阅读全文请下载PDF文档
阅读全文请下载PDF文档 阅读全文请下载PDF文档
Ξ : Ramsey , , : , , , , , , , : Ramsey , , ( 100029) ; , 1 1960 1980 2000 GDP , , , , , ? , Acemoglu , , , , , , 94 Ξ , , , , Daron Acemoglu , I nt roduction to Modern Economic Grow th , Princeton NJ : Princeton University Press , 2008 , p . 155. © 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
- Page 2 and 3: 1 GDP : ( Kernet Estimation) : Da
- Page 4 and 5: , , Ramsey , , , , , , , Ram
- Page 6 and 7: ; , , 1 , , ; , 0 , , () ,
- Page 8 and 9: Ramsey Ljungqvist Sargent , Ramsey
- Page 10 and 11: , , , , , , , Ramsey , , R
- Page 12 and 13: , Ramsey , , = , = , , , , : , z
- Page 14 and 15: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
- Page 16: 2010 3 monopoly industries into ju
Ξ<br />
<br />
: Ramsey , <br />
, : , <br />
, <br />
, , , <br />
, , <br />
<br />
: Ramsey <br />
, , ( 100029) ; <br />
, <br />
<br />
1 1960 1980 2000 <br />
GDP ,<br />
<br />
<br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
? , Acemoglu , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, <br />
94<br />
Ξ , <br />
, , <br />
, <br />
Daron Acemoglu , I nt roduction to Modern Economic Grow th , Princeton NJ : Princeton University Press ,<br />
2008 , p . 155.<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
1 GDP <br />
: ( Kernet Estimation) <br />
: Daron Acemoglu , I nt roduction to Modern Economic Growth , p . 4 ; A. Heston , Robert Summers and Bettina<br />
Aten , Penn W orl d Tables V ersion 611 , Center for International Comparisons , University of Pennsylvania , 2004.<br />
Acemoglu , ,<br />
Acemoglu , <br />
Acemoglu , , <br />
, , <br />
, <br />
, , <br />
<br />
, <br />
, <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
<br />
Daron Acemoglu , I nt roduction to Modern Economic Grow th , p . 157.<br />
Daron Acemoglu , Simon Johnson and James Robinson , The Colonial Origins of Comparative<br />
Development : An Empirical Investigation ," A merican Economic Review , vol. 91 , no. 5 , 2001 , pp. 13692<br />
1401 ; Daron Acemoglu , Simon Johnson and James Robinson , Reversal of Fortune : Geography and<br />
Institutions in the Making of the Modern World Income Distribution ," Quarterl y J ournal of Economics ,<br />
vol. 117 , no. 4 , 2002 , pp. 123121294 ; Daron Acemoglu , Simon Johnson and James Robinson ,<br />
Institutions as a Fundamental Cause of Long2run Growth ," in P. Aghion and S. Durlauf , eds. ,<br />
H andbook of Economic Grow th , Amsterdam : North Holland , 2005 , pp . 3842473.<br />
:: , : , 1994 , 28 <br />
29 ; J ustin Yifu Lin , Development Strategy , Viability , and Economic Convergence ,"<br />
95<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net<br />
Economic<br />
Development and Cultural Change , vol. 51 , no. 2 , 2003 , pp . 2772308 ; J ustin Yifu Lin , Development<br />
and Transition : Idea , Strategy and Viability ," Working Paper Series , No. E 2007007 , China Center for<br />
Economic Research , Peking University , 2007 , pp. 18225.
