OHIO STATE DENTAL BOARD BOARD MEETING - the Ohio State ...
OHIO STATE DENTAL BOARD BOARD MEETING - the Ohio State ...
OHIO STATE DENTAL BOARD BOARD MEETING - the Ohio State ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong><br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008<br />
ATTENDANCE ...................................................................................................... 1<br />
CALL TO ORDER .................................................................................................. 1<br />
INTRODUCTION OF <strong>BOARD</strong> MEMBERS ........................................................... 2<br />
EXECUTIVE SESSION........................................................................................... 2<br />
OPEN SESSION.............................................................................................................. 3<br />
REVIEW OF THE SEPTEMBER <strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES ........................... 3<br />
ENFORCEMENT REPORT .................................................................................... 3<br />
PERSONAL APPEARANCE(S) ...................................................................................... 3<br />
SAMUEL S. KALUDY, D.D.S........................................................................................................ 3<br />
REVIEW OF CASES WHEREIN NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY WERE ISSUED<br />
AND NO HEARING WAS REQUESTED .......................................................................... 4<br />
DENTISTS .................................................................................................................................. 5<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS.................................................................................................................. 5<br />
EXECUTIVE SESSION............................................................................................................................... 6<br />
OPEN SESSION........................................................................................................................................ 6<br />
DECISION IN THE MATTER OF AUTOMATICALLY SUSPENDED DENTISTS AND <strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS<br />
FOR NON-RENEWAL OF LICENSURE ................................................................................................... 7<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED MOTIONS......................................................................... 10<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY SURRENDER(S)...................................... 11<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY RETIREMENT(S) .................................... 11<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED CONSENT AGREEMENT(S) .......................................... 12<br />
DISCIPLINARY.......................................................................................................................... 12<br />
JEFFREY J. BECKER, D.D.S............................................................................................................... 12<br />
ROBERT E. BURNS, D.D.S............................................................................................................... 12<br />
HECTOR A. CABALLERO, D.D.S. .................................................................................................... 12<br />
WILLIAM H. CARDWELL, JR., D.D.S............................................................................................. 13<br />
MARK DEVINCENZO, D.D.S. ......................................................................................................... 13<br />
STACEY M. HARRIS, R.D.H. ........................................................................................................... 13<br />
BERNARD J. JOHNSON, D.D.S. ....................................................................................................... 13<br />
RICHARD LAPP, D.D.S. ........................................................................................................................13<br />
LINCOLN W. LAWRENCE, D.D.S......................................................................................................... 14<br />
TRACEY PATRIARCA, R.D.H................................................................................................................. 14<br />
GARY L. WARREN, D.D.S. .............................................................................................................. 14<br />
NON-DISCIPLINARY ................................................................................................................. 14<br />
RAJESH GUTTA, D.D.S.........................................................................................................................14<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY .................................... 14<br />
CHARLES L. DIPASQUALE, D.D.S......................................................................................................... 15<br />
BRENDA L. WILCOX, R.D.H. ............................................................................................................... 15<br />
MALCOLM WALTERS, JR., D.D.S.......................................................................................................... 15<br />
ENFORCEMENT UPDATE ......................................................................................... 15<br />
REVIEW OF LICENSE APPLICATIONS.............................................................. 17
LICENSURE REPORT.................................................................................................. 17<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong>................................................................................................................................... 17<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE .................................................................................................................... 18<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> ASSISTANT RADIOGRAPHER ......................................................................................... 18<br />
CORONAL POLISHING............................................................................................................... 20<br />
EXPANED FUNCTION <strong>DENTAL</strong> AUXILIARY................................................................................... 20<br />
GRADUATE OF UNACCREDITED <strong>DENTAL</strong> COLLEGE LOCATED OUTSIDE THE UNITED <strong>STATE</strong>S LICENSE<br />
APPLICATION(S) ............................................................................................................................ 21<br />
REIN<strong>STATE</strong>MENT LICENSE APPLICATION(S) – NO INTERVIEW .................... 21<br />
COLLEEN C. FEIST, R.D.H. ...................................................................................................... 21<br />
CAROLYN C. JACKSON, R.D.H.................................................................................................. 22<br />
NOEL P. PATTON, D.D.S. ........................................................................................................ 22<br />
KIMBERLY A. RICHARDS, R.D.H. ............................................................................................. 22<br />
ANESTHESIA COMMITTEE REPORT................................................................ 22<br />
REVIEW OF PROVISIONAL CONSCIOUS SEDATION PRIVILEGE(S) ............... 22<br />
REVIEW OF CONSCIOUS SEDATION PERMIT APPLICATION(S) ..................... 23<br />
EDUCATION COMMITTEE REPORT ................................................................ 23<br />
REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR<br />
