21.04.2015 Views

ASIC response to MoFLNRO re: Lot 224 - savary island committee

ASIC response to MoFLNRO re: Lot 224 - savary island committee

ASIC response to MoFLNRO re: Lot 224 - savary island committee

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

1847 Savary Island Road, Savary Island, BC V0N 2G0. Mail <strong>to</strong> PO Box 222, Lund, BC V0N 2G0.<br />

Visit www.<strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>.ca, contact <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

February 1, 2012<br />

And<strong>re</strong>a Cowgill<br />

Land Technical Officer<br />

Ministry of Fo<strong>re</strong>sts Lands and Natural Resource Operations<br />

Dear And<strong>re</strong>a,<br />

Thank you for sending the <strong><strong>re</strong>sponse</strong>s <strong>to</strong> our Crown Land Application from The Natu<strong>re</strong> Trust (TNT)<br />

and BC Parks. I will attempt <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>spond <strong>to</strong> the concerns raised by both groups. I apologize if the<br />

comments a<strong>re</strong> somewhat <strong>re</strong>petitive but I thought I should add<strong>re</strong>ss each concern di<strong>re</strong>ctly.<br />

1. His<strong>to</strong>ry of Savary Island Refundables Depot<br />

For many years, the Savary Island Volunteer Fi<strong>re</strong> Department (SIVFD) operated a <strong>re</strong>fundables<br />

depot on Savary Island. Unfortunately, the depot was located on Ministry of Transportation (MoT)<br />

road allowance. Over time, as some of the properties adjacent <strong>to</strong> the depot we<strong>re</strong> developed,<br />

concerns we<strong>re</strong> raised. The adjacent properties we<strong>re</strong> within 50 feet of the depot. In June 2009, MoT<br />

asked the SIVFD <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>move the depot while allowing them time <strong>to</strong> find a mo<strong>re</strong> suitable location.<br />

In August of 2010, the Association of the Savary Island Committee (<strong>ASIC</strong>), which <strong>re</strong>p<strong>re</strong>sents over<br />

700 property owners, held an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM). A motion was passed by<br />

those attending, over 100 property owners, <strong>to</strong> support closu<strong>re</strong> of the cur<strong>re</strong>nt location of the bottle<br />

depot and <strong>to</strong> pursue development of a new location.<br />

It was clear at the meeting that property owners believed the bottle depot service was valuable <strong>to</strong><br />

the <strong>island</strong>. <strong>ASIC</strong> Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>rs ag<strong>re</strong>ed <strong>to</strong> take on the task of finding a new location that would not be in<br />

t<strong>re</strong>spass and would be less disruptive <strong>to</strong> neighbours than was the cur<strong>re</strong>nt location.<br />

2. Letter from The Natu<strong>re</strong> Trust of British Columbia (TNT).<br />

In the memorandum from TNT, they note in section “His<strong>to</strong>ry of <strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong>” that lot <strong>224</strong> did not <strong>re</strong>ceive<br />

higher protection i.e. park status and as such, appears <strong>to</strong> be an idle parcel of Crown land. This<br />

statement is true, but befo<strong>re</strong> <strong>ASIC</strong> made the crown land application, we <strong>re</strong>cognized the complicated<br />

<strong>re</strong>lationship between TNT and BC Parks associated with lot <strong>224</strong>.<br />

On behalf of <strong>ASIC</strong>, I met with <strong>re</strong>p<strong>re</strong>sentatives of TNT and BC Parks <strong>to</strong> explain <strong>ASIC</strong>’s concept for a<br />

community service site in the ext<strong>re</strong>me eastern point of lot <strong>224</strong> and <strong>to</strong> determine if the<strong>re</strong> we<strong>re</strong> any<br />

potential issues impeding a successful application. At the time, no serious issues we<strong>re</strong> raised with<br />

the proposal so we proceeded with our application.<br />

TNT Concerns.<br />

2a. Lack of consultation with public or Savary Island Land Trust (SILT).


The issue of a <strong>re</strong>fundables depot was discussed at the <strong>ASIC</strong> EGM in summer of 2010. A motion<br />

was put forward by the members supporting the closu<strong>re</strong> of the existing depot, with the expectation<br />

that efforts <strong>to</strong> find a new location should continue so the service could be maintained. The<strong>re</strong>after,<br />

efforts <strong>to</strong> find a new location occur<strong>re</strong>d during the <strong>re</strong>mainder of 2010 and early 2011.<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> <strong>re</strong>cognized the complicated <strong>re</strong>lationship between TNT and BC Parks associated with lot <strong>224</strong>.<br />

