Vol. 16â1962 - NorthEastern Weed Science Society
Vol. 16â1962 - NorthEastern Weed Science Society Vol. 16â1962 - NorthEastern Weed Science Society
536 EXPERIMENTS ONTHECHOOCALCOIm'l)LOF CRABGRASS IN LAWNTURF Cla;yton M. Switzer * Considerable variability in the response of' crabgrass (Digitaria" sPP.) to herbicides has been f~n4 by JI1&ll71nv8StJ,~tors. This variabillt.T is influenced. by such factors as '.1011moisture, ~w btl'lll1,cI1tT,soil •. air temperature, soil fertility, tillle of treatment relative to stages of· growth, and to variety (or species) of this grass. Sinee it is impossible' for a home owner to control such factors to any great extent, it would cap,:; pear that the most acceptable crabgrass herbicides will be those that are effective over the widest range of conditions. . ' At present it appears that' in general. the p;:-e-emergence crabgr&s. killers are most effective. While the use of this type' of herbicide fi:ts,'in . well with the operations of professional gardeners and golf-oourse superintendents, it has oot been widely ac~epted by the aV'J"llIe homeowner, probably because of' the tendency of t'he~layman not to.w+.rtY about weeds, i~ects or diseases until they beeane apparent .to. him. Therefore, investigati~s:on the cClltrol of crabgrass in turf· should continue to include chemicals capable of killing this weed after elllersence, as well.4f the pre-emergence materials. An ideal herbicide woul'l1eeemto be one wtth both pre- and poisi;-;, 8IIlergence activity, and having sufficient residual effect'to make yearly application unnecessary. . This paper reports on the results of experSlilentsusing pre- ~ pos1;.;eJllergence chemicals, and on the residual effectiveness of ,SOlll8 of these chemicals on crabgrass. I§1'HODS All experimental work was ~ed out on tIMumpus of the Ontario Agricultural College. The turf gra'''s were mainly'lentuoky and Cenadablue with SOIlle oreeping red fescue .end ereepingbent gruil. Plots were 100 sq.' ft. in area and in most experiments. treatments were replicated 4 times in a randomized block design. The areas seleoted were OOTeredwith sparse tUrf' and had bean infested with a hea'V)' orabgrass population the 'year previotj,s ~ treatment. Sprays were applied (100 gal/A) with a knapsack sprayer and granulars were distributed by meanaof a small fe~1.z.r spreader. * Associate Professor, DepartmerJt.of Botany, Ontario~rioultural Colle$e, Guelph, Canada. 1/:
RESULTS Pre-emergence treatment: The efrEf~ts of chemicals applied Apr!l 27 - May 1, 1961are presen~ed in Table 1. Rainfallon the plot area between April 29 arid May 3 was 0,78 in. First crabgrass emergence was noted in the control plots on May 15th. -, . S37 Excellent control of crabgrass with no injury to other grasses was given by all rates of zytron (-bt:rt1fliquid and granular formulations), dacthal (wettable powder and granular), diphenatrile (diphenylacetonitrile) and dipropalin. Diphenylacetonitrile (Agrico formulation) gave good control (over 90%.1 at the lower rates and excellent controla'e--the highe st rate. Calcium propyl arsonate was good at 60 Ib/A but not satisfactory at lower rates. This chemical had a strong inhibitory effect on clover. . Pax (36.5% metallic arsenic) and Chip Cal (50% tricalcium arsenate) gave good control at the highest rates but were poor at lower rates..T:r.:H'luralin causedmarked burning of all plants in the plots and, therefore, was not satisfactory even though it gave 100% control of crabgrass. Similar results were 0 btained in 1960 -d.n an experiment; in which zytron (liquid and granular), dacthal (granular) and calcium arsenate were tested, Residual effects: .The 1960 plo;ts WEl!'eunintnine.d and observations-on-the:residual effects were made periodically dUring the summer of 1961. Some crabgrass was found in all the ; plots, but those treated with all rates of zytron (a, 16, 24 Ib/A both liquid and granular) and those treated with tricalcium arsenate at 15 Ib/1000 sq. ft. or with dacthal granular at 15 Ib/A, had considerably less than the others. Control with both 16 and 24 Ib/A of zyYron exceeded 90% throughout the s\.Ulllller. The g Ib rate gave fair control (50-70%) as the granular formulation, but liquid zytron at a Ib/A did not have as much residual effect. In another experiment, set up to stnrdy the effectiveness of application of pre-emergence crabgrass herbicides in the fall, plots were treated on Nov. 14, 1960 with zytron, liquid and granular (10,20,30), dacthal, wettable powder and granular (10~15, 20), and tricalcium arsenate.(5-,7!,10,15).Rates of zytron and dacthal are Ib active/A, and of tricalcium arsenate are Ib active/ 1000 sq. ft. Only the plots receiving the low rate of dacthal' granular and the lowest two rates of tricalcium arsenate weren()t completely free of crabgrass on July 21, 1961'" 'However, by August 31, crabgrass was noted in all plots except.~hose receiving 20 or 30 Lb of zytron or 20 Ib of d/icthal, al.t.hough, plo t s treated with ~tron 10, dacthal 15, or tricalcium arsenate 15, contained on~y a few crabgrass plants. On11 the: highest rate ~f zytron caused any turf dffinage (some thinning) and even these piots recovered by early Jurie , A m::l,...l.ra~ ~+-.;"""" ,.......:...._ ~~ L'_ -
- Page 486 and 487: Lima and ferd'1izer applications sh
- Page 488 and 489: 4es 1'.o~~1ty, ", .ewf!r''''rsenc.