2010 3 <br />
Ramsey , <br />
, ,<br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, <br />
<br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, , <br />
, , , , <br />
, <br />
<br />
, <br />
, , <br />
; , <br />
, , , <br />
,<br />
<br />
, Ramsey , <br />
Ramsey , Stackelberg <br />
, , <br />
, , Ramsey ,<br />
, , <br />
, <br />
:: ,2008 4 ; <br />
M. Daniel Westbrook and James Tybout , Estimating Returns to Scale with Large Imperfect Panels : An<br />
96<br />
: , 2008 8 ; Robert Baldwin , The Case against Infant2<br />
industry Tariff Protection ," J ournal of Political Economy , vol. 77 , no. 3 , 1969 , pp. 2952305 ; Barbara<br />
Spencer and James Brander , International R &D Rivalry and Industrial Strategy ," Review of Economic<br />
S tudies , vol. 50 , no. 4 , 1983 , pp. 7072722 ; James Brander and Barbara Spencer , Export Subsidies and<br />
International Market Share Rivalry ," J ournal of I nternational Economics , vol. 18 , 1985 , pp . 832100.<br />
Application to Chilean Manufacturing Industries ," The W orl d B ank Economic Review , vol. 7 , no. 1 ,<br />
1993 , pp. 852112 ; Richard Beason and David Weistein , Growth , Economies of Scale , and Targeting in<br />
Japan (195521990) ," Review of Economics and S tatistics , vol. 78 , no. 2 , 1996 , pp . 2862295.<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
, <br />
<br />
, Ramsey , , <br />
, , , <br />
, , Ramsey <br />
, , , , <br />
, , , <br />
Ramsey <br />
: , Ramsey , <br />
, ; , , Ramsey <br />
; , ; , , <br />
, <br />
<br />
() <br />
, <br />
, ; <br />
, :<br />
yi<br />
= Ai k i<br />
i l 1 - i<br />
i (i = 1 ,2) (1)<br />
, , 1 < 2 <br />
, ,<br />
y1 , y2 <br />
, ( TFP) , <br />
, (1) li i , ki i <br />
, :<br />
l1 + l2 = 1 (2)<br />
k1 + k2 = k (3)<br />
, k <br />
, , <br />
:<br />
Kenneth J udd , Redistributive Taxation in a Simple Perfect Foresight Model ," J ournal of Public<br />
Economics , vol. 28 , 1985 , pp . 59283 ; Christophe Chamley , Optimal Taxation of Capital Income in<br />
General Equilibrium with Infinite Lives ," Economet rica , vol. 54 , no. 3 , 1986 , pp. 6072622 ; Isabel<br />
Correia , Should Capital Income Be Taxed in the Steady State ?" J ournal of Public Economics , vol. 60 ,<br />
1996 , pp. 1472151.<br />
Daron Acemoglu , Michael Golosov and Aleh Tsyvinski , Dynamic Mirrlees Taxation under Political<br />
Economy Constraints ," Review of Economic S tudies , forthcoming ; Daron Acemoglu , Michael Golosov<br />
and Aleh Tsyvinski , Political Econom y of Ramsey Tax ation , mimeo , 2009.<br />
97<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
2010 3 <br />
y = y <br />
1 y 1 - <br />
2 (4)<br />
:<br />
<br />
c 1 -<br />
0 1 - e<br />
- t dt (5)<br />
: c ; > 0 , ; 0 < 1 , <br />
:<br />
c + gk = w + rk + (6)<br />
(6) , w rk ; <br />
, c gk , 0 , <br />
, <br />
y = w + rk +, , c + gk = y <br />
, , :<br />
gc c<br />
= 1 (r - <br />
) (7)<br />
U [ u (c) ,v (y2 ) ] , u (c) , v (y2 )<br />
y2 , <br />
, <br />
, ,<br />
<br />
, U (u ,v) , U (u ,v) , <br />
; , :<br />
U 1 > 0 ,U 2 > 0 ,U 12 = U 21 0 ,v> 0 (8)<br />
U 1 > 0 ,<br />
; U 2 > 0 v> 0 <br />