As P<strong>re</strong>sident of <strong>ASIC</strong>, I met with <strong>re</strong>p<strong>re</strong>sentatives of TNT and BC Parks <strong>to</strong> explain <strong>ASIC</strong>’s concept<br />

for a community service site in the ext<strong>re</strong>me eastern point of lot <strong>224</strong> and <strong>to</strong> determine if the<strong>re</strong> we<strong>re</strong><br />

any potential issues impeding a successful application. At the time, no serious issues we<strong>re</strong> raised<br />

by TNT or BC Parks, so we proceeded with our application.<br />

In March 2011, on behalf of <strong>ASIC</strong>, I sent an email <strong>to</strong> SILT <strong>to</strong> inform them of our intent <strong>to</strong> submit an<br />

application for use of a small portion of lot <strong>224</strong> for a Community Service Site and bottle depot<br />

location. In April 2011, the Executive Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>r of SILT informed me that the SILT board passed a<br />

motion supporting in principle the bottle depot on lot <strong>224</strong> subject <strong>to</strong> mo<strong>re</strong> detail, including a map,<br />

application details and information about the application process. A number of SILT members a<strong>re</strong><br />

also members of <strong>ASIC</strong> and attended the AGM in July 2011 and we<strong>re</strong> updated on the status of the<br />

application process.<br />

The May 2011 decision <strong>to</strong> apply for a portion of lot <strong>224</strong> was p<strong>re</strong>sented and discussed at the <strong>ASIC</strong><br />

AGM in July of 2011, which was attended by over 200 property owners.<br />

One of <strong>ASIC</strong>’s Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>rs <strong>re</strong>p<strong>re</strong>senting the eastern portion of the <strong>island</strong> contacted the 3 property<br />

owners nea<strong>re</strong>st <strong>to</strong> the proposed site <strong>to</strong> discuss the possible new location. Their <strong><strong>re</strong>sponse</strong> was that<br />

they did not like the proposal and asked us <strong>to</strong> find another location. <strong>ASIC</strong> explained that we had<br />

examined all the Crown land on Savary with the help of the Powell River Regional District<br />

Administra<strong>to</strong>r Frances Lad<strong>re</strong>t as well as Regional Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>r Patrick Brabazon and believed this <strong>to</strong> be<br />

the most isolated location we could find. One property owner questioned the need for a depot. <strong>ASIC</strong><br />

explained that the general message from our over 700 members was that the bottle depot was an<br />

important community service.<br />

One of the nearby properties is a church. The church managers asked that sorting not occur on<br />

Sunday mornings.<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> also sends monthly updates <strong>to</strong> our members, cur<strong>re</strong>ntly over 700, and these updates have<br />

always provided information on the status of the application for use of Crown land. Our updates a<strong>re</strong><br />

also published in the Savary Island News which is an on-<strong>island</strong> newspaper sent <strong>to</strong> approximately<br />

300 subscribers 10 months of the year. <strong>ASIC</strong> provided a bottle depot update in 8 <strong>re</strong>cent issues of<br />

the Savary Island News (April, May, Jun, Sept, Oct, Nov, and Dec 2011; and Jan 2012). SILT also<br />

writes for this newspaper <strong>re</strong>gularly so is awa<strong>re</strong> of <strong>ASIC</strong>’s articles.<br />

In addition, <strong>ASIC</strong> posts the monthly meeting minutes at the government wharf on Savary as well as<br />

on our website, which has updates of the application status. <strong>ASIC</strong> has posted a site plan at the<br />

proposed site, as well as a notice in the Powell River Peak newspaper, attached.<br />

The Regional Board of the Powell River Regional District is supportive of the community bottle<br />

depot application as per the attached minutes. The Sliammon First Nation is supportive of<br />

temporary use of the proposed site as per their letter <strong>to</strong> you in December 2011.<br />

2b. Application indicates adjacent landowners do not object.


Nowhe<strong>re</strong> in the application is the<strong>re</strong> <strong>re</strong>fe<strong>re</strong>nce <strong>to</strong> views of adjacent landowners. We commented that<br />

the site is isolated from cottages and sc<strong>re</strong>ened by vegetation. The closest cottage is approximately<br />

300 feet away. Pho<strong>to</strong>s of the a<strong>re</strong>a we<strong>re</strong> provided in the application.<br />

2c. Inc<strong>re</strong>ased traffic will impact the existing roadway.<br />

The transportation of bins (which hold bottles) <strong>to</strong> the depot will occur along Vancouver Boulevard<br />

which is the main road on the <strong>island</strong> and is used by all vehicles on Savary Island This road is<br />

maintained by Ministry of Transportation and is graded twice a year and dust control is applied in<br />

summer. Entrance <strong>to</strong> the site is by way of Savary Island Lane which will need some minor<br />

upgrading and will <strong>re</strong>ceive traffic actively by about 5 vehicles for 2 hours 3 days a week in July and<br />

August. Use drops off in the shoulder seasons and virtually nothing in the fall, winter and spring.<br />

This calculation of traffic is based on my personal experience having been a bottle sorter for 5<br />

years.<br />

The level of traffic will not change on Vancouver Blvd between the wharf pickup site and the<br />

proposed new location, but traffic west of the new site and the closest adjacent properties will<br />

diminish as traffic will not be <strong>re</strong>qui<strong>re</strong>d <strong>to</strong> move bottles and cans down <strong>island</strong> <strong>to</strong> the old site.<br />

