16.11.2012 Views

The Boeing 737/757 Lean Story

The Boeing 737/757 Lean Story

The Boeing 737/757 Lean Story

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

1<br />

2<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> <strong>737</strong>/<strong>757</strong> <strong>Lean</strong> <strong>Story</strong><br />

<strong>737</strong>-800<br />

Dan Becker<br />

Vice President - Manufacturing and Quality<br />

<strong>Boeing</strong> Commercial Airplanes<br />

April 2, 2003<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> <strong>737</strong>/<strong>757</strong> <strong>Lean</strong> <strong>Story</strong><br />

Similarities between….<br />

Pilot<br />

USNS SHUGART (TAKR 295)<br />

Bulkheads<br />

Rigid barrier<br />

Keel Beam<br />

Rudder<br />

Doors<br />

Engines<br />

APU<br />

Interiors<br />

Floors<br />

Skin panels<br />

Crew accommodations<br />

Galley<br />

Cargo<br />

Fire protection, Loading<br />

Systems<br />

communication, emergency, lighting, potable water<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company


3<br />

4<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> <strong>737</strong>/<strong>757</strong> <strong>Lean</strong> <strong>Story</strong><br />

Our Ship we used to build…..<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Toyota Describes TPS With This<br />

Balanced House<br />

Just<br />

In<br />

Time<br />

• Lowest Cost<br />

• Highest Quality<br />

• Shortest Time<br />

Stability<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Autonomation<br />

&<br />

Jidoka


5<br />

6<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

BOEING PRODUCTION SYSTEM ACADEMY<br />

a.k.a. <strong>Lean</strong> Academy<br />

• OBJECTIVES: Create a cohesive, uniformly trained team centered on on<br />

an identified<br />

Value Stream based on:<br />

• o A common understanding of <strong>Lean</strong> principles<br />

• o Integrating <strong>Lean</strong> strategies into a system easily understood at every level.<br />

• o One plan for improvement<br />

• o Top management involvement<br />

• DIFFERENCE: <strong>The</strong> Academy:<br />

• § Integrates a Value Stream TEAM in BPS training and implementation<br />

implementation<br />

• § Includes Managers<br />

• § Uses powerful simulations<br />

• § Uses graduates (and ONLY graduates) as instructors and facilitators facilitators<br />

• § Gives you an implementation plan for your Value Stream Future State<br />

• § Promotes and enables linkage of <strong>Lean</strong> activities<br />

• § Culminates in a Value Stream Mapping exercise that will point to where and to<br />

what kind of <strong>Lean</strong> activity to conduct.<br />

• Excess inventory<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

<strong>737</strong>/<strong>757</strong> Traditional Factory<br />

1965-2001 1965 2001<br />

• Time loss during airplane line moves<br />

• Production and support groups work<br />

to different schedules and different<br />

priorities<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

• Tools, parts and drawings not readily<br />

available to mechanics<br />

• Production status of factory not visible<br />

• Flow time not correlated to customer<br />

demand


7<br />

8<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

9-Step Step Plan<br />

�� Value stream mapping and analysis<br />

�� Balance the line<br />

�� Standardize work<br />

�� Put visuals in place<br />

�� Point of use staging<br />

�� Establish feeder/supply chain lines<br />

�� Break-through Break through process re-design re design along main line<br />

�� Convert line to a pulse line<br />

�� Convert to moving line (continuously flowing or one piece<br />

flow line)<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 1 — Value Stream Mapping<br />

Before <strong>Lean</strong> Implementation<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company


9<br />

10<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

Step 1 — Value Stream Mapping<br />

After <strong>Lean</strong> Implementation<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 2 — Balancing the Line<br />

Distributing the Work Evenly<br />

By POSITION by DAY by SHIFT<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company


11<br />

12<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

Step 3 — Standardize Work<br />

<strong>The</strong> fastest way to perform the task at the lowest cost with<br />

the highest quality every time the task is performed<br />

• Support cell next to airplane<br />

• Andon board visible from floor<br />

and from support cell<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 4 — Put Visuals in Place<br />

<strong>737</strong>-<strong>757</strong> <strong>737</strong> <strong>757</strong> Cross Functional Support Teams – Andon System<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

• Andon visual notification<br />

• Audibly – Floor to Support Cell<br />

• Automatic Support Cell paging<br />

when line stops


Color<br />

Coding<br />

Kit<br />

Queues<br />

13<br />

14<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

Step 4 — Put Visuals in Place<br />

Pitch Marks/Color Coding/Kit Queues<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 5 — Point of Use Staging<br />

