23.04.2015 Views

proposed integrated complex for delhi judicial academy

proposed integrated complex for delhi judicial academy

proposed integrated complex for delhi judicial academy

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

RAPID ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT (REIA)<br />

(MAIN REPORT)<br />

<strong>for</strong><br />

PROPOSED INTEGRATED COMPLEX FOR DELHI JUDICIAL<br />

ACADEMY, NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL, AND NATIONAL INSTITUTE<br />

FOR MEDIATION & CONCILIATION<br />

AT DWARKA, NEW DELHI<br />

JUNE 2006<br />

1


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

Foreword<br />

The Study Team<br />

List of Tables………………………………………………………………….. vi<br />

List of Figures…………………………………………………………………. viii<br />

List of Annexures……………………………………………………………… x<br />

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY………………………………………………….... xi<br />

1. Introduction………………………………………………… 1-12<br />

1.1 Project Overview…………………………………………………………... 1<br />

1.2 Project Site Location………………………………………………………. 2<br />

1.3 Project Site and Surroundings Description………………………………... 2<br />

1.4 Current Land Use and Ownership………………………………………… 5<br />

1.5 Objectives of the REIA Study…………………………………………….. 5<br />

1.6 Stages in the REIA Study…………………………………………………. 6<br />

1.7 Report Organization and Structure………………………………………... 7<br />

1.8 Project Proponent Name and Contact……………………………………... 9<br />

1.9 Permits and Approvals…………………………………………………….. 9<br />

2. Environmental Regulatory Context 13-23<br />

2.1 Indian Environmental Legislations………………………………………... 13<br />

2.2 Major Provisions in Indian Environmental Legislations………………….. 14<br />

2.3 Applicable Environmental Standards……………………………………... 19<br />

2.4 Environmental Clearance Requirements…………………………………... 20<br />

2.5 Applicable State Level Legislations……………………………………….. 22<br />

3. Project Description…………………………………………… 24-47<br />

3.1 Major Project Components and Requirements…………………………….. 24<br />

3.1.1 Project Layout and Development Concept………………………………... 24<br />

3.1.2 Land Use and Area Statement………………………………………………. 26<br />

3.1.3 Water Requirements and Supply……………………………………………. 30<br />

2


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

3.1.4 Power Requirements and Supply…………………………………………… 30<br />

3.1.5 Back Up Power Supply System……………………………………………… 30<br />

3.1.6 Fuel Requirements……………………………………………………………. 31<br />

3.1.7 Water Storage Tanks and Pump Room…………………………………….. 31<br />

3.1.8 Sewage Collection, Treatment and Disposal System…………………….. 32<br />

3.1.9 Storm Water Drainage System……………………………………………… 33<br />

3.1.10 Internal Road Network and Vehicle Parking……………………………... 33<br />

3.1.11 Air Conditioning System…………………………………………………….. 34<br />

3.1.12 Fire Fighting System…………………………………………………………. 35<br />

3.1.13 Solar Water Heating System………………………………………………… 36<br />

3.2 Project Activities…………………………………………………………... 36<br />

3.2.1 Construction Phase…………………………………………………………... 36<br />

3.2.2 Operation Phase……………………………………………………………… 37<br />

3.3 Water Balance Statement………………………………………………….. 37<br />

3.4 Building Design Features on Seismic Load……………………………….. 41<br />

3.5 Resource and Construction Material Requirements………………………. 41<br />

3.6 Solid, Liquid and Gaseous Wastes Generation……………………………. 42<br />

3.7 Construction Plan and Timetable………………………………………….. 43<br />

3.8 Construction Work<strong>for</strong>ce Requirements…………………………………… 43<br />

3.9 Project Cost………………………………………………………………... 44<br />

3.10 Project Site Layout Plan and Model Photographs………………………… 44<br />

4. Description of the Existing Environment…………………. 48-100<br />

4.1 Introduction………………………………………………………………... 48<br />

4.2 Physiography……………………………………………………………… 48<br />

4.3 Climate…………………………………………………………………….. 51<br />

4.4 Micro-meteorological Characteristics……………………………………... 52<br />

4.5 Air Environment…………………………………………………………... 54<br />

4.5.1 Ambient Air Quality Scenario in Delhi……………………………………. 54<br />

4.5.2 Ambient Air Quality Survey…………………………………………………. 62<br />

4.5.3 Analysis of Baseline Concentrations………………………………………. 63<br />

3


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

4.6 Noise Environment………………………………………………………... 68<br />

4.7 Water Environment………………………………………………………... 71<br />

4.7.1 Ground Water Hydrology…………………………………………………… 71<br />

4.7.2 Drainage Pattern……………………………………………………………... 76<br />

4.7.3 Ground Water Quality……………………………………………………….. 76<br />

4.8 Land Environment………………………………………………………… 80<br />

4.8.1 Seismic Stability………………………………………………………………. 80<br />

4.8.2 Geology………………………………………………………………………… 80<br />

4.8.3 Land Use Pattern……………………………………………………………... 81<br />

4.8.4 Soil Quality…………………………………………………………………… 84<br />

4.9 Biological Environment…………………………………………………… 87<br />

4.9.1 Vegetation Pattern……………………………………………………………. 87<br />

4.9.2 Fauna…………………………………………………………………………... 88<br />

4.10 Socio-Economic Environment…………………………………………….. 91<br />

4.10.1 Demographic Structure of the Study Area………………………………… 92<br />

4.10.2 Physical Infrastructure Resource Base……………………………………. 93<br />

4.10.3 Education……………………………………………………………………… 95<br />

4.10.4 Health………………………………………………………………………….. 95<br />

4.10.5 Economic Aspects…………………………………………………………….. 95<br />

4.10.6 Cultural Heritage…………………………………………………………….. 96<br />

4.10.7 Aesthetic Aspects……………………………………………………………… 96<br />

4.10.8 Communications and Transportation……………………………………… 96<br />

5. Anticipated Environmental Impacts……………………….. 101-120<br />

5.1 Introduction………………………………………………………………... 101<br />

5.2 Impacts on Ambient Air Environment…………………………………….. 102<br />

5.2.1 Impacts During Construction……………………………………………….. 103<br />

5.2.2 Impacts During Operation…………………………………………………… 103<br />

5.3 Impacts on Ambient Noise Environment………………………………….. 104<br />

5.4 Impacts on Water Environment……………………………………………. 108<br />

5.4.1 Impacts on Ground Water……………………………….…………………… 108<br />

4


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

5.4.2 Impacts on Piped Water Supply…………………………………………….. 109<br />

5.4.3 Impacts Due to Wastewater Generation…………………………………… 110<br />

5.5 Impacts on Land Environment…………………………………………….. 112<br />

5.5.1 Impacts on Land Use…………………………………………………………. 112<br />

5.5.2 Impacts on Soil………………………………………………………………… 113<br />

5.5.3 Construction Wastes………………………………………………………….. 114<br />

5.5.4 Solid Wastes Generation and Disposal…………………………………….. 114<br />

5.6 Impacts on Socio – Economic Environment………………………………. 115<br />

5.6.1 Hazards to Construction Workers and the Local Population…………… 115<br />

5.6.2 Housing and Transportation of Construction Workers………………….. 115<br />

5.6.3 Socio – cultural Impacts……………………………………………………… 116<br />

5.6.4 Impacts on Physical Infrastructure…………………………………………. 116<br />

5.6.5 Employment Opportunities…………………………………………………... 116<br />

5.7 Renewable Resources……………………………………………………… 117<br />

5.8 Potential Environmental Impacts Matrix…………………………………... 118<br />

6. Environmental Impact Statement………………………….. 121-125<br />

6.1 Air Environment…………………………………………………………… 121<br />

6.2 Noise Environment………………………………………………………… 122<br />

6.3 Water Environment………………………………………………………... 122<br />

6.4 Land Environment…………………………………………………………. 123<br />

6.5 Socio-Economic Environment……………………………………………... 124<br />

7. Environmental Management Plan………………………….. 126-140<br />

7.1 Introduction………………………………………………………………... 126<br />

7.2 Mitigation Measures during Construction…………………………………. 127<br />

7.2.1 Air Quality and Dust………………………………………………………….. 127<br />

7.2.2 Noise……………………………………………………………………………. 127<br />

7.2.3 Land Environment…………………………………………………………….. 128<br />

7.2.4 Hazards to Construction Workers and the Local Population…………… 128<br />

7.2.5 Ground Water Quality and Quantity……………………………………….. 128<br />

7.2.6 Housing and Transportation of Construction Workers………………….. 129<br />

5


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

7.2.7 Traffic Pattern…………………………………………………………………. 129<br />

7.3 Mitigation Measures during Operation……………………………………. 129<br />

7.3.1 Air Quality……………………………………………………………………... 129<br />

7.3.2 Noise……………………………………………………………………………. 129<br />

7.3.3 Land Environment…………………………………………………………….. 130<br />

7.3.4 Ground Water Quality and Quantity……………………………………….. 130<br />

7.3.5 Infrastructure………………………………………………………………….. 130<br />

7.3.6 Traffic Pattern…………………………………………………………………. 130<br />

7.4 Human Health and Safety Management Plan……………………………… 131<br />

7.5 Fire Safety and Protection…………………………………………………. 132<br />

7.6 Rainwater Harvesting Plan………………………………………………… 133<br />

7.7 Landscaping and Green Belt Development Plan…………………………... 135<br />

7.8 Vehicle Parking and Management Plan…………………………………… 136<br />

7.9 Energy Conservation Plan…………………………………………………. 139<br />

8. Environmental Monitoring Plan……………………………. 141-142<br />

8.1 Ambient Air Quality………………………………………………………. 141<br />

8.2 Ambient Noise Quality……………………………………………………. 141<br />

8.3 Ground Water Quality…………………………………………………….. 142<br />

8.4 Wastewater Quality………………………………………………………... 142<br />

9. Cost Estimates………………………………………………… 143<br />

LIST OF TABLES<br />

Table 3.1 Details of Proposed Built up Area of Academic Complex.…………... 27<br />

Table 3.2 Details of Proposed Built up Area of Residential Buildings…………. 28<br />

Table 3.3 Proposed Land Use <strong>for</strong> the Integrated Complex……………………… 29<br />

Table 3.4 Estimated Quantities of Construction Materials……………………… 42<br />

Table 3.5 Proposed Integrated Judicial Complex Construction Schedule………. 43<br />

Table 4.1 Summary of Data Collection from Various Sources…………………. 50<br />

6


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 4.2 Emission Factors <strong>for</strong> Different Vehicles……………………………... 57<br />

Table 4.3 Emission Factors Comparison………………………………………... 57<br />

Table 4.4 Sampling Locations <strong>for</strong> Ambient Air Quality Monitoring…………… 65<br />

Table 4.5 Ambient Air Quality Results (March – May 2006)…………………... 66<br />

Table 4.6 Statistical Analysis of Ambient Air Quality Results…………………. 67<br />

Table 4.7 Equivalent Noise Levels in the Study Area (Core Zone)…………….. 70<br />

Table 4.8 Sampling Locations <strong>for</strong> Ground Water Quality Monitoring……......... 78<br />

Table 4.9 Ground Water Quality Results………………………………………... 79<br />

Table 4.10 Locations <strong>for</strong> Collection of Soil Samples…………………………….. 85<br />

Table 4.11 Chemical Characteristics of Soil in Study Area……………………… 86<br />

Table 4.12 Relationship of CEC with Productivity………………………………. 86<br />

Table 4.13 Relationship of CEC with Absorptivity………………………………. 86<br />

Table 4.14 Fertility Status of Soil………………………………………………… 87<br />

Table 4.15 List of Tree Species in the Study Area……………………………….. 89<br />

Table 4.16 List of Faunal Species in the Study Area……………………………... 90<br />

Table 4.17 Demographic Structure of the Study Area……………………………. 92<br />

Table 5.1<br />

Increase in Noise Levels due to Operation of Various Construction<br />

Equipments…………………………………………………………… 105<br />

Table 5.2 Transmission Loss <strong>for</strong> Common Construction Materials…………….. 107<br />

Table 5.3 Expected Characteristics of Untreated Wastewater…………………... 111<br />

Table 5.4 Expected Characteristics of Treated Wastewater…………………….. 112<br />

Table 5.5 Potential Environmental Impact Matrix……………………………… 120<br />

7


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

LIST OF FIGURES<br />

Figure 1.1 Location Map of the Project Area...………………………………… 11<br />

Figure 1.2 Key Plan Map of the Proposed Site………………………………… 12<br />

Figure 3.0 Water Balance………………………………………………………. 40<br />

Figure 3.1 Proposed Project Site Layout Plan………………………………….. 45<br />

Figure 3.2 Model Photograph I………………………………………………… 46<br />

Figure 3.3 Model Photograph II………………………………………………... 47<br />

Figure 4.1 Physiographic Regions Map of Delhi……………………………… 49<br />

Figure 4.2 Windrose Diagram………………………………………………….. 53<br />

Figure 4.3 SO2 Source in Ambient Air………………………………………… 58<br />

Figure 4.4 NOx Sources in Ambient Air……………………………………….. 60<br />

Figure 4.5 SPM Sources in Ambient Air………………………………………. 61<br />

8


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.6 Thickness of Alluvium Map………………………………………... 73<br />

Figure 4.7 Decline in Water Table Levels Map of Delhi……………………… 74<br />

Figure 4.8 Ground water Salinity Map…………………………………………. 75<br />

Figure 4.9 Sewerage And Drainage Zones Map of Delhi……………………… 77<br />

Figure 4.10 Seismic Zoning Map of India………………………………………. 80<br />

Figure 4.11 Geological Map of NCT Delhi……………………………………... 82<br />

Figure 4.12 Land Use Distribution Map of Dwarka…………………………….. 83<br />

Figure 4.13 Piped Water Supply Distribution Map of Delhi……………………. 97<br />

Figure 4.14 Water Treatment Plants in Delhi (Existing and Proposed)…………. 98<br />

Figure 4.15 Municipal Waste Disposal Sites Locations in Delhi………………... 99<br />

Figure 4.16 Location Map of Heritage Sites and Environmental Sensitive Sites.. 100<br />

Figure 5.1 Noise Level due to Operation of Various Construction Equipments. 106<br />

Figure 7.1 Cross Section of Rainwater Harvesting Recharging Pit……………. 134<br />

Figure 7.2 Layout Plan Showing Rain Water Harvesting……………………… 137<br />

Figure 7.3 Layout Plan Showing Landscape and Green Belt Development…… 138<br />

9


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

LIST OF ANNEXURES<br />

Annexure 1 National Ambient Air Quality Standards…………………………… 144<br />

Annexure 2 Ambient Air Quality Standards In Respect of Noise……………….. 145<br />

Annexure 3 Standards <strong>for</strong> Occupational Noise Exposure……………………….. 146<br />

Annexure 4 Wastewater Discharge Standards…………………………………… 147<br />

Annexure 5<br />

Standards / Guidelines <strong>for</strong> Control of Noise Pollution from<br />

Stationary Diesel Generator (DG) Sets……………………………... 148<br />

Annexure 6 Drinking Water Standards and Probable Effects on Human Health... 151<br />

10


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

1. INTRODUCTION<br />

1.1 Project Overview<br />

An <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong> <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy, National Law School, and National Institute of<br />

mediation and conciliation is <strong>proposed</strong> to be established in Delhi on a land measuring about<br />

49352.00 sq. meters (12.195 acres). This land has been allotted by the Delhi Development<br />

Authority (DDA) in Sector – 14, Dwarka, Phase – II, Delhi. All these three teaching components of<br />

the <strong>complex</strong> will function as independent institutions and will be <strong>integrated</strong> as a unified <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

In addition to the training programmes of the Judicial Academy and the Institute of Mediation and<br />

Conciliation, the National Law School will offer five years degree course in Law. All these<br />

Institutions shall share certain common facilities in the campus, while maintaining their identities<br />

and independent functioning.<br />

As there is requirement of substantial residential accommodation <strong>for</strong> the National Law School as<br />

well as <strong>for</strong> the Delhi Judicial Academy, the Ministry of Urban Development after the<br />

recommendation by DDA has issued a gazette notification to bifurcate the site with different land<br />

uses, namely Institutional and Residential.<br />

The academic <strong>complex</strong> encompasses about 26172.00 sq. meters (6.467 acres) i.e. 53.03% of the<br />

total plot area. The <strong>proposed</strong> covered area on ground floor is 6156.381 sq. meters (23.52%) against<br />

the permissible ground coverage of 6543.00 sq. meters (25%) and with total built up area of<br />

34,223.275 sq. meters (including basement). FAR achieved have been 97.89 against the permissible<br />

FAR of 100.<br />

The plot area under residential <strong>complex</strong> is about 23180.00 sq. meters (5.728 acres) i.e. 46.97% of<br />

the total plot area. The <strong>proposed</strong> covered area on ground floor is 6210.206 sq. meters (26.79%)<br />

against the permissible ground coverage of 7725.894 sq. meters (33.33%) and with total built up<br />

area of 33,959.864 sq. meters (including basement). FAR achieved have been 125.046 against the<br />

permissible FAR of 133.<br />

In order to assess the potential environmental impacts arising out due to the construction and<br />

operation of the <strong>proposed</strong> project activities and to comply with the statutory requirements of the<br />

Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF) under the Environment (Protection) Act 1986, the<br />

project proponent retained M/s AET Infrastructure Environmental Services, New Delhi to<br />

undertake Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) study <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong> project. As per<br />

the notification issued by Ministry of Environment & Forests, New Delhi dated 7th July, 2004, the<br />

Central Government has made the amendment in the notification number S.0.60 (E) dated the 27th<br />

January 1994 and included the following categories (i) New Construction Projects (ii) New<br />

11


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

industrial estates under S.No 31 and 32 into the list of projects listed in Schedule -I which requires<br />

environmental clearance from Central Government.<br />

1.2 Project Site Location<br />

Delhi is situated in the northern part of the country and lies between latitudes 28° 24’ 17” and 28°<br />

53’ 00” North and longitudes of 76° 50’ 24” and 77° 20’ 37” East. It shares its boundary with the<br />

States of Uttar Pradesh and Haryana. Delhi has a geographical area of 1,483 sq. km. and population<br />

of 13,850,507 as per 2001 census records. Its maximum length is 51.90 km. and greatest width is<br />

48.48 km. Delhi has a population density of about 9340 persons per sq. km.<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project site is located at Sector -14, Dwarka, Phase II in South West District of Delhi.<br />

The location map of the project area is given in the Figure 1.1.<br />

Figure 1.2 shows the key map of the <strong>proposed</strong> project site.<br />

1.3 Project Site and Surroundings Description<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project site is surrounded by a network of roads on 3 sides, whereas on the Northern<br />

periphery a Master Plan green belt is <strong>proposed</strong>.<br />

The shape of the plot is an irregular one and the terrain is quite flat without any undulations. There<br />

are no existing natural features which may affect the planning process. A well exists in the middle<br />

of the plot and attempt would be made to retain the same <strong>for</strong> rainwater harvesting.<br />

Southern Side: 45 m wide road runs along in front of the southern side of the plot. Across the road,<br />

a vacant plot has been earmarked <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong> General hospital. Further away from this vacant<br />

land, residential apartment exists. The terrain is almost flat.<br />

12


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Western Side: On the western side, 60 m wide double road exists. High tension electric cables go<br />

along the road. About 500 meters away from the <strong>proposed</strong> project’s plot boundary, residential<br />

apartments exists. Surface storm water drain crosses this road a little further down.<br />

Northern Side: On the northern periphery, a Master Plan green belt is <strong>proposed</strong>. Across this patch<br />

of land, other vacant lands meant <strong>for</strong> institutional purposes are there. Within 1 km radius of the<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> plot site, 220 /66 KV Grid sub station is there, which will serve as the source of power<br />

supply to the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

Eastern Side: On the eastern side, 30 m wide road exists which goes towards the metro station.<br />

Across the road, Intellectual Building Complex exists. Adjacent to this building, DDA park exists.<br />

13


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

1.4 Current Land Use and Ownership<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project site lies in the Public / Semi-public land use category of the project area and<br />

is a part of the sub city. The adjoining lands to the project site are essentially institutional. Within 1<br />

Km radius of the <strong>proposed</strong> project site, many residential apartments also exist. As there is<br />

requirement of substantial residential accommodation <strong>for</strong> the National Law School as well as <strong>for</strong><br />

the Delhi Judicial Academy, the Ministry of Urban Development after the recommendation by<br />

DDA has issued a gazette notification to bifurcate the project site with different land uses, namely<br />

Institutional and Residential. No agricultural and industrial areas exist within the core zone of the<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> project site. The <strong>proposed</strong> project site is designated <strong>for</strong> the intended purpose and the<br />

necessary change in the land use of the plot area measuring 23,180 sq. meters (5.72 acres) has<br />

already been effected by converting it to land use <strong>for</strong> residential use from land use <strong>for</strong> Government<br />

use in MPD-2001.<br />

1.5 Objectives of the REIA Study<br />

The purpose of Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) is to assist in the decision making<br />

process and to ensure that the project under consideration are environmentally sound and<br />

sustainable. REIA identifies the ways of improving project environmentally by preventing,<br />

minimizing, mitigating or compensating <strong>for</strong> adverse impacts.<br />

Urban development projects including housing and office <strong>complex</strong>es do have the potential in<br />

altering environmental resources of any urban area. They cause stress on local environmental assets<br />

of the urban area and could become the potential source <strong>for</strong> limiting the growth of the city.<br />

Unplanned construction and operation of such projects usually result in impacts on various facets of<br />

environment.<br />

14


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Keeping above issues under considerations, an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) study is<br />

conducted which incorporates into development and planning process, a plan <strong>for</strong> environmental<br />

protection and conservation. The procedure identifies the possible positive and negative impacts on<br />

the environment likely to emanate as a result of construction and operation of a project. The EIA<br />

thus, provides <strong>for</strong> a plan which, upon implementation, will reduce or offset the negative impacts of<br />

a project resulting in a minimum level of environmental degradation. This minimization may be a<br />

result of implementation of a project modifications or environmental protection measures which<br />

simply reduces the severity or number or magnitude of negative impacts. The plan may also result<br />

in utilization of positive impacts <strong>for</strong> enhancement measures which offset negative impacts.<br />

To measure the level of plan implementation and the degree of effectiveness of the above<br />

environmental protection provisions, the EIA provides a monitoring programme. This programme<br />

is so designed that it identifies the parameters of uncertainty and measures the related impacts.<br />

It is necessary that there is close integration of EIA with various aspects of a project including<br />

financial and engineering aspects which ensures environmental consideration are given due weight<br />

in project selection, siting design and operation.<br />

Analysis of past experiences indicate that it is necessary to examine a number of problem areas in<br />

order to ensure that environmental concerns can be effectively <strong>integrated</strong> in the development<br />

process. Similar approach has been adopted while conducting the REIA study <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong><br />

<strong>integrated</strong> Judicial Academy <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

1.6 Stages in the REIA Study<br />

The purpose of this section is to enumerate the methodology <strong>for</strong> Rapid Environmental Impact<br />

Assessment (REIA) which has been followed <strong>for</strong> this study. Any activity involving construction<br />

and operation is expected to cause impacts on surrounding environment. The impacts may be<br />

adverse or beneficial, short term or long term, and reversible or irreversible. In order to assess the<br />

significance of impacts, various steps that are used in conducting an REIA within core and buffer<br />

zone around the <strong>proposed</strong> project construction site are divided into the following phases:<br />

• Identification of significant environmental parameters and assessing the existing status within<br />

the impact zone with respect to air, water, noise, land, biological, and socioeconomic<br />

components of environment.<br />

• Study of various activities of the <strong>proposed</strong> project components to identify the areas leading to<br />

impact/change in environmental quality.<br />

15


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• Identification of potential impacts on various environmental components due to the activities<br />

envisaged during pre-construction, construction, and operational phases of the <strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

• Prediction of significant impacts on the major environmental components using qualitative /<br />

quantitative techniques.<br />

• Preparation of environmental impact statement based on the identification, prediction and<br />

evaluation of impacts.<br />

• Delineation of environmental management plan (EMP) outlining preventive and curative<br />

strategies <strong>for</strong> minimizing adverse impacts during pre-construction, construction and operational<br />

phases of the <strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

• Formulation of environment quality monitoring programme <strong>for</strong> construction and operational<br />

phases to be pursued by the project proponent.<br />

1.7 Report Organization and Structure<br />

The contents of the present study are arranged as follows:<br />

Section 1: This section gives an overview of the project, site location and the current land use<br />

pattern of the project area. The objectives and need <strong>for</strong> REIA study too have been covered as a part<br />

of this section.<br />

Section 2: This section gives the brief review of the policies and the Environmental legislations at<br />

the National and State level to understand the legal requirements and implications of the <strong>proposed</strong><br />

project interventions.<br />

Section 3: A brief write-up on various project appurtenances, construction schedule and related<br />

aspects have been covered in this section.<br />

Section 4: Baseline environmental conditions including physical, biological and socio-economic<br />

parameters, resource base and infrastructure have been described in this section. Be<strong>for</strong>e the start of<br />

the project, it is essential to ascertain the baseline conditions of appropriate environmental<br />

parameters which could be significantly affected by the implementation of the project. The baseline<br />

setting has been described <strong>for</strong> parameters most relevant to the type of <strong>proposed</strong> project. The<br />

baseline study involved both field work and review of existing in<strong>for</strong>mation, which were available<br />

through different agencies / organizations.<br />

16


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Section 5: Anticipated positive and negative impacts as a result of the construction and operation of<br />

the <strong>proposed</strong> project are covered as a part of this section. The section attempts to <strong>for</strong>ecast the future<br />

environmental conditions of the project area that might be expected to occur as a result of the<br />

construction and operation of the <strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

Section 6: This section gives the environmental impact statement based on the identification,<br />

prediction and evaluation of impacts.<br />

Section 7: Environmental Management Plan (EMP) <strong>for</strong> amelioration of anticipated adverse impacts<br />

likely to accrue as a result of the <strong>proposed</strong> project is outlined in this section. The approach <strong>for</strong><br />