2d. Excess Garbage attracting wasps and rodents.<br />

Unfortunately, some property owners and <strong>re</strong>nters do dump non-<strong>re</strong>fundable items and some<br />

garbage in the bins. Volunteers sort this material and dispose of the garbage at the Regional<br />

District waste management site in Powell River. The cost of this activity is paid for by the<br />

<strong>re</strong>fundables.<br />

Wasps can be of some issue in the August and September months. Volunteers deploy wasp traps<br />

at that time. Rodents a<strong>re</strong> not an issue on Savary Island. The<strong>re</strong> a<strong>re</strong> mice but <strong>to</strong> the best of our<br />

knowledge no rats have been observed on the <strong>island</strong>.<br />

2e. Noise.<br />

We <strong>re</strong>cognize that the sorting operations do <strong>re</strong>sult in some noise. We intend <strong>to</strong> mitigate this issue<br />

as best we can by maintaining the vegetation sc<strong>re</strong>en between the nearby properties and the depot.<br />

In addition, the depot will be constructed so that the active side (the entrance) faces away from the<br />

nearby properties and will be some 300 feet from these properties. <strong>ASIC</strong> will also continue <strong>to</strong><br />

consider other options <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>duce noise as <strong>re</strong>qui<strong>re</strong>d.<br />

As mentioned p<strong>re</strong>viously, the site will be used 3 days per week for about 2 hours per day in July<br />

and August and one day a week in the <strong>re</strong>mainder of the year.<br />

2f. Length of Tenu<strong>re</strong>.<br />

The issue of the tenu<strong>re</strong> for the site is difficult. The<strong>re</strong> is very limited Crown land available on Savary,<br />

which has been heavily subdivided in<strong>to</strong> approximately 1100 lots. The large parcels of land on the<br />

<strong>island</strong> a<strong>re</strong> privately owned and no property owners have voluntee<strong>re</strong>d a portion of these lands for a<br />

community service site.<br />

The cost of <strong>re</strong>locations and constructing a depot <strong>re</strong>qui<strong>re</strong>s <strong>ASIC</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>quest at least 5 years of use of<br />

the site with some form of <strong>re</strong>newal option in the event other locations do not become available.


2g. Degrading the Conservation Values.<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> <strong>to</strong>tally disag<strong>re</strong>es with this TNT comment. The tiny portion of lot <strong>224</strong> which we have applied for<br />

tenu<strong>re</strong> is the least valuable portion of the lot. Our proposal does not <strong>re</strong>qui<strong>re</strong> the <strong>re</strong>moval of any<br />

standing t<strong>re</strong>es and we a<strong>re</strong> planning on maintaining as much of the vegetation on the site as a<br />

sc<strong>re</strong>en for the nearby properties. The only plants affected will be sword ferns, which dominate the<br />

site.<br />

I would also ask that you look at Dr. Roemer’s <strong>re</strong>connaissance inven<strong>to</strong>ry <strong>re</strong>port (provided by BC<br />

Parks) whe<strong>re</strong> he points out that much of the eastern end of the property is “st<strong>re</strong>wn with wood waste<br />

from saw-milling activities, machinery parts and car bodies.”<br />

Further, we point <strong>to</strong> the attached Official Community Plan map, which clearly shows the lot as being<br />

outside Savary’s ecologically sensitive a<strong>re</strong>as.<br />

2h. Bottle Depot Cur<strong>re</strong>ntly Not Operating.<br />

It is true that the <strong>re</strong>fundable depot did not operate in 2011. One business at the eastern end of the<br />

<strong>island</strong> did inc<strong>re</strong>ase his capacity <strong>to</strong> collect and transport <strong>re</strong>fundables off the <strong>island</strong>. At the western<br />

end of the <strong>island</strong>, one permanent <strong>re</strong>sident started collecting <strong>re</strong>fundables. In this case, we have<br />

<strong>re</strong>ceived complaints from his adjacent neighbour about this operation, as it is less than 30 feet away<br />

from their cottage. Property owners did step up their efforts <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>move <strong>re</strong>fundables as well but we<br />

have seen some inc<strong>re</strong>ase in litter on the <strong>island</strong>.<br />

Not providing this service on <strong>island</strong> is an option but it eliminates a significant funding source for<br />

other important <strong>island</strong> issues.<br />

3. Letter from BC Parks.<br />

Concerns from BC Parks.<br />

3a. Proposal Not Consistent with protection of Ecological Values.<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> <strong>re</strong>cognizes that lot <strong>224</strong> was acqui<strong>re</strong>d as part of a potential plan for protecting the fo<strong>re</strong>sted<br />

ancient sand dunes in the a<strong>re</strong>a. However, I would point out that the eastern portion of lot <strong>224</strong> does<br />

not have any sand dunes. In addition as pointed out p<strong>re</strong>viously in the <strong>re</strong>port provided by BC Parks,<br />

the a<strong>re</strong>a is “st<strong>re</strong>wn with wood waste from saw-milling activities, machinery parts and car bodies.”<br />

