Review’s favourite<br />
new products and innovations<br />
from the past few months.<br />
Directory<br />
82 Events diary<br />
80<br />
6<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
VARIOTRANS® COLOUR-EFFECT GLASS<br />
SURP<strong>RISING</strong>LY NOCTURNAL<br />
At night, colour-effect glass shows off its wide range of “dichroic” colours<br />
in a particularly spectacular way. Illuminated from behind, it throws fascinating,<br />
multi-coloured, illuminated shades into the darkness. Its crystal-clear transparency<br />
remains almost perfect.<br />
Be surprised – order some samples.<br />
www.variotrans-glass.<strong>com</strong>
The intelligence > Blueprints<br />
The LEAF Review’s projects to watch.<br />
Blueprints<br />
1. Rio Olympic Park, Barra<br />
de Tijuca, Brazil<br />
Master plan<br />
AECOM<br />
Expected <strong>com</strong>pletion: 2016<br />
2 1<br />
3<br />
2. eVolo 11 Skyscraper<br />
Recipro-City Concept, Portugal<br />
Mixed use<br />
S3 Arquitectos<br />
Expected <strong>com</strong>pletion: TBC<br />
3. Seattle Jelly Bean,<br />
Washington DC, US<br />
Installation<br />
PRAUD and Machado & Silvetti Associates<br />
Expected <strong>com</strong>pletion: TBC<br />
8<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
The intelligence > Blueprints<br />
4<br />
4. Design Museum,<br />
London, UK<br />
Cultural centre<br />
OMA and John Pawson<br />
Expected <strong>com</strong>pletion: 2014<br />
5. CityCenterDC,<br />
Washington DC, US<br />
Mixed use<br />
Foster + Partners<br />
Expected <strong>com</strong>pletion: 2013<br />
6. Yas Island,<br />
Abu Dhabi, UAE<br />
Leisure and entertainment<br />
Benoy<br />
Expected <strong>com</strong>petion: 2018<br />
6<br />
5<br />
On the web<br />
For detailed information on these projects and<br />
many others, visit our website:<br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>/projects<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
9
Big interview > David Adjaye<br />
© Adjaye Associates<br />
The<br />
visible<br />
man<br />
As work starts on the National Museum of African<br />
American History and Culture, Phin Foster meets<br />
David Adjaye to discuss the importance of<br />
social agenda, architecture as a political act<br />
and the art of disappearance.<br />
© Xxxxxxxx.<br />
10<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Big interview > David Adjaye<br />
David Adjaye is a ‘starchitect’.<br />
He will not thank me for<br />
saying so, in fact he’ll most<br />
likely reject the notion entirely, but<br />
the man is as close as architecture<br />
gets to an international pin-up.<br />
Photogenic, outspoken, hip, mediasavvy<br />
and – a rare characteristic in<br />
the world of Western architecture<br />
– non-white, the Tanzania-born<br />
45-year-old has spent the best part of<br />
his professional career in the public<br />
eye. He must love the attention.<br />
But appearances can be deceiving.<br />
Adjaye is one of the most vocal<br />
critics of a previous generation of<br />
‘celebrity architects’; those who, in<br />
his eyes, became overly associated<br />
with building corporate temples<br />
to excess, creating buildings that<br />
struggle to resonate beyond the<br />
iconic. He, on the other hand, has<br />
never shied away from having, as<br />
he puts it, “an agenda”. Adjaye<br />
may have first made his name<br />
designing townhouses for London’s<br />
artistic set, but the work that<br />
truly established his reputation is<br />
based firmly in the public realm:<br />
libraries in unfashionable postcodes;<br />
publicly funded exhibition spaces;<br />
a <strong>com</strong>munity college founded in<br />
honour of murdered architectural<br />
student Stephen Lawrence.<br />
The defining aspect of this work<br />
is an outright rejection of icon.<br />
Adjaye’s buildings do not demand to<br />
be looked at; they are participatory,<br />
engaged and plugged into their<br />
milieu. The best examples, such<br />
as his Idea Stores in London’s east<br />
end, are thrust into the beating<br />
heart of their <strong>com</strong>munity and yet<br />
camouflaged from view, so seamless<br />
is the nature of their interaction. A<br />
very visible architect, he is adroit at<br />
the design of invisible buildings.<br />
Disappearance impossible<br />
But this could only ever remain the<br />
case for so long. Adjaye Associates<br />
now has high-profile <strong>com</strong>missions<br />
on its books that could never scream<br />
subtlety. Chief among these is the<br />
$500 million National Museum<br />
of African American History and<br />
Culture, set in the shadow of the<br />
Washington Monument and arguably<br />
the most politically charged US<br />
development in a generation.<br />
It’s been a long time <strong>com</strong>ing:<br />
African-American veterans of the<br />
Civil War were the first to call for its<br />
formation. At the groundbreaking<br />
ceremony in Washington DC’s<br />
National Mall back in February 2012,<br />
President Obama observed: “What<br />
we build here will not just be an<br />
achievement for our time; it will be<br />
a monument for all time”. Due for<br />
<strong>com</strong>pletion in 2015, invisibility is no<br />
longer an option.<br />
“It’s be<strong>com</strong>ing harder to<br />
disappear,” Adjaye, sitting in his<br />
New York office, says with a hearty<br />
laugh. “I’m suddenly aware of being<br />
extremely visible and have never<br />
done anything more public in my<br />
life. We’re dealing with federal<br />
money, the National Mall, the<br />
Smithsonian. It doesn’t get more<br />
accountable than this and I can’t<br />
run away from the fact that this is a<br />
political monument that symbolises<br />
both history and change.<br />
Politically charged projects of this<br />
type <strong>com</strong>e around perhaps ever 30 to<br />
40 years. It’s both a great honour and<br />
a tremendous undertaking.”<br />
Adjaye likens the experience to<br />
“working inside a bubble” and his<br />
forced removal from mainstream<br />
discourse has seen the architect<br />
delve further back into history for<br />
precedents and counsel. “I recently<br />
met with Oscar Niemeyer and had<br />
1<br />
1. The National Museum of African American History and Culture.<br />
2. Adjaye has built his reputation working in the public realm.<br />
2<br />
“There is now a real confidence,<br />
both among architects and<br />
clients, to talk about agenda, to<br />
insist that design needs purposE.”<br />
the most <strong>com</strong>pelling conversation<br />
about building Brasilia when he<br />
was just 35 years old,” he explains.<br />
“Struggling with these social and<br />
political ideas about creating a<br />
nation and how form helps make that<br />
image, it was extremely powerful. I<br />
also spent a bit of time with Charles<br />
Correa, discussing his relationship<br />
with Nehru in the early years.<br />
Connecting with people who have<br />
engaged in these sorts of discussions<br />
has been invaluable.”<br />
Upon winning the <strong>com</strong>mission in<br />
2009, a visit was also made to IM Pei,<br />
the most recent architect to build<br />
a museum on the mall – it looks<br />
as though Adjaye will be the last,<br />
<strong>com</strong>pleting the Mall master plan.<br />
“In a way I felt as though I was<br />
making a bookend to his building<br />
and it was important that I hear his<br />
thoughts,” he explains. There were<br />
clearly no hard feelings: Pei, alongside<br />
other stellar names such as Norman<br />
Foster and Moshe Safdie, had lost out<br />
to Adjaye at the final hurdle.<br />
Concept of history<br />
It was a unanimous decision. The<br />
concept behind the design sounds<br />
simple enough – a square building<br />
held by four columns, with an open<br />
first floor contained in a porchlike<br />
design – but where Adjaye’s<br />
proposal stands apart is through its<br />
evocation of something that reaches<br />
back through hundreds of years to<br />
West Africa, while at the same time<br />
engaging in a historical dialogue<br />
with its surrounding environment.<br />
“There is a duality of the political<br />
and the social running throughout<br />
the project,” he explains. “I felt we<br />
© Ed Reeve<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
11
Big interview > David Adjaye<br />
© David Adjaye<br />
© David Adjaye<br />
needed to tell the story of a people<br />
who emanate from the African<br />
continent, specifically the West<br />
African horn, and have be<strong>com</strong>e<br />
hybridised through American culture<br />
to be<strong>com</strong>e this unique group.<br />
“The site is also on hallowed<br />
ground where the high Greek style<br />
is used in a neo classical way to<br />
extort the idea of democracy and<br />
a new empire. But you also have a<br />
Pharaonic needle, the Washington<br />
memorial, which is really one of the<br />
needles of Karnak.<br />
“It was those classical African<br />
roots that I felt allowed me to find<br />
a trajectory to the roots of West<br />
Africa, which shares a very dynamic<br />
relationship with ancient Egypt,”<br />
Adjaye recalls.<br />
The ‘corona’ or inverted zigurrat<br />
shell; a perforated bronze filigree<br />
envelope that serves as a paean to<br />
African-American craftsmanship;<br />
Corinthian-esque central columns<br />
that are actually inspired by the<br />
verandas of Yaruba shrine houses:<br />
all of these <strong>com</strong>e together in an<br />
amalgamation of cultures and<br />
influences that blurs the lines<br />
between African and classical,<br />
serving both to tell a story and<br />
evoke a people. That story is direct<br />
and linear, while at the same time<br />
wide-ranging and <strong>com</strong>plex; this is<br />
a celebratory narrative of progress<br />
and heritage rather than a sober<br />
retrospective on hardship.<br />
“We wanted to create an<br />
architecture that begins to chronicle<br />
its contents and its context before<br />
visitors have even <strong>com</strong>e to look at an<br />
artefact,” Adjaye explains. “The tale<br />
is transformational; how a people<br />
came to change the very nature of a<br />
world superpower.”<br />
A personal odyssey<br />
It is also a dialogue that tells us much<br />
of Adjaye’s own journey. Extensive<br />
travels in Africa – first as the son of a<br />
Ghanaian diplomat, prior to settling<br />
in London aged 13, and later the<br />
undertaking of a personal odyssey<br />
that en<strong>com</strong>passed 52 African<br />
capitals, culminating in last year’s<br />
publication of the seven volume<br />
photographic survey Adjaye · Africa<br />
· Architecture – have helped shape<br />
his world view and create a distinctly<br />
political architect.<br />
“It’s given me the confidence to<br />
reference Africa in a way that is<br />
not exotic,” Adjaye believes. “We’re<br />
talking about somewhere that has<br />
been urbanised for as long as<br />
Europe, if not longer, yet has this<br />
reputation as being a landscape<br />
continent. There is a tendency to<br />
project onto Africa rather than learn<br />
from it and so much that claims to<br />
1<br />
2<br />
1. Nouakchott, Mauritania; taken by Adjaye during his<br />
travels through Africa.<br />
2. Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire, seen through the eyes of Adjaye.<br />
be inspired by ‘the African<br />
experience’ is mere pastiche.”<br />
At the time of our conversation,<br />
Adjaye is only just back from Gabon,<br />
where his practice is working on<br />
several administration-backed<br />
<strong>com</strong>missions, and is shortly off to a<br />
Future Cities conference in Lagos,<br />
where he will address delegates<br />
from across the continent. The story<br />
he tells is of a region undergoing<br />
urban and social transformation at an<br />
unprecedented rate, a development<br />
that both excites and concerns.<br />
“The incredible influx of<br />
<strong>com</strong>modity money has seen a<br />
growing awareness of national<br />
image,” he says. “It seems almost<br />
ridiculous to discuss national identity<br />
when these countries are no more<br />
than 50 years old and one is often<br />
dealing with a generation that<br />
believes in that somewhat Soviet<br />
notion of symbolic constructs, which<br />
are nothing more than simplistic<br />
image making.<br />
“Others look to the Middle East<br />
because they see it as the closest<br />
tangible model of modernity to copy.<br />
That scares me. We’re seeing lots of<br />
corporate American and European<br />
practices who struggle to find work at<br />
home <strong>com</strong>ing into the continent and<br />
trying to offer these solutions. They’ll<br />
always go where the money is.”<br />
But Adjaye also sees an<br />
emerging generation of political<br />
leaders, planners and architects<br />
as offering plenty of hope for the<br />
future in expressing the distinct<br />
characteristics of different parts of<br />
the continent. “Suddenly there’s<br />
money and ideas and people are<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
13
Big interview > David Adjaye<br />
Adjaye’s Moscow School of Management is among the most<br />
high-profile Russian projects by a Western architect in recent times.<br />
waking up to the potential of<br />
architecture,” he says.<br />
Adjaye is benefiting from this<br />
awakening, but he is no opportunist.<br />
You will not find examples of his<br />
work in Dubai and, despite plenty<br />
of offers, the practice has refused to<br />
cash in on the Chinese architectural<br />
boom. “It has never felt that<br />
<strong>com</strong>fortable,” he explains.<br />
Road to Russia<br />
One fast-growing economy where<br />
Adjaye has made his mark is Russia,<br />
still something of an uncharted<br />
territory for Western architects. The<br />
Moscow School of Management<br />
opened last year, another <strong>com</strong>mission<br />
where a fundamental part of the brief<br />
was being visible. Located beyond<br />
Moscow’s outer ring road, four<br />
buildings precariously cantilever over<br />
a large circular base sat in abstract<br />
isolation, demanding to be looked at.<br />
“It’s an unusual brief,” the architect<br />
observes, “designing a public<br />
building in a field. The area is set to<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e Moscow’s new industrial<br />
belt, but there wasn’t an audience<br />
to speak to in the traditional sense<br />
of a neighbourhood. That is quite a<br />
challenge, making a building that is<br />
anticipatory and must provide enough<br />
precedent and possibility for what<br />
is to follow. That is why it is in two<br />
parts. The top, which is almost like<br />
a still life, predicts a landscape that<br />
is yet to form and awaits a dialogue<br />
with that landscape. The base, the<br />
incubator containing the main work<br />
spaces, is a more generic form that<br />
looks to observe rather than interact.”<br />
They do things differently in Russia<br />
and for an architect so used to public<br />
discourse and debate this might have<br />
proved a challenge. Adjaye does not<br />
see things changing overnight, but<br />
what he has witnessed goes some<br />
way in supporting his claim that<br />
architecture is a political act.<br />
“I think our building has given<br />
Moscow an incredible confidence<br />
that it can do great buildings that<br />
both look back to their history as well<br />
as the rest of the world,” says Adjaye,<br />
who made repeated reference to<br />
Russian avant garde artist Kazimir<br />
Malevich throughout the design<br />
process. “They can’t believe that this<br />
work by an outsider takes reference<br />
points from their culture and it’s<br />
interesting to see domestic architects<br />
make reference to how the building<br />
was put together. The project<br />
has given them the confidence to<br />
appreciate Russianness.”<br />
Future highlights<br />
Operating out of London, New<br />
York and Berlin, the practice is now<br />
exporting this agenda of education and<br />
change on an unprecedented scale.<br />
Up<strong>com</strong>ing highlights include two<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity libraries in Washington<br />
DC that, in terms of size and profile,<br />
couldn’t be further removed from<br />
events taking place a few miles away<br />
on the mall and which Adjaye cites<br />
as further exploration in creating<br />
participatory buildings. “I think they’ll<br />
surprise a few people,” he says.<br />
A <strong>com</strong>munity park in New Orleans,<br />
where Adjaye has been very active<br />
building terraced houses pro bono for<br />
Brad Pitt’s Make it Right foundation,<br />
is also nearing <strong>com</strong>pletion and,<br />
prior to our meeting, plans were<br />
revealed for a vast ‘Kulturecampus’ in<br />
Frankfurt, grouping nine institutions<br />
on a single 16.5-hectare site. “It will<br />
take a few more years to get off the<br />
ground, but the city really wants it,”<br />
says Adjaye. “We’ve had incredible<br />
support and the wonderful thing<br />
about Frankfurt is how porous,<br />
mutable and giving a town it is. They<br />
really are open to new ideas and I’m<br />
so excited about this project.”<br />
In terms of acreage, it will be the<br />
practice’s largest <strong>com</strong>mission to<br />
date, something Adjaye believes is<br />
indicative of a fundamental change<br />
in mindset directly attributable to<br />
the fallout from the economic crisis.<br />
With excess out of fashion, the<br />
architectural dialogue is changing.<br />
He talks of “an end to psychobabble”:<br />
simplifying language without<br />
dumbing down concepts.<br />
“Where previously these issues<br />
might have been more softly spoken,”<br />
he observes, “there is now a real<br />
confidence, both among architects<br />
and clients, to talk about agenda,<br />
to insist that design needs purpose.<br />
Architecture is not just the sum<br />
of a fantastic piece of technical<br />
performance, nor is it the sum of<br />
solving the brief well. When you<br />
can do so much, it’s not enough to<br />
merely look good.<br />
“I believe there’s an emerging<br />
generation that sees the world<br />
differently. The previous generation<br />
also felt they were the harbingers of<br />
change; it’s natural, but look at what<br />
has happened 20 years later. We now<br />
distrust the engines that were meant<br />
to make us all rich and so defined<br />
the architectural agenda forged in<br />
an environment of incredible wealth.<br />
We are turning to questions of social<br />
responsibility and change is very<br />
much in the air.”<br />
He is in the vanguard of that<br />
movement, one of its highestprofile<br />
ambassadors. This may be<br />
a generation that eschews the very<br />
notion of starchitects, but, like it or not,<br />
Adjaye is now very visible indeed. ●<br />
14<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Stairway to heaven<br />
A staircase can be the focal point of a building, but bringing ideas to reality within the unique constraints of a<br />
structure requires expertise. Custom-made staircase manufacturer EeStairs offers support every step of the way.<br />
The art of stair-making has been<br />
around for generations, but<br />
rarely has one feature within<br />
a property offered so much potential<br />
for the expression of individuality.<br />
EeStairs is a modern custom staircase<br />
manufacturer that works with<br />
architects, interior designers and<br />
end-users to unleash their creative<br />
freedom and help their ideas <strong>com</strong>e<br />
to fruition. The <strong>com</strong>pany delivers a<br />
customised solution for both corporate<br />
and residential buildings.<br />
EeStairs has considerable experience<br />
of bringing to life architects’ designs<br />
or taking a construction drawing<br />
from a contractor and interpreting<br />
it accurately. Operating quickly to<br />
ensure that projects are delivered on<br />
time, the <strong>com</strong>pany keeps its clients<br />
fully informed throughout the project<br />
so that they know what to expect at<br />
every stage.<br />
EeStairs aims to make every staircase<br />
special, whether through custom<br />
design for specific requirements<br />
or using one of its wide range of<br />
standard staircase designs. The<br />
<strong>com</strong>pany can do almost anything<br />
in terms of design, materials and<br />
implementation to bring your ideas<br />
to life without losing sight of what<br />
is practical and feasible. At an early<br />
stage, the <strong>com</strong>pany will present<br />
visuals to show you what your design<br />
will look like, and it is fully prepared to<br />
work together to modify the finished<br />
product in light of budget, structural<br />
demands or site constraints – without<br />
losing the spirit of the design.<br />
Whether a customer is looking for a<br />
unique staircase, or perhaps has a<br />
design in mind that requires expert<br />
refinement, EeStairs is the perfect<br />
partner to work with. ●<br />
Further information<br />
EeStairs<br />
www.eestairs.<strong>com</strong><br />
A staircase offers individuality<br />
through custom design.<br />
for beauty between levels<br />
Headquarters & Benelux<br />
EeStairs Nederland bv<br />
Harselaarseweg 102<br />
PO Box 4<br />
3770 AA Barneveld<br />
T: +31 342 405700<br />
The Netherlands<br />
UK, Ireland & Export<br />
EeStairs UK Ltd<br />
Unit 3, The Old Printworks<br />
20 Wharf Road<br />
Eastbourne<br />
East Sussex BN21 3AW<br />
T: +44 1323 646 904<br />
United Kingdom<br />
we support you in<br />
creating stairs into<br />
a thing of beauty<br />
CUSTOM DESIGN<br />
STANDARD DESIGNS<br />
ENGINEERED<br />
www.eestairs.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
15
Company insight<br />
An uplifting urban experience<br />
Designing an elevator is like <strong>com</strong>posing music, explains KONE design director Anne Stenros. You need the right<br />
harmonies – access, lighting, acoustics, temperature and materials – to get it right.<br />
You’re stressed and running<br />
late. You dash through the<br />
lobby and intuitively find<br />
your way to the elevator banks. You<br />
push a button and within seconds<br />
you are whisked upward in the airconditioned<br />
<strong>com</strong>fort of a spacious<br />
scenic car. The view is inspiring.<br />
You take a deep breath and arrive<br />
at your floor feeling relaxed.<br />
“This is what our design philosophy<br />
is all about,” says Anne Stenros,<br />
design director at KONE. “We see<br />
elevators not as objects, but as an<br />
experience or a memorable journey<br />
through space. We focus on the<br />
ambient experience.<br />
“We’re not just styling attractive<br />
products, we are using design to dig<br />
deeper. We strive to optimise not<br />
only the user experience but also the<br />
wider urban infrastructure. On our<br />
own small scale, we harness design<br />
to create more liveable cities.”<br />
Opening innovation<br />
Urban areas are facing vast<br />
challenges related to sustainability<br />
and infrastructure. With a growing<br />
proportion of the global population<br />
living in megacities, the smooth<br />
movement of people in congested<br />
settings is a key enabler<br />
of liveability.<br />
“By offering efficient and emotional<br />
solutions for smooth people flow,<br />
we provide architects and city<br />
planners with the tools to create<br />
a more functional and human<br />
urban fabric,” says Stenros. “We<br />
use design as a strategic tool to<br />
improve quality of life.”<br />
Collaboration, she adds, is how you<br />
solve these <strong>com</strong>plex challenges.<br />
“We work closely with universities<br />
in Helsinki and Shanghai, and<br />
with other external partners to<br />
open up the ‘closed’ innovation<br />
funnel. Partnerships, both small<br />
and large, are the only way to make<br />
sustainable change happen.”<br />
Forward thinking<br />
Urban utopias represent a new area<br />
of study for Stenros. She is working<br />
on holistic future scenarios,<br />
With a growing proportion of the global<br />
population living in megacities, the smooth<br />
movement of people in congested settings<br />
is a key enabler of liveability.<br />
KONE provides tools to<br />
create a more functional and<br />
human urban fabric.<br />
learning from the bold visions laid<br />
out by the British avant-garde<br />
architect group Archigram during<br />
the 1960s and 1970s.<br />
“Archigram’s visions are now a<br />
reality,” she says. “We are also<br />
using foresight to imagine what<br />
the cities of tomorrow will look<br />
like. We are constantly monitoring<br />
micro and macro trends, and the<br />
capabilities we need to support our<br />
desired future vision.”<br />
Wide-ranging research explains<br />
why KONE is the industry leader in<br />
design innovation. One of the R&D<br />
areas in which the <strong>com</strong>pany invests<br />
generously is user-experience<br />
research, which studies how people<br />
respond when interacting with<br />
technology and their environment.<br />
Rigorous usability testing ensures<br />
that all user interfaces are fit<br />
for purpose, pleasant to use and<br />
entirely intuitive.<br />
“Users shouldn’t have to think<br />
about how our equipment works<br />
or how to get to their desired<br />
destination,” says Stenros. “This<br />
should be automatically obvious.”<br />
Local inspiration<br />
KONE is also active in a specialised<br />
area of design dedicated to colours,<br />
materials and finishes. Through<br />
trend research, KONE fine-tunes<br />
its designs to strike the right<br />
emotional chord in step with<br />
current tastes.<br />
But tastes vary. How does KONE<br />
ensure that its equipment is visually<br />
pleasing to different cultures?<br />
16<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
We will be seeing more intelligent<br />
elevators with integrated access control.<br />
Lighting, too, will play a greater role as<br />
a mood enhancer.<br />
“We create global concepts, but<br />
we localise them by changing their<br />
‘skin’,” explains Stenros. “Colours,<br />
patterns and material <strong>com</strong>binations<br />
are strong elements that touch the<br />
emotions. We work hard to create<br />
the right local impact.”<br />
In India, for example, people<br />
prefer much brighter tones than<br />
in Scandinavia. Stenros recently<br />
worked with a young Indian artist<br />
who added exuberant new shades<br />
to the KONE palette.<br />
“We love collaborating with local<br />
artists and designers because they<br />
inspire us and help us think outside<br />
the box,” she says. “And, of course,<br />
they know their culture best.”<br />
As well as the right cultural<br />
trimmings, what else<br />
goes into creating a great<br />
ambient experience?<br />
a bigger space,” says Stenros. “An<br />
elevator shouldn’t feel like a tin can.”<br />
Spine of the building<br />
One of the most exciting trends is<br />
‘elastic design’, which promises to<br />
make next-generation technology<br />
more intuitive than ever.<br />
“When I buy a new smartphone, for<br />
example, it takes a while before I<br />
learn to use it,” says Stenros. “In the<br />
future, I will teach the technology to<br />
understand me. It will adapt itself to<br />
my way of using it.”<br />
She describes elevators as the<br />
‘spine’ of the building and claims<br />
that they will be<strong>com</strong>e information<br />
centres equipped with Wi-Fi access<br />
or information screens. We will be<br />
seeing more intelligent elevators<br />
with integrated access control.<br />
Lighting, too, will play a greater role<br />
as a mood enhancer.<br />
“Easy access, pleasant lighting,<br />
good acoustics, optimum<br />
temperature, durable materials,<br />
attractive finishes, the right<br />
look and feel – inspiration for all<br />
senses,” explains Stenros. “There<br />
are countless ‘instruments’ that<br />
we blend together to create a<br />
harmonious mood. Beyond that, we<br />
want to create an uplifting feeling.<br />
We aim to inspire.”<br />
Elevators are one of the safest<br />
means of transportation, but<br />
some people have a natural<br />
aversion to riding in them. How<br />
can design help?<br />
“Glossy surfaces, mirrors and floating<br />
ceilings can conjure the illusion of<br />
Meanwhile, environmental<br />
requirements are growing<br />
tougher. “We have to ensure that<br />
all the materials we use are fully<br />
sustainable throughout their entire<br />
lifecycle, from sourcing to disposal.”<br />
Social innovation is another<br />
interesting domain. “How can we<br />
make elevators a <strong>com</strong>fortable place<br />
to interact?,” asks Stenros. “How<br />
can we benefit socially from this<br />
small, intimate space?”<br />
Wow factor<br />
Good design, Stenros emphasises,<br />
however you define it, is something<br />
from which everyone benefits.<br />
Users get better quality of life,<br />
architects get <strong>com</strong>ponents to<br />
Easy access, pleasant lighting and<br />
attractive finishes help make the<br />
elevator ride an enjoyable experience.<br />
match the image of the buildings<br />
they design and developers get a<br />
valuable branding tool.<br />
“A mall developer once told me<br />
that it’s pointless to offer highend<br />
brands if the mall itself<br />
doesn’t have a ‘wow’ factor,” says<br />
Stenros. “Shoppers will take their<br />
money elsewhere, because the<br />
same brands are everywhere. It’s<br />
a mistake to underestimate the<br />
sophistication of consumers.”<br />
When asked to define good design,<br />
Stenros fires off a confident reply.<br />
“It doesn’t have to scream for<br />
attention. It’s not just about looks<br />
or economics – it’s that certain<br />
something that inspires and energises<br />
you. Whether it’s a chair, car or<br />
elevator, good design supports who<br />
you are – and who you want to be.” ●<br />
Further information<br />
KONE<br />
www.kone.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
17
Insight > Construction<br />
© Snøhetta<br />
Snøhetta’s Memorial Museum<br />
Pavilion in New York.<br />
Foundations for<br />
remembrance<br />
Despite chronic delays, the National September 11<br />
Memorial is finally open, with work progressing on the<br />
museum. Bill Millard meets architects from Snøhetta<br />
and Davis Brody Bond, and hears why this high-profile<br />
public site calls for long-range thinking.<br />
Patience is not a quality<br />
generally attributed to<br />
Americans, particularly New<br />
Yorkers. As the tenth anniversary of<br />
the World Trade Center attack passed<br />
last September, even the dignified<br />
opening ceremony for the Memorial<br />
Plaza couldn’t dispel a sense of<br />
frustration at the time it has taken<br />
to realise the final version of Daniel<br />