<strong>for</strong>mulation of an EMP was to maximize the positive environmental impacts and minimize the<br />

negative ones.<br />

Section 8: Environmental Monitoring Programme <strong>for</strong> implementation during project construction<br />

and operation phases has also been delineated in this section. The objective of environmental<br />

monitoring programme is to assess the adequacy of various environmental safeguards and to<br />

compare the predicted and actual scenario during construction and operation phases. This enables<br />

suggestion of remedial measures not <strong>for</strong>eseen during the planning stage but arising during these<br />

phases.<br />

Section 9: The estimated cost <strong>for</strong> implementation of suggested environmental management<br />

measures.<br />

1.8 Project Proponent Name and Contact<br />

The name and contact of the project proponent and architects are:<br />

Project Proponent<br />

Government of National Capital Territory (NCT) of Delhi,<br />

(Through Executive Engineer)<br />

PWD Division, Zone - I<br />

New Delhi<br />

Architects<br />

Behal Joshi and Associates<br />

(Architects and Interior Designers)<br />

P – 9, Hauz Khas Enclave,<br />

New Delhi – 110016<br />

17


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

1.9 Permits and Approvals<br />

Various permits and approvals already obtained <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong> project are:<br />

• The <strong>proposed</strong> project has been approved by the Delhi Urban Arts Commission (DUAC) at<br />

conceptual stage.<br />

• The Ministry of Urban Development has issued a gazette notification to bifurcate the project<br />

site with different land uses, namely Institutional and Residential.<br />

18


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

PROJECT AREA<br />

Figure 1.1: Location Map of the Project Area<br />

19


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 1.2: Key Plan Map of the Proposed Project Site<br />

20


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

2. ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATORY CONTEXT<br />

This section reviews the policies and the Environment legislations at the National and State level to<br />

understand the legal requirements and implications on the <strong>proposed</strong> project. All activities under the<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> project must be consistent with all applicable laws, regulations, notifications, and<br />

standards. It is the responsibility of the project Implementing Agency to ensure that project<br />

activities are consistent with the regulatory/legal framework, whether national, state or<br />

municipal/local.<br />

2.1 Indian Environmental Legislations<br />

The Constitution of India directs the State to endeavor to protect and improve the environment and<br />

to safeguard the <strong>for</strong>est and wildlife of the country. Article 51(g) of the constitution states that it<br />

shall be the duty of every citizen of India to protect and improve the national environment including<br />

<strong>for</strong>ests, lakes, rivers and wildlife and to have compassion <strong>for</strong> living creatures. The language of the<br />

Directive principles of the state policy (Article 47) also contains a specific provision, which<br />

commits the state to protect the environment.<br />

In addition to Constitutional provisions, India has established a comprehensive set of laws <strong>for</strong> the<br />

management and protection of the environment. The Acts, Notifications, Rules and Amendments<br />

applicable to any type of development projects include the following:<br />

• The Environment (Protection) Act and Rules, 1986<br />

• The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 1994 and amendments <strong>for</strong><br />

Environmental Clearance<br />

• Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980<br />

• The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, Rules and Amendment, 1981, 1982, 1983,<br />

1987<br />

• The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act and Rules, 1974, 1975<br />

• The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Cess Act and Rules, 1977, 1978, 1991<br />

• The Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991<br />

• The Environmental Standards Notification, 1993, 1996<br />

• The Hazardous Waste Management and Handling Rules, 1989 and amendment rules 2000<br />

• The Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules 2000, 2002<br />

• The National Environment Tribunal Act, 1995<br />

• The Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000<br />

21


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Note:<br />

The Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) has stipulated general discharge standards <strong>for</strong><br />

water effluents, and general emission standards <strong>for</strong> air and noise emissions. These standards limit<br />

the concentration and volumes of the effluents and emissions released to the atmosphere. The<br />

respective State Pollution Control Boards (SPCBs) could make these standards more stringent<br />

based on the environmental sensitivity of a specific location.<br />

The project proponents are required to take Consents (<strong>for</strong> both air and water) and No Objection<br />

Certificates (NOCs) from the relevant SPCBs be<strong>for</strong>e initiating any activity.<br />

In addition to the above, the Central Pollution Control board (CPCB) has also specified National<br />

Ambient Air Quality and Noise Standards <strong>for</strong> residential, commercial, industrial and sensitive<br />

zones <strong>for</strong> the country as a whole.<br />

2.2 Major Provisions in Indian Environmental Legislations<br />

2.2.1 The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 including Rules 1986<br />

This Act is an umbrella legislation that provides a single focus <strong>for</strong> the protection of the<br />

environment. The potential scope of the Act is broad, with “environment” defined to include water,<br />

air and land and the inter-relationships which exist among water, air and land, and human beings<br />

and other living creatures, plants, micro-organisms and property.<br />

The Act has been enacted to provide <strong>for</strong> the protection and improvement of environment by<br />

preparation of manuals, codes or guides relating to prevention, control and abatement of<br />

environment pollution.<br />

The Act provides powers to the Central Government to take necessary measures <strong>for</strong> the purpose of<br />

protecting and improving the quality of the environment and prevention, control and abatement of<br />

environmental pollution. It lays down standards <strong>for</strong> the quality of the environment, emissions or<br />

discharges of environmental pollutants from various sources. It provides restriction on discharge or<br />

emission of pollutants in excess of the prescribed standards. Environmental Impact Assessment<br />

Notification, 1994 and the various amendments pertaining to this notification <strong>for</strong>m a part of the<br />

regulations under this legislation.<br />

2.2.2 Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 1994 and<br />

Amendments<br />

22


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

As per the EIA notification, 1994 and subsequent amendments, new or expansion or modernisation<br />

of any activity falling in the 32 categories of activities shall not be undertaken in any part of India<br />

unless it has been accorded environmental clearance by the Central Government in accordance with<br />

the procedures specified in the notification.<br />

Until January 1994, obtaining environmental clearance from the MoEF was only an administrative<br />

requirement intended <strong>for</strong> mega projects undertaken by the government or public sector<br />

undertakings.<br />

Relevance to the Construction Projects (Housing and Office Complex):<br />

• Certain type of urban housing projects needs environmental clearance from the<br />

MoEF. These include those (i) that are worth Rs. 500 million or above, (ii) intended<br />

<strong>for</strong> 1,000 persons or more, and (iii) would discharge 50,000 litres or more of<br />

sewage. If there are single housing construction projects that would exceed the<br />

above cost, then the environmental clearance should be obtained prior to<br />

implementation. Contractors should adhere to the conditions prescribed in the<br />

clearance.<br />

• In all their plant operations, the contractors need to meet the requirements /<br />

standards prescribed in the various Environmental Protection Rules and other<br />

environmental regulations.<br />

Whenever a project is given environmental clearance, a set of recommendations and conditions are<br />

stipulated by the Appraisal Committee that has to be complied with by the proponent once the<br />

project is commissioned. Project authorities are required to submit periodical compliance reports to<br />

the MoEF to enable the Ministry to monitor the implementation of the recommendations and<br />

conditions of environmental clearance. Cases of noncompliance of recommendations and<br />

conditions of environmental clearance are brought to the notice of the concerned SPCB <strong>for</strong> action.<br />

2.2.3 THE AIR (PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF POLLUTION) ACT, 1981<br />

This Act was enacted to implement measures devised <strong>for</strong> its effective prevention, control or<br />

abatement of air pollution. The Act prohibits the construction and operation of any specified<br />

activity without the consent of SPCBs. For the prevention and control of air pollution, the State<br />

Government, in consultation with the SPCB has the powers to set standards <strong>for</strong> emissions from<br />

automobiles, impose restrictions on use of certain activities and prohibit emissions of air pollutants<br />

in excess of the standards laid down by the SPCB. It can also make an application to the court <strong>for</strong><br />

restraining persons from causing air pollution. In addition, it also has the power of entry and<br />

inspection, power to obtain in<strong>for</strong>mation and power to take samples of air emissions and conduct the<br />

appropriate follow up. The CPCB, as well as the SPCBs are eligible <strong>for</strong> contributions from the<br />

Central as well as the State Government, respectively, to per<strong>for</strong>m their functions appropriately. The<br />

Act also allows <strong>for</strong> appropriate penalties and procedures <strong>for</strong> non-compliance.<br />

23


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

2.2.4 The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, amended in 1988<br />

This Act has been enacted to implement measures devised <strong>for</strong> effective prevention and control of<br />

water pollution. It empowers the State Pollution Control Board to prepare manuals, codes or guides<br />

relating to treatment and disposal of sewage and trade effluents and in<strong>for</strong>mation dissemination <strong>for</strong><br />

maintaining or restoring wholesomeness of water.<br />

2.2.5 The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Cess Act, 1977<br />

This Act provides <strong>for</strong> levy and collection of Cess on water consumed by persons carrying on<br />

certain activities and by the local authorities with a view to augment the resources of CPCB and<br />

SPCBs <strong>for</strong> the prevention and control of water pollution, constituted under the Water Act, 1974. It<br />

also covers specifications on affixing of meters, furnishing of returns, assessment of Cess, interest<br />

payable <strong>for</strong> delay in payment of Cess and penalties <strong>for</strong> non-payment of Cess within the specified<br />

time.<br />

2.2.6 The Hazardous Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 (as<br />

amended, May 2003)<br />

The Act requires owners to identify their wastes <strong>for</strong> applicability under the hazardous wastes<br />

amendment rules 2003 and manage them as per the prescribed guidelines. The assessment criteria<br />

under the amended rules are based on process and concentration.<br />

2.2.7 THE PUBLIC LIABILITY INSURANCE ACT, 1991<br />

The Public Liability Insurance Act (PLI), 1991, imposes on the owner the liability to provide<br />

immediate relief in respect of death or injury to any person or damage to any property resulting<br />

from an accident while handling any of the notified hazardous chemicals. This relief has to be<br />

provided on "no fault" basis. Owner handling hazardous chemicals has to take an insurance policy<br />

of an amount equal to its "paid up capital" or upto Rs 500 millions, which ever is less. The policy<br />

has to be renewed every year. New undertakings have to take this policy be<strong>for</strong>e the commencement<br />

of the activity. The owner also has to pay an amount equal to its annual premium to the Central<br />

Government's Environment Relief Fund (ERF). The payment under the Act is only <strong>for</strong> the<br />

immediate relief; owners shall have to provide the final compensation, if any, arising out of the<br />

legal proceedings.<br />

2.2.8 Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980<br />

Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 pertains to the cases of diversion of <strong>for</strong>est area and felling of<br />

roadside plantation. Depending on the size of the tract to be cleared, clearances are applied <strong>for</strong> at<br />

the following levels of government:<br />

• If the area of <strong>for</strong>ests to be cleared or diverted exceeds 20ha (or, 10ha in hilly area) then prior<br />

permission of Central Government is required;<br />

24


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• If the area of <strong>for</strong>est to be cleared or diverted is between 5 to 20ha, the Regional Office of Chief<br />

Conservator of Forests is empowered to approve;<br />

• If the area of <strong>for</strong>est to be cleared or diverted is below or equal to 5ha, the State Government can<br />

give permission; and,<br />

• If the area to be clear-felled has a <strong>for</strong>est density of more than 40%, permission to undertake any<br />

work is needed from the Central Government, irrespective of the area to be cleared.<br />

Restrictions and clearance procedure <strong>proposed</strong> in the Forest (Conservation) Act applies wholly to<br />

the natural <strong>for</strong>est areas, even in case the protected/designated <strong>for</strong>est area does not have any<br />

vegetation cover. If the activities are going to necessitate the diversion of <strong>for</strong>est area, then the<br />

respective line departments have to take the necessary clearances from the Forest Department /<br />

MoEF.<br />

2.2.9 MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTES (MANAGEMENT AND HANDLING) RULES, 2000<br />

The Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000 provides <strong>for</strong> procedures <strong>for</strong><br />

collection, segregation, storage, transportation, processing and disposal of municipal solid waste.<br />

2.2.10 Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958<br />

According to this Act, area within radii of 100m and 300m from the “protected property” are<br />

designated as “protected area” and “controlled area” respectively. No development activity<br />

(including building, mining, excavating, blasting) is permitted in the “protected area” and<br />

development activities likely to damage the protected property are not permitted in the “controlled<br />

area” without prior permission of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) if the site/remains/<br />

monuments are protected by ASI or the State Department of Archaeology if these are protected by<br />

the State.<br />

Relevance to the Construction Projects (Housing and Office Complex):<br />

• Activities in protected areas should not be undertaken.<br />

• If activities are to be done in the controlled area of protected properties, then the necessary<br />

permissions should be taken from the ASI.<br />

2.3 Applicable Environmental Standards<br />

The MoEF has the overall responsibility to set policy and standards <strong>for</strong> the protection of<br />

environment along with Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB). This includes air, noise, water,<br />

and hazardous waste standards. The relevant standards, which may be of significance to the<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> project, are as follows:<br />

25


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

2.3.1 Ambient Air Quality Standards<br />

The standards <strong>for</strong> National Ambient Air Quality (NAAQS) has been prescribed by CPCB vide<br />

Gazette Notification dated 11th April 1994. The prescribed Indian standards are given in Annexure<br />

1.<br />

2.3.2 Ambient Noise Standards<br />

Ambient standards with respect to noise have been notified by the MoEF vide gazette notification<br />

dated 26th December 1989. It is based on the A weighted equivalent noise level (Leq). The<br />

standards are given in Annexure 2.<br />

2.3.3 Noise Standards <strong>for</strong> Occupational Exposure<br />

Noise standards in the work environment are specified by Occupational Safety and Health<br />

Administration (OSHA-USA) which in turn are being en<strong>for</strong>ced by the Government of India through<br />

model rules framed under the Factories Act. These are given in Annexure 3.<br />

2.3.4 Wastewater Discharge Standards<br />

The discharge of treated wastewater from the sewage treatment plant (STP) should comply with the<br />

norms prescribed by the Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC). These are given in Annexure<br />

4.<br />

2.3.5 Noise Standards <strong>for</strong> Stationary DG sets<br />

The prescribed noise standards <strong>for</strong> control of noise pollution from stationary Diesel Generator (DG)<br />

sets are given in Annexure 5.<br />

2.4 Environmental Clearance Requirements<br />

As per the policies and legal framework, <strong>for</strong> any new activity the following set of environmental<br />

approvals are necessary from the State Pollution Control Board (SPCB):<br />

• Consent to Establish<br />

• Consent to Operate<br />

2.4.1 Consent to Establish<br />

The provision of `Consent to Establish' under the Water and Air Acts have been made obligatory<br />

after amendments to the Acts made in 1988 and 1987 respectively. Earlier, SPCBs were issuing<br />

separate NOCs <strong>for</strong> only siting of an industry and <strong>for</strong> adequacy and appropriateness of pollution<br />

control equipment and related measures. This requirement has now been replaced by the `Consent<br />

to Establish' and even extended to projects on housing and office <strong>complex</strong>. However, some SPCBs<br />

26


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

have not yet notified the amended rules. In such cases, the proponent is still required to obtain a<br />

NOC from the SPCB and not the `Consent to Establish'.<br />

2.4.2 Consent to establish <strong>for</strong> discharge of effluents under the Water Act, 1974<br />

All projects (operation, process or any treatment and disposal system) which are likely to discharge<br />

sewage or trade effluents into a stream, sewer or on land, are required to obtain `Consent to<br />

Establish <strong>for</strong> Discharge of Effluents' under the Water Act, 1974 (amended in 1988). For obtaining<br />

this consent, an application is to be submitted to the concerned SPCB in the prescribed <strong>for</strong>m along<br />

with the prescribed application fee.<br />

2.4.3 Consent to establish <strong>for</strong> emission under the Air Act, 1981<br />

All projects (operation or process) located in an Air Pollution Control Area (APCA) declared so by<br />

the concerned SPCB, and likely to emit air pollutants in the atmosphere, are required to obtain<br />

`Consent to Establish <strong>for</strong> Emissions' under the Air Act, 1981 (amended in 1987). For obtaining this<br />

consent, an application is to be submitted to the concerned SPCB, in the prescribed <strong>for</strong>m and along<br />

with the prescribed application fee.<br />

After obtaining the `Consent to Establish' and `Environmental Clearance', the project proponents<br />

can begin work related to the setting up of the project. After this, a periodic compliance report is to<br />

be submitted indicating effective implementation of the recommendations and connotations.<br />

2.4.4 Environmental Public Hearing (Public Consultation)<br />

The public participation in the EIA process has become mandatory as per the latest notification SO<br />

318 (E) dated 10 April, 1997. As per the notification, the environmental public hearing process<br />

shall precede the grant of Consent to Establish. On receipt of application of Environmental Public<br />

Hearing and Consent to Establish, the SPCB constitutes Public Hearing Panel comprising of<br />

members representing:<br />

- State Pollution Control Board<br />

- State government department dealing with the subject<br />

- District Collector or his nominee<br />

- State government department dealing with the Environmental matters<br />

- Members (maximum) of Municipality/Panchayat<br />

- Senior Citizens from local area<br />

Following panel constitution, SPCB releases Notice <strong>for</strong> the EPH in two local newspapers inviting<br />

objections from the bonafide people likely to be affected by a project covered under EIA<br />

notification.<br />

27


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

2.5 Applicable State Level Legislations<br />

2.5.1 Delhi Water Board (Amendment) Bill, 2002<br />

The Delhi Water Board has been established under section 3 of the Delhi Water Board Act, 1998<br />

(Delhi Act No.4 of 1998) to discharge the functions of water supply, sewerage and sewage disposal<br />

and drainage within the National Capital Territory of Delhi and <strong>for</strong> matters connected therewith.<br />

This bill is to protect groundwater resources, to provide safeguards against hazards of its overexploitation<br />

and to ensure its planned development and management in the NCT of Delhi and <strong>for</strong><br />

matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. The bill empowers the board to develop, control,<br />

regulate and administer the groundwater in the state by ensuring its optimal and efficient utilization<br />

in consultation with the Central Groundwater Authority. This also provides <strong>for</strong> conjunctive use of<br />

surface and groundwater. This bill provides <strong>for</strong> registration of new users of wells and also<br />

prohibition of sinking wells in notified areas without permit. It empowers the authority to penalise<br />

the activities not in accordance with the act regarded as offences.<br />

2.5.2 The Delhi Plastic Bag (Manufacture, Sales and Usage) and Non-Biodegradable Garbage<br />

(Control) Act, 2000<br />

This Act has been enacted to prevent contamination of foodstuff carried in recycled plastic bag,<br />

reduce the use of plastic bag, throwing or depositing non-biodegradable garbage in public drain,<br />

roads and places open to public view in the National Capital Territory of Delhi.<br />

According to the Act, it shall be the duty of the owners and occupiers of lands and building to<br />

collect or to cause to be collected from their respective land and buildings the non biodegradable<br />

garbage and to be deposited, in public receptacles, deposits or places provided <strong>for</strong> temporary<br />

deposit or collection of the non-biodegradable garbage by the local authority in the area. Also, the<br />

owner should provide separate receptacles or dustbins, other than those kept and maintained <strong>for</strong><br />

deposit of bio-degradable garbage, of the type and in the manner prescribed by the local authority<br />

<strong>for</strong> collection therein of all the non-biodegradable waste from such land and building and to keep<br />

such receptacles / dustbins in good conditions and repair.<br />

3. PROJECT DESCRIPTION<br />

This section of the report describes the features of the <strong>proposed</strong> project in sufficient detail to allow<br />

an assessment of its environmental impact. A complete description is important to understand the<br />

potential environmental implications of the initiative and accordingly addressing issues in an<br />

28


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

appropriate manner. Description of the <strong>proposed</strong> project components and activities are presented<br />

together with the aspects during the construction and operation phase of the project which are also<br />

important from the environmental perspective.<br />

3.1 Major Project Components and Requirements<br />

The major project components and resource requirements are described below:<br />

3.1.1 Project Layout and Development Concept<br />

An <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong> <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy, National Law School, and National Institute of<br />

mediation and conciliation is <strong>proposed</strong> to be established in Delhi on a land measuring about<br />

49352.00 sq. meters (12.195 acres). This land has been allotted by the Delhi Development<br />

Authority (DDA) in Sector – 14, Dwarka, Phase – II, Delhi. All these three teaching components of<br />

the <strong>complex</strong> will function as independent institutions and will be <strong>integrated</strong> as a unified <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

In addition to the training programmes of the Judicial Academy and the Institute of Mediation and<br />

Conciliation, the National Law School will offer five years degree course in Law. All these<br />

Institutions shall share certain common facilities in the campus, while maintaining their identities<br />

and independent functioning.<br />

As there is requirement of substantial residential accommodation <strong>for</strong> the National Law School as<br />

well as <strong>for</strong> the Delhi Judicial Academy, the Ministry of Urban Development after the<br />

recommendation by DDA has issued a gazette notification to bifurcate the site with different land<br />

uses, namely Institutional and Residential.<br />

The layout plan of the <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong> has been developed keeping in view of the following<br />

major design considerations:<br />

• Meeting the projected spatial requirements <strong>for</strong> the entire <strong>complex</strong> as well as individual<br />

buildings, as per the design brief and other guidelines issued by the committee of the Hon.<br />

Judges of High Court of Delhi.<br />

• Fulfilling client’s aspirations <strong>for</strong> developing an institution with a conducive environment <strong>for</strong><br />

learning.<br />

• Design to be responsive, to the site parameters and the nature of building <strong>proposed</strong>.<br />

• Creating an architecturally satisfying building <strong>complex</strong> which will stand out as a landmark in<br />

the vicinity.<br />

• Adherence to the building bye-laws and master plan implications.<br />

After series of meetings with the officials of the Judicial Academy and with Hon. Judges of the<br />

Delhi High Court, the designs of various buildings and the layout of the <strong>complex</strong>, has been<br />

29


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

finalized, which has also been <strong>for</strong>mally approved by the Committee of Hon. Judges <strong>for</strong> the Judicial<br />

Academy.<br />

The overriding prime objective of the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong> is streamlining the functionary<br />

efficiency of the <strong>complex</strong> and catering to the needs of various users groups, such as the students of<br />

law college and trainees in the <strong>judicial</strong> <strong>academy</strong>, because both the user group have distinct<br />

identities and status in the <strong>judicial</strong> system. A combined building <strong>for</strong> the academic activities and a<br />

combined administration <strong>complex</strong> has been designed. The facilities like auditorium, cafeteria and<br />

library have been clubbed around the main buildings.<br />

According to the layout plan, the Academic Complex shall consist of the following building blocks:<br />

• Academic block<br />

• Administration and Management block<br />

• Library<br />

• Auditorium<br />

• Cafeteria and convenient shopping<br />

• Club building<br />

On the other hand the Residential Complex will accommodate the following structures:<br />

• Chairman’s residence<br />

• Director’s residence – Judicial Academy<br />

• Director’s residence – Law School<br />

• Staff housing<br />

• Hostel <strong>for</strong> trainees <strong>for</strong> Judicial Academy<br />

• Hostel <strong>for</strong> boys<br />

• Hostel <strong>for</strong> girls<br />

• Guest house <strong>for</strong> visiting faculty and guests.<br />

• Essential Staff<br />

3.1.2 Land Use and Area Statement<br />

The academic <strong>complex</strong> encompasses about 26172.00 sq. meters (6.467 acres) i.e. 53.03% of the<br />

total plot area. The <strong>proposed</strong> covered area on ground floor is 6156.381 sq. meters (23.52%) against<br />

the permissible ground coverage of 6543.00 sq. meters (25%) and with total built up area of<br />

34,223.275 sq. meters (including basement). FAR achieved have been 97.89 against the permissible<br />

FAR of 100. The details of <strong>proposed</strong> built up area of academic <strong>complex</strong> and other related buildings<br />

is given in Table 3.1.<br />

30


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The plot area under residential <strong>complex</strong> is about 23180.00 sq. meters (5.728 acres) i.e. 46.97% of<br />

the total plot area. The <strong>proposed</strong> covered area on ground floor is 6210.206 sq. meters (26.79%)<br />

against the permissible ground coverage of 7725.894 sq. meters (33.33%) and with total built up<br />

area of 33,959.864 sq. meters (including basement). FAR achieved have been 125.046 against the<br />

permissible FAR of 133. The details of <strong>proposed</strong> built up area of residential <strong>complex</strong> is given in<br />

Table 3.2. The detail of the <strong>proposed</strong> land use <strong>for</strong> the project is given in Table 3.3.<br />

3.1.3 Water Requirements and Supply<br />

As per the initial estimation, the average water requirement <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong> project will be 200<br />

m 3 /day during the construction phase and 297 m 3 /day during the operation phase. Water<br />

requirement during the construction phase will be met both through tankers and tubewells. The<br />

project proponent will obtain necessary permission from the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) be<strong>for</strong>e drawing<br />

water from the ground <strong>for</strong> the construction activity.<br />

Water during the operation phase will be partly met from the piped water supply network of DJB<br />

and partly from tubewells on site. Water conservation and rain water harvesting plan will be<br />

implemented as per DJB guidelines to conserve the resources.<br />

It is estimated about 200 m 3 of water will be reserved separately <strong>for</strong> fire fighting purpose in the<br />

premises.<br />

3.1.4 Power Requirements and Supply<br />

Power demand <strong>for</strong> the academic <strong>complex</strong> is estimated to be about 4250 KVA and <strong>for</strong> residential<br />

<strong>complex</strong> 570 KVA. Electricity supply shall be provided from the nearest 220/66 KV grid substation.<br />

A separate electrical room / sub-station building will be constructed separately in each of<br />

the <strong>complex</strong> as per the requirement. All fire and safety measures will be taken as directed by the<br />

concerned authority. The construction of electric sub station and installation of trans<strong>for</strong>mers, LT<br />

and HT panels shall be as per the provision specified by the concerned authorities.<br />

The power requirement during construction will be met either through DG sets or supply through<br />

the nearest grid.<br />

31


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 3.1<br />

Details of Proposed Built Up Area of Academic Complex and Other Related Buildings<br />