Additionally, the attached Official Community Plan map clearly shows the lot as being outside<br />

Savary’s ecologically sensitive a<strong>re</strong>as.<br />

3b. Request for details of the location and footprint of any structu<strong>re</strong>.<br />

Attached is a site plan of <strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong> p<strong>re</strong>pa<strong>re</strong>d by Emery and Rae Land Survey.<br />

3c. No Rationale for why a new location is <strong>re</strong>qui<strong>re</strong>d.<br />

For many years, the Savary Island Volunteer Fi<strong>re</strong> Department (SIVFD) operated a <strong>re</strong>fundables<br />

depot on Savary Island. Unfortunately, the depot was on Ministry of Transportation road allowance.<br />

In June 2009, Ministry of Transportation asked the SIVFD <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>move the depot.


In August of 2010, at the <strong>ASIC</strong> EGM, a motion was passed by those attending <strong>to</strong> support closu<strong>re</strong> of<br />

the bottle depot and <strong>to</strong> pursue development of a new location closer <strong>to</strong> the main departu<strong>re</strong> a<strong>re</strong>a of<br />

the <strong>island</strong>. It was clear at the meeting that property owners believed this was a valuable service <strong>to</strong><br />

the <strong>island</strong> as well as a good <strong>re</strong>venue source for community initiatives. <strong>ASIC</strong> Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>rs ag<strong>re</strong>ed <strong>to</strong><br />

take on the task of finding a new location that would not be in t<strong>re</strong>spass and less disruptive <strong>to</strong><br />

neighbours than the cur<strong>re</strong>nt location.<br />

3d. Assessment of Alternative Locations.<br />

During 2010 and early 2011, <strong>ASIC</strong> and the Regional District <strong>re</strong>viewed a map of Savary Island and<br />

the location of existing Crown land and RD-owned lots on the <strong>island</strong>. The<strong>re</strong> is very little Crown land<br />

available on Savary Island and only one that we have found that would provide any distance from<br />

nearby cottages. We believe we have explo<strong>re</strong>d all other locations, and in our view, this is the best<br />

location available at this time.<br />

3e. Tenu<strong>re</strong> no mo<strong>re</strong> than 5 years.<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> believes a 5-year tenu<strong>re</strong> would be acceptable but we would like the flexibility for extension<br />

should no other better location become available.<br />

3f. Consultation.<br />

The issue of finding a new location for the depot was discussed at the <strong>ASIC</strong> EGM in summer of<br />

2010. Efforts <strong>to</strong> find a new location occur<strong>re</strong>d during the <strong>re</strong>mainder of 2010 and early 2011.<br />

Application for the site was made in May 2011. The decision <strong>to</strong> apply for a portion of lot <strong>224</strong> was<br />

p<strong>re</strong>sented and discussed at the <strong>ASIC</strong> AGM in July of 2011, which was attended by over 200<br />

property owners. Members of the Savary Island Land Trust (SILT) we<strong>re</strong> also in attendance.<br />

One of <strong>ASIC</strong>’s Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>rs <strong>re</strong>p<strong>re</strong>senting the eastern portion of Savary Island, contacted the 3 nearby<br />

property owners <strong>to</strong> discuss <strong>ASIC</strong>’s proposed new bottle depot location. The <strong><strong>re</strong>sponse</strong> was they did<br />

not like the proposal and asked <strong>ASIC</strong> <strong>to</strong> find another location. <strong>ASIC</strong> explained that we had<br />

examined all the Crown land on Savary and believed this <strong>to</strong> be the most isolated location we could<br />

find. One property owner questioned the need for a depot. <strong>ASIC</strong> explained that the general<br />

message from our over 700 members was that the bottle depot was an important community<br />

service.<br />

One of the properties is a church. The church managers asked that sorting not occur on Sunday<br />

mornings.<br />

In March 2011, on behalf of <strong>ASIC</strong>, I sent an email <strong>to</strong> SILT <strong>to</strong> inform them of our intent <strong>to</strong> submit an<br />

application for use of a small portion of lot <strong>224</strong> for a Community Service Site and bottle depot<br />

location. In April 2011, the Executive Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>r of SILT informed me that the SILT board passed a<br />

motion supporting, in principle, the bottle depot on lot <strong>224</strong> subject <strong>to</strong> mo<strong>re</strong> detail, including a map,<br />

application details and information about the application process. A number of SILT members a<strong>re</strong><br />

also members of <strong>ASIC</strong> who attended the AGM in July 2011 and we<strong>re</strong> updated on the status of the<br />

application process. Again no objections we<strong>re</strong> made by the membership at that time.<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> also sends monthly updates <strong>to</strong> our members, cur<strong>re</strong>ntly over 700, and these updates have<br />

always provided information on the status of the application for use of Crown land. Our updates a<strong>re</strong>


also published in the Savary Island News which is an on <strong>island</strong> newspaper sent <strong>to</strong> subscribers 10<br />

months of the year.<br />

In addition, <strong>ASIC</strong> posts the monthly meeting minutes at the government wharf on Savary as well as<br />

on our website, which has updates of the application status. <strong>ASIC</strong> has posted a site plan at the<br />

proposed site, as well as a notice in the Powell River Peak newspaper, attached.<br />