APPLICATION(S) .............................................................................................................. 23<br />
REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR RENEWAL<br />
APPLICATION(S) .............................................................................................................. 24<br />
REVIEW OF REQUIRED TRAINING COURSE(S)................................................... 24<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE MEDICAL EMERGENCY COURSE(S) ................................................................. 24<br />
REVIEW OF SPECIAL REQUEST(S).......................................................................... 24<br />
CONTINUING EDUCATION COURSE CONSIDERATION REQUEST(S)............................................... 24<br />
LAW AND RULES REVIEW COMMITTEE REPORT ......................................... 25<br />
SECRETARY'S EXPENSE REPORT...................................................................... 25<br />
OFFICE EXPENSE REPORT ................................................................................ 25<br />
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S REPORT................................................................... 25<br />
AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> ADMINISTRATORS/ AMERICAN<br />
ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> EXAMINERS <strong>MEETING</strong>S............................................... 25<br />
ANYTHING FOR THE GOOD OF THE <strong>BOARD</strong>................................................. 26<br />
ELECTION OF OFFICERS........................................................................................... 26<br />
UPDATED <strong>BOARD</strong> ROSTER ...................................................................................... 26<br />
COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS .................................................................................. 27<br />
ADJOURN............................................................................................................ 28
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong><br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008<br />
MINUTES<br />
ATTENDANCE<br />
The <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board (Board) met in Room 1960, 19 th Floor of The Vern<br />
Riffe Center for Government and <strong>the</strong> Arts, 77 South High Street, Columbus, <strong>Ohio</strong> on<br />
November 5, 2008, beginning at 1:00 p.m. Board members present were:<br />
Mark T. Armstrong, D.D.S., Vice-President<br />
Edward R. Hills, D.D.S., Secretary<br />
Ketki B. Desai, D.D.S.<br />
W. Chris Hanners, D.D.S.<br />
Berta I. Howard, D.D.S.<br />
Lawrence B. Kaye, D.D.S.<br />
Billie Sue Kyger, D.D.S.<br />
William G. Leffler, D.D.S.<br />
Ann E. Naber, R.D.H.<br />
Chad A. Readler, Esq.<br />
Linda R. Staley, R.D.H.<br />
Douglas W. Wallace, D.D.S.<br />
Clifford Jones, R.D.H. was unable to attend <strong>the</strong> meeting due to jury duty obligation.<br />
The following guests were also in attendance: Ka<strong>the</strong>rine Bockbrader, Esq. of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong><br />
Attorney General’s Office; Michele Carr, R.D.H., M.A. and first year dental hygiene<br />
students of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> University (OSU) Department of Dental Hygiene; Keith<br />
Kerns, Esq. and Dennis Burns, D.D.S. of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Dental Association (ODA); Lili Reitz,<br />
Esq., Executive Director, Joseph Yonadi, Enforcement Supervisor, Gail Davis, Dental<br />
Board Enforcement Officer, Jayne Smith, Licensure Coordinator, and Malynda Franks,<br />
Executive Secretary of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board; and o<strong>the</strong>r guests.<br />
CALL TO ORDER<br />
Dr. Armstrong extended greetings to everyone and noting that <strong>the</strong>re was a quorum<br />
present called <strong>the</strong> meeting to order at 1:17 p.m. He requested all members and guests<br />
sign <strong>the</strong> attendance roster.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 2<br />
INTRODUCTION OF <strong>BOARD</strong> MEMBERS<br />
Dr. Armstrong introduced himself as <strong>the</strong> Board Vice-President, a general dentist from<br />
Troy. He <strong>the</strong>n introduced <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r Board members: Dr. Edward Hills, <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
Secretary, a general dentist from Cleveland, Dr. Ketki Desai, a general dentist from<br />
Columbus, Dr. Chris Hanners, a general dentist from Chillico<strong>the</strong>, Dr. Berta Howard, a<br />
general dentist from Hamilton, Dr. Larry Kaye, a periodontist from Akron, Dr. Billie Sue<br />
Kyger, a general dentist from Gallipolis, Dr. William Leffler, a general dentist from<br />
Massillon, Dr. Douglas Wallace, an oral and maxillofacial surgeon from Fairfield, Ms.<br />
Linda Staley, a dental hygienist from Lima, Ms. Ann Naber, a dental hygienist from<br />
Cincinnati, and Mr. Chad Readler, an attorney from Columbus. Dr. Armstrong noted<br />
that Clifford Jones, R.D.H., a dental hygienist from Cincinnati was not in attendance to<br />
<strong>the</strong> meeting.<br />
EXECUTIVE SESSION<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Naber, to move <strong>the</strong> Board into<br />
executive session pursuant to <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code Section 121.22(G)(3) to confer<br />
with counsel on matters that are <strong>the</strong> subject of pending or imminent court action.<br />
Roll call vote:<br />
Dr. Armstrong – Yes<br />
Dr. Hills – Yes<br />
Dr. Desai – Yes<br />
Dr. Hanners – Yes<br />
Dr. Howard – Yes<br />
Dr. Kaye – Yes<br />
Dr. Kyger - Yes<br />
Dr. Leffler – Yes<br />
Ms. Naber – Yes<br />
Mr. Readler – Yes<br />
Ms. Staley - Yes<br />
Dr. Wallace - Yes<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
Dr. Armstrong invited Ms. Reitz, Mr. Yonadi, and Ms. Bockbrader to attend <strong>the</strong><br />
executive session.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 3<br />
OPEN SESSION<br />
The Board resumed open session at 1:48 p.m. Dr. Armstrong approved <strong>the</strong> agenda<br />
for <strong>the</strong> afternoon as presented with <strong>the</strong> notation that <strong>the</strong> Chair may modify <strong>the</strong> agenda<br />
due to timing constraints or extenuating circumstances.<br />
REVIEW OF THE SEPTEMBER <strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
The Board reviewed <strong>the</strong> minutes of <strong>the</strong> September 17, 2008 Board meeting.<br />
Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> September 17,<br />
2008 Board meeting minutes as presented.<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
ENFORCEMENT REPORT<br />
PERSONAL APPEARANCE(S)<br />
SAMUEL S. KALUDY, D.D.S.<br />
Ms. Davis introduced Samuel S. Kaludy, D.D.S. and stated Dr. Kaludy was appearing<br />
before <strong>the</strong> Board today for his second appearance. She reminded <strong>the</strong> Board members of<br />
<strong>the</strong> issue that brought Dr. Kaludy before <strong>the</strong>m today. She <strong>the</strong>n explained that he is<br />
required to attend Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) weekly and provide one (1) urine screen<br />
monthly, which remains negative. In addition, Ms. Davis stated that Dr. Kaludy has<br />
been attending aftercare at One Step on a weekly basis. She pointed out that she had<br />
spoken to Dr. Kaludy regarding <strong>the</strong> staff members that he involved in this matter and<br />
that he stated he has “made amends” and apologized for his behavior. Ms. Davis<br />
indicated that Dr. Kaludy recognizes that he put <strong>the</strong>m in harm’s way, could have gotten<br />
<strong>the</strong>m in a lot of trouble, and that this was a big step for Dr. Kaludy to make in his<br />