S.<br />

NO.<br />

BUILDING BLOCKS<br />

AREA AT BASEMENT FLOOR<br />

(IN SQ. METERS)<br />

NO. OF FLOORS<br />

(IN NOS.)<br />

AREA AT GROUND<br />

FLOOR<br />

(IN SQ. METERS)<br />

AREA ON ALL<br />

FLOORS<br />

(EXCLUDING<br />

BASEMENT)<br />

(IN SQ. METERS)<br />

1. Academic Block 8018.845<br />

B+G+5 1718.354 9411.862<br />

(Area at combined basement<br />

2. Auditorium Block below these three blocks)<br />

B+G+1 1389.37 2463.81<br />

3. Administration<br />

and Management Block<br />

B+G+6 2406.793 11098.07<br />

4. Club Block 582.058 B+G+2 641.864 1432.85<br />

TOTAL 8600.903 6156.381 24406.592<br />

32


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 3.2<br />

Details of Proposed Built Up Area of Residential Buildings<br />

S.<br />

NO.<br />

BUILDING BLOCKS<br />

AREA AT BASEMENT FLOOR<br />

(IN SQ. METERS)<br />

NO. OF FLOORS<br />

(IN NOS.)<br />

AREA AT GROUND<br />

FLOOR<br />

(IN SQ. METERS)<br />

AREA ON ALL<br />

FLOORS<br />

(EXCLUDING<br />

BASEMENT)<br />

(IN SQ. METERS)<br />

1. Chairman’s Residence - G+1 262.987 431.904<br />

2. Director’s Residences<br />

(2 Nos.)<br />

- G+1 397.474 648.856<br />

3. Hostel <strong>for</strong> Judicial<br />

Academy<br />

1365.114 B+G+4 1273.49 5597.798<br />

4. Girls Hostel 1804.536 B+G+6 1291.288 6191.486<br />

5. Boys Hostel 1804.536 B+G+6 1291.288 6191.486<br />

6. Staff Housing - S+9 710.256 6392.304<br />

7. Essential Staff Quarters - S+3 190.224 570.672<br />

8. Guest House - G+3 793.199 2917.697<br />

33


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

9. Area under lifts<br />

And stairs on stilt<br />

- - - 43.475<br />

TOTAL 4974.186 6210.206 28985.678<br />

Table 3.3<br />

Proposed Land Use <strong>for</strong> the Integrated Complex<br />

S.<br />

NO.<br />

LAND USE<br />

AREA (SQ. METERS)<br />

% OF THE TOTAL PLOT AREA<br />

I.E. 49352.00 SQ. METERS<br />

Academic Complex Residential Complex Academic Complex Residential Complex<br />

1. Plot Area 26172.00 23180.00 53.03 46.97<br />

2. Covered Area of Building<br />

at Ground Floor<br />

6156.381 6210.206 12.47 12.58<br />

3. Open Area 20015.619 16969.794 40.56 34.38<br />

4. Landscaped & Green Area 14059.159 12291.822 28.49 24.91<br />

5. Roads and Driveways 3043.33 2107.291 6.17 4.27<br />

6. Open Parking 2913.134 2570.681 5.90 5.21<br />

34


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

35


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

3.1.5 Back Up Power Supply System<br />

It is <strong>proposed</strong> to install four D.G. sets of 1000 KVA and one D.G. set of 500 KVA <strong>for</strong> full power<br />

back up in the academic <strong>complex</strong>. No DG set will be provided in the residential <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

However, certain essential services in it will be linked with the DG sets in the academic<br />

<strong>complex</strong>. The ventilating stacks of adequate height above the roof of the building will be<br />

provided as per the norms. Each DG set will also be equipped with state-of-the-art insulating and<br />

acoustic enclosures.<br />

3.1.6 Fuel Requirements<br />

Diesel / Industrial Oil will be consumed <strong>for</strong> Diesel Generators in case of Power failure. The<br />

Diesel and Oil if required to be stored on the site as a reserved stock, will be stored in a drum /<br />

tin with proper identification mark / labels in identified area. Fire and safety measures will be<br />

taken as per the guidelines from the concerned authority.<br />

3.1.7 Water Storage Tanks and Pump Room<br />

The project will provide two underground water storage tanks of capacities 250 m 3 and 225 m 3 in<br />

the academic and residential <strong>complex</strong> respectively. Additional overhead water storage tanks will<br />

also be provided in different blocks of the <strong>complex</strong>. Capacities of these tanks will be:<br />

In Academic Complex<br />

• Academic Block - 43,200 litres<br />

• Administration and Management Block - 50,000 litres<br />

• Auditorium and Cafeteria - 34,000 litres<br />

• Club Building - 25,000 litres<br />

In Residential Complex<br />

• Chairman’s Residence - 2000 litres<br />

• Director’s Residence - 4000 litres<br />

• Staff Housing - 41,200 litres<br />

• Guest House - 25,000 litres<br />

• Hostel <strong>for</strong> Judicial Academy - 27,000 litres<br />

• Boy’s Hostel - 38,000 litres<br />

• Girl’s Hostel - 38,000 litres<br />

• Essential Staff Housing - 5400 litres<br />

36


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

A substantial portion of the basement will be utilized <strong>for</strong> the pump room. It is estimated about<br />

60% of the water requirement will be met through piped water supply from DJB and the<br />

remaining from ground water.<br />

3.1.8 Sewage Collection, Treatment and Disposal System<br />

It is <strong>proposed</strong> to establish one STP of 250 m 3 /day capacity in the <strong>complex</strong> based on aerobic<br />

Fluidized Bed Reactor Technology. The wastewater generated will be treated up to tertiary level.<br />

The single STP will serve both the academic and residential <strong>complex</strong>. The wastewater will be<br />

collected through a network of drainage system to be designed accordingly keeping in view the<br />

location of the STP. The treated effluent will be mostly reused <strong>for</strong> flushing of toilets in the<br />

residential <strong>complex</strong> and <strong>for</strong> gardening. Dual plumbing system will be provided <strong>for</strong> utilizing<br />

treated water <strong>for</strong> flushing of toilets. Unutilized treated effluent shall be discharged into the<br />

municipal sewerage network which is available around the <strong>proposed</strong> site. Reuse of treated<br />

effluent within the <strong>complex</strong> will reduce the overall requirement of fresh water as well as put less<br />

load on the existing sewerage network.<br />

During the project construction phase, the major source of water pollution will be sewage from<br />

labour camps and makeshift office. It is expected that at any given time during the construction<br />

phase, the peak manpower strength on construction site comprising of technical staff,<br />

clerical/supervisor, skilled and unskilled workers would be about 500 persons. The average<br />

domestic water requirements would be about 50 lpcd. Thus, total water requirements work out to<br />

be 25,000 litres / day (max.). It is assumed that about 80% of the water required will be<br />

generated as sewage. Thus, total quantum of sewage generated in peak situation is expected to be<br />

about 20,000 litres / day. The generated sewage would pass through a septic tank and its<br />

discharge would be connected to the existing municipal sewage network of the area.<br />

3.1.9 Storm Water Drainage System<br />

All along the road storm water drains would be provided to collect water during rains. They<br />

would be adequately sized to prevent over flooding of the site. The storm water collection system<br />

will be designed in such a manner so that clean storm water from garden, parking areas,<br />

roadways and lawns is used <strong>for</strong> recharging of ground water. The excess run off will be directed<br />

towards the nearest storm water drain.<br />

37


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

3.1.10 Internal Road Network and Vehicle Parking<br />

The layout plan of the <strong>proposed</strong> site has developed an internal road network in such a manner<br />

that it will not only cater to various buildings but also integrate the whole <strong>complex</strong> in an<br />

interesting composition of built masses and open spaces with a pedestrian dominated movement<br />

pattern.<br />

Entry points to the <strong>complex</strong> have been worked out keeping in view the desired movement of<br />

vehicles. Main <strong>for</strong>mal entry to the Administration block is planned from the main road on the<br />

Southern side, whereas a second entry is planned from the Western side <strong>for</strong> students.<br />

The entry to the residential <strong>complex</strong> is planned from the side road on Eastern side. This road<br />

leads to the Metro rail station in sector-14 from where inhabitants of the residential <strong>complex</strong> will<br />

be able to communicate and travel to main city.<br />

Adequately wide roads to cater to two way traffic and to meet the fire regulations are planned in<br />

the <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

It is <strong>proposed</strong> to provide total equivalent car space (ECS) of 356 in the academic <strong>complex</strong>. This<br />

includes 126 ECS <strong>for</strong> open parking and 230 ECS <strong>for</strong> basement parking. The total area covered<br />

under open parking is 2913.134 sq. meters and in combined basement 7385.123 sq. meters.<br />

The total 115 ECS will be provided in the residential housing and 187 ECS in hostels. Parking<br />

facilities in the residential housing includes 79 ECS in open parking, 30 ECS in stilt parking and<br />

6 ECS in covered garages. In the Hostels, 32 ECS will be provided in open parking and 155 ECS<br />

in basement. The total area covered in open parking in the residential <strong>complex</strong> is 2570.681 sq.<br />

meters, 857.005 sq. meters in stilt parking and 4974.186 sq. meters in basement parking.<br />

3.1.11 Air Conditioning System<br />

The complete academic <strong>complex</strong> and a part of residential <strong>complex</strong> would be fitted with a central<br />

air conditioning system using water cooled rotary scress chillers to provide summer / monsoon<br />

cooling and winter heating. It is <strong>proposed</strong> to install 4 nos. chillers of each of 400 TR capacity<br />

working in conjunction with dedicated chilled and condenser water pumps (having a redundant<br />

pump on each circuit) to maintain an ambient temperature of 24+- 1 o C, with relative humidity in<br />

region of 50 – 60%. The complete system will consist of water cooled rotary screw chillers along<br />

with condenser water pump sets, chilled water pump sets, air handling units, electrical works,<br />

38


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

GSS ducting, duct lining, duct insulation, powder coated aluminium grills and diffusers and other<br />

accessories <strong>for</strong> total air conditioned area of 15,835 sq. meters in the academic <strong>complex</strong> and 6530<br />

sq. meters in the residential <strong>complex</strong> to cater to a refrigeration load of 1520 TR approximately<br />

with a diversity of 0.95.<br />

The water chilling machines, condenser and chilled water pump sets, main electrical panel shall<br />

be installed in the plant room located in the services building and cooling towers shall be<br />

installed on terrace of utility block. The chilled water produced by the water chilling machines<br />

shall be fed to various air handling units located on various floors with the help of buried /<br />

insulated chilled water piping running in vertical shafts. The salient feature of the HVAC system<br />

design include optimization of power demand by installation of Energy Recovery Wheel (ERW)<br />

in the fresh air system, to reduce the refrigeration load by 805, which in turn will also reduce the<br />

air conditioning plant load by 12 – 15%.<br />

The design also envisaged mechanical ventilation <strong>for</strong> the basements, lift well, stair case, plant<br />

room and other similar areas. Mechanical ventilation <strong>for</strong> basement involves 10 air changes per<br />

hour and in case of fire, same would be increased to 30 air changes per hour.<br />

The total electrical connected load will be approximately 1500 KW.<br />

The chillers used in the <strong>proposed</strong> air conditioning plant will be of non CFC and HCFC<br />

specifications.<br />

The daily make up water requirements <strong>for</strong> the system will be about 42,000 litres. The water<br />

requirements will take into consideration the following U values <strong>proposed</strong> to be achieved <strong>for</strong>:<br />

• Walls – 0.36 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

• Floors – 0.46 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

• Roofs - 0.12 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

• Windows - 1.13 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

The expected quality of water required <strong>for</strong> the system will be less than 7 pH value.<br />

3.1.12 Fire Fighting System<br />

Fire fighting system in the <strong>complex</strong> will consist of fire detection system and fire fighting system.<br />

Automatic fire detection system with different types of heat and smoke detectors will be<br />

39


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

provided in different areas of the building. The system shall be connected to the fire alarm<br />

system. An emergency intercommunication system shall be provided <strong>for</strong> the entire building. The<br />

control room / security room with communication system to all floors and facility <strong>for</strong> receiving<br />

messages from different floors shall be provided at entrance on ground floor.<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong> will be provided with adequate fire protection arrangements such as<br />

underground water storage tank of 2 lakh litres capacity, one over head water storage tank of<br />

20,000 litres capacity, fire pump, wet riser system, hose reel, hose box, fire alarm system,<br />

portable fire extinguisher, one standby DG set connected with lift, fire pump, emergency light.<br />

Automatic sprinklers shall be installed in the entire building. The portable fire extinguishers shall<br />

be provided at strategic locations.<br />

It is also <strong>proposed</strong> to appoint a qualified fire officer in the building to maintain / look after fire<br />

fighting system / fire order. To prevent any fire hazard, good house keeping inside and outside<br />

the building shall be strictly maintained.<br />

3.1.13 Solar Water Heating System<br />

It is also <strong>proposed</strong> to provide solar water heating system in the hostel and staff housing block of<br />

the residential <strong>complex</strong>. The system will consist of solar panels, insulated hot water storage tank,<br />

and insulated piping. The estimated demand <strong>for</strong> the hot water will be about 10,000 litres per day.<br />

3.2 Project Activities<br />

3.2.1 Construction Phase<br />

The civil works <strong>for</strong> the construction and development of <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong> include bulk<br />

earthworks, construction of internal roads, pavements, parking area, underground water storage<br />

tanks, foundations <strong>for</strong> buildings and structures, installation of storm water drainage, water<br />

supply, and sewage drainage network, services, landscaping and security fencing. Detailed<br />

excavation will be required <strong>for</strong> the multi-storeyed buildings. Other excavation will be limited to<br />

trenching <strong>for</strong> storm water, water tanks, sewerage, electrical rooms/sub-stations and other<br />

facilities. AC plant, pump room and storage etc. will be based in the lower basement of the<br />

services building block of the <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

40


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

3.2.2 Operation Phase<br />

The regular operation and maintenance will be required <strong>for</strong> sewage treatment plant, air<br />

conditioning plant, pumps, and DG sets. These will be equipped with electrical control and<br />

mechanical fittings. The maintenance of bore well area and rainwater harvesting system will be<br />

required both on short term and long term basis. The trained operators will be deployed on all<br />

these facilities.<br />

3.3 Water Balance Statement<br />

The water balance <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong> project during the construction and operation phase is given<br />

below:<br />

3.3.1 CONSTRUCTION PHASE<br />

• Total water requirement during the construction phase (<strong>for</strong><br />

concrete curing, mortar mixing and curing <strong>for</strong> block work,<br />

mortar mixing and curing <strong>for</strong> plastering, floor finishes, roof<br />

works / Screed, and sprinkling <strong>for</strong> dust suppression) is<br />

estimated to be about<br />

• Total water requirement during the construction phase <strong>for</strong><br />

domestic purpose<br />

112,500 m 3<br />

37,500 m 3<br />

• Construction Period 30 months<br />

• No. of working days / month 25<br />

• Total no. of working days 750<br />

Average water consumption per day (For Construction) 150 m 3<br />

Average water consumption per day (For Domestic) 50 m 3<br />

3.3.2 OPERATION PHASE<br />

• Water Requirement <strong>for</strong> Academic Complex:<br />

i) Break Up of daily water consumption<br />

Academic Block<br />

Administration Block<br />

= 46,000 litres<br />

= 60,000 litres<br />

41


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Auditorium<br />

= 14,000 litres<br />

Club Bldg.<br />

= 5000 litres<br />

Sub-stations<br />

= 2000 litres<br />

Site Office<br />

= 2000 litres<br />

(Above requirements has been worked out based on Non-Residential Building requirement<br />

@ 45 litres per capita per day, 10% floating population, and assuming occupancy @ 10 sq.<br />

meter per person).<br />

Total Water Requirements <strong>for</strong> Academic Complex<br />

= 129 m 3 /day<br />

ii)<br />

Wastewater Generation<br />

Assuming 80% of this coming out as waste water, Quantity of waste water generated from<br />

the Academic Complex is estimated to be about 103 m 3 /day.<br />

• Water Requirement <strong>for</strong> Residential Complex:<br />

i) Break Up of daily water consumption<br />

Chairman’s Residence (G+1)<br />

Director’s Residence (G+1, 2 nos.)<br />

Staff housing (36 nos., G+9) 36x5x200<br />

Guest House (G+ 3, 24 suits) 24x1.5x200<br />

Hostel <strong>for</strong> J. Academy (B+G+4) 80X200<br />

Hostel <strong>for</strong> Boys (G+6, 200 Person) 200x200<br />

Hostel <strong>for</strong> Girls (G+6, 200 Person) 200x200<br />

Essential Staff Quarters (S+3, 12 nos.) 12x5x200<br />

= 2000 litres<br />

= 4000 litres<br />

= 36,000 litres<br />

= 7200 litres<br />

= 16,000 litres<br />

= 40,000 litres<br />

= 40,000 litres<br />

= 12,000 litres<br />

Total Water Requirements <strong>for</strong> Residential Complex = 157 m 3 /day<br />

Considering 20% of daily water consumption as recycled water <strong>for</strong> toilet flushing, the total<br />

potable water requirement <strong>for</strong> drinking and other purposes = 126 m 3 /day<br />

Quantity of treated water used <strong>for</strong> flushing purpose = 31 m 3 /day<br />

ii)<br />

Wastewater Generation<br />

Assuming 80% of daily potable water consumption coming out as waste water,<br />

Wastewater Quantity<br />

= 101 m 3 /day<br />

42


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Total Wastewater Quantity from the Residential Complex<br />

= 101 + 31 = 132 m 3 /day<br />

Total Average Wastewater flow from both Academic and Residential Complex is estimated<br />

to be about<br />

= 103 + 132 = 235 m 3 /day<br />

Hence it is <strong>proposed</strong> to set up a Sewage Treatment Plant of capacity 250 m 3 /day.<br />

• AC Make Up Water Requirement:<br />

The make up water requirements <strong>for</strong> the air conditioning plant will be about = 42 m 3 /day<br />

Figure 3.0 gives the water balance diagram of the <strong>proposed</strong> project during the operation phase.<br />

3.4 Building Design Features on Seismic Load<br />

Various measures taken to make the <strong>proposed</strong> building structure earthquake resistance include:<br />

• Building designed as a RCC framed structure.<br />

• The design of frame structures is based on stipulation of I.S. codes of earthquake design (I.S.<br />

1893)<br />

• Ductility provisions to improve earthquake resistivity, as per the Indian Standards<br />

requirement also being incorporated.<br />

As such the structure is designed <strong>for</strong> earthquake resistivity taking into account latest provisions<br />

of Indian Standars codes <strong>for</strong> earthquake resistivity.<br />

3.5 Resource and Construction Material Requirements<br />

Construction of the project components will require the use of renewable and non-renewable<br />

resources including wood, gravel, sand, steel, concrete, cement, bricks and paper products. The<br />

materials, apart from paper products, will be used during the construction period only and will<br />

not be required during the operation phase of the project. Paper products (e.g., paper, cardboard)<br />

will be used during the operation <strong>for</strong> record keeping, general commercial use etc. However, their<br />

use will be minimized. The estimated quantities of construction materials required are given in<br />

Table 3.4.<br />

During the construction activity, it is expected that no fill materials will be transported from<br />

outside. The total quantity of earthwork involved is estimated to be about 91,000 m 3 .<br />

43


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 3.0: Water Balance (m 3 /day)<br />

Water Supply<br />

(60% from DJB and rest from Bore well on site)<br />

297 m 3 /day (Potable Water)<br />

126 m 3 /day 129 m 3 /day 42 m 3 /day<br />

Residential<br />

Complex<br />

Academic<br />

Complex<br />

Air Conditioned<br />

Make Up Water<br />

132 m 3 /day<br />

103 m 3 /day<br />

Sewage<br />

Treatment Plant<br />

of Capacity 250<br />

m 3 /day<br />

Treated Water<br />

31 m 3 /day<br />

Toilet<br />

Flushing<br />

Gardening<br />

(in both<br />

<strong>complex</strong>)<br />

44


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The material used <strong>for</strong> construction of the building will be of non – combustible nature. Non –<br />

combustible material will only be used <strong>for</strong> the construction / erection of false ceiling including<br />

all fixtures and used <strong>for</strong> its suspension / erection etc. and of low flame rating.<br />

Fossil fuels, such as diesel fuel, gasoline and oil will be used during the construction and<br />

operation of the project <strong>for</strong> mechanical and electrical equipments.<br />

Electricity will be used during construction to provide power to construction equipment and<br />

during operation <strong>for</strong> lighting of buildings and running utilities equipments. Electricity<br />

consumption will be kept at a minimum when possible by adopting electricity conservation<br />

measures.<br />

Table 3.4<br />

Estimated Quantities of Construction Materials<br />

Type of Construction Material Unit Quantity<br />

Sand m 3 50,200<br />

Coarse aggregate m 3 45,000<br />

Fine aggregate m 3 48,000<br />

Cement MT 16,800<br />

Structural steel MT 200<br />

Rein<strong>for</strong>cement steel MT 3500<br />

Wood m 2 54,000<br />

Bricks / Blocks For 75 mm thick b.w. 3,20,700*<br />

* 25% of total bricks used in the project will be fly ash bricks.<br />

3.6 Solid, Liquid and Gaseous Wastes Generation<br />

Dust will be generated during the construction phase from earthworks, movement of vehicles and<br />

by wind erosion of areas cleared of vegetation. The degree of dust generated would depend on<br />

the soil compaction and moisture content of the ground surface during construction.<br />

The generation of waste material is inevitable during the construction phase of the development.<br />

Waste materials normally include general refuse including scrap metal, cardboard, plastics; inert<br />

waste including excess fill and building rubble; and sewage wastes from the construction<br />

workers housing. Clean waste material such as rock and rubble will mostly be used <strong>for</strong> earth fill<br />

on the site itself. Other solid wastes generated during construction will be needed to be disposed<br />

to a designated landfill site.<br />

45


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Domestic sewage will be generated during the operation phase of the project which will be<br />

treated in the <strong>proposed</strong> STP in the <strong>complex</strong>. Significant proportion of Municipal Solid Wastes<br />

will be generated from both the academic and residential <strong>complex</strong> and will need to be disposed<br />

off safely. The sludge generated from STP will be reused in horticulture within and outside the<br />

project site.<br />

3.7 Construction Plan and Timetable<br />

The preliminary schedule and timetable of major construction activities is outlined in Table 3.5.<br />

The total construction period <strong>for</strong> the entire <strong>complex</strong> will be about 30 months. This schedule is<br />

dependant on receiving timely environmental approvals from the concerned authorities.<br />

Table 3.5<br />

Proposed Integrated Judicial Complex Construction Schedule<br />

project activity<br />

Earth Excavation<br />

Casting of foundations and basement<br />

Casting of roof slabs<br />

Finishing<br />

Development and other related work<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> duration (FROM<br />

START DATE)<br />

1 month<br />

4 months<br />

18 months<br />

24 months<br />

30 months<br />

3.8 Construction Work<strong>for</strong>ce Requirements<br />

The site works during construction are highly labour intensive and a sizeable work<strong>for</strong>ce is<br />

anticipated. The entire project will be executed in 30 months period. The peak labour <strong>for</strong>ce<br />

requirement <strong>for</strong> the project will be about 1500 workers. It is expected that about 500 workers<br />

will stay in temporary shelters on the site during the construction period.<br />

3.9 Project Cost<br />

The estimated cost of the project including construction and machinery cost is expected to be Rs<br />

125 crores.<br />

3.10 Project Site Layout Plan and Model Photographs<br />

46


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project site layout plan <strong>for</strong> the construction of academic and residential <strong>integrated</strong><br />

<strong>complex</strong> is given in Figure 3.1. This illustrates the major project components and their locations<br />

on the site. Figure 3.2 and 3.3 gives the model photographs of the <strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

47


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 3.1: Proposed Project Site Layout Plan


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 3.2: Model Photograph – I


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 3.3: Model Photograph – II


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

4. DESCRIPTION OF THE EXISTING ENVIRONMENT<br />

4.1 Introduction<br />

This chapter describes the existing environmental characteristics of the project area. Be<strong>for</strong>e start of<br />

any EIA study, it is necessary to identify the baseline levels of relevant environmental parameters<br />

which are likely to be affected as a result of the construction and operation of the <strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

The baseline status of various environmental attributes at the micro and macro levels determines<br />

the existing environmental quality of the project area and serves as the basis <strong>for</strong> identification and<br />

prediction of impacts. The environmental quality of the project area is assessed through both field<br />

studies and secondary sources within the environmental impact zone <strong>for</strong> various components of<br />

environment, viz. Air, Noise, Water, Biological, Land and Socio-economic. The baseline<br />

environmental status <strong>for</strong> the summer season 2006 in the present REIA study has been assessed<br />

within core (local and immediate vicinity) and buffer (within 10 km radius) zone from the <strong>proposed</strong><br />

project construction site. The summary of data collected from various sources as a part of the REIA<br />

study is outlined in Table 4.1.<br />

4.2 Physiography<br />

Physiographically, the NCT of Delhi has two distinct natural features - "the ridge", which is the<br />

rocky outcrop of Aravalli Hills and the "River Yamuna", which flows in eastern side of Delhi and<br />

flows in southern direction. Further, the distinct physiographic units of NCT of Delhi are:<br />

• Old flood plain (old Khadar) and Recent flood plain (new Khadar) of Yamuna River<br />

• Upper Alluvial plain (Bangar)<br />

• The quartzite ridge (Kohi)<br />

• The nearly closed alluvial basin of chattarpur in South Delhi<br />

Figure 4.1 shows the physiographic regions map of Delhi. Delhi sprawls over 1483-sq km between<br />

latitude 28 0 34’ N and a longitude of 77 0 07’ E. The average elevation of Delhi plain is 198 m to 200<br />

m above the mean sea level (amsl).<br />

The ridge, however has a higher elevation going upto 250 m above mean sea level (amsl) and is<br />

about 15 to 20 m above the surrounding plains. The Shahdara area drains from East to West into<br />

Yamuna River. Similarly Delhi and New Delhi areas also drain in Yamuna River through various<br />

drains such as Najafgarh drain. Many small watercourses intersect the terrain causing a variation in<br />

relief. However, the average gradient of terrain is gentle, in the order of 1 to 3 m per km.<br />

51


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.1: Physiographic Regions Map of Delhi<br />

52


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

East to South-South-West.<br />

aspect<br />

Delhi area is generally flat except <strong>for</strong> a gentle rise to <strong>for</strong>m a central ridge from North-North-<br />