<strong>737</strong>-<strong>757</strong> <strong>737</strong> <strong>757</strong> Parts Control Areas (PCAs)<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Pitch<br />

Marks<br />

• Kits are<br />

replenished in<br />

PCA/Tooling<br />

work cells,<br />

located next to<br />

the airplane they<br />

support


15<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

Step 5 — Point of Use Staging<br />

<strong>737</strong>-<strong>757</strong> <strong>737</strong> <strong>757</strong> Job Kitting<br />

• All materials needed to complete<br />

the job<br />

16<br />

• Parts<br />

• Tools<br />

• FOD<br />

• Hazardous material<br />

• Consumables<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 6 — Establish Feeder Lines<br />

Before: 16 hours on airplane<br />

• Over 900<br />

parts<br />

<strong>737</strong>-<strong>757</strong> <strong>737</strong> <strong>757</strong> Fuel Tubes<br />

• Ergonomic<br />

• Quality<br />

problem area<br />

issues<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

After: After


17<br />

18<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

Step 7 — Break-Through Break Through Process<br />

Re-Design Re Design Along Main Line — <strong>737</strong>/<strong>757</strong> Service-Ready Service Ready Wings<br />

Eliminated 2 days of flow<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 7 — Break-Through Break Through Process<br />

Re-Design Re Design Along Main Line — <strong>737</strong> Service-Ready Service Ready Wings<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

• In Wing Assembly…<br />

• Trailing edge outboard<br />

flaps installed and<br />

rigged<br />

• Leading edge slats and<br />

slat panels installed and<br />

rigged<br />

• In Final Assembly…<br />

• 160 fewer labor hours<br />

• 100 fewer parts and<br />

assemblies installed<br />

• Tooling and access<br />

stands reduction


19<br />

20<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

Step 7 — Break-Through Break Through Process<br />

Re-Design Re Design Along Main Line—<strong>757</strong> Line <strong>757</strong> Transporter<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 7 — Break-Through Break Through Process<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Transporter<br />

Re-Design Re Design Along Main Line — <strong>737</strong>-<strong>757</strong> <strong>737</strong> <strong>757</strong> ”Hay Elevator” Seat Loader


21<br />

22<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

Step 8 — Convert Line to a Pulse Line<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Step 9 — Convert Line to a Moving Line<br />

<strong>737</strong> Final Assembly <strong>757</strong> Final Assembly<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company


23<br />

24<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>737</strong>-<strong>757</strong> <strong>737</strong> <strong>757</strong> Final Assembly <strong>Lean</strong><br />

Production System<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Supplier <strong>Lean</strong> Efforts<br />

• Wichita Division<br />

• Fabrication Division<br />

• Propulsion System Division<br />

• Value stream mapping and analysis<br />

• Aircraft Systems & Interiors<br />

• Yokohama Rubber Company<br />

• Turkish Aerospace Industries<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company


25<br />

26<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>Lean</strong> Global Enterprise<br />

Wichita Division <strong>Lean</strong> Improvements<br />

<strong>737</strong> Monolithic Bulkhead Structure<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

<strong>Lean</strong> Global Enterprise<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

• Weight - 7% Reduction<br />

• Cost - 9% Reduction<br />

• Parts - 49% Reduction<br />

• Simpler Installation<br />

Wichita Division <strong>Lean</strong> Improvements<br />

<strong>757</strong> Section 43, 44 & 46 Floor Beam Assembly Work Transfer to Wichita<br />

• Utilization of existing universal holding fixture eliminate 3 floor gantry’s, assembly jigs, &<br />

numerous drill tools<br />

• Utilization of NEOS Robot eliminates the need for current “applied type” tooling used in<br />

Renton - Eliminates Auburn Machine Shop routing - Drills all TBS 1, 2 & 3 extruded beams<br />

• Utilization of existing production lines eliminates approx. 4300 sq ft of manufacturing<br />

space<br />

Universal Holding Fixture NEOS Robot Production Flow Lines


27<br />

<strong>737</strong> MAIN LANDING GEAR<br />

SUPPORT<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>Lean</strong> Global Enterprise<br />