recovery.<br />
Upon questioning by <strong>the</strong> Board Dr. Kaludy stated that he felt his recovery was going<br />
well. He stated that since his last appearance he had completed twenty (20) hours of<br />
continuing education in dental ethics with Donna Homenko, R.D.H., Ph.D. and<br />
continues to work on complying with <strong>the</strong> Board’s requirements. Dr. Kaludy informed<br />
<strong>the</strong> Board members that he had been drafting a business plan with a fellow classmate<br />
that would allow both of <strong>the</strong>m to return to practice part-time, three (3) days per week.<br />
He stated that he is excited to get back into practice and anxious to see patients again.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 4<br />
Mr. Readler asked Dr. Kaludy to clarify Ms. Davis’ earlier statement regarding<br />
apologies to his staff and family members. Dr. Kaludy stated that he recognized that his<br />
actions put his staff members, some of whom are family members, in harm’s way and<br />
could have caused <strong>the</strong>m a great deal of trouble by violating <strong>the</strong> law. He stated that he<br />
recognized that he caused <strong>the</strong>se issues and has sincerely apologized to <strong>the</strong>m, as he felt it<br />
difficult to live with himself knowing that he had placed <strong>the</strong>m in harm’s way.<br />
Motion by Dr. Howard, second by Mr. Readler, to reinstate <strong>the</strong> license of<br />
Samuel S. Kaludy, D.D.S. to practice dentistry in <strong>the</strong> <strong>State</strong> of <strong>Ohio</strong> pursuant to<br />
<strong>the</strong> terms set forth in his consent agreement with <strong>the</strong> Board.<br />
Motion carried with one (1) abstention and one (1) opposed.<br />
REVIEW OF CASES WHEREIN NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY<br />
WERE ISSUED AND NO HEARING WAS REQUESTED<br />
Dr. Armstrong turned <strong>the</strong> meeting over to Dr. Hills to conduct <strong>the</strong> evidentiary<br />
reviews. Dr. Hills <strong>the</strong>n stated for <strong>the</strong> record:<br />
“This is an evidentiary review involving dentists and dental hygienists that failed to<br />
renew <strong>the</strong>ir licenses. pursuant to Chapters 119. and 4715. of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code.<br />
The purpose of this proceeding is to give <strong>the</strong> Board information about <strong>the</strong>se matters, in<br />
lieu of <strong>the</strong> Administrative Hearing that would have occurred if <strong>the</strong>se licensees had<br />
requested a hearing. The Board’s minutes will serve as <strong>the</strong> official record of this<br />
proceeding.”<br />
Dr. Hills asked if <strong>the</strong> <strong>State</strong> would like to present any additional information to<br />
support <strong>the</strong> charges outlined in <strong>the</strong> Notices of Immediate Suspension and Opportunity<br />
for Hearing.<br />
Ms. Bockbrader said yes <strong>the</strong>n began by stating that she was introducing an affidavit<br />
for <strong>the</strong> Board’s review and consideration. She stated that <strong>State</strong>’s Exhibit 1 is an affidavit<br />
from Jayne Smith, Licensure Coordinator, dated November 4, 2008, wherein she attests<br />
that <strong>the</strong> following listed licensees failed to renew <strong>the</strong>ir licenses to practice by January 1,<br />
2008 and have not submitted valid renewal application as of <strong>the</strong> date of her sworn<br />
affidavit. Ms. Bockbrader stated that in <strong>the</strong> affidavit, Ms. Smith attests that <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
office has not received any continuing education nor has <strong>the</strong> Board executive office<br />
received any written requests for hearings from <strong>the</strong> following licensees.<br />
Ms. Bockbrader informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>State</strong>’s Exhibit 2 is true and accurate copies<br />
of all <strong>the</strong> Notices of Opportunity for Hearing and signed and dated certified mail
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 5<br />
receipts indicating that each licensee was served with <strong>the</strong>ir respective Notice of<br />
Opportunity for Hearing in <strong>the</strong>se matters.<br />
DENTISTS<br />
Frank J Crocco 30-013058 08-18-0290<br />
Edward R Falkner 30-010578 08-18-0286<br />
Robert P Gardner 30-012008 08-25-0318<br />
David D Hamlar 30-010164 08-25-0316<br />
Kyeongseon Kim 30-022176 08-25-0313<br />
Henry A Maxim 30-013532 08-15-0253<br />
Emmett Millit 30-011049 08-07-0247<br />
Wilbur E Neel 30-010462 08-29-0328<br />
Charles L Ortman 30-010291 08-09-0248<br />
Scott D Pelok 30-020109 08-48-0355<br />
Robert R Price 30-011466 08-41-0340<br />
Shabnam Rahimdashti 30-022434 08-18-0255<br />
Rami Salloum 30-022285 08-87-0408<br />
Thomas L Snodgrass 30-015338 08-41-0341<br />
Brian Stratman 30-022001 08-25-0302<br />
Herbert L White 30-012368 08-25-0326<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS<br />
Susan J Barnett 31-007110 08-18-0276<br />
Sandra R Comes 31-001195 08-48-0361<br />
Betsy Schnell Comtess 31-005396 08-25-0323<br />
Ryan Davis 31-011673 08-21-0294<br />
Hilda Feduik 31-002347 08-72-0385<br />
Julie K Hardesty 31-004058 08-32-0335<br />
Sandra E Hawk 31-004833 08-02-0244<br />
Rhena M Heyman 31-005980 08-39-0338<br />
Peisung Hsu 31-011772 08-25-0314<br />
Angela M Hypes 31-006930 08-57-0374<br />
Deborah A Makosky-Fye 31-008376 08-78-0400<br />
Beverly Miller 31-003162 08-77-0398<br />
Trudy M Palmateer 31-003255 08-48-0356<br />
Carol A Pohlmann 31-001884 08-20-0292<br />
Amandeep Rai 31-011445 08-18-0263<br />
F Mary Roman 31-003512 08-76-0390<br />
Natalie Roner 31-010455 08-25-0305<br />
Donna L Schultz 31-004323 08-57-0372
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 6<br />
Michelle C Whited 31-006403 08-77-0395<br />
Ms. Staley asked for clarification as to whe<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong>se licensees did not respond to any<br />
of <strong>the</strong> Board’s earlier correspondence or if <strong>the</strong> individuals had been offered retirement in<br />
lieu of formal action by <strong>the</strong> Board. Ms. Bockbrader indicated that <strong>the</strong> aforementioned<br />
licensees had not responded in any manner to <strong>the</strong> Board’s Notice of Opportunity for<br />
Hearing as issued.<br />
Ms. Bockbrader <strong>the</strong>n requested that <strong>the</strong> evidence as submitted be admitted into <strong>the</strong><br />
record. Dr. Hills accepted <strong>the</strong> <strong>State</strong>’s Exhibits in this matter and entered <strong>the</strong>m into<br />
evidence.<br />
EXECUTIVE SESSION<br />
Motion by Dr. Howard, second Ms. Staley, to move <strong>the</strong> Board into executive<br />
session pursuant to <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code Section 121.22(G)(1) to deliberate and<br />
consider <strong>the</strong> charges and evidence presented in <strong>the</strong>se matters.<br />
Roll call vote:<br />
Dr. Armstrong – Yes<br />
Dr. Hills – Yes<br />
Dr. Desai – Yes<br />
Dr. Hanners – Yes<br />
Dr. Howard – Yes<br />
Dr. Kaye – Yes<br />
Dr. Kyger - Yes<br />
Dr. Leffler – Yes<br />
Ms. Naber – Yes<br />
Mr. Readler – Yes<br />
Ms. Staley - Yes<br />
Dr. Wallace - Yes<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
OPEN SESSION<br />
The Board resumed open session at 2:12 p.m.<br />
Dr. Hills <strong>the</strong>n stated, “Let <strong>the</strong> record reflect that I, Dr. Edward R. Hills was <strong>the</strong><br />
secretary in <strong>the</strong>se matters, and <strong>the</strong>refore I will abstain from final vote. Fur<strong>the</strong>rmore, I<br />
was not present during executive session and did not participate in <strong>the</strong> deliberations in<br />
<strong>the</strong>se matters.”