- Page 490 and 491: } ) Table 1. Besu):ta.Qf 1961 pre-e
- Page 492 and 493: 492 corresponding plots on este.bl1
- Page 494 and 495: 494 ae.u!s,'I!IIDi,cua.:Lon leUllll
- Page 496 and 497: 496 D±!3pa,~n~ Resul te)I? .,l-ta,
- Page 498 and 499: 498 1 . 1 J. E. Gallagher and n. J.
- Page 500 and 501: 500 Da1;ejJ01 e~uations ~,a.;t'ollC
- Page 502 and 503: 502 TADLEIt Comparison of "severalc
- Page 504 and 505: 504 TADLE3: Pre-oemergence and poet
- Page 506 and 507: 506 Table 1. Re8eeding Resulte:afit
- Page 508 and 509: 5"8 d1propalin ortrifluralin 'at ':
- Page 510 and 511: 510 aUlIPIl iri '-1: ' D" "" Diphen
- Page 512 and 513: Fall ve. spriif ~nts .. 'Ibe",obl1.
- Page 514 and 515: 514 ~ Tab1e2. Cr&bgraS$'Contr01 in
- Page 516 and 517: 516 ,';1:".i'"'f'!r": :~,j i: .. r
- Page 518 and 519: . ~lS residual cemtrol of crabgrssi
- Page 520 and 521: 520 - . \.. ; ."," ,
- Page 522 and 523: 5~2 'rab4t13.· ~gtnc. ·QGabtiol:o
- Page 524 and 525: 524 PRE.._RGENCE AMU' POsT-EHERGENC
- Page 526 and 527: 526 Table 1. 'l'a):lsra,. ContrO.k1
- Page 528 and 529: 528 Pre- andpost ..emergejljCec:rab
- Page 530 and 531: 530 Prior to each chemical applicat
- Page 532 and 533: u 532 3) Those trea.t,mellts which
- Page 534 and 535: Table I (Coot'd) 27. JSc.F,~iOe t$~
- Page 538 and 539: ~______ , 53S Table 1: Control of c
- Page 540 and 541: 54' In a similar po st-ell1~rgence
- Page 542: 542 da~hal and diphenatrile) at ear
- Page 545 and 546: .. ";' -:' il; JT!.: .'\ i~'J" ; ~J
- Page 547 and 548: 541 Distr:tbution of radioacti~tl t
- Page 549 and 550: 549 •RESULTS The distribution of
- Page 551 and 552: GRAPHII: Comparison of the~.tl;'i~u
- Page 553: "-...-.. J.4 The distribution of r~
RESULTS<br />
Pre-emergence treatment: The efrEf~ts of chemicals<br />
applied Apr!l 27 - May 1, 1961are presen~ed in Table 1. Rainfallon<br />
the plot area between April 29 arid May 3 was 0,78 in.<br />
First crabgrass emergence was noted in the control plots on<br />
May 15th. -, .<br />
S37<br />
Excellent control of crabgrass with no injury to other<br />
grasses was given by all rates of zytron (-bt:rt1fliquid and<br />
granular formulations), dacthal (wettable powder and granular),<br />
diphenatrile (diphenylacetonitrile) and dipropalin. Diphenylacetonitrile<br />
(Agrico formulation) gave good control (over 90%.1<br />
at the lower rates and excellent controla'e--the highe st rate.<br />
Calcium propyl arsonate was good at 60 Ib/A but not satisfactory<br />
at lower rates. This chemical had a strong inhibitory effect on<br />
clover.<br />
. Pax (36.5% metallic arsenic) and Chip Cal (50%<br />
tricalcium arsenate) gave good control at the highest rates but<br />
were poor at lower rates..T:r.:H'luralin causedmarked burning of<br />
all plants in the plots and, therefore, was not satisfactory<br />
even though it gave 100% control of crabgrass.<br />
Similar results were 0 btained in 1960 -d.n an experiment;<br />
in which zytron (liquid and granular), dacthal (granular) and<br />
calcium arsenate were tested,<br />
Residual effects: .The 1960 plo;ts WEl!'eunintnine.d and<br />
observations-on-the:residual effects were made periodically dUring<br />
the summer of 1961. Some crabgrass was found in all the ;<br />
plots, but those treated with all rates of zytron (a, 16, 24 Ib/A<br />
both liquid and granular) and those treated with tricalcium<br />
arsenate at 15 Ib/1000 sq. ft. or with dacthal granular at<br />
15 Ib/A, had considerably less than the others. Control with<br />
both 16 and 24 Ib/A of zyYron exceeded 90% throughout the s\.Ulllller.<br />
The g Ib rate gave fair control (50-70%) as the granular formulation,<br />
but liquid zytron at a Ib/A did not have as much residual<br />
effect.<br />
In another experiment, set up to stnrdy the effectiveness<br />
of application of pre-emergence crabgrass herbicides in the fall,<br />
plots were treated on Nov. 14, 1960 with zytron, liquid and<br />
granular (10,20,30), dacthal, wettable powder and granular (10~15,<br />
20), and tricalcium arsenate.(5-,7!,10,15).Rates of zytron and<br />
dacthal are Ib active/A, and of tricalcium arsenate are Ib active/<br />
1000 sq. ft. Only the plots receiving the low rate of dacthal'<br />
granular and the lowest two rates of tricalcium arsenate weren()t<br />
completely free of crabgrass on July 21, 1961'" 'However, by August<br />
31, crabgrass was noted in all plots except.~hose receiving 20 or<br />
30 Lb of zytron or 20 Ib of d/icthal, al.t.hough, plo t s treated with<br />
~tron 10, dacthal 15, or tricalcium arsenate 15, contained on~y a<br />
few crabgrass plants. On11 the: highest rate ~f zytron caused any<br />
turf dffinage (some thinning) and even these piots recovered by early<br />
Jurie , A m::l,...l.ra~ ~+-.;"""" ,.......:...._ ~~ L'_ -