Micrometeorology<br />

Ambient<br />

Quality<br />

Ambient<br />

Quality<br />

Air<br />

Noise<br />

Ground Water<br />

Quality<br />

Ground Water<br />

Hydrology<br />

Table 4.1<br />

Summary of Data Collection from Various Sources<br />

mode of data<br />

collection<br />

Primary<br />

Secondary<br />

Primary<br />

Primary<br />

and<br />

parameters monitored frequency source (s)<br />

Temperature, Humidity,<br />

Wind Speed, Wind<br />

Direction, Rainfall<br />

SPM, RPM, SO2, NOX,<br />

CO<br />

Hourly noise equivalent<br />

levels (L day , L night , L dn )<br />

Primary Physico – chemical<br />

parameters<br />

Secondary<br />

Ground water table, rate<br />

of recharge, available<br />

yield,<br />

aquifer<br />

characteristics<br />

Soil Quality Primary Physico Chemical<br />

parameters<br />

Three months<br />

(March to May<br />

2006)<br />

Twice a week <strong>for</strong> 4<br />

weeks <strong>for</strong> three<br />

months<br />

Once in a season<br />

Once in a season<br />

Field Studies and<br />

Indian<br />

Meteorological<br />

Department (IMD)<br />

Field Studies<br />

Field Studies<br />

Field Studies<br />

- Central Ground<br />

Water Board<br />

Once in a season<br />

Field Studies<br />

Vegetation Secondary Type of species - Forest Department<br />

Socio Economic Secondary Demographic and socio<br />

economic parameters,<br />

physical and social<br />

infrastructure<br />

- Census Data 2001,<br />

DDA, Other<br />

published reports<br />

4.3 Climate<br />

The average annual rainfall in the NCT of Delhi is 612 mm. The rainfall over NCT of Delhi<br />

generates surface water run-off through streams, drains and as sheet flow. Delhi being highly<br />

urbanized the percentage run-off is high due to the extensive paved area. The average annual<br />

evaporation is about 2540 mm in Delhi. The mean relative humidity is 66%.<br />

The climatic regime of Delhi falls under the semi arid type, as influenced by the considerable<br />

distance of the city from the sea and prevalence of continental winds during major portion of the<br />

year. Extreme dryness with hot summers and cold winters are characteristics of the climate. The<br />

year can broadly be divided into four seasons. The cold season starts towards the later half of<br />

November when both day and night temperature drop rapidly with the advance of the season.<br />

53


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

January is the coldest month with the mean daily maximum temperature at 21.3ºC and the<br />

mean daily minimum at 7.3ºC.<br />

This is followed by the hot season starting in March, which lasts till about the end of June when the<br />

monsoon arrives. May and June are the hottest months. While day temperatures are higher in May<br />

the nights are warmer in June. From April the hot wind known locally as ‘looh’ blows and the<br />

weather is unpleasant. In May and June maximum temperature may sometimes reach 46 or 47 ºC.<br />

April and May are the driest months with relative humidity of 30% in the morning and less then<br />

20% in the afternoon. The monsoon continues until the last week of September. The two post<br />

monsoon months of October and November constitute a transition period from the monsoon to the<br />

winter season.<br />

The monsoon season witnesses the least pollution due to frequent washout of pollutants along with<br />

rains. Mixing height is one of the important parameters that influence the dilution of pollutants. It<br />

follows diurnal and seasonal variations. During winter, ground based temperature inversions are a<br />

regular feature that restricts mixing height to low levels. Lower temperatures, calm conditions,<br />

lower mixing height, and temperature inversions during winter is to restrict and confine pollutant<br />

dispersion and dispersal (CPCB 1993/94 and CPCB 2000).<br />

4.4 Micro Meteorological Characteristics<br />

Winter evenings, have higher pollution build-up because of frequent calm conditions with<br />

temperature inversions resulting in poor natural ventilation and high emission loads due to evening<br />

traffic peaks. In the summer season, there are frequent pre-monsoon dust storms, when strong<br />

westerly winds from Rajasthan desert deposit large concentration of dust particles in Delhi’s<br />

atmosphere.<br />

The study area, a part of South West District of Delhi, receives about 81.2% of the annual rainfall<br />

during the monsoon months June to September. On an average, rain of 2.5 mm or more falls on<br />

38.3 days in a year in this region of Delhi. The annual average rainfall is about 792.8 mm based on<br />

22 years of data. The rainfall intensity of 20 to 30 mm generally occurs in one hour duration.<br />

A mechanical meteorological station was installed at the <strong>proposed</strong> project site <strong>for</strong> three months<br />

during the months of March to May 2006 to record various meteorological parameters on hourly<br />

basis to understand the local wind speed, wind direction, Temperature variation, relative humidity<br />

variation etc.<br />

During the study period the wind roses are plotted at an interval <strong>for</strong> 24 hrs (00-24hrs). Figure 4.2<br />

represents the wind pattern of the study period.<br />

54


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

4.5 Air Environment<br />

55


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The quality of ambient air depends upon the background concentration of specific pollutants,<br />

the sources of emission and meteorological conditions. The baseline studies on air environment<br />

include identification of specific air pollution parameters and assessing their existing levels in<br />

ambient air.<br />

4.5.1 Ambient Air Quality Scenario in Delhi<br />

The air quality in<strong>for</strong>mation on air quality statistics from the various urban areas in the country,<br />

generated from the NAMP network is compiled and published regularly by the CPCB. The air<br />

quality parameters regularly monitored nationwide are SPM (8 hourly <strong>for</strong> 24 hours), sulphur<br />

dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxide (NOx) (4 hourly <strong>for</strong> 24 hours), while additional parameters like<br />

carbon monoxide (CO), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), ozone, respirable suspended<br />

particulate matter (RSPM), benzene and trace metals are additionally monitored in Delhi and some<br />

other cities, but not in all the cities. The annual ambient air quality data of CPCB <strong>for</strong> the years 1995<br />

and 2002 has been studied and comparison of data <strong>for</strong> the respective years has been made to<br />

establish trends in the air quality of these years <strong>for</strong> Delhi area.<br />

Delhi, in terms of air pollution, was ranked fourth among the 41 most polluted cities in the world,<br />

in the 90’s. The annual average levels of suspended particulate matter increased to 450 µg/m 3<br />

during 1996, which is nearly three times the National Ambient Air Quality Standard of 140 µg / m 3<br />

<strong>for</strong> residential areas as notified by the Ministry of Environment, Govt. of India. During this period,<br />

the annual average levels of CO also increased to 5587 µg/m 3 as against the National Ambient Air<br />

Quality Standard of 2000 µg / m 3 <strong>for</strong> the residential areas. Vehicles, thermal power plants and large<br />

as well as small-scale industrial units in Delhi were the major sources of these pollutants.<br />

Though Delhi remains a polluted city, there is not much of chemical pollution. The period from<br />

1989 to 1996 saw a rapid increase in pollution levels. The Year 1996 may be considered as the peak<br />

year. But in the wake of use of CNG as an alternate fuel, the contribution of vehicular sector<br />

towards air pollution has been reduced in the subsequent years. This is also supported by the fact<br />

that there is a significant improvement in the air quality. The best place to witness this change is the<br />

busy ITO traffic intersection, where toxic fumes no longer irritate the eyes as earlier. Carbon<br />

Monoxide, Nitrogen Dioxide, Lead and Sulphur Dioxide levels have all shown a declining trend.<br />

The annual average of 42 µg / m 3 of Sulphur Dioxide in the year 1996 came down to as much as 18<br />

µg / m 3 during 2002 at ITO Intersection, whereas NO2 came down from 75 µg / m 3 in 1996 to 59<br />

µg / m 3 in 2002. Further, there has been a marked decline in the annual Lead levels after<br />

introduction of unleaded petrol in 1998. Also, the results show a significant improvement in the<br />

overall air quality of the city. The concentration of Carbon Monoxide has fallen by 32 per cent;<br />

Sulphur Dioxide levels have fallen by 39 per cent in 2002 as compared to 1997. The concentration<br />

of other pollutants like Lead and Benzene has also registered a marked decline.<br />

56


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Despite the phenomenal growth in vehicular population, the levels of Nitrogen Dioxide have<br />

remained more or less constant, this can be attributed to the phasing out of old commercial vehicles<br />

and implementation of Euro-I and subsequently Euro-II norms <strong>for</strong> petrol and diesel driven private<br />

vehicles.<br />

The main fuels used in vehicles are petrol, diesel and CNG Gas. The main pollutants that come out<br />

from the exhaust tail of vehicular engines are:<br />

- Carbon dioxide<br />

- Carbon monoxides<br />

- Oxides of Nitrogen<br />

- Oxides of Sulphur<br />

- Hydrocarbon, and<br />

- Particulate Matter<br />

In addition to above pollutants, unburnt products like aldehydes, <strong>for</strong>maldehydes, acrolein,<br />

acetaldehyde and smoke would also be emitted from petrol and diesel operated vehicles. The<br />

concentration of these pollutants in the engine exhaust varies with the type of engine namely, spark<br />

ignition (petrol engine) or compression ignition (diesel engine) two stroke or four stroke engines;<br />

and also mode of engine operation. Table 4.2 gives the emission factor of various major pollutants<br />

from petrol (SI), diesel (CI) and CNG engines.<br />

Diesel exhaust concentration of hydrocarbons is more than that of SI engine exhaust. Carbon<br />

monoxide concentrations in diesel engine exhaust is negligible to that of SI engines. Concentration<br />

of oxides of nitrogen is more in diesel exhaust. Thus diesel engine exhaust contains lower<br />

concentrations of harmful pollutants like hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide and there<strong>for</strong>e, it is less<br />

hazardous. Table 4.3 summarises the comparative emissions from CNG and Diesel engines. From<br />

this table it could be concluded that CO, NOx and PM are about 45 to 300% higher in diesel<br />

vehicles than CNG vehicles.<br />

Sulphur Dioxide<br />

The oxides of sulphur (SOx) occur in ambient air to a large extent as primary specific pollutants in<br />

the <strong>for</strong>m of sulphur dioxide (SO2) and sulphur trioxide(SO3) under ambient conditions. It has been<br />

observed that the percentage of SO2 existing in ambient air may be more than 95 percent, while the<br />

remaining 5 per cent or less of SOx may be in the <strong>for</strong>m of sulphur trioxide. The major atmospheric<br />

man-made sources of SO2 are burning of fossil fuels in stationary combustion and industrial<br />

processes, viz. petroleum, chemical, metallurgical and mineral industries, domestic emissions and<br />

fires, while the natural sources are volcanoes, geothermal activity, bacterial decomposition of<br />

organic matter, <strong>for</strong>est fires, etc. These sources are described in the Figure 4.3.<br />

57


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The record shows that over the last few years, the levels of SO 2 have drastically come down<br />

in the ambient air of Delhi. Annual mean SO 2 levels were observed as 18.03 µg/m 3 , 14.1 µg/m 3 ,<br />

11.3 µg/m 3 in the year 2000, 2001 and 2002 respectively. SO 2 levels decreased by 21.8 % & 19.6<br />

% in the year 2001 & 2002 respectively. The annual mean SO 2 levels in Delhi satisfy the annual<br />

average of National Ambient Air quality Standards <strong>for</strong> residential areas, which is 60 µg/m 3 .<br />

Nitrogen Dioxide<br />

The nitrogen oxides exist in ambient air in various <strong>for</strong>ms viz. nitrous oxide (N2O), nitric oxide<br />

(NO), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), nitrogen trioxide (NO3), nitrogen tetroxide (N2O4) and nitrogen<br />

sesquioxide (N2O5). However, only nitric oxide and nitrogen dioxide that exist freely in air are<br />

important as air pollutants. Generally, the atmospheric concentration of nitric oxide and nitrogen<br />

dioxide are clubbed together and reported as oxides of nitrogen (NOx). The nitric oxide (NO) in<br />

ambient environment is less stable and rapidly gets converted to nitrogen dioxide. The nitrogen<br />

dioxide is considered to be important from the view point of pollution and smog <strong>for</strong>mation,<br />

primarily because of its photo-dissipation effect into ozone and oxidation products of hydrocarbons,<br />

wherever the unburnt hydrocarbon exists in atmospheric air. Sources of oxides of nitrogen are<br />

presented in Figure 4.4.<br />

The figure shows the annual average values of NO2 observed during last six years. Despite, an<br />

increase in the number of vehicles from 1997 to 2002, the NO2 levels have shown an increase from<br />

41.7 to 47.2 µg / m 3 which is not very significant. The annual mean of NO2 levels in Delhi is well<br />

within the annual average of National Ambient Air Quality Standards <strong>for</strong> residential areas, which is<br />

60 µg/ m 3 .<br />

Suspended Particulate Matter (SPM)<br />

The airborne particles or particulate matter (PM) can be solid or comprising liquid droplets of<br />

diameter ranging between 0.002 to 500 micron having a life time in suspension varying from few<br />

seconds to several months. The suspended particulate matter (SPM) are the particles/aerosols<br />

having diameter less than 100 micron that tend to remain suspended in the atmosphere <strong>for</strong> a long<br />

period of time. The particles may be directly emitted into the atmosphere. The sources of PM, SPM<br />

and RSPM/PM10 are given in Figure 4.5.<br />

The figure shows that SPM levels have increased from 363 to 456 µg/ m 3 between 1997 to 2002.<br />

But, SPM levels reduced by 11.4% in the year 2001 and increased again to 19.4 % in the year 2002.<br />

This could be attributed to the adverse meteorological conditions in 2002.<br />

58


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 4.2<br />

Table 4.3<br />

59


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

FIGURE 4.3: SO2 SOURCES IN AMBIENT AIR<br />

60


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

FIGURE 4.4: NOx SOURCES IN AMBIENT AIR<br />

61


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

FIGURE 4.5: SPM SOURCES IN AMBIENT AIR<br />

Respirable particulate matter (RSPM) or PM10<br />

62


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The figure shows the annual average of RSPM levels over the city. It is clear that RSPM<br />

levels have reduced to 21.4 % in the year 2001 and remained almost constant in the year 2002 as<br />

compared to year 2000. The increase could be due to adverse meteorological conditions in 2002.<br />

Carbon Monoxide (CO)<br />

The annual average CO levels as shown in the figure indicate constant reduction of CO levels at<br />

ITO intersection. The observed concentration of CO came down from 4183 µg/m 3 in Year 2001 to<br />

3258 µg/ m 3 in Year 2002. This could be attributed to the stringent vehicular emission norms, fuel<br />

quality up-gradation and development of better engines. Though the annual average levels of<br />

Carbon Monoxide continue to be above the danger mark of 2,000 µg / m 3 , there has been a gradual<br />

decline.<br />

4.5.2 Ambient Air Quality Survey<br />

The existing ambient air quality in the core zone (local and immediate vicinity) of the <strong>proposed</strong><br />

project site has been assessed during summer 2006 through a network of four ambient air quality<br />

stations. The prime objectives were to establish existing local background levels and baseline air<br />

pollution status. The ambient air quality monitoring network has been designed keeping in view the<br />

available predominant wind direction and wind speed in the project area. One station was kept at<br />

the centre and the other three at about 120 o direction apart. The sources of air pollution in the<br />

project area are mainly vehicular traffic, construction activities, and general human activities.<br />

The following points were also taken into consideration in designing the network of sampling<br />

stations:<br />

• Locations with increasing mixed residential and commercial development within the study<br />

area.<br />

• Locations near Schools, hospitals and other sensitive areas within the study area.<br />

• Locations which are representative of land-use categories.<br />

• Representation of cross sectional distribution in downward direction.<br />

• Locations where the baseline ambient air quality are established such that it can be<br />

resurveyed in the future to monitor changes in the ambient environment.<br />

• Locations within the project area with the least interference of anthropological activities.<br />

63


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The existing Ambient Air Quality (AAQ) status has been monitored <strong>for</strong> SPM, RPM, SO 2 ,<br />

NOX and CO representing the criteria pollutants. SPM & RPM at each station has been monitored<br />

on 24 hourly basis and CO on 8 hourly basis. Pre calibrated high volume samplers have been used<br />

<strong>for</strong> monitoring of the existing AAQ status. The Respirable particulate matter (RPM) was separated<br />

through cyclone and measured by gravimetric method similar to SPM. SO 2 and NOx were analyzed<br />

by Colorimetric method.<br />

Methodologies adopted <strong>for</strong> sampling and analysis were, as per the approved methods of Central<br />

Pollution Control Board (CPCB). Maximum, minimum, average and percentile values have been<br />

computed from the raw data collected at all individual sampling stations to represent the ambient<br />

air quality status of the study area.<br />

4.5.3 Analysis of Baseline Concentrations<br />

The details about sampling locations identified during study period are presented in Table 4.4. The<br />

locations have been identified keeping in view predominant wind direction prevailing during study<br />

period, sensitivity, human settlement, construction activities, traffic concentration, and others.<br />

The results of ambient air quality within the study area monitored between March and May 2006<br />

are presented in Table 4.5. And percentile distribution of SPM, RPM, SO 2 and NOx are presented<br />

in Table 4.6. The average concentration of SPM, RPM, SO 2 , CO, and NOx monitored during the<br />

study period were found to be less than NAAQS prescribed <strong>for</strong> residential areas at most of the<br />

locations.<br />

• Suspended Particulate Matter - SPM<br />

Suspended particulate matter monitored in the study area showed 98 th percentile values in the<br />

range of 172 – 195 µg/m 3 . The highest value of SPM level (215 µg/m 3 ) was observed at AAQ4<br />

station. The average SPM concentration at all the four locations is well within the limit<br />

prescribed <strong>for</strong> residential areas.<br />

• Respirable Particulate Matter - RPM<br />

RPM values monitored at 4 locations showed 98 th percentile values in the range of 60 – 76<br />

µg/m 3 . Highest value of 81 µg/m 3 was recorded at AAQ3 station. However, the average values<br />

at most of the locations are well within the limits <strong>for</strong> residential areas.<br />

• Sulphur dioxide - SO 2<br />

64


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

98 th percentile value of Sulphur dioxide in the study area from the monitored data was in<br />

the range of 9 – 13 µg/m 3 . Maximum value of sulphur dioxide of 16 µg/m 3 obtained near the<br />

sampling location AAQ4. The values of SO 2 monitored in the study area are well within the<br />

limits of NAAQ standards <strong>for</strong> residential as well as sensitive areas.<br />

• Oxides of Nitrogen – NOx<br />

Ambient air quality status monitored <strong>for</strong> nitrogen oxides in the study area were in the range<br />

with 98 th percentile values between 19 – 22 µg/m 3 . A maximum value of 25 µg/m 3 was<br />

prevailing at the time of sampling at AAQ2. The values of NOx monitored in the study area are<br />

well within the limits of NAAQ standards <strong>for</strong> residential as well as sensitive areas.<br />

• Carbon Monoxide - CO<br />

CO concentration at all the locations was found to be less than 1 ppm.<br />

Table 4.4<br />

Sampling Locations <strong>for</strong> Ambient Air Quality Monitoring<br />

S. No. Station<br />

Code<br />

LOCATION<br />

DIRECTIO<br />

N<br />

DISTANCE<br />

(Km)<br />

w.r.t. <strong>proposed</strong> project site<br />

1. AAQ1 Project site - -<br />

2. AAQ2 Near DDA Flats, Sector<br />

16B, Pkt 3C, Phase II<br />

3. AAQ3 Near DDA MIG, Sector 17,<br />

Plot A, Phase II<br />

W<br />

S<br />

0.5 km<br />

0.7 km<br />

4. AAQ4 Near Metro View<br />

Apartments, SFS Flats,<br />

Sector 13, Pkt B, Phase II<br />

NE<br />

1 km<br />

65


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 4.5<br />

Ambient Air Quality Results (March – May 2006)<br />

S. No. Station<br />

Code<br />

Location<br />

AVERAGE CONCENTRATION (µg/m 3 )<br />

RPM SPM SO 2 NO X CO<br />

(ppm)<br />

1. AAQ1 Project Site 55 164 12 18 < 1<br />

2. AAQ2 Near DDA Flats,<br />

Sector 16B, Pkt 3C,<br />

Phase II<br />

70 185 11 22 < 1<br />

3. AAQ3 Near DDA MIG,<br />

Sector 17, Plot A,<br />

Phase II<br />

68 180 10 20 < 1<br />

4. AAQ4 Near Metro View<br />

Apartments, SFS<br />

Flats, Sector 13, Pkt<br />

B, Phase II<br />

75 205 14 22 < 1<br />

CPCB Standards<br />

Residential Area 100 200 80 80 2000<br />

Sensitive Area 75 100 30 30 1000<br />

Table 4.6<br />

Statistical Analysis of Ambient Air Quality Results<br />

Parameters Unit AAQMS Mes Min Max AM P 98<br />

66


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

RPM µg/m 3 AAQ1 20 50 64 55 60<br />

AAQ2 20 62 78 70 73<br />

AAQ3 20 60 78 68 72<br />

AAQ4 20 67 81 75 76<br />

SPM µg/m 3 AAQ1 20 158 174 164 172<br />

AAQ2 20 170 190 185 180<br />

AAQ3 20 165 192 180 182<br />

AAQ4 20 176 215 205 195<br />

SO 2 µg/m 3 AAQ1 20 9 14 12 11<br />

AAQ2 20 10 15 11 10<br />

AAQ3 20 8 12 10 9<br />

AAQ4 20 11 16 14 13<br />

NOx µg/m 3 AAQ1 20 15 22 18 21<br />

AAQ2 20 18 25 22 22<br />

AAQ3 20 17 22 20 19<br />

AAQ4 20 19 24 22 20<br />

AAQMS<br />

Mes<br />

AM<br />

P 98<br />

- Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Station<br />

- Number of Measurements<br />

- Arithmetic Mean<br />

- 98 th Percentile Value<br />

4.6 Noise Environment<br />

Noise in general is sound, which is composed of many frequency components of various loudness<br />

distributed over the audible frequency range. The most common and universally accepted scale is<br />

67


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

the A weighted Scale which is measured as dB (A). This is more suitable <strong>for</strong> audible range of<br />

20 to 20,000 Hz.<br />

The acoustical environment varies dynamically in magnitude and character through out most<br />

communities. The noise level variation can be temporal, spectral and spatial. The residential noise<br />

level is that level below which the ambient noise does not seem to dropdown during the given<br />

interval of time and is generally characterised by unidentified sources. Ambient noise level is<br />

characterised by significant variations above a base or a residential noise level. The maximum<br />

impact of noise is felt on urban areas, which is mostly due to the commercial activities and<br />

vehicular movement during peak hours of the day.<br />

Measured noise levels displayed as a function of time provides a useful scheme <strong>for</strong> describing the<br />

acoustical climate of a community. Noise levels recorded at each station with a time interval of<br />

about 30 minutes are computed <strong>for</strong> equivalent noise levels (L eq ). Equivalent noise level is a single<br />

number descriptor <strong>for</strong> describing time varying noise levels.<br />

L eq is the equivalent continuous sound level that is equivalent to the same sound energy as the<br />

actual fluctuating sound measured in the same period. This is necessary because sound from noise<br />

source often fluctuates widely during a given period of time. This is calculated from the following:<br />

L day is defined as the equivalent noise level measured over a period of time during day (6 am to 10<br />

pm).<br />

L night is defined as the equivalent noise level measured over a period of time during night (10 pm to<br />

6 am).<br />

A noise rating developed by Environment Protection Agency, USEPA <strong>for</strong> specification of<br />

community noise from all the sources is the Day-Night Sound Level, L dn .<br />

The noise rating developed <strong>for</strong> community noise from all sources is the Day- Night Sound Level<br />

(L dn ). It is similar to a 24 hr equivalent sound level except that during night time period (10 pm to 6<br />

am) a 10 dB (A) weighting penalty added to the instantaneous sound level be<strong>for</strong>e computing the 24<br />

hr average.<br />

L eq = 10 log 1/T N i=1 Ti (10) Li/10<br />

Where, T = total time of sampling,<br />

Ti = Time duration of ith phase<br />

N = Number of phases<br />

Li = L eq <strong>for</strong> the ith phase<br />

This night time penalty is added to account <strong>for</strong> the fact that noise during night when people usually<br />

sleep is judged as more annoying than the same noise during the day time.<br />

68


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The L dn <strong>for</strong> a given location in a community may be calculated from the hourly L eq , by the<br />

following equation.<br />

L dn = 10 log {1/24[16(10 L day /10) + 8 x 10(L night +10)/10)]}<br />

Where, L day is the equivalent sound level during the day time (6 am to 10 pm) and<br />

L night is the equivalent sound level during the night time (10 pm to 6 am).<br />

In order to assess the ambient noise levels in the study area, monitoring was carried out at five<br />

different locations within the core zone of the study area. Noise levels were recorded at each station<br />

with a time interval of 5 minutes <strong>for</strong> about 30 minutes in each hour and were computed <strong>for</strong><br />

equivalent noise levels <strong>for</strong> day-equivalent, night equivalent and day-night equivalent.<br />

Noise levels were monitored using sound level meter (CYGNET Model – 2013) <strong>for</strong> the study area.<br />

The details of sampling locations are presented in Table 4.7 along with data on the observed noise<br />

levels and noise equivalent levels. It is observed that noise equivalent levels of study area in the<br />

core zone varied in the range 50 - 53 dB (A) in the day time and 43 – 46 dB (A) in the night time.<br />

These observations indicate that the ambient noise levels within the core impact zone comply with<br />

prescribed standards <strong>for</strong> residential area. At the <strong>proposed</strong> project site, the values are also within the<br />

prescribed standards <strong>for</strong> residential and commercial area.<br />

Table 4.7<br />

Equivalent Noise Levels in the Study Area (Core Zone)<br />

Station<br />

Code<br />

Locations<br />

L day<br />

dB (A)<br />

L night<br />

dB (A)<br />

L dn<br />

dB (A)<br />

N1 Project Site 50 45 47<br />

N2 Near DDA Flats, Sector 16B,<br />

Pkt 3C, Phase II<br />

N3 Near DDA MIG, Sector 17,<br />

Plot A, Phase II<br />

N4<br />

Near Metro View<br />

Apartments, SFS Flats, Sector<br />

13, Pkt B, Phase II<br />

N5 Near DDA Park, Sector 13,<br />

Phase II<br />

51 44 48<br />

53 45 49<br />

53 46 50<br />

52 43 47<br />

CPCB standards <strong>for</strong> Residential Area: 55 45<br />

CPCB standards <strong>for</strong> Commercial Area: 65 55<br />

CPCB standards <strong>for</strong> Sensitive Zone: 50 40<br />

Note:<br />

69


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• Day Time is from 6.00 am to 10.00 pm, Night time is 10.00 pm to 6.00 am<br />

• Silence zone is defined as area up to 100 meters around premises of hospitals, educational<br />

institutions and courts. Use of vehicle horns, loud speakers and bursting of crackers are<br />

banned in these zones.<br />

4.7 Water Environment<br />

The study area, a part of South West District of Delhi, receives about 81.2% of the annual rainfall<br />

during the monsoon months June to September. On an average, rain of 2.5 mm or more falls on<br />

38.3 days in a year in this region of Delhi. The annual average rainfall is about 792.8 mm based on<br />