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 7<br />
DECISION IN THE MATTER OF AUTOMATICALLY SUSPENDED<br />
DENTISTS AND <strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENISTS FOR NON-RENEWAL OF LICENSURE<br />
Motion by Dr. Howard, second by Ms. Staley, that Count #1 in <strong>the</strong> Notice of<br />
Opportunity for Hearing is found to be true and that it is hereby Ordered that all<br />
licensees in this matter be indefinitely suspended with <strong>the</strong> standard terms and<br />
conditions:<br />
Discussion followed wherein it was decided that <strong>the</strong>re should be terms for<br />
reinstatement of all dental and dental hygiene licenses.<br />
Motion by Ms. Naber, second by Dr. Leffler, to amend <strong>the</strong> motion as follows:<br />
Denists:<br />
Frank J Crocco 30-013058 08-18-0290<br />
Edward R Falkner 30-010578 08-18-0286<br />
Robert P Gardner 30-012008 08-25-0318<br />
David D Hamlar 30-010164 08-25-0316<br />
Kyeongseon Kim 30-022176 08-25-0313<br />
Henry A Maxim 30-013532 08-15-0253<br />
Emmett Millit 30-011049 08-07-0247<br />
Wilbur E Neel 30-010462 08-29-0328<br />
Charles L Ortman 30-010291 08-09-0248<br />
Scott D Pelok 30-020109 08-48-0355<br />
Robert R Price 30-011466 08-41-0340<br />
Shabnam Rahimdashti 30-022434 08-18-0255<br />
Rami Salloum 30-022285 08-87-0408<br />
Thomas L Snodgrass 30-015338 08-41-0341<br />
Brian Stratman 30-022001 08-25-0302<br />
Herbert L White 30-012368 08-25-0326<br />
It is hereby ORDERED,<br />
(1) That <strong>the</strong> license of (LICENSEE) to practice dentistry in <strong>the</strong> state of<br />
<strong>Ohio</strong> is INDEFINITELY SUSPENDED.<br />
a. No one in <strong>the</strong> dental office may perform dentistry or dental hygiene<br />
duties or o<strong>the</strong>rwise treat patients during <strong>the</strong> period of suspension.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 8<br />
b. A receptionist may answer <strong>the</strong> phone with “Dr. (LICENSEE’s) office”,<br />
or <strong>the</strong> name of <strong>the</strong> practice, for <strong>the</strong> sole purpose of answering<br />
questions, scheduling/rescheduling appointments, and making<br />
referrals.<br />
c. The LICENSEE may not receive any income ei<strong>the</strong>r from a legal or<br />
beneficial interest in <strong>the</strong> dental practice during <strong>the</strong> period of<br />
suspension<br />
(2) The <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board shall not consider Reinstatement of <strong>the</strong><br />
LICENSEE’s license to practice unless and until all <strong>the</strong> following<br />
requirements are met:<br />
a. The LICENSEE shall submit a reinstatement application to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
Secretary, complete those requirements set forth <strong>the</strong>rein, and include<br />
all appropriate fees and late fees.<br />
b. The LICENSEE shall submit documentation satisfactory to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
that all continuing education requirements are current and up to date<br />
pursuant to RC 4715.141 (dentists) RC 4715.25 (dental hygienists).<br />
c. The LICENSEE shall take sixteen (16) hours of continuing education<br />
in Ethics, approved in advance by <strong>the</strong> Board Secretary.<br />
d. The LICENSEE shall take and pass <strong>the</strong> Jurisprudence, Ethics and Risk<br />
Management (JERM) Exam administered by <strong>the</strong> North East Regional<br />
Board of Dental Examiners, Inc.<br />
(3) Once reinstated, <strong>the</strong> LICENSEE shall automatically submit<br />
documentation acceptable to <strong>the</strong> Board of satisfactory completion of<br />
<strong>the</strong> requisite hours of Continuing Education necessary for renewal for<br />
<strong>the</strong> next two bienniums. This documentation shall be due in <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
office by November 30 th of <strong>the</strong> odd-numbered year prior to submitting<br />
<strong>the</strong> LICENSEES application for renewal of <strong>the</strong> LICENSEES<br />
dental/dental hygiene license.<br />
This ORDER shall become effective thirty (30) days from <strong>the</strong> date of <strong>the</strong><br />
mailing of this ORDER.<br />
Dental Hygienists:<br />
Susan J Barnett 31-007110 08-18-0276<br />
Sandra R Comes 31-001195 08-48-0361<br />
Betsy Schnell Comtess 31-005396 08-25-0323<br />
Ryan Davis 31-011673 08-21-0294
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 9<br />
Hilda Feduik 31-002347 08-72-0385<br />
Julie K Hardesty 31-004058 08-32-0335<br />
Sandra E Hawk 31-004833 08-02-0244<br />
Rhena M Heyman 31-005980 08-39-0338<br />
Peisung Hsu 31-011772 08-25-0314<br />
Angela M Hypes 31-006930 08-57-0374<br />
Deborah A Makosky-Fye 31-008376 08-78-0400<br />
Beverly Miller 31-003162 08-77-0398<br />
Trudy M Palmateer 31-003255 08-48-0356<br />
Carol A Pohlmann 31-001884 08-20-0292<br />
Amandeep Rai 31-011445 08-18-0263<br />
F Mary Roman 31-003512 08-76-0390<br />
Natalie Roner 31-010455 08-25-0305<br />
Donna L Schultz 31-004323 08-57-0372<br />
Michelle C Whited 31-006403 08-77-0395<br />
It is hereby ORDERED,<br />
(1) That <strong>the</strong> license of LICENSEE to practice dentistry in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong><br />
is INDEFINITELY SUSPENDED.<br />
(2) The <strong>Ohio</strong> <strong>State</strong> Dental Board shall not consider Reinstatement of <strong>the</strong><br />
LICENSEE’s license to practice unless and until all <strong>the</strong> following<br />
requirements are met:<br />
a. The LICENSEE shall submit a reinstatement application to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
Secretary, complete those requirements set forth <strong>the</strong>rein, and include<br />
all appropriate fees and late fees.<br />
b. The LICENSEE shall submit documentation satisfactory to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
that all continuing education requirements are current and up to date<br />
pursuant to RC 4715.141 (dentists) RC 4715.25 (dental hygienists).<br />
c. The LICENSEE shall take sixteen (16) hours of continuing education<br />
in Ethics, approved in advance by <strong>the</strong> Board Secretary.<br />
d. The LICENSEE shall take and pass <strong>the</strong> Jurisprudence, Ethics and Risk<br />
Management (JERM) Exam administered by <strong>the</strong> North East Regional<br />
Board of Dental Examiners, Inc.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 10<br />
(3) Once reinstated, <strong>the</strong> LICENSEE shall automatically submit<br />
documentation acceptable to <strong>the</strong> Board of satisfactory completion of<br />
<strong>the</strong> requisite hours of Continuing Education necessary for renewal for<br />
<strong>the</strong> next two bienniums. This documentation shall be due in <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
office by November 30 th of <strong>the</strong> odd-numbered year prior to submitting<br />
<strong>the</strong> LICENSEES application for renewal of <strong>the</strong> LICENSEES<br />
dental/dental hygiene license.<br />
This ORDER shall become effective thirty (30) days from <strong>the</strong> date of <strong>the</strong><br />
mailing of this ORDER.<br />
Motion carried<br />
Dr. Armstrong <strong>the</strong>n called <strong>the</strong> question on <strong>the</strong> amended motion.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED MOTIONS<br />
Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Dr. Kyger, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />
automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for <strong>the</strong> Mikala<br />
