03.05.2015 Views

o_19kdfsn0q18e31dfraas1esh19vta.pdf

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

saddled with innumerable compulsions and phobias.<br />

Believe it or not, the show Monk is actually a comedy. It turns out that when you combine a<br />

miserable, life-crippling disability with an INTJ's sense of humor, independent spirit, and<br />

stubbornness, it isn't nearly as gloomy as you would expect. Much of the humor in the show<br />

derives from Monk's persistence in attempting to conform the outside world to his inner vision of<br />

orthogonal perfection.<br />

• He would notice that the odometer read 999999 and try to get it to 1000000 by driving back<br />

and forth, back and forth...while on a stakeout.<br />

• He hurt his hand and had to get a bandage. So then he got a second bandage on his other<br />

hand so that they would be symmetrical.<br />

• When you vacuum the carpet, it leaves lines behind. For Monk, it was important that the<br />

lines be straight and form 90º angles to the walls.<br />

• Once, when trying to rescue his brother from a burning house, he paused, coughing on<br />

smoke, to straighten some disarrayed books.<br />

• He separated his foods and ate them from different plates.<br />

It might seem like there was nothing good about Monk's problems. However, this tells only half of<br />

the story; in fact, the same traits that fueled his OCPD also fueled his detective abilities. Monk<br />

always described his situation with the statement, "It's a gift...and a curse," because the same<br />

powers that enabled him to do great detective work also formed the basis of his OCD/OCDC. The<br />

gift vs. curse dilemma is a theme in type and mental health.<br />

Detecting Style<br />

Monk had a highly intuitive detection style. He was particularly noted for being able to see<br />

connections between things that seemed on the surface to be unrelated. For instance, he would<br />

observe that someone who was tall committed a crime in one area, then connect this fact to that<br />

another, much different crime was committed by a tall man in a different area. The sensing police<br />

would point out to him that there were tons of tall criminals in the world, and that was a connection<br />

between the two crimes was improbable. But to Monk's intuition, this was enough to go on.<br />

In another case, he believed that a murderer was trying to prevent him from connecting two<br />

disparate articles in a newspaper which could incriminate when put together. As Monk speculated,<br />

"He [the murderer] knew I was the only one who could possibly see the connection between them."<br />

(The newspaper theory turned out to be spurious, but Monk actually did solve several other,<br />

unrelated crimes by studying the paper.) On another occasion, he figured out that two very different<br />

murders were connected because the serial numbers on the dollar bills used in each murder were<br />

sequential. His intuitive ability to make connections was a key part of his detection abilities.<br />

Yet, seemingly in contradiction to this, he also noted minute physical details, i.e. the serial numbers.<br />

One of the arguments one often hears in discussions over the type of famous detectives is, "They<br />

can't be an intuitive because they notice details." This is true, to an extent; Hennessy (1999) noted<br />

that sensor police officers tend to be better at collecting evidence at a crime scene than intuitive<br />

officers. However, a Rational will notice whatever they have trained themselves to look for in order<br />

to pursue their current subject of interest. I, a geologically trained intuitive, can see all kinds of<br />

things in a rock that an average sensor would not notice. An intuitive archaeologist will notice<br />

details like a dead fly lying behind the door of a tomb because these details hold significance when<br />

placed in the context of a larger body of knowledge. Such "details" do not seem like the purview of

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!