13.05.2015 Views

OHIO STATE DENTAL BOARD BOARD MEETING - the Ohio State ...

OHIO STATE DENTAL BOARD BOARD MEETING - the Ohio State ...

OHIO STATE DENTAL BOARD BOARD MEETING - the Ohio State ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong><br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008<br />

ATTENDANCE ...................................................................................................... 1<br />

CALL TO ORDER .................................................................................................. 1<br />

INTRODUCTION OF <strong>BOARD</strong> MEMBERS ........................................................... 2<br />

EXECUTIVE SESSION........................................................................................... 2<br />

OPEN SESSION.............................................................................................................. 3<br />

REVIEW OF THE SEPTEMBER <strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES ........................... 3<br />

ENFORCEMENT REPORT .................................................................................... 3<br />

PERSONAL APPEARANCE(S) ...................................................................................... 3<br />

SAMUEL S. KALUDY, D.D.S........................................................................................................ 3<br />

REVIEW OF CASES WHEREIN NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY WERE ISSUED<br />

AND NO HEARING WAS REQUESTED .......................................................................... 4<br />

DENTISTS .................................................................................................................................. 5<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS.................................................................................................................. 5<br />

EXECUTIVE SESSION............................................................................................................................... 6<br />

OPEN SESSION........................................................................................................................................ 6<br />

DECISION IN THE MATTER OF AUTOMATICALLY SUSPENDED DENTISTS AND <strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS<br />

FOR NON-RENEWAL OF LICENSURE ................................................................................................... 7<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED MOTIONS......................................................................... 10<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY SURRENDER(S)...................................... 11<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY RETIREMENT(S) .................................... 11<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED CONSENT AGREEMENT(S) .......................................... 12<br />

DISCIPLINARY.......................................................................................................................... 12<br />

JEFFREY J. BECKER, D.D.S............................................................................................................... 12<br />

ROBERT E. BURNS, D.D.S............................................................................................................... 12<br />

HECTOR A. CABALLERO, D.D.S. .................................................................................................... 12<br />

WILLIAM H. CARDWELL, JR., D.D.S............................................................................................. 13<br />

MARK DEVINCENZO, D.D.S. ......................................................................................................... 13<br />

STACEY M. HARRIS, R.D.H. ........................................................................................................... 13<br />

BERNARD J. JOHNSON, D.D.S. ....................................................................................................... 13<br />

RICHARD LAPP, D.D.S. ........................................................................................................................13<br />

LINCOLN W. LAWRENCE, D.D.S......................................................................................................... 14<br />

TRACEY PATRIARCA, R.D.H................................................................................................................. 14<br />

GARY L. WARREN, D.D.S. .............................................................................................................. 14<br />

NON-DISCIPLINARY ................................................................................................................. 14<br />

RAJESH GUTTA, D.D.S.........................................................................................................................14<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY .................................... 14<br />

CHARLES L. DIPASQUALE, D.D.S......................................................................................................... 15<br />

BRENDA L. WILCOX, R.D.H. ............................................................................................................... 15<br />

MALCOLM WALTERS, JR., D.D.S.......................................................................................................... 15<br />

ENFORCEMENT UPDATE ......................................................................................... 15<br />

REVIEW OF LICENSE APPLICATIONS.............................................................. 17


LICENSURE REPORT.................................................................................................. 17<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong>................................................................................................................................... 17<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE .................................................................................................................... 18<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> ASSISTANT RADIOGRAPHER ......................................................................................... 18<br />

CORONAL POLISHING............................................................................................................... 20<br />

EXPANED FUNCTION <strong>DENTAL</strong> AUXILIARY................................................................................... 20<br />

GRADUATE OF UNACCREDITED <strong>DENTAL</strong> COLLEGE LOCATED OUTSIDE THE UNITED <strong>STATE</strong>S LICENSE<br />

APPLICATION(S) ............................................................................................................................ 21<br />

REIN<strong>STATE</strong>MENT LICENSE APPLICATION(S) – NO INTERVIEW .................... 21<br />

COLLEEN C. FEIST, R.D.H. ...................................................................................................... 21<br />

CAROLYN C. JACKSON, R.D.H.................................................................................................. 22<br />

NOEL P. PATTON, D.D.S. ........................................................................................................ 22<br />

KIMBERLY A. RICHARDS, R.D.H. ............................................................................................. 22<br />

ANESTHESIA COMMITTEE REPORT................................................................ 22<br />

REVIEW OF PROVISIONAL CONSCIOUS SEDATION PRIVILEGE(S) ............... 22<br />

REVIEW OF CONSCIOUS SEDATION PERMIT APPLICATION(S) ..................... 23<br />

EDUCATION COMMITTEE REPORT ................................................................ 23<br />

REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR<br />

APPLICATION(S) .............................................................................................................. 23<br />

REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR RENEWAL<br />

APPLICATION(S) .............................................................................................................. 24<br />

REVIEW OF REQUIRED TRAINING COURSE(S)................................................... 24<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE MEDICAL EMERGENCY COURSE(S) ................................................................. 24<br />

REVIEW OF SPECIAL REQUEST(S).......................................................................... 24<br />

CONTINUING EDUCATION COURSE CONSIDERATION REQUEST(S)............................................... 24<br />

LAW AND RULES REVIEW COMMITTEE REPORT ......................................... 25<br />

SECRETARY'S EXPENSE REPORT...................................................................... 25<br />

OFFICE EXPENSE REPORT ................................................................................ 25<br />

EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S REPORT................................................................... 25<br />

AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> ADMINISTRATORS/ AMERICAN<br />

ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> EXAMINERS <strong>MEETING</strong>S............................................... 25<br />

ANYTHING FOR THE GOOD OF THE <strong>BOARD</strong>................................................. 26<br />

ELECTION OF OFFICERS........................................................................................... 26<br />

UPDATED <strong>BOARD</strong> ROSTER ...................................................................................... 26<br />

COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS .................................................................................. 27<br />

ADJOURN............................................................................................................ 28


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong><br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008<br />

MINUTES<br />

ATTENDANCE<br />

The <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board (Board) met in Room 1960, 19 th Floor of The Vern<br />

Riffe Center for Government and <strong>the</strong> Arts, 77 South High Street, Columbus, <strong>Ohio</strong> on<br />

November 5, 2008, beginning at 1:00 p.m. Board members present were:<br />

Mark T. Armstrong, D.D.S., Vice-President<br />

Edward R. Hills, D.D.S., Secretary<br />

Ketki B. Desai, D.D.S.<br />

W. Chris Hanners, D.D.S.<br />

Berta I. Howard, D.D.S.<br />

Lawrence B. Kaye, D.D.S.<br />

Billie Sue Kyger, D.D.S.<br />

William G. Leffler, D.D.S.<br />

Ann E. Naber, R.D.H.<br />

Chad A. Readler, Esq.<br />

Linda R. Staley, R.D.H.<br />

Douglas W. Wallace, D.D.S.<br />

Clifford Jones, R.D.H. was unable to attend <strong>the</strong> meeting due to jury duty obligation.<br />