Libeskind’s Ground Zero Master Plan.<br />
Four towers will eventually occupy<br />
the 16-acre site. Two are currently<br />
making significant progress: the<br />
revised 1 WTC by Skidmore, Owings<br />
and Merrill (no longer known as the<br />
Freedom Tower, and now New York’s<br />
tallest structure, having surpassed<br />
the Empire State Building on 30 April)<br />
and 4 WTC by Fumihiko Maki. On 2<br />
WTC by Foster + Partners and 3 WTC<br />
by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners,<br />
18<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Construction<br />
structural work proceeds for severely<br />
shortened designs, with construction<br />
schedules and full-height redesigns<br />
contingent on fundraising by<br />
developer Larry Silverstein.<br />
Attention to the towers can<br />
overshadow the site’s lower-level<br />
<strong>com</strong>ponents: the WTC Transportation<br />
Hub by Santiago Calatrava (slated for<br />
<strong>com</strong>pletion in 2015), the Memorial<br />
Plaza, the National September 11<br />
Museum by Davis Brody Bond<br />
(DBB), and the Museum Entry<br />
Pavilion by Norwegian/American<br />
firm Snøhetta. Amid all the security<br />
fencing, construction noise, and<br />
incessant presence of the local and<br />
global media, elements of a <strong>com</strong>plex<br />
public space are all emerging, but not<br />
quickly or steadily.<br />
Difficulties, delays<br />
and deadlines<br />
After a drastic revamp of the<br />
construction schedule and an<br />
expensive effort to <strong>com</strong>plete the<br />
plaza in time to honour a former<br />
governor’s pledge to victims’ families<br />
that it would open within a decade,<br />
a financial dispute between the Port<br />
Authority of New York and New<br />
Jersey (the site’s landowner) and the<br />
9/11 Memorial Foundation led to a<br />
delay in payment for subcontractors<br />
working on the museum. Work ground<br />
to a halt in the third quarter of 2011.<br />
A partial payment brought the subs<br />
some relief in April this year, and local<br />
business-press reports have suggested<br />
a mid-2013 <strong>com</strong>pletion date (revised<br />
from the optimistic previous estimate<br />
of 11 September 2012). Architects from<br />
the firms working on the museum and<br />
pavilion say it’s impossible to give a<br />
definitive date.<br />
Some New Yorkers and national<br />
pundits find it embarrassing that the<br />
US has not marshalled the financial,<br />
political or organisational resources<br />
to rebuild Ground Zero on a timetable<br />
rivaling those seen recently in China.<br />
The likelihood that it won’t appear in<br />
our lifetimes has be<strong>com</strong>e a <strong>com</strong>mon<br />
lament, in a city where kvetching<br />
<strong>com</strong>es as naturally as breathing.<br />
What strikes some observers as<br />
a symptom of cumbersome public<br />
processes and private obstructionism<br />
appears to others, particularly those<br />
closer to the site, as not a flaw but an<br />
inevitable, even admirable feature.<br />
These 16 acres are hallowed ground<br />
(particularly, but not exclusively, to<br />
the loved ones of the 2,983 victims<br />
whose names appear on the fountain<br />
parapets); for those lost in the twin<br />
towers, Ground Zero is their gravesite.<br />
It is also high-value land in a dense<br />
city with an acute need for open space.<br />
Construction within this tight<br />
site, shared by multiple projects and<br />
intersected below grade by active<br />
train lines, poses multidimensional,<br />
multivariate problems. The difficulties<br />
are chronological as well as spatial;<br />
along with solving problems of<br />
structure, circulation, security,<br />
lighting, materials and programme,<br />
the architects must remain aware<br />
of immediate and long-range<br />
imperatives that are often in tension.<br />
Reconciling these disparate<br />
impulses would be difficult<br />
regardless of distractions like<br />
political grandstanding and financial<br />
disputes. Most of what the public<br />
sees of Ground Zero is a massive<br />
construction site with airport-style<br />
controlled access – a hole filled with<br />
promises and money. What those<br />
working there observe is a series of<br />
transformations, the most radical of<br />
which remains invisible: a vast space<br />
that served as the original towers’<br />
underground garages is be<strong>com</strong>ing<br />
a shrine that preserves artefacts,<br />
memories and values. Rarely is<br />
architecture’s entanglement with<br />
hot-button philosophical and social<br />
questions as explicit as it is here.<br />
There is a strong case for not<br />
rushing the job. Carl Krebs, partner<br />
at DBB and a chief spokesman for<br />
the firm, suggests that the successful<br />
opening of the memorial has “in<br />
some degree given the foundation<br />
the ability to take some time [on<br />
the museum]. In a sense they’ve<br />
delivered a very important project to<br />
the public, and that has enabled them<br />
to be much more measured in these<br />
next steps.”<br />
Above and below<br />
The mission for both the memorial<br />
and museum is to do justice to<br />
the past, Snøhetta principal Craig<br />
Dykers notes, as the <strong>com</strong>mercial<br />
towers look toward the future.<br />
His firm’s pavilion links these<br />
elements, emphasising immediate<br />
present experience through its<br />
scale (three humble storeys seen<br />
from outside near the taller towers,<br />
then a deep and dramatic descent<br />
into its atrium), its forms (largely<br />
non-orthogonal, contrasting<br />
sharply with the symmetries of the<br />
square fountains), and its materials<br />
(especially its semi-reflective mattefinish<br />
stainless steel, which scatters<br />
light while hinting at legible images,<br />
acting as both lampshade and mirror<br />
to ‘grow light’).<br />
“Our framework of developing<br />
the geometry was based on how<br />
we could connect it to daily life and<br />
your normal range of vision, so the<br />
building is very horizontal in nature,”<br />
Dykers says. “It fits into your eye<br />
as you move through the street; it<br />
rises up from the ground plane and<br />
right where it touches the ground,<br />
you’re able to interact with the<br />
building directly through reflections<br />
in the façade. So there’s a sense that<br />
because of its diminutive size, its<br />
horizontal frame and its reflectivity,<br />
it is interacting with the daily life of<br />
those that pass by.”<br />
One of Snøhetta’s earlier<br />
projects, Cairo’s Alexandria Library,<br />
puts contemporary frustrations<br />
in perspective.<br />
“That was an undertaking that<br />
already had 2,000 years of history<br />
behind it, and it took us over a<br />
decade to <strong>com</strong>plete,” explains<br />
Dykers. “But as long as that might<br />
sound, it’s a third the length of time<br />
it took to <strong>com</strong>plete the British<br />
National Library.”<br />
If anything, the negotiations and<br />
decisions at the WTC strike him as<br />
moving too quickly.<br />
“These 16 acres are hallowed<br />
ground; for those lost<br />
in the twin towers, Ground Zero is<br />
their gravesite.”<br />
“Some aspects of the planning<br />
work could have been slower, to allow<br />
different factions to coalesce into<br />
more fluid attitudes and be managed<br />
easier during the design process.<br />
When things happen too quickly, it<br />
can polarise people quickly.”<br />
Recognising that the site will<br />
mature, he likens current reactions to<br />
“looking at a sonogram of a baby”.<br />
Snøhetta’s project manager Anne<br />
Lewison, having worked for 11 years<br />
on another building of great historic<br />
gravity, Pei Cobb Freed’s Holocaust<br />
Memorial in Washington, DC, notes<br />
that 50 years passed between the<br />
horrors being <strong>com</strong>memorated and that<br />
building’s design and construction.<br />
“The rush to finish that one was<br />
because the survivors were dying,”<br />
she explains. “[The 9/11 Museum is]<br />
much more a memorial for people<br />
who have no cemetery, no gravestone,<br />
no marker and the existence of the<br />
marker is tremendously important<br />
in this generation of its life. This<br />
memorial, I think, will have a different<br />
tone in 20 years. It was designed and<br />
built very freshly after the event, with<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
19
Insight > Construction<br />
what I would consider emotions still<br />
profoundly felt and close to the surface.”<br />
Time and relationships<br />
Memory of the 9/11 trauma is<br />
steadily exchanging immediacy<br />
for longer perspective; the trees<br />
will grow, and the surfaces acquire<br />
patinas. At the same time, the<br />
popular relation to the site is likely<br />
to mature as well. War memorials<br />
as a typology of large-scale public<br />
space, Lewison observes, are rarer<br />
in the US than in Europe. Aside<br />
from relatively scarce battlegrounds<br />
or monuments from the American<br />
Revolution, the Civil War and<br />
conflicts between Native Americans<br />
and settlers, history has largely<br />
spared US land the burdens and<br />
scars of military attack.<br />
The great concrete slurry wall<br />
held back the water pressure<br />
from the Hudson.<br />
© Michael Arad and Peter Walker<br />
“Arlington Cemetery is one of<br />
the only ones of this magnitude<br />
and solemnity,” says Lewison. “Our<br />
cultural experiences tend to be more<br />
entertainment-based.”<br />
Lewison finds that the site often<br />
generates reactions of patriotism and<br />
resilience among Americans, while<br />
international visitors tend to respond<br />
with solemnity and a sense of solidarity<br />
rather than ‘ownership’. Children<br />
visiting the memorial, too, run and<br />
throw gravel as they would do in any<br />
park; appropriate use of such a space<br />
is a learned behaviour. This cultural<br />
context affects design decisions: in<br />
a setting where the programme’s<br />
inherent gravitas is anomalous, the<br />
pavilion and museum need to reconcile<br />
the imperatives of education, security,<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity, fidelity and dignity.<br />
The experience of visiting the<br />
museum, DBB’s architects agree,<br />
best honours its subject by rejecting<br />
excessive programming or packaging.<br />
Circulation is one way, but didactic<br />
texts are de-emphasised, especially<br />
at critical points like the column base<br />
of the original towers, so as to avoid<br />
narrowing visitors’ interpretation of<br />
the events and their background.<br />
Aware that “everybody who <strong>com</strong>es<br />
to this museum has had a 9/11<br />
experience”, as Krebs notes, and that<br />
some factions want the museum to<br />
tell their 9/11 story and their story<br />
alone, DBB and the curators lean<br />
toward letting the site’s features and<br />
contents speak for themselves.<br />
Form and control<br />
Ground Zero’s heightened security<br />
concerns present further questions<br />
of control.<br />
“The museum is a very emotionally<br />
challenging experience to begin with<br />
and it doesn’t need to be made any<br />
more painful,” says Krebs.<br />
Security must be tight, with<br />
screening at the pavilion and<br />
cameras ubiquitous (if discreet).<br />
“The entire site is under incredible<br />
scrutiny,” Krebs says. “One of the<br />
things the Port Authority did was<br />
to implement a series of site-wide<br />
standards, so each of the projects<br />
meets certain requirements...<br />
beyond typical code requirements<br />
for security, egress, and life safety.”<br />
Snøhetta’s Lewison puts it<br />
succinctly: “We really had to design<br />
a bunker without it looking like a<br />
bunker at all.”<br />
One enters the museum from the<br />
plaza, “taking you from the world of<br />
“Libeskind views the slurry wall as<br />
a strong metaphor for democratic<br />
values and institutions that held<br />
fast under attack.”<br />
the city into the precinct of the 9/11<br />
dead,” as Krebs says, passing first<br />
through the pavilion and descending<br />
via escalator or stairs past an<br />
enormous icon of the original towers:<br />
a pair of trident columns salvaged<br />
from the attack site. This is one of<br />
many artefacts that emphasise the<br />
scale of the destroyed buildings and<br />
the immensity of the loss; the space<br />
itself is another.<br />
Curator Alice Greenwald notes<br />
that the museum is “a site where the<br />
foundations still exist in situ. So, in<br />
many respects, where other museums<br />
are buildings that house artefacts,<br />
we’re a museum sitting within one”.<br />
Gradually acclimating the visitor to<br />
the space’s strangeness and power,<br />
a ‘ribbon ramp’ of gently descending<br />
planes with a prominent switchback<br />
at an observation point above the<br />
main floor makes the approach a<br />
logical procession through dramatic<br />
moments and positions. The main<br />
museum space is cathedral-sized,<br />
with 60ft-high ceilings, large enough<br />
to contain either the Guggenheim<br />
Museum or the Whitney Museum of<br />
American Art.<br />
The final descent to this floor<br />
passes the Survivor Stairway, the<br />
last above-ground remnant of the<br />
ruined <strong>com</strong>plex and a route to safety<br />
for hundreds of evacuees during the<br />
attack, preserved and moved across<br />
the site to join the other exhibition<br />
features, including individual profiles<br />
of each victim, steel fragments<br />
(some mutilated by the attack and<br />
some during lifesaving efforts), a<br />
crushed taxicab, part of the north<br />
tower’s broadcast antenna, and the<br />
final salvaged and graffiti-inscribed<br />
box column.<br />
Meaningful access<br />
The master plan mandates that the<br />
museum provide “meaningful access”<br />
to various features: the bedrock of<br />
Manhattan schist that originally<br />
supported the towers, the shearedoff<br />
box-column bases, the tower<br />
footprints and the concrete slurry<br />
wall that held back water pressure<br />
from the Hudson (preventing an even<br />
greater disaster). Libeskind views the<br />
slurry wall as a strong metaphor for<br />
democratic values and institutions<br />
that held fast under attack, and it<br />
has consequently been designated a<br />
historic asset; marking a centrepiece<br />
of the museum, its massive<br />
tiebacks protrude as mute sentinels<br />
overseeing the space and resisting<br />
static pressure.<br />
“What you see is not actually<br />
original concrete,” says Krebs. “It’s<br />
this remedial concrete that was put<br />
on it after the period of recovery, a<br />
testament to the recovery of the site.”<br />
It also contrasts strongly with the<br />
crisp, polished concrete of the new<br />
flooring, which almost resembles<br />
terrazzo, and the excavated sections<br />
that expose large chunks of the<br />
20<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
CHOOSE<br />
YOUR STYLE,<br />
MAKE THE<br />
DIFFERENCE<br />
3M DI-NOC <br />
Architectural Finishes<br />
More than 500 Patterns,<br />
Unlimited Creativity.<br />
A range of films which recreate the effects<br />
of natural materials and laminates.<br />
Visit www.3M.eu/ArchitecturalMarkets for the most current,<br />
up-to-date information and free samples.<br />
ADV 3M Di-Noc LeafReview 3.indd 1 24/05/12 16.41<br />
A REVOLUTION IN WOOD<br />
Until recently, beautiful wood types were<br />
traditionally associated with rain forest<br />
wood. Kebony has changed all that.<br />
Choose Kebony – a revolutionary new organic modification of<br />
wood. As aesthetic, strong and durable as rain forest wood, yet<br />
100 % environmentally friendly. Read more at www.kebony.<strong>com</strong><br />
Bexhill Pavillions/Brighton<br />
1988_Annonse The Leaf Review.indd 1 28.11.11 11.07
Insight > Construction<br />
The museum’s interior features the final salvaged and graffiti-inscribed box column.<br />
“Finally re-emerging into open<br />
space will offer ample<br />
opportunities to <strong>com</strong>prehend the<br />
event’s personal and<br />
cultural meanings.”<br />
foundations. Associate partner<br />
Joseph Grant finds that these<br />
materials, some from the 1970s<br />
and some post-attack, encode the<br />
building’s history.<br />
“You’re seeing a <strong>com</strong>bination of<br />
what the original building was and<br />
what the restoration process required<br />
the site to be<strong>com</strong>e,” he says.<br />
The juxtaposition of refined and<br />
industrial elements is a recurring<br />
motif throughout.<br />
“We didn’t want this to look<br />
like the perfect beautiful concrete<br />
building,” Krebs adds. “Having some<br />
roughness or inconsistency in the<br />
concrete is part of the atmosphere of<br />
being in this deep hole.”<br />
The tower footprints are now<br />
embodied as the plaza’s north and<br />
south fountains. Correcting early<br />
plans in which street-grid restoration<br />
prevented the north pool from<br />
precisely matching the north tower<br />
site, Krebs reports, both are now<br />
exactly where the towers stood.<br />
“From the perspective of the<br />
museum,” he says, “it was actually<br />
critical, we felt, to get them to align,<br />
because when you got down to the<br />
column bases, there was going to be<br />
no ability to fake it.”<br />
Above the column stumps, the<br />
undersides of these pools hang some<br />
30ft from the plaza surface into the<br />
exhibition space, underlit and clad in<br />
an eyecatching recycled aluminium<br />
foam (Cymat Alusion, a lightweight<br />
aerospace material) that, Krebs says,<br />
“accepts the light in an incredibly<br />
liquid way [and] has this ethereal,<br />
ghostly quality. It almost be<strong>com</strong>es a<br />
cloud of light.” It is also an abstract<br />
reference to the aluminium cladding<br />
of the original towers, transformed<br />
into something irregularly textured,<br />
nearly organic.<br />
These volumes are a central<br />
organising feature of the space,<br />
imparting a sense of vast scale<br />
matching that of the fountains above.<br />
Instead of subdivision into smaller<br />
sequential galleries, and a screening<br />
room added beneath the south tower,<br />
this museum uses an open plan.<br />
“We knew we had to ac<strong>com</strong>modate<br />
a lot of flexible space for that kind<br />
of interpretive exhibit, almost<br />
black-box space,” Krebs explains.<br />
“So, trying to do that, whether it<br />
was consciously or not, we slowly<br />
evolved into a process where the<br />
public spaces are really about the insitu<br />
artifacts, the envelope, the big<br />
pieces of relics, but the footprints<br />
themselves were carved out as really<br />
distinct environments that could<br />
handle media, graphics and smallerscale<br />
objects.”<br />
Towards the light<br />
Returning to the plaza, the visitor will<br />
have <strong>com</strong>pleted a process of descent<br />
and ascent that mirrors and inverts<br />
© DBB<br />
the path taken by survivors who<br />
escaped their burning workplaces<br />
through corridors and fire stairs. If<br />
it is conventional to associate an<br />
increase in altitude with a positive<br />
movement toward light, contrasting<br />
with the ‘descent through the<br />
underworld’ motif undertaken by<br />
countless mythological heroes, the<br />
experience of passing through this<br />
museum, contemplating the atrocity<br />
itself and the instances of rescue and<br />
sacrifice recorded on that day, then<br />
finally re-emerging into open space<br />
will offer ample opportunities to<br />
<strong>com</strong>prehend the event’s personal<br />
and cultural meanings.<br />
“We also see the plaza as really<br />
the last experience in the visit to<br />
the museum, because you’ve seen<br />
the story, you’ve heard the stories<br />
of people who went through the<br />
events, and you <strong>com</strong>e back up to the<br />
memorial, and maybe potentially you<br />
see the memorial again in a different<br />
light,” Krebs explains.<br />
No constructed space can<br />
<strong>com</strong>pletely dictate its possible uses,<br />
but through exhibits, educational<br />
presentations and respectful<br />
design decisions alike, the National<br />
September 11 Museum and Memorial<br />
will strive to emphasise the gravity<br />
of the event and of the most forwardthinking<br />
responses to it.<br />
Greenwald speaks of the sense of<br />
awe produced by the west chamber,<br />
which includes the majestic slurry<br />
wall, as representative of the<br />
intended overall effect.<br />
“In a sense it be<strong>com</strong>es the<br />
foundation not of the buildings<br />
that aren’t there any more; it’s the<br />
foundation of the world we’re going<br />
to build going out of this museum,<br />
and <strong>com</strong>mitting ourselves to, a<br />
world in which you don’t have to<br />
fly planes into buildings to make a<br />
point,” he says.<br />
Destruction, after all, is the ultimate<br />
act of inarticulacy and immaturity. A<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity’s efforts to rise above that<br />
level take time – and deserve it. ●<br />
22<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
More than just<br />
a simple switch<br />
Corlo Touch:<br />
jewellery for<br />
interiors.<br />
Building technology is the perfect <strong>com</strong>bination of flexible technical solutions, <strong>com</strong>fortable<br />
operation and forward-looking design. That is why even today, all of Elsner Elektronik’s<br />
sensors, actuators and operating units are developed and manufactured to the highest standard.<br />
Elsner Elektronik’s new<br />
operating display, Corlo Touch,<br />
found the approval of visitors<br />
at the Light+Building 2012 fair in<br />
Frankfurt, Germany.<br />
Thanks to the touch-sensitive surface,<br />
Corlo Touch’s KNX touch display can<br />
be used as a normal switch or adapted<br />
to suit different needs. The brilliant<br />
screen shows values and messages,<br />
as well as pictures. At the same time,<br />
Corlo Touch is an operation unit for<br />
automatic sun screen, ventilation and<br />
room conditions.<br />
As well as exchange via the KNX<br />
connection, Corlo Touch can receive<br />
data by Mini SD card and USB.<br />
This way, pictures and icons can be<br />
transmitted easily. The LAN version of<br />
Corlo Touch can show websites, live<br />
camera pictures or any other data from<br />
the IP network. The current display can<br />
be also visualised on a smartphone.<br />
The Corlo Touch has a glass surface,<br />
and the frame is chrome-plated<br />
and available as one, two or threegang<br />
versions. The touch display<br />
reacts very quickly and is ready for<br />
<strong>com</strong>mands, even in energy-saving<br />
mode. A sensor registers the user’s<br />
approach and switches on the device<br />
even before it is touched. An ambient<br />
light with selectable colour makes<br />
sure Corlo Touch adapts to the room<br />
perfectly. All of these details turn the<br />
Corlo Touch into a piece of jewellery<br />
for high-class interiors. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Elsner Elektronik<br />
www.elsner-elektronik.de<br />
It‘s a switch<br />
an elegant solution for manual operation.<br />
It‘s a room controller<br />
for adjustment of conditions in smart buildings.<br />
It‘s an info display<br />
for messages, (motion) pictures and web pages<br />
that also connects with your smartphone.<br />
It‘s Corlo Touch<br />
Elsner Elektronik GmbH<br />
Building Automation<br />
Herdweg 7<br />
75391 Gechingen<br />
Germany<br />
Phone: +49 7056/93 97-0<br />
info@elsner-elektronik.de<br />
www.elsner-elektronik.de<br />
m a d e i n g e r m a n y<br />
Works with the<br />
Available from 3 rd quarter of 2012.<br />
Picture about original size.<br />
bus system.<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
23
Insight > Construction<br />
Increasing urban density and rising sea levels lend<br />
weight to the argument of building on water as an<br />
alternative to freeing up vital urban space.<br />
But how feasible is the concept, in terms of<br />
design and sustainability? Ross Davies speaks<br />
to the most notable leaders in the field about<br />
how cities could extend well beyond their<br />
levees in the <strong>com</strong>ing years.<br />
Atlantis<br />
rising<br />
among us hasn’t at one<br />
point wanted to ditch it all and<br />
“Who<br />
start afresh on a desert island?”<br />
So says George Petrie when I call him at his<br />
Houston home. Petrie is director of engineering<br />
at the Seasteading Institute, a US-based think<br />
tank dedicated to the creation of independent<br />
sovereign states on the world’s seas as an<br />
alternative to “today’s political systems”.<br />
“The bad news is that there are no deserted<br />
islands left,” he continues. “Every piece of<br />
land on the planet has been claimed by at<br />
least one country. So you need to build your<br />
own island, so to speak.”<br />
The concept of floating utopian<br />
principalities may well smack of blue-sky<br />
thinking, but politics aside, it does touch<br />
upon two salient issues at hand that<br />
are threatening to hamstring some of<br />
the world’s largest cities.<br />
In line with rising urbanisation,<br />
city infrastructures are facing<br />
unprecedented space<br />
constraints. And with<br />
the world’s population<br />
forecasted to hit nine<br />
billion in 2015,<br />
the endemic<br />
24<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Construction<br />
is showing no signs of dissipating.<br />
There is also the insidious threat of<br />
rising tides to consider – the UN’s<br />
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate<br />
Change (IPCC) predicts that sea levels<br />
will have risen by 18–59cm by 2100.<br />
Given that several of the world’s<br />
metropolises, including the likes of<br />
New York, Tokyo, Shanghai, Sydney<br />
and Mumbai, are found on the<br />
coast, governments and city<br />
planners may soon face the tough<br />
task of either having to extend<br />
conurbations further into the<br />
hinterland, or break out beyond<br />
their seafronts and build on water.<br />
It would seem that many would<br />
do well to follow the lead of the<br />
Netherlands. With about 50% of land<br />
lying below sea level, the country has<br />
notably spent centuries constructing<br />
dams, dykes and canals in order to<br />
fend off water. However, according<br />
to Koen Olthuis, founder of Dutchbased<br />
architecture firm Waterstudio,<br />
in recent years this approach has<br />
parlayed into “embracing” the<br />
country’s nexus of waterways.<br />
“The Netherlands has effectively<br />
been an artificial country for<br />
hundreds of years,” he says. “We<br />
have always fought against water for<br />
one reason – to get space. However,<br />
these days, this entails actually<br />
working with it. And it’s not just for<br />
here – it can apply to anywhere.”<br />
Water world<br />
Olthuis, who was once ranked by<br />
readers of TIME magazine as the<br />
122nd most influential person in the<br />
world, is a trailblazer in the field of<br />
aqua architecture. In his homeland,<br />
he has played a pivotal part in the<br />
development of water houses, such<br />
as those found in Amsterdam’s<br />
IJburg district, the world’s first<br />
floating residential neighbourhood.<br />
The buildings are supported by<br />
moored, pontoon-like structures<br />
<strong>com</strong>prised of foam bodies encased<br />
in concrete – not dissimilar to the<br />
floating structures used in the<br />
offshore industry.<br />
As a result, Amsterdam has<br />
effectively adjusted and expanded<br />
its parameters to house citizens.<br />
And, as Olthuis infers, such<br />
projects aren’t solely confined to<br />
his homeland.<br />
Through his other venture, Dutch<br />
Docklands, he is in the process<br />
of transferring the practice to the<br />
Maldives. Commissioned by former<br />
president Mohamed Nasheed, the<br />
firm is currently engineering a<br />
floating golf course and resort in the<br />
region, which will be interconnected<br />
by a network of underwater tunnels.<br />
The project is set to cost in the<br />
region of $500 million and should be<br />
<strong>com</strong>pleted by 2015.<br />
The South Pacific archipelago<br />
– at the mercy of its surrounding<br />
“City planners may soon face the tough task of either<br />
having to extend conurbations further into the<br />
hinterland, or break out beyond their Seafronts and<br />
build on water.”<br />
waters since time immemorial –<br />
could benefit exponentially from the<br />
development. The resort has been<br />
designed to ramp up the country’s<br />
tourism trade – essential to its<br />
economy – while also paving the<br />
way for further residential floating<br />
structures in the future.<br />
“The idea is that if you can<br />
build a floating golf course, you<br />
can use the same technology<br />
for floating housing, as well as<br />
agriculture and energy,” he says.<br />
“There’s a market emerging in terms<br />
of challenging urbanisation and<br />
climate change. The project in the<br />
1<br />
2<br />
1. Olthuis’ Sea Tree: architecture exclusively for flora and fauna.<br />
2. S+PBA’s Wetropolis, Bangkok.<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
25
Your specialist<br />
for translucent<br />
building elements<br />
RODECA: the inventor and one of the market leaders in the<br />
field of translucent facade cladding.<br />
Diversity and quality are what characterises the product range<br />
of RODECA: whether transparent construction elements for<br />
the wall, roof and facade design, the design series for colourful<br />
highlights, or <strong>com</strong>plete system solutions from modular elements<br />
– building contractors, planners and architects invariably profit<br />
from our product range.<br />
PC 3560-12<br />
a 60mm thick panel with<br />
12 chambers achieves<br />
an Up-Value from 0.71<br />
to 0.77 W/m²K depending<br />
on the installation situation<br />
Thanks to the multilayered structure, translucent building<br />
elements and multi-wall sheets offer optimum heat insulation<br />
for energy-efficient facade and roof glazing and establish new<br />
standards in transparent heat insulation<br />
www.rodeca.de<br />
Depending on the type of construction and specific initial situation,<br />
energy consumption can be reduced by up to 80%.<br />
Rodeca has more than 40 years experience in the extrusion of<br />
polycarbonate panels and multiwall sheets and their pioneering<br />
spirit has already left its mark in many of the major cities.