The Regional Board of the Powell River Regional District is supportive of the community bottle<br />

depot application as per the attached minutes. The Sliammon First Nation is supportive of<br />

temporary use of the proposed site as per their letter <strong>to</strong> you in December 2011.<br />

4. Letters of support.<br />

The letters submitted <strong>to</strong> the <strong>ASIC</strong> board have been compiled and added as an attachment.<br />

5. Reconsideration by <strong>MoFLNRO</strong>.<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> has been seeking a new location for Savary Island’s bottle depot since August 2010. We have<br />

<strong>re</strong>sponsibly add<strong>re</strong>ssed every concern put forward by the community, and feel that the absence of<br />

the depot would be harmful <strong>to</strong> both the funding needed for the community, and the maintenance of<br />

a pristine environment, which is in the inte<strong>re</strong>st of all who ca<strong>re</strong> for Savary Island.<br />

We <strong>re</strong>quest that you ca<strong>re</strong>fully <strong>re</strong>consider the due diligence that <strong>ASIC</strong> has undertaken.<br />

Since<strong>re</strong>ly,<br />

Bud Graham<br />

P<strong>re</strong>sident, Association of the Savary Island Committee<br />

250-658-4782<br />

budgraham@shaw.ca<br />

cc. Patrick Brabazon, Regional Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>r, PRRD<br />

Mac Fraser, Chief Administrative Officer, PRRD<br />

Nicholas Simons, Sunshine Coast MLA<br />

Clint Monson, A<strong>re</strong>a Manager, MoT<br />

/attachments


124-50 W<br />

124-49 W<br />

124-48 W<br />

124-47 W<br />

124-46 W<br />

124-45 W<br />

49-57-40 N<br />

49-57-20 N<br />

49-57-0 N<br />

49-57-20 N<br />

49-57-40 N<br />

49-57-0 N<br />

49-56-40 N<br />

49-56-20 N<br />

49-56-0 N<br />

49-55-40 N<br />

49-56-0 N<br />

49-56-20 N<br />

49-56-40 N<br />

49-55-40 N<br />

124-50 W<br />

124-49 W<br />

124-48 W<br />

124-47 W<br />

124-46 W<br />

124-45 W<br />

49-55-20 N


³<br />

Indian Point<br />

SAVARY ISLAND OFFICIAL COMMUNITY PLAN<br />

SCHEDULE D<br />

DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT & DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AREAS<br />

Mace Point<br />

STRAIT OF GEORGIA<br />

Second Point<br />

First Point<br />

Wharf<br />

Malaspina Promenade<br />

Vancouver Boulevard<br />

Tennyson Road<br />

Savary Island Road<br />

Vancouver Boulevard<br />

Vancouver Boulevard<br />

Vancouver Boulevard<br />

Whalebone Point<br />

Beacon Point<br />

STRAIT OF GEORGIA<br />

Legend<br />

Development Assessment A<strong>re</strong>as (DA)<br />

DA-1 Sho<strong>re</strong>line A<strong>re</strong>as<br />

DA-2 Sho<strong>re</strong>line and Inland Dune A<strong>re</strong>as<br />

DA-3 Ecologically Sensitive A<strong>re</strong>as<br />

Development Permit A<strong>re</strong>as (DP)<br />

DP-1 Sho<strong>re</strong>line A<strong>re</strong>as<br />

DP-2 Sho<strong>re</strong>line and Inland Dune A<strong>re</strong>as<br />

SCALE<br />

500 250 0 500 1,000<br />

Meters<br />

DP-3 Ecologically Sensitive A<strong>re</strong>as<br />

Roads


January 29, 2012<br />

And<strong>re</strong>a Cowgill, Land Officer<br />

Ministry of Fo<strong>re</strong>sts, Lands and Natural Resource Operations<br />

10428 153rd St<strong>re</strong>et, Suite 200<br />

Sur<strong>re</strong>y, BC V3R 1E1<br />

Dear And<strong>re</strong>a,<br />

The SIVFD Association supports the application <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>locate the Savary Island Bottle Recycling Depot<br />

<strong>to</strong> DL 1373, <strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong>.<br />