22 years of data (Source: IMD).<br />

4.7.1 Ground Water Hydrology<br />

Delhi is situated on the banks of the river Yamuna. The river Yamuna flows from north to south. A<br />

hard rocky ridge running from the Southern border of NCT in the south west in a north easterly<br />

direction to the western banks of the river Yamuna near Wazirabad barrage <strong>for</strong>ms the main<br />

watershed in NCT of Delhi. The topography created a drainage system that carries rain and storm<br />

water from the higher elevations of the West to the Yamuna. The eastern low-lying side was<br />

originally part of the flood plain of the river and considered unhabitable. Today however this<br />

Eastern wing, also known as the Trans Yamuna area, houses about 23% of the total population of<br />

Delhi.<br />

The hydro geological situation is characterized by the occurrence of alluvial and hard rock<br />

<strong>for</strong>mations and controls the groundwater availability in the territory. The quality of the groundwater<br />

in the hard rock <strong>for</strong>mation in Delhi is generally potable, whereas in the alluvial <strong>for</strong>mation<br />

groundwater, the water quality deteriorates with depth. Hard rock <strong>for</strong>mation is found to be in North<br />

East – South West to North North East – South South West with steep dips towards South East and<br />

East. During 1960 – 2001, ground water levels were observed to have declined by 2 – 6 m in most<br />

parts of the alluvium areas. A decline of 8 – 20 m is recorded in Najafgarh Block and in Mehrauli<br />

Block the decline is 8 – 35 m.<br />

Dwarka is located in the western part of the NCT Delhi, on older alluvial plains. Dwarka’s<br />

hydrology is characterized by the proximity of the Najafgarh Drain which <strong>for</strong>ms the western limit<br />

of the sub-city, and constitutes an important source of groundwater recharge. In the Dwarka clay<br />

and kankar <strong>for</strong>mation exists in the top layer upto a depth of 4m below ground level. This layer of<br />

clay is followed by kankar and silt upto a depth of 68 m below ground level. The thickness of the<br />

70


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

alluvium is about 300 m in the area and potential aquifers can be found at depths up to 240<br />

meters below ground level (Figure 4.6).<br />

As shown in Figure 4.7, the western part of NCT shows a rapid decline in water levels due to<br />

tapping of groundwater <strong>for</strong> domestic and agricultural uses. The depth of water tables increases from<br />

5m to 12 m as we move away from the drain. A comparative study of water level map of 1960 and<br />

2002 shows in Dwarka the water level which was at 2 to 5m below ground level has gone down to<br />

5 to 10 mts below ground water level. There are number of deep tubewells in the area producing<br />

about 25,000 – 30,000 m 3 /day. The potable quality of water is mostly available at the depth of 15-<br />

20 meters below ground level.<br />

The main problem in Dwarka, as far as groundwater resources are concerned is the occurrence of<br />

brackish and saline water in the deeper aquifers. In the Northern part of Dwarka, salinity occurs at<br />

all levels (Figure 4.8). High concentrations of fluoride have also been found in samples collected<br />

by the Central Ground Water Board. According to the calculation of the Central Ground Water<br />

Board, the total reserve of potable water is limited to 16 Million Cubic Meter (MCM) 2 . The<br />

requirement of the current population is considered to be 28 Million Liters per Day (MLD), <strong>for</strong> an<br />

available supply of 12 MLD. The annual gap represents 16 MLD (around 6 MCM).<br />

South Western district of Delhi are comparatively at a disadvantage situation in terms of providing<br />

piped water supply, as the water treatment plants are located in northern part of Delhi. The<br />

government is able to supply only 74 lpcd (litres per capita per day). The demand and supply gap in<br />

this district keeps on increasing high because of large scale development in the residential sector.<br />

To meet this demand supply gap, a new water treatment plant is being <strong>proposed</strong> which will reduce<br />

the dependency on the ground water fro potable purpose.<br />

71


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.6: Thickness of Alluvium Map<br />

72


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.7: Decline in Water Table Levels Map<br />

73


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.8: Groundwater Salinity Map<br />

74


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

4.7.2 Drainage Pattern<br />

Drainage has two aspects – flood protection and storm water discharge, which are interrelated. The<br />

storm water and flood protection in Delhi are not local but have regional bearing including areas of<br />

Haryana and Rajasthan. The main drainage system of Delhi is such that all water collected through<br />

main drains, link drains and small rivulets is discharged into Yamuna. On the basis of topographical<br />

characteristics and existing drainage network, NCT of Delhi has been divided into five drainage<br />

basins namely Najafgarh, Alipur, Shahdara, Khushak nallah and Mehrauli. The major portion of<br />

NCT – Delhi is being drained by Najafgarh drain leading to Yamuna River. Most of these drains<br />

mainly carry the urban sewage and industrial effluents. Figure 4.9 shows the drainage system in<br />

NCT Delhi. The relief and soil conditions cause localized stagnation during rainy season. During<br />

high rains and high floods in Yamuna River, the drainage system becomes ineffective as the outlets<br />

of rainwater blocked.<br />

There is a natural surface storm water drain close to the <strong>proposed</strong> project site. This carries the<br />

discharge to the Najafgarh drain. The wastewater is normally carried away by the sewer lines which<br />

exist in the project area.<br />

4.7.3 Ground Water Quality<br />

Assessment of baseline data on water environment includes:<br />

• Identification of ground water sources<br />

• Collection of water samples<br />

• Analyzing water samples collected <strong>for</strong> physico – chemical and biological parameters<br />

Assessment of water quality in the study area was done to assess the parameters as per the Indian<br />

standard IS 10500 (drinking water standard). Four ground water samples from borewells /<br />

tubewells from various locations in and around the <strong>proposed</strong> project site within the core zone were<br />

collected during summer season 2006 <strong>for</strong> assessment of the physico – chemical quality.<br />

75


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.9: Sewerage and Drainage Zones Map of Delhi<br />

76


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The locations of water sampling are listed in Table 4.8. Methodologies adopted <strong>for</strong> sampling<br />

and analysis were according to the IS methods. Field parameters such as pH, Temperature and<br />

Dissolved Oxygen were monitored at site. The parameters thus analyzed were compared with IS<br />

10500.<br />

The physicochemical characteristics of ground water samples collected from various locations are<br />

summarized in Table 4.9. The overall ground water showed most of the parameters within<br />

permissible values as specified in IS 10500. The quality of ground water is slightly alkaline with<br />

pH ranging between 7.2 to 7.8, chloride content ranges between 400 and 525 mg/l. The fluoride<br />

content was found to be in the range 0.45 – 0.79 and iron concentration 0.05 – 0.19. Annexure 6<br />

gives the drinking water standards and probable effects of human health as per IS 10500.<br />

Table 4.8<br />

Sampling Locations <strong>for</strong> Ground Water Quality Monitoring<br />

S.<br />

No.<br />

Sample<br />

Code<br />

Sampling Locations Direction Type of Source<br />

1 GW1 Near Project Site - Borewell<br />

2 GW2 DDA Flats, Sector 16B, Pkt<br />

3C, Phase II<br />

3 GW3 DDA MIG, Sector 17, Plot<br />

A, Phase II<br />

4 GW4 Near DDA Park, Sector 13,<br />

Phase II<br />

W<br />

S<br />

E<br />

Borewell<br />

Borewell<br />

Borewell<br />

Table 4.9<br />

Ground Water Quality Results<br />

77


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Sr.<br />

No<br />

Parameters<br />

Concentration<br />

AS Per IS<br />

10500-1991<br />

(Desirable)<br />

GW1 GW2 GW3 GW4<br />

Physical Parameters<br />

1. pH 7.4 7.3 7.2 7.8 6.5-8.5<br />

2 Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) 950 964 1220 1444 500<br />

Inorganic Parameters<br />

4 Alkalinity 232 220 254 200 200<br />

5 Chlorides as Cl 447 400 525 500 250<br />

6 Sulphate as SO 4 335 300 340 355 200<br />

7 Total Hardness as CaCO 3 510 550 680 620 300<br />

8 Calcium as Ca 80 65 82 79 75<br />

9 Magnesium as Mg 20 18 22 18 30<br />

10 Fluoride as F 0.60 0.79 0.45 0.50 1.0<br />

Nutrients<br />

11 Nitrate as NO 3 45 55 67 76 45<br />

Metals<br />

12 Iron as Fe 0.05 0.1 0.08 0.19 0.3<br />

13 Lead as Pb ND ND ND ND 0.05<br />

14 Mercury as Hg ND ND ND ND 0.001<br />

15 Arsenic as As ND ND ND ND 0.05<br />

16 Chromium as Cr 6+ ND ND ND ND 0.05<br />

Note: All analytical results are in mg/lit except pH<br />

4.8 Land Environment<br />

78


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

4.8.1 Seismic Stability<br />

The project area falls in Zone-IV of Seismic Zoning<br />

Map of India (Figure 4.10). Delhi region shows<br />

active and prolonged seismic history. Earthquakes<br />

of 3 to 6.7 magnitude on Richter scale have<br />

occurred in past around Delhi. The most active area<br />

of the region is considered to be the trijunction of<br />

the Delhi-Hardwar ridge, Lahore-Delhi ridge and<br />

axis of Delhi folding. Most of the shocks are<br />

interpreted to have shallow focus and have locations<br />

to the West of Delhi. Maximum concentrations of<br />

the earthquakes epicentre have been around<br />

Sonepat, Rohtak and Gurgaon region and the<br />

tectonic elements of the area are considered capable<br />

of generating an earthquake of magnitude 7 on Richter scale. The seismic factors have been<br />

appropriately incorporated in the civil designs <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

4.8.2 Geology<br />

The geological <strong>for</strong>mations of the NCT Delhi date from the proterozoic to the Quarternary ages. The<br />

generalized succession of the rock <strong>for</strong>mations reported are the Quaternary era represented by recent<br />

soils, alluvium, blow sand and nodular limestone; Pegamites and the basic intrusives belonging to<br />

post Delhi intrusives; and the Alwar quartzites of the Delhi system. The area is a part of the Indo-<br />

Gangetic plain. Figure 4.11 shows the geological map of NCT - Delhi.<br />

The greatest part of Delhi lies in the alluvium, but the small hills and ridges in and around New<br />

Delhi consist of Alwar quartzites. Delhi area is occupied by quartzites interbedded with mica schist<br />

belonging to the Delhi Super Group, uncon<strong>for</strong>mably overlain by unconsolidated Quaternary to<br />

recent sediments. The quartzites are grey to brownish grey, massive to thinly bedded and<br />

structurally <strong>for</strong>m a coaxially refolded regional anti<strong>for</strong>m plunging towards southwest. The major<br />

planar structure strikes NE-SW with steep southeasterly dips. These quartzites occur in the central<br />

and southern part of the area while the Quaternary sediments comprising older and newer alluvium<br />

cover the rest of the area. The older alluvium comprises silt, clay with minor lenticular fine sand<br />

and kankar beds. The newer alluvium mainly consists of unoxidised sands, silt and clay occurring<br />

in the older and active flood plains of Yamuna river. The thickness of the alluvium, both on the<br />

eastern and western side of the ridge, is variable, but it is generally larger to the West of the ridge.<br />

The project area is located in the western part of the NCT Delhi, on older alluvial plains. They are<br />

mostly covered with quaternary sediments belonging to mainly older alluvium soil. These older<br />

79


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

alluvium consists of a polycyclic sequence of sand, silt and clay with frequent kankar<br />

disseminations.<br />

4.8.3 Land Use Pattern<br />

The land use distribution of Dwarka follows a distinct hierarchical pattern from sub-city level to<br />

sector level. The land use distribution of the area is as follows:<br />

• Gross Residential - 48.54%<br />

• Commercial - 7.05%<br />

• Government - 0.94%<br />

• Public / Semi-Public - 6.20%<br />

• Recreational - 19.94%<br />

• Transport - 14.33%<br />

• Utilities - 3.00%<br />

Figure 4.12 shows the land use distribution of Dwarka. The project site lies in the Public / Semipublic<br />

land use category of the project area. The adjoining lands to the project site are essentially<br />

80


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.11: Geological Map of NCT Delhi<br />

81


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.12: Land Use Distribution Map of Dwarka<br />

82


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

institutional. Within 1 Km radius of the <strong>proposed</strong> project site, many residential apartments<br />

also exist. As there is requirement of substantial residential accommodation <strong>for</strong> the National Law<br />

School as well as <strong>for</strong> the Delhi Judicial Academy, the Ministry of Urban Development after the<br />

recommendation by DDA has issued a gazette notification to bifurcate the project site with<br />

different land uses, namely Institutional and Residential. No agricultural and industrial areas exist<br />

within the core zone of the <strong>proposed</strong> project site. The <strong>proposed</strong> project site is designated <strong>for</strong> the<br />

intended purpose and the necessary change in the land use of the plot area measuring 23,180 sq.<br />

meters (5.72 acres) has already been effected by converting it to land use <strong>for</strong> residential use from<br />

land use <strong>for</strong> Government use in MPD-2001.<br />

4.8.4 Soil Quality<br />

The soils of the Delhi area are mostly light with subordinate amount of medium texture soils. The<br />

light texture soils are represented by sandy, loamy, sand and sandy loam; whereas medium texture<br />

soils are represented by loam silty loam.<br />

Four locations within the core zone of the <strong>proposed</strong> project site have been identified <strong>for</strong> collection<br />

of soil samples. The sampling locations, their distances and bearing from the <strong>proposed</strong> site are<br />

listed in Table 4.10. Data collected <strong>for</strong> chemical characteristics of soils through select parameters<br />

viz. pH, EC, soluble anions, cation and cation exchange capacity are presented in Table 4.11.<br />

pH is an important parameter indicative of alkaline or acidic nature of soil. It greatly affects the<br />

microbial population as well as solubility of metal ions and regulates nutrient availability.<br />

Variations in the pH of the soil in the study area are found to be 7.1 to 7.9 thus conducive <strong>for</strong><br />

growth of plant.<br />

Electrical conductivity, a measure of soluble salt in the soil is in the range of 0.25 to 0.38. The<br />

important cations in the soil are calcium and magnesium. It is observed that calcium and<br />

magnesium concentrations are in the ranges 0.42 to 0.56% and 0.39 to 0.65% respectively.<br />

Chlorides are in the range of 0.008 to 0.012%. Variation in CEC of the study area was found in the<br />

range of 35.7 - 46.2 meq/100g. The relationship of CEC with productivity and absorptivity is<br />

shown in Table 4.12 and Table 4.13.<br />

Fertility status of soil is presented in Table 4.14. Organic matter present in soil influences its<br />

physical and chemical properties of soil and is responsible <strong>for</strong> stability of soil aggregates. Organic<br />

matter of soil is found in the range 0.59 % to 0.75 % showed moderate fertility of the soil. The<br />

presence of organic matter enhances the metabolic activities of soil affecting the nitrogen and<br />

potash content of soil. The fertility status in respect of Nitrogen, P 2 O 5 & K 2 O shows Moderate<br />

level of fertility, which indicates the supplementations of these fertilizers are required. This shows<br />

that soil is moderately fertile in organic and nutrient content.<br />

83


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 4.10<br />

Locations <strong>for</strong> Collection of Soil Samples<br />

S.<br />

No.<br />

Sampling Locations Bearing Aerial<br />

Distance<br />

(Km)<br />

With Respect to project site<br />

1. Project site (S1) - -<br />

2. Near DDA Flats, Sector 16B, Pkt<br />

3C, Phase II<br />

3. Near DDA MIG, Sector 17, Plot A,<br />

Phase II<br />

W<br />

S<br />

0.5 km<br />

0.7 km<br />

4. DDA Park, Sector 13, Phase II E 0.7 km<br />

Table 4.11<br />

Chemical Characteristics of Soil in Study Area<br />

S.<br />

No.<br />

Location pH EC<br />

(µmhos)<br />

Org. C Cl SO 4 Ca Mg<br />

1. S1 7.5 0.38 0.84 0.012 0.007 0.42 0.44 46.2<br />

2. S2 7.9 0.32 0.45 0.010 0.005 0.48 0.39 40.7<br />

3. S3 7.6 0.30 0.32 0.008 0.004 0.53 0.65 39.2<br />

4. S4 7.1 0.25 0.42 0.008 0.003 0.56 0.39 35.7<br />

%<br />

CEC<br />

meq.<br />

/100gm<br />

Table 4.12<br />

Relationship of CEC with Productivity<br />

S. No. CEC Range<br />

(meq/100g)<br />

Productivity<br />

1. < 10 Very Low -<br />

2. 10 – 20 Low -<br />

Location<br />

(S. No.)<br />

3. 20 – 50 Moderate All locations<br />

4. > 50 High -<br />

84


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 4.13<br />

Relationship of CEC with Absorptivity<br />

S. No. CEC Range<br />

(meq/100g)<br />

Absorptivity<br />

1. 0.75 > 560 > 57 > 337<br />

4.9 Biological Environment<br />

4.9.1 Vegetation Pattern<br />

Delhi has 111 sq. km of <strong>for</strong>est cover and 40 sq. km. of tree cover against the geographical area of<br />

1483 sq. km, representing only 10.2% of total land area of the city. The green cover is not<br />

uni<strong>for</strong>mly distributed in Delhi as some parts have considerable greenery than the others. The New<br />

Delhi and South Districts are much greener compared to other Districts.<br />

85


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The <strong>for</strong>est area in South West Delhi is 30.09 sq. km against the geographical area of 420.54<br />

sq. km, representing 7.16% of <strong>for</strong>est cover. There are 3city <strong>for</strong>ests being developed and managed in<br />

South West Delhi by Forest Department. These are - Nasirpur City Forest, Mitraon City Forest, and<br />

Ghumenhera City Forests. There are MP green areas also in the project area which represents as<br />

protected <strong>for</strong>est under DDA and L&DO.<br />

The flora of Delhi comprises nearly 1,000 species of flowering plants belonging to some 120<br />

families. Sixty per cent of the species are either indigenous or naturalized and the remaining<br />

introduced. More than 50 percent of the indigenous flora represents the tropical species. Nearly<br />

eight percent is from tropical Africa less than 50 percent from the New World, and two per cent<br />

from the temperate region.<br />

As a consequence of urbanization, much of the naturally existing vegetation has been cleared over<br />

the years. The city level <strong>for</strong>ests, the Ridge, the protected and reserved <strong>for</strong>ests have surviving<br />

pockets of natural vegetation in Delhi. The other open spaces are an admixture of indigenous and<br />

exotic species project.<br />

The lists of tree species observed in the project area are given in Table 4.15. Among the city’s<br />

residential area, the ones in the area are amply dotted with trees and shrubs. These data on flora was<br />

collected and collated from the in<strong>for</strong>mation available with the <strong>for</strong>est department. No <strong>for</strong>est cover /<br />

reserved <strong>for</strong>est exist in the core zone of the <strong>proposed</strong> project site. The area is covered by roadside<br />

plantations, private and public gardens as well as plantations done by the institutions and housing<br />

colonies.<br />

4.9.2 Fauna<br />

There is no unique faunal community within the core and buffer zone of the project area, except<br />

most common ones like toad, frog, crow, sparrow and maina etc. The species observed in the<br />

project area are given in Table 4.16.<br />

86


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 4.15<br />

List of Tree Species in the Study Area<br />

S.No.<br />

Common<br />

Name<br />

Botanical name<br />

1 Neem Azadirachta indica<br />

2 Amaltas Cassia – fistula<br />

3 Jamun Eugenia jambolana<br />

4 Peepal Ficus – religiosa<br />

5 Arjun Terminalia arjuna<br />

6 Gulmohur Dalbergia – sisoo<br />

7 Sausage tree Kigelia pinnata<br />

8 Cachnar Bauhinia purpurea<br />

9 Indian coral tree Erythrina indica<br />

10 Siris Albizzia lebbeck<br />

11 Shatoot Morus Alba<br />

12 Jacaranda Jacaranda imosfolia<br />

13 Silk cotton Salmalia malabarica<br />

14 Eucalyptus Eucalyptus<br />

15 Shisham Dalbergia sissoo<br />

16 Maulsiri Mimusops elengi<br />

17 Semal Bombax ceiba<br />

Table 4.16<br />

List of Faunal Species in the Study Area<br />

87


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

S.No.<br />

Common Name<br />

Zoological name<br />

1 Toad Bufo sp.<br />

2 Frog Rana tigrina<br />

3 Indian green lizards Calotes versicolor<br />

4 House lizards Hemidactylus sp.<br />

5 Indian palm squirrel Fumambulus pennanti<br />

6 Cat Felis sp.<br />

7 Dog Cuon sp.<br />

8 Cow Bos sp.<br />

9 Rat Rattus rattus<br />

10 Crow Corves splendens<br />

11 Horse Equs sp.<br />

12 Sparrow Passer domesticus<br />

13 Baya Ploceus philippinus<br />

14 Parrot Psittacula krameri<br />

15 Bulbul Pycnonotus barbatus<br />

16 Myna Acridotheres tristis<br />

4.10 Socio – Economic Environment<br />

Socio-economic and cultural impacts arising from project construction and environmental<br />

trans<strong>for</strong>mation are rooted in the <strong>complex</strong> interactivity between social and biophysical<br />

environments. Human communities are integral components of their environment as well as<br />

potential agents <strong>for</strong> environmental change. Hence environmental changes in settled areas are often<br />

88


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

profoundly interlinked with subsequent changes that occur within society. The<br />

trans<strong>for</strong>mation of environmental parameters can generate dynamic social impacts, which alter<br />

economic and cultural relations between individuals and the community, as well as between the<br />

social infrastructure and social institutions at large. In turn, these may induce long term changes in<br />

the socio-cultural and economic organisation of human communities and prevailing modes of life<br />

and activity, eventually trans<strong>for</strong>ming the ethical values, cultural belief-systems and social norms<br />

that define group behaviour. The social consequences of environmental change are principally<br />

manifested in three <strong>for</strong>ms:<br />

Demographic impacts which relate changes in population characteristics such as settlement density,<br />

gender ratios, literacy rate, Occupational in<strong>for</strong>mation etc., to resultant increases in the<br />

infrastructural need <strong>for</strong> housing, state healthcare, education and welfare services, as well as to<br />

alterations in the patterns of resource-use and the organisation of productive activity visible in<br />

indicators like land use trans<strong>for</strong>mation and the changing occupational structure.<br />

Cultural impacts, involving modification of ethno-cultural structures, their historic and<br />

archaeological artefacts and their ethno-religious connotations as the result of the development of<br />

new communities and the migration of cultures.<br />

Socio-cultural impacts, involving long term restructuring of the social organisation and its social<br />

institutions as a result of the definition of new individual and community roles within it, as well as<br />

changes in cultural beliefs and values around it. During the EIA process, spatial prediction of the<br />

limits and extent of these impacts are preceded by meticulous compilation of baseline in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />

from existing documentary sources, and by qualitative assessment of current socio-dynamic trends<br />

from other data assembled on field.<br />

4.10.1 Demographic Structure of the Study Area<br />

After independence, Sixth Population Census was undertaken in the entire area of NCT of Delhi<br />

from 9 th February to 28 th February 2001 with a revisional round from 1 st to 5 th March, 2001. As<br />

such, the population of Delhi as on 1st March 2001 has been worked out at 13.85 millions as<br />

against 9.42 millions as on 1st March 1991. This reflects decennial growth of 47.02% of population<br />

after 1991census. The corresponding percentage at All-India level has been worked out at 21.34%.<br />

The total population of Delhi is 1.34% of the All-India Population.<br />

The total area of NCT of Delhi is 1483 sq. km with an urban segment of 685.34 sq. km in the year<br />

1991. Urban population grew at 51.53% from 1991-2001 as compared to 46.89% during 1981-<br />

1991. Comparing this with rural population growth of only 1.69% during 1991-2001. The density<br />

of the population also increased to 9294 persons per sq. km (the highest in the country) in the year<br />

2001 against 6352 persons per sq. km in 1991.<br />

89


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Delhi was considered as a single district <strong>for</strong> Population Census 1991. In 1996, Government<br />

of NCT of Delhi through a Gazette notification created 9 districts and 27 sub-divisions. Population<br />

Census 2001 was conducted in Delhi in each of 9 districts and 27 Sub-divisions.<br />

Comparison of socio-economic attributes of the study area (South West District) and NCT of Delhi<br />

is given in Table 4.17.<br />

Table 4.17<br />

Demographic Structure of the Study Area<br />

PARTICULARS<br />

STUDY AREA<br />

(SOUTH WEST DISTRICT)<br />

NCT OF DELHI<br />

Area - 1483 sq. km<br />

Population (in 2001) 17,49,492 1,38,50,507<br />

% of total Population of state<br />

(in 2001)<br />

Sex Ratio (No. of females per<br />

thousand males)<br />

12.63 100<br />

790 821<br />

Population Density 9,050 9,340<br />

Literacy Rate 83.63<br />

(Males – 89.53 and Females –<br />

Rural – Urban Ratio<br />

Literacy Rate in Rural and<br />

Urban<br />

Source: Census Data 2001<br />

76.00)<br />

17,49,492 (Persons)<br />

223688 (Rural)<br />

1525804 (Urban)<br />

83.63<br />

80.48 (Rural)<br />

84.09 (Urban)<br />

81.67<br />

(Males – 87.33 and Females –<br />

74.71)<br />

13850507 (Persons)<br />

944727 (Rural)<br />

12905780 (Urban)<br />

81.67<br />

78.05 (Rural)<br />

82.00 (Urban)<br />

4.10.2 Physical Infrastructure Resource Base<br />

Physical Infrastructure resource base of the project area with reference to water supply, power<br />

supply, sewerage, and solid waste is briefly described below:<br />

• Water Supply:<br />

The municipal water supply and storage infrastructure exists in the project area. As shown in<br />

Figure 4.13, the quantity of piped water supplied to the places in study area is on the lower side as<br />

90


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

compared to many other places in Delhi. As a consequence, households and businesses have<br />

had to resort to exploiting ground water resources. In summer season, the demand is also met<br />

through water tankers. However, it is expected that the piped water supply in the study area will be<br />

augmented in the near future as a result of functioning of 80 MGD new water treatment plant<br />

