The Social Cancer, by José Rizal - Home

CHAPTER XXXIII 160
For a long time after Elias had become silent Ibarra remained thoughtful, not answering him or saying a word.
"I'm sorry that that man is dead!" he exclaimed at length. "From him something more might have been
learned."
"If he had lived, he would have escaped from the trembling hand of blind human justice. God has judged him,
God has killed him, let God be the only Judge!"
Crisostomo gazed for a moment at the man, who, while he spoke thus, exposed his muscular arms covered
with lumps and bruises. "Do you also believe in the miracle?" he asked with a smile. "You know what a
miracle the people are talking about."
"Were I to believe in miracles, I should not believe in God. I should believe in a deified man, I should believe
that man had really created a god in his own image and likeness," the mysterious pilot answered solemnly.
"But I believe in Him, I have felt His hand more than once. When the whole apparatus was falling down and
threatening destruction to all who happened to be near it, I, I myself, caught the criminal, I placed myself at
his side. He was struck and I am safe and sound."
"You! So it was you--"
"Yes! I caught him when he tried to escape, once his deadly work had begun. I saw his crime, and I say this to
you: let God be the sole judge among men, let Him be the only one to have the right over life, let no man ever
think to take His place!"
"But you in this instance--"
"No!" interrupted Elias, guessing the objection. "It's not the same. When a man condemns others to death or
destroys their future forever he does it with impunity and uses the strength of others to execute his judgments,
which after all may be mistaken or erroneous. But I, in exposing the criminal to the same peril that he had
prepared for others, incurred the same risk as he did. I did not kill him, but let the hand of God smite him."
"Then you don't believe in accidents?"
"Believing in accidents is like believing in miracles; both presuppose that God does not know the future. What
is an accident? An event that no one has at all foreseen. What is a miracle? A contradiction, an overturning of
natural laws. Lack of foresight and contradiction in the Intelligence that rules the machinery of the world
indicate two great defects."
"Who are you?" Ibarra again asked with some awe.
"Have you ever studied?"
"I have had to believe greatly in God, because I have lost faith in men," answered the pilot, avoiding the
question.
Ibarra thought he understood this hunted youth; he rejected human justice, he refused to recognize the right of
man to judge his fellows, he protested against force and the superiority of some classes over others.
"But nevertheless you must admit the necessity of human justice, however imperfect it may be," he answered.
"God, in spite of the many ministers He may have on earth, cannot, or rather does not, pronounce His
judgments clearly to settle the million conflicts that our passions excite. It is proper, it is necessary, it is just,
that man sometimes judge his fellows."