The tax funds the Savary Island Volunteer Fi<strong>re</strong> Department <strong>re</strong>ceives a<strong>re</strong> only enough <strong>to</strong> keep the fi<strong>re</strong><br />

department operating. Since the closing of the bottle <strong>re</strong>cycling depot at its p<strong>re</strong>vious location in May 2011,<br />

the<strong>re</strong> is cur<strong>re</strong>ntly no other means <strong>to</strong> raise additional funds for new equipment or trucks except for the<br />

generosity of <strong>island</strong>ers who donate money. So the continued existence of a bottle depot and the funds it<br />

generates is beneficial <strong>to</strong> the enti<strong>re</strong> community.<br />

In 2007, Fi<strong>re</strong>fighters, First Responders, and concerned civilians formed the Savary Island Volunteer Fi<strong>re</strong><br />

Department Association in part <strong>to</strong> gain access <strong>to</strong> a Di<strong>re</strong>ct Access Program Grant (DAPG). This helped<br />

bring about necessary public safety purchases that had not been possible within the limits of the fi<strong>re</strong><br />

department’s yearly budget. The DAPG provided assistance in purchasing a 4x4 First Responder Vehicle<br />

capable of traversing our worst roads (see pho<strong>to</strong> on next page). It <strong>re</strong>placed the aging traditional st<strong>re</strong>et<br />

ambulance our fi<strong>re</strong> department was using.<br />

Our obligation was 25% of the <strong>to</strong>tal cost of the 4x4 FR Vehicle, a significant portion of which was provided<br />

by the hard work of the SIVFDA members who sorted <strong>re</strong>fundables at the bottle depot. The 4x4 FR Vehicle<br />

has been helping transport patients since June 2009.<br />

The SIVFDA is hoping <strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>ly on the bottle depot as a source of funding in the futu<strong>re</strong>.<br />

Since<strong>re</strong>ly,<br />

Mike Meagher, P<strong>re</strong>sident<br />

Doug Smith, Past P<strong>re</strong>sident (2007-2011)<br />

Phil Zweep, T<strong>re</strong>asu<strong>re</strong>r<br />

cc: Bud Graham, P<strong>re</strong>sident, <strong>ASIC</strong> . . . 2<br />

BC Incorporation Number S-52528


Pho<strong>to</strong> of the SIVFD Association’s 4x4 First Responder Vehicle designed <strong>to</strong> handle our worst roads.<br />

Since June 2009 it has been used in many 9-1-1 calls in helping transport patients.<br />

The purchase of this vehicle was made possible by the hard work of the SIVFDA members who sorted <strong>re</strong>fundables at the bottle depot.<br />

BC Incorporation Number S-52528


SIVFD<br />

SAVARY ISLAND VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPARTMENT<br />

1847-1853 Savary Island Road, Savary Island, British Columbia<br />

Mail <strong>to</strong>: PO Box 63, Lund, BC V0N 2G0<br />

Fi<strong>re</strong> Chief: 604-483-3373<br />

January 29, 2012<br />

And<strong>re</strong>a Cowgill<br />

Land Officer<br />

Ministry of Fo<strong>re</strong>sts, Lands and Natural Resource Operations<br />

and<strong>re</strong>a.cowgill@gov.bc.ca<br />

Dear And<strong>re</strong>a,<br />

The SIVFD is writing this letter in support of the <strong>re</strong>location of the Savary Island Bottle<br />

Recycling Depot <strong>to</strong> DL 1373, <strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong>.<br />

For a number of years the SIVFD has been the <strong>re</strong>cipient of the efforts and funds generated<br />

by the bottle <strong>re</strong>cycling depot, and has used those funds <strong>to</strong> purchase vehicles, equipment and<br />

supplies that help protect the Savary Island community against the risk of fi<strong>re</strong>, and for 9-1-1<br />

medical <strong>re</strong>lated <strong>re</strong>scues.<br />

Since 2009 the community has looked at many other locations around the <strong>island</strong> and all of<br />

them have been <strong>re</strong>jected. At this point in time, the small a<strong>re</strong>a in the corner of <strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong> is the<br />

only option for the depot’s temporary <strong>re</strong>location and also the last chance for the SIVFD <strong>to</strong> have<br />

access <strong>to</strong> the funds generated by the <strong>re</strong>fundables.<br />

Since<strong>re</strong>ly,<br />

Verne Rosenberg Eric Fer<strong>re</strong>ira Doug Smith Phil Zweep<br />

Fi<strong>re</strong> Chief Fi<strong>re</strong> Chief (Ret’d) Deputy Chief T<strong>re</strong>asu<strong>re</strong>r<br />

cc: Bud Graham, P<strong>re</strong>sident, <strong>ASIC</strong>


BOTTLE DEPOT CORRESPONDENCE<br />

JANUARY 25 <strong>to</strong> JANUARY 31, 2012<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

19.<br />

From: Chris<strong>to</strong>pher Sahlin <br />

Date: January 31, 2012 1:18:00 PM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Bottle Depot<br />

To whom it may concern,<br />

I am in favour of <strong>ASIC</strong>'s proposed on <strong>island</strong> bottle depot <strong>to</strong> support local<br />

initiatives.<br />

Chris Sahlin<br />

Savary property owner<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

18.<br />

From: Roger Sahlin <br />

Date: January 31, 2012 1:18:01 PM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Bottle Depot<br />

Reply-To: rrrconstruction@qwes<strong>to</strong>ffice.net<br />

To whom it may concern,<br />

I am in favour of <strong>ASIC</strong>'s proposed on <strong>island</strong> bottle depot <strong>to</strong> support local<br />

initiatives.<br />

Roger Sahlin<br />

Savary property owner<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

17.