Genrich, D.D.S., license number 30-022146, case number 08-25-0317.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice(s)<br />
of automatic suspension and notice(s) of opportunity for hearing for Donald H.<br />
Harpster, D.D.S., license number 30-012022, case number 08-48-0363.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice(s)<br />
of automatic suspension and notice(s) of opportunity for hearing for Finn F.<br />
L’Orange, D.D.S., license number 30-00-8548, case number 08-18-0257.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />
automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for Charles L.<br />
Ortmann, D.D.S., license number 30-008548, case number 08-09-0248.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 11<br />
Motion carried.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Mr. Readler, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />
automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for Mark B. Soller,<br />
D.D.S., license number 30-017422, case number 08-50-0364.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to rescind <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />
automatic suspension and notice of opportunity for hearing for Brian A. Stern,<br />
D.D.S., license number 30-022067, case number 07-23-0579.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY SURRENDER(S)<br />
The Board reviewed one (1) proposed voluntary surrender. The name of <strong>the</strong><br />
individual/licensee was not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board. The name<br />
of <strong>the</strong> individual/licensee has been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public notice purposes.<br />
Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed voluntary<br />
surrender of license for Christina V. Dauka, R.D.H., license number 31-00-3779,<br />
case number 08-89-0100.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED VOLUNTARY RETIREMENT(S)<br />
The Board reviewed twelve (12) proposed voluntary retirement(s). The names of <strong>the</strong><br />
individuals/licensees were not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board. The<br />
names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees have been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public notice<br />
purposes.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed<br />
voluntary retirements for <strong>the</strong> following licensees:<br />
Gavin M. Aaron, D.D.S. 30021842 08-25-0312<br />
Ashley Cornils, D.D.S. 30022120 08-19-0291<br />
Donald R. Curtis, D.D.S. 30015736 08-48-0360<br />
Linda L. Dugan, R.D.H. 31006057 08-02-0420<br />
Roger S. Ely, D.D.S. 30010408 08-86-0406<br />
Mary P. Fandrey, R.D.H. 31005302 08-48-0352
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 12<br />
Anneliese Haws, D.D.S. 30022307 08-25-0315<br />
Michael B. Jones, D.D.S. 30022427 08-18-0266<br />
Sheila Lall, D.D.S. 30022177 08-25-0310<br />
J. Perry Royston, D.D.S. 30020846 08-09-0249<br />
Susan F. Urell, R.D.H. 31006593 08-25-0301<br />
Douglas Vrudny, D.D.S. 30013018 08-57-0370<br />
Motion carried.<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED CONSENT AGREEMENT(S)<br />
The Board reviewed twelve (12) proposed consent agreements. The names of <strong>the</strong><br />
individuals/licensees were not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board. The<br />
names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees have been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public notice<br />
purposes.<br />
DISCIPLINARY<br />
JEFFREY J. BECKER, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Jeffrey J. Becker, D.D.S., license number 30-018193, case number<br />
07-22-0420.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
ROBERT E. BURNS, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Staley, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Robert E. Burns, D.D.S., license number 30-018900, case number<br />
08-25-0528.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
HECTOR A. CABALLERO, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kaye, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Hector A. Caballero, D.D.S., license number 30-019517, case<br />
number 06-89-0418.<br />
Motion carried.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 13<br />
WILLIAM H. CARDWELL, JR., D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for William H. Cardwell, Jr., D.D.S., license number 30-015816, case<br />
number 07-45-0603.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
MARK DEVINCENZO, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Desai, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Mark DeVincenzo, D.D.S., license number 30-017327, case<br />
number 08-57-0568.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
STACEY M. HARRIS, R.D.H.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Staley, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Stacey M. Harris, R.D.H., license number 31-010689, case number<br />
08-57-0422.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
BERNARD J. JOHNSON, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Howard, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed<br />
consent agreement for Bernard J. Johnson, D.D.S., license number 30-013689,<br />
case number 08-76-0437.<br />
Motion carried. Bill abstained<br />
RICHARD LAPP, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Desai, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Richard Lapp, D.D.S., license number 30-011423, case number 07-<br />
60-0355.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 14<br />
Motion carried with two (2) abstention.<br />
LINCOLN W. LAWRENCE, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Lincoln W. Lawrence, D.D.S., license number 30-015242, case<br />
number 06-46-0816.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
TRACEY PATRIARCA, R.D.H.<br />
Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Tracey Patriarca, R.D.H., license number 31-008921, case number<br />
08-89-0467.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
GARY L. WARREN, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Gary L. Warren, D.D.S., license number 30-014584, case number<br />
08-25-0425.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
NON-DISCIPLINARY<br />
RAJESH GUTTA, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed consent<br />
agreement for Rajesh Gutta, D.D.S., license number 30-022922.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
REVIEW OF PROPOSED NOTICE(S) OF OPPORTUNITY<br />
The Board reviewed three (3) proposed notices of opportunity for hearing. The<br />
names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees were not included in <strong>the</strong> documents reviewed by <strong>the</strong>
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 15<br />
Board. The names of <strong>the</strong> individuals/licensees have been added to <strong>the</strong> minutes for public<br />
notice purposes.<br />
CHARLES L. DIPASQUALE, D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed notice of<br />
opportunity for hearing and forward it to Charles DiPasquale, D.D.S., license<br />
number 30-014427, and case numbers 07-57-0528, 07-57-0554, and 08-57-0118.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
BRENDA L. WILCOX, R.D.H.<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed notice<br />
of opportunity for hearing and forward it to Brenda L. Wilcox, R.D.H., license<br />
number 31-008690, and case number 08-33-0426.<br />
Motion carried with one abstention.<br />
MALCOLM WALTERS, JR., D.D.S.<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> proposed notice<br />
of opportunity for hearing and forward it to Malcolm Walters, Jr., D.D.S., license<br />
number 30-020238, and case number 05-18-0296 Amended.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