Fabrication Division <strong>Lean</strong> Improvements<br />

Goals: Substantially reduce product<br />

flow days / cycle time, work in<br />

process, and unit cost<br />

Methods: Develop <strong>Lean</strong> Manufacturing<br />

cell utilizing “right sized” equipment,<br />

point of use tooling and Just-In-Time<br />

component stores<br />

28<br />

Results:<br />

120%<br />

100%<br />

80%<br />

60%<br />

40%<br />

20%<br />

0%<br />

30<br />

10<br />

0%<br />

Percent Cost<br />

100%<br />

52%<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

25%<br />

1996 Current Target<br />

Before Current Target<br />

Product Moves<br />

21<br />

12,200 ft<br />

12,000<br />

1996 Current Target<br />

Before<br />

4<br />

6000<br />

0<br />

People Travel<br />

4<br />

2,500 ft<br />

Before 1996 Current Target<br />

<strong>Lean</strong> Global Enterprise<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

6000<br />

3000<br />

0<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

0<br />

2000 ft<br />

Product Travel<br />

5,300 ft<br />

Flow Days<br />

75<br />

1,000 ft<br />

Before 1996 Current Target<br />

18<br />

800 ft<br />

10<br />

1996 Current Target<br />

Before Current Target<br />

Propulsion Systems Division <strong>Lean</strong> Improvements<br />

Before<br />

After Before<br />

<strong>737</strong> Engine Build Up Flow Reduction<br />

• Unit Time flow reduction from 3 days to 1 day<br />

- 66% inventory reduction per shipset<br />

- Current cycle time is 4.5 hours per engine<br />

3 Flow Days<br />

After<br />

1 Flow Day<br />

66% Inventory Reduction


29<br />

30<br />

4 Assembly<br />

Workstations<br />

Move to Takt<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>Lean</strong> Global Enterprise<br />

Aircraft Systems & Interiors <strong>Lean</strong> Improvements<br />

Parts are replenished<br />

from front of operator<br />

Two bin system in place<br />

to fill standards<br />

Support response<br />

system in place<br />

<strong>737</strong> / <strong>757</strong> Stowage Bin Moving Flow Line<br />

Established in 2001 - Implemented a moving flow<br />

line to produce stowage bins Just-In-Time with<br />

reduced hrs/part, floor space, and inventory<br />

Hrs/Part:<br />

Assembly Stations:<br />

Floor Space:<br />

Work In Process:<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Benefits / Reductions<br />

23% (6.9 to 5.3)<br />

20% (5 to 4)<br />

1500 Sq. Feet<br />

66% (12 Bins to 4 Bins)<br />

• Increased predictability of output and adherence to<br />

takt time<br />

• Elimination of ergonomic issues associated with<br />

manual bin transfer<br />

• All Line stoppages are logged and if possible fixed<br />

immediately<br />

<strong>Lean</strong> Global Enterprise<br />

Supplier Management & Procurement <strong>Lean</strong> Improvements<br />

Yokohama Rubber Company<br />

Before<br />

After<br />

<strong>757</strong> Program Objectives<br />

• Reduce manufacturing lead time by 40%<br />

• Implement moving line<br />

Results<br />

<strong>757</strong> Program<br />

• Lead time reduction of 40% +<br />

• New light weight assembly fixture<br />

• Standard operations/moving line<br />

Yokohama Rubber Company<br />

• Cycle time reduction of 60%<br />

• Work in Process reduction of 50%<br />

• New light weight assembly fixture<br />

• Standard operations/moving line<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company


31<br />

32<br />

L RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>Lean</strong> Global Enterprise<br />

Supplier Management & Procurement <strong>Lean</strong> Improvements<br />

Turkish Aerospace Industries<br />

Before<br />

After<br />

<strong>737</strong> Program Objectives<br />

• Increase Volume of Flight Deck Panels by 50%<br />

— Assure 100% On Time Delivery<br />

— Assure 100% Quality Acceptance<br />

Results<br />

<strong>737</strong> Program<br />

• Volume increase achieved<br />

• Achieved On Time Delivery of 99.5%<br />

• Achieved Quality Acceptance of 99.0%<br />

Turkish Aerospace Industries<br />

• Cycle time reduction of 49%<br />

• Point of Use Kitting Sub components<br />

• Standard operations established<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company<br />

Renton Factory Gains Illustration<br />

WIP At 21 <strong>737</strong> airplanes per month<br />

Before…29 airplanes After…14 airplanes<br />

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Copyright 2003,<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Boeing</strong> Company

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!