The following guests were also in attendance: Ka<strong>the</strong>rine Bockbrader, Esq. of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong><br />

Attorney General’s Office; Michele Carr, R.D.H., M.A. and first year dental hygiene<br />

students of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> University (OSU) Department of Dental Hygiene; Keith<br />

Kerns, Esq. and Dennis Burns, D.D.S. of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Dental Association (ODA); Lili Reitz,<br />

Esq., Executive Director, Joseph Yonadi, Enforcement Supervisor, Gail Davis, Dental<br />

Board Enforcement Officer, Jayne Smith, Licensure Coordinator, and Malynda Franks,<br />

Executive Secretary of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board; and o<strong>the</strong>r guests.<br />

CALL TO ORDER<br />

Dr. Armstrong extended greetings to everyone and noting that <strong>the</strong>re was a quorum<br />

present called <strong>the</strong> meeting to order at 1:17 p.m. He requested all members and guests<br />

sign <strong>the</strong> attendance roster.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 2<br />

INTRODUCTION OF <strong>BOARD</strong> MEMBERS<br />

Dr. Armstrong introduced himself as <strong>the</strong> Board Vice-President, a general dentist from<br />

Troy. He <strong>the</strong>n introduced <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r Board members: Dr. Edward Hills, <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

Secretary, a general dentist from Cleveland, Dr. Ketki Desai, a general dentist from<br />

Columbus, Dr. Chris Hanners, a general dentist from Chillico<strong>the</strong>, Dr. Berta Howard, a<br />

general dentist from Hamilton, Dr. Larry Kaye, a periodontist from Akron, Dr. Billie Sue<br />

Kyger, a general dentist from Gallipolis, Dr. William Leffler, a general dentist from<br />

Massillon, Dr. Douglas Wallace, an oral and maxillofacial surgeon from Fairfield, Ms.<br />

Linda Staley, a dental hygienist from Lima, Ms. Ann Naber, a dental hygienist from<br />

Cincinnati, and Mr. Chad Readler, an attorney from Columbus. Dr. Armstrong noted<br />

that Clifford Jones, R.D.H., a dental hygienist from Cincinnati was not in attendance to<br />

<strong>the</strong> meeting.<br />

EXECUTIVE SESSION<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Naber, to move <strong>the</strong> Board into<br />

executive session pursuant to <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code Section 121.22(G)(3) to confer<br />

with counsel on matters that are <strong>the</strong> subject of pending or imminent court action.<br />

Roll call vote:<br />

Dr. Armstrong – Yes<br />

Dr. Hills – Yes<br />

Dr. Desai – Yes<br />

Dr. Hanners – Yes<br />

Dr. Howard – Yes<br />

Dr. Kaye – Yes<br />

Dr. Kyger - Yes<br />

Dr. Leffler – Yes<br />

Ms. Naber – Yes<br />

Mr. Readler – Yes<br />

Ms. Staley - Yes<br />

Dr. Wallace - Yes<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

Dr. Armstrong invited Ms. Reitz, Mr. Yonadi, and Ms. Bockbrader to attend <strong>the</strong><br />

executive session.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 3<br />

OPEN SESSION<br />

The Board resumed open session at 1:48 p.m. Dr. Armstrong approved <strong>the</strong> agenda<br />

for <strong>the</strong> afternoon as presented with <strong>the</strong> notation that <strong>the</strong> Chair may modify <strong>the</strong> agenda<br />

due to timing constraints or extenuating circumstances.<br />

REVIEW OF THE SEPTEMBER <strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

The Board reviewed <strong>the</strong> minutes of <strong>the</strong> September 17, 2008 Board meeting.<br />

Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> September 17,<br />

2008 Board meeting minutes as presented.<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

ENFORCEMENT REPORT<br />

PERSONAL APPEARANCE(S)<br />

SAMUEL S. KALUDY, D.D.S.<br />

Ms. Davis introduced Samuel S. Kaludy, D.D.S. and stated Dr. Kaludy was appearing<br />

before <strong>the</strong> Board today for his second appearance. She reminded <strong>the</strong> Board members of<br />

<strong>the</strong> issue that brought Dr. Kaludy before <strong>the</strong>m today. She <strong>the</strong>n explained that he is<br />

required to attend Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) weekly and provide one (1) urine screen<br />

monthly, which remains negative. In addition, Ms. Davis stated that Dr. Kaludy has<br />

been attending aftercare at One Step on a weekly basis. She pointed out that she had<br />

spoken to Dr. Kaludy regarding <strong>the</strong> staff members that he involved in this matter and<br />

that he stated he has “made amends” and apologized for his behavior. Ms. Davis<br />

indicated that Dr. Kaludy recognizes that he put <strong>the</strong>m in harm’s way, could have gotten<br />

<strong>the</strong>m in a lot of trouble, and that this was a big step for Dr. Kaludy to make in his<br />

recovery.<br />

Upon questioning by <strong>the</strong> Board Dr. Kaludy stated that he felt his recovery was going<br />

well. He stated that since his last appearance he had completed twenty (20) hours of<br />

continuing education in dental ethics with Donna Homenko, R.D.H., Ph.D. and<br />

continues to work on complying with <strong>the</strong> Board’s requirements. Dr. Kaludy informed<br />

<strong>the</strong> Board members that he had been drafting a business plan with a fellow classmate<br />

that would allow both of <strong>the</strong>m to return to practice part-time, three (3) days per week.<br />

He stated that he is excited to get back into practice and anxious to see patients again.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 4<br />

Mr. Readler asked Dr. Kaludy to clarify Ms. Davis’ earlier statement regarding<br />

apologies to his staff and family members. Dr. Kaludy stated that he recognized that his<br />

actions put his staff members, some of whom are family members, in harm’s way and<br />

could have caused <strong>the</strong>m a great deal of trouble by violating <strong>the</strong> law. He stated that he<br />

recognized that he caused <strong>the</strong>se issues and has sincerely apologized to <strong>the</strong>m, as he felt it<br />

difficult to live with himself knowing that he had placed <strong>the</strong>m in harm’s way.<br />

Motion by Dr. Howard, second by Mr. Readler, to reinstate <strong>the</strong> license of<br />

Samuel S. Kaludy, D.D.S. to practice dentistry in <strong>the</strong> <strong>State</strong> of <strong>Ohio</strong> pursuant to<br />

<strong>the</strong> terms set forth in his consent agreement with <strong>the</strong> Board.<br />

Motion carried with one (1) abstention and one (1) opposed.<br />

REVIEW OF CASES WHEREIN NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY<br />

WERE ISSUED AND NO HEARING WAS REQUESTED<br />

Dr. Armstrong turned <strong>the</strong> meeting over to Dr. Hills to conduct <strong>the</strong> evidentiary<br />

reviews. Dr. Hills <strong>the</strong>n stated for <strong>the</strong> record:<br />

“This is an evidentiary review involving dentists and dental hygienists that failed to<br />

renew <strong>the</strong>ir licenses. pursuant to Chapters 119. and 4715. of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code.<br />