, ; U 12 = U 21 0 <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, : <br />
<br />
1<br />
u (c)<br />
- v (y2 ) e - t dt (9)<br />
0<br />
,> 0 , , 0 1 , <br />
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, , <br />
<br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , , , <br />
98<br />
, , <br />
, <br />
, <br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
; , <br />
, 1 , , <br />
; , 0 , , <br />
<br />
<br />
() <br />
, , <br />
, ,<br />
, <br />
, : ,<br />
, , <br />
(1 - ) 1p1 A1 k 1<br />
1 - 1<br />
l 1 - 1<br />
1 (1 + ) 2p 2 A2 k 2 - 1<br />
, , :<br />
(1 - ) 1p 1 A1 k 1 - 1<br />
1 = (1 + )<br />
1 l 1 - 1<br />
: pi i <br />
2p2 A2 k 2<br />
2 - 1<br />
l 1 - 2<br />
2 l 1 - 2<br />
2 (10)<br />
2 , <br />
, , <br />
, :<br />
:<br />
<br />
1p1 A1 k 1<br />
1 = <br />
1 l 1 - 1<br />
2p2 A2 k 2<br />
2 l 1 - 2<br />
2 (11)<br />
y 1 , (4) , <br />
p 1<br />
= y<br />
y1<br />
p2<br />
=<br />
(1 - ) y<br />
y2<br />
(10) (11) (12) k = k1 + k2 , <br />
:<br />
k1<br />
= 1 - 2 (1 - )<br />
k k2<br />
<br />
(12)<br />
= 2 (1 - ) (1 + )<br />
k (13)<br />
<br />
, = 1 + 2 (1 - ) , , 0
2010 3 <br />
:<br />
y = Bf ( ) k (15)<br />
, 0
Ramsey Ljungqvist Sargent , <br />
Ramsey <br />
1 : (k ,c) (p 1 ,<br />
p2 ,r ,w) (, ) , <br />
, (p 1 ,p2 ,r ,w) (, ) , , <br />
(k ,c) <br />
, (k ,c) (p1 ,p 2 ,r ,w) , (, ) <br />
(11) <br />
2 : k0 , Ramsey , (9) <br />
<br />
(p1 ,p2 ,r ,w) (12) (18) , <br />
(k ,c) , (10) (11) <br />
, Ramsey , <br />
, <br />
Ramsey <br />
, (9) , <br />
:<br />
U (u ,v) =<br />
u (c)<br />
1 - y <br />
2 (19)<br />
, u (c) y2 (19) , :<br />
max<br />
<br />
Ac<br />
0<br />
(1 - ) (1 -<br />
, A , :<br />
A = A 2 2 (1 - ) <br />
2<br />
(1 - ) 1 - <br />
)<br />
(1 + ) 2 k 2 e - t dt (20)<br />
2 l (1 - 2 )<br />
2 <br />
, , <br />
:<br />
H = Ac<br />
:<br />
(1 - ) (1 -<br />
5 H<br />
5 = 2Ac<br />
:<br />
g= +<br />
g= + Bk - 2<br />
) (1 + ) 2 k 2 + c Bf (<br />
) k- 1 - +Bf ( ) k - c (21)<br />
(1 - ) (1 -<br />
) (1 + ) 2 - 1 k 2 + ( c +k) Bf<br />
( ) k- 1 = 0 (22)<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) (1 + ) ( c +k) Bf<br />
2 c ( ) k- 1 - gc c<br />
( c<br />
+k)<br />
+ (23)<br />
(1 + ) f ( ) - f ( ) + c<br />
f ( ) (24)<br />
(22) k c , (k ,c , ) <br />
(6) (7) (23) (24) 2 <br />
2 : k , c , :<br />
w , <br />
101<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
2010 3 <br />
k 3 = Bf (3 )<br />
<br />
3 =<br />
1/ (1 - )<br />
, c 3 = ( <br />
)<br />
/ (1 -<br />
) Bf ( 3 )<br />
1 (1 - )<br />
(1 - ) 2 (1 - ) +(1 - ) (1 - ) (1 - )<br />
1/ (1 - )<br />
,<br />
: , :<br />
Bf ( ) k - 1 | 3 = <br />
(23) (24) , :<br />
g= (1<br />
+<br />
- ) (1 - ) (1 + ) f ( )<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) (1 +<br />
+1 + ) f ( )<br />
2 f ( )<br />
2 f ( )<br />
g= (1 + ) f ( )<br />
(1<br />
+ 1 - +<br />
+ )<br />
f (<br />
f ( )<br />
)<br />
f ( )<br />
, gg0 , (26) (27) , :<br />
(1 +<br />
) f ( ) = -<br />
f ( )<br />
(17) , :<br />
2 (1 - )<br />
(1 - ) 2 + (1 - ) (1 - )<br />
(1 +<br />
) f ( ) 2 (1 - )<br />
= -<br />
f ( )<br />
1 - 2 (1 - )<br />
, , 3 , <br />
<br />
2 , <br />
1 : , 3 , :<br />
lim ()<br />