From: Janine Reimer <br />

Date: January 30, 2012 3:39:54 PM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: support for lot<strong>224</strong><br />

Dear <strong>ASIC</strong>,<br />

I am in full support of the <strong>re</strong>location of the bottle depot <strong>to</strong> <strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong>.<br />

Janine Reimer<br />

Savary Island<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

16.<br />

From: JIM POZER <br />

Date: January 30, 2012 12:41:01 PM MST<br />

To: and<strong>re</strong>a.cowgill@gov.bc.ca<br />

Cc: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Savary Island Volunteer Fi<strong>re</strong> Department Letter <strong>re</strong>: Bottle Depot<br />

Hi the<strong>re</strong>,<br />

Please be advised that we support the letter sent <strong>to</strong> you by the Savary Island<br />

Volunteer Fi<strong>re</strong> Department <strong>re</strong>: having a Bottle Depot on Savary Island.<br />

Thank you for your consideration of this matter.<br />

Jim and Suzanne Pozer<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

15.<br />

From: John T<strong>re</strong>en [mail<strong>to</strong>:jjt<strong>re</strong>en@shaw.ca] Sent: January-29-12 6:26 PM To:<br />

Bryan Miles Subject: Re: Association of the Savary Island Committee (<strong>ASIC</strong>)<br />

Bottle Depot Land Use Application<br />

To the Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>rs of <strong>ASIC</strong>:<br />

We definitely support the establishment of the new location for the bottle depot


on Savary Island on <strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong>. We have voluntee<strong>re</strong>d at the bottle depot in the past<br />

and <strong>re</strong>alize how important it is as a fund raiser for projects on the Island. We<br />

look forward <strong>to</strong> assisting with the construction and sorting at the new depot.<br />

Since<strong>re</strong>ly,<br />

Joan and John T<strong>re</strong>en.<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

14.<br />

From: "Sandra Miles" <br />

Date: January 29, 2012 2:43:27 PM MST<br />

To: "'Bryan Miles'" <br />

Bryan Miles, Di<strong>re</strong>c<strong>to</strong>r<br />

<strong>ASIC</strong> Community Service Committee<br />

I support the <strong>re</strong>location of the Bottle Depot <strong>to</strong> the Crown Land Property on <strong>Lot</strong><br />

<strong>224</strong><br />

Sandy Miles<br />

Property Owner<br />

Savary Sho<strong>re</strong>s<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

13.<br />

From: "Mike and Deb Meagher" <br />

Date: January 28, 2012 2:59:53 PM MST<br />

To: "Bryan Miles" <br />

Subject: Re: Association of the Savary Island Committee (<strong>ASIC</strong>) Bottle<br />

Depot Land Use Application<br />

Dear <strong>ASIC</strong>, we support the <strong>re</strong>location of the Bottle Depot <strong>to</strong> the Savary Island<br />

Lane and Vancouver Blvd location. Thanks so much <strong>to</strong> <strong>ASIC</strong> for their hard work<br />

on this matter. We look forward <strong>to</strong> helping out at the new location.<br />

Mike and Deb Meagher☺


*********************************************************************<br />

12.<br />

From: "Kay Lutz" <br />

Date: January 28, 2012 10:59:54 AM MST<br />

To: "Bryan Miles" <br />

Subject: Re: Association of the Savary Island Committee (<strong>ASIC</strong>) Bottle<br />

Depot Land Use Application<br />

We, owners of <strong>Lot</strong>s 97 & 98 in Savary Sho<strong>re</strong>s, a<strong>re</strong> in favour of the proposed<br />

bottle <strong>re</strong>-cycling depot site . Since the p<strong>re</strong>vious site closed-down we<br />

noticed that considerably mo<strong>re</strong> <strong>re</strong>cyclable garbage is p<strong>re</strong>sent along the<br />

roads. The<strong>re</strong>fo<strong>re</strong>, please try <strong>to</strong> proceed with the site as fast as possible for the<br />

upcoming season.<br />

Jorg & Kay Lutz<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

11.<br />

From: "Jeff Isert" <br />

Date: January 27, 2012 8:11:38 PM MST<br />

To: "Bryan Miles" <br />

Subject: Re: Association of the Savary Island Committee (<strong>ASIC</strong>) Bottle<br />