The purpose of this proceeding is to give <strong>the</strong> Board information about <strong>the</strong>se matters, in<br />

lieu of <strong>the</strong> Administrative Hearing that would have occurred if <strong>the</strong>se licensees had<br />

requested a hearing. The Board’s minutes will serve as <strong>the</strong> official record of this<br />

proceeding.”<br />

Dr. Hills asked if <strong>the</strong> <strong>State</strong> would like to present any additional information to<br />

support <strong>the</strong> charges outlined in <strong>the</strong> Notices of Immediate Suspension and Opportunity<br />

for Hearing.<br />

Ms. Bockbrader said yes <strong>the</strong>n began by stating that she was introducing an affidavit<br />

for <strong>the</strong> Board’s review and consideration. She stated that <strong>State</strong>’s Exhibit 1 is an affidavit<br />

from Jayne Smith, Licensure Coordinator, dated November 4, 2008, wherein she attests<br />

that <strong>the</strong> following listed licensees failed to renew <strong>the</strong>ir licenses to practice by January 1,<br />

2008 and have not submitted valid renewal application as of <strong>the</strong> date of her sworn<br />

affidavit. Ms. Bockbrader stated that in <strong>the</strong> affidavit, Ms. Smith attests that <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

office has not received any continuing education nor has <strong>the</strong> Board executive office<br />

received any written requests for hearings from <strong>the</strong> following licensees.<br />

Ms. Bockbrader informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>State</strong>’s Exhibit 2 is true and accurate copies<br />

of all <strong>the</strong> Notices of Opportunity for Hearing and signed and dated certified mail


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 5<br />

receipts indicating that each licensee was served with <strong>the</strong>ir respective Notice of<br />

Opportunity for Hearing in <strong>the</strong>se matters.<br />

DENTISTS<br />

Frank J Crocco 30-013058 08-18-0290<br />

Edward R Falkner 30-010578 08-18-0286<br />

Robert P Gardner 30-012008 08-25-0318<br />

David D Hamlar 30-010164 08-25-0316<br />

Kyeongseon Kim 30-022176 08-25-0313<br />

Henry A Maxim 30-013532 08-15-0253<br />

Emmett Millit 30-011049 08-07-0247<br />

Wilbur E Neel 30-010462 08-29-0328<br />

Charles L Ortman 30-010291 08-09-0248<br />

Scott D Pelok 30-020109 08-48-0355<br />

Robert R Price 30-011466 08-41-0340<br />

Shabnam Rahimdashti 30-022434 08-18-0255<br />

Rami Salloum 30-022285 08-87-0408<br />

Thomas L Snodgrass 30-015338 08-41-0341<br />

Brian Stratman 30-022001 08-25-0302<br />

Herbert L White 30-012368 08-25-0326<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS<br />

Susan J Barnett 31-007110 08-18-0276<br />

Sandra R Comes 31-001195 08-48-0361<br />

Betsy Schnell Comtess 31-005396 08-25-0323<br />

Ryan Davis 31-011673 08-21-0294<br />

Hilda Feduik 31-002347 08-72-0385<br />

Julie K Hardesty 31-004058 08-32-0335<br />

Sandra E Hawk 31-004833 08-02-0244<br />

Rhena M Heyman 31-005980 08-39-0338<br />

Peisung Hsu 31-011772 08-25-0314<br />

Angela M Hypes 31-006930 08-57-0374<br />

Deborah A Makosky-Fye 31-008376 08-78-0400<br />

Beverly Miller 31-003162 08-77-0398<br />

Trudy M Palmateer 31-003255 08-48-0356<br />

Carol A Pohlmann 31-001884 08-20-0292<br />

Amandeep Rai 31-011445 08-18-0263<br />

F Mary Roman 31-003512 08-76-0390<br />

Natalie Roner 31-010455 08-25-0305<br />

Donna L Schultz 31-004323 08-57-0372


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 6<br />

Michelle C Whited 31-006403 08-77-0395<br />

Ms. Staley asked for clarification as to whe<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong>se licensees did not respond to any<br />

of <strong>the</strong> Board’s earlier correspondence or if <strong>the</strong> individuals had been offered retirement in<br />

lieu of formal action by <strong>the</strong> Board. Ms. Bockbrader indicated that <strong>the</strong> aforementioned<br />

licensees had not responded in any manner to <strong>the</strong> Board’s Notice of Opportunity for<br />

Hearing as issued.<br />

Ms. Bockbrader <strong>the</strong>n requested that <strong>the</strong> evidence as submitted be admitted into <strong>the</strong><br />

record. Dr. Hills accepted <strong>the</strong> <strong>State</strong>’s Exhibits in this matter and entered <strong>the</strong>m into<br />

evidence.<br />

EXECUTIVE SESSION<br />

Motion by Dr. Howard, second Ms. Staley, to move <strong>the</strong> Board into executive<br />

session pursuant to <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code Section 121.22(G)(1) to deliberate and<br />

consider <strong>the</strong> charges and evidence presented in <strong>the</strong>se matters.<br />

Roll call vote:<br />

Dr. Armstrong – Yes<br />

Dr. Hills – Yes<br />

Dr. Desai – Yes<br />

Dr. Hanners – Yes<br />

Dr. Howard – Yes<br />

Dr. Kaye – Yes<br />

Dr. Kyger - Yes<br />

Dr. Leffler – Yes<br />

Ms. Naber – Yes<br />

Mr. Readler – Yes<br />

Ms. Staley - Yes<br />

Dr. Wallace - Yes<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

OPEN SESSION<br />

The Board resumed open session at 2:12 p.m.<br />

Dr. Hills <strong>the</strong>n stated, “Let <strong>the</strong> record reflect that I, Dr. Edward R. Hills was <strong>the</strong><br />

secretary in <strong>the</strong>se matters, and <strong>the</strong>refore I will abstain from final vote. Fur<strong>the</strong>rmore, I<br />

was not present during executive session and did not participate in <strong>the</strong> deliberations in<br />

<strong>the</strong>se matters.”