Insight > Construction<br />
Maldives could make a real impact<br />
in this area.”<br />
Sink or swim<br />
Across the Bay of Bengal, Thailand<br />
is facing a similar danger. Bangkok,<br />
built on silt and swampland, is<br />
slowly sinking. Throw in a booming<br />
urban density – the city’s population<br />
has passed the ten million mark<br />
– and the capital’s future hangs<br />
un<strong>com</strong>fortably in the balance.<br />
In response, local architects such<br />
as S+PBA are looking beyond the<br />
banks of the brimming Chao Phraya<br />
River as a means of sustainably<br />
freeing up space – particularly<br />
pertinent given the country’s<br />
ill-conceived deforestation<br />
programmes of the past.<br />
Last year, the group published a<br />
paper entitled ‘A Post-Diluvian Future’<br />
1. Floating modular structures will house Wetropolis inhabitants.<br />
2. The Wetropolis project extends into the Chao Phraya River.<br />
addressing the possibility of building<br />
on water. The report proposes the<br />
construction of the artificial city<br />
‘Wetropolis’, in which <strong>com</strong>munities<br />
would be housed on a set of floating<br />
modular structures, framed by a<br />
network of bridge-like steel arcs.<br />
“Wetropolis may be the only way<br />
for people living along the coastal<br />
areas to survive,” says Songsuda<br />
Adhibai, a senior partner at the<br />
firm. “The design would certainly<br />
1<br />
2<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
27
Insight > Construction<br />
1<br />
2<br />
1. London’s Floating Village will be mobile.<br />
2. Floating apartments by Waterstudio.<br />
minimise our footprint, as well. Our<br />
aim is for it to be a city with a low<br />
impact on the natural environment,<br />
where humans can co-exist with<br />
nature symbiotically.”<br />
As well as bridging sociological<br />
and ecological gaps, some believe<br />
that building on water may, in fact,<br />
offer an additional aesthetical boon<br />
to cities, especially with regards<br />
to the revival of disused and<br />
dilapidated harbours and seafronts.<br />
Christophe Egret is one such<br />
proponent of this argument. Egret,<br />
who contributed to the Royal<br />
Institute of British Architects’ (RIBA)<br />
2010 report ‘Facing up to Rising Sea<br />
Levels’, is a founding partner<br />
of London-based architecture<br />
practice Studio Egret West.<br />
In October, the firm won planning<br />
<strong>com</strong>mission to design and construct<br />
London’s Floating Village around<br />
the city’s Royal Docks. Work is set to<br />
<strong>com</strong>mence after the 2012 Olympics.<br />
“We are hoping that the village<br />
could symbolise the regeneration<br />
of the docks and really animate<br />
the space, which has been empty<br />
for so long,” he says. “It will house<br />
a swimming pool, as well as<br />
restaurants, cafés and bars. Also,<br />
the beautiful thing about a floating<br />
structure, such as a pontoon, is that<br />
it is mobile and can be moved from<br />
A to B if needs be.”<br />
Changing perception<br />
The architectural <strong>com</strong>munity would<br />
appear to be in agreement that, in<br />
terms of technology, building on<br />
water is more than viable. Today’s<br />
cruise megaships, which can<br />
carry over 3,000 passengers, are<br />
<strong>com</strong>monly cited as the “If they can,<br />
why can’t we?” benchmark. The<br />
same goes for offshore platforms,<br />
upon which personnel can be<br />
billeted for several months at a time.<br />
According to Olthuis, the real<br />
challenge may <strong>com</strong>e in convincing<br />
the general public that such<br />
structures offer real social benefits,<br />
as opposed to mere novelty factor<br />
and architectural grandstanding.<br />
“For us, the biggest battle is to<br />
change perceptions; the minds<br />
of normal people,” he says.<br />
“That is to say that living on<br />
water can be exactly the same<br />
as on land, and that space on<br />
water is just as valuable.”<br />
Nonetheless, Olthuis has gone<br />
some way towards dispelling such<br />
scepticism, as demonstrated by his<br />
latest project, the Sea Tree.<br />
Issued at the start of the year, the<br />
rendering of a multitiered tower<br />
located in the heart of New York’s<br />
Upper Bay – designed as a haven<br />
for flora and fauna endangered by<br />
urban pollution – was met with<br />
considerable public interest as a<br />
result of its ingenuity.<br />
In light of such efforts, we may<br />
well see more architects follow suit<br />
in reimagining water: not as an<br />
intractable force of nature, but that<br />
of prized and abundant real estate,<br />
which could sustain the urban<br />
landscape for many generations<br />
to <strong>com</strong>e.<br />
And, who knows, George Petrie’s<br />
vision of autonomous kingdoms on<br />
the waves may one day not seem so<br />
radical after all. ●<br />
© Koen Olthuis<br />
28<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Cradle-to-cradle flooring:<br />
recyclability as standard<br />
Shaw Contact Group offers a <strong>com</strong>plete line of fully certified<br />
recyclable flooring solutions for <strong>com</strong>mercial applications.<br />
Imagine if we designed buildings<br />
and their contents to be recycled.<br />
How drastically would that affect<br />
our impact upon the environment?<br />
The cradle-to-cradle philosophy takes<br />
its cues from nature’s own cycle of<br />
reuse by focusing on creating products<br />
that will be deconstructed and recycled<br />
into their original materials, over and<br />
over again. Shaw Contract Group, the<br />
world’s first flooring manufacturer<br />
to leverage Cradle to Cradle<br />
certification, now boasts a <strong>com</strong>plete<br />
line of fully certified recyclable<br />
flooring solutions for <strong>com</strong>mercial<br />
applications. These include:<br />
• carpet tile and broadloom –<br />
EcoWorx is a PVC-free,<br />
bitumen-free, fully recyclable<br />
backing that delivers highperformance<br />
durability and is<br />
made of 44% recycled content<br />
• hardsurface − Shaw hardwoods<br />
have recycled wood at their<br />
core and a surface designed to<br />
withstand the high traffic of a<br />
<strong>com</strong>mercial environment<br />
• certified installation<br />
solutions − LokDots is a virtually<br />
VOC-free installation alternative<br />
to traditional wet adhesive, ideal<br />
for high-moisture or occupied<br />
space installations.<br />
With more than 270 Silver-certified<br />
products, Shaw Contract Group has the<br />
most diverse and <strong>com</strong>plete catalogue of<br />
cradle-to-cradle solutions. ●<br />
Shaw’s No Rules range of<br />
high-quality carpet tiles allows<br />
designers freedom and creativity.<br />
Further information<br />
Shaw Contract Group<br />
www.shawcontractgroup.<strong>com</strong><br />
ON THE EDGE COLLECTION | VERTICAL EDGE TILE<br />
DESIGN IS<br />
More than 4,000 colours and styles, fully customisable, thoroughly sustainable Waste is not an option.<br />
COMMERCIAL TILE, BROADLOOM & HARDWOOD<br />
www.shawcontractgroup.<strong>com</strong> | London Showroom: 0207 490 4006<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
29
Company insight<br />
Seamless strength<br />
and beauty in stone<br />
The Cosentino Group is a global leading <strong>com</strong>pany, focusing its activity on the<br />
design, production and distribution of quartz, recycled and other natural stone<br />
surfaces for <strong>com</strong>mercial and domestic projects.<br />
Cosentino’s most important<br />
brands include the<br />
leading quartz surface<br />
Silestone and ECO by Cosentino,<br />
a revolutionary surface made from<br />
75% recycled materials.<br />
Functional, beautiful and extremely<br />
hygienic, Silestone quartz work<br />
surfaces are <strong>com</strong>posed of over 90%<br />
natural quartz crystals; only three<br />
other natural minerals – diamond,<br />
sapphire and topaz – are harder<br />
than quartz.<br />
Ideal qualities<br />
Perfect for use in <strong>com</strong>mercial and<br />
consumer projects, Silestone has<br />
bacteriostatic protection, nearly<br />
five times the flexural strength<br />
of granite, and high resistance to<br />
scratches, stains and heat. With a<br />
ten-year warranty, Silestone is the<br />
ideal surface for use in a variety of<br />
applications, including work surfaces,<br />
bar/reception tops, flooring, vanity<br />
units, splashbacks and wall cladding.<br />
Silestone is available in more<br />
than 60 distinctive through-body<br />
Silostone sinks <strong>com</strong>e in a<br />
range of colours and finishes.<br />
colours, with a shade and tone<br />
consistency that is not found with<br />
natural stone. It also has three<br />
textures: polished, leather (slightly<br />
matt) and Volcano (textured).<br />
Silestone slabs without joints<br />
are available in two sizes<br />
(1.38m×3.04m and 1.57m×3.25m)<br />
and three thicknesses (1.2cm, 2cm<br />
and 3cm). Silestone tiles are also<br />
available in five sizes (60×30cm,<br />
60×40cm, 60×60cm, 40×40cm<br />
and 30×30cm).<br />
Silestone can be used as work surfaces,<br />
flooring, splashbacks or cladding.<br />
Perfect for use in <strong>com</strong>mercial and consumer<br />
projects, Silestone has bacteriostatic protection,<br />
five times the flexural strength of granite and<br />
high resistance to scratches, stains and heat.<br />
Silestone can be seen in some of<br />
the world’s unique, high-profile<br />
constructions, such as the Hotel<br />
Burj Al Arab in Dubai, London’s<br />
Wembley Stadium, the Carrousel<br />
du Louvre in Paris, the Torre Agbar<br />
in Barcelona, and Telefónica’s<br />
flagship centre in Madrid.<br />
Silestone Integrity sinks<br />
Following extensive research,<br />
innovation and development,<br />
Cosentino introduced the Silestone<br />
Integrity DUE sinks, made from one<br />
piece of Silestone, which means<br />
there are no weak areas or joints.<br />
The sink integrates perfectly with<br />
the worktop for a continuous sleek<br />
design and has all the benefits of a<br />
Silestone product.<br />
Available in a wide range of<br />
colours, DUE sinks <strong>com</strong>e in two<br />
sizes and provide clean, straight<br />
lines for drainage. The first sink<br />
measures 37×34×15.5cm and is<br />
ideal for double sink spaces; while<br />
the second, with dimensions of<br />
37×51×15.5cm, is a great choice for<br />
a single sink.<br />
The DUE sinks can also be teamed<br />
together to create a popular oneand-a-half<br />
sink design. The original<br />
Silestone Integrity ONE sink<br />
measures 41×51×15.5cm.<br />
ECO by Cosentino<br />
Available in an array of beautiful<br />
colours, the stunning ECO by<br />
Cosentino surfaces are <strong>com</strong>posed<br />
of 75% recycled materials, including<br />
mirrors and glass for striking<br />
designs that are also extremely<br />
durable, with high stain, scratch<br />
and scorch-resistance.<br />
Available in jumbo slabs of<br />
327×159cm, as well as standard tile<br />
sizes, ECO by Cosentino is ideal for<br />
use in a huge range of applications,<br />
including work surfaces, flooring<br />
and wall cladding. The large slabs<br />
allow for a higher square footage<br />
of material per container, therefore<br />
minimising the product’s carbon<br />
footprint, and providing a higher<br />
yield of material during fabrication<br />
that reduces seams and waste. The<br />
slabs are available in 1.2cm, 2cm<br />
and 3cm thicknesses to respond to<br />
varying market needs. ●<br />
Further information<br />
The Cosentino Group<br />
www.cosentinogroup.net<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
31
Company insight<br />
All-round cover<br />
As well as providing sun protection, Markilux awnings <strong>com</strong>e in many styles and offer a host of impressive technical functions.<br />
Lifestyle awnings by Markilux provide practical<br />
functions, such as quiet opening and closing<br />
operations via a special sound system.<br />
manufacturer has, over the course<br />
of 40 years, focused on designing<br />
convenience awnings that have<br />
intelligent functions. As a result, the<br />
firm offers a range of products with<br />
different technical capabilities.<br />
Awning with an integrated<br />
illumination system.<br />
Typically, an awning provides<br />
protection from the sun,<br />
gives shade and perhaps<br />
adds a touch of colour to a<br />
building’s façade. Yet Markilux, the<br />
German awning specialist of stylish<br />
and technically innovative sun<br />
protection, can show that awnings<br />
do far more than just provide<br />
shade, protection and colour.<br />
Optimised design<br />
Robust, easy-to-maintain and durable<br />
materials are the basis of Markilux’s<br />
high-quality lifestyle awnings;<br />
however, as well as providing<br />
classic sun-protection equipment,<br />
the creative awning and textiles<br />
Practical functions<br />
New Silentec technology ensures<br />
that the automated opening of the<br />
awning is quiet, while some awning<br />
designs incorporate a sounding<br />
body through which relaxing<br />
music is played.<br />
A range of illumination systems<br />
create atmospheric accent lighting<br />
or the ‘schattenplus’ function – an<br />
awning within an awning that<br />
provides protection, even when the<br />
sun is low in the sky.<br />
The Skylife system raises the centre<br />
of the awning into an apex for<br />
improved rainwater drainage, while<br />
dirt and water-repellent materials<br />
ensure that the awnings and<br />
sun-protection fabrics, which offer<br />
maximum UV protection, continue<br />
to look attractive for long periods.<br />
Markilux is one of the largest German<br />
brand names and for more than<br />
a quarter of a century it has been<br />
devoted to making life on the balcony<br />
and patio even more enjoyable.<br />
Markilux focuses on multifunctional<br />
products that are well-designed,<br />
durable, stylish and easy to handle,<br />
making awnings more than just a<br />
classic sun-protection product. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Markilux<br />
www.markilux.<strong>com</strong><br />
32<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
safe • timeless • beautiful<br />
„The markilux ES-1:<br />
design and technology<br />
in perfect harmony.“<br />
markilux 1700<br />
Patio awning with round, fluid lines and attractive<br />
teardrop shape at sides. Available in two versions:<br />
· “open” where cover can be seen when awning is closed<br />
· “full-cassette” where cover goes back <strong>com</strong>pletely<br />
into the cassette when awning is closed<br />
For more information please contact us:<br />
markilux (UK) Ltd. · Tel. 01244 650170 · www.markilux.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Stone vision<br />
by tradition<br />
SF Kooperation is an international group of leading<br />
building materials and paving stone producers that<br />
offers specialist services for its members.<br />
INTERLOCKING PAVINGS AND SHAPED STONES<br />
For all roads, paths and public squares. Interlocking pavings<br />
are stable and particularly robust in areas subject to heavy<br />
loads and shear stresses.<br />
Further information and the addresses of your local paving<br />
stone manufacturers are available on the internet at:<br />
SF-Kooperation GmbH, Beton-Konzepte<br />
P.O Box 77 03 10 . D-28703 Bremen . GERMANY<br />
Telefon +49 (0)421 / 6 93 53 80<br />
Telefax +49 (0)421 / 6 93 53 99<br />
e-mail: info@sf-kooperation.de<br />
The The international association<br />
of leading of leading concrete stone producers<br />
SF Kooperation’s paving<br />
stones offer architecturally<br />
appealing solutions<br />
for public, <strong>com</strong>mercial and<br />
private sector applications.<br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany was founded in<br />
1970 as a cooperative alliance of<br />
S-shaped full interlocking block<br />
manufacturers.<br />
With more than 40 years of<br />
technological and design<br />
expertise, SF has developed<br />
into an international group of<br />
leading building material and<br />
paving stone producers.<br />
Even today, the S-shaped block is<br />
one of the most successful concrete<br />
paving stones in use.<br />
The aim of SF is to secure the<br />
business success of its members<br />
by providing a range of services,<br />
of which the most important<br />
is product development – from<br />
preliminary ideas for construction<br />
and design through to perfect<br />
definition and presentation<br />
of the product.<br />
Research and development is an<br />
equally important area. Major<br />
investigations include:<br />
• rolling noise development on<br />
concrete paving stone traffic<br />
surfaces, which looked at various<br />
stone types and arrangements<br />
Paving stones to suit the<br />
needs of the public, private<br />
and <strong>com</strong>mercial sectors.<br />
SF Kooperation shareholders answer<br />
questions about concrete.<br />
• ecological paving surfaces,<br />
highlighting the seepage<br />
performance of diverse stone<br />
types with different lifetime uses<br />
• the development of software for<br />
application and construction<br />
projects such as stability<br />
calculation and the sizing of<br />
foundations for retaining walls,<br />
the calculation of the duration<br />
of rainwater seepage in seepage<br />
basins, and the sizing of basins.<br />
Over 130 production plants,<br />
30 shareholder and cooperation<br />
partners, as well as 25 partners<br />
in North America, produce and<br />
distribute SF products worldwide. ●<br />
Further information<br />
SF Kooperation<br />
www.sf-kooperation.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
A sustainable choice<br />
Brick buildings last on<br />
average over 100 years.<br />
Brick is a natural material sustainable throughout all<br />
phases of its lifecycle, says the Vandersanden Group<br />
Brick is manufactured to<br />
last for generations. The<br />
average lifespan of a brick<br />
building is over 100 years, during<br />
which time it offers excellent living<br />
conditions and outstanding <strong>com</strong>fort.<br />
Its porous structure provides thermal<br />
insulation,while its mass guarantees<br />
good acoustic insulation. When a<br />
brick building is demolished, the<br />
facing bricks can be recovered and<br />
given a second life, or recycled and<br />
used for foundation work.<br />
Sustainable building is not only about<br />
lifespan, it is also about ecologically<br />
sound building materials and<br />
buildings. This means using a material<br />
that harms the environment as little<br />
as possible during its production,<br />
use and demolition stage. Brick is an<br />
excellent choice as it’s a natural, highquality,<br />
user and maintenance-friendly<br />
product that is sustainable during all<br />
phases of its life cycle.<br />
The life cycle of a material begins<br />
when it is in its natural state. Clay<br />
is a virtually inexhaustible resource,<br />
and excavated sites are redeveloped<br />
for agricultural or recreational use.<br />
To restrict the development of<br />
excavation sites, raw materials that<br />
are released during infrastructure and<br />
construction projects are used for<br />
the production of bricks. As a result,<br />
brick also provides a solution to the<br />
problem of surplus soil.<br />
Bricks are <strong>com</strong>posed exclusively<br />
of natural raw materials – every<br />
kilogramme of raw material is<br />
converted into a kilogramme of bricks.<br />
There is no waste, nor is there any<br />
waste water as the water used during<br />
the production process circulates in a<br />
closed circuit, which means there is no<br />
danger of soil pollution.<br />
Brick manufacturer Vandersanden also<br />
pays extra attention to environmental<br />
air quality. For years, this specialist in<br />
facing bricks, moulded bricks, brick<br />
slips and pavers has used tunnel kilns<br />
run on natural gas, which minimise<br />
energy usage. Combustion gases are<br />
purified in a flue gas filter, resulting<br />
in the cleanest emissions in the<br />
sector, beating the current stringent<br />
standards. Hot air from the kilns is<br />
also recovered to dry the bricks. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Vandersanden Group<br />
www.vandersandengroup.<strong>com</strong><br />
BRICKS & BRICK SOLUTIONS<br />
TOP QUALITY BRICKS & BRICK SOLUTIONS<br />
Vandersanden converts<br />
classical brick traditions into<br />
modern-day and future<br />
brick solutions.<br />
Service, innovation and durability are<br />
the key words.<br />
Curious about what else we have<br />
to offer?<br />
Call us on +32 89 51 01 40.<br />
We are pleased to serve you with<br />
customized, personal advice.<br />
A special range of facing<br />
bricks, manufactured with<br />
love and craftsmanship.<br />
Insulation and facing brick slips<br />
for finishing exterior walls: the<br />
clever 2-in-1 solution.<br />
Insulation boards,<br />
ready-made finish<br />
with facing brick slips.<br />
Sustainable, innovative<br />
pavers with spacers for<br />
public works and garden<br />
applications.<br />
The ultimate brick innovation:<br />
joint-free brickwork the<br />
traditional way.<br />
Rock-solid service<br />
Count on our people to make<br />
the difference; with a smile,<br />
understanding and correct advice.<br />
Want to know more?<br />
www.vandersandengroup.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
35
Company insight > Construction<br />
ETFE technology<br />
meets solar power<br />
The roof uses a<br />
photovoltaic<br />
cell system.<br />
Taiyo Europe was behind the construction of a new carport roof in Munich that<br />
incorporates photovoltaic modules with self-cleaning ETFE foil cushions.<br />
Anew carport roof structure,<br />
consisting of three-layer<br />
ethylene-tetrafluoroethylene<br />
(ETFE) cushions with an integrated,<br />
flexible photovoltaic cell system, has<br />
been installed at the headquarters of<br />
the AWM waste disposal operation<br />
in Munich, Germany.<br />
This project reconstructed the<br />
carport roof that shelters municipal<br />
vehicles. It was designed by Munich<br />
architects Ackermann & Partner<br />
and <strong>com</strong>pleted by Taiyo Europe in<br />
October 2011.<br />
The request for natural lighting and<br />
ventilation was achieved by using<br />
self-cleaning ETFE foil cushions.<br />
The material has a very high light<br />
transmission and excellent resistance<br />
to various weather environments.<br />
A total of 220 pneumatic multilayer<br />
cushions cover the 9,600m² roof.<br />
The inner layer is printed to provide<br />
shading on the carport deck during<br />
summer. The photovoltaic modules<br />
are mounted in the middle layer<br />
using mechanical fasteners, which<br />
are partly moveable and flexible to<br />
resist deformation caused by heavy<br />
loads. In order to easily replace<br />
defected photovoltaic modules, the<br />
upper layer is fixed separately from<br />
the other two layers, which can also<br />
be opened independently.<br />
This project is a milestone in the<br />
ongoing development of photovoltaic<br />
applications in <strong>com</strong>bination with<br />
architectural membranes for roof<br />
and façade structures, which will<br />
provide customers with the aesthetic<br />
properties of the structures in<br />
addition to energy savings. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Taiyo Europe<br />
www.taiyo-europe.<strong>com</strong><br />
Taiyo Europe<br />
textile architecture worldwide<br />
consulting design engineering<br />
fabrication installation maintenance<br />
Taiyo Europe GmbH<br />
Muehlweg 2<br />
82054 Sauerlach/Germany<br />
Phone: +49 8104 628 98-0<br />
Fax: +49 8104 628 98-99<br />
info@taiyo-europe.<strong>com</strong><br />
www.taiyo-europe.<strong>com</strong><br />
36<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight > Sustainability<br />
Beautiful: inside and out<br />
A structure’s façade must catch the outside observer’s eye.<br />
Glass art creator Prinz Optics presents a colourful solution.<br />
The Harpa building in Reykjavik. During the evening you can see<br />
reflections and illumination of the dichroic glass elements, which<br />
change depending on the light source and location.<br />
It is arguably not the market<br />
that decides on the value of a<br />
work of art, but its observer.<br />
An aspect of surprise, the aesthetic<br />
experience and how it enhances its<br />
environment are all potentially taken<br />
into consideration when deciding<br />
its value. This applies to art in both<br />
private and public spaces.<br />
The architect is tasked with<br />
conveying the interests of the<br />
owner or user to the outside<br />
observer through the artistic<br />
design of the building. The outer<br />
appearance is not just an expression<br />
of the interior, but something worth<br />
seeing that enriches the cityscape.<br />
Meeting this ‘social function’ at<br />
VarioTrans filter at night: spectacular shades of light are<br />
produced when the glass is illuminated.<br />
all times of day and night is one<br />
of the expectations made of<br />
the façade as a contemporary<br />
architectural medium.<br />
Colour effect<br />
Glass, colour and illumination<br />
are the design mediums through<br />
which to create art on a façade.<br />
VarioTrans colour-effect glass<br />
by Prinz Optics ideally <strong>com</strong>bines<br />
these three <strong>com</strong>ponents in<br />
one material. It connects the<br />
functionality of clear glass with<br />
the aesthetics of colour, without<br />
any loss in luminosity. This noncoloured,<br />
dichroic glass transmits<br />
light almost unrestrictedly, yet is<br />
seen in colour.<br />
This effect is based on the<br />
interference of light waves on<br />
meeting thin, transparent layers.<br />
Here, white light is split into<br />
colours without being absorbed.<br />
The visibility and projection of the<br />
interference colours is dependent<br />
on the respective incident light<br />
radiation and the angle of view of<br />
the observer. What at one moment<br />
seems to be crystal clear appears as<br />
a changing play of light and colour<br />
when seen one moment later<br />
through a change of perspective.<br />
This applies to daylight as well as<br />
to interior lighting radiating<br />
outwards when it is dark.<br />
Work of art<br />
The new Harpa Concert Hall and<br />
Conference Centre in Reykjavik,<br />
Iceland, offers an impressive<br />
example of a colourfully illuminated<br />
transparent glass façade. The<br />
intention of architect Henning<br />
Larsen and artist Olafur Eliasson<br />
was that this much-admired<br />
building should form a close<br />
interrelationship with its<br />
environment. As a result, the<br />
constantly changing local light<br />
conditions alter the appearance<br />
of the building. Secondly, this<br />
centre, located on the old harbour<br />
of the Icelandic capital, brings the<br />
environment visually to life,<br />
particularly in periods of darkness.<br />
The reflections of the dichroic<br />
glass honey<strong>com</strong>bs of the façade<br />
appear a cool yellow-orange-green<br />
during the day, but at night they<br />
radiate warm blue – both soft and<br />
strong shades – and bright pink<br />
through the transmission of<br />
interior lighting. It is a surprising<br />
sight for the observer, an aesthetic<br />
pleasure and an enhancement of<br />
their environment. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Prinz Optics<br />
www.variotrans-glass.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
37
Insight > Sustainability<br />
1<br />
1. The energy-efficient, super-tall Pearl River Tower.<br />
2. Sauerbruch Hutton’s Photonic Centre in Berlin.<br />
3. The Lightcatcher’s 36ft-tall, 180ft-long translucent double skin.<br />
2<br />
3<br />
Double-skin façades are at the heart of<br />
many of the greenest and most visually<br />
striking projects today. Rod James<br />
speaks to Louisa Hutton,<br />
Gordon Gill and Jim Olson about<br />
new technological approaches,<br />
the aesthetic possibilities<br />
they present, and winning a<br />
building’s occupants over to a<br />
new way of thinking.<br />
Two-faced<br />
architecture<br />
© Adrian Smith + Gordon Gill Architecture<br />
38<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Sustainability<br />
In 1929, Le Corbusier made<br />
an early foray into urban<br />
regeneration. He was to design<br />
a residential block known as Le Cité<br />
de Refuge, a Salvation Army shelter<br />
for Paris’s homeless. Fully funded<br />
by the philanthropist Princesse de<br />
Polignac and given free artistic rein,<br />
the great Swiss architect decided to<br />
try something new.<br />
The building’s face was to consist<br />
of two large sheets of glass separated<br />
by a cavity containing a mechanical<br />
ventilation system. Known as the<br />
mur neutralisant (neutralising wall) or<br />
double skin, it would circulate heated<br />
air around the chamber, insulating the<br />
building from noise and temperature<br />
fluctuations. Unfortunately,<br />
disagreements with the client meant<br />
the plan never came to fruition.<br />
A single-layer sealed glaze was<br />
employed instead – a move that<br />
proved disastrous. On hot days,<br />
residents baked in their south-facing<br />
rooms, forcing the <strong>com</strong>plete redesign<br />
of the façade in 1952, this time with<br />
operable windows. Although double<br />
skins were employed intermittently<br />
over the next few decades, they<br />
remained a niche concept.<br />
Clear cut<br />
But ever since architects have started<br />
to place a premium on energyefficiency,<br />
the double-skin façade<br />
has made an impressive <strong>com</strong>eback.<br />
As well as being a relatively simple<br />
way to reduce a building’s energy<br />
usage and improve the quality of<br />
inside air, the double-skin façade<br />
fulfils a <strong>com</strong>mon aesthetic desire<br />
for transparency. A leading practice<br />
in this revival was Berlin-based<br />
Sauerbruch Hutton, with its 1991<br />
GSW building project.<br />
The first high rise to go up in<br />
Berlin since the Wall came down, air<br />
enters through its eastern façade,<br />
which is dotted with automatically<br />
operated triple-glazed windows<br />
with between-pane blinds. The<br />
western face consists of a doubleskin<br />
façade with operable interior<br />
double-pane windows, and a sealed<br />
10mm exterior glazing layer. Outside<br />
air cross-ventilates from east to west<br />
and spreads throughout the western<br />
façade via stack effect. The project<br />
demonstrated that double skins could<br />
be applied to a high-rise structure,<br />
but, as one of Sauerbruch Hutton’s<br />
partners Louisa Hutton is keen to<br />
point out, the ideas employed were<br />
by no means novel.<br />
“GSW was our first big double<br />
façade, but even before that we built<br />
the Photonic Centre in Berlin,” she<br />
says. “It is a very simple unilateral<br />
façade. The cool air <strong>com</strong>es in at low<br />
level through a 60cm-wide chamber.<br />
The warm air travels sideways at a<br />
high level into a thermal flu within<br />
the thickness of the façade. It then<br />
rises up three storeys to the top of the<br />
building, and leaves through the roof.<br />
That was a very simple and effective<br />
façade to start with.”<br />
“the double-skin faÇade reduces a<br />
building’s energy usage, improves<br />
air quality and fulfils a <strong>com</strong>mon<br />
aesthetic desire for transparency.”<br />
These initial ideas have developed<br />
greatly since then. Sauerbruch and<br />
Hutton’s KfW building in Frankfurt,<br />
<strong>com</strong>pleted in 2010, recently won<br />
the Council on Tall Buildings and<br />
Urban Habitat’s Best Tall Building<br />
Worldwide Award. At its core is a<br />
unique double-skin façade fitted<br />
with automated blinds that help<br />
limit solar gain. The exterior is also<br />
characterised by scores of brightly<br />
coloured ventilation flaps, which are<br />
controlled by a building management<br />
system that monitors and responds to<br />
wind speed and direction.<br />
Hutton emphasises the need<br />
for a holistic approach to sustainable<br />
design. No <strong>com</strong>ponent can be viewed<br />
in isolation.<br />
© Jan Bitter Fotografie<br />
© Benjamin Benschneider<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
39
Insight > Sustainability<br />
“the double wall gathers and<br />
reflects daylight, illuminating<br />
interiors, and at night it glows<br />
like a lantern from within.”<br />
“The decision to go for a double<br />
façade is part of a group of related<br />
decisions,” she explains. “Together,<br />