(Figure 4.14). The <strong>proposed</strong> project is also dependent on meeting its 60% of total water demand<br />

through municipal supply.<br />

• Sewerage:<br />

The project area is served by both open surface storm water drain and closed municipal sewerage<br />

drains. Most of the domestic sewage generated in the project area is carried away by the municipal<br />

drain and discharged into the sewage treatment plant. The open surface storm water drain lies very<br />

close to the <strong>proposed</strong> project site. However, the project will construct a decentralized sewage<br />

treatment plant within its own <strong>complex</strong> to reduce the burden of discharge in the municipal drain<br />

and at the same time to reuse the treated water within the <strong>complex</strong>. Some portion of the unutilized<br />

treated water might find its way to the drain.<br />

• Solid Waste:<br />

Municipal solid waste collection and disposal infrastructure exists in the project area. Figure 4.15<br />

shows the municipal waste disposal sites that exist in Delhi. It is expected that the project area will<br />

see further improvement in the solid waste management in the near future with the operation of the<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> waste disposal sites.<br />

• Power Supply:<br />

Power supply network infrastructure adequately exists in the project area. Although the gap in the<br />

demand and supply fluctuates in different period of the year, the situation will improve in the near<br />

future. Delhi has already initiated the re<strong>for</strong>ms measures in the power sector and is moving towards<br />

the path of energy sufficiency. Although the <strong>proposed</strong> project will provide the in-house power back<br />

up facilities, the improved network supply situation will reduce the dependency on the in-house<br />

generators and hence reduce the associated pollution issues associated with their operation.<br />

4.10.3 Education<br />

Education is an essential element of human development. It plays a major role in improving<br />

economic opportunities <strong>for</strong> people and enhancing their quality of life by building capabilities,<br />

enhancing skill levels and providing more productive employment.<br />

The project area is well placed in having adequate infrastructure facilities <strong>for</strong> education. Number of<br />

pre-primary, primary, middle, secondary and senior secondary schools exists in the area. Over the<br />

91


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

past decade, the project area has grown as a potential site <strong>for</strong> the development of educational<br />

institutions. Some of the renowned schools like Delhi Public School, Modern Convent School,<br />

N.K. Bagrodia School, Bal Bharati School, St. Mary, Bal Bhavan International, DAV, Mary<br />

School, ITL Public School, Venkateshwar etc. exist in the area.<br />

In Delhi, the per capita expenditure on education (including Sports, and Art & Culture) is Rs<br />

926.83 in 2003-04 which is far above the national level of Rs 749.29. With the increase in demand,<br />

more growth in educational infrastructure will likely to come up in the project area.<br />

4.10.4 Health<br />

The project area is in advantageous position in terms of healthcare infrastructure. There exists many<br />

general / intermediate hospitals, polyclinics, nursing homes in the area. Many more government<br />

and private healthcare facilities are being developed in the project area.<br />

4.10.5 Economic Aspects<br />

The project area is witnessing a fast growth in the economic activities. Many big shopping<br />

<strong>complex</strong>es, malls, and hotels are coming up in the area. This will enhance the economic status of<br />

the project area vis-à-vis other parts of the city. Well positioned infrastructure of the project area is<br />

one of the dictating factors <strong>for</strong> the promoters to set up many economic centers in the area. The<br />

location of district centers in the project area will become the major commercial centres in future.<br />

The commercial hub of the area is also being developed along the Metro Railway Line in a linear<br />

<strong>for</strong>m.<br />

4.10.6 Cultural Heritage<br />

Delhi has numerous historic buildings and cultural heritage sites. The ecologically and<br />

environmentally sensitive sites as shown in Figure 4.16 need to be protected from the impact of<br />

any development. However, none of these sites are located within 1 km from the <strong>proposed</strong> project<br />

site.<br />

4.10.7 Aesthetic Aspects<br />

The landscape concept of the project area has evolved a system of open spaces which have the<br />

potential to develop into a landscape with distinctive visual qualities, fulfilling the required<br />

ecological and recreational functions. The location and alignment of existing landscape features<br />

have been used to structure the development of the area.<br />

4.10.8 Communications and Transportation<br />

92


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The project area is well connected to the road network from all sides to the rest of the city. Each<br />

residential sector is bounded on all sides by arterial roads of 45 m and 60 m wide. From arterial<br />

roads four entries have been taken into the sector at a minimum distance of 450 m. a network of<br />

cycle tracks and pedestrian pathways have been provided within each sector which links the<br />

housing clusters and their facilities within each sector.<br />

MRTS has also reached the project area. Bus based public transport system is also the primary<br />

mode of transportation of the people in the project area. The continual improvement which is taking<br />

place in the city including the project area in traffic and transportation will further bring beneficial<br />

impact to the residing population in future.<br />

93


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.13: Piped Water Supply Distribution Map of Delhi<br />

94


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.14: Water Treatment Plant in Delhi (Existing and Proposed)<br />

95


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.15: Municipal Waste Disposal Sites Locations in Delhi<br />

96


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 4.16: Location Map of Heritage Sites and Environmentally Sensitive Sites in Delhi<br />

5. ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS<br />

5.1 Introduction<br />

This section identifies and predicts the potential impacts on different environmental components<br />

due to the construction and operation of the <strong>proposed</strong> project. It details all the potential impacts on<br />

biophysical and socio-economic components of the local environment due to the <strong>proposed</strong> activities<br />

and sub-activities.<br />

Prediction of impacts is the most important component in the Environmental Impact Assessment<br />

studies. Several qualitative and quantitative techniques and methodologies are used to conduct<br />

analysis of the potential impacts likely to accrue as a result of the <strong>proposed</strong> development activities<br />

on physical, ecological and socio-economic environments. Such predictions are superimposed over<br />

the baseline (pre-project) status of the environmental quality to derive at the ultimate (post-project)<br />

scenario of environmental conditions. The prediction of impacts helps to minimize the adverse<br />

impacts and maximize the beneficial impacts on environmental quality during pre and post project<br />

execution.<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong> project would create impacts on the environment in two distinct<br />

phases:<br />

• During the construction phase which may be regarded as temporary or short – term<br />

• The other during the operation stage which would have long – term effects<br />

97


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The environmental impacts in this section have, as such, been discussed separately <strong>for</strong> the<br />

construction phase and the operation stages of the <strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

The environmental impact assessment approach used to evaluate the <strong>proposed</strong> project comprises of<br />

three sequential elements. These are impacts identification, prediction and evaluation.<br />

The first step of the impact assessment process involves identifying the key issues associated with<br />

the construction and operation phases of the project. Issues and concerns of the <strong>proposed</strong> project<br />

are scoped based on the knowledge and experience with respect to environmental setting and<br />

project elements. Accordingly, the existing environmental system is described and the components<br />

of the project are determined.<br />

This step involves identification of the environmental modification that may be significant,<br />

<strong>for</strong>ecasting of the quality and spatial dimension of change in the environment identified and<br />

estimation of the probability that the impact will occur.<br />

This step involve determination of the incidence of benefit to user groups and population affected<br />

by the project, specification and comparison of effects between various alternatives, and assessment<br />

of the likely effect of the project on the environmental, economical and social components<br />

indicating the nature of effects.<br />

5.2 Impacts on Ambient Air Environment<br />

The potential ambient air quality impacts arising from the <strong>proposed</strong> project would occur mainly<br />

during project construction phase. Suspended Particulate Matter (SPM) and Respirable Particulate<br />

Matter (RPM) would be the predominant pollutant generated from construction activities. The<br />

gaseous emissions such as SO 2 , NOx and CO would be generated from the construction equipments<br />

and vehicles. During operation phase, DG sets would be the only point source of emission.<br />

The ambient air quality monitoring results show that the SPM and RPM concentrations at most of<br />

the locations within the core zone of the <strong>proposed</strong> project site are close to the norms prescribed <strong>for</strong><br />

the residential areas. However, appropriate mitigation measures would still be employed during the<br />

construction stage to reduce any incremental rise in pollution level to an acceptable limit.<br />

98


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Monitored values of SO 2 , NOx and CO in the ambient air are well within the limits<br />

indicating low pollution level (L) as per the CPCB criteria.<br />

5.2.1 Impacts During Construction<br />

During construction, the project would have two major impacts on ambient air quality due to an<br />

increase in gaseous emissions by heavy construction equipments and vehicles, and an increase in<br />

dust by construction activities. Earth excavation work, foundation work, superstructure work,<br />

material storage, transportation and handling of construction materials, and wind erosion are the<br />

major factors that would produce a temporary, localized increase in SPM and RPM levels. The<br />

increased movement of heavy vehicles carrying construction materials, operation of DG sets as<br />

standby power back up system would generate gaseous emissions. The degree of dust generated<br />

would depend on the soil compaction and moisture content of the ground surface during<br />

construction. Dust and exhaust particulate emissions from heavy equipment operations would<br />

temporarily degrade air quality in the immediate construction zone. The increase in air particulates<br />

would be minimized by the per<strong>for</strong>mance of the work.<br />

The construction contractor will visually monitor dust levels on the site during construction. Dust<br />

suppression will be instituted, using water tankers mounted on tractors, sprinklers and other means<br />

as necessary, in the event that high levels of dust are observed, strong winds and dry conditions<br />

make dust generation likely, and complaints about dust are received.<br />

Other diffused source of gaseous emissions from the construction site would be if the construction<br />

labours use fuel wood <strong>for</strong> cooking and heating during winters. The construction contractor will<br />

ensure that such practice is not adopted by the labours and they are provided with LPG cylinders<br />

<strong>for</strong> cooking in their labour camps.<br />

5.2.2 Impacts During Operation<br />

None of the <strong>proposed</strong> structures at the project site would be expected to have an impact on air<br />

quality during their normal operation. However, the only point source of emission will be DG sets<br />

which will be installed as standby power supply system. To meet the power requirement during<br />

emergencies, the project has <strong>proposed</strong> to install DG sets as standby power supply system.<br />

99


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The DG sets will be run on HSD with a maximum sulphur content of 1.0 %. It is <strong>proposed</strong> to<br />

install individual stacks of adequate height to exhaust the DG emissions. The stacks of adequate<br />

height will be provided from above the roof of the building as per the norms.<br />

Since heavy fuel will be used, very small quantity of Particulate matter, SO 2 , NOx and CO will be<br />

generated during the combustion process.<br />

Also, during the operation phase of the project, the impacts on air quality due to vehicular<br />

emissions in the <strong>complex</strong> will be very less as the <strong>complex</strong> will not result in generation of any large<br />

volume of traffic. Considering the nature of activities which the <strong>proposed</strong> project will result, low<br />

level of vehicles movement within the <strong>complex</strong>, and low threshold values, air pollution is not<br />

expected to be a major concern. It is <strong>for</strong> these reasons that the ambient air quality predictions using<br />

models have not been carried out.<br />

5.3 Impacts on Ambient Noise Environment<br />

5.3.1 Impacts During Construction<br />

Construction activities normally result in temporary and short duration increases in noise levels.<br />

The main sources of noise during construction period include movement of vehicles <strong>for</strong> loading and<br />

unloading of construction materials, fabrication, handling of equipment and materials, operation of<br />

power shovels, concrete mixing plants, generators etc. The areas affected are those close to the site.<br />

The noise level due to operation of various construction equipments are given in Figure 5.1<br />

Under the worst case scenario, considered <strong>for</strong> prediction of noise levels during construction phase,<br />

it has been assumed that all these equipments generate noise from a common point at an average<br />

noise level of 85 dB (A). The increase in noise levels due to operation of various construction<br />

equipments are given in Table 5.1.<br />

100


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 5.1<br />

Increase in noise levels due to operation of various construction equipments<br />

DISTANCE<br />

(M)<br />

MONITORED<br />

DAY-TIME<br />

AMBIENT<br />

NOISE<br />

LEVELS AT<br />

PROJECT<br />

INCREASE IN<br />

NOISE LEVEL<br />

DUE TO<br />

CONSTRUCTION<br />

ACTIVITIES<br />

DB(A)<br />

NOISE LEVEL<br />

DUE TO<br />

CONSTRUCTION<br />

ACTIVITIES<br />

DB(A)<br />

INCREASE IN<br />

AMBIENT NOISE<br />

LEVEL DUE TO<br />

CONSTRUCTION<br />

ACTIVITIES<br />

DB(A)<br />

SITE DB(A)<br />

15 50 85 85 35<br />

50 50 80 80 30<br />

100 50 75 75 25<br />

200 50 70 70 20<br />

500 50 62 62 12<br />

1000 50 56 56 6<br />

1500 50 52 52 2<br />

2000 50 50 50 -<br />

101


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

102


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 5.1: Noise level due to operation of various construction equipments<br />

It is a known fact that there is a reduction in noise level as the sound wave passes through a barrier.<br />

The transmission loss values <strong>for</strong> common construction materials are given in Table 5.2.<br />

Table 5.2<br />

Transmission loss <strong>for</strong> common construction materials<br />

MATERIAL<br />

THICKNESS OF<br />

CONSTRUCTION<br />

DECREASE IN NOISE<br />

LEVEL DB(A)<br />

MATERIAL (INCHES)<br />

Light concrete<br />

4 38<br />

6 39<br />

Dense concrete 4 40<br />

Concrete block<br />

4 32<br />

6 36<br />

Brick 4 33<br />

Granite 4 40<br />

Thus, the walls of the adjoining buildings along with other factors like air absorption, vegetal cover<br />

etc. would result in significant attenuation of atleast 20 - 25 dB(A) at 100 m distance. The resultant<br />

noise levels on <strong>proposed</strong> project site at 50m distance at peak level of construction are anticipated to<br />

be about 55 – 60 dB(A), which is well within the limit <strong>for</strong> commercial area during the day time.<br />

Further to minimize these potential impacts, major construction activities would be scheduled<br />

during normal daylight working hours and would be implemented consistent with the applicable<br />

standards. The construction contractor will use equipments that are adapted to operate with<br />

appropriate noise muffling devices resulting in the least possible noise. Every ef<strong>for</strong>t would be taken<br />

103


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

to minimize the noise levels including the mandatory use of construction equipment with<br />

operable mufflers.<br />

5.3.2 Impacts During Operation<br />

During operation, the DG set and central air conditioning plant will be the point sources of noise<br />

pollution in the <strong>complex</strong>. The DG set room, compressor and pumps room will be isolated from the<br />

outside environment and proper acoustic arrangements will be made to control the noise generated<br />

from the rooms. The noise levels out side the room will be maintained within the stipulated norms<br />

both during the day and night time.<br />

The effect of high noise levels on the operating personnel in the DG, compressor and pump rooms<br />

will also be considered and appropriate mitigation measures would be adopted. The continuous<br />

exposures to high noise levels above 90 dB(A) affects the hearing capacity of the workers/operators<br />

and hence would be avoided. To prevent these effects, it has been recommended by Occupational<br />

Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) that the exposure period of affected persons be limited<br />

as given in Annexure 3.<br />

5.4 Impacts on Water Environment<br />

5.4.1 Impacts on Ground Water<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project does not have the potential of impacting the ground water quality and<br />

quantity in a significant manner in the long term during the operation phase. The project would<br />

likely to withdraw groundwater at maximum rate of 5 m 3 /hr to meet its daily requirement of about<br />

297 m 3 /hr. However, the new buildings, parking lots and other built up facilities would decrease the<br />

natural infiltration rate of rainwater. Also, since the project area is experiencing the increasing<br />

number of borewells, the cumulative effects could enhance the degree of impact of the individual<br />

system. The quality of groundwater could deteriorate in terms of nitrate, fluoride, and chloride, if<br />

the abstraction of groundwater over a longer period leads to further lowering of the ground water<br />

table.<br />

However, with the project proposing to implement the rain water harvesting <strong>for</strong> ground water<br />

recharge, conservation through education to bring about greater water efficiency, and reuse of<br />

104


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

treated wastewater on the <strong>proposed</strong> site during operation of the project <strong>for</strong> use in horticulture<br />

and other auxiliary purposes, the effect would be minimized. The wastewater generated will be<br />

treated and reused within the campus. About 6-8 m 3 /hr of treated water will be reused <strong>for</strong> flushing<br />

of toilets and horticulture purpose. It is also expected that there will be a significant increase in the<br />

municipal piped supply of water with the augmentation of the capacity of the water treatment plants<br />

in the area in near future. Both these measures along with implementation of rainwater harvesting<br />

and conservation measures would have positive impact on the ground water quality and quantity.<br />

These measures would reduce the fresh intake quantity from the ground water.<br />

Groundwater was tested at the project site and was compared to IS: 10500 (1991) <strong>for</strong> evaluation.<br />

Most of the parameters are observed to be within the limits prescribed by this standard. Since no<br />

wastewater from the <strong>complex</strong> will be discharged into the open, no impact on groundwater quality is<br />

envisaged.<br />

The water requirement during the construction phase will be partly met through tankers and in<br />

limited case through borewell and hence no adverse impacts on ground water are envisaged.<br />

5.4.2 Impacts on Piped Water Supply<br />

Water consumption in the <strong>proposed</strong> residential and academic <strong>complex</strong> is estimated to be about 297<br />

m 3 / day. About 60% of this consumption will be met through the municipal piped water supply and<br />

the remaining will be from the ground water. The increase in water demand from the existing water<br />

supply network would decrease the number of supply hours <strong>for</strong> the existing users in the project<br />

area. It is expected that the increase in water demand will be met from additional water available<br />

from new water treatment which is being <strong>proposed</strong> in Dwarka and will come soon and hence would<br />

not have any significant impact on the existing water supply. Moreover, by setting up of the STP<br />

on-site, the consumption of fresh water intake would likely to be reduced. Also, with the present<br />

water supply potential of the existing system i.e. 74 lpcd, the demand <strong>for</strong> the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong><br />

could easily be met.<br />

During construction phase, no demand will be put on the existing piped water supply network and<br />

will be partly met through tankers and partly from the ground water.<br />

5.5.3 Impacts Due to Wastewater Generation<br />

105


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

During Construction<br />

The major source of water pollution during project construction phase will be sewage from labour<br />

camps and makeshift office. It is expected that at any given time during the construction phase, the<br />

peak manpower strength on construction site comprising of technical staff, clerical/supervisor,<br />

skilled and unskilled workers would be about 1500 persons. The average domestic water<br />

requirements would be about 50 lpcd. Thus, total water requirements work out to be 75,000 litres /<br />

day (max.). It is assumed that about 80% of the water required will be generated as sewage. Thus,<br />

total quantum of sewage generated in peak situation is expected to be about 60,000 litres / day. The<br />

generated sewage would pass through a septic tank and its discharge would be connected to the<br />

existing municipal sewage network of the area.<br />

During Operation<br />

The major source of water pollution during project operation phase will be the wastewater from the<br />

academic and residential <strong>complex</strong>. During project operation phase, due to the absence of any large<br />

scale construction activities, the cause and source of water pollution will be much different. It is<br />

expected about 235 m 3 /day of sewage will be generated. The expected characteristics of the<br />

untreated wastewater will be as given in Table 5.3. The total BOD loading without treatment will<br />

be of the order of 35 to 60 kg/day. This is significant to cause any adverse impact on any receiving<br />

water body. The impacts that may occur due to disposal of untreated sewage will be mitigated as a<br />

result of commissioning of adequate sewage treatment plant (STP) in the <strong>proposed</strong> facilities.<br />

Table 5.3<br />

Expected Characteristics of Untreated Wastewater<br />

S. No. Parameters expected value<br />

1. Color Turbid / Grey<br />

2. pH 5.5 – 6.5<br />

3. Oil and Grease 15 – 30 mg/l<br />

4. Total Suspended Solids 180 – 260 mg/l<br />

5. Total Dissolved Solids 1000 – 1300 mg/l<br />

106


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

6. BOD 3 @ 27 o C 150 – 250 mg/l<br />

7. COD 275 – 450 mg/l<br />

It is <strong>proposed</strong> to treat the wastewater through a full fledged decentralized STP based on Aerobic<br />

Fluidized Bed Reactor Technology. The STP will be set up <strong>for</strong> a mean daily flow rate of 10.42<br />

m 3 /hr., peak hourly flow rate of 20 m 3 /hr., and minimum flow rate of 4.5 m 3 /hr.<br />

The system will consist of a collection cum equalization tank where the waste water will be<br />

received and homogenized and equalized <strong>for</strong> the continuous operation of the treatment plant. It will<br />

be followed by primary clarifier to remove most of the suspended solids from the wastewater. The<br />

wastewater thereafter will flow to aerated fluidized bed reactor <strong>for</strong> the biological oxidation of the<br />

organics to reduce BOD and COD and also to reduce the bacterial population by order magnitude.<br />

A secondary clarifier will separate the microorganism in the <strong>for</strong>m of biological sludge to be<br />

recycled back to the aeration chamber. A sludge collection sump will be provided to collect the<br />

sludge. A sludge pump will dewater the sludge with a provision <strong>for</strong> recycle of sludge to the<br />

fluidized bed reactor during start up. Sludge filtration system will be provided in the <strong>for</strong>m of filter<br />

press. Treated wastewater will be chlorinated in the disinfection tank. An intermediate treated water<br />

storage tank will be provided <strong>for</strong> further tertiary treatment. The treated wastewater in tertiary<br />

treatment will pass through pressure sand filter <strong>for</strong> the final clarification. Activated carbon filter<br />

will be provided to remove the final traces of organic matters and make it suitable <strong>for</strong> reuse within<br />

the campus. A collection tank will be provided <strong>for</strong> collection and storage of the clear tertiary treated<br />

waste water <strong>for</strong> reuse within the campus.<br />

The disinfection will be carried out by means of chlorination. This will be done by the hypochlorite<br />

solution as the chlorinating agent. The hypochlorite solution is easily available in different<br />

concentration ranges with free chlorine content of 10% or more and is quite easy to handle because<br />

of operation at ambient pressure and being able to pump the liquid by means of normal dosing<br />

pumps.<br />

The treated wastewater will be used <strong>for</strong> flushing of toilets and in horticulture purpose within the<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

The expected characteristics of the treated wastewater after secondary and tertiary treatment<br />

process are given in Table 5.4.<br />

107


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 5.4<br />

Expected Characteristics of Treated Wastewater<br />

S. No. Parameters after secondary<br />

treatment<br />

AFTER<br />

TERTIARY<br />

TREATMENT<br />

1. pH 7.5 7.2<br />

2. Oil and Grease Nil Nil<br />

3. Total Suspended Solids 60 5<br />

4. Total Dissolved Solids 850 850<br />

5. BOD 3 @ 27 o C 25 10<br />

6. COD 75 40<br />

5.5 Impacts on Land Environment<br />

5.5.1 Impacts on Land Use<br />

The project site lies in the Public / Semi-public land use category of the project area. The adjoining<br />

lands to the project site are essentially institutional. Within 1 Km radius of the <strong>proposed</strong> project<br />

site, many residential apartments also exist. As there is requirement of substantial residential<br />

accommodation <strong>for</strong> the National Law School as well as <strong>for</strong> the Delhi Judicial Academy, the<br />

Ministry of Urban Development after the recommendation by DDA has issued a gazette<br />

notification to bifurcate the project site with different land uses, namely Institutional and<br />

Residential.<br />

108


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project site is designated <strong>for</strong> the intended purpose and the necessary change in<br />

the land use of the plot area measuring 23,180 sq. meters (5.72 acres) has already been effected by<br />

converting it to land use <strong>for</strong> residential use from land use <strong>for</strong> Government use in MPD-2001.<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project site is a vacant land and does not involve activity of any type. It is anticipated<br />

that the construction activities of the <strong>proposed</strong> project would not have an adverse effect on the land<br />

use activities in the project area, and will not be encroached during the construction of the project.<br />

Moreover, local land use planning will control the type, density and location of development in the<br />

future. Hence, the <strong>proposed</strong> new construction could be considered to comply with the present<br />

zoning classification of neighborhood business.<br />

Development of green belt and other landscape on the <strong>proposed</strong> site would enhance the visual<br />

aesthetics of the area.<br />

5.5.2 Impacts on Soil<br />

The site clearing and preparation activities will involve removal of only scanty vegetation existing<br />

on the <strong>proposed</strong> plant site. The project site is primarily dominated by undergrowth and unwanted<br />

bushes. As the topography in and around the site is mostly plain with no slope, the digging of the<br />

site be<strong>for</strong>e the start of the construction work <strong>for</strong> the foundation work would not result any<br />

significant effect on soil erosion and silt run off, even during the heavy rains. The project requires<br />

extensive work on the excavation and removal of soil and hence will temporarily affect soil<br />

structure and stability localized.<br />

The project proponent will adopt good construction practices that will ensure the environmental<br />

impacts of waste effluents generated on-site during construction will be minimized.<br />

5.5.3 Construction Wastes<br />

The generation of waste material is inevitable during the construction phase of the development.<br />

Waste is generated at different stages of construction process. Waste during construction activity<br />

relates to excessive cement mix or concrete left after work is over, rejection caused due to change<br />

in design or wrong workmanship etc. Estimated waste generation during construction is 40 to 60 kg<br />

109


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

per sq. m. Concrete appears in two <strong>for</strong>ms in the waste. Structural elements of building have<br />

rein<strong>for</strong>ced concrete, while foundations have mass non-rein<strong>for</strong>ced concrete.<br />

Excavation of earth and rock generates muck. Other wastes include top soil, clay, sand, and gravel.<br />

These are normally re-used as filler at the same site after completion of excavation work. Other<br />

miscellaneous materials that arise as waste include glass, plastic material, general refuse, scrap<br />

metal, cardboard, plastics, and sewage wastes from the construction workers housing.<br />

Construction waste is bulky and heavy and is mostly unsuitable <strong>for</strong> disposal by incineration or<br />

composting. Unutilized or unused solid wastes generated during construction will be disposed of to<br />

a designated landfill sites in the project area.<br />

5.5.4 Solid Wastes Generation and Disposal<br />

Solid wastes will be generated from the residential <strong>complex</strong>, academic <strong>complex</strong>, and sewage<br />

treatment plant during the operation phase of the project. The academic <strong>complex</strong> will generate solid<br />

wastes such as paper, cardboard, plastics, and general refuse by routine activities. The domestic<br />

solid waste from the residential <strong>complex</strong> and academic <strong>complex</strong> is expected to be generated to the<br />

tune of 540 kg / day considering per capita of waste generation of 0.45 kg/person/day from the<br />

residential <strong>complex</strong> <strong>for</strong> about 750 persons and about 0.1 kg/person/day from the academic <strong>complex</strong><br />