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 7<br />

DECISION IN THE MATTER OF AUTOMATICALLY SUSPENDED<br />

DENTISTS AND <strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS FOR NON-RENEWAL OF LICENSURE<br />

Motion by Dr. Howard, second by Ms. Staley, that Count #1 in <strong>the</strong> Notice of<br />

Opportunity for Hearing is found to be true and that it is hereby Ordered that all<br />

licensees in this matter be indefinitely suspended with <strong>the</strong> standard terms and<br />

conditions:<br />

Discussion followed wherein it was decided that <strong>the</strong>re should be terms for<br />

reinstatement of all dental and dental hygiene licenses.<br />

Motion by Ms. Naber, second by Dr. Leffler, to amend <strong>the</strong> motion as follows:<br />

Denists:<br />

Frank J Crocco 30-013058 08-18-0290<br />

Edward R Falkner 30-010578 08-18-0286<br />

Robert P Gardner 30-012008 08-25-0318<br />

David D Hamlar 30-010164 08-25-0316<br />

Kyeongseon Kim 30-022176 08-25-0313<br />

Henry A Maxim 30-013532 08-15-0253<br />

Emmett Millit 30-011049 08-07-0247<br />

Wilbur E Neel 30-010462 08-29-0328<br />

Charles L Ortman 30-010291 08-09-0248<br />

Scott D Pelok 30-020109 08-48-0355<br />

Robert R Price 30-011466 08-41-0340<br />

Shabnam Rahimdashti 30-022434 08-18-0255<br />

Rami Salloum 30-022285 08-87-0408<br />

Thomas L Snodgrass 30-015338 08-41-0341<br />

Brian Stratman 30-022001 08-25-0302<br />

Herbert L White 30-012368 08-25-0326<br />

It is hereby ORDERED,<br />

(1) That <strong>the</strong> license of (LICENSEE) to practice dentistry in <strong>the</strong> state of<br />

<strong>Ohio</strong> is INDEFINITELY SUSPENDED.<br />

a. No one in <strong>the</strong> dental office may perform dentistry or dental hygiene<br />

duties or o<strong>the</strong>rwise treat patients during <strong>the</strong> period of suspension.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 8<br />

b. A receptionist may answer <strong>the</strong> phone with “Dr. (LICENSEE’s) office”,<br />

or <strong>the</strong> name of <strong>the</strong> practice, for <strong>the</strong> sole purpose of answering<br />

questions, scheduling/rescheduling appointments, and making<br />

referrals.<br />

c. The LICENSEE may not receive any income ei<strong>the</strong>r from a legal or<br />

beneficial interest in <strong>the</strong> dental practice during <strong>the</strong> period of<br />

suspension<br />

(2) The <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board shall not consider Reinstatement of <strong>the</strong><br />

LICENSEE’s license to practice unless and until all <strong>the</strong> following<br />

requirements are met:<br />

a. The LICENSEE shall submit a reinstatement application to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

Secretary, complete those requirements set forth <strong>the</strong>rein, and include<br />

all appropriate fees and late fees.<br />

b. The LICENSEE shall submit documentation satisfactory to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

that all continuing education requirements are current and up to date<br />

pursuant to RC 4715.141 (dentists) RC 4715.25 (dental hygienists).<br />

c. The LICENSEE shall take sixteen (16) hours of continuing education<br />

in Ethics, approved in advance by <strong>the</strong> Board Secretary.<br />

d. The LICENSEE shall take and pass <strong>the</strong> Jurisprudence, Ethics and Risk<br />

Management (JERM) Exam administered by <strong>the</strong> North East Regional<br />

Board of Dental Examiners, Inc.<br />

(3) Once reinstated, <strong>the</strong> LICENSEE shall automatically submit<br />

documentation acceptable to <strong>the</strong> Board of satisfactory completion of<br />

<strong>the</strong> requisite hours of Continuing Education necessary for renewal for<br />

<strong>the</strong> next two bienniums. This documentation shall be due in <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

office by November 30 th of <strong>the</strong> odd-numbered year prior to submitting<br />

<strong>the</strong> LICENSEES application for renewal of <strong>the</strong> LICENSEES<br />

dental/dental hygiene license.<br />

This ORDER shall become effective thirty (30) days from <strong>the</strong> date of <strong>the</strong><br />

mailing of this ORDER.<br />

Dental Hygienists:<br />

Susan J Barnett 31-007110 08-18-0276<br />

Sandra R Comes 31-001195 08-48-0361<br />

Betsy Schnell Comtess 31-005396 08-25-0323<br />

Ryan Davis 31-011673 08-21-0294


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 9<br />

Hilda Feduik 31-002347 08-72-0385<br />

Julie K Hardesty 31-004058 08-32-0335<br />

Sandra E Hawk 31-004833 08-02-0244<br />

Rhena M Heyman 31-005980 08-39-0338<br />

Peisung Hsu 31-011772 08-25-0314<br />

Angela M Hypes 31-006930 08-57-0374<br />

Deborah A Makosky-Fye 31-008376 08-78-0400<br />

Beverly Miller 31-003162 08-77-0398<br />

Trudy M Palmateer 31-003255 08-48-0356<br />

Carol A Pohlmann 31-001884 08-20-0292<br />

Amandeep Rai 31-011445 08-18-0263<br />

F Mary Roman 31-003512 08-76-0390<br />

Natalie Roner 31-010455 08-25-0305<br />

Donna L Schultz 31-004323 08-57-0372<br />

Michelle C Whited 31-006403 08-77-0395<br />

It is hereby ORDERED,<br />

(1) That <strong>the</strong> license of LICENSEE to practice dentistry in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong><br />

is INDEFINITELY SUSPENDED.<br />

(2) The <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board shall not consider Reinstatement of <strong>the</strong><br />

LICENSEE’s license to practice unless and until all <strong>the</strong> following<br />

requirements are met:<br />

a. The LICENSEE shall submit a reinstatement application to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

Secretary, complete those requirements set forth <strong>the</strong>rein, and include<br />

all appropriate fees and late fees.<br />

b. The LICENSEE shall submit documentation satisfactory to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

that all continuing education requirements are current and up to date<br />

pursuant to RC 4715.141 (dentists) RC 4715.25 (dental hygienists).<br />

c. The LICENSEE shall take sixteen (16) hours of continuing education<br />

in Ethics, approved in advance by <strong>the</strong> Board Secretary.<br />

d. The LICENSEE shall take and pass <strong>the</strong> Jurisprudence, Ethics and Risk<br />

Management (JERM) Exam administered by <strong>the</strong> North East Regional<br />

Board of Dental Examiners, Inc.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 10<br />

(3) Once reinstated, <strong>the</strong> LICENSEE shall automatically submit<br />

documentation acceptable to <strong>the</strong> Board of satisfactory completion of<br />

<strong>the</strong> requisite hours of Continuing Education necessary for renewal for<br />

<strong>the</strong> next two bienniums. This documentation shall be due in <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

office by November 30 th of <strong>the</strong> odd-numbered year prior to submitting<br />

<strong>the</strong> LICENSEES application for renewal of <strong>the</strong> LICENSEES<br />

dental/dental hygiene license.<br />

This ORDER shall become effective thirty (30) days from <strong>the</strong> date of <strong>the</strong><br />

mailing of this ORDER.<br />

Motion carried<br />

Dr. Armstrong <strong>the</strong>n called <strong>the</strong> question on <strong>the</strong> amended motion.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED MOTIONS<br />

Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Dr. Kyger, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />

automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for <strong>the</strong> Mikala<br />

Genrich, D.D.S., license number 30-022146, case number 08-25-0317.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice(s)<br />

of automatic suspension and notice(s) of opportunity for hearing for Donald H.<br />

Harpster, D.D.S., license number 30-012022, case number 08-48-0363.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice(s)<br />

of automatic suspension and notice(s) of opportunity for hearing for Finn F.<br />