they need to make a convincing<br />
whole. It’s done in <strong>com</strong>bination with<br />
things such as exposed concrete<br />
flaps and columns, and the ability to<br />
flush the building with cold air on<br />
summer nights so that it can radiate<br />
throughout the day. Some double<br />
façades are prototypical, which is<br />
a risk because they bring together<br />
many elements and you have to<br />
figure out how they all work.”<br />
Another level<br />
Another firm that has experimented<br />
extensively with the concept is Adrian<br />
Smith + Gordon Gill Architecture. The<br />
two former Skidmore, Owings and<br />
Merrill architects were responsible<br />
for the world’s most energy-efficient<br />
super-tall building, Guangzhou’s<br />
Pearl River Tower. They have<br />
recently been exploring ways to<br />
take the double wall and turn it into<br />
what Gill describes as a “sweater<br />
around the building”.<br />
“There was a project in Niagara<br />
Falls in the 1960s that had a double<br />
wall that you could actually stand<br />
in,” he explains. “It was about 3ftwide<br />
and was an envelope that ran<br />
uninterrupted around the building.<br />
We’ve tested this idea in Chicago<br />
and found it is possible to balance<br />
the thermal properties of the entire<br />
chamber, creating a thermos around<br />
the building.”<br />
The idea was put forward for, and<br />
won, a <strong>com</strong>petition to design a new<br />
office building in Seoul, South Korea.<br />
The architects initially planned to<br />
move the air around the chamber<br />
using fans in the corners, but this<br />
proved unnecessary.<br />
“We found that just by making<br />
calculated openings in the wall and<br />
© Jan Bitter Fotografie<br />
using the natural convection of the<br />
chamber, the air would move all<br />
around the thermos,” Gill explains.<br />
“You can do this on a floor-by-floor<br />
basis, allowing you to insulate the<br />
whole building if the climate is<br />
right. The thermal properties of the<br />
chamber also let you reduce the<br />
reflectivity of the glass. This gives<br />
you beautiful views and very<br />
transparent, crystalline aesthetics.”<br />
Looking good<br />
Both architects emphasise the<br />
aesthetic possibilities offered by<br />
double-skin façades. Gill + Smith<br />
have experimented with stone<br />
interior façade walls and cone-shaped<br />
fittings to aid the movement of air.<br />
The environmental aspirations of<br />
Sauerbruch Hutton’s creations are<br />
mirrored through the use of oranges<br />
and pinks on westerly façades, which<br />
reflect the setting sun.<br />
Over in Washington state, in the US<br />
city of Bellingham, is a particularly<br />
striking example. The Lightcatcher<br />
by Olson Kundig Architects is a<br />
36ft-tall, 180ft-long translucent<br />
double façade that illuminates the<br />
city’s What<strong>com</strong> Museum. It takes<br />
maximum advantage of the area’s<br />
limited natural light while creating a<br />
sense of depth and mystery.<br />
“There is a coastal climate with lots<br />
of cloud cover and low sun angles,”<br />
says Jim Olson, the partner behind<br />
the design. “We wanted the building<br />
to harvest natural light and bring it<br />
into the courtyard and the building.<br />
Air flow through the cavity wall is<br />
guided by mechanically operated<br />
louvres at the top of the wall, which<br />
are operated by the building’s<br />
direct digital control system. The<br />
wall gathers daylight and reflects<br />
it into the courtyard, while softly<br />
illuminating the interior, and at night<br />
it glows like a lantern from within.”<br />
For all the aesthetic and<br />
environmental benefits double<br />
skins bring, it is not always easy to<br />
convince clients of their worth. Gill<br />
admits that paying for uninhabited<br />
space can be deemed a luxury,<br />
particularly in areas where square<br />
footage is at a premium. His practice<br />
has examined the idea of using the<br />
façade chamber as a functioning<br />
room, employing a transom system<br />
to ventilate the space externally.<br />
He believes that, in most cases, the<br />
benefits of a double skin are too<br />
strong to ignore.<br />
“Depending on where you are and<br />
the way square footage is calculated,<br />
we’ve seen resistance to the double<br />
wall,” he says. “People think they are<br />
paying more for the net area they<br />
can use. But in many cases the value<br />
the system brings and the quality of<br />
the environment inside the building<br />
over<strong>com</strong>es these concerns. When<br />
testing our thermos concept we<br />
even had cases where cities said,<br />
‘We’ll help you with an incentive for<br />
floor-area ratio because we think it’s a<br />
valuable idea’.”<br />
Education is key<br />
Hutton is keen to stress the human<br />
element, which can be drowned in<br />
talk of science and technology. No<br />
environmental design concept can<br />
be effective if those inside the<br />
building don’t understand and buy<br />
into it. She believes that education<br />
is certainly improving, although there<br />
is still some way to go.<br />
“Something that often gets<br />
forgotten is user behaviour and<br />
expectations,” she says. “There is<br />
a long period of optimisation from<br />
the moment the building is finished<br />
through to when users work in<br />
synergy with it. You have to get<br />
people to act as sensibly in their office<br />
as they would at home. For example,<br />
you could have an override system<br />
that operates windows and shutters<br />
automatically, but it’s much nicer if<br />
people do it themselves.<br />
“It’s important that buildings are<br />
measured and results published, but<br />
you should look ten years down the<br />
line before you do it,” she concludes. ●<br />
40<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Aquatic form<br />
and function<br />
A regular decorative attendee of high-profile sporting<br />
events, well-crafted and colourful GAIL ceramics are also<br />
used in domestic, industrial and <strong>com</strong>mercial buildings.<br />
GAIL ceramics dominated the 60,000m²<br />
newbuild swimming <strong>com</strong>plex at the<br />
16th Asian Games in Guangzou, China.<br />
in Bestform<br />
unction in top form<br />
ctionnalité<br />
meilleur de sa forme<br />
For decades architects, planners and construction <strong>com</strong>panies have<br />
placed trust in the high-quality products made by GAIL Architektur<br />
Keramik GmbH. Within GAIL’s <strong>com</strong>pany products and technical<br />
consultating services for architects and planners are associated with<br />
each other, achieving a well known high level of detailed <strong>com</strong>petence<br />
worldwide in the realisation of high-level projects.<br />
Whether it is a brewery, factory or warehouse, airport terminal or<br />
underground station, GAIL is used all over the world for building<br />
and designing. In addition to ceramic products for industry and<br />
façades, GAIL offers an extensive range of swimming pool ceramics<br />
and overflow systems with high-quality ceramic tiles for the variety<br />
of applications in baths.<br />
Top projects around the world have been realised in close and<br />
trusted cooperation with our architectural department.<br />
Our qualified consultants are pleased to be at your disposal!<br />
GAIL Architektur-Keramik GmbH<br />
Erdkauter Weg 40-50, D – 35392 Gießen, GERMANY<br />
www.gail.de Email: sales@gail.de Phone: 0049 641 703 0<br />
GAIL specialises in the<br />
manufacture of high-quality<br />
ceramics for artful and<br />
ambitious aquatic fun parks, spas,<br />
wellness pools and sport facilities.<br />
The pool ceramics specialist offers<br />
an expansive colour and form palette<br />
ideal for innovative swimming pools<br />
and renovations.<br />
In the last few years, planners of large<br />
swimming pools have relied on the<br />
quality and functionality of GAIL’s<br />
swimming pool ceramics, which is<br />
why the firm was chosen to provide<br />
products for the 2008 Olympic Games<br />
in Beijing, and for the Asian Games in<br />
2006 and 2010.<br />
GAIL products also appeared at the<br />
16th Asian Games in Guangzou,<br />
China, in the form of a 60,000m²<br />
newbuild. In this highly aesthetic<br />
project, the predominant element<br />
– water – was represented by the<br />
colours blue and white, dominating<br />
the building inside and out.<br />
Complementing this colour scheme,<br />
the <strong>com</strong>petition, training and diving<br />
pools were decorated with white<br />
and dark blue dry-pressed tiles,<br />
split tiles and special form tiles.<br />
Ceramics from the Special-Form<br />
and Combi-Color II collections<br />
were used throughout this modern<br />
<strong>com</strong>plex, which is the training camp<br />
of the Chinese national team.<br />
Combi-Color II is available in 50<br />
colours and consists of dry-pressed<br />
tiles that can be used to build<br />
swimming pools, walls and façades<br />
of social, domestic, industrial,<br />
<strong>com</strong>mercial and private buildings. ●<br />
Further information<br />
GAIL<br />
www.gail.de<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
41
Company insight<br />
Sanitaryware<br />
goes green<br />
Stainless steel sanitaryware specialist SENDA has<br />
introduced an eco-friendly programme to prove the<br />
green credentials of its product range.<br />
High-end bathroom solutions<br />
are part of SENDA’s broad<br />
product range.<br />
of stainless-steel sanitaryware in<br />
order to ensure the environmentally<br />
friendly credentials of its products.<br />
Raw material: according to<br />
statistics, approximately 70% of new<br />
stainless steel <strong>com</strong>es from recycling<br />
old stainless-steel products.<br />
Production: the production<br />
of stainless-steel sanitaryware<br />
consumes less energy than<br />
ceramic sanitary ware production.<br />
For SENDA products, the production<br />
processes and product engineering<br />
are optimised to consume the<br />
minimum of energy; for example, cold<br />
deep pressing and TIG welding.<br />
SENDA is a leading European<br />
manufacturer of top-quality<br />
stainless-steel sanitaryware.<br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany offers a unique range<br />
of stainless-steel sanitaryware<br />
solutions, from public/heavy-duty<br />
applications through to high-end<br />
private bathrooms.<br />
SENDA has secured major contracts<br />
in Europe, the Middle East, Africa<br />
and Latin America for buildings such<br />
as airports, train and underground<br />
stations, sports facilities, universities,<br />
hospitals, military premises and<br />
prisons.<br />
The firm is also recognised for its<br />
exclusive and <strong>com</strong>plete<br />
range of sanitaryware for the<br />
private bathroom.<br />
In an effort to promote stainless-steel<br />
sanitaryware as a ‘green’ product,<br />
SENDA has embarked upon the<br />
SENDA goes GREEN programme.<br />
During this programme, the firm<br />
examined the <strong>com</strong>plete lifecycle<br />
Transportation: stainless-steel<br />
sanitaryware fixtures are lightweight<br />
– a container can be filled with<br />
stainless-steel products and the<br />
weight limit of the container is<br />
never reached, increasing the<br />
transportation efficiency in terms<br />
of energy and costs.<br />
Use: under normal conditions and<br />
using the right flushing systems<br />
and taps, stainless-steel sanitaryware<br />
can save water. When considering<br />
maintenance and repair, stainless<br />
steel has virtually zero maintenance.<br />
This means that a stainless-steel<br />
WC, wash basin or urinal need never<br />
be replaced.<br />
Disposal: the cycle is <strong>com</strong>pleted<br />
through the collection and recycling<br />
of the stainless-steel fixtures to<br />
produce ‘new’ stainless steel.<br />
Thanks to the above, there can be no<br />
doubt that SENDA’s stainless-steel<br />
sanitaryware is eco-friendly. ●<br />
Further information<br />
SENDA<br />
www.senda.pt<br />
42<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Join the visual revolution<br />
The boundless creative possibilities of Visio-Technic’s digital technology give architects the opportunity to blend their<br />
projects seamlessly into the cultural heritage of their locations and to ensure they make a significant mark on our times.<br />
Create graphic<br />
effects that truly<br />
make a mark.<br />
Every architect dreams of<br />
having the absolute freedom<br />
to give their heart and soul<br />
to a project. With Numericoat, this<br />
dream could <strong>com</strong>e true.<br />
Numericoat gives you the<br />
opportunity to boundlessly express<br />
your artistic sense and creativity<br />
when designing structures.<br />
Through the integration of any<br />
digitised image, photo or drawing<br />
inside an extremely resistant<br />
thermosetting coating, Visio-<br />
Technic gives your creations the<br />
full potential of digital technology.<br />
Nevertheless, creativity is not<br />
offered at the expense of technical<br />
know-how. Numericoat allows you<br />
to worry only about the essentials,<br />
while Visio-Technic deals with<br />
durability. You benefit from:<br />
• a ten-year warranty covering<br />
the outdoor use of the coating,<br />
including colour variation,<br />
adhesion and fading<br />
• an exceptional anti-UV coating,<br />
<strong>com</strong>bined with a cutting-edge<br />
anti-graffiti varnish<br />
• an aluminum pre-treatment that<br />
follows the Qualicoat standard.<br />
When you choose Numericoat,<br />
you can harmoniously integrate<br />
a building with its environment<br />
by using a large variety of media<br />
(such as glass, aluminum frames,<br />
metallic profiles, steel wall curtains<br />
and <strong>com</strong>posite panels) <strong>com</strong>bined<br />
with the great range of incredible<br />
effects the <strong>com</strong>pany offers. Mix<br />
the graphic effects you apply to<br />
your materials and create unique<br />
designs never seen before. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Visio-Technic<br />
www.visio-technic.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
43
Insight > Materials<br />
Healthy<br />
reflection<br />
Traditionally questioned over their sustainable<br />
credentials, attitudes towards all-glass buildings are<br />
changing. Elly Earls meets Design Embassy Europe<br />
CEO Brent Richards, KPF’s Robert Whitlock,<br />
and RMJM’s Jonathan Knight and Chris Jones<br />
to discover how the clever use of the material is driving<br />
a sustainable agenda and improving general well-being.<br />
44<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Materials<br />
Man’s fascination with glass<br />
architecture is nothing<br />
new. As far back as the<br />
Romans, windows were being used as<br />
architectural <strong>com</strong>ponents, and frames<br />
were finished with thick green/bluecast<br />
glass and implemented as a form<br />
of conservatory for growing vegetables.<br />
But it is not only the functional aspects<br />
of the material that have been drawing<br />
architects’ attention for thousands of<br />
years; glass also has an artistic and<br />
philosophic purpose to which no other<br />
building material can lay claim.<br />
“It’s the only material with which<br />
we can explore spatiality and interior<br />
architecture,” says Brent Richards,<br />
creative director and CEO of the Design<br />
Embassy Europe. “The idea of being<br />
able to see both inside and outside has<br />
always been a fascination.”<br />
But it is only recently that architects<br />
have been able to use glass on the<br />
scale they have been dreaming about<br />
for so many years.<br />
“It’s not that it’s suddenly be<strong>com</strong>e<br />
popular,” Richards, author of New<br />
Glass Architecture, explains.<br />
“What’s happening at the moment<br />
is a convergence between industry,<br />
affordability and people’s everyday<br />
understanding of the material. There’s<br />
an architectural and artistic symbiosis<br />
between the technical possibilities of<br />
what the industry can provide and what<br />
the <strong>com</strong>missioners can afford. Since<br />
2000, those things have developed.”<br />
Balance of facets<br />
While the past 40 years have seen huge<br />
developments in glass technology –<br />
from the size of the sheets to the types<br />
of coatings used and the ways in which<br />
the panels can be connected – it is<br />
really only in the last ten to 15 years that<br />
architects’ understanding of glass has<br />
increased to the extent that they can<br />
now control how the material performs.<br />
“There is still this question of<br />
affordability, but essentially I think we<br />
can now say that we can control the<br />
environmental aspects of glass,” says<br />
Richards. “We can control performance<br />
and sustainability in order to create an<br />
all-glass building that is carbon neutral<br />
and therefore sustainable.<br />
“If we can increase the dosage of<br />
natural, rather than artificial,<br />
light, your health and general<br />
well-being will benefit.”<br />
“You have a whole range of<br />
possibilities – interlayers, different<br />
gases, coatings on different sides of the<br />
glass,” he continues. “You can change<br />
the characteristics of the glass either<br />
environmentally or artistically in terms<br />
of colour and texture, and you can<br />
control the type of light that <strong>com</strong>es in.”<br />
For Robert Whitlock, a principal at<br />
KPF, Richards’ final point is key.<br />
“So many things contribute to the<br />
efficiency of an office building,” he says.<br />
“You’re trying to keep the radiation<br />
out but let daylight in. In an attempt to<br />
have a high-performing building, there’s<br />
a constant balance between keeping<br />
light out to cut down on the solar load<br />
and letting enough light in to reduce<br />
reliance on artificial illumination.”<br />
In order to achieve this balance,<br />
collaboration with manufacturers is<br />
absolutely crucial.<br />
“It’s remarkable how far the industry<br />
has <strong>com</strong>e in customising coatings,”<br />
Whitlock says. “We now have dialogues<br />
with manufacturers to tweak the<br />
performance – shading co-efficient<br />
vs value vs the amount of reflectivity,<br />
as well as the colour of the glass. It’s<br />
like a big recipe to fine-tune these<br />
coatings so that they perform the<br />
1<br />
1. With its 18° westward incline, the Capital Gate tower in Abu<br />
Dhabi is the world’s furthest-leaning man-made tower.<br />
2. Capital Gate tower’s Cardinal LoE 2 -240 glazing system<br />
blocks out 84% of harmful UV and infrared radiation.<br />
2<br />
way we need them to relative to the<br />
environment they’re in.”<br />
Grand performance<br />
At Hysan Place, a mixed-use retail and<br />
office development in Hong Kong, and<br />
the region’s first LEED Platinum precertified<br />
<strong>com</strong>mercial project, KPF used<br />
several different strategies to achieve<br />
the precise performance required.<br />
“We had a light shelf in the curtain<br />
wall with a portion that projected out<br />
from the glazing, acting as a sunshade,”<br />
Whitlock explains. “It also had a<br />
<strong>com</strong>ponent inside that was configured<br />
to bounce light back into the deeper<br />
parts of the office space using the<br />
ceiling as part of the reflecting surface.<br />
We were also able to test different<br />
shading co-efficients above and below<br />
the light shelf to try and optimise<br />
performance of the entire envelope.”<br />
The glazing system used by the team<br />
at RMJM, which designed the iconic<br />
Capital Gate tower in Abu Dhabi, is<br />
similarly <strong>com</strong>plex.<br />
“The Cardinal glass LoE²-240<br />
blocks 84% of harmful UV radiation,”<br />
says Jonathan Knight, international<br />
design principal at RMJM. “It absorbs<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
45
Insight > Materials<br />
60% of the visible light, which gives<br />
the coating glare control and its soft,<br />
muted-blue colour. It reflects nearly all<br />
of the invisible infrared rays.”<br />
The Cardinal façade is 51% more<br />
efficient at restricting solar heat to<br />
a building than a standard façade,<br />
reducing the energy consumption of<br />
the HVAC system by 15%, according<br />
to RMJM managing principal Chris<br />
Jones. “The façade uses natural light to<br />
the full and with the type of glass used,<br />
the Cardinal LoE²-240, it blocks the<br />
UV and infrared radiation, and permits<br />
visible light,” he adds.<br />
Green credibility<br />
Glass’s natural properties also contribute<br />
to its environmental credentials.<br />
“It’s a natural material made from<br />
natural substances that can be crushed,<br />
recycled and remade continuously,<br />
although you have to take into account<br />
that you also need to fire up a furnace<br />
and that most glass production has<br />
to be a continuous flow process,”<br />
Richards says. “But if you accept<br />
that limitation, you’ve got a fantastic<br />
sustainable material.”<br />
Yet Richards is just as keen to<br />
emphasise that the sustainability of a<br />
building is holistic.<br />
“There’s the performance of the<br />
building in terms of energy use and<br />
there’s how you construct the<br />
building,” he says. “But on top of<br />
that, once you’ve constructed it,<br />
you need to consider the building’s<br />
entire lifecycle. Does it pay back in<br />
terms of creating energy for you,<br />
controlling your environment and<br />
developing well-being?”<br />
Fortunately, glass unequivocally ticks<br />
the final box.<br />
“Obviously glass buildings require<br />
an investment because they’re very<br />
technical and <strong>com</strong>plex, but once you’ve<br />
got them up, they perform for you,”<br />
Richards says. “Glass is a quick reactor.<br />
If you’ve got a stone or a brick building,<br />
it tends to warm up and lose heat<br />
very slowly, whereas a glass building<br />
reacts quite quickly. So, as long as you<br />
understand that reaction time, you can<br />
use it to your advantage.”<br />
Healthy outlook<br />
For Whitlock, it’s that understanding<br />
of how the material can be used that<br />
is really going to contribute to the<br />
success of future glass developments.<br />
“With subsequent projects, it’s going<br />
to be<strong>com</strong>e easier to get into it faster<br />
and do it more quickly,” he says.<br />
But the understanding goes far<br />
beyond the <strong>com</strong>prehension of how the<br />
physical characteristics of glass work<br />
together to create an energy-efficient<br />
building. Richards is currently working<br />
with the University of Oxford in the<br />
UK to prove that living and working<br />
in a predominantly glass building can<br />
actually improve health and well-being.<br />
In the next ten years, the industry’s<br />
technology is set to develop to the point<br />
where glass coatings can change its<br />
state relative to the environment.<br />
“There are also products being tested<br />
that change an inert gas in the cavity<br />
of an insulated glass unit from invisible<br />
to cloudy, providing privacy or shading<br />
– this is typically achieved through an<br />
electrical current,” says Whitlock.<br />
Going still further, some industry<br />
members are looking at the idea of<br />
gestural language.<br />
“You will be able to gesture to the<br />
building and it will respond to you,”<br />
Richards explains. “For example, in<br />
an area of outstanding natural beauty,<br />
you would be able to increase your<br />
connectivity to nature. We believe<br />
that if we can increase the dosage of<br />
natural, rather than artificial, light, your<br />
health and general well-being will<br />
benefit, and that’s really exciting.”<br />
Architects will be able to apply this<br />
to buildings such as schools, other<br />
learning environments and spas.<br />
“We’ll be able to say there’s another<br />
reason for building glass buildings,”<br />
says Richards. “Not only because of<br />
aesthetics, the design and because we<br />
like to be able to see the garden, but<br />
because it’s fundamentally better for<br />
you than living in a cave.” ●<br />
The Hysan Place high-rise in Hong Kong is the region’s first<br />
LEED Platinum pre-certified <strong>com</strong>mercial project.<br />
46<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight > Materials<br />
Fire safety in modern atria<br />
Atria appeal emotionally to visitors by providing a connection between the building’s interior and the external space within<br />
which it sits. They bring with them, however, a set of fire safety challenges that require the solutions Wrightstyle provides.<br />
The glass atrium at Bridgewater House.<br />
It was the Romans who first<br />
made the atrium fashionable,<br />
and gave it the name by which<br />
we still know it today.<br />
Today, atria remain a popular design<br />
feature, allowing light to flood into<br />
a building and providing it with a<br />
sense of space.<br />
However, they bring a special set<br />
of protective challenges as they<br />
can act as a roofed-over chimney,<br />
therefore providing an easy route for<br />
heat, fire and gases to spread from<br />
the seat of a fire.<br />
Today, it is internal curtain<br />
walling that provides the best<br />
design solution, allowing for large<br />
expanses of glazing to be safely and<br />
cost-effectively achieved without<br />
the need for secondary support<br />
assemblies. Specifiers, however,<br />
should always ensure that the glass<br />
and its framing system have been<br />
tested as one <strong>com</strong>patible unit.<br />
Wrightstyle is a leading specialist<br />
in the design, fabrication and<br />
installation of steel and glass<br />
systems for both internal and<br />
external applications, and has<br />
supplied materials to atria projects<br />
in the UK and internationally.<br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany recently <strong>com</strong>pleted<br />
a project at Bridgewater House in<br />
Bristol, UK. This project is set<br />
around a five-storey, three-sided<br />
glass atrium that has been designed<br />
to bring maximum light to each<br />
intermediate floor while also<br />
providing 30 minutes of integrity and<br />
insulation, protecting inhabitants. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Wrightstyle<br />
www.wrightstyle.co.uk<br />
Inspiring Architecture<br />
All great architecture starts with a simple idea. Then<br />
<strong>com</strong>es the inspiration to turn it into built reality.<br />
At Wrightstyle we work with architects around the<br />
world, bringing to life even the most challenging ideas.<br />
We aren’t just one of the world’s most innovative<br />
suppliers of <strong>com</strong>plete and guaranteed steel and<br />
glass systems. We’re also world leaders in reinventing<br />
what glass and steel facade systems can do.<br />
From large-span or fire-resistant glazing to curtain<br />
walling able to withstand a lorry bomb, we are at the<br />
forefront of our technologies, pushing the boundaries<br />
of what glass and steel are capable of achieving.<br />
Our interior and exterior systems can be found<br />
worldwide, and we have a portfolio of examples to<br />
illuminate and surprise.<br />
Our systems don’t simply protect buildings against the<br />
full range of threats. The inherent strength of steel<br />
and our optically-brilliant glasses allow architects to<br />
think in new ways.<br />
So if you’ve got a design idea, talk to us. We’ll help<br />
provide the inspiration to make it happen.<br />
High Performance Steel & Glass Systems • Complete & Guaranteed<br />
T +44 (0)1380 722 239 E info@wrightstyle.co.uk W www.wrightstyle.co.uk<br />
11800 Wright Style Advert.indd 2 05/01/2011 14:08<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
47
Company insight<br />
Innovation driven by the three<br />
Ps: people, planet and profits<br />
Using the cradle-to-cradle concept, carpet manufacturer Desso has rebranded for the circular economy. Its<br />
mission: to ensure that its carpet tiles improve human health and have a positive impact on the environment<br />
There is a link between a<br />
carpet tile that clears the<br />
air and a business model<br />
that scores highly on the three Ps:<br />
people, planet and profits.<br />
In 2008, Desso made the bold<br />
decision to recreate itself for<br />
the circular economy by following<br />
the cradle-to-cradle concept<br />
as defined by German chemist<br />
Michael Braungart and US architect<br />
William McDonough.<br />
This set the firm on course to<br />
move away from the unsustainable<br />
linear economy of ‘take, make and<br />
dispose’ and towards the circular<br />
model, where goods are recycled<br />
and reused on an ongoing basis.<br />
The cradle to cradle concept views carpet<br />
as being made up of nutrients that should be reused.<br />
Economist Umair Haque, author<br />
of The New Capitalist Manifesto<br />
– Building a Disruptively Better<br />
Business, describes the shift:<br />
“21st-century businesses are now<br />
built on value cycles,” he says. “In<br />
stark contrast to linear production,<br />
the essence of a cycle is circular<br />
production. Circular production<br />
adds a ‘back-to lifecycle’ to the<br />
orthodox lifecycle. The goal of<br />
a value cycle is simple: waste<br />
nothing, replenish everything.”<br />
Renewable gains<br />
With cradle to cradle as its guide,<br />
Desso uses positively defined<br />
materials (where all ingredients are<br />
assessed as optimal or tolerable)<br />
and designs its products for<br />
disassembly, so they can easily be<br />
taken apart for remanufacturing.<br />
The firm will increasingly draw<br />
on renewable energies, manage<br />
its water with care, and ensure<br />
that it promotes a motivated and<br />
diverse workforce.<br />
Desso CEO Stef Kranendijk recently<br />
spoke at the World Economic Forum<br />
in Davos, Switzerland, following<br />
the publication of the ‘Towards the<br />
circular economy’ report from<br />
the Ellen MacArthur Foundation<br />
and McKinsey Global Institute.<br />
This report showed that there<br />
was an economic opportunity of<br />
$630 billion a year for European<br />
industry in the pursuit of circular<br />
economic models.<br />
“A major spur to innovation and an<br />
inspiration for both customers and<br />
employees, Desso’s broad adoption<br />
of the circular economy principles<br />
has been driving top-line growth,”<br />
the report stated.<br />
Green heart<br />
But what does cradle to cradle<br />
mean for Desso customers?<br />
It means that Desso puts the<br />
following at the heart of everything:<br />
ensuring that its products improve<br />
human health and the environment.<br />
Thinking about human health led<br />
Desso’s R&D teams to consider<br />
Desso AirMaster carpet tiles are eight times more<br />
effective at capturing and retaining fine dust than hard flooring.<br />
how to <strong>com</strong>bat the problem of<br />
bad indoor air quality, which in<br />
turn led to the development of<br />
Desso’s AirMaster carpet tile.<br />
Independently verified by German<br />
test institute GUI, the material<br />
is eight times better than hard<br />
floors and four times better than<br />
regular carpets at retaining the<br />
fine dust that can cause respiratory<br />
problems, such as asthma.<br />
This kind of new thinking, which<br />
links a carpet tile to the three Ps,<br />
will drive innovation at Desso long<br />
into the future. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Desso<br />
www.desso.<strong>com</strong><br />
48<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Patent: NL 2002808<br />
DESSO AirMaster ® The carpet that cleans the air<br />
Indoor air quality plays a major role in our health and well-being, since we spend on average more than 90% of our time indoors. Extensive evidence from<br />
the World Health Organization indicates that in most cities in developed countries around the world indoor air quality results in serious health risks, for a great<br />
deal caused by the presence of airborne fine dust*.<br />
DESSO AirMaster ® , with its patented technology, has been specially developed to remove fine dust from the air more effectively than any other flooring<br />
solution. In fact it is 8 times more effective in capturing and retaining fine dust than hard flooring solutions**.<br />
With DESSO AirMaster ® you can rely on the proven solution that captures and retains harmful fine dust.<br />
For more information, please visit our website www.desso.<strong>com</strong><br />
* Source: World Health Organization Air quality guidelines for particulate matter, global update 2005.<br />