<br />
= 0 lim ()<br />
1 (1 - )<br />
0<br />
1<br />
=<br />
2 (1 - ) (1 - )<br />
2 : , 3 <br />
(25) , <br />
2 1 2 <br />
, <br />
, 2 1 2 , , , <br />
() , <br />
, <br />
2 (25) , ,<br />
, <br />
; , , ; <br />
, <br />
<br />
(25)<br />
(26)<br />
(27)<br />
(28)<br />
(29)<br />
Ramsey <br />
, , , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
102<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
, <br />
<br />
, , , <br />
<br />
<br />
, , , <br />
Ramsey , <br />
, Ramsey <br />
, Ramsey <br />
, (19) <br />
, :<br />
c ,k 2<br />
,l 2<br />
A <br />
2<br />
0<br />
max<br />
(1 - ) 1 - c<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) k 2 <br />
2 l 2 <br />
2 k 2 e - t dt (30)<br />
(20) , , <br />
, <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, (2) (3) (6) , <br />
:<br />
H =<br />
+ ;<br />
A <br />
2<br />
(1 - ) 1 - c<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) k 2 <br />
2 l (1 - 2 )<br />
2 k 2 <br />
A <br />
1 A 1 2 - (1 - k2 ) 1 (1 - l2 ) (1 - 1 ) k 2<br />
, ; , 1 + 2 (1 - ) <br />
(31) :<br />
5 H<br />
5 c<br />
5 H<br />
5 k2<br />
5 H<br />
5 l2<br />
:<br />
;<br />
;<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) A 2<br />
=<br />
(1 - ) 1 - c<br />
= 2A <br />
2<br />
(1 - ) 1 - c<br />
= 2A <br />
2<br />
(1 - ) 1 - c<br />
(1 -<br />
2 )<br />
l (1 - 2<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) - 1 k 2 <br />
2 l (1 - 2 )<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) k 2<br />
2 - 1<br />
l (1 - 2 )<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) k 2 (1 -<br />
2 l<br />
2 )- 1<br />
2 k 2 - ; y<br />
2 k 2 - ; y<br />
= - A <br />
1 A 1 2 - (1 - k2 ) 1 (1 - l2 ) (1 - 1 ) k 2<br />
, , <br />
) (1 -<br />
2 )<br />
k - c (31)<br />
2 k 2 - ; (32)<br />
(1 -<br />
2 )<br />
l (1 - 2<br />
1 <br />
- 1 (1 - )<br />
1 - k2 k2<br />
(1 - 1 )<br />
-<br />
1 - l2<br />
(1 - 2 ) (1 - )<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net<br />
l2<br />
(33)<br />
(34)<br />
) (1 -<br />
2 )<br />
k - 1 (35)<br />
(32) (35) , <br />
, <br />
(32) (33) (34) , 0 , :<br />
<br />
2<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) c y<br />
(1 - 2 )<br />
<br />
(1 - ) (1 - ) c y<br />
k2 - 2 (1 - )<br />
=<br />
1 - k2<br />
(1 - ) l2 - (1 - 2 ) (1 - )<br />
=<br />
1 - l2<br />
(36)<br />
(37)<br />
103
2010 3 <br />
, 0 , , c <br />
y, :<br />
k 2<br />
3 = 2 / (1 - ) (1 - ) + 2 (1 - )<br />
(38)<br />
2 / (1 - ) (1 - ) +<br />
l 2 3<br />
= 2 / (1 - ) (1 - ) + (1 - 2 ) (1 - )<br />
(39)<br />
2 / (1 - ) (1 - ) + 1 - <br />
, 3 <br />
3 : , Ramsey ; <br />
, Ramsey , <br />
, , , <br />
Ramsey , , , Ramsey<br />
: Ramsey , <br />
? Ramsey , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, <br />
, 3 , , <br />
Ramsey , , <br />
, , , Ramsey , <br />
, , <br />
<br />
3 , <br />
3 : Ramsey , , <br />
<br />
, , , Ramsey<br />
, , Ramsey , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
4 : = 0 , Ramsey Ramsey <br />
<br />
: = 0 , (25) = 0 , <br />
k c , = 0 , k c <br />
Ramsey <br />
= 0 = 0 (13) (14) (38) (39) , , <br />
Ramsey , <br />
, = 0 , Ramsey Ramsey <br />
4 , Ramsey , <br />