L’Orange, D.D.S., license number 30-00-8548, case number 08-18-0257.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />

automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for Charles L.<br />

Ortmann, D.D.S., license number 30-008548, case number 08-09-0248.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 11<br />

Motion carried.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Mr. Readler, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />

automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for Mark B. Soller,<br />

D.D.S., license number 30-017422, case number 08-50-0364.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />

automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for Brian A. Stern,<br />

D.D.S., license number 30-022067, case number 07-23-0579.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY SURRENDER(S)<br />

The Board reviewed one (1) proposed voluntary surrender. The name of <strong>the</strong><br />

individual/licensee was not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board. The name<br />

of <strong>the</strong> individual/licensee has been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public notice purposes.<br />

Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed voluntary<br />

surrender of license for Christina V. Dauka, R.D.H., license number 31-00-3779,<br />

case number 08-89-0100.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY RETIREMENT(S)<br />

The Board reviewed twelve (12) proposed voluntary retirement(s). The names of <strong>the</strong><br />

individuals/licensees were not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board. The<br />

names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees have been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public notice<br />

purposes.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed<br />

voluntary retirements for <strong>the</strong> following licensees:<br />

Gavin M. Aaron, D.D.S. 30021842 08-25-0312<br />

Ashley Cornils, D.D.S. 30022120 08-19-0291<br />

Donald R. Curtis, D.D.S. 30015736 08-48-0360<br />

Linda L. Dugan, R.D.H. 31006057 08-02-0420<br />

Roger S. Ely, D.D.S. 30010408 08-86-0406<br />

Mary P. Fandrey, R.D.H. 31005302 08-48-0352


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 12<br />

Anneliese Haws, D.D.S. 30022307 08-25-0315<br />

Michael B. Jones, D.D.S. 30022427 08-18-0266<br />

Sheila Lall, D.D.S. 30022177 08-25-0310<br />

J. Perry Royston, D.D.S. 30020846 08-09-0249<br />

Susan F. Urell, R.D.H. 31006593 08-25-0301<br />

Douglas Vrudny, D.D.S. 30013018 08-57-0370<br />

Motion carried.<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED CONSENT AGREEMENT(S)<br />

The Board reviewed twelve (12) proposed consent agreements. The names of <strong>the</strong><br />

individuals/licensees were not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board. The<br />

names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees have been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public notice<br />

purposes.<br />

DISCIPLINARY<br />

JEFFREY J. BECKER, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Jeffrey J. Becker, D.D.S., license number 30-018193, case number<br />

07-22-0420.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

ROBERT E. BURNS, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Staley, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Robert E. Burns, D.D.S., license number 30-018900, case number<br />

08-25-0528.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

HECTOR A. CABALLERO, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kaye, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Hector A. Caballero, D.D.S., license number 30-019517, case<br />

number 06-89-0418.<br />

Motion carried.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 13<br />

WILLIAM H. CARDWELL, JR., D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for William H. Cardwell, Jr., D.D.S., license number 30-015816, case<br />

number 07-45-0603.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

MARK DEVINCENZO, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Desai, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Mark DeVincenzo, D.D.S., license number 30-017327, case<br />

number 08-57-0568.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

STACEY M. HARRIS, R.D.H.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Staley, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Stacey M. Harris, R.D.H., license number 31-010689, case number<br />

08-57-0422.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

BERNARD J. JOHNSON, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Howard, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed<br />

consent agreement for Bernard J. Johnson, D.D.S., license number 30-013689,<br />

case number 08-76-0437.<br />

Motion carried. Bill abstained<br />

RICHARD LAPP, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Desai, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Richard Lapp, D.D.S., license number 30-011423, case number 07-<br />

60-0355.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 14<br />

Motion carried with two (2) abstention.<br />

LINCOLN W. LAWRENCE, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Lincoln W. Lawrence, D.D.S., license number 30-015242, case<br />

number 06-46-0816.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

TRACEY PATRIARCA, R.D.H.<br />

Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Tracey Patriarca, R.D.H., license number 31-008921, case number<br />

08-89-0467.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

GARY L. WARREN, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Gary L. Warren, D.D.S., license number 30-014584, case number<br />

08-25-0425.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

NON-DISCIPLINARY<br />

RAJESH GUTTA, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />

agreement for Rajesh Gutta, D.D.S., license number 30-022922.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

REVIEW OF PROPOSED NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY<br />

The Board reviewed three (3) proposed notices of opportunity for hearing. The<br />

names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees were not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong>


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 15<br />

Board. The names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees have been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public<br />

notice purposes.<br />

CHARLES L. DIPASQUALE, D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />

opportunity for hearing and forward it to Charles DiPasquale, D.D.S., license<br />

number 30-014427, and case numbers 07-57-0528, 07-57-0554, and 08-57-0118.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

BRENDA L. WILCOX, R.D.H.<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed notice<br />

of opportunity for hearing and forward it to Brenda L. Wilcox, R.D.H., license<br />

number 31-008690, and case number 08-33-0426.<br />

Motion carried with one abstention.<br />

MALCOLM WALTERS, JR., D.D.S.<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed notice<br />

of opportunity for hearing and forward it to Malcolm Walters, Jr., D.D.S., license<br />

number 30-020238, and case number 05-18-0296 Amended.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

ENFORCEMENT UPDATE<br />

Mr. Yonadi informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong>re were five (5) cases pending hearings, of<br />

which all have been assigned for hearing and that we still have five (5) cases under<br />

appeal. Mr. Yonadi stated that <strong>the</strong>re are currently twenty-five (25) licensees under<br />

suspension. He informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that we have five (5) cases still pending<br />

QUIP with one (1) additional licensee entering into QUIP.<br />

Mr. Yonadi informed <strong>the</strong> Board that Forty-eight (48) cases have been investigated<br />

and reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board Secretary and are recommended to be closed.<br />

Due to <strong>the</strong> requirement in Chapter 4715.03(D) of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code, that "The<br />

board shall not dismiss any complaint or terminate any investigation except by a


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 16<br />

majority vote of its members,..." Mr. Yonadi reviewed <strong>the</strong> cases to be closed with <strong>the</strong><br />