** Based on tests performed by GUI, with DESSO AirMaster ® versus standard PVC hardfloor.
Company insight > Construction<br />
Eco credentials<br />
that are set in stone<br />
Burlington Stone provided<br />
cladding and flooring stones for<br />
the Vestas HQ in Denmark<br />
Burlington Stone puts environmental management at the heart of its operations and has<br />
achieved independent recognition for the durability of its stone products.<br />
British stone engineer<br />
Burlington Stone, the name<br />
behind one of the finest and<br />
most durable natural stones in the<br />
world, has been leading the way<br />
in ensuring that its business and<br />
products protect and enhance the<br />
environment for generations to <strong>com</strong>e.<br />
Burlington Stone works with<br />
architects and designers to maximise<br />
stone usage and its extraction<br />
through effective planning and the<br />
optimisation of modular stone sizes<br />
that minimise waste.<br />
At present, approximately 90–95% of<br />
the slate and stone extracted from<br />
the <strong>com</strong>pany’s Kirkby and Baycliff<br />
quarries be<strong>com</strong>es the finished<br />
product. What would previously<br />
have been discarded is now being<br />
used for landscaping products, such<br />
as Burlington Stone’s new tumbled<br />
natural stone setts block paving<br />
solution and contemporary interior<br />
solutions, including mosaics and<br />
decorative cladding panels.<br />
Burlington Stone’s achievement of<br />
the environmental management<br />
system ISO 14001:2004 highlights<br />
the sustainability of the <strong>com</strong>pany’s<br />
manufacturing processes. For<br />
example, Burlington Stone has<br />
been involved with the successful<br />
cladding and flooring of the Vestas<br />
headquarters in Denmark using<br />
Burlington Kirkby blue and Brandy<br />
Crag stones, pictured above. This<br />
structure, designed by Arkitema<br />
Architects, has since be<strong>com</strong>e<br />
northern Europe’s first LEED<br />
platinum-accredited building. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Burlington Stone<br />
www.burlingtonstone.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE ULTIMATE BRITISH<br />
NATURAL STONE<br />
Burlington’s highly-skilled stone engineers craft a diverse range of luxurious and<br />
signature British natural stone products that exude the ultimate in opulent quality<br />
and permanence.<br />
Using a natural stone source laid down in the English Lake District over 450 million<br />
years ago, inspiration <strong>com</strong>es in the form of standard product lines and truly bespoke<br />
pieces, and is limited only by the imagination.<br />
To ensure the sustainability of their natural resource, Burlington Stone ensure not only<br />
the sympathetic extraction of their stone, but also maximise their output by utilising<br />
the skills of their British craftsmen to craft a unique and varied product offering.<br />
With already nearly 175 years of experience, Burlington Stone continue to give you<br />
the ultimate interior and exterior finishing statement.<br />
VISIT OUR SHOWROOM. Open: Monday-Friday: 9am-5pm.<br />
Saturday: 9am-3pm. Closed: Sundays and Bank Holidays.<br />
BURLINGTON SLATE LTD<br />
Cavendish House Kirkby-in-Furness Cumbria LA17 7UN<br />
t: 01229 889 661 e: sales@burlingtonstone.co.uk<br />
www.burlingtonstone.<strong>com</strong><br />
Burlington LEAF April2012 Ad.indd 1 15/03/2012 09:09<br />
50<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
A healing environment<br />
The aim of modern hospital design is to create a pleasant atmosphere that supports the healing process. The<br />
Orbis Medical Center, with lighting by TRILUX, goes a step further, offering staff and patients the benefits of a<br />
hospital and medical centre under one roof, along with the highest level of <strong>com</strong>fort.<br />
The Orbis Medical Center<br />
in the Dutch town of<br />
Sittard sets an example<br />
with its state-of-the-art technical<br />
equipment, responsible treatment<br />
of staff and patients, and the high<br />
quality of its architectural design.<br />
As a modern medical centre, it<br />
<strong>com</strong>bines hospital wards, surgeries<br />
and specialist clinics with a<br />
research and <strong>com</strong>petence centre<br />
that employs 350 people.<br />
With the Orbis Medical Center,<br />
the Dutch practice Bonnema<br />
Architects has created a highly<br />
advanced healthcare building that,<br />
with 425 beds across 12 wards,<br />
eight operating theatres and 100<br />
consultation rooms, offers ample<br />
space for professional medical<br />
treatment, all illuminated by an<br />
innovative light concept designed<br />
by TRILUX.<br />
Bright and wel<strong>com</strong>ing<br />
The main entrance at the gable<br />
end of the building leads into a<br />
265m-long atrium space. Clever<br />
zoning means that, despite its size,<br />
it does not feel overwhelming. The<br />
space serves as a central meeting<br />
and distribution point.<br />
Daylight enters partly through<br />
the façade on one side, but most<br />
significantly through the glazed roof<br />
areas, which are carefully designed<br />
to prevent overheating in summer.<br />
At night or when there is insufficient<br />
daylight, the space is lit through a<br />
<strong>com</strong>bination of direct and indirect<br />
light sources.<br />
Spotlights on the walls and ceiling,<br />
strong uplighters and large wallmounted<br />
mirrors ensure a bright,<br />
<strong>com</strong>fortable and wel<strong>com</strong>ing<br />
environment, whatever the weather.<br />
Home from home<br />
The hospital wards are located on<br />
the quieter top three floors of the<br />
building. All Orbis Medical Center<br />
patients enjoy spacious, individual<br />
rooms with en-suite bathrooms.<br />
As with the atrium, direct and<br />
indirect lighting offers <strong>com</strong>fort and<br />
a pleasant ambience to patients and<br />
functionality to hospital staff.<br />
Rather than soulless <strong>com</strong>munal<br />
rooms, the generous corridors next<br />
to the rooms have been designed<br />
to ac<strong>com</strong>modate cosy lounge areas<br />
with a homely atmosphere, offering a<br />
place to meet or rest.<br />
A separate back entrance provides<br />
doctors and staff with their own<br />
private space. Changing rooms in the<br />
basement connect directly to this area<br />
behind the consultation rooms, which<br />
also grant access to the integrated<br />
research and <strong>com</strong>petence centre.<br />
Colour and light: work and rest<br />
In the four zones within the Orbis<br />
Medical Center – public areas,<br />
meeting points, patient rooms and<br />
work spaces – TRILUX consciously<br />
applied light and colour to achieve<br />
a positive effect on the building’s<br />
occupants; for example, the atrium<br />
employs greens and other natural<br />
shades to create a warm, bright and<br />
friendly atmosphere, while the staff<br />
The Orbis Medical Center houses a<br />
cheerful, generously designed cafeteria.<br />
TRILUX consciously applies light and colour<br />
to the Orbis Medical Center in order to achieve<br />
a positive effect on patients and staff.<br />
work areas have cool, refreshing<br />
colours to create a stimulating and<br />
attractive environment.<br />
External spaces surrounding the<br />
building have also been landscaped<br />
to create pleasant surroundings<br />
that promote healing and speed up<br />
patients’ recovery.<br />
The TRILUX touch<br />
For 100 years, TRILUX has been<br />
working daily to shape the future<br />
of light. The <strong>com</strong>pany’s lighting<br />
solutions use intelligent, dependable<br />
and award-winning technology<br />
that promotes energy-efficiency.<br />
As a partner for New Light, TRILUX<br />
supports its customers throughout<br />
the entire process, covering design,<br />
implementation and service.<br />
The internationally active, midsized<br />
<strong>com</strong>pany with headquarters<br />
in Arnsberg, Germany, employs<br />
more than 5,000 employees at nine<br />
locations in Europe and Asia, as well<br />
as 12 subsidiaries and six expertise<br />
centres in Germany. ●<br />
Further information<br />
TRILUX<br />
www.trilux.<strong>com</strong><br />
© TRILUX<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
51
Company insight<br />
Material roof innovation<br />
The LEAF Review discovers how systems engineering <strong>com</strong>pany Hightex worked in partnership with fabrics expert<br />
Sefar on the project to refurbish the BC Place Stadium in Vancouver, Canada.<br />
How did Hightex get<br />
involved in the<br />
BC Place project?<br />
Hightex, as a leading systems<br />
engineering <strong>com</strong>pany that designs,<br />
fabricates and installs large-area,<br />
cable-supported, lightweight<br />
membrane roofs and façades,<br />
is a global partner for projects,<br />
particularly in sporting stadia and<br />
arenas, airport terminals, train<br />
stations and shopping malls.<br />
Hightex uses environmentally friendly<br />
materials and is focused on innovative<br />
technology and coatings, which help<br />
to reduce a building’s energy costs.<br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany has been involved<br />
in the construction of high-profile<br />
buildings, such as South Africa’s<br />
Cape Town Stadium and Soccer<br />
City Stadium in Johannesburg, the<br />
Wimbledon Centre Court retractable<br />
roof in the UK, and the roof of the<br />
Suvarnabhumi International Airport<br />
in Bangkok, Thailand.<br />
Based on its expertise in large projects<br />
worldwide, in <strong>com</strong>bination with a<br />
high-profile interdisciplinary team,<br />
Hightex was re<strong>com</strong>mended for the<br />
refurbishment of the BC Place Stadium<br />
in Vancouver, Canada; however, the<br />
first involvement on BC Place was the<br />
inspection of the former membrane<br />
roof, which had some problems.<br />
Hightex performed well on this<br />
inspection and in a later stage<br />
proposed a new roofing system with<br />
a retractable inflated-membrane<br />
cushion roof, which is a new<br />
technology. Hightex re<strong>com</strong>mended<br />
developing such a system with the<br />
two engineering <strong>com</strong>panies, Geiger<br />
and SBP, which are among the leading<br />
<strong>com</strong>panies for stadia roofing systems.<br />
What was the nature of your<br />
involvement in BP Place?<br />
Hightex’s project scope was to supply<br />
the retractable cushion roof and the<br />
fixed ethylene tetrafluorethylene<br />
(ETFE) façade. The contract involved<br />
the fabrication and installation of the<br />
retractable portion of the membrane<br />
roof system − which is made of<br />
Tenara, a woven, high-translucency<br />
polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) fabric<br />
produced by Sefar − as well as the<br />
façade system, which will be made<br />
from a transparent membrane with a<br />
light-controlling frit pattern.<br />
What factors have to be taken<br />
into account when designing a<br />
membrane for a sliding roof?<br />
One big issue is weather conditions,<br />
especially snow load. You also have to<br />
select a material that is smooth enough<br />
Using Sefar Architecture Tenara Fabric,<br />
the new roof of the BC Place Stadium<br />
will provide energy savings of 25%<br />
<strong>com</strong>pared with the old roof.<br />
to be folded during the opening and<br />
closing of the roof, without damaging<br />
the PTFE coating of the material. Other<br />
issues were the huge forces on the<br />
stressing belts and the time restrictions<br />
for opening and closing the roof,<br />
which has to be inflated or deflated.<br />
This means you have an area of over<br />
80,000ft² that is closed in 12 minutes<br />
and opened in 16 minutes.<br />
Was saving energy a big factor?<br />
Yes, every event location/stadium<br />
operator has cost challenges,<br />
especially energy. The new roof is more<br />
energy-efficient than the original one,<br />
saving 25% on energy costs, which in<br />
this project is about C$350,000 a year.<br />
What materials did you opt for?<br />
We used ETFE for the façade and<br />
a PTFE fabric with a PTFE coating,<br />
Tenara by Sefar, for the roof. ETFE<br />
is a perfect fit because it is a highgrade,<br />
thin (value) film suitable for<br />
air-supported tensile roof or façade<br />
modules, and for double or multilayer<br />
systems for insulation as it is selfcleaning,<br />
has the lowest fire load, is<br />
self-extinguishing and hail-resistant,<br />
has a light transmission of up to 100%<br />
and a life expectancy of over 20 years.<br />
It also has a high UV-resistance factor,<br />
excellent mechanical properties, is<br />
very lightweight, waterproof and offers<br />
thermal insulation.<br />
We chose Sefar’s PTFE fabric for the<br />
roof because it is the highest class of<br />
woven membrane for permanent and<br />
retractable shading structures, and<br />
has an optimum folding capability.<br />
It is fire-retardant (B1), has a high<br />
UV-resistance, a high and lasting solar<br />
reflectance, excellent durability, a superb<br />
aesthetic, a high light transmission<br />
(up to 35%), an anti-adhesive,<br />
self-cleaning, waterproof surface and<br />
a life expectancy of over 20 years.<br />
How did your relationship<br />
with Sefar help Hightex<br />
devise a solution?<br />
We continue to have a very good<br />
relationship with Sefar and we had<br />
already used the Tenara material for<br />
other high-class retractable roofs, such<br />
as the roof of Wimbledon’s Centre Court.<br />
Sefar has a high-quality approach and<br />
is very customer-oriented. It develops<br />
a lot of high-end customer solutions<br />
and provides support if technically<br />
possible. Sefar and Hightex have built<br />
up an excellent team and both are<br />
quality leaders in their business. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Sefar and Hightex<br />
www.sefar.<strong>com</strong><br />
www.hightexworld.<strong>com</strong><br />
52<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Designing high-end heating<br />
solutions<br />
Every heating solution from MEINERTZ is designed and manufactured<br />
according to clients’ needs and scaled to their required heat output.<br />
If you want your heating<br />
solution to be an integrated part<br />
of the architecture, MEINERTZ<br />
has just what you need. Anyone<br />
looking for trench heating solutions,<br />
minimalistic heating panels,<br />
radiators, convectors, finned tubes,<br />
bench radiators – or something<br />
<strong>com</strong>pletely different – will find a<br />
warm solution with MEINERTZ.<br />
MEINERTZ is the architects’<br />
choice, translating ideas into<br />
unique design solutions. No<br />
goods are held in stock – all<br />
heating solutions are bespoke,<br />
manufactured to specific<br />
dimensions, and scaled according<br />
to the required heat output.<br />
MEINERTZ’s core <strong>com</strong>petence is<br />
the ability to think outside and in,<br />
to be inspired by its partners and to<br />
understand their ideas, because it is<br />
the detail that makes the design.<br />
The desired look of a heating<br />
solution can be achieved in many<br />
different ways. The minimalistic<br />
look can be reached by choosing<br />
a trench heating solution, such as<br />
MEINERTZ ProLine convection<br />
grilles or the Convec FloorLine<br />
<strong>com</strong>fort panel.<br />
If a more raw and rustic look<br />
is required, MEINERTZ Finned<br />
Tubes could be the solution. The<br />
MEINERTZ Convector and Radiator<br />
range represents more traditional<br />
heating solutions, but they can<br />
be slimmed down or given a flat<br />
front for a different expression.<br />
MEINERTZ Design Radiators cover<br />
different bench solutions, but they<br />
can also be specially designed to be<br />
mounted on large glazing units to<br />
prevent cold draughts. ●<br />
MEINERTZ offers bespoke<br />
heating solutions.<br />
Further information<br />
MEINERTZ<br />
www.meinertz.<strong>com</strong><br />
www.meinertz.<strong>com</strong>Architects choice<br />
Danish radiator design in high-end quality<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
53
Company insight<br />
It’s what’s<br />
underneath<br />
that counts<br />
Tecsom carpet tiles have beautiful and durable surfaces,<br />
and are backed by high environmental credentials.<br />
The environment is a key consideration during the<br />
manufacturing of Tecsom tiles.<br />
Tecsom was the first<br />
manufacturer to be awarded<br />
a Building Research<br />
Establishment Environmental Profile<br />
for its entire range of carpet tiles in<br />
2003. The <strong>com</strong>pany achieved this<br />
coveted ‘A’ rating certification for<br />
its meticulous attention to detail<br />
throughout the production, delivery<br />
and life of its carpet tiles.<br />
Tecsom’s team of experienced<br />
flooring specialists are always<br />
on hand to provide a <strong>com</strong>plete<br />
solutions-based service, offering<br />
sound product, technical and design<br />
advice. Solution-dyed yarns, a unique<br />
recycled backing and sustainability<br />
elements are key features of its<br />
extensive carpet tile range.<br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany continues to develop<br />
materials and manufacturing methods<br />
that provide high-performance products<br />
that are kinder to the environment.<br />
This is particularly important when<br />
one considers that floor coverings have<br />
the most significant environmental<br />
impact in a typical <strong>com</strong>mercial building<br />
<strong>com</strong>pared with any other material.<br />
Backing system<br />
Unlike other manufacturers, Tecsom’s<br />
BS Backing is produced using 100%<br />
pure recycled vinyl. The unique<br />
system gives excellent dimensional<br />
stability, while offering flexibility and<br />
tear-resistance far superior to any<br />
other product. It has outstanding<br />
acoustic properties and optimises<br />
<strong>com</strong>fort underfoot, a valuable element<br />
in a working environment.<br />
The high stability of Tecsom carpet tiles<br />
means they will not lose their shape.<br />
They can be moved, replaced or simply<br />
lifted so that, for example, work can be<br />
carried out on cables underneath.<br />
Yarn system<br />
The yarn used in Tecsom products<br />
is the basis for wear-resistance,<br />
colour-fastness and maintenance.<br />
Contributing to excellent<br />
sustainability, the yarn and fibres<br />
contain up to 20% recycled materials<br />
and are made from 100% polyamide,<br />
which is solution-dyed to reduce<br />
water consumption and polluted<br />
liquid effluent. This gives the best<br />
wear and aesthetic qualities to<br />
provide a floor that will perform well,<br />
even under heavy traffic conditions,<br />
and has minimum impact on the<br />
environment during manufacture.<br />
Maintenance and manufacture<br />
All Tecsom carpets are made for ease<br />
of cleaning, thus reducing the amount<br />
of water and chemicals required. A<br />
network of qualified cleaners ensures<br />
that the maintenance of its carpets is<br />
carried out to strict guidelines.<br />
• Solution-dyed yarn and fibres are<br />
used to reduce water consumption<br />
and polluted liquid effluent.<br />
• The yarn used for all certified<br />
Tecsom tiles contains up to 20%<br />
recycled materials.<br />
• The processed tufted width<br />
is reduced to minimise<br />
production wastage.<br />
• DOP plasticiser was eliminated<br />
in 2001.<br />
• New binding formulations reduce<br />
the amount of plasticiser or<br />
<strong>com</strong>pound required.<br />
• Tecsom BS Backing is made<br />
with 100% pure recycled vinyl.<br />
• Cardboard yarn cones are<br />
reused to minimise the use<br />
of new resources.<br />
• Packaging is manufactured<br />
using recycled cardboard.<br />
• Tecsom is <strong>com</strong>mitted to caring<br />
for the environment, in-house<br />
and throughout the industry.<br />
Tecsom carpets are manufactured<br />
in ISO 14001-recognised factories.<br />
Benefits<br />
• Tecsom ranges offer a wide<br />
choice of cut-pile, loop-pile<br />
and structured products in an<br />
extensive array of colours and<br />
designs. All products contribute<br />
to obtaining points towards MR2,<br />
MR4, MR5, IEQ4.1 and IEQ4.3<br />
credits for the LEED certification<br />
of buildings.<br />
Tecsom is a European manufacturer<br />
and supplier of high-quality carpets<br />
for <strong>com</strong>mercial applications.<br />
Its employees are dedicated to<br />
producing top-of-the-range products<br />
and services to ensure customer<br />
satisfaction and manufacturing<br />
with environmental consideration. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Tecsom<br />
www.tecsom.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
55
Insight > Design<br />
© Planmöbel/Lichtblick Fotografie, Volker Bültmann<br />
In good shape<br />
adidas Laces, the sportswear brand’s new headquarters, is designed to promote a fluid, collaborative work<br />
culture with WORKOUT, a modular furniture system that can be assembled in myriad ways. Abi Millar talks to<br />
Dirk Zweering of Kada Wittfeld and Karim El-Ishmawi of KINZO to discuss how architectural and interior<br />
innovation can best enhance a <strong>com</strong>pany’s working practices.<br />
In mid-2011, 1,700 adidas<br />
employees moved into their<br />
new corporate headquarters<br />
in Herzogenaurach, Germany.<br />
The latest addition to the brand’s<br />
thriving ‘World of Sports’ campus,<br />
adidas Laces sits between the Adi<br />
Dassler Sportplatz stadium and the<br />
adidas brand centre exhibition hall.<br />
Its mission: to foster creativity and<br />
team play through the conduit of<br />
clever design.<br />
Herzogenaurach, a small town in<br />
rural Franconia, is well known for<br />
its associations with sportswear,<br />
specifically a bitter sibling rivalry<br />
that spawned two global brands.<br />
It was here that Rudolph and<br />
Adi Dassler lived, worked and died,<br />
producing their first handmade<br />
sports shoes in their mother’s<br />
laundry room before quarrelling<br />
irreconcilably and moving to<br />
opposite sides of town.<br />
The rift was not merely fraternal;<br />
it involved the whole <strong>com</strong>munity,<br />
with the rival manufacturers (Puma<br />
and adidas) going so far as to<br />
sponsor separate football teams.<br />
This engendered a peculiarly<br />
sartorial kind of tribalism.<br />
Herzogenaurach was nicknamed<br />
‘the town of bent necks’, because<br />
residents would not speak to<br />
strangers until they had first<br />
looked down to check their shoes.<br />
Today Puma and adidas are<br />
based just a few miles apart,<br />
and while the animosity has<br />
cooled, the town’s fixation with<br />
sportswear remains. Situated on<br />
a one-time military air base, the<br />
adidas campus boasts a cluster<br />
of sports facilities, outdoor areas,<br />
residential units and offices.<br />
Not until the opening of Laces,<br />
however, did the ‘creatives’ gain a<br />
workspace specifically designed to<br />
suit their purposes.<br />
“We wanted to establish a<br />
custom-made office with a<br />
holistic concept,” says Karim El-<br />
Ishmawi of Berlin-based interior<br />
design firm KINZO. “When a<br />
corporation has its own identity,<br />
they want to live that identity,<br />
56<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Design<br />
rather than expressing it just<br />
through external <strong>com</strong>munications.”<br />
A flexible solution<br />
KINZO is the creative force behind<br />
WORKOUT, a modular furniture<br />
system custom-made for adidas,<br />
<strong>com</strong>prising 46 flexible elements.<br />
Manufactured by Planmöbel,<br />
the system runs throughout the<br />
entirety of the office area, and can<br />
be arranged to suit a wide range of<br />
needs. Here, the furniture choice is<br />
not merely a matter of kitting out<br />
a pre-partitioned space. Rather,<br />
it assumes some of the structural<br />
functions of interior design.<br />
Most salient in this regard is<br />
the central element: Teamplayer.<br />
A multifunctional room module,<br />
Teamplayer brings the other<br />
utensils together and can be used<br />
for storage or desktop support.<br />
More than that, however, it shapes<br />
the area, dividing and connecting<br />
teams as appropriate, and creating<br />
breakout spaces, workstations and<br />
meeting rooms.<br />
With its dark punched plate wall,<br />
the module contrives to look both<br />
semi-transparent from a distance<br />
and near-opaque up close. As<br />
such, it promotes both privacy<br />
and accessibility, <strong>com</strong>bining<br />
the breeziness of an open-plan<br />
workspace with the necessary<br />
degree of seclusion.<br />
“You are able to adjust the<br />
programme to the various needs<br />
of the building,” says El-Ishmawi,<br />
“creating either a really open kind<br />
1<br />
1. In adidas’s new Laces building, the ‘creatives’ gained a<br />
workspace specifically designed to suit their purposes.<br />
2-5. The WORKOUT modular furniture system <strong>com</strong>prises 46 flexible<br />
elements – the system runs through the entirety of the office<br />
area, and can be arranged to suit a wide range of needs.<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
© KINZO<br />
“whereas cubicle-based offices are<br />
geared toward nine-to-five, Today’s<br />
office designers are exploring<br />
ways to dismantle that rigidity.”<br />
of feeling, with a few desks and low<br />
partitions, or a dense atmosphere<br />
in which the partitions go almost<br />
up to the ceiling and are equipped<br />
with lots of fabrics and so forth.”<br />
The creatives’ requirements, no<br />
matter how idiosyncratic, were<br />
central to the design. An eclectic<br />
band of materials researchers,<br />
biomechanical experts, designers,<br />
engineers, product developers<br />
and marketing specialists,<br />
these workers do not confine<br />
themselves to files and paper.<br />
The system enables them to store<br />
their most unorthodox office<br />
items – textiles, shoes, balls and<br />
bags – and display them against an<br />
unobtrusive backdrop.<br />
KINZO has also endeavoured<br />
to reflect the realities of a flexible<br />
working culture. “There are lots<br />
of modern office concepts, such<br />
as mobile working, desk sharing,<br />
co-working, you name it,” says El-<br />
Ishmawi. “These are all just words,<br />
and you have to build the space<br />
around the ideas.”<br />
Inspired thinking<br />
Whereas old-style cubicle-based<br />
offices are geared toward nine-tofive,<br />
today’s office designers are<br />
exploring ways to dismantle that<br />
© Planmöbel/Lichtblick Fotografie, Volker Bültmann<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
57
9TH ANNUAL<br />
EMIRATES GLASS<br />
Sponsored by<br />
21st September,The Four Seasons Park Lane, London<br />
Sponsorship<br />
opportunities<br />
available!<br />
Please call Natasha Raynor<br />
on +44 207 936 6932 for<br />
further details<br />
To reserve your seat or<br />
table at LEAF Awards 2012<br />
please call Luisa De Vita<br />
on +44 (0)20 79366847<br />
www.arena-international.<strong>com</strong>/leafawards<br />
Follow us @ArchitectAwards<br />
Organised by
Insight > Design<br />
© Planmöbel/Lichtblick Fotografie, Volker Bültmann<br />
“WORKOUT supplies a framework,<br />
and adidas can create their world<br />
within this framework. A perfect<br />
fit with their work identity is the<br />
most important thing.”<br />
rigidity. In practice, this means<br />
handling variations in the numbers<br />
physically present at their desks.<br />
Because the <strong>com</strong>ponents can be<br />
easily rearranged, these furnishings<br />
are ideally suited to the vagaries of<br />
shape-shifting teams.<br />
This high adaptability and<br />
specialisation presents, as El-<br />
Ishmawi sees it, a resounding<br />
argument for going custom-made.<br />
“WORKOUT supplies a<br />
framework, and adidas can<br />
create their world within this<br />
framework,” he says. “Perfect fit<br />
with their work identity is the most<br />
important thing.”<br />
1<br />
1. Furnishings are ideally suited to shape-shifting teams.<br />
2. adidas products feature in the interior design.<br />
3. A perfect fit for adidas’s work identity was key.<br />
3<br />
2<br />
Conceptually, this is far removed<br />
from a traditional office design. A<br />
typical corporation, preparing to<br />
deck out its empty building, would<br />
generally select a furniture range<br />
that connoted certain traits – a<br />
‘classic’ range to suggest affluence,<br />
say, or more contemporary pieces<br />
to seem hip.<br />
The danger here is that the office<br />
will lose any sense of individuality,<br />
<strong>com</strong>municating its values through<br />
an appropriated dialect as opposed<br />
to its natural idiom. At worst, the<br />
space may resemble a furniture<br />
showroom; at best, the hundreds<br />
of other ‘hip’ or ‘classic’ offices in<br />
which the same range is deployed.<br />
Keeping fit<br />
This furniture, by contrast,<br />
conveys all the easy-going<br />