<strong>for</strong> about 2000 persons.<br />

The domestic solid wastes will be segregated into bio-degradable and non-biodegradable. Where<br />

recycling is feasible, these wastes will be stored in segregated bins and removed as required. Other<br />

solid wastes will be removed by sanitary contractor on a regular basis and disposed to a designated<br />

municipal landfill site.<br />

The solid waste generated from the STP will be dewatered and used <strong>for</strong> the horticulture purpose<br />

within and outside the <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

5.6 Impacts on Socio – Economic Environment<br />

5.6.1 Hazards to Construction Workers and the Local Population<br />

110


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

During the construction period, the activities may result pondage of water in the dug – out<br />

areas of the site. This has the potential <strong>for</strong> creation of mosquitoes breeding and spreading of vector<br />

borne diseases. The most important construction aspects are the impediment of temporary drainage<br />

by blocked silt traps or the ponding of water within foundation works. Other mosquito breeding<br />

sites maybe created through the use of uncovered water tanks. The project will give careful<br />

attention to the design and maintenance of earthworks and drainage systems during construction to<br />

avoid the creation of significant habitat areas <strong>for</strong> mosquito larvae. The use of larvicides may be<br />

required to prevent mosquito breeding in silt traps.<br />

5.6.2 Housing and Transportation of Construction Workers<br />

The project will facilitate maximum participation of the fair and equitable local work <strong>for</strong>ce <strong>for</strong> the<br />

construction. This will not only benefit local economy and employment, but also reduce the need to<br />

build temporary shelter and supply services. However, the project will still require some skilled and<br />

unskilled migrant workers. In such case, the project will provide portable toilets, washing facilities,<br />

potable water supply, and LPG <strong>for</strong> cooking on site during construction. The sewage will be<br />

temporarily connected to the municipal drains.<br />

The supply of LPG cylinders <strong>for</strong> cooking will reduce the dependency of the construction workers<br />

on the fuel wood and hence the chances of any smoke and other air pollutants.<br />

5.6.3 Socio – cultural Impacts<br />

The project will contribute only marginally to the socio-economic development of the area at the<br />

local level. The land values around the project site are likely to be increased after the operation of<br />

the project. The direct and indirect employment to the local population during the operation of the<br />

project at both skilled and unskilled levels will benefit the local population and its specific groups.<br />

About 750 persons will stay in residential <strong>complex</strong> and thus add only marginally to the existing<br />

population of the area. The transient population to the academic <strong>complex</strong> will be about 250-300<br />

persons. The project area and its local population would benefit from the easy access to the <strong>judicial</strong><br />

<strong>academy</strong> and National Law School. Economic activity will get a boost <strong>for</strong> small shopkeepers,<br />

vendors and hence have a positive impact.<br />

5.6.4 Impacts on Physical Infrastructure<br />

111


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project would not impact the existing water supply infrastructure of DJB as the<br />

increasing demand in future would be met through an additional supply from new water treatment<br />

plant which is being <strong>proposed</strong> in Dwarka. Existing sewerage network would not be loaded as the<br />

project is proposing to install a decentralized sewage treatment plant on-site. Power supply<br />

infrastructure adequately exists in the project area. However, the project is also proposing to install<br />

DG sets <strong>for</strong> meeting the power requirement in-house in case of emergency situations.<br />

5.6.5 Employment Opportunities<br />

The construction of the <strong>proposed</strong> project is expected to provide temporary employment to a good<br />

number of skilled and unskilled workers directly and to others like owner of plant and equipments,<br />

vehicles etc. <strong>for</strong> a nearly 30 months, thus indirectly constituting a moderate positive impact.<br />

Along with direct employment, there will be scope <strong>for</strong> generation of secondary employment to<br />

provide services to the working people during the operation of the <strong>proposed</strong> project <strong>for</strong> various<br />

needs. All these will be beneficial to the local economy.<br />

5.7 Renewable Resources<br />

Potential adverse effects from the use of renewable resources are associated with the construction<br />

of the project components that will require the use of renewable and non-renewable resources<br />

including wood, gravel, sand, steel, concrete and paper products. The materials, apart from paper<br />

products, will be used during the construction period only and will not be required during the<br />

operation of the <strong>proposed</strong> project. Paper products (e.g., paper, cardboard) will be used during the<br />

operation of these components <strong>for</strong> record keeping, etc. However, their use will be limited. It is<br />

expected that the use of these materials during construction will result in negligible adverse effects<br />

on renewable resource supply as the construction materials will be procured from the licensed<br />

materials supplier.<br />

Fossil fuels, such as diesel fuel, gasoline and oil will be used during the construction and operation<br />

of the project <strong>for</strong> mechanical and electrical equipments and should have negligible adverse effects<br />

on renewable resources.<br />

112


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Electricity will be used during construction to provide power to construction equipment and<br />

in operation <strong>for</strong> lighting of buildings and running utilities equipments. Electricity consumption will<br />

be kept at a minimum when possible by adopting electricity conservation measures.<br />

The project proponent will ensure that the contractor selected to construct the project will<br />

implement best management practices to conserve renewable resources. These may include, but are<br />

not limited to:<br />

• Use of energy-efficient lighting;<br />

• Lighting of only critical areas during non-working hours;<br />

• Efficient scheduling of construction crews;<br />

• Minimizing idling of construction equipment and vehicles;<br />

• Recycling of used motor oils and hydraulic fluids.<br />

5.8 Potential Environmental Impact Matrix<br />

This methodology incorporates a list of project activities with a checklist of environmental<br />

components that might be affected. Matrix methods incorporate environmental conditions on one<br />

axis and <strong>proposed</strong> actions on the other.<br />

The impact of each action on the various environmental components are filled in a tabular <strong>for</strong>mat to<br />

estimate the impacts may be either qualitative, insignificant, high, adverse, beneficial or<br />

quantitative by assessing a numerical score, but in the end there should be a grand total to signify<br />

the magnitude of the impact. The activities discussed above are likely to affect the environment in<br />

varying degrees. Relevant components of environment, which are likely to experience some<br />

impacts due to the project activities, have been identified.<br />

Environmental parameters are broadly classified under three following groups considering the<br />

cause - effect relationship:<br />

• Physical Environment<br />

• Biological Environment<br />

• Non Biophysical Components (NBP)<br />

113


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The parameters selected <strong>for</strong> impact identification are site activities and project specific.<br />

Different parameters considered under the said groups are as follows:<br />

• Ambient Air Quality<br />

• Noise<br />

• Ground water quality<br />

• Ground water quantity<br />

• Soil stability / erosion<br />

• Soil quality<br />

• Vegetation<br />

• Resource use<br />

• Health<br />

• Socio economic<br />

The interaction between project activities and environmental parameters described above are shown<br />

in the impact matrix in the Table 5.4. The matrix points out each activity and its impact on specific<br />

environmental parameters. This is a qualitative work and does not indicate quantitative impact.<br />

Some of the impacts are temporary and localized and some impacts are short term and long term in<br />

the matrix.<br />

114


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Table 5.5 Potential Environmental Impact Matrix<br />

project activities<br />

physical biological non Biophysical Components (NBP)<br />

Construction Phase<br />

Air Quality<br />

Ground<br />

Water<br />

Quality<br />

Ground<br />

Water<br />

Quantity<br />

Soil<br />

Stability /<br />

Erosion<br />

Soil<br />

Quality<br />

Noise Vegetation Resource<br />

Use (Water<br />

supply<br />

and use,<br />

visual<br />

features)<br />

Health<br />

(Individual<br />

/Community,<br />

Occupational)<br />

Socioeconomic<br />

(Population,<br />

Community<br />

Infrastructure,<br />

Employment)<br />

Site excavation<br />

and foundation<br />

work<br />

Material storage,<br />

transportation and<br />

handling<br />

Movement of<br />

vehicles<br />

Construction<br />

workers camps<br />

Operation Phase<br />

ST, - ve,<br />

RE<br />

ST, -ve,<br />

RE<br />

ST, -ve ST, -ve ST, +ve<br />

ST, -ve ST, -ve ST, -ve ST, +ve<br />

ST, -ve ST, -ve +ve<br />

ST, -ve ST, -ve +ve<br />

Running of DG<br />

sets,compressors,<br />

pumps<br />

Sewage<br />

discharge<br />

Operation of<br />

Complex<br />

Water<br />

Requirement<br />

RE, LT,<br />

- ve<br />

RE, - ve,<br />

LT<br />

-ve<br />

IR, -ve, LT<br />

LT, -ve LT, +ve LT, +ve, + ve, LT<br />

LT, IR, -ve LT, IR, -ve LT, IR, -ve<br />

ST Short Term LT Long Term RE Reversible IR Irreversible<br />

+ve Potential Positive Impacts<br />

- ve Potential Negative Impacts (require mitigation measures)<br />

115


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

6. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT<br />

Environmental impact checklists combine the assessment of individual impacts with a<br />

checklist of probable impacts <strong>for</strong> a project. The following five environmental components<br />

have been considered <strong>for</strong> the purpose of assessment and evaluation of the environmental<br />

impact due to the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

• Air Environment<br />

• Noise Environment<br />

• Water Environment<br />

• Land Environment<br />

• Socio Economic Environment<br />

6.1 Air Environment<br />

Land development activities may lead to the generation of dust. Foundation work would<br />

require pile driving using heavy machinery, which may produce gaseous pollutants.<br />

Construction work will involve excavation and concreting etc. All these activities may<br />

give rise to dust, resulting in air pollution. The structural work will involve steelwork,<br />

concrete work, masonry work etc. and construction equipment like concrete mixers,<br />

hoists, and welding sets etc. will be used. These activities at times produce air<br />

contaminants.<br />

The dust generated during the activities will be of low magnitude and will be settable in<br />

nature. The quantum of any gaseous pollution is insignificant. The impact due to such<br />

emissions is expected to be confined within the close vicinity of the <strong>proposed</strong><br />

construction site. The impact will, however, be marginal, reversible and short term.<br />

During the operation of the <strong>complex</strong> no significant sources of gaseous pollution are<br />

expected. Only at the time of power cut, DG sets will be operated with required height of<br />

116


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

stack <strong>for</strong> adequate dispersion of gaseous pollutants as per the guidelines of the<br />

environmental standards.<br />

Air Environment: In general, the <strong>proposed</strong> Complex will have a short term, marginal<br />

reversible and localized impact on air quality in the neighborhood during the<br />

construction phase and insignificant impact during operational phase.<br />

6.2 Noise Environment<br />

During the construction phase, different types of plant and machinery will be deployed<br />

resulting at times an increase in noise levels at the construction site. Proper planning of<br />

these operations will be made during this period so that the disturbances will be<br />

minimized due to such noise generation. Most of the construction work would be<br />

undertaken only between 8 am to 6 pm.<br />

Functioning of the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong> is not expected to create any noise pollution. DG<br />

sets, compressor, pumps will be placed inside the covered room to avoid any noise<br />

problem.<br />

Noise Environment: In general, the overall impact on noise level due to the <strong>proposed</strong><br />

Complex will be almost insignificant.<br />

6.3 Water Environment<br />

• Ground Water Hydrology<br />

Ground water will be used during the construction phase activities (only after permission)<br />

as well as <strong>for</strong> meeting the daily demand of the Complex during the operational phase.<br />

However, maximum care will be taken to avoid any misuse of ground water.<br />

Ground Water Environment: As such, the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong> will have a marginal but no<br />

long – term impact on the ground water hydrology.<br />

117


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• Water Use<br />

Water requirements during construction phase will be mainly met through tankers. The<br />

requirements during operation will be met through both municipal supply and ground<br />

water.<br />

Water Use: In general, the <strong>proposed</strong> Complex is not likely to have any significant longterm<br />

impact on the water use scenario of the region during construction & operational<br />

phases.<br />

6.4 Land Environment<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project will not alter the land use pattern of the <strong>proposed</strong> site. The site,<br />

after completion of its development, would consist of build up structure neatly<br />

landscaped, leading to a pleasant outlook. Plantation of trees in the open spaces would<br />

add a different dimension to the existing landscape of open vacant lands and would<br />

provide a visual com<strong>for</strong>t.<br />

Land Environment: As such, there will be an insignificant impact on the land use during<br />

the construction period while a beneficial impact is expected in the operational of the<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

• ECOLOGY<br />

The impact of construction activities will be primarily confined to the project site. The<br />

site doesn’t involve any <strong>for</strong>estland. Thus, the site development work will not lead to any<br />

significant loss of any important taxonomy. Removal of topsoil often leads to soil<br />

erosion. Deposition of fugitive dust on leaves of nearby vegetation may lead to temporary<br />

118


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

reduction of photosynthesis. Such impacts will, however, be confined mostly to the initial<br />

periods of the construction phase.<br />

The entire <strong>complex</strong> would be extensively landscaped with a variety of taxa. No wild life<br />

sanctuary is involved in the site and vicinity. There<strong>for</strong>e, there is no likely tangible impact<br />

from noise and emissions during construction on the animals and birds in the area.<br />

Ecological Environment: No impact on terrestrial and aquatic ecology is expected due<br />

to the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

6.5 Socio Economic Environment<br />

A sizeable work<strong>for</strong>ce comprising skilled, semi skilled and unskilled labours will be<br />

needed at the peak period of construction phase. Significant number of semi skilled and<br />

unskilled labourers will be recruited from the near by areas. This will create some<br />

employment opportunities in the area. Since most of the sizeable labour <strong>for</strong>ce will be<br />

drawn from neighborhood, no new environmental problem is anticipated.<br />

Temporary accommodation in the <strong>for</strong>m of workers camp will be constructed <strong>for</strong> a few<br />

special categories of migrant skilled and semi skilled workers within the project site. In<br />

such eventuality, certain measurers will be taken. The camp will be provided with the<br />

adequate sanitation facilities. There<strong>for</strong>e, it will not cause any significant social stress,<br />

though some degradation in the immediate physical environment would be unavoidable.<br />

Most of the construction work is labour intensive. As contractors will do most of the job,<br />

it will be ensured that the contractor workers are provided with proper facilities including<br />

proper sanitation and safe drinking water supply.<br />

There is no permanent resident on the project site and as such, the project would not<br />

result in any direct evictions. The construction materials will be procured local market<br />

and also though various sources. Thus, there is a possibly of local employment<br />

generation, though temporary.<br />

119


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Construction activities will provide direct and indirect job opportunities to a large number<br />

of people, thus having a beneficial impact on local economy.<br />

The project is expected to have a marginal but significant positive impact on local<br />

economic scenario.<br />

Socio Economic Environment: In general, the <strong>proposed</strong> Complex will have a positive<br />

impact on the socioeconomic environment. It will have a long-term positive impact on the<br />

socioeconomic environment and it will increase the over all value of the surrounding<br />

area.<br />

7. ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN<br />

7.1 Introduction<br />

This section outlines the key environmental management and safeguards that will be<br />

initiated by the project proponent to manage the project’s key environmental concerns.<br />

Environmental Management Plan (EMP) is the mechanism to ensure that environmental<br />

considerations are <strong>integrated</strong> into the project survey and design, contract documents and<br />

project supervision and monitoring. These are tools <strong>for</strong> mitigating or offsetting the<br />

potential adverse environmental impacts resulting from various activities of the project.<br />

120


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The environmental management plan (EMP) mainly consists of integrating potential<br />

impacts (positive or negative), environmental mitigation measures, implementation<br />

schedule, and monitoring plans.<br />

The potential environmental impacts and <strong>proposed</strong> management associated with each<br />

stage of the project development are described here. The primary objective of this<br />

<strong>proposed</strong> environmental management and monitoring programme is to control<br />

environmental impacts to levels within acceptable standards, and to minimise possible<br />

impact on the community and the work<strong>for</strong>ce of <strong>for</strong>eseeable risks during the construction<br />

and subsequent operation phases of the project.<br />

Also, it is very important to highlight here that such environmental mitigation measures<br />

shall be used in conjunction with good management practices and good engineering<br />

design, construction and operation practices.<br />

The EMP will be a working document that personnel on site need to both understand and<br />

undertake environmental management. It will be ensured personnel are in a position to<br />

adequately manage the environmental concerns of the site and effectively monitor <strong>for</strong> and<br />

mitigate impacts.<br />

7.2 Mitigation Measures during Construction<br />

7.2.1 Air Quality and Dust<br />

• All dusty materials shall be sprayed with water prior to any loading, unloading or<br />

transfer operation so as to maintain the dusty materials wet.<br />

121


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• Stockpiles of aggregate or spoil shall be covered and water applied.<br />

• Vehicles delivering loose and fine materials like sand and fine aggregates shall be<br />

covered to reduce spills on roads.<br />

• The height from which excavated materials are dropped shall be controlled to a<br />

minimum practical height to limit fugitive dust generation from unloading.<br />

• All vehicles, equipment and machinery used <strong>for</strong> construction shall be regularly<br />

maintained to ensure that the pollution emission levels con<strong>for</strong>m to the CPCB norms.<br />

• The random ambient air quality monitoring shall be done to ensure that the significant<br />

impacts are being mitigated adequately.<br />

7.2.2 Noise<br />

• Proposed project site is within an institutional / residential area.<br />

• Construction shall be carried out in accordance with standard procedures. All plants<br />

and construction equipments shall be fitted with noise control measures and shall<br />

strictly con<strong>for</strong>m to the MoEF/CPCB noise standards.<br />

• On-site power gensets shall be covered with an acoustic enclosure and fitted with<br />

muffler and shall con<strong>for</strong>m to the noise emission standards.<br />

• Servicing of all construction vehicles and machinery shall be done regularly and<br />

during routine servicing operations, the effectiveness of exhaust silencers will be<br />

checked and if found defective will be replaced. Vehicles hired <strong>for</strong> bringing<br />

construction materials at site shall con<strong>for</strong>m to the noise emission standards and shall<br />

be operated during non peak hours.<br />

• Ambient noise level monitoring shall be conducted at suitable locations at periodic<br />

intervals during construction phase to con<strong>for</strong>m to the stipulated standards both during<br />

day and night time. Data shall be reviewed and analyzed by the project manager <strong>for</strong><br />

adhering to any strict measure.<br />

7.2.3 Land Environment<br />

122


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• The project will take prior permission from the competent authority <strong>for</strong> disposal of<br />

construction waste on landfill site in the project area.<br />

• It will be ensured that no construction spoils of any unsuitable material are disposed<br />

off on roadside or any other place in the project area.<br />

• Construction debris will be collected and suitably used on site as per construction<br />

waste management plan<br />

7.2.4 Hazards to Construction Workers and the Local Population<br />

• Careful attention to design and maintenance of earthworks and drainage systems<br />

during construction to avoid creation of significant habitat areas <strong>for</strong> mosquito larvae.<br />

• Use of larvicides may be required to prevent mosquito breeding in silt traps.<br />

7.2.5 Ground Water Quality and Quantity<br />

• Contractor will arrange adequate supply and storage of water <strong>for</strong> the whole<br />

construction period.<br />

• The water requirement during construction will be mainly met through tankers.<br />

• Alternate water supply will also be met through ground water but after taking<br />

permission from Delhi Water Board. If permitted, balanced approach will be followed<br />

towards utilization of ground water in construction work.<br />

• The contractor will take all precautions to minimize the wastage of water in the<br />

construction process.<br />

7.2.6 Housing and Transportation of Construction Workers<br />

• The project will provide kerosene or cooking gas to the construction workers on-site<br />

so that they do not resort to using fuel wood <strong>for</strong> cooking.<br />

• Temporary sanitary facilities shall be provided on-site and proper hygienic conditions<br />

are maintained.<br />

123


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

7.2.7 Traffic Pattern<br />

• Heavy vehicular movement will be restricted to daytime only and adequate parking<br />

facility will be provided.<br />

7.3 Mitigation Measures during Operation<br />

7.3.1 Air Quality<br />

• Use of ultra low sulphur diesel will be used in the DG sets.<br />

• Green belt development with specific species will reduce SPM levels.<br />

• Use of clean fuel by the vehicles will reduce the emission of pollutants.<br />

7.3.2 Noise<br />

• Proposed project site is within an institutional / residential area.<br />

• All noise generating sources in the <strong>complex</strong> will be equipped with appropriate noise<br />

control measures. Sound levels will be consistent with local government regulations.<br />

• Ambient noise levels will be periodically monitored to determine compliance with the<br />

norms.<br />

• Noise levels will also be monitored at point sources <strong>for</strong> occupational noise exposure<br />

and ensuring health risk.<br />

7.3.3 Land Environment<br />

• Solid waste generated from the STP will be reused <strong>for</strong> horticulture purpose within<br />

and outside the <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

• Domestic solid waste generated from the court and residential <strong>complex</strong> will be<br />

segregated in biodegradable and non biodegradable. The unutilized and non reused<br />

waste shall be disposed to a designated municipal landfill site in the project area.<br />

124


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

7.3.4 Ground Water Quality and Quantity<br />

• Rainwater harvesting <strong>for</strong> optimum utilization of rainwater to recharge the ground<br />

water level / borewell area to be adopted.<br />

• Well design storm water network to collect the rain water from the site area and<br />

diverted to the <strong>proposed</strong> rainwater harvesting pits <strong>for</strong> recharging the ground water.<br />

• All ef<strong>for</strong>ts to conserve water in the <strong>complex</strong> to comply with the standards of water<br />

conservation practices.<br />

• Ground water quality shall be periodically monitored and records shall be reviewed<br />

and analyzed on regular basis.<br />

7.3.5 Infrastructure<br />

• Run off from building areas during rains will be utilized <strong>for</strong> harvesting and recharge<br />

of ground water. Appropriate water conservation measures will be adopted in regular<br />

activities.<br />

• Vegetative barriers along the site boundary will act as a noise barrier.<br />

• The domestic sewage generated from the <strong>complex</strong> will be linked to STP being set up<br />

on-site. The treated water will be reused <strong>for</strong> flushing of toilets and hence will reduce<br />

the fresh water consumption <strong>for</strong> the same activity.<br />

7.3.6 Traffic Pattern<br />

• Vehicle movement will be regulated inside the site with adequate roads and parking<br />

lots.<br />

7.4 Human Health and Safety Management Plan<br />

125


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The objective is to ensure that the health and safety of on-site personnel is proactively<br />

managed during the construction stage of the project. Below are given the <strong>proposed</strong><br />

project related human health and safety environmental concerns and its management.<br />

• The primary concern on potential health risks <strong>for</strong> the construction workers and other<br />

employees on site during construction are associated with drinking water quality. The<br />

project would ensure safe potable water supply to the workers on site.<br />

• Adequate space needs to be provided <strong>for</strong> construction of temporary sheds <strong>for</strong><br />

construction workers to avoid unhygienic conditions.<br />

• Construction site will be provided with a readily available first aid kit including an<br />

adequate supply of sterilized dressing materials and appliances. Suitable transport to<br />

take injured or sick person to the nearest hospital will be immediately provided.<br />

• The project will ensure the safe working of all workers. Each construction worker<br />

will be provided with safety gadgets and made to wear during the construction work.<br />

This will include protective footwear, helmets, and gloves to all workers employed<br />

<strong>for</strong> the work on mixing, cement, lime mortars, concrete etc.; the welder’s protective<br />

eye-shields to workers who are engaged in welding works; earplugs to workers<br />

exposed to loud noise; safety belts to the labours working at higher plat<strong>for</strong>ms; and<br />

masks to avoid dust.<br />

• The project will strictly follow the statutory child labour act. The project will also<br />

ensure that no paint containing lead or lead products is used except in the <strong>for</strong>m of<br />

paste or readymade paint. Facemasks will be provided <strong>for</strong> use to the workers when<br />

paint is applied in the <strong>for</strong>m of spray. Adequate safety measures will be ensured <strong>for</strong><br />

workers during handling of materials at site. The project will comply with all<br />

regulations regarding safe scaffolding, ladders, working plat<strong>for</strong>ms, gangway,<br />

stairwells, excavations, and safe means of entry and exit.<br />

126


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• The project will take adequate precautions to prevent danger from electrical<br />

equipments. No material will be so stacked or placed as to cause danger or<br />

inconvenience to any person or the public. All necessary fencing and lights will be<br />

provided to protect the public. All machines to be used in the construction will<br />

con<strong>for</strong>m to the relevant Indian Standard Codes, will be free from patent defect, will<br />

be kept in good working order, will be regularly inspected and properly maintained as<br />

per IS provision.<br />

• Work spots will be maintained clean, and provided with optimum lighting.<br />

7.5 Fire Safety and Protection<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>complex</strong> will be provided with adequate fire protection arrangements such<br />

as underground water storage tank of 2 lakh litres capacity, one over head water storage<br />

tank of 20,000 litres capacity, fire pump, wet riser system, hose reel, hose box, fire alarm<br />

system, portable fire extinguisher, one standby DG set connected with lift, fire pump,<br />

emergency light.<br />

Main entrance to the <strong>complex</strong> shall be of adequate width to allow easy access to the fire<br />

fighting appliances. The <strong>proposed</strong> building shall be suitably compartmentalized so that<br />

fire/smoke remains confined to the area where fire incidents have occurred and does not<br />

spread to the remaining part of the building. The services, ESS standby generator,<br />

canteen, stores etc. must be segregated from other by erecting fire resisting wall of atleast<br />

4 hrs rating.<br />

The materials used <strong>for</strong> construction of the building shall be of non combustible. Non<br />

combustible materials shall only be used <strong>for</strong> the construction / erection of false ceiling<br />

including all fixtures and used <strong>for</strong> its suspension / erection etc. and shall be of low flame<br />

rating.<br />

127


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The standby electric generator shall be installed to supply power to staircase and corridor<br />

lighting circuit, ventilation and smoke extraction system, lifts, exit signs and fire pump in<br />

case of failure of normal electric supply.<br />

The construction of electric sub station and installation of trans<strong>for</strong>mers, LT and HT<br />

panels shall be as per the provisions specified by the DVB authorities. The HT and LT<br />

panels shall be separated with the walls of 4 hrs fire rating. Each trans<strong>for</strong>mer will be<br />

separated from the other by fire resistant shield wall extending up to one meters on sides<br />

above the highest point of the trans<strong>for</strong>mer so that fire risk is minimized. HT and LT<br />

panels shall be protected with manually operated CO2 protection system.<br />

Automatic sprinklers shall be installed in the entire building. The portable fire<br />

extinguishers shall be provided at strategic locations. Automatic fire detection system i.e.<br />

smoke / heat detection system shall be provided in the buildings. The system shall be<br />

connected to the fire alarm system. An emergency intercommunication system shall be<br />

provided <strong>for</strong> the entire building. The control room / security room with communication<br />

system to all floors and facility <strong>for</strong> receiving messages from different floors shall be<br />

provided at entrance on ground floor.<br />

It is also <strong>proposed</strong> to appoint a qualified fire officer in the building to maintain / look<br />

after fire fighting system / fire order. To prevent any fire hazard, good house keeping<br />

inside and outside the building shall be strictly maintained.<br />

7.6 Rainwater Harvesting Plan<br />

The project will adopt all appropriate methods on the <strong>proposed</strong> site <strong>for</strong> harvesting of<br />

rainwater. Four nos. of rainwater collecting pits having boreholes going to the permeable<br />

strata level will be provided in the <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