Board.<br />

The following cases are recommended to be closed:<br />

07-25-0096 Standard Of Care<br />

07-25-0174 Standard Of Care<br />

08-09-0533 Standard Of Care<br />

08-09-0563 Standard Of Care<br />

08-12-0498 Standard Of Care/<br />

Misrepresentation<br />

08-13-0529 Conduct/Standard<br />

08-13-0535 Standard/Conduct<br />

08-14-0508 Standard Of Care<br />

08-18-0168 Standard Of Care/<br />

Dentures<br />

08-18-0453 Policy/Standard Of<br />

Care<br />

08-18-0463 Standard/Misrep<br />

08-18-0488 Denture<br />

08-18-0503 Records-Warning<br />

08-18-0504 Standard Of Care<br />

08-18-0510 Behavior<br />

08-25-0211 Standard Of Care/<br />

Conduct<br />

08-25-0228 Adverse Occurrence<br />

08-25-0512 Standard Of Care<br />

08-30-0497 Standard Of Care<br />

08-31-0479 Standard Of Care<br />

08-31-0480 Standard Of Care<br />

08-31-0482 Standard Of Care<br />

08-31-0483 Advertising<br />

08-31-0527 Dentures<br />

08-31-0530 Standard Of Care<br />

08-31-0531 Adverse Occurrence<br />

08-31-0547 Standard Of Care/<br />

Conduct<br />

08-31-0562 Standard Of Care/<br />

Dentures<br />

08-35-0053 Standard Of Care<br />

08-43-0490 Adverse Occurrence<br />

08-45-0494 Standard/Dentures<br />

08-48-0153 Standard Of Care<br />

08-50-0179 Records<br />

08-57-0216 Standard Of Care/<br />

Warning<br />

08-57-0474 Misrepresentation<br />

08-57-0475 Standard Of Care<br />

08-57-0481 Standard Of Care<br />

08-57-0532 Standard Of Care<br />

08-57-0549 Standard Of Care<br />

08-57-0553 Standard Of Care<br />

08-73-0511 Dentures<br />

08-76-0444 Conduct/Drugs<br />

08-77-0059 Standard Of Care/<br />

Warning<br />

08-77-0476 Standard Of Care<br />

08-77-0499 Impairment/Conduct<br />

08-77-0513 Abandement<br />

08-78-0485 Standard Of Care/<br />

Abandonment<br />

08-83-0478 Outside Scope<br />

Prior to <strong>the</strong> vote to close <strong>the</strong> above listed cases, Dr. Armstrong inquired as to whe<strong>the</strong>r<br />

any of <strong>the</strong> Board members had any personal knowledge that <strong>the</strong> cases that were being<br />

voted on today involve ei<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong>mselves or a personal friend.<br />

Roll call:<br />

Dr. Armstrong – No<br />

Dr. Hills – Abstain<br />

Dr. Desai – No<br />

Dr. Hanners – No


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 17<br />

Dr. Howard – Abstain<br />

Dr. Kaye – No<br />

Dr. Kyger - No<br />

Dr. Leffler – No<br />

Ms. Naber – No<br />

Mr. Readler – No<br />

Ms. Staley – No<br />

Dr. Wallace - No<br />

Dr. Armstrong <strong>the</strong>n called for a motion to close <strong>the</strong> cases.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Staley, to close <strong>the</strong> above forty-eight (48)<br />

cases.<br />

Roll call vote:<br />

Dr. Armstrong – Yes<br />

Dr. Hills – Abstain<br />

Dr. Desai – Yes<br />

Dr. Hanners – Yes<br />

Dr. Howard – Abstain<br />

Dr. Kaye – Yes<br />

Dr. Kyger - Yes<br />

Dr. Leffler – Yes<br />

Ms. Naber – Yes<br />

Mr. Readler – Yes<br />

Ms. Staley – Yes<br />

Dr. Wallace - Yes<br />

Motion carried.<br />

REVIEW OF LICENSE APPLICATIONS<br />

LICENSURE REPORT<br />

Jayne Smith, Licensure Coordinator, had prepared a report of <strong>the</strong> licenses issued since<br />

<strong>the</strong> September 2008 meeting, for Board member review.<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong><br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />

for <strong>the</strong> following dental licenses issued by North East Regional Board, Inc.<br />

(NERB) examination:


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

AUGUST 13, 2008 PAGE 18<br />

Andrew N. Amborski<br />

Serjio R. Arias<br />

Karen R. Coe<br />

Kristen A. Darville<br />

Nazik H. Elrayah<br />

Shirley S. Ferreira<br />

Mona A. Gokani<br />

Anne V. Gormley<br />

Joseph B. Grubler<br />

Meghan M. Hajduch<br />

Suparna A. Mahalaha<br />

Ka<strong>the</strong>rine E. Miller<br />

Giulia M. Pagano<br />

Holly H. Park-Nah<br />

Siddhi R. Patel<br />

Carlos Pires<br />

Pedro A. Rodriguez<br />

Troy A. Rogers<br />

Elliot P. Schlang<br />

Sharon T. Schmeiser<br />

Robert S. Schneider<br />

Michael C. Sivik<br />

Michael A. Sullivan<br />

William F. Traynor<br />

Amber M. Weidner<br />

Hee-Jin Yang<br />

John D. Young<br />

Ruth A. Youngquist<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />

for <strong>the</strong> following dental hygiene licenses issued by North East Regional Board,<br />

Inc. (NERB) examination:<br />

Nicole L. Beasley<br />

Ellen F. Cielenski<br />

Amanda J. Coss<br />

Ashley N. Dilworth<br />

Kristen R. Gutschow<br />

Robin D. Kochur<br />

Nicole B. Lahaye<br />

Ashley P. Lloyd<br />

LaTesha S. Moore<br />

Justina M. Reutepohler<br />

Kimberly L. Siburt<br />

Tina L. Troy-White<br />

Amber M. Uhrig<br />

Stephanie A. Urban<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> ASSISTANT RADIOGRAPHER<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Staley, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />

for <strong>the</strong> following dental assistant radiographer licenses issued by: acceptable<br />

certification or licensure in ano<strong>the</strong>r state, certification by <strong>the</strong> Dental Assisting<br />

National Board (DANB) or <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Commission on Dental Assistant<br />

Certification (OCDAC), or successful completion of <strong>the</strong> Board-approved<br />

Radiography course:


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 19<br />

Stephanie Ambrose<br />

Sarah Arrighi<br />

Marianne Ashman<br />

Erin Aufmuth<br />

Danyel Aurand<br />

Katie Austin<br />

Yasmeen Badgett<br />

Kelly Basso<br />

Hope Baumbach<br />

Michelle Black<br />

Jessica Blair<br />

Jaimi Boldman<br />

Teresa Bounce<br />

Lisa Bowers<br />

Trisha Brenton<br />

Mariya Bryant<br />

Tammy Bullard<br />

Marjorie Campbell<br />

Tina Campbell<br />

Holly Candle<br />

Brittanie Card<br />

Naomi Constanty<br />

Shuzhen Cui<br />

Frances Daugherty<br />

Erica Dobberstein<br />

Dahkibra Draper<br />

Cecily Earls<br />

Mina Eskander<br />

Maria Evegan<br />

Merrilee Ewing<br />

Maria Federico<br />

Codi Flower<br />

Nicole Gamble<br />

Helen Garen<br />

Megan Gehring<br />

Judith Gibson<br />

Sarah Golembiewski<br />

Leah Gooden<br />

Snieguole Goson<br />

Jessica Gray<br />

Deborah Grazel<br />

Tiffany Grove<br />

Kasha Grubbs<br />

Susan Hacker<br />

Nicole Hammer<br />

Jennifer Hanus<br />

Patricia Hartley<br />

Christina Hayes<br />

Coralie Hea<strong>the</strong>rly<br />

Shayna Henry<br />

Courtney Hudson<br />

Bernice Johnson<br />

Courtney Johnson<br />

Lakeisha Johnson<br />

Nicole Joy<br />

Adam Kapis<br />

Tiffany Keegan<br />

Carrie Kill<br />

Rebecca Kretzer<br />

Tracie Martin<br />

Shellie Ma<strong>the</strong>ney<br />

Susan Maximo<br />

Candance McKinley<br />

Tasha McPeek<br />

Samir Merchant<br />

Melissa Moore<br />

Darnell Morgan<br />

Mitzi Mueller-Kreis<br />

Suzanne O'connor<br />

Crystal Patrick<br />

Tiffany Pawlowski<br />

Melanie Pearsall<br />

Rene Perez<br />

Michelle Poch<br />

Rendie Pohl<br />

Lauren Politowicz<br />

Brittany Porter<br />

Chantee Provitt<br />

Jamie Rapp<br />

Karen Reeves<br />

Modjeska Richards<br />

Holly Richmond<br />

Cynthia Riggs<br />

Franko Rivera-Sierra


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 20<br />

Katie Roark<br />

Angelica Roman<br />

Nassren Saad<br />

Amannda Sawyer<br />

Misty Sergent<br />

Amanda Shaw<br />

Donna Shrock<br />

Amanda Siliko<br />

Ashley Siwek<br />

Michelle Streets<br />

Lakisha Sutton<br />

Brittany Thies<br />

Connie Thompson<br />

Erika Torres<br />

Maria Valentin<br />

Natalie Verboon<br />

Arrolla Wagner<br />

Jennifer Walls<br />

Juliene Walls<br />

Kerrie Wells<br />

Lisa West<br />

Jesssica Williams<br />

Sarah Williams<br />

Terra Wi<strong>the</strong>rspoon<br />

Shannon Witt<br />

Staci Wolf<br />

Charlotte Workman<br />

Gina Young<br />

Sharron Yowell<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

CORONAL POLISHING<br />

Motion Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report for<br />

<strong>the</strong> following coronal polishing certificates issued by: certification by <strong>the</strong> Dental<br />

Assisting National Board (DANB) or <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Commission on Dental Assistant<br />

Certification (OCDAC) and completion of <strong>the</strong> requirements necessary to obtain<br />

certification:<br />

Logan U. Abrahamson<br />

David M. Achille<br />

Shannon C. Armstrong<br />

Tammy Brodman<br />

Maria A. DuPonty<br />

Cashimera B. Harvey<br />

Angela Kinson<br />

Michelle L. Lehman<br />

Bonny L. McPherson<br />

Theresa M. Oder<br />

Brenda L. Omerzo<br />

Susan A. Rusu<br />

Erin D. Seidenschmidt<br />

Kerrymarie L. Tedesco<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

EXPANED FUNCTION <strong>DENTAL</strong> AUXILIARY<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Desai, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />

for <strong>the</strong> following expanded function dental auxiliary registrations issued by:<br />

certification by <strong>the</strong> Dental Assisting National Board (DANB) or <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong>


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 21<br />

Commission on Dental Assistant Certification (OCDAC) and completion of <strong>the</strong><br />

requirements necessary to obtain registration:<br />

Jessica R Agee<br />

Myling Bonilla<br />

Kathy Y Bruning<br />

Latisha A Collins<br />

Alisha R Dixon<br />

Ann G Durst<br />

Kristen A Farnsworth<br />

Trisha Gable<br />

Mindy Gessner<br />

Amy Jo Glandon<br />

Brandy Goetz<br />

Dawn N Hacker<br />

Dawn M Jones<br />

Kelly Laird<br />

Nicole D Marks<br />

Jarrod D Mihalic<br />

Jocelyn Moreford<br />

Nicole L. Myers<br />

Brenda L Omerzo<br />

Eileen M Remllong<br />

Tammie M Ridgway<br />

Priscilla A Ross<br />

Diana M Sprague<br />

Alisa A Wenger<br />

Connie Kane Wojcik<br />

Nicole D Worley<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

GRADUATE OF UNACCREDITED <strong>DENTAL</strong> COLLEGE LOCATED OUTSIDE<br />

THE UNITED <strong>STATE</strong>S LICENSE APPLICATION(S)<br />

Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure<br />

application for dental license issued by graduation from an unaccredited dental<br />

college located outside <strong>the</strong> United <strong>State</strong>s for Rajesh Gutta, D.D.S.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

REIN<strong>STATE</strong>MENT LICENSE APPLICATION(S) – NO INTERVIEW<br />

COLLEEN C. FEIST, R.D.H.<br />

The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Colleen C. Feist,<br />

R.D.H. that was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Staley, to approve Ms. Feist’s<br />

reinstatement application for dental hygiene licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />

Motion carried unanimously.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 22<br />

CAROLYN C. JACKSON, R.D.H.<br />

The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Carolyn C. Jackson,<br />

R.D.H., which was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Naber, to approve Ms. Jackson’s<br />

reinstatement application for dental hygiene licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

NOEL P. PATTON, D.D.S.<br />

The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Noel P. Patton,<br />

D.D.S., which was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kaye, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve Dr. Patton’s<br />

reinstatement application for dental licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

KIMBERLY A. RICHARDS, R.D.H.<br />

The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Kimberly A.<br />

Richards, R.D.H., which was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />

Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve Ms. Richards’<br />

reinstatement application for dental hygiene licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />

Motion carried unanimously.<br />

ANESTHESIA COMMITTEE REPORT<br />

REVIEW OF PROVISIONAL CONSCIOUS SEDATION<br />

PRIVILEGE(S)<br />

Dr. Wallace stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals have applied for Conscious Sedation<br />

permits. He explained that <strong>the</strong> Anes<strong>the</strong>sia Committee has reviewed <strong>the</strong> applications and<br />

<strong>the</strong> applicants are recommended to receive provisional privileges:<br />

Dr. Kapil Davar – Sylvania, <strong>Ohio</strong><br />

- Oral for children 12 years or younger<br />

Dr. Ronald D. Fowler – Columbus, <strong>Ohio</strong>


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 23<br />

- Intravenous<br />

Dr. John Segnini – Columbus, <strong>Ohio</strong><br />

- Intravenous<br />

REVIEW OF CONSCIOUS SEDATION PERMIT APPLICATION(S)<br />

Dr. Wallace stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals have applied for Conscious Sedation<br />

permits. He explained that <strong>the</strong> Anes<strong>the</strong>sia Committee has reviewed <strong>the</strong> applications,<br />

evaluations have been performed and <strong>the</strong> applicants are recommended to receive<br />

conscious sedation permits:<br />

Dr. Martha G. Dever<br />

- Intravenous<br />

Dr. Scott A. Kelley<br />

- Intravenous<br />

Dr. Michael P. Nedley<br />

- Non-intravenous parenteral<br />

Dr. Adam M. Pollock<br />

- Oral for children 12 years or younger<br />

Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Ms. Naber, to accept <strong>the</strong> Anes<strong>the</strong>sia<br />