athleticism for which adidas is<br />
known. It integrates seamlessly<br />
with the design thread running<br />
throughout the rest of the building,<br />
such that it is difficult to say<br />
where KINZO’s role starts and the<br />
architect’s remit ends.<br />
Unusually for a corporate<br />
building, furniture, interior design<br />
and architecture were not treated<br />
as separate themes, but rather<br />
as a single design signature.<br />
The processes were developed<br />
in parallel, with furniture design<br />
incorporated at a strikingly early<br />
stage in the proceedings – when<br />
KINZO began work, the buildingto-be<br />
was still little more than a<br />
hole in the ground.<br />
The project architect, Aachenbased<br />
firm Kada Wittfeld, was<br />
working towards the same goals:<br />
creating a hub of collaboration and<br />
invention that would reflect the<br />
character of the brand.<br />
Their design went above and<br />
beyond adidas’s original brief,<br />
eschewing a standard office<br />
typology in favour of something far<br />
more distinctive.<br />
“It could be said that we won<br />
the <strong>com</strong>mission because we didn’t<br />
follow the brief in every aspect,”<br />
says Dirk Zweering, project partner.<br />
“We couldn’t imagine these<br />
creatives and designers working in<br />
a conventional office space.”<br />
The adidas guidelines specified<br />
an arrangement of around 70 office<br />
units, positioned to minimise<br />
internal through-traffic. While the<br />
expected solution would have been<br />
to intersperse the building with<br />
courtyards, Kada Wittfeld felt that<br />
such an approach lacked context.<br />
“We considered it to be<br />
wrong that, as a young and<br />
ambitious designer in such green<br />
surroundings, you would have<br />
to sit in your office and look out<br />
across your generic courtyard, onto<br />
the façade of your own building,”<br />
says Zweering. “You could be<br />
anywhere with that.”<br />
© Planmöbel/Lichtblick Fotografie, Volker Bültmann © Werner Huthmacher, Berlin<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
59
Insight > Design<br />
© Werner Huthmacher, Berlin<br />
The geometries of the adidas headquarters are clean and<br />
minimalistic with sporty contour lines.<br />
“There are lots of modern<br />
office concepts, such as mobile<br />
working, desk sharing... these are<br />
just words, you have to build the<br />
space around the ideas.”<br />
View points<br />
Kada Wittfeld thus determined that<br />
each workstation should have one<br />
view into a central atrium, and one<br />
towards the historic landscape of<br />
Herzogenaurach. From here, they<br />
developed the idea of a ringshaped<br />
building intersected by<br />
zig-zagging bridges.<br />
Made from steel 30cm thick,<br />
these bridges, or ‘laces’, are<br />
suspended from lattice supports,<br />
and serve to ‘tie’ the building<br />
together. They link units on<br />
opposite sides of the atrium<br />
and create a workspace rich<br />
in relationships.<br />
Six storeys high, the exterior is<br />
covered with windows and a flat,<br />
mirrored façade. The atrium, lush<br />
with greenery, has something of<br />
the semblance of a park, such that<br />
it is contiguous with the campus<br />
outside and invites those within it<br />
to interact. Communicability and<br />
transparency are the keynotes.<br />
The final result is unmistakably<br />
adidas. A squeezed parallelogram,<br />
roughly the same shape as a<br />
bow-tie, its geometries are clean<br />
and minimalistic, its contour lines<br />
sporty and straight.<br />
Set against the blanched colour<br />
scheme, the black bridges evoke<br />
nothing so much as the adidas<br />
logo. Were you to land here with<br />
zero foreknowledge, it wouldn’t<br />
take you long to guess the brand.<br />
Team spirit<br />
As workers familiarise themselves<br />
with the spaces, the building<br />
looks firmly poised to add value<br />
to the organisation.<br />
“Architecture, for sure, can provide<br />
the right circumstances for creativity<br />
and team play, and by doing so is<br />
able to enhance an existing corporate<br />
culture,” says Zweering. “If you walk<br />
through the adidas building right<br />
now, you will be able to sense that<br />
new team spirit.”<br />
El-Ishmawi agrees. “The only<br />
way to create your own identity,<br />
as an office, is to incorporate your<br />
specific needs – your culture and<br />
the way you work – into the<br />
design process. Interior design<br />
in office space is a relatively<br />
new field but, because of the<br />
change in working environments,<br />
the need has grown greater than<br />
ever before.”<br />
With this in mind, we might<br />
think back to Adi Dassler’s shoe<br />
designs, which were guided by a<br />
single tenet.<br />
He believed that shoes should<br />
be ideally adapted to the discipline<br />
in hand, with all their features<br />
expressly tailored to maximise<br />
the wearer’s performance. No<br />
doubt he would have expected<br />
nothing less from his brand’s<br />
corporate headquarters.<br />
As El-Ishmawi puts it, “A<br />
corporation has to think about how<br />
it can optimise its ways of working<br />
and install it into a building. You<br />
build the way you work.” ●<br />
60<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight > Design<br />
Filler-free ceilings made easy<br />
Designers can create homogenous ceiling surfaces and make sanding and cross-sanding a thing of the past with<br />
VoglFuge from German ceiling systems manufacturer Vogl Deckensysteme.<br />
Acoustic design ceilings<br />
are expected to display a<br />
homogenous appearance.<br />
To achieve this, ceiling systems<br />
manufacturer Vogl Deckensysteme<br />
offers installers the use of VoglFuge –<br />
an alternative to existing joint systems,<br />
which use adhesive and <strong>com</strong>pound<br />
seams. With VoglFuge, joint finishing<br />
and levelling of the ceiling surface<br />
can be efficiently, easily and safely<br />
ac<strong>com</strong>plished, with excellent results.<br />
How does it work? First, the<br />
individual acoustic ceiling elements<br />
are installed on a rigid ceiling<br />
framework to create an even surface.<br />
Next, the <strong>com</strong>prehensive VoglFuge<br />
system kit is used to carry out the<br />
levelling procedure.<br />
After <strong>com</strong>pensating for any height<br />
discrepancies by readjusting the Vogl<br />
perforated panel screws, the screw<br />
heads in the joint area are spot-filled<br />
with Vogl screw head and repair<br />
filler, and any protruding pieces of<br />
plasterboard removed using a sanding<br />
pad. The joint area is then slightly<br />
moistened with a sponge and the<br />
ready-mixed Vogl liquid joint coating<br />
is applied with a lambskin roller.<br />
The VoglFuge strip is placed in the<br />
middle of the moist liquid joint coating<br />
with its rubberised side down, affixing<br />
it to the joint, and the panel joint area<br />
is covered generously with liquid joint<br />
coating. This takes two hours to dry<br />
– plenty of time to spot-fill the screw<br />
heads in the middle of the panels.<br />
Finally, the joint surface is smoothed<br />
with sanding paper.<br />
With VoglFuge, sanding and crosssanding<br />
are a thing of the past and<br />
the result is impressive: an appealing<br />
surface image without any visible<br />
panel edges. ●<br />
© Donal Murphy Photography<br />
Further information<br />
Vogl Deckensysteme<br />
www.vogl-deckensysteme.de<br />
Banish the<br />
appearance of<br />
panel edges.<br />
Full range for perfect ceilings<br />
Ceiling systems in form, colour and performance www.vogl-ceilingsystems.<strong>com</strong><br />
Acoustics Design Lighting Climate<br />
Base product are plasterboard ceiling systems that can perform various functions with all the requirements of the modern ceiling design – especially in high-traffic areas.<br />
Acoustics, design, lighting and climate ceilings are our core <strong>com</strong>petencies. In addition to seamless ceilings and stretch ceilings our product portfolio also includes various<br />
types of arches, domes or curved segments as well as our visually attractive, but most of all acoustically highly active acoustic plaster system.<br />
Vogl Deckensysteme GmbH ● Industriestrasse 10 ● 91448 Emskirchen ● Germany ● Phone: +49 (0) 9104 - 825 - 0 ● info@vogl-deckensysteme.de<br />
Anzeige_220x106_eng.indd 1 01.12.2010 14:02:13<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
61
Insight > Design<br />
The elements<br />
of surprise<br />
With <strong>com</strong>missions ranging<br />
from converted textile<br />
mills to the Playboy Club,<br />
award-winning international<br />
practice Jestico + Whiles<br />
is celebrated for its playful<br />
take on design. Abi Millar,<br />
John Whiles and James<br />
Dilley discuss the firm’s<br />
marriage of theatricality<br />
with understatement.<br />
When Playboy began talks<br />
with Jestico + Whiles,<br />
it was adamant that its<br />
new Mayfair-based club should<br />
<strong>com</strong>municate the unique character of<br />
its brand.<br />
“’Just how many bunny heads<br />
can you fit on a building?’” recalls<br />
James Dilley, associate director at the<br />
architecture and interior design firm.<br />
“That was how the conversation with<br />
Playboy went. They said, ‘If you give<br />
us 10,000, we’ll be over the moon’.”<br />
Playboy being Playboy, subtlety<br />
was out of the equation. The brand is<br />
known for its highly distinctive – and<br />
somewhat retrogressive – aesthetic;<br />
a typology that would work perfectly<br />
in a tawdry Las Vegas casino. With<br />
the location being central London’s<br />
upmarket Mayfair district, however,<br />
62<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Design<br />
© James Newton ©.Gerry O’Leary<br />
the challenge was clear: how would<br />
a building emblazoned with 10,000<br />
bunny heads fit in?<br />
The eventual design solution was<br />
as simple as it was ingenious: opaque<br />
mashrabiya-style partitions that cover<br />
the windows and section off the ground<br />
floor. Each of these screens can pivot<br />
180°, facilitating privacy or openness.<br />
Most inventively, they are cut with<br />
radial patterns of thousands of bunny<br />
heads, which at first glance resemble<br />
little more than elaborate latticework.<br />
“It’s understated, even though<br />
we may have 10,000 logos on the<br />
wall,” says Dilley. “We had to mediate<br />
between the requirements of the<br />
context and the operator – huge signs<br />
shouting ‘Playboy’ wouldn’t necessarily<br />
have been appropriate. But you didn’t<br />
pick up that those were bunny heads,<br />
so that means we’ve succeeded.”<br />
Subtle distinction<br />
I am sitting with Dilley and the firm’s<br />
founding director John Whiles in their<br />
slick offices just off London’s Euston<br />
Road. Guided by a slideshow, they are<br />
running me through their portfolio and<br />
I can testify that the bunny heads did<br />
indeed pass me by. This is typical of<br />
a practice whose work is designed to<br />
sneak up on the viewer.<br />
“Design should grow on you,”<br />
says Whiles. “If you pass one of our<br />
buildings on a bus, you’ll say, ’Oh<br />
yes’, but then the next day you’ll go,<br />
’Oh that’s interesting’. And that effect<br />
builds. It’s not in your face; it’s subtle.”<br />
Jestico + Whiles was founded in<br />
1977 by Whiles and fellow architect<br />
Tom Jestico. The firm has since<br />
grown dramatically with a second<br />
office in Prague, a plethora of awards<br />
to its credit and <strong>com</strong>missions<br />
across the world. Its expertise<br />
spans many sectors – housing,<br />
hotels, retail, restaurants, offices,<br />
schools, universities, and transport<br />
infrastructure, among others.<br />
Theirs is a diverse portfolio without<br />
much in the way of visual continuity<br />
– each project draws far more upon<br />
1<br />
1. andel’s Hotel Lodz, Poland, mixes industry and tradition.<br />
2. Thousands of bunny heads adorn the Playboy Club Mayfair.<br />
3. The University of Southampton’s Mountbatten Building.<br />
4. Yas Viceroy Hotel, Abu Dhabi, is one of a kind.<br />
contextual factors than it does upon<br />
signature motifs. Nonetheless, certain<br />
key tenets do resound throughout<br />
their output: humour, theatricality and<br />
an element of surprise. “I think people<br />
go into our buildings and smile,” says<br />
Whiles. “Something’s happening there<br />
that they would not expect.”<br />
Take andel’s Hotel Lodz in Poland, a<br />
former textile mill <strong>com</strong>pleted in 2009:<br />
this is a witty, striking, art-glutted<br />
storybook of a hotel, simultaneously<br />
honouring its industrial origins and<br />
entrammelling itself in Polish culture.<br />
In the conference break-out area,<br />
there are seats that look like sweets<br />
– <strong>com</strong>modious confectionary pieced<br />
together from scraps of fabric – and on<br />
the roof a one-time water storage tank<br />
has been converted into a swimming<br />
pool. Lucent and ethereal with<br />
music playing underwater, the pool<br />
is surrounded by transparent, glasspanelled<br />
flooring. Beneath is a sheer<br />
seven-storey drop, allowing a straight<br />
view down to the wintry city below.<br />
Pride of place<br />
Jestico + Whiles takes a particular<br />
interest in hotel design, having<br />
started out some 15 years ago in a<br />
purely architectural capacity before<br />
moving on to interiors. The list of past<br />
<strong>com</strong>missions is substantial: the Dead<br />
Sea Spa Hotel in Jordan; London’s<br />
Hempel Hotel and One Aldwych; Abu<br />
Dhabi’s Yas Viceroy Hotel; and the<br />
Red & Blue Design Hotel in Prague to<br />
name but a few.<br />
Most recently, two newbuilds in<br />
London have opened just in time for<br />
the 2012 Olympic Games.<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
63
Insight > Design<br />
“London’s a very difficult place in<br />
which to build if you don’t take the<br />
pastichr route,” <strong>com</strong>ments Dilley.<br />
“We’ve been sensitive and gentle, but<br />
also quite brave because no one’s<br />
done anything like this in this location.<br />
Especially with this forming part of the<br />
Olympic torch relay route, it’s good to<br />
have something that Westminster can<br />
be proud of in a global context.”<br />
He is referring to the W London,<br />
which came with some particularly<br />
fusty local authority planners. Sitting<br />
across three conservation areas, the<br />
building was tasked with reflecting<br />
the vibrancy of Soho, the theatre of<br />
Leicester Square and the Edwardian<br />
formality of Haymarket, all within the<br />
context of a young and elite brand.<br />
The firm responded by applying<br />
the high design treatment. Because<br />
planning laws required active<br />
frontages at street level, the hotel<br />
itself does not start until the first floor,<br />
meaning the entrance works as a kind<br />
of stage, and the lights and glamour of<br />
the elevated reception spill out onto<br />
the bustling streets below.<br />
Reflecting the context took a highly<br />
literal slant. Translucent glass was<br />
suspended from the façade, mirroring<br />
the surrounding hubbub. A cacophony<br />
of colour is visible by day; an internally<br />
illuminated veil of light by night.<br />
The second hotel, Aloft London<br />
Excel, which opened last December,<br />
was created within equally tight<br />
constraints. Situated in London’s<br />
Docklands and connected to the ExCel<br />
Centre, the property is a serpentine<br />
shape that does not to encroach on the<br />
dockside. With a glass central plane<br />
and two external wings in a specially<br />
treated, light-reflective stainless steel, it<br />
is dappled with an undulating skyscape<br />
of purples, pinks, greys and blues.<br />
Entertainment vs <strong>com</strong>munity<br />
Insofar as visual dazzle is often low<br />
down a hotel’s agenda, Jestico +<br />
Whiles redresses a recent trend. “Over<br />
the last 15–20 years, hotels have lost<br />
some glamour,” laments Dilley. “In the<br />
70s, going to a Hilton was the epitome<br />
of luxury and class, but hotels have<br />
been allowed to slip into a kind of<br />
mediocrity. It doesn’t have to be that<br />
way. You don’t need to spend more<br />
money to make something an icon.”<br />
Their portfolio thus eschews the idea<br />
of a hotel as merely somewhere private<br />
to recoup. Intimacy is supplemented<br />
with entertainment, snugness with<br />
spectacle and closed-off corridors with<br />
an expansive, public-oriented ethos.<br />
Nor is this element of <strong>com</strong>municability<br />
confined to their hotels. At present,<br />
the firm is working on two research<br />
laboratories specifically designed to<br />
facilitate interaction.<br />
“Research is all about the incidental<br />
meeting of people walking past each<br />
other and chatting,” says Whiles.<br />
“So we’ve put whiteboards in the<br />
corridors; we’ve included settees so<br />
people can sit down; we’ve made<br />
the landings on the staircases extra<br />
large so that people passing on the<br />
stairs can hang out and talk without<br />
interrupting the flow. The buildings are<br />
designed to inspire people and make<br />
the workplace a happy one.”<br />
These buildings are just two of<br />
many new projects in the pipeline.<br />
On the day of our interview, Whiles is<br />
gearing up for an up<strong>com</strong>ing meeting<br />
about an arts centre in Sri Lanka,<br />
and has just taken a call about a<br />
large retail outlet in Milan. A few<br />
weeks later, he will head to Cuba to<br />
discuss the prospect of developing<br />
a nanotechnology laboratory there.<br />
Dilley, meanwhile, is working on the<br />
off-site construction of West African<br />
modular hotels.<br />
Both agree that the travel is<br />
enlivening, adding extra character and<br />
flavour to their practice.<br />
Whiles remarks that he did not<br />
expect this level of growth when he<br />
started out, but he concedes that<br />
sheer grit might have had a role to<br />
play – this is an issue of trust, so<br />
the staff have a personal incentive to<br />
give their all. Everyone, says Whiles,<br />
works “bloody hard”.<br />
W London reflects the vibrancy of Soho,<br />
the theatre of Leicester Square and the<br />
Edwardian formality of Haymarket.<br />
“INTIMACY IS SUPPLEMENTED<br />
WITH ENTERTAINMENT, SNUGNESS<br />
WITH SPECTACLE AND CLOSED-OFF<br />
CORRIDORS WITH AN EXPANSIVE,<br />
PUBLIC-ORIENTED ETHOS.”<br />
A testament to their ongoing<br />
success came last summer when<br />
Whiles took a trip back to an early<br />
project – Burrells Wharf in the<br />
Docklands. An industrial-style<br />
residential development, in the 20<br />
years since its conception it has<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e a surprising social hub. As<br />
Whiles sat in the main square with his<br />
picnic, residents emerged from their<br />
buildings to share their views.<br />
“Their reaction was just wonderful,”<br />
Whiles recalls. “They said, ‘This is the<br />
best place to live’, with the barbecues<br />
in the summer and an active website.<br />
The managing concierge told us we’ve<br />
designed a <strong>com</strong>munity. Or, at least,<br />
we’ve designed the catalyst for the<br />
<strong>com</strong>munity to work.”<br />
Whatever the building, Jestico<br />
+ Whiles sees its central task as<br />
developing empathy with its context.<br />
If you conceptualise a building as<br />
a journey then the designer’s task<br />
is primarily to understand how<br />
that journey makes people feel: the<br />
emotions elicited from the moment<br />
you pull up in the taxi through to the<br />
point at which you leave.<br />
Even the Playboy Club has done<br />
a sterling job of dispelling unwanted<br />
associations, evincing the firm’s rare<br />
knack for turning potential quandaries<br />
into triumphs. “We’ve been lucky<br />
enough to get a lot of once-in-a-lifetime<br />
opportunities back to back,” says Dilley.<br />
“As a design practice, you can’t really<br />
ask for much more than that.” ●<br />
© James Newton<br />
64<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Undercover inspiration<br />
More than mere canopies, Textil Bau’s membrane structures provide intelligent and<br />
innovative solutions for a wide range of construction projects.<br />
Textil Bau, founded in 1999, is<br />
a <strong>com</strong>pany that designs and<br />
implements projects in the<br />
field of textile architecture. The firm is<br />
known for its challenging membrane<br />
constructions throughout the world,<br />
in particular on cruise liners and<br />
ocean-going yachts, as well as in<br />
trade fairs and exhibitions, hotels,<br />
gastronomic areas, and landscape<br />
gardening and architecture.<br />
Textil Bau’s unique membrane<br />
constructions are created in<br />
cooperation with an established<br />
network of international engineers,<br />
steel and membrane construction<br />
builders, and installation experts.<br />
Whether they are conical shapes,<br />
free forms or arches, Textil Bau’s<br />
membrane structures are intelligent<br />
and innovative solutions.<br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany’s service starts with<br />
a consultation about the design and<br />
structure, covering detail planning,<br />
production and installation, and<br />
culminating in maintenance issues.<br />
This enables Textil Bau to guarantee<br />
a professional and economical project<br />
management service, from the first<br />
design to the finished installation.<br />
One successful project is the renovation<br />
and modernisation of the Niggemann<br />
fresh food market in Bochum, Germany,<br />
for which Textil Bau installed new<br />
roofing for the customer parking area.<br />
This is an interlinked construction<br />
made of eight textile funnel sunshades<br />
covering a total area of 1,100m².<br />
The supporting structure consists<br />
of eight pillars, each with eight<br />
galvanised steel cantilever arms. The<br />
membrane roof is made of a PVCcoated<br />
polyester fabric manufactured<br />
by Ferrari, and is strengthened<br />
by edge and radial straps. The<br />
A Textil Bau canopy covering the parking area of<br />
the Niggemann fresh food market in Bochum.<br />
outstanding characteristics of this<br />
structure are that the funnels are made<br />
in one piece and the cutting pattern of<br />
the shades was inspired by the natural<br />
form and structure of a leaf. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Textil Bau<br />
www.textilbau.de<br />
innovative membrane structures<br />
We offer a full service for your<br />
membrane construction:<br />
Design & Engineering<br />
Project management<br />
Production<br />
Installation<br />
Maintenance<br />
Take a look at our website<br />
www.textilbau.de<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
65
Company insight<br />
Above and beyond<br />
With approximately 40% of the world’s energy consumed by buildings, efficient<br />
people flow is crucial. Kone Corporation’s director of products and technology,<br />
Johannes de Jong, discusses how the modern elevator can help architects<br />
improve the design, efficiency and performance of today’s buildings.<br />
“We have a great variety of intelligent<br />
ways to increase elevator efficiency,”<br />
says de Jong. “Our destination control<br />
system, for example, puts people<br />
going in the same destination in the<br />
same car. It adds organisation to the<br />
whole flow process and is around<br />
25% more efficient than a single-deck<br />
conventional button system.<br />
Though rarely appreciated,<br />
the modern high-rise would<br />
be unthinkable if not for the<br />
invention of vertical transportation.<br />
Without a carefully designed<br />
elevator system controlling the flow<br />
of people, most buildings simply<br />
could not function. According to a<br />
recent study by Consumer Watch,<br />
US elevators alone make over 18<br />
billion trips each year. Industry<br />
experts often describe this situation<br />
like a body’s bloodstream – without<br />
the right flow, it just won’t work.<br />
Today’s elevators expend 2–10% of<br />
a building’s energy; a startling figure<br />
given that buildings account for 40%<br />
of the world’s energy output. It’s<br />
estimated that with a modern design,<br />
the elevator could reduce its carbon<br />
footprint by as much as 70%, a huge<br />
saving in financial, environmental and<br />
social terms. Kone has been at the<br />
forefront of that effort. Having received<br />
an impressive 83/100 rating from the<br />
Carbon Disclosure Project, it’s now<br />
considered the most eco-efficient<br />
elevator <strong>com</strong>pany in the world.<br />
Target efficiency<br />
“According to data we saw at a<br />
summit in Copenhagen, the only<br />
way to effectively control the rise<br />
in global temperature by 2020 is to<br />
target efficiency,” says Johannes<br />
de Jong, director of products and<br />
technology at Kone Corporation. “As<br />
things stand, efficiency levels are too<br />
low to meet the level needed. So, as a<br />
<strong>com</strong>pany, we’ve done various things<br />
to improve eco-efficiency in the<br />
It’s estimated that<br />
with a modern design,<br />
the elevator can reduce<br />
its carbon footprint by<br />
as much as 70%, a<br />
huge saving in financial,<br />
environmental and<br />
social terms.<br />
design, construction and operation<br />
of the elevator.”<br />
Conventional elevation technology<br />
works by using a zone of lifts and<br />
a standard pushbutton system. As<br />
people arrive in the lobby, lots of<br />
buttons get pressed and many stops<br />
are made. Each stop can take up to<br />
12 seconds between acceleration,<br />
which, with time the crucial<br />
yardstick of successful elevation,<br />
is usually considered too slow. Also,<br />
traditional systems are too large,<br />
encroaching on space that could<br />
otherwise be used by the owners.<br />
“There are three ways that we can<br />
improve the temporal and spatial<br />
efficiency of the lift,” explains de<br />
Jong. “With zoning, we can split the<br />
building into stacked areas, which<br />
keeps down the number of stops<br />
made and the length of time people<br />
spend waiting. Secondly, by stacking<br />
the cars, we can minimise elevator<br />
core space and use the building<br />
more efficiently. The idea is to place<br />
two cars on top of one another and<br />
get twice the population in the same<br />
cross-sectional area. Finally, when<br />
buildings get really big, the trick<br />
is to divide them in two and build<br />
a shuttle service up to the local<br />
sky lobby. These are <strong>com</strong>plicated<br />
arrangements where you have to<br />
know exactly what you’re doing.<br />
I think the use of consultancy is<br />
extremely valuable.”<br />
Better design<br />
Kone has a variety of mechanical<br />
ways to improve the efficiency of<br />
lift design. One of these, introduced<br />
in 1996, is the machine-room-less<br />
elevator. In this case, by removing<br />
the separate area over the hoistway<br />
it’s possible to build an entirely new<br />
floor for the building, expanding<br />
lease space and improving<br />
efficiency. Another device, also<br />
bought to market by Kone, is the<br />
counterweight-less elevator, which<br />
can expand the size of the car in<br />
a way that improves wheelchair<br />
access and safety.<br />
“Our selection of elevator traffic<br />
tools offer architects who need to<br />
do all kinds of different trials the<br />
right technology, without heavy<br />
consultancy fees. We also have<br />
a range of eco-efficient solutions<br />
that are designed to improve the<br />
elevator’s core operational ability.<br />
These include sliding doors,<br />
lubrication-free step chains, and<br />
regenerative drive systems that can<br />
reuse up to 35% of the car’s energy.”<br />
The JumpLift<br />
When a building is under assembly,<br />
vertical transportation can prove<br />
challenging. A recent study by the<br />
University of Hong Kong estimated<br />
that greater efficiency in elevation<br />
could save up to 20% more labour<br />
time than conventional rack and<br />
pinion systems. Kone’s self-climbing<br />
JumpLift is specifically designed to<br />
achieve that level of efficiency in<br />
construction. Capable of carrying<br />
4,000kg at up to 4m/s, the elevator<br />
is being used in London’s Shard<br />
building where it’s thought to save<br />
as much as 750 hours every day.<br />
Along with the Carbon Disclosure<br />
Project, a string of other awards<br />
have recognised the dramatic role<br />
Kone has played in reducing energy<br />
consumption. With the economic and<br />
social costs of powering a building<br />
rising, that work is likely to be<strong>com</strong>e<br />
even more valuable in the near future. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Kone Corporation<br />
www.kone.<strong>com</strong><br />
66<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
3D quality assured<br />
An enriched 3D modelling system from CAD/CAM solutions provider bocad enables architects and engineers<br />