ENFORCEMENT UPDATE<br />
Mr. Yonadi informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong>re were five (5) cases pending hearings, of<br />
which all have been assigned for hearing and that we still have five (5) cases under<br />
appeal. Mr. Yonadi stated that <strong>the</strong>re are currently twenty-five (25) licensees under<br />
suspension. He informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that we have five (5) cases still pending<br />
QUIP with one (1) additional licensee entering into QUIP.<br />
Mr. Yonadi informed <strong>the</strong> Board that Forty-eight (48) cases have been investigated<br />
and reviewed by <strong>the</strong> Board Secretary and are recommended to be closed.<br />
Due to <strong>the</strong> requirement in Chapter 4715.03(D) of <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Revised Code, that "The<br />
board shall not dismiss any complaint or terminate any investigation except by a
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 16<br />
majority vote of its members,..." Mr. Yonadi reviewed <strong>the</strong> cases to be closed with <strong>the</strong><br />
Board.<br />
The following cases are recommended to be closed:<br />
07-25-0096 Standard Of Care<br />
07-25-0174 Standard Of Care<br />
08-09-0533 Standard Of Care<br />
08-09-0563 Standard Of Care<br />
08-12-0498 Standard Of Care/<br />
Misrepresentation<br />
08-13-0529 Conduct/Standard<br />
08-13-0535 Standard/Conduct<br />
08-14-0508 Standard Of Care<br />
08-18-0168 Standard Of Care/<br />
Dentures<br />
08-18-0453 Policy/Standard Of<br />
Care<br />
08-18-0463 Standard/Misrep<br />
08-18-0488 Denture<br />
08-18-0503 Records-Warning<br />
08-18-0504 Standard Of Care<br />
08-18-0510 Behavior<br />
08-25-0211 Standard Of Care/<br />
Conduct<br />
08-25-0228 Adverse Occurrence<br />
08-25-0512 Standard Of Care<br />
08-30-0497 Standard Of Care<br />
08-31-0479 Standard Of Care<br />
08-31-0480 Standard Of Care<br />
08-31-0482 Standard Of Care<br />
08-31-0483 Advertising<br />
08-31-0527 Dentures<br />
08-31-0530 Standard Of Care<br />
08-31-0531 Adverse Occurrence<br />
08-31-0547 Standard Of Care/<br />
Conduct<br />
08-31-0562 Standard Of Care/<br />
Dentures<br />
08-35-0053 Standard Of Care<br />
08-43-0490 Adverse Occurrence<br />
08-45-0494 Standard/Dentures<br />
08-48-0153 Standard Of Care<br />
08-50-0179 Records<br />
08-57-0216 Standard Of Care/<br />
Warning<br />
08-57-0474 Misrepresentation<br />
08-57-0475 Standard Of Care<br />
08-57-0481 Standard Of Care<br />
08-57-0532 Standard Of Care<br />
08-57-0549 Standard Of Care<br />
08-57-0553 Standard Of Care<br />
08-73-0511 Dentures<br />
08-76-0444 Conduct/Drugs<br />
08-77-0059 Standard Of Care/<br />
Warning<br />
08-77-0476 Standard Of Care<br />
08-77-0499 Impairment/Conduct<br />
08-77-0513 Abandement<br />
08-78-0485 Standard Of Care/<br />
Abandonment<br />
08-83-0478 Outside Scope<br />
Prior to <strong>the</strong> vote to close <strong>the</strong> above listed cases, Dr. Armstrong inquired as to whe<strong>the</strong>r<br />
any of <strong>the</strong> Board members had any personal knowledge that <strong>the</strong> cases that were being<br />
voted on today involve ei<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong>mselves or a personal friend.<br />
Roll call:<br />
Dr. Armstrong – No<br />
Dr. Hills – Abstain<br />
Dr. Desai – No<br />
Dr. Hanners – No
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 17<br />
Dr. Howard – Abstain<br />
Dr. Kaye – No<br />
Dr. Kyger - No<br />
Dr. Leffler – No<br />
Ms. Naber – No<br />
Mr. Readler – No<br />
Ms. Staley – No<br />
Dr. Wallace - No<br />
Dr. Armstrong <strong>the</strong>n called for a motion to close <strong>the</strong> cases.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Staley, to close <strong>the</strong> above forty-eight (48)<br />
cases.<br />
Roll call vote:<br />
Dr. Armstrong – Yes<br />
Dr. Hills – Abstain<br />
Dr. Desai – Yes<br />
Dr. Hanners – Yes<br />
Dr. Howard – Abstain<br />
Dr. Kaye – Yes<br />
Dr. Kyger - Yes<br />
Dr. Leffler – Yes<br />
Ms. Naber – Yes<br />
Mr. Readler – Yes<br />
Ms. Staley – Yes<br />
Dr. Wallace - Yes<br />
Motion carried.<br />
REVIEW OF LICENSE APPLICATIONS<br />
LICENSURE REPORT<br />
Jayne Smith, Licensure Coordinator, had prepared a report of <strong>the</strong> licenses issued since<br />
<strong>the</strong> September 2008 meeting, for Board member review.<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong><br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />
for <strong>the</strong> following dental licenses issued by North East Regional Board, Inc.<br />
(NERB) examination:
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
AUGUST 13, 2008 PAGE 18<br />
Andrew N. Amborski<br />
Serjio R. Arias<br />
Karen R. Coe<br />
Kristen A. Darville<br />
Nazik H. Elrayah<br />
Shirley S. Ferreira<br />
Mona A. Gokani<br />
Anne V. Gormley<br />
Joseph B. Grubler<br />
Meghan M. Hajduch<br />
Suparna A. Mahalaha<br />
Ka<strong>the</strong>rine E. Miller<br />
Giulia M. Pagano<br />
Holly H. Park-Nah<br />
Siddhi R. Patel<br />
Carlos Pires<br />
Pedro A. Rodriguez<br />
Troy A. Rogers<br />
Elliot P. Schlang<br />
Sharon T. Schmeiser<br />
Robert S. Schneider<br />
Michael C. Sivik<br />
Michael A. Sullivan<br />
William F. Traynor<br />
Amber M. Weidner<br />
Hee-Jin Yang<br />
John D. Young<br />
Ruth A. Youngquist<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Dr. Wallace, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />
for <strong>the</strong> following dental hygiene licenses issued by North East Regional Board,<br />
Inc. (NERB) examination:<br />
Nicole L. Beasley<br />
Ellen F. Cielenski<br />
Amanda J. Coss<br />
Ashley N. Dilworth<br />
Kristen R. Gutschow<br />
Robin D. Kochur<br />
Nicole B. Lahaye<br />
Ashley P. Lloyd<br />
LaTesha S. Moore<br />
Justina M. Reutepohler<br />
Kimberly L. Siburt<br />
Tina L. Troy-White<br />
Amber M. Uhrig<br />
Stephanie A. Urban<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> ASSISTANT RADIOGRAPHER<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Ms. Staley, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />
for <strong>the</strong> following dental assistant radiographer licenses issued by: acceptable<br />
certification or licensure in ano<strong>the</strong>r state, certification by <strong>the</strong> Dental Assisting<br />
National Board (DANB) or <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Commission on Dental Assistant<br />
Certification (OCDAC), or successful completion of <strong>the</strong> Board-approved<br />
Radiography course:
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 19<br />
Stephanie Ambrose<br />
Sarah Arrighi<br />
Marianne Ashman<br />
Erin Aufmuth<br />
Danyel Aurand<br />
Katie Austin<br />
Yasmeen Badgett<br />
Kelly Basso<br />
Hope Baumbach<br />
Michelle Black<br />
Jessica Blair<br />
Jaimi Boldman<br />
Teresa Bounce<br />
Lisa Bowers<br />
Trisha Brenton<br />
Mariya Bryant<br />
Tammy Bullard<br />
Marjorie Campbell<br />
Tina Campbell<br />
Holly Candle<br />
Brittanie Card<br />
Naomi Constanty<br />
Shuzhen Cui<br />
Frances Daugherty<br />
Erica Dobberstein<br />
Dahkibra Draper<br />
Cecily Earls<br />
Mina Eskander<br />
Maria Evegan<br />
Merrilee Ewing<br />
Maria Federico<br />
Codi Flower<br />
Nicole Gamble<br />
Helen Garen<br />
Megan Gehring<br />
Judith Gibson<br />
Sarah Golembiewski<br />
Leah Gooden<br />
Snieguole Goson<br />
Jessica Gray<br />
Deborah Grazel<br />
Tiffany Grove<br />
Kasha Grubbs<br />
Susan Hacker<br />
Nicole Hammer<br />
Jennifer Hanus<br />
Patricia Hartley<br />
Christina Hayes<br />
Coralie Hea<strong>the</strong>rly<br />
Shayna Henry<br />
Courtney Hudson<br />