Committee recommendations and approve <strong>the</strong> above applicants to receive<br />

privileges.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

EDUCATION COMMITTEE REPORT<br />

REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR<br />

APPLICATION(S)<br />

Dr. Howard stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals/organizations have applied for<br />

approval as biennial sponsors of continuing education for <strong>the</strong> years 2008-2009 and have<br />

been recommended for approval by <strong>the</strong> Education Committee:<br />

Dutton Dental Concepts, Inc.<br />

Matia, D.D.S., M.S.D., James I.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 24<br />

REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR<br />

RENEWAL APPLICATION(S)<br />

Dr. Howard stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals/organizations have applied for<br />

approval as biennial sponsors of continuing education for <strong>the</strong> years 2008-2009 and have<br />

been recommended for approval by <strong>the</strong> Education Committee:<br />

Eagle-Pyramid Seminars (formerly Eagle Clinical Dentistry Seminars)<br />

Heights Dental Study Club<br />

Malcmacher, D.D.S., M.A.G.D., Louis<br />

Palermo-Edwards and Cacchillo, D.D.S., Inc.<br />

Seattle Study Club of Akron<br />

West Shore Dental Study Club<br />

REVIEW OF REQUIRED TRAINING COURSE(S)<br />

<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE MEDICAL EMERGENCY COURSE(S)<br />

Dr. Howard informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong> following sponsor has submitted an<br />

application for <strong>the</strong> dental hygiene medical emergency course. She stated that <strong>the</strong><br />

Education Committee has reviewed <strong>the</strong> course, determined that it fulfills all <strong>the</strong><br />

necessary requirements, and has recommended <strong>the</strong> following for approval:<br />

West Liberty <strong>State</strong> College, Dental Hygiene :Program<br />

“Medical Emergencies in <strong>the</strong> Dental Office: Prevention, Recognition, and<br />

Management” by Michael Mermigas, R.Ph., D.D.S.<br />

REVIEW OF SPECIAL REQUEST(S)<br />

CONTINUING EDUCATION COURSE CONSIDERATION REQUEST(S)<br />

Dr. Howard informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong> Education Committee had received requests<br />

from licensees for review and consideration of dental and/or dental hygiene continuing<br />

education for <strong>the</strong> following course:<br />

Institute for Natural Resources<br />

“Cerebral Dominance – The Left and Right Brain”<br />

Dr. Howard informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong> Committee had <strong>the</strong> opportunity to review<br />

<strong>the</strong>se courses and <strong>the</strong>ir content and recommends that <strong>the</strong>se courses be denied based on<br />

<strong>the</strong> guidelines set forth in Board statute, rule and policy.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 25<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to accept <strong>the</strong> Education<br />

Committees recommendations and approve all <strong>the</strong> above applications.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

LAW AND RULES REVIEW COMMITTEE REPORT<br />

Dr. Armstrong informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that <strong>the</strong> Law and Rules Review<br />

Committee met earlier that day to review changes to <strong>the</strong> infection control rules that had<br />

been recommended by Dental Board Enforcement Officer, Kathy Carson. He stated that<br />

all proposed recommended changes would be prepared and presented to <strong>the</strong> committee<br />

and <strong>the</strong> full Board at its January meeting for consideration and possible vote for filing.<br />

SECRETARY'S EXPENSE REPORT<br />

Dr. Hills attested to <strong>the</strong> Board that he had spent in excess of twenty (20) hours per<br />

week attending to Board business.<br />

Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> Secretary's expense<br />

report.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

OFFICE EXPENSE REPORT<br />

The report of <strong>the</strong> Board expenditures was reviewed.<br />

Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> expense report<br />

and approve payment of <strong>the</strong> September, 2008 Board bills.<br />

Motion carried.<br />

EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S REPORT<br />

AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> ADMINISTRATORS/<br />

AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> EXAMINERS <strong>MEETING</strong>S<br />

Ms. Reitz informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that she has been really busy, including<br />

presentations she has been making to <strong>the</strong> dental societies and dental groups. Since <strong>the</strong><br />

Annual meetings in San Antonio, she has not had time to prepare her report from <strong>the</strong>


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 26<br />

American Association of Dental Administrators/American Association of Dental<br />

Examiners meeting held in mid-October. She did note that she had one announcement<br />

she wished to share with <strong>the</strong> Board members. Ms. Reitz explained that one of <strong>the</strong> goals<br />

of AADA in her term as President was to ask AADE to consider permitting a Dental<br />

Board administrator to be represented on <strong>the</strong> AADE Executive Committee in an advisory<br />

capacity. She was happy to note that for <strong>the</strong> first time in AADE history <strong>the</strong>y have<br />

chosen to appoint her to <strong>the</strong> Executive Committee as <strong>the</strong>ir newly appointed Dental<br />

Board Administrative Member.<br />

Ms. Reitz informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that she would be attending her first retreat<br />

in this capacity in South Dakota during <strong>the</strong> first weekend in December.<br />

ANYTHING FOR THE GOOD OF THE <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

ELECTION OF OFFICERS<br />

Ms. Naber requested that Board return to <strong>the</strong> tabled motion regarding election of<br />

officers. Discussion ensued wherein it was determined that <strong>the</strong> Board had decided to<br />

hold its election of officers during its November meeting with <strong>the</strong> elected officers<br />

positions becoming effective beginning in January 2009. Dr. Armstrong <strong>the</strong>n opened <strong>the</strong><br />

floor for nominations.<br />

Dr. Hills nominated Dr. Armstrong for President, Dr. Kyger for Vice President, Dr.<br />

Howard for Secretary, and Dr. Leffler for Vice Secretary.<br />

Dr. Armstrong asked if <strong>the</strong>re were any o<strong>the</strong>r nominations. Noting that <strong>the</strong>re were<br />

none he stated that as such <strong>the</strong> nominations were closed. Additionally, he stated that<br />

<strong>the</strong>refore that by acclamation <strong>the</strong> slate holds unopposed.<br />

Board members expressed <strong>the</strong>ir congratulations to <strong>the</strong> newly appointed officers.<br />

UPDATED <strong>BOARD</strong> ROSTER<br />

Ms. Reitz distributed a revised version of <strong>the</strong> Board Roster and requested each Board<br />

member to review <strong>the</strong>ir information for correctness and to inform her of any additional<br />

changes.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 27<br />

COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS<br />

Dr. Armstrong distributed copies of <strong>the</strong> new committee assignments to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />

members for <strong>the</strong>ir review. He requested all members to review <strong>the</strong>ir new committee<br />

assignments to note any changes. Following a brief discussion, it was decided that <strong>the</strong><br />

committee appointments would begin for <strong>the</strong> December meeting of <strong>the</strong> Board.


<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />

<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />

NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 28<br />

ADJOURN<br />

Dr. Armstrong adjourned <strong>the</strong> meeting at 3:03 p.m. He stated that <strong>the</strong> next meeting<br />

would be on December 3, 2008.<br />

Mark T. Armstrong, D.D.S.<br />

Vice-President and Acting Chair<br />

Edward R. Hills, D.D.S.<br />

Secretary

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!