to limit technical issues ahead of the building phase.<br />
Wouldn’t it be great if<br />
architects could minimise<br />
technical problems in<br />
the planning stage and simply<br />
concentrate on the creative act?<br />
This dream became reality in the<br />
creation of a new football stadium<br />
in Posen, Poland, when design and<br />
functionality were merged into a 3D<br />
model and the project became visible.<br />
The challenge of detailing this model<br />
– to precisely design all members,<br />
connections and bracing constructions<br />
– was carried out with the aid of<br />
bocad’s digital workflow system.<br />
All models of CAD systems for<br />
architects are focused on design. At<br />
the point of import to the bocad-3D<br />
system, technological information<br />
regarding materials, connection means<br />
and standards were contributed by<br />
bocad from its knowledge database,<br />
and the model was thereby upgraded.<br />
On the basis of this enriched 3D<br />
model, it was possible to define<br />
numerous construction rules, based<br />
upon which thousands of nodes could<br />
be detailed automatically.<br />
Besides the increased quality, the<br />
detailing speed also accelerated<br />
enormously. To ensure that<br />
everything fitted perfectly, the<br />
bocad-3D model was again<br />
enriched with production-specific<br />
information. Using this, production<br />
steps and sequences were defined<br />
and planned. The numerical control<br />
data was also derived automatically<br />
from the enriched 3D model,<br />
allowing the direct operation of<br />
NC machines.<br />
This demonstrates how bocad’s<br />
digital workflow lets visions <strong>com</strong>e to<br />
life – through the use of added-value<br />
3D models. ●<br />
Further information<br />
bocad<br />
www.bocad.<strong>com</strong><br />
How bocad’s<br />
system works.<br />
steel<br />
concrete<br />
glazing<br />
timber<br />
cladding<br />
R<br />
bocad‘s<br />
Digital Workflow<br />
lets visions <strong>com</strong>e true –<br />
by 3D models<br />
with surplus value.<br />
bocad<br />
Your High-Performance-Partner in CAD/CAM<br />
Am Umweltpark 7<br />
44793 Bochum Germany<br />
© Cimolai - Soccer City Johannesburg<br />
The software solution for<br />
design, detailing, manufacturing, erection.<br />
Fon + 49 234-96417-55<br />
Fax + 49 234-96417-58<br />
CAD/CAM<br />
Technology for your sucess<br />
www.bocad.<strong>com</strong><br />
info@bocad.<strong>com</strong><br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
67
Special report > Practices<br />
Size vs creativity<br />
As multinational practices grow ever larger, to what<br />
extent are we witnessing a flight towards safety at the<br />
expense of ambition? And does scale stifle style?<br />
Herbert Wright meets RPBW’s Renzo Piano, Aedas<br />
CEO David Roberts and partners from boutique<br />
firms DGT and Plasma Studio to discuss a shifting<br />
architectural landscape and whether size truly matters<br />
68<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Special report > Practices<br />
In 2011, less than ten years<br />
after its formation, Aedas<br />
was declared the largest<br />
practice on the planet, with 1,500<br />
architectural employees among<br />
its staff. In a troubled economic<br />
environment, and challenging time<br />
for the construction industry, the<br />
news seems counterintuitive. But<br />
Aedas’ rise reflects a wider trend:<br />
the emergence of the super practice,<br />
a new breed of unfashionable<br />
multinational behemoths that<br />
don’t entice the media attention of<br />
established ‘starchitects’, yet boast an<br />
unprecedentedly bulging and diverse<br />
portfolio of offices, projects and styles.<br />
What does their success tell us<br />
about the state of the market and<br />
the motivations of those holding<br />
the purse strings? One popular<br />
interpretation is that corporate and<br />
public clients have be<strong>com</strong>e more riskaverse<br />
and see safety in scale. Where<br />
this leaves young, small practices<br />
looking to enter the international<br />
arena is just one of the questions<br />
arising from such a shift and, if young<br />
talent is being muscled out, what are<br />
the longer-term permutations for our<br />
built environment?<br />
Wary of growth<br />
Paris-based Dorell.Ghotmeh.Tane/<br />
Architects (DGT) is a young boutique<br />
practice, and Lina Ghotmeh, one of its<br />
three partners, would be happy to see<br />
its size double to 30, but fears that any<br />
bigger and the practice would have<br />
to “abide by strict rules of design,<br />
productivity, efficiency and hierarchy<br />
in order for it to persist”.<br />
“At some point,” she continues,<br />
“these factors overflow the creative<br />
aspects of architecture as well as the<br />
uniqueness of each intervention.”<br />
Aedas is some hundred times<br />
bigger than DGT, but London-based<br />
CEO David Roberts doesn’t think size<br />
stifles creativity. “We believe our scale<br />
offers an efficient infrastructure that<br />
frees up our designers to concentrate<br />
on the creative process. Also, the<br />
number of designers and breadth of<br />
experience throughout the practice<br />
allows an exchange of ideas, which<br />
supports the creative process.”<br />
Roberts describes the 32 worldwide<br />
Aedas offices as “rooted in their local<br />
<strong>com</strong>munities” in Europe, the Middle<br />
East and Asia.<br />
The autonomy of corporate local<br />
offices is evidence that smallness can<br />
increase open-thinking and bigness<br />
stifle creativity. At least that’s how<br />
co-founding partner of Plasma Studio<br />
Holger Kehne feels. “It is proven by<br />
the fact that larger corporations have<br />
strategies to bring down their scale<br />
and form smaller subgroups in order<br />
to perform,” he says.<br />
Plasma started in London in 1999<br />
and now has three partners and 10<br />
project architects, although Kehne<br />
acknowledges that it shares resources<br />
with its sister <strong>com</strong>pany Groundlab,<br />
a landscape urbanism studio. With<br />
offices in London, Italy and Beijing,<br />
Plasma already has as many bases<br />
as far larger firms, such as Renzo<br />
Piano’s RPBW, with offices in Paris,<br />
Genoa and New York.<br />
From the Centre Pompidou to<br />
London’s Shard, Piano’s tireless<br />
inventiveness has established the<br />
74-year-old Italian as one of the<br />
world’s greatest architects, and,<br />
with about 150 people, his firm’s<br />
size is logarithmically half-way<br />
between Plasma or DGT and Aedas.<br />
He says the right size ultimately<br />
means being “big enough to do<br />
whatever you want”.<br />
“Then you be<strong>com</strong>e like one of those<br />
people who doesn’t change weight,”<br />
he continues. “A good metabolism. You<br />
1<br />
1. The Paris offices of DGT.<br />
2. Renovation of 1 Grosvenor Place by Aedas.<br />
3. Aedas CEO David Roberts.<br />
2<br />
3<br />
don’t suffer from getting thinner or fatter;<br />
you have great continuity.” Piano refers<br />
to his ten partners and 15 associates as<br />
“the rock upon which we base the office<br />
– a secret of why we’re doing well”.<br />
But in an increasingly globalised<br />
environment, how does size relate to<br />
a global marketplace? Aedas started<br />
in 2002 when young Hong Kong<br />
practice LPT approached mid-sized<br />
UK practice Abbey Holford Rowe,<br />
suggesting they merge. “We were<br />
able to capitalise on the boom in<br />
construction throughout both Western<br />
Europe and the Far East,” explains<br />
Roberts. “Size alone was never the<br />
objective; the ability to offer a full<br />
range of architectural solutions to<br />
both multinational and locally based<br />
clients was always the priority.”<br />
DGT’s international origin has quite<br />
different roots. Its three partners,<br />
drawn from Italy, Lebanon and Japan,<br />
got together in London in 2006 and<br />
decided to go for the Estonian National<br />
Museum <strong>com</strong>petition. When they won,<br />
Ghotmeh realised: “Our international<br />
mix dressed the project with the<br />
strange familiarity of its being”.<br />
“We all <strong>com</strong>e from totally different<br />
backgrounds,” observes co-partner<br />
Tsuyoshi Tane. “This makes us more<br />
aware of what is happening in this<br />
globalised situation.”<br />
Developing talent<br />
Open <strong>com</strong>petitions are the gateway<br />
to the international stage and should<br />
give newer, smaller practices a chance<br />
on high-profile projects, but without<br />
a win, they burn scant resources.<br />
“Competitions have been vital for our<br />
development and we started doing<br />
them on a shoe-string,” recalls Kehne.<br />
“It is difficult, however, to keep doing<br />
that over a longer period. Now we are<br />
very rarely able to do open ones, but<br />
concentrate on invited <strong>com</strong>petitions<br />
where costs are covered.”<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
69
Special report > Practices<br />
“Competitions are important to<br />
develop and trigger our creativity,”<br />
says Ghotmeh. “They also help<br />
consolidate and define our design<br />
approach and can put us on the<br />
market at the same level of various<br />
types of offices. It is true that they are<br />
a bit ‘dangerous’ resource-wise, so the<br />
type and number of <strong>com</strong>petitions we<br />
enter is always considered closely.”<br />
That last factor is certainly an<br />
area where Roberts sees Aedas’<br />
size helping. “In some respects, we<br />
have an advantage in that we can<br />
fund ourselves when bidding for a<br />
job, whereas some smaller practices<br />
might struggle,” he acknowledges.<br />
“However, clients will ultimately still<br />
be swayed by design and it is the<br />
quality of design above and beyond all<br />
other factors that wins jobs.”<br />
Big-name credibility<br />
Can the credibility associated with<br />
a big name help win <strong>com</strong>missions,<br />
particularly with large clients? “This<br />
is sadly often the case,” reflects<br />
Kehne. “Although history shows that<br />
an ambitious small office can get<br />
anything done and, in turn, many<br />
projects by large corporate practices<br />
have been a disaster. There are still<br />
misconceptions regarding size and<br />
ability to deliver. This is increasingly<br />
at odds with the volatilities of the<br />
market. In order to maintain a sizable<br />
office, a firm might be forced to<br />
<strong>com</strong>promise by taking jobs that are<br />
not exactly aligned with their ethos,<br />
skill set or quality expectations.”<br />
Roberts recognises the sizecredibility<br />
link. “In the current<br />
economic climate, there is no doubt<br />
that clients are reassured to be<br />
working with a well resourced and<br />
well managed practice that they can<br />
trust to deliver the job,” he says.<br />
Piano’s name is clearly a key factor<br />
with clients, but he is keen to stress<br />
that this means much less internally.<br />
“I’m not the owner,” he insists. “I<br />
share this. I push to share.” Asked<br />
if he would change RPBW’s name,<br />
as former collaborator and fellow<br />
starchitect Richard Rogers did with his<br />
practice, he admits,“I’ve been thinking<br />
about that; we’ll be<strong>com</strong>e the Building<br />
Workshop one day”, but suggests that<br />
will be when he decides to step away.<br />
There’s certainly no sign of that yet.<br />
Small success<br />
Over at DGT, Ghotmeh is <strong>com</strong>fortable<br />
that size has not proved a hindrance.<br />
“As a small office, we have not<br />
encountered such a problem,” she<br />
insists. “We have always tried to<br />
<strong>com</strong>municate our <strong>com</strong>petence<br />
through our work and through<br />
exposing to the clients the process<br />
that leads to our designs.”<br />
Those designs may be ambitious<br />
and innovative, but when times are<br />
tight, they can also lose out to lowercost,<br />
safer proposals. “There seems<br />
to be a trend towards risk-averse<br />
processes and cost overruns can<br />
happen more dramatically nowadays,”<br />
observes Kehne, although he notes<br />
that in China, Plasma has found this<br />
to be “slightly less the case as the<br />
country is redefining its identity and<br />
new ideas are often sought”.<br />
“We have worked with low budgets<br />
and produced boundary pushing<br />
projects,” adds Ghotmeh. “In the end,<br />
what is a safe design?”<br />
It’s worth noting that in 2010,<br />
the biggest architectural billing<br />
in the US was from a firm without<br />
the name cache of any polled here.<br />
Ae<strong>com</strong>’s $666 million architectural<br />
turnover was just a ninth of their<br />
total in<strong>com</strong>e as a global ‘technical<br />
and management services’ <strong>com</strong>pany.<br />
At the other end of the scale, an<br />
incredible number of firms are tiny.<br />
In 2009, no less than 79% of RIBAchartered<br />
UK practices employed 10<br />
people or less – and their clients may<br />
hardly stretch beyond the country, let<br />
alone the globe.<br />
Free thinking<br />
“We are at the heart of a what<br />
a capitalist mode of production<br />
1. London Bridge Quarter.<br />
2. Renzo Piano outside his workshop.<br />
produced, in terms of a homogeneous<br />
mental environment as well as<br />
architecture,” Ghotmeh muses. “Being<br />
big doesn’t necessarily mean you’re<br />
clever, and being small doesn’t mean<br />
you can’t deliver dreams.” Such an<br />
outlook clearly chimes with Piano.<br />
“You have to be free, and not worried<br />
about whether you will be recognised<br />
for the project. That’s something I’m<br />
very passionate about,” he insists.<br />
Roberts talks about Aedas’ “ability<br />
to offer an environment that fosters<br />
best design practice”, but if the top<br />
is focused on a corporate rather than<br />
creative agenda, size won’t help –<br />
1<br />
2<br />
just look at giant RMJM under Peter<br />
Morrison, still suffering an exodus of<br />
top talent (Tony Kettle in February),<br />
staff (most recently in the US) and<br />
clients (Seoul springs to mind).<br />
By contrast, Piano still feels the<br />
he understands what will make<br />
a practice tick, regardless of size.<br />
“My authority doesn’t <strong>com</strong>e from<br />
<strong>com</strong>manding because I am the<br />
patron, but from explaining with this,”<br />
he exclaims, holding his pen aloft.<br />
“RPBW is well ordered, but not a<br />
hierarchy; it’s a joyful machine.”<br />
And perhaps that’s the best any<br />
practice can hope for. ●<br />
© RPBW © Herbert Wright<br />
70<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Quiet spaces<br />
To absorb sound, improve acoustics and enhance the<br />
architecture, lomakka’s sound-absorbing structures for<br />
<strong>com</strong>mercial and residential solutions are ideal.<br />
Sound-absorbing structures<br />
and rugs are manufactured<br />
by lomakka through<br />
a process that employs a<br />
<strong>com</strong>bination of industrial<br />
and handicraft techniques.<br />
The fabrication procedure<br />
<strong>com</strong>bines the wool fibres’ unique<br />
properties with the raw character<br />
of the felt. They are the perfect<br />
solution for enhancing spaces<br />
that require a good acoustic<br />
standard while maintaining<br />
aesthetic cohesion.<br />
Since 2001, lomakka has been<br />
developing its Swedish wool fibre,<br />
which has a unique grey lustre,<br />
into 3D products. Over the years,<br />
the wool fibre has achieved<br />
a high degree of warmth and<br />
is adaptable to changes in<br />
demanding architecture.<br />
There is no doubt that textiles<br />
integrated with architecture<br />
can possess an importance that<br />
far exceeds their practical and<br />
aesthetical function. Dealing with<br />
the textile as a starting point<br />
makes it possible to reinforce the<br />
architectural structure of a space<br />
and fulfil its role of enhancing the<br />
general context. Using structures<br />
from lomakka is more about<br />
visually quietening the space<br />
than merely decorating it.<br />
“It is important to draw on the<br />
archaic qualities possessed by<br />
the wool felt and turn it into a<br />
challenging material that can be<br />
used in modern environments,”<br />
says Barbro Lomakka, following<br />
an assignment for the Swedish<br />
Embassy in Washington DC, where<br />
lomakka’s Krasis structure houses<br />
the architectonical qualities of the<br />
materials in the building.<br />
When placing textures in a<br />
designed room, the odds are<br />
often against you. By integrating<br />
them from the very beginning, it<br />
is possible to vastly improve the<br />
end result, both in economical and<br />
aesthetical terms. The structures<br />
are produced in Sweden and<br />
custom-made for clients. ●<br />
Further information<br />
lomakka<br />
www.lomakka.se<br />
lomakka’s Swedish wool fibre is<br />
distinctive and versatile.<br />
Front desk. Rugstructure Fond.<br />
Barbro Lomakka, Grasp studio<br />
Norra Kyrkogatan 3<br />
621 55 Visby Sweden<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong> 71<br />
Phone: +46 498 - 27 29 51
Insight > Technology<br />
Light<br />
show<br />
As prices drop and efficiency increases, ever more<br />
architects are incorporating cutting-edge lighting<br />
technologies into the very core of their projects. Abi Millar<br />
talks to partners from Information Based Architecture,<br />
Arup Lighting and Cinimod Design Studio to find out<br />
how architects and lighting designers are balancing new<br />
technical possibilities against a taste for restraint.<br />
© Zhou Ruogu Architecture Photography<br />
72<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Technology<br />
At 600m high, the Canton<br />
Tower in Guangzhou,<br />
China, was always going to<br />
dominate the skyline. One of the tallest<br />
buildings in the world, the shape is<br />
unmistakable – a hyperboloid structure<br />
far removed from the boxy linearity of<br />
most towers. With its curved, slender<br />
frame, cinched in the middle, it is<br />
locally known as the ‘supermodel’.<br />
Visit by day, however, and you’ll only<br />
feel half the impact. Once the sun sets,<br />
the exterior gleams with light, a vivid<br />
kaleidoscope of colour that streams<br />
from the whole surface. Sometimes<br />
pink, sometimes blue, often striped, the<br />
precise shades change frequently, as<br />
candy-bright as a fairground ride and<br />
visible for miles around.<br />
“We designed the tower as a beacon<br />
for the city; something that would give<br />
the people of Guangzhou something<br />
to be proud of, to aspire to,” says Mark<br />
Hemel, partner at Dutch architectural<br />
firm Information Based Architecture<br />
(IBA), which designed the building.<br />
“The lighting, of course, has an<br />
important role to play in that.”<br />
Technically aided by Arup<br />
Lighting, the structure is one of the<br />
most striking recent examples of<br />
architectural lighting in action. More<br />
than just an add-on, the lighting is<br />
incorporated into the very fabric of<br />
the building, with 7,000 light-emitting<br />
diodes (LEDs) illuminating the<br />
structure from within.<br />
“Since these LED models have been<br />
on the market, we have benefitted<br />
enormously from a new freedom in<br />
lighting design,” says Simone Collon,<br />
Europe lighting leader at Arup. “An<br />
LED can be seen as a single pixel<br />
module, so you can create matrixes<br />
and assemble these pixels in any<br />
shape you want. Light has be<strong>com</strong>e an<br />
architectural material.”<br />
During most of their history, LEDs<br />
were confined to laboratory equipment<br />
and household devices, their utility<br />
severely constrained by their price. In<br />
recent years, however, as the medium<br />
has grown cheaper and more efficient,<br />
architects have begun to tap a rich<br />
seam of potential applications.<br />
Fresh ideas<br />
Just ten years ago, when Collon<br />
started work at Arup, media façades<br />
were still something of a novelty.<br />
An early project of hers, the Galleria<br />
Fashion Store in Seoul was <strong>com</strong>monly<br />
cited as breaking new ground.<br />
“The building previously had a bare<br />
concrete façade, which we retrofitted,”<br />
she explains. “All of a sudden, there<br />
was a luminous surface glowing,<br />
radiating the character of the building<br />
1<br />
1. The slim Canton Tower is known locally as the ‘supermodel’.<br />
2. Abu Dhabi’s Sheikh Zayed Bridge is festively colour-coded.<br />
2<br />
to the people. Now it’s the talk of the<br />
town, popping up in tourist guides.”<br />
A trained architect, Collon went on<br />
to work on projects such as GreenPix<br />
(a zero-energy media façade in China’s<br />
Beijing); the Sheikh Zayek Bridge in<br />
Abu Dhabi (colour-coded to convey<br />
the spirit of local festivities); and the<br />
Star Place mall in Kaohsiung, Taiwan<br />
(frittered glass illuminated with the<br />
themes of the passing seasons).<br />
At present, she has two projects<br />
underway in the Yongsan development<br />
in Seoul. The first, a residential tower<br />
with a media feature, will move<br />
away from abstract light washes and<br />
towards pictorial content – carpets<br />
of cherry blossoms and Korean<br />
contemporary poetry in white script.<br />
Another tower, taller still than its<br />
Guangzhou forebear, will visualise<br />
nature through light. Powered by<br />
photovoltaic cells, it will not only<br />
reflect natural fluctuations, but use<br />
them for energy; its night-time<br />
luminosity depending on levels of sun<br />
that day. “Lighting is a very powerful<br />
tool,” enthuses Collon. “More and<br />
more clients and architects have<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e aware that if you hire an<br />
independent lighting designer, it can<br />
hugely increase the quality of space.”<br />
Viable options<br />
It’s a trend from which<br />
multidisciplinary practice Cinimod<br />
has benefitted. Combining art with<br />
architecture and product design, the<br />
firm has been able to gain a lateral<br />
view of the possibilities at every scale.<br />
“I’m a big believer that, in general,<br />
the architecture and the lighting<br />
professions don’t talk together<br />
soon enough on big projects,” says<br />
Cinimod founder Dominic Harris.<br />
“It’s something we’re actively trying<br />
to change. My preferred point of<br />
involvement is quite early on so we<br />
have a chance to achieve the most<br />
seamless and beautiful results.”<br />
© Christian Richters<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
73
Insight > Technology<br />
The entire surface of Cinimod’s Peru National Football Stadium is<br />
interactive, so the lights change according to the crowd’s mood.<br />
His practice is perhaps best known<br />
for its work on the Peru National<br />
Football Stadium, in which the entire<br />
façade became interactive. Aiming<br />
to reify the excitement of the crowd,<br />
the firm installed sensors to map the<br />
stadium’s noise levels. This information<br />
is fed into a <strong>com</strong>puter programme,<br />
which renders the prevailing mood in<br />
the form of a lighting display.<br />
In projects such as this, artistic<br />
and technical considerations are<br />
inextricable, with today’s crop of<br />
lighting designers breaking bounds<br />
on either count. “I think we quite<br />
routinely push the technology far<br />
and hard,” says Harris. “When we’re<br />
conceiving a project, we don’t just<br />
use what is already on the market.<br />
Instead we will challenge the big<br />
suppliers to make bespoke products,<br />
and sometimes make our own. I do not<br />
believe that concepts or art should be<br />
limited by technical constraints.”<br />
One technology in the pipeline is<br />
organic LEDs (OLEDs), a flat, waferthin<br />
layer that can be used to coat any<br />
material. Based not on pixels but on a<br />
single, flexible surface, these look set to<br />
attain <strong>com</strong>mercial viability within five<br />
years. Left-field applications such as<br />
glowing wallpaper would seem to be<br />
close at hand.<br />
Future proof<br />
The big question for the future, in fact,<br />
may not be so much what can as what<br />
ought to be achieved. With lighting<br />
applications growing ever more<br />
multifarious, designers will need to<br />
pay heed to their impact on the built<br />
environment. After all, the downside of<br />
omnipresent lighting façades is surely<br />
the potential for overkill: the tipping<br />
point between boldness and a clamour<br />
of visual noise.<br />
Take Hong Kong, in which building<br />
after brightly coloured building<br />
projects a Babel of light. Media<br />
façades blazon advertising messages,<br />
each surface <strong>com</strong>peting with the<br />
next to grab the spectator’s attention.<br />
For many visitors, the effect is sheer<br />
aesthetic cacophony.<br />
Elsewhere in the world, not least<br />
Europe, there is a clear trend towards<br />
sustainability and restraint. “I think<br />
that modern lighting designers<br />
working with colour-changing LEDs<br />
have a social responsibility to prevent<br />
our urban environment be<strong>com</strong>ing<br />
awash with non-stop colour-changing<br />
rainbow façades,” says Harris. “I spend<br />
a lot of time working with our clients<br />
to explore what else can be done with<br />
this wonderful technology.”<br />
Collon concurs. “There’s a tendency<br />
visible these days that less is more.<br />
Nowadays, we’re reducing colours and<br />
not having buildings change from pink<br />
to green to blue in one minute. That’s<br />
not something people want to see.”<br />
Of course, statements about visual<br />
preference fall under the banner of<br />
cultural contingency and Collon<br />
concedes that the Canton Tower<br />
was geared towards specifically<br />
Chinese tastes. Built to open in time<br />
for the 2010 Asian Games, the tower<br />
constituted a key <strong>com</strong>ponent of the<br />
host city’s regeneration, with the final<br />
say over its colour scheme falling to<br />
the authorities.<br />
“The city had a direct interest in<br />
interfering in what you see,” explains<br />
Hemel. “I see its current appearance<br />
more as a temporary statement that<br />
has been directly influenced by the<br />
local authorities than a statement of<br />
our design intentions.”<br />
IBA and Arup had intended to<br />
create something white and simple,<br />
luminous and contrastive.<br />
“We wanted to make the building<br />
resemble an afterimage,” expands<br />
Collon. “In the daytime, if you look at<br />
the tower and then close your eyes,<br />
you see a beautiful, glowing structure.<br />
This gave us the idea to integrate<br />
lighting fixtures into the design.”<br />
While their plan for the<br />
infrastructure did survive, the<br />
versatility of their chosen medium<br />
turned out to be their undoing.<br />
Crucially, because each of the LEDs<br />
is individually controllable, the diodes<br />
function as a blank canvas – you<br />
can project pearlescent subtlety or<br />
rainbow pageantry according to whim.<br />
Needless to say, once local<br />
designers had been drafted in, local<br />
preferences won out.<br />
Freedom of choice<br />
Hemel, surveying his somewhat<br />
<strong>com</strong>promised handiwork, sounds<br />
a note of caution. “LEDs have an<br />
enormous advantage in that you<br />
can do anything with them, but to me<br />
that highlights the difficulties at the<br />
same time,” he says. “It’s great that<br />
there are more possibilities, but you<br />
have to find the artistic freedom to<br />
decide what not to use.”<br />
As further technological obstacles<br />
are over<strong>com</strong>e, these words supply<br />
an important guiding principle.<br />
If the last decade in lighting has<br />
demonstrated anything, it is surely<br />
that LEDs have an extraordinary effect<br />
on their environment. Monument<br />
to frustrated potential or otherwise,<br />
the Canton Tower’s visual sway over<br />
Guangzhou is clear.<br />
“Light has an enormous impact on<br />
people,” says Collon, who envisages<br />
an almost limitless scope for future<br />
innovation. “It’s often underestimated<br />
how much it can change the<br />
atmosphere of a space.” ●<br />
74<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Exciting accents for<br />
demanding architecture<br />
Architecture with a high aesthetic claim has found the<br />
perfect partner in the elegant Gira electrical switch range.<br />
and glass – and sets exciting accents<br />
in <strong>com</strong>bination with natural materials<br />
such as wood and natural stone.<br />
Precise lines characterise the clear forms<br />
of the Gira Esprit switch range.<br />
Precise and clear lines<br />
characterise the simple yet<br />
independent forms used in<br />
the Gira Esprit switch range. Gira has<br />
now added a very high-quality version<br />
with shining black glass to the frame<br />
variants made of real materials.<br />