Bernice Johnson<br />
Courtney Johnson<br />
Lakeisha Johnson<br />
Nicole Joy<br />
Adam Kapis<br />
Tiffany Keegan<br />
Carrie Kill<br />
Rebecca Kretzer<br />
Tracie Martin<br />
Shellie Ma<strong>the</strong>ney<br />
Susan Maximo<br />
Candance McKinley<br />
Tasha McPeek<br />
Samir Merchant<br />
Melissa Moore<br />
Darnell Morgan<br />
Mitzi Mueller-Kreis<br />
Suzanne O'connor<br />
Crystal Patrick<br />
Tiffany Pawlowski<br />
Melanie Pearsall<br />
Rene Perez<br />
Michelle Poch<br />
Rendie Pohl<br />
Lauren Politowicz<br />
Brittany Porter<br />
Chantee Provitt<br />
Jamie Rapp<br />
Karen Reeves<br />
Modjeska Richards<br />
Holly Richmond<br />
Cynthia Riggs<br />
Franko Rivera-Sierra
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 20<br />
Katie Roark<br />
Angelica Roman<br />
Nassren Saad<br />
Amannda Sawyer<br />
Misty Sergent<br />
Amanda Shaw<br />
Donna Shrock<br />
Amanda Siliko<br />
Ashley Siwek<br />
Michelle Streets<br />
Lakisha Sutton<br />
Brittany Thies<br />
Connie Thompson<br />
Erika Torres<br />
Maria Valentin<br />
Natalie Verboon<br />
Arrolla Wagner<br />
Jennifer Walls<br />
Juliene Walls<br />
Kerrie Wells<br />
Lisa West<br />
Jesssica Williams<br />
Sarah Williams<br />
Terra Wi<strong>the</strong>rspoon<br />
Shannon Witt<br />
Staci Wolf<br />
Charlotte Workman<br />
Gina Young<br />
Sharron Yowell<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
CORONAL POLISHING<br />
Motion Ms. Staley, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report for<br />
<strong>the</strong> following coronal polishing certificates issued by: certification by <strong>the</strong> Dental<br />
Assisting National Board (DANB) or <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong> Commission on Dental Assistant<br />
Certification (OCDAC) and completion of <strong>the</strong> requirements necessary to obtain<br />
certification:<br />
Logan U. Abrahamson<br />
David M. Achille<br />
Shannon C. Armstrong<br />
Tammy Brodman<br />
Maria A. DuPonty<br />
Cashimera B. Harvey<br />
Angela Kinson<br />
Michelle L. Lehman<br />
Bonny L. McPherson<br />
Theresa M. Oder<br />
Brenda L. Omerzo<br />
Susan A. Rusu<br />
Erin D. Seidenschmidt<br />
Kerrymarie L. Tedesco<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
EXPANED FUNCTION <strong>DENTAL</strong> AUXILIARY<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Desai, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure report<br />
for <strong>the</strong> following expanded function dental auxiliary registrations issued by:<br />
certification by <strong>the</strong> Dental Assisting National Board (DANB) or <strong>the</strong> <strong>Ohio</strong>
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 21<br />
Commission on Dental Assistant Certification (OCDAC) and completion of <strong>the</strong><br />
requirements necessary to obtain registration:<br />
Jessica R Agee<br />
Myling Bonilla<br />
Kathy Y Bruning<br />
Latisha A Collins<br />
Alisha R Dixon<br />
Ann G Durst<br />
Kristen A Farnsworth<br />
Trisha Gable<br />
Mindy Gessner<br />
Amy Jo Glandon<br />
Brandy Goetz<br />
Dawn N Hacker<br />
Dawn M Jones<br />
Kelly Laird<br />
Nicole D Marks<br />
Jarrod D Mihalic<br />
Jocelyn Moreford<br />
Nicole L. Myers<br />
Brenda L Omerzo<br />
Eileen M Remllong<br />
Tammie M Ridgway<br />
Priscilla A Ross<br />
Diana M Sprague<br />
Alisa A Wenger<br />
Connie Kane Wojcik<br />
Nicole D Worley<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
GRADUATE OF UNACCREDITED <strong>DENTAL</strong> COLLEGE LOCATED OUTSIDE<br />
THE UNITED <strong>STATE</strong>S LICENSE APPLICATION(S)<br />
Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> licensure<br />
application for dental license issued by graduation from an unaccredited dental<br />
college located outside <strong>the</strong> United <strong>State</strong>s for Rajesh Gutta, D.D.S.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
REIN<strong>STATE</strong>MENT LICENSE APPLICATION(S) – NO INTERVIEW<br />
COLLEEN C. FEIST, R.D.H.<br />
The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Colleen C. Feist,<br />
R.D.H. that was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Staley, to approve Ms. Feist’s<br />
reinstatement application for dental hygiene licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />
Motion carried unanimously.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 22<br />
CAROLYN C. JACKSON, R.D.H.<br />
The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Carolyn C. Jackson,<br />
R.D.H., which was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Naber, to approve Ms. Jackson’s<br />
reinstatement application for dental hygiene licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
NOEL P. PATTON, D.D.S.<br />
The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Noel P. Patton,<br />
D.D.S., which was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kaye, second by Dr. Leffler, to approve Dr. Patton’s<br />
reinstatement application for dental licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
KIMBERLY A. RICHARDS, R.D.H.<br />
The Board reviewed and considered <strong>the</strong> licensure information for Kimberly A.<br />
Richards, R.D.H., which was prepared by Ms. Smith.<br />
Motion by Ms. Staley, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve Ms. Richards’<br />
reinstatement application for dental hygiene licensure in <strong>the</strong> state of <strong>Ohio</strong>.<br />
Motion carried unanimously.<br />
ANESTHESIA COMMITTEE REPORT<br />
REVIEW OF PROVISIONAL CONSCIOUS SEDATION<br />
PRIVILEGE(S)<br />
Dr. Wallace stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals have applied for Conscious Sedation<br />
permits. He explained that <strong>the</strong> Anes<strong>the</strong>sia Committee has reviewed <strong>the</strong> applications and<br />
<strong>the</strong> applicants are recommended to receive provisional privileges:<br />
Dr. Kapil Davar – Sylvania, <strong>Ohio</strong><br />
- Oral for children 12 years or younger<br />
Dr. Ronald D. Fowler – Columbus, <strong>Ohio</strong>
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 23<br />
- Intravenous<br />
Dr. John Segnini – Columbus, <strong>Ohio</strong><br />
- Intravenous<br />
REVIEW OF CONSCIOUS SEDATION PERMIT APPLICATION(S)<br />
Dr. Wallace stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals have applied for Conscious Sedation<br />
permits. He explained that <strong>the</strong> Anes<strong>the</strong>sia Committee has reviewed <strong>the</strong> applications,<br />
evaluations have been performed and <strong>the</strong> applicants are recommended to receive<br />
conscious sedation permits:<br />
Dr. Martha G. Dever<br />
- Intravenous<br />
Dr. Scott A. Kelley<br />
- Intravenous<br />
Dr. Michael P. Nedley<br />
- Non-intravenous parenteral<br />
Dr. Adam M. Pollock<br />
- Oral for children 12 years or younger<br />
Motion by Dr. Leffler, second by Ms. Naber, to accept <strong>the</strong> Anes<strong>the</strong>sia<br />
Committee recommendations and approve <strong>the</strong> above applicants to receive<br />
privileges.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
EDUCATION COMMITTEE REPORT<br />
REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR<br />
APPLICATION(S)<br />
Dr. Howard stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals/organizations have applied for<br />
approval as biennial sponsors of continuing education for <strong>the</strong> years 2008-2009 and have<br />
been recommended for approval by <strong>the</strong> Education Committee:<br />
Dutton Dental Concepts, Inc.<br />
Matia, D.D.S., M.S.D., James I.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 24<br />
REVIEW OF BIENNIAL CONTINUING EDUCATION SPONSOR<br />
RENEWAL APPLICATION(S)<br />