Ramsey <br />
, 3 <br />
104<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
, Ramsey , <br />
, = , =<br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
:<br />
, z , z =<br />
c/+k gz k c<br />
gz = c<br />
( g<br />
+ gc c<br />
) +k (<br />
g<br />
+ gk k ) (40)<br />
k c (40) , :<br />
gz z<br />
= + Af ( ) (1 k- 1 - ) (1 - ) + 2 (1 +<br />
) f ( ) + 1 - + c<br />
2 <br />
f ( )<br />
z ( - 1)<br />
, =, z c k z , k c <br />
c k z , <br />
(41)<br />
1 (= )<br />
c 3 k 3 y 3 2 3<br />
0 11 3735 715540 11 2208 0<br />
01 05 11 3545 715049 11 3278 011454<br />
01 25 11 2722 619973 11 5036 014875<br />
01 50 11 1631 613972 11 5416 016907<br />
01 75 11 0804 519416 11 5317 018021<br />
01 95 11 0286 516574 11 5146 018606<br />
1 11 0172 515943 11 5099 018725<br />
=, <br />
4 : =, , , <br />
3 <br />
5 : =, c , k z , c 3 k 3 z 3 <br />
c 3 k 3 z 3 <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
1 = 0135 , 2 = 0165 , = 017 , = 0144 ; = 0108 , =<br />
, <br />
, , <br />
, 1 , <br />
, <br />
105<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
2010 3 <br />
: , , <br />
, 1 2 <br />
2 (= )<br />
3 (= )<br />
, , <br />
Runge2Kutta , 010005 , <br />
(reverse shooting) , (c 3 ,k 3 ,z 3 ) <br />
, (c ,k ,z) (22) <br />
, , , <br />
(0199999c 3 ,k 3 ,z 3 ) , <br />
2 3 =c ,<br />
= 0125 = 0175 2 , c <br />
, , , , <br />
3 , , 4 <br />
106<br />
Kenneth J udd , N umerical Methods in Economics , Cambridge , Mass. : MIT Press , 1998 ; Mario Miranda<br />
and Paul Fackler , A p plied Com putational Economics and Finance , Cambridge , Mass. : MIT Press ,<br />
2002.<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, <br />
, , ,<br />
, , <br />
<br />
, <br />
, , <br />
, <br />
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, , , <br />
, ,<br />
, , , <br />
, , ,<br />
, FDI <br />
; , , , <br />
<br />
, , , <br />
, , <br />
, <br />
, , <br />
, <br />
<br />
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, , , , <br />
The World Bank ,<br />
The Grow th Report : S t rategies f or S ustained Grow th and I ncl usive Development , Washington DC ,<br />
2008 , p . 48.<br />
Dani Rodrik , Industrial Policies for the Twenty2First Century ," KSG Working Paper , No. RWP042047 ,<br />
2004 ; The World Bank , The Grow th Report : S t rategies f or S ustained Grow th and I ncl usive<br />
Development , p. 49.<br />
, , : <br />
, , 2004 21 ; :<br />
,2004 12 27 <br />
107<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
2010 3 <br />
<br />
, , , <br />
, <br />
, , <br />
<br />
, <br />
, <br />
? , ? , <br />
? , <br />
, , <br />
, , , <br />
, , , <br />
<br />
, , , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , <br />
, , Ramsey <br />
, , <br />
, ,<br />
: <br />
: , () 2 2 , 2003 ;<br />
J ustin Yifu Lin , Development and Transition : Idea , Strategy and Viability ," pp . 61265.<br />
: , () <br />
108<br />
9 2 , 2010 <br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
2010 3 <br />
monopoly industries into justified and unjustified portions. The empirical analysis shows t hat<br />
more t han 50 % of t he salary difference between employees in monopoly and competitive<br />