The frame’s dark shimmering glass<br />
corresponds perfectly with the<br />
architectural, linear design of the<br />
switch, and lends Gira Esprit its<br />
particularly elegant character. The<br />
high-gloss surface has a distinctive<br />
depth effect and provides an optical<br />
perfection that cannot be achieved<br />
with any other material or colour.<br />
Gira Esprit has an expressive presence<br />
that blends unobtrusively into its<br />
surroundings. The range is particularly<br />
well suited for use in architecture with<br />
a high aesthetic claim – for example<br />
with open masonry, exposed concrete<br />
The aluminium switch inserts<br />
and covers harmonise ideally with<br />
the black glass cover frame. Inserts<br />
and covers are available in anthracite,<br />
matt pure white and glossy pure white<br />
colour variants.<br />
More than 180 functions of the modern<br />
electrical installation can be <strong>com</strong>bined<br />
with the Gira Esprit cover frame,<br />
including the home stations of the Gira<br />
door <strong>com</strong>munication system. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Gira<br />
www.gira.<strong>com</strong><br />
Gira Esprit<br />
New frame variants<br />
Gira is expanding the material and colour diversity of the Esprit switch range. With the new aluminium black, aluminium brown and walnut-aluminium frame<br />
variants, the successful design concept is being pursued consistently: clear forms, carefully selected materials and perfect surfaces. The natural grained<br />
structure of the material remains visible in the frames made of anodised aluminium. The organic grain of walnut wood lends each frame its own individual<br />
character. More than 280 functions are available for Gira Esprit. For more information, see www.gira.<strong>com</strong>/esprit<br />
Ill. from left to right Aluminium black/anthracite, aluminium brown/cream white glossy, walnut-aluminium/colour aluminium<br />
14628_Anz_Esprit_Neuheiten_Kombi_220x106_EN.indd 1 29.11.11 12:41<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
75
Company insight<br />
OUTDOOR /STREET LIGHTS<br />
INDUSTRIAL LIGHTS<br />
LIFESTYLE LIGHTS<br />
RETROFITS<br />
ACCESSORIES<br />
INDOOR/OFFICE LIGHTS<br />
Visit<br />
Visit<br />
us<br />
us<br />
in<br />
in<br />
September<br />
April at the<br />
at the<br />
LED Professional<br />
Light+Building 2012<br />
Symposium & Expo in<br />
Bregenz,<br />
in Frankfurt.<br />
Austria.<br />
Hall<br />
Booth<br />
4.1 K10<br />
B2<br />
Get ready to<br />
see the light<br />
Operating in Germany and with a <strong>com</strong>prehensive European<br />
distribution network, Zenaro Lighting develops and<br />
markets <strong>com</strong>plete lifestyle, office, industrial and street<br />
LED luminaire units, as well as LED retrofits for the direct<br />
replacement of old bulbs and lamps.<br />
Zenaro’s cutting-edge<br />
lighting solutions are<br />
equipped with advanced<br />
LED technology from parent<br />
<strong>com</strong>pany Everlight Electronics.<br />
SOHO<br />
SETTING<br />
CREATIVE ACCENTS<br />
WITH EFFICIENCY.<br />
The SOHO LED downlight by Zenaro.<br />
Brilliant LED light <strong>com</strong>es in a brilliant design. With a mere power consumption<br />
of 30 W, the LED downlight SOHO sets creative accents in<br />
neutral white (5000 K) or warm white (3000 K) wherever efficiency in<br />
style is required. 100% glare-free and in a 60° beam angle, thanks to<br />
its <strong>com</strong>bined reflector technology. Easy and safe mounting: the coffer<br />
in classy white perfectly fits 215 mm cut-outs of ceiling elements with<br />
a 5 to 20 mm thickness. The 3-year warranty plus an extra-long life<br />
cycle of 25,000 hours minimize running and maintenance costs to the<br />
max. Ensuring top performance – even in the long run.<br />
For more about tomorrow’s light,<br />
visit today:<br />
www.zenarolighting.<strong>com</strong><br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany’s close relationship<br />
with this LED pioneer, which has<br />
decades of industry experience in<br />
LED technology and lighting, creates<br />
added value and enormous product<br />
development advantages.<br />
Zenaro creates imaginative and<br />
affordable lighting solutions for<br />
every key application area based<br />
on the latest LED technology, with<br />
its specific benefits and enhanced<br />
design possibilities. Sustainability is<br />
always factored in.<br />
The recessed LED ceiling luminaire<br />
SOHO <strong>com</strong>es with a clean, modern<br />
design that makes it particularly<br />
suitable for the discreet illumination<br />
of offices and prestigious premises.<br />
The circular ceiling lamp in a white<br />
housing is equipped with nine highpowered<br />
LEDs in neutral (5,000K) or<br />
warm white (3,000K) and has a beam<br />
angle of 60°. Three retaining springs<br />
allow safe mounting in ceilings.<br />
SOHO provides glare-free light<br />
thanks to a specially designed<br />
light control system. The external<br />
The SOHO circular ceiling light boasts nine high-powered LEDs.<br />
Zenaro’s new ultra-flat<br />
and dimmable AXENIA light.<br />
LED power supply unit, with plugand-play<br />
connection, is located next<br />
to the luminaire housing.<br />
Zenaro’s visually appealing<br />
SOHO light emits neither UV nor IR<br />
radiation, has a product life of 25,000<br />
hours and is available with a threeyear<br />
warranty. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Zenaro Lighting<br />
www.zenarolighting.<strong>com</strong>
Insight > Technology<br />
Laid-back<br />
lighting<br />
Using discreet lighting to<br />
strike a balance between<br />
style and sustainability is<br />
no easy task. Elly Earls<br />
meets Lighting Design<br />
International’s Ellie Greisen<br />
to find out how a concealed<br />
LED lighting scheme exceeds<br />
today’s stringent energyefficiency<br />
standards to create<br />
the desired client experience<br />
at Corinthia Hotel’s ESPA Life<br />
spa in London.<br />
Concealed linear LED lighting is energy-efficient and<br />
<strong>com</strong>plements the mirror-like surfaces of the ESPA Life spa rooms.<br />
Professional bodies are<br />
increasingly emphasising the<br />
importance of energy efficiency<br />
across the entire construction<br />
and design cycle; for example,<br />
the American Society of Interior<br />
Designers (ASID) recognises that<br />
sustainability should be an essential<br />
part of any interior designer’s<br />
professional responsibilities.<br />
ASID acknowledges that this<br />
extends to resource and energy<br />
efficiency, indoor environments that<br />
support occupant well-being and<br />
productivity, and integrated building<br />
design developed by collaborative<br />
multidisciplinary teams.<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
77
Insight > Technology<br />
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
1. Corinthia Hotel’s ESPA Life spa swimming pool.<br />
2. The ESPA Life spa lounge.<br />
3. Female changing rooms.<br />
4. ESPA Life spa reception.<br />
5. The luxurious EPSA Life spa sauna.<br />
Lighting designers play no small<br />
role in this picture and are increasingly<br />
being asked to deliver schemes that<br />
not only satisfy stringent energyefficiency<br />
criteria, but also continue<br />
to wow on the style front.<br />
The brief Lighting Design<br />
International (LDI) received from<br />
Corinthia Hotel’s ESPA Life spa was<br />
no different. The consultancy was<br />
asked to create a <strong>com</strong>plementary<br />
lighting scheme, which was energy<br />
efficient, while being respectful to<br />
the original features of the historical<br />
building in which it is located.<br />
The scheme was also required<br />
to <strong>com</strong>plement different moods<br />
on each of the four individually<br />
designed floors, while creating a<br />
holistic experience for the facility’s<br />
discerning clientele.<br />
“We had three different clients<br />
throughout this project: GA Design,<br />
the interior designers; ESPA, the spa<br />
managers; and Corinthia, the head<br />
client,” says Ellie Greisen, senior<br />
lighting designer at LDI. “They had<br />
strong ideas in terms of the lighting<br />
effects. Not only did they need to<br />
keep downlights to a minimum,<br />
they wanted each floor to have<br />
a <strong>com</strong>pletely different feel.”<br />
Discreet system<br />
For Greisen, the only option for the<br />
base scheme was concealed linear LED<br />
lighting, as this could satisfy the client’s<br />
sustainability criteria while creating a<br />
mood suitable for a luxury spa.<br />
Because the finishes in the spa<br />
were principally Kinon (a hand-cast<br />
resin with different effects), textured<br />
stone, marble and rich fabrics, the<br />
lighting needed to <strong>com</strong>plement<br />
these without taking away any<br />
attention from them.<br />
“Kinon is a highly reflective surface,<br />
which acts almost like a mirror, and it<br />
was a big challenge to work with this<br />
kind of finish,” says Greisen.<br />
“In some areas, we had limited<br />
amounts of space, which meant that<br />
every detail had to be carefully<br />
mocked up and tested. Linear LED is<br />
not a pretty thing to look at, so you<br />
have to conceal it. Making sure you<br />
couldn’t see any linear LEDs from<br />
any angle across the whole project<br />
was a big challenge.”<br />
Yet Greisen’s hard work paid off, and<br />
not only is it impossible to catch even a<br />
glimpse of the concealed LED lighting<br />
scheme, the use of hidden lights<br />
provided a big tick in the Corinthia<br />
Hotel’s energy-efficiency box.<br />
“Energy efficiency was really<br />
important and it was something that<br />
drove a lot of the design process,”<br />
Greisen explains. “We had a unique<br />
opportunity to use <strong>com</strong>pletely<br />
concealed lighting, which also means<br />
it’s mostly energy-efficient lighting.”<br />
Going underground<br />
Another key challenge for LDI was the<br />
client’s desire to bring four <strong>com</strong>pletely<br />
contrasting floors into harmony. Each<br />
floor is designed to have a different<br />
feel, with the finishes be<strong>com</strong>ing<br />
darker as you go further underground.<br />
While the lighting focuses on the<br />
finishes, highlighting the different<br />
moods of each floor, LDI also had to<br />
<strong>com</strong>e up with an overriding concept<br />
to bring the whole project together.<br />
The London-based consultancy<br />
opted to use the lighting of the spa’s<br />
marble staircase as the project’s<br />
joining feature, concealing lighting<br />
detail at the staircase’s sides, which,<br />
when taken with the reflective<br />
surfaces across the rest of the spa,<br />
gives the facility’s clients a sense of<br />
floating. Diffusers conceal the light<br />
source, softening the lighting effect.<br />
“It wasn’t as difficult as it sounds<br />
because the finishes helped a lot,”<br />
says Greisen. “The staircase is the<br />
central element that goes from the<br />
top floor entrance all the way down to<br />
the sub-basement. The only lighting<br />
detail on the stairs is the glow at the<br />
side, it’s a clever way of tying the<br />
whole lighting scheme together.”<br />
Although concealed lighting was<br />
the mainstay of the ESPA Life project,<br />
it was simply not viable to <strong>com</strong>pletely<br />
avoid the use of up and down-lighting.<br />
The spa features pieces of artwork,<br />
including sculptures, which serve as<br />
focal points for spa-users to move<br />
around the space. “To highlight these<br />
focus points, we used uplighting and<br />
downlighting,” explains Greisen. It<br />
gave them a bit more emphasis.”<br />
Moreover, the stainless steel<br />
swimming pool, which is housed in<br />
the spa’s sub-basement, required fibre<br />
-optic uplights, which illuminate the<br />
water onto the white ceiling. Uplights<br />
were also used on frosted glass fins,<br />
casting patterns on the ceiling.<br />
The use of downlights was kept to<br />
a minimum. “Where we have used<br />
downlights in the changing rooms,<br />
a lot of them are LED,” Greisen says.<br />
“We’ve only got a small number of<br />
low-voltage halogen downlights.”<br />
LDI’s focus on energy efficiency<br />
undoubtedly paid off. The total<br />
installed load of the project is<br />
20.6 W/m², while the Lighting<br />
Energy Numeric Indicator result<br />
of the scheme is 95, a figure that<br />
<strong>com</strong>pares favourably with the<br />
benchmark values set out in the<br />
European Standards for the energy<br />
performance of buildings.<br />
Just as these statistics testify to<br />
the energy efficiency of the project’s<br />
lighting scheme, the stylistic success<br />
LDI achieved with the ESPA Life spa<br />
is clear to see, demonstrating that<br />
style and sustainability can and do<br />
still go hand in hand. ●<br />
This article was first published on<br />
www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>.<br />
78<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Company insight<br />
Switch makes<br />
light work<br />
LED lighting specialist Switch Made is expanding<br />
its range of products to suit specific environments<br />
and offer a greater local presence.<br />
Switch Made’s showroom<br />
is located in Le Cube<br />
Orange, near Lyon.<br />
Your projects<br />
Our LED solutions !<br />
European first, the Mionnay Golf 100% LED lighted<br />
Products : FORTY II - LINE TECH II<br />
Switch Made offers a wide<br />
range of reliable and highquality<br />
LED products and<br />
support to its customers throughout<br />
the development of their projects.<br />
Switch Made is a start-up that was<br />
created four years ago in Lyon,<br />
France. Since then, it has grown<br />
considerably as a result of a strong<br />
investment strategy and significant<br />
capital resources. It has also rapidly<br />
developed its export department,<br />
thanks to the success of<br />
its subsidiaries and strong partnerships.<br />
With a cumulative turnover of<br />
€23 million, Switch Made’s objectives<br />
are to reach €40 million in 2012, to<br />
rapidly extend its country coverage,<br />
and to continue along the path to<br />
be<strong>com</strong>ing the major brand on the<br />
European lighting market.<br />
Key concepts<br />
Energy saving, performance, security<br />
and visual <strong>com</strong>fort are central to the<br />
needs of various market participants.<br />
Switch Made can meet these criteria<br />
by offering its customers:<br />
• innovative 100% LED products<br />
• <strong>com</strong>petitive price positioning<br />
• a large range of products<br />
covering the majority of<br />
lighting applications<br />
• product availability.<br />
The <strong>com</strong>pany’s strengths include:<br />
• a local presence with ideally<br />
located showrooms<br />
• experienced and dedicated teams<br />
(including R&D, logistics, sales<br />
and technical staff)<br />
• products adapted to specific<br />
environments (special requests)<br />
• quality products, meeting the latest<br />
European norms, all tested through<br />
a strict quality control process. ●<br />
Further information<br />
Switch Made<br />
www.switch-made.<strong>com</strong><br />
w w w . s w i t c h - m a d e . c o m
Innovations<br />
The innovations list<br />
Our favourite new products and<br />
innovations from the last few months.<br />
1 Developed by British designer<br />
Ross Lovegrove in partnership with<br />
Czech glass and crystal producer<br />
Lasvit, Liquidkristal is a highprecision<br />
heat transfer process<br />
that creates organic-looking glass<br />
panels. Allowing for variations in<br />
opacity and texture, the technology<br />
creates flowing glass installations for<br />
architectural spaces.<br />
www.rosslovegrove.<strong>com</strong><br />
1<br />
2 Designed by Japanese practice<br />
Torafu Architects, the Koloro-desk is<br />
a small, self-enclosed study space.<br />
The customisable desk includes<br />
lighting, a window, space for potted<br />
plants, books and hot drinks, and<br />
adjustable side and back hatches.<br />
www.torafu.<strong>com</strong><br />
3 London-based designer Philippe<br />
Malouin has expanded on his<br />
Gridlock furniture range with five<br />
new pieces: a bowl, desk, shelf and<br />
two lights. Based upon repetitive<br />
grid structures, the range pairs<br />
handmade brass lattices with<br />
concrete slabs in a nod towards a<br />
brutalist and industrial aesthetic.<br />
www.philippemalouin.<strong>com</strong><br />
4 Barcelona-based SF Kooperation<br />
shareholder Breinco has unveiled<br />
its new ELEMENTS street furniture<br />
range, which has been created to<br />
brighten up contemporary urban<br />
public spaces. Featuring seats,<br />
LED lamps and planter boxes, the<br />
refreshing new line was designed to<br />
appeal to a future-oriented customer<br />
base through innovative designs<br />
using eco-friendly materials, striking<br />
colours and excellent surface finishes.<br />
www.sf-kooperation.<strong>com</strong><br />
www.breincobluefuture.<strong>com</strong><br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
80<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Innovations<br />
5 The fruits of a collaboration<br />
between Zurich-based UrbanFarmers<br />
and Conceptual Devices, the Globe<br />
(Hedron) is a geodesic greenhouse<br />
designed to rest on top of flat roofs in<br />
urban areas. Framed with bamboo,<br />
the dome-shaped aquaponic<br />
greenhouse contains both fish and<br />
vegetables. The project has been put<br />
forward for this year’s Buckminster<br />
Fuller Challenge.<br />
www.conceptualdevices.<strong>com</strong><br />
6 British design studio Barber<br />
Osgerby won the International<br />
Design Award for the London 2012<br />
Olympic torch. Chosen from among<br />
89 entries, the winning torch is<br />
crafted from aluminium and is being<br />
carried more than 8,000 miles in total<br />
across the UK to London. It is also<br />
perforated with 8,000 holes that are<br />
more than merely decorative: they<br />
reduce the weight and prevent the<br />
heat of the flame being conducted<br />
into the bearer’s hand.<br />
www.barberosgerby.<strong>com</strong><br />
7 Possibly one of the world’s first<br />
tables to generate power through<br />
moss, the unique structure of<br />
the Moss Table incorporates<br />
biophotovoltaic technology, in<br />
which electrons produced during<br />
photosynthesis are converted<br />
into electricity. Designed by<br />
Biophotovoltaics, the table is still<br />
in its conceptual stages, but is<br />
already able to produce enough<br />
energy to support devices such<br />
as digital alarm clocks.<br />
www.biophotovoltaics.<br />
wordpress.<strong>com</strong><br />
8 French architect Jean Nouvel<br />
has showcased a new line of<br />
un<strong>com</strong>plicated laser-cut furniture<br />
at Milan Design Week 2012.<br />
The stackable, weather-resistant<br />
chairs are made from aluminium<br />
and <strong>com</strong>e in a range of colours<br />
including white, red and grey.<br />
Nouvel’s MIA collection, which<br />
includes elegantly designed<br />
armchairs, benches,<br />
stools and tables, was designed<br />
in collaboration with<br />
Italian manufacturer Emu.<br />
www.jeannouvel.<strong>com</strong><br />
9 90° MINUTO is the latest addition<br />
to the Teckell Collection, which<br />
puts a new twist on the game of<br />
table football. Designed by brothers<br />
Davide and Gabriele Adriano, it is<br />
<strong>com</strong>posed of a light wooden frame,<br />
which supports a crystal enclosure<br />
that is populated by abstractly<br />
carved footballers. Elegant and<br />
attractive, it is a novel take on a<br />
traditional game.<br />
www.adrianodesign.it<br />
5<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong><br />
81
Directory > Events diary and Suppliers guide<br />
Events diary<br />
Hands-On Urbanism, 1850–2012<br />
How urban architecture like Hong Kong’s has learned to adapt.<br />
The Greatest Grid:<br />
The Master Plan of<br />
Manhattan, 1811–2011<br />
Until 15 July<br />
Museum of the City of New<br />
York, US<br />
www.mcny.org<br />
Celebrating the 200th anniversary of<br />
the Commissioners’ Plan of 1811, the<br />
foundational document that established<br />
Manhattan’s famous street grid, this<br />
exhibition features an original hand-drawn<br />
map of New York’s planned streets and<br />
avenues prepared by the Commission in<br />
1811, as well as other rare historic maps,<br />
photographs and prints of the evolution of<br />
the city’s streets.<br />
Bauhaus twenty-21:<br />
An Ongoing Legacy<br />
8 June–22 September<br />
Yksi Expo, Eindhoven,<br />
Holland<br />
www.yksi.nl<br />
This acclaimed exhibition has been<br />
travelling widely throughout Europe<br />
since its opening at the German<br />
Architecture Museum in Frankfurt in 2009,<br />
<strong>com</strong>memorating the 90th anniversary of<br />
the founding of the Bauhaus School. It has<br />
been shown in eight venues and there are<br />
three more to <strong>com</strong>e, with the European tour<br />
scheduled to finish in 2013–14.<br />
© Shu-Mei Huang<br />
Until 25 June<br />
Architekturzentrum Wien,<br />
Vienna, Austria<br />
www.azw.at<br />
Looking at how the world’s towns and<br />
cities have adapted to modernisation, the<br />
exhibit takes a look at the lessons learned<br />
and the innovative thinking of architects<br />
that have changed the face of construction<br />
in an ever-developing urban environment.<br />
Consense 2012<br />
19–20 June<br />
Stuttgart, Germany<br />
www.dgnb.de<br />
This year Consense hosts the World Green<br />
Building Congress in which the World Green<br />
Building Council brings together experts<br />
across the built environment to drive forward<br />
sustainable and green building solutions.<br />
London Festival of<br />
Architecture<br />
23 June–8 July<br />
London, UK<br />
www.lfa2012.org<br />
Drawing on the London 2012 Olympic Games,<br />
this year’s event celebrates ‘The Playful City’.<br />
A midnight bike ride, London Velonotte 2012,<br />
highlights the changing face of architecture<br />
in East London, with guides including Peter<br />
Ackroyd, Ricky Burdett and David Adjaye.<br />
Stadia: Sport and<br />
Vision in Architecture<br />
6 July–22 September<br />
Sir John Soane’s Museum,<br />
London, UK<br />
www.soane.org<br />
May 2012 – October 2012<br />
With the London Olympic Games stealing<br />
the headlines in 2012, Stadia takes a look at<br />
the influence of sport on our architecture.<br />
The exhibition tracks the development of<br />
early athletic and sporting venues to modernday<br />
facilities, showcasing the deep ancient<br />
history of these events while celebrating the<br />
role of architecture in delivering them.<br />
ONE Lab: Future Cities<br />
9 July–3 August<br />
New York City, US<br />
www.onelab.org<br />
ONE Lab addresses the emerging discipline<br />
of global urbaneering by assembling a wide<br />
range of innovators from fields as diverse as,<br />
architecture, material science, urban design,<br />
biology, civil engineering and media art.<br />
Europe’s Best Buildings<br />
19 July–8 October<br />
Architekturzentrum Wien,<br />
Vienna, Austria<br />
www.azw.at<br />
Europe’s Best Buildings will attempt to<br />
engage young architects and showcase<br />
the very best in European construction.<br />
Celebrating and recognising architectural<br />
ac<strong>com</strong>plishments within the EU, prizes<br />
will be awarded to certain projects for the<br />
development of contemporary architecture.<br />
International Festival<br />
of Art & Construction<br />
2–11 August<br />
Villarino de los Aires,<br />
Salamanca, Spain<br />
www.ifac2012.<strong>com</strong><br />
Two hundred young people involved in art<br />
and architecture will live and build together<br />
in a creative space where ideas, work and<br />
experiences are shared as well as new links and<br />
contacts within the architectural <strong>com</strong>munity.<br />
LEAF International<br />
12–14 September<br />
Amsterdam, The Netherlands<br />
www.arena-international.<strong>com</strong>/leaf<br />
The Leading European Architects Forum<br />
brings together leading international<br />
practices and designers operating in Europe<br />
and beyond to share knowledge, to network<br />
and to develop new partnerships.<br />
Suppliers guide<br />
3M ...................................................................21<br />
www.3m.eu<br />
Artecta...........................................................12<br />
www.artecta.nl<br />
bocad .............................................................67<br />
www.bocad.<strong>com</strong><br />
Burlington Slate ..........................................50<br />
www.burlingtonstone.<strong>com</strong><br />
Cosentino ......................................................30<br />
www.silestone.<strong>com</strong><br />
Desso .............................................................49<br />
www.desso.<strong>com</strong><br />
EeStairs .........................................................15<br />
www.eestairs.<strong>com</strong><br />
Elsner Elektronik ........................................23<br />
www.elsner-elektronik.de<br />
GAIL Architektur Keramik .......................41<br />
www.gail.de<br />
Gira .................................................................75<br />
www.gira.<strong>com</strong><br />
Kebony...........................................................21<br />
www.kebony.<strong>com</strong><br />
KONE ................................... front cover, OBC<br />
www.kone.<strong>com</strong><br />
Kusch+Co ........................................................4<br />
www.kusch.<strong>com</strong><br />
lomakka ........................................................71<br />
www.lomakka.se<br />
Markilux ........................................................33<br />
www.markilux.<strong>com</strong><br />
MEINERTZ ....................................................53<br />
www.meinertz.<strong>com</strong><br />
Prinz Optics....................................................7<br />
www.variotrans-glass.<strong>com</strong><br />
Rodeca ...........................................................26<br />
www.rodeca.de<br />
Sefar ............................................................ IBC<br />
www.sefar.<strong>com</strong><br />
SENDA ...........................................................42<br />
www.senda.pt<br />
SF-Kooperation ............................................34<br />
www.sf-kooperation.<strong>com</strong><br />
Shaw Contract Group ................................29<br />
www.shawcontractgroup.<strong>com</strong><br />
Switch Made ................................................79<br />
www.switch-made.<strong>com</strong><br />
Taiyo Europe ................................................36<br />
www.taiyo-europe.<strong>com</strong><br />
Tecsom ..........................................................54<br />
www.tecsom.<strong>com</strong><br />
Textil Bau ......................................................65<br />
www.textilbau.de<br />
TRILUX ....................................................... IFC<br />
www.trilux.co.uk<br />
Vandersanden Group .................................35<br />
www.vandersandengroup.<strong>com</strong><br />
Visio-Technic ...............................................43<br />
www.visio-technic.<strong>com</strong><br />
Vogl Deckensysteme .................................61<br />
www.vogl-ceilingsystems.<strong>com</strong><br />
Wrightstyle ..................................................47<br />
www.wrightstyle.co.uk<br />
Zenaro Lighting ..........................................76<br />
www.zenarolighting.<strong>com</strong><br />
82<br />
THE LEAF REVIEW The Magazine for Leading European Architects | www.designbuild-network.<strong>com</strong>
Making<br />
the functional<br />
attractive<br />
Architecture<br />
Modular fabric ceilings<br />
for lighting and acoustics<br />
Sefar AG<br />
Architecture<br />
Hinterbissaustrasse 12<br />
9410 Heiden<br />
Switzerland<br />
Phone direct +41 (0)71 898 56 18<br />
Phone general +41 (0)71 898 56 17<br />
Fax +41 (0)71 898 58 71<br />
systems@sefararchitecture.<strong>com</strong><br />
www.sefar.<strong>com</strong>
17:45<br />
RESIDENTIAL BUILDING, MILAN<br />
Helping the Bilotta<br />
family reduce their<br />
building’s carbon<br />
footprint with every<br />
elevator ride<br />
KONE is constantly looking for new ways<br />
to improve the energy efficiency of its<br />
solutions. During 2010 we achieved our 50<br />
percent energy reduction target for volume<br />
elevators, an ambitious goal set in 2008.<br />
Our elevators have also been awarded<br />
A-class energy ratings.<br />
In 2010, KONE celebrated 100 years as a<br />
pioneer of innovation. In the future we will<br />
continue to lead the way in developing<br />
innovative and eco-efficient solutions that<br />
help people move smoothly in urban<br />
environments.<br />
kone.<strong>com</strong><br />
KONE elevators’ energy efficiency<br />
performance according to VDI 4707*<br />
A<br />
B<br />
C<br />
D<br />
E<br />
A<br />
KONE MonoSpace®<br />
KONE MiniSpace<br />
F<br />
G<br />
*Guideline issued by the Association of German Engineers