Dr. Howard stated that <strong>the</strong> following individuals/organizations have applied for<br />
approval as biennial sponsors of continuing education for <strong>the</strong> years 2008-2009 and have<br />
been recommended for approval by <strong>the</strong> Education Committee:<br />
Eagle-Pyramid Seminars (formerly Eagle Clinical Dentistry Seminars)<br />
Heights Dental Study Club<br />
Malcmacher, D.D.S., M.A.G.D., Louis<br />
Palermo-Edwards and Cacchillo, D.D.S., Inc.<br />
Seattle Study Club of Akron<br />
West Shore Dental Study Club<br />
REVIEW OF REQUIRED TRAINING COURSE(S)<br />
<strong>DENTAL</strong> HYGIENE MEDICAL EMERGENCY COURSE(S)<br />
Dr. Howard informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong> following sponsor has submitted an<br />
application for <strong>the</strong> dental hygiene medical emergency course. She stated that <strong>the</strong><br />
Education Committee has reviewed <strong>the</strong> course, determined that it fulfills all <strong>the</strong><br />
necessary requirements, and has recommended <strong>the</strong> following for approval:<br />
West Liberty <strong>State</strong> College, Dental Hygiene :Program<br />
“Medical Emergencies in <strong>the</strong> Dental Office: Prevention, Recognition, and<br />
Management” by Michael Mermigas, R.Ph., D.D.S.<br />
REVIEW OF SPECIAL REQUEST(S)<br />
CONTINUING EDUCATION COURSE CONSIDERATION REQUEST(S)<br />
Dr. Howard informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong> Education Committee had received requests<br />
from licensees for review and consideration of dental and/or dental hygiene continuing<br />
education for <strong>the</strong> following course:<br />
Institute for Natural Resources<br />
“Cerebral Dominance – The Left and Right Brain”<br />
Dr. Howard informed <strong>the</strong> Board that <strong>the</strong> Committee had <strong>the</strong> opportunity to review<br />
<strong>the</strong>se courses and <strong>the</strong>ir content and recommends that <strong>the</strong>se courses be denied based on<br />
<strong>the</strong> guidelines set forth in Board statute, rule and policy.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 25<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to accept <strong>the</strong> Education<br />
Committees recommendations and approve all <strong>the</strong> above applications.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
LAW AND RULES REVIEW COMMITTEE REPORT<br />
Dr. Armstrong informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that <strong>the</strong> Law and Rules Review<br />
Committee met earlier that day to review changes to <strong>the</strong> infection control rules that had<br />
been recommended by Dental Board Enforcement Officer, Kathy Carson. He stated that<br />
all proposed recommended changes would be prepared and presented to <strong>the</strong> committee<br />
and <strong>the</strong> full Board at its January meeting for consideration and possible vote for filing.<br />
SECRETARY'S EXPENSE REPORT<br />
Dr. Hills attested to <strong>the</strong> Board that he had spent in excess of twenty (20) hours per<br />
week attending to Board business.<br />
Motion by Dr. Kyger, second by Ms. Naber, to approve <strong>the</strong> Secretary's expense<br />
report.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
OFFICE EXPENSE REPORT<br />
The report of <strong>the</strong> Board expenditures was reviewed.<br />
Motion by Dr. Wallace, second by Dr. Kyger, to approve <strong>the</strong> expense report<br />
and approve payment of <strong>the</strong> September, 2008 Board bills.<br />
Motion carried.<br />
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S REPORT<br />
AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> ADMINISTRATORS/<br />
AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF <strong>DENTAL</strong> EXAMINERS <strong>MEETING</strong>S<br />
Ms. Reitz informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that she has been really busy, including<br />
presentations she has been making to <strong>the</strong> dental societies and dental groups. Since <strong>the</strong><br />
Annual meetings in San Antonio, she has not had time to prepare her report from <strong>the</strong>
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 26<br />
American Association of Dental Administrators/American Association of Dental<br />
Examiners meeting held in mid-October. She did note that she had one announcement<br />
she wished to share with <strong>the</strong> Board members. Ms. Reitz explained that one of <strong>the</strong> goals<br />
of AADA in her term as President was to ask AADE to consider permitting a Dental<br />
Board administrator to be represented on <strong>the</strong> AADE Executive Committee in an advisory<br />
capacity. She was happy to note that for <strong>the</strong> first time in AADE history <strong>the</strong>y have<br />
chosen to appoint her to <strong>the</strong> Executive Committee as <strong>the</strong>ir newly appointed Dental<br />
Board Administrative Member.<br />
Ms. Reitz informed <strong>the</strong> Board members that she would be attending her first retreat<br />
in this capacity in South Dakota during <strong>the</strong> first weekend in December.<br />
ANYTHING FOR THE GOOD OF THE <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
ELECTION OF OFFICERS<br />
Ms. Naber requested that Board return to <strong>the</strong> tabled motion regarding election of<br />
officers. Discussion ensued wherein it was determined that <strong>the</strong> Board had decided to<br />
hold its election of officers during its November meeting with <strong>the</strong> elected officers<br />
positions becoming effective beginning in January 2009. Dr. Armstrong <strong>the</strong>n opened <strong>the</strong><br />
floor for nominations.<br />
Dr. Hills nominated Dr. Armstrong for President, Dr. Kyger for Vice President, Dr.<br />
Howard for Secretary, and Dr. Leffler for Vice Secretary.<br />
Dr. Armstrong asked if <strong>the</strong>re were any o<strong>the</strong>r nominations. Noting that <strong>the</strong>re were<br />
none he stated that as such <strong>the</strong> nominations were closed. Additionally, he stated that<br />
<strong>the</strong>refore that by acclamation <strong>the</strong> slate holds unopposed.<br />
Board members expressed <strong>the</strong>ir congratulations to <strong>the</strong> newly appointed officers.<br />
UPDATED <strong>BOARD</strong> ROSTER<br />
Ms. Reitz distributed a revised version of <strong>the</strong> Board Roster and requested each Board<br />
member to review <strong>the</strong>ir information for correctness and to inform her of any additional<br />
changes.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 27<br />
COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENTS<br />
Dr. Armstrong distributed copies of <strong>the</strong> new committee assignments to <strong>the</strong> Board<br />
members for <strong>the</strong>ir review. He requested all members to review <strong>the</strong>ir new committee<br />
assignments to note any changes. Following a brief discussion, it was decided that <strong>the</strong><br />
committee appointments would begin for <strong>the</strong> December meeting of <strong>the</strong> Board.
<strong>OHIO</strong> <strong>STATE</strong> <strong>DENTAL</strong> <strong>BOARD</strong><br />
<strong>BOARD</strong> <strong>MEETING</strong> MINUTES<br />
NOVEMBER 5, 2008 PAGE 28<br />
ADJOURN<br />
Dr. Armstrong adjourned <strong>the</strong> meeting at 3:03 p.m. He stated that <strong>the</strong> next meeting<br />
would be on December 3, 2008.<br />
Mark T. Armstrong, D.D.S.<br />
Vice-President and Acting Chair<br />
Edward R. Hills, D.D.S.<br />
Secretary