128


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The water table recharging pits of 24 meter overall depth will be constructed. They will<br />

have 3M x 3M x 3.65M deep clear inside chamber having 230 – 460 mm thick brick wall<br />

all around in cement mortar 1:4 (1 cement : 4 coarse sand), 760 mm wide x 200 mm deep<br />

PCC below brick work. The chamber shall be partially filled with stone ballast, coarse<br />

sand gravel and boulders as shown in Figure 7.1. Four nos. per<strong>for</strong>ated 110 mm NB<br />

uPVC pipe 750 mm long one in each wall <strong>for</strong> taking the run off water into the recharging<br />

pit will be provided. The bottom pit portion shall have a dia of 350 mm, with a 200 NB<br />

slotted uPVC pipe of CS thick 23.5 M placed at center of pit having a GI per<strong>for</strong>ated sheet<br />

cover at top <strong>for</strong> regulating the run off water to the bottom of the pit. The top cover shall<br />

be RC slab in 1:1.5:3 150 mm thick with rein<strong>for</strong>cement at top and bottom as per design<br />

with a precast RCC manhole cover MD -10 500 mm dia fixed in position.<br />

The storm water drains carrying the surface run off from the plot area will be directed<br />

towards these recharge pits. There will be a provision of sedimentation tanks where any<br />

silt or floating materials carried away by the flowing water will be settled down be<strong>for</strong>e<br />

the water enters the recharge area. Figure 7.2 gives the layout plan showing rain water<br />

harvesting pits in the <strong>proposed</strong> <strong>integrated</strong> <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

7.7 Landscaping and Green Belt Development Plan<br />

It is <strong>proposed</strong> to develop landscape and green area in approx. 28.49% of total plot area in<br />

academic <strong>complex</strong> and approx. 24.91% of total plot area in residential <strong>complex</strong>. The<br />

implementation <strong>for</strong> development of green belt is of immense importance, as it not only<br />

acts as a pollution sink <strong>for</strong> dust emissions, gaseous pollutants and noise pollution but also<br />

enhances the visual appearance of the developed site.<br />

129


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 7.1: Cross Section of Rainwater Harvesting Recharging Pit<br />

130


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The species to be grown on the site will be fast growing native species having broad leaf<br />

base so that a permanent green belt is created in a short period. The effective plantation<br />

will also stabilize the soil and reduce any nuisance during windstorm. About 600 – 700<br />

numbers of trees will be planted. Some of the species of trees to be planted are:<br />

• Australian Kikar<br />

• Saptaparni<br />

• Neem<br />

• Kachanar<br />

• Kolar<br />

• Amaltas<br />

• Gulmohar<br />

• Basant Rani<br />

Besides this, the visual aesthetics of the <strong>proposed</strong> site will be enhanced by developing<br />

parks/lawn with local ornamental plants in the open spaces. Figure 7.3 shows the<br />

landscape and green belt development plan to be incorporated in the <strong>proposed</strong> project.<br />

7.8 Vehicle Parking and Management Plan<br />

The layout plan of the <strong>proposed</strong> site has developed an internal road network in such a<br />

manner that it will not only cater to various buildings but also integrate the whole<br />

<strong>complex</strong> in an interesting composition of built masses and open spaces with a pedestrian<br />

dominated movement pattern.<br />

Entry points to the <strong>complex</strong> have been worked out keeping in view the desired movement<br />

of vehicles. Main <strong>for</strong>mal entry to the Administration block is planned from the main road<br />

on the Southern side, whereas a second entry is planned from the Western side <strong>for</strong><br />

students.<br />

131


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The entry to the residential <strong>complex</strong> is planned from the side road on Eastern side. This<br />

road leads to the Metro rail station in sector-14 from where inhabitants of the residential<br />

<strong>complex</strong> will be able to communicate and travel to main city.<br />

Adequately wide roads to cater to two way traffic and to meet the fire regulations are<br />

planned in the <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

It is <strong>proposed</strong> to provide total equivalent car space (ECS) of 356 in the academic<br />

<strong>complex</strong>. This includes 126 ECS <strong>for</strong> open parking and 230 ECS <strong>for</strong> basement parking.<br />

The total area covered under open parking is 2913.134 sq. meters and in combined<br />

basement 7385.123 sq. meters.<br />

The total 115 ECS will be provided in the residential housing and 187 ECS in hostels.<br />

Parking facilities in the residential housing includes 79 ECS in open parking, 30 ECS in<br />

stilt parking and 6 ECS in covered garages. In the Hostels, 32 ECS will be provided in<br />

open parking and 155 ECS in basement. The total area covered in open parking in the<br />

residential <strong>complex</strong> is 2570.681 sq. meters, 857.005 sq. meters in stilt parking and<br />

4974.186 sq. meters in basement parking.<br />

132


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

133


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 7.2: Layout Plan showing Rainwater Harvesting Recharging Pits Location<br />

134


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Figure 7.3: Layout Plan showing Landscape and Green Belt Development<br />

7.9 Energy Conservation Plan<br />

Various energy conservation measures to be adopted in the <strong>proposed</strong> project are<br />

described below:<br />

• Solar Architectural Features<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project will provide enough day light factors in the building to permit<br />

maximum day light to interior to minimize overall energy consumption. These features<br />

will also minimize the impact of climate both in summer and in winter and as a result, the<br />

use of electricity will likely to be reduced. The energy consumption per square foot of<br />

built up area has been assumed to be 9.0 Watt <strong>for</strong> academic <strong>complex</strong> and 3.0 Watt <strong>for</strong><br />

residential <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

135


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• Thermal Characteristics of Building Envelope<br />

The <strong>proposed</strong> project will follow the following U-factors related to the building<br />

envelopes:<br />

- Roof U-value (max): 0.12 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

- Max U-value of over wall assembly: 0.36 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

- Window (max): 1.13 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

- Window to wall ratio: 3.13 Btu per hour per sq. ft per degree F<br />

• Characteristics of Glass<br />

The project will provide heat reflected, tinted and toughened glass having properties<br />

which will make it energy saving element in the building and shall provide safety and<br />

transparency of the desired level. The glass of 6 mm and weight of 15 kgs / sqm will be<br />

provided.<br />

• Energy Saving Measures<br />

- Use of solar water heating system has been <strong>proposed</strong> in the project <strong>for</strong> the<br />

residential <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

- Energy efficient appliances will be installed in the building.<br />

- Constant monitoring of energy consumption and defining targets <strong>for</strong> energy<br />

conservation will be employed.<br />

- Compact fluorescent lamps and low voltage lighting system will be used<br />

- Sunscreen films on windows to reduce heating inside the buildings will be used.<br />

- Awareness on energy conservation will be raised among the users of the buildings<br />

in the <strong>complex</strong>.<br />

136


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

8. ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PLAN<br />

Environmental monitoring of critical parameters is essential to assess the changes in<br />

environmental conditions, if any, during construction and operation of the project; to<br />

137


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

monitor the effective implementation of mitigation measures; and to suggest <strong>for</strong> any<br />

additional mitigation measures in case of significant deterioration of environmental<br />

quality.<br />

It is <strong>proposed</strong> to monitor essential parameters <strong>for</strong> ambient air quality, ambient noise<br />

quality, ground water quality, and waste water quality both during the construction and<br />

operation phases of the project.<br />

8.1 Ambient Air Quality<br />

Construction Phase<br />

The ambient air quality monitoring shall be carried out only during the construction<br />

phase of the project. The frequency of monitoring shall be twice every month at atleast<br />

three locations within 500 meter radius of the <strong>proposed</strong> site. The parameters to be<br />

monitored are Respirable Particulate Matter (RPM), Suspended Particulate Matter<br />

(SPM), Sulphur Dioxide (SO 2 ), and Nitrogen Oxide (NO x ).<br />

8.2 Ambient Noise Quality<br />

Construction Phase<br />

Noise emissions from vehicular movement, operation of various construction equipments<br />

shall be monitored during construction phase. The frequency of monitoring shall be once<br />

every month at all important locations within 500 meter radius of the <strong>proposed</strong> site <strong>for</strong><br />

L day , L night and L dn .<br />

Operation Phase<br />

138


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Ambient noise level within the <strong>complex</strong> will be monitored <strong>for</strong> L day , L night and L dn during<br />

the operation phase of the project at appropriate locations. The frequency of monitoring<br />

shall be once in six months.<br />

8.3 Ground Water Quality<br />

Construction Phase<br />

Ground water (if any) used <strong>for</strong> the construction and human consumption shall be<br />

monitored <strong>for</strong> the desired parameters as per BIS standards once in every month.<br />

Operation Phase<br />

It is also <strong>proposed</strong> to analyze ground water samples <strong>for</strong> the essential parameters once in<br />

every six months to ascertain any change in its quality due to regular usage.<br />

8.4 Wastewater Quality<br />

During project operation phase, a sewage treatment plant (STP) has been <strong>proposed</strong> to<br />

treat the sewage from both academic and residential <strong>complex</strong>. It is <strong>proposed</strong> to analyze a<br />

sample each be<strong>for</strong>e and after the STP once every <strong>for</strong>tnight. The parameters to be<br />

analyzed include pH, oil and grease, total suspended solids, total dissolved solids, BOD,<br />

and COD.<br />

139


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

9. COST ESTIMATES<br />

The total budget envisaged <strong>for</strong> implementation of Environmental Management Plan<br />

(EMP) shall be about Rs 2,78,00,000. The break up of the major items is:<br />

• Landscaping and Green Belt - Rs<br />

1,15,00,000<br />

• Rain Water Harvesting - Rs 4,00,000<br />

• Storm Water Drains - Rs 32,00,000<br />

• Sewage Treatment Plant (including recirculation of treated water) - Rs 20,00,000<br />

• Fire Safety and Protection - Rs 75,00,000<br />

• Drainage (Sewage lines) - Rs 27,00,000<br />

• Environmental Monitoring - Rs 5,00,000<br />

The Environmental Management Plan shall be effectively implemented so that optimum<br />

benefit could be achieved. The Environmental Management and Monitoring Plan shall be<br />

synchronized with the construction schedules.<br />

140


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Pollutant<br />

Time Weighted<br />

average<br />

Annexure 1<br />

National Ambient Air Quality Standards<br />

Concentration in ambient air<br />

Method of<br />

measurement<br />

Industrial Area Residential, Rural<br />

& other areas,<br />

Sensitive<br />

Area<br />

1 2 3 4 5 6<br />

Sulphur Dioxide<br />

(SO2 )<br />

Annual Average* 80 µg/m³ 60µg/m ³ 15 µg/m³ 1. Improved West<br />

and Gecke<br />

method<br />

Oxides of<br />

Nitrogen as NO2<br />

Suspended<br />

Particulate<br />

Matter (SPM)<br />

Respirable<br />

Particulate<br />

matter (size less<br />

than10<br />

um)(RPM)<br />

Lead (Pb)<br />

Ammonia<br />

Carbon<br />

Monoxide<br />

24 hours ** 120 µg/m³ 80 µg/m³ 30µg/m³ 2. Ultraviolet<br />

fluorescence<br />

Annual Average* 80 µg/m³ 60µg/m ³ 15 µg/m³ 1. Jacob &<br />

Hochheister<br />

modified ( Na-<br />

Arsenite)<br />

Method<br />

24 hours ** 120 µg/m³ 80 µg/m³ 30µg/m³ 2. Gas Phase<br />

Chemiluminesc<br />

ence<br />

Annual Average* 360 µg/m³ 140 µg/m³ 70 µg/m³<br />

24 hours ** 500 µg/m³ 200 µg/m³ 100 µg/m³<br />

Annual Average* 120 µg/m³ 60µg/m ³ 50µg/m ³<br />

24 hours ** 150µg/m ³ 100µg/m ³ 75µg/m ³<br />

Annual Average* 1.0µg/m ³ 0.75µg/m ³ 0.50µg/m ³<br />

24 hours ** 1.5µg/m ³ 1.00µg/m ³ 0.75µg/m ³<br />

High Volume<br />

Sampling (Average<br />

flow rate not less<br />

than 1.1 m ³/minute)<br />

RPM Sampler<br />

AAS Method after<br />

sampling using EPM<br />

2000<br />

or equivalent filter<br />

paper<br />

-<br />

Annual Average* 0.1mg/m ³ - -<br />

24 hours ** 0.4 mg/m ³ - -<br />

8 hours 5.0µg/m ³ 2.0µg/m ³ 1.0µg/m ³ Non dispersive<br />

141


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Monoxide<br />

(CO)<br />

I hour 10.0µg/m ³ 4.0µg/m ³ 2.0µg/m ³ infrared<br />

spectroscopy<br />

* Annual Arithmetic mean of minimum 104 measurements in a year taken twice a week 24 hourly at uni<strong>for</strong>m<br />

intervals<br />

** 24 hourly/8 hourly values should be met 98% of the time in a year. However, 2% of the time, it may exceed<br />

but not on two consecutive days.<br />

NOTE:<br />

a. National Ambient Air Quality Standard: The levels of air quality necessary with an adequate margin of safety,<br />

to protect the public health, vegetation and property.<br />

b. Whenever and wherever two consecutive values exceed the limit specified above <strong>for</strong> the respective category, it<br />

would be considered adequate reason to institute regular/continuous monitoring and further investigations.<br />

Annexure 2<br />

142


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Annexure 3<br />

Standards <strong>for</strong> Occupational Noise Exposure<br />

143


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

144


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Annexure 4<br />

Wastewater Discharge Standards<br />

S. No. Parameters DPCC Norm<br />

1. pH 6.0 – 8.5<br />

2. Oil and Grease


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

Annexure 5<br />

Standards / Guidelines <strong>for</strong> control of Noise Pollution from<br />

Stationary Diesel Generator (DG) Sets<br />

(A)<br />

Noise Standards <strong>for</strong> DG Sets (15-500 KVA)<br />

The total sound power level, Lw, of a DG set should be less than, 94+10 log 10 (KVA),<br />

dB(A), at<br />

the manufacturing stage, where, KVA is the nominal power rating of a DG set.<br />

This level should fall by 5 dB(A) every five years, till 2007, i.e. in 2002 and then in 2007.<br />

(B)<br />

Mandatory acoustic enclosure/acoustic treatment of room <strong>for</strong> stationary DG sets<br />

(5 KVA and above)<br />

Noise from the DG set should be controlled by providing an acoustic enclosure or by<br />

treating the<br />

room acoustically.<br />

The acoustic enclosure/acoustic treatment of the room should be designed <strong>for</strong> minimum<br />

25 dB(A) Insertion Loss or <strong>for</strong> meeting the ambient noise standards, which ever is on the<br />

higher side (if the actual ambient noise is on the higher side, it may not be possible to<br />

check the per<strong>for</strong>mance of the acoustic enclosure/acoustic treatment. Under such<br />

circumstances the per<strong>for</strong>mance may be checked <strong>for</strong> noise reduction upto actual ambient<br />

noise level, preferably, in the night time). The measurement <strong>for</strong> Insertion Loss may be<br />

done at different points at 0.5m from the acoustic enclosure/room, and then averaged.<br />

146


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

The DG set should also be provide with proper exhaust muffler with Insertion Loss of<br />

minimum 25 dB(A).<br />

(C)<br />

Guidelines <strong>for</strong> the manufacturers/users of DG sets (5 KVA and above)<br />

• The manufacturer should offer to the user a standard acoustic enclosure of 25 dB(A)<br />

Insertion Loss and also a suitable exhaust muffler with Insertion Loss of 25 dB(A).<br />

• The user should make ef<strong>for</strong>ts to bring down the noise levels due to the DG set,<br />

outside his premises, within the ambient noise requirements by proper siting and<br />

control measures.<br />

• The manufacturer should furnish noise power levels of the unlicenced DG sets as per<br />

standards prescribed under (A)<br />

• The total sound power level of a DG set, at the user's end, shall be within 2 dB(A) of<br />

the total sound power level of the DG set, at the manufacturing stage, as prescribed<br />

under (A).<br />

• Installation of a DG set must be strictly in compliance with the recommendation of<br />

the DG set manufacturer.<br />

• A proper routine and preventive maintenance procedure <strong>for</strong> the DG set should be set<br />

and followed in consultation with the DG set manufacturer which would help prevent<br />

noise levels of the DG set from deteriorating with use.<br />

Order of the Lt. Governor of Delhi in respect of D.G. Sets<br />

(5th December, 2001)<br />

In exercise of the powers conferred by section 5 of the Environment (Protection) Act,<br />

1986, (29 of 1986), read with the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs<br />

notification S.O. 667 (E) bearing No. F.No. U-11030/J/91-VTL dated 10th September,<br />

1992, the Lt. Governor of Government of National Capital of Delhi hereby directs to all<br />

owners/users of generators sets in the National Capital Territory of Delhi as follows :-<br />

147


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

• That generator sets above the capacity of 5 KVA shall not be operated in residential<br />

areas between the hours of 10.00 PM to 6.00 AM;<br />

• That the generator sets above the capacity of 5 KVA in all areas<br />

residential/commercial/industrial shall operate only with the mandatory acoustic<br />

enclosures and other standards prescribed in the Environment (Protection) Rules,<br />

1986;<br />

• That mobile generator sets used in social gatherings and public functions shall be<br />

permitted only if they have installed mandatory acoustic enclosures and adhere to the<br />

prescribed standards <strong>for</strong> noise and emission as laid down in the Environment<br />

(Protection) Rules, 1986.<br />

The contravention of the above directions shall make the offender liable <strong>for</strong> prosecution<br />

under section 15 of the said Act which stipulates punishment of imprisonment <strong>for</strong> a term<br />

which may extend to five years with fine which may extend to one lakh rupees, or with<br />

both, and in case the failure of contravention continues, with additional fine which may<br />

extend to five thousand rupees <strong>for</strong> every day during which such failure or contravention<br />

continues after the conviction <strong>for</strong> the first such failure or contravention and if still the<br />

failure or contravention continues beyond a period of one year after the date of<br />

contravention, the offender continues beyond a period of one year after the date of<br />

contravention, the offender shall be punishable with imprisonment <strong>for</strong> a term which may<br />

extend to seven years.<br />

Order Dated : 21st June, 2002<br />

In exercise of the powers conferred by section 5 of the Environment (Protection) Act,<br />

1986 (29 of 1986) read with the Govt. of India, Ministry of Home Affairs notifivation<br />

S.O. 667(E) bearing No. U-11030/J/91-VTL dated the 10th September, 1992, the Lt.<br />

Governor Govt. of the National Capital Territory of Delhi hereby makes the following<br />

amendment/modification in his order dated the 5th December, 2001 regarding the<br />

operation of generator sets, namely:-<br />

Amendments/modifications<br />

148


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

In the above said order, <strong>for</strong> clause (1), the following shall be substituted, namely:-<br />

"(1) that the generator stets above 5KVA shall not be operated in residential areas<br />

between the hours from 10.00 p.m. to 6.00 a.m. except generator sets of Group Housing<br />

Societies and Multi-storey residential apartments".<br />

Annexure 6<br />

Drinking Water Standards and Probable Effects on Human Health<br />

(BIS: 10500, 1991)<br />

S. Parameters<br />

Prescribed limits Probable effects<br />

No.<br />

Desirable Permissible<br />

1 COLOUR (HAZEN UNIT) 5 25 Aesthetically undesirable.<br />

2 ODOUR Essentially free Aesthetically undesirable.<br />

3 TASTE Agreeable Aesthetically undesirable.<br />

4 TURBIDITY (NTU) 5 10 Indicates pollution/ contamination.<br />

5 pH 6.5 8.5 Affects taste, corrosivity & supply system.<br />

6 HARDNESS, as CaCO 3, mg/l 300 600 Causes scaling, excessive soap consumption,<br />

calcification of arteries.<br />

149


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

7 IRON, as Fe , mg/l 0.30 1.00 Causes staining of laundry and porcelain. In<br />

traces it is essential <strong>for</strong> nutrition.<br />

8 CHLORIDE, as Cl , mg/l 250 1000 May be injurious to heart or kidney patients.<br />

Taste, indigestion, corrosion & palatability are<br />

affected.<br />

9 RESIDUAL CHLORINE, only<br />

when Water is chlorinated<br />

0.20 - Excessive chlorination causes asthma, colitis &<br />

eczema<br />

10 TOTAL DISSOLVED 500 2000 May cause gastro-intestinal irritation, corrosion<br />

SOLIDS, mg/l<br />

and laxative effect to new users.<br />

11 CALCIUM, as Ca, mg/l 75 200 Excessive Cause incrustation, deficiency causes<br />

rickets, essential <strong>for</strong> nervous, muscular, cardiac<br />

functions and in coagulation of blood.<br />

12 MAGNESIUM, as Mg, mg/l 30 100 Its salts are cathartics and diuretic. Excessive<br />

may cause laxative effect; deficiency causes<br />

structural and functional changes. It is activator of<br />

many enzyme systems.<br />

13 COPPER, as Cu, mg/l 0.05 1.50 Beneficial in human metabolism, deficiency<br />

results in nutritional anaemia in infants. Large<br />

amounts may result in liver damage, causes<br />

central nervous system irritation & depression.<br />

Enhances corrosion of Al in water supply<br />

systems.<br />

14 SULPHATE, as SO 4, mg/l 200 400 Causes gastro-intestinal irritation. Along with Mg<br />

or Na can have a cathartic effect. Concentration<br />

more than 750 mg/l may have laxative effect.<br />

15 NITRATE, as N, mg/l 45 100 Causes infant methaemoglobinaemia, at very high<br />

concentration causes gastric cancer and effects<br />

central nervous & cardiovascular system.<br />

16 FLUORIDE, as F, mg/l 1.00 1.50 Reduces dental carries, very high concentration<br />

may cause crippling skeletal fluorosis.<br />

17 CADMIUM, as Cd, mg/l 0.01 No relaxation Acute toxicity may be associated with renal,<br />

arterial hypertension, itai-itai (bone disease). Cd<br />

salts cause cramps, nausea, vomiting & diarrhea.<br />

18 LEAD, as Pb, mg/l 0.05 No relaxation Burning in mouth, severe inflammation of gastrointestinal<br />

tract with vomiting and diarrhea.<br />

Chronic toxicity produces nausea, severe<br />

abdominal pain, paralysis, mental confusion,<br />

visual disturbances, and anaemia etc.<br />

19 ZINC, as Zn , mg/l 5 15 Essential & beneficial in human metabolism.<br />

Imparts astringent taste to water.<br />

20 CHROMIUM, as Cr, mg/l 0.05 No relaxation Cr 6+ produces lung tumors, cutaneous and nasal<br />

150


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

mucous membrane ulcers and dermatitis.<br />

21 ARSENIC, as As, mg/l 0.05 No relaxation Causes skin damage, circulatory problems,<br />

increased risk of skin cancer.<br />

22 ANTIMONY, as Sb, mg/l 0.006 No relaxation Raises blood cholesterol, lowers blood sugar.<br />

23 ALUMINIUM, as Al, mg/l 0.030 0.200 Leads to neurological disorders.<br />

24 BARIUM, as Ba, mg/l 2 No relaxation Increases blood pressure.<br />

25 BERYLLIUM, as Be, mg/l nil 0.0002 Is carcinogenic<br />

26 CYANIDE, as CN, mg/l 0.05 No relaxation Causes nerve damage, thyroid problem.<br />

27 MERCURY, as Hg, mg/l 0.001 No relaxation Neurological and renal disturbances. Excess<br />

causes gonadotoxic and mutagenic effects and<br />

disturbs the cholesterol metabolism.<br />

28 MANGANESE, as Mn, mg/l 0.10 0.30 Essential as a cofactor in enzyme systems and<br />

metabolism processes. Excessive causes change<br />

in appetite and reduction in metabolism of iron to<br />

<strong>for</strong>m haemoglobin. Imparts undesirable taste and<br />

stains plumbing fixtures and laundry.<br />

29 SELENIUM, as Se, mg/l 0.01 No relaxation Leads to hair, finger loss, and numbness in fingers<br />

or toes, circulatory problems.<br />

30 BORON, as B, mg/l 1.00 5.00 Affects central nervous system, salts may cause<br />

nausea, cramps, convulsions, coma, etc.<br />

31 ALKALINITY, as CaCO 3, 200 600 Imparts unpleasant taste, deleterious to humans in<br />

mg/l<br />

presence of high pH, hardness and TDS.<br />

32 PESTICIDES, ug/l nil 0.001 Imparts toxicity, accumulates in different organs<br />

of body, affects immune and nervous systems.<br />

Carcinogenic.<br />

33 PHOSPHATE, as PO 4, mg/l No guideline High concentration causes vomiting & diarrhoea<br />

stimulates secondary hyperthyroidism and bone<br />

loss.<br />

34 SODIUM, as Na, mg/l No guideline Harmful to persons suffering from cardiac, renal<br />

& circulatory diseases.<br />

35 POTASSIUM, as K, mg/l No guideline Essential nutrition element but excessive amounts<br />

is cathartic.<br />

36 NICKEL, as Ni , mg/l No guideline Non-toxic element but may be carcinogenic in<br />

animals, can react with DNA resulting in DNA<br />

damage in animals.<br />

37 PATHOGENS<br />

1 10 Causes water borne diseases like coli<strong>for</strong>m<br />

a)TOTAL COLIFORM<br />

jaundice; Typhoid, Cholera etc. produces<br />

No/dl<br />

b)FAECAL COLIFORM<br />

infections involving skin mucous membrane of<br />

eyes, ears and throat.<br />

No/dl<br />

151


Rapid Environmental Impact Assessment (REIA) Study <strong>for</strong> Proposed Integrated Complex <strong>for</strong> Delhi Judicial Academy,<br />

National Law School, and National Institute <strong>for</strong> Mediation & Conciliation at Dwarka, New Delhi<br />

38 RADIOACTIVITY:<br />

-BETA PARTICLES<br />

-ALPHA PARTICLES<br />

-RADIUM<br />

0-4 millirem/year<br />

0-15 picocuries/year<br />

0-05 picocuries/year<br />

Increases risk of cancer.<br />

152

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!