industries cannot be explained and is mainly t he result of administrative monopoly. Due to t he<br />
absence of the data on employee benefit s and subsidies , t he above estimate is based solely on an<br />
analysis of base salaries , which would underestimate t he unexplained portion of the high income<br />
of monopoly industry employees.<br />
(7) Development Strategy and Economic Growth X u Zhaoy ang and J usti n Yi f u L i n 94 <br />
Based on t he model of endogenous industry structure , this paper construct s a Ramsey<br />
problem model to examine t he impact of the governmentπs develop ment strategy on industry<br />
struct ural upgrading and economic performance. Our research shows t hat industry struct ure is<br />
endogenous to factor endowment structure and that it s upgrading proceeds in tandem wit h t he<br />
latter. The fact t hat t he government is deviating from factor endowment struct ure and giving<br />
priority to the develop ment of heavy industry will lead to resource misallocation and less efficient<br />
economic develop ment . Therefore what is crucial to economic develop ment lies not in t he<br />
upgrading of industrial struct ure , but that of factor endowment struct ure. Advisable industrial<br />
policies , which should be agnostic about particular industries , may promote t he upgrading of<br />
industrial structure , but their effectiveness remains subject to t he struct ure of factor<br />
endowment s.<br />
(8) Cyber Crime and Viable Solutions for Chinese Criminal La w Yu Zhi gan g 109 <br />
Internet2related variations of traditional crimes involve changes in their constit uent element s ,<br />
harmf ulness to society and patterns of crime. Such crimes have multiple causes , but t heir direct<br />
cause is t he intergenerational technological evolution of cyberspace. Expanded judicial<br />
interpretation is t he first preference in dealing wit h cyber crime , but it has obvious limitations. In<br />
t he face of t hese altered crimes , upgrading some act s of preparation and rendering t hem<br />
independent as act s of perpetration along wit h treating some accomplices as principals are two<br />
inevitable options for f uture criminal legislation.<br />
(9) Deterrence Supplementation and Lenient Sentencing upon Compensation"<br />
D ai X i n 127 <br />
Utilizing t he analytical f ramework provided by law and economicsπ theory of deterrence , and<br />
in particular t he thought s on two basic justifications for t he necessity of criminal p unishment s (i.<br />
e. the insolvency" problem and the inadequate deterrent " problem) , t his article discusses ,<br />
f rom t he angle of systematic efficiency , t he feasibility , advantages as well as potential problems<br />
of lenient sentencing upon compensation. " The aut hor argues t hat criminal p unishment and civil<br />
liability for tort , despite the commonly emp hasized sectorial differences and boundaries between<br />
p ublic law and private law , do share certain underlying rationale of efficiency. Recognition of<br />
222<br />
<br />
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net