Depot Land Use Application<br />

Bryan,<br />

Thank you again for all your work on this.<br />

I am <strong>to</strong>tally in support of this.<br />

Kind <strong>re</strong>gards,<br />

Jeff<br />

*********************************************************************


10.<br />

From: Jack McGui<strong>re</strong> <br />

Date: January 29, 2012 5:38:08 PM MST<br />

To: and<strong>re</strong>a.cowgill@gov.bc.ca<br />

Cc: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Savary Island Bottle Depot<br />

To:<br />

And<strong>re</strong>a Cowgill, Land Officer<br />

Ministry of Fo<strong>re</strong>sts, Lands and Natural Resource Operations<br />

10428 153rd St<strong>re</strong>et, Suite 200<br />

Sur<strong>re</strong>y, BC V3R 1E1<br />

We have owned property on Savary since, at 1137 Sunset Trail, since this time<br />

of the year in 1983.<br />

We support the Fi<strong>re</strong> Department's effort <strong>to</strong> locate the bottle depot on DL 1373,<br />

<strong>Lot</strong> <strong>224</strong>.<br />

Yours truly<br />

Daphne and Jack McGui<strong>re</strong><br />

*********************************************************************<br />

9.<br />

From: Harold Robertson <br />

Date: January 29, 2012 5:31:42 PM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Bottle Depot<br />

Reply-To: Harold Robertson harry1551@twincomm.ca<br />

To whom it may concern,<br />

My family and I have been coming every summer <strong>to</strong> Savary <strong>island</strong> for over forty<br />

years. In the last decade the number of visi<strong>to</strong>rs has grown dramatically. Cabin<br />

owners, <strong>re</strong>nters, guests, day trippers, all seem <strong>to</strong> arrive in ever inc<strong>re</strong>asing<br />

numbers.Our cabin is near the dock. The number of cases of soft drinks, beer,<br />

cider, and wine that pass over the wharfhead never ceases <strong>to</strong> amaze us.<br />

Garbage and <strong>re</strong>cyclables have become a <strong>re</strong>al problem on our <strong>island</strong>, probably<br />

mo<strong>re</strong> so than any other place I have seen. The bottle depot and the wonderful,<br />

dedicated volunteers who man it a<strong>re</strong> essential <strong>to</strong> keeping the <strong>island</strong> clear of<br />

<strong>re</strong>cyclables that would otherwise be left st<strong>re</strong>wn about. Please, whoever makes


the decision on a new location for this much needed service, <strong>re</strong>cognize how<br />

important and imperative it is <strong>to</strong> Savary that it be approved.<br />

Thank you for your serious consideration in this matter,<br />

Yours Since<strong>re</strong>ly,<br />

Harold Robertson<br />

2976 Malaspina Promenade<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

8.<br />

From: Gael Crawford <br />

Date: January 27, 2012 1:06:41 PM MST<br />

To: "<strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca" <br />

Subject: new bottle depot<br />

Reply-To: Gael Crawford gaelcrawford@yahoo.ca<br />

We would like <strong>to</strong> go on <strong>re</strong>cord in support of the new bottle depot. Having bottle<br />

<strong>re</strong>cycling on the <strong>island</strong> is very important, not only for the funds it raises but for<br />

keeping the <strong>island</strong> clean. Thank you for all your hard work and perseverance in<br />

dealing with this issue.<br />

Gael and Ron Johns<strong>to</strong>ne<br />

Oceanview Lane<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

7.<br />

From: FNI <br />

Date: January 27, 2012 11:43:44 AM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Bottle depot<br />

Since the bottle depot has been closed it has been a challenge <strong>to</strong> keep the<br />

discarded bottles and beer cans off the roadways and beaches. A lot of us that<br />

own cottages on Savary <strong>island</strong> have been picking up these discarded cans and<br />

bottles and having <strong>to</strong> s<strong>to</strong><strong>re</strong> them until someone in our a<strong>re</strong>a is going <strong>to</strong> <strong>to</strong>wn or<br />

has a Grand Son or Daughter coming <strong>to</strong> Savary and wants <strong>to</strong> earn some cash.<br />

Truly these funds can be used for Savary Island fi<strong>re</strong> dept or perhaps for<br />

...GARBAGE DISPOSAL which is another much needed service on our Island.<br />

Since<strong>re</strong>ly Gordon and Rose Pelletier


Savary Island Add<strong>re</strong>ss ; 3154 Ocean View Lane Savary Island<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

6.<br />

From: s <br />

Date: January 26, 2012 11:21:25 AM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: bottle depot<br />

I am in favor of the proposed location of the bottle<br />

depot<br />

Sean Harvey<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

5.<br />

From: Lorraine and Glenn Waring <br />

Date: January 25, 2012 8:34:41 PM MST<br />

To: "<strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca" <br />

Subject: Bottle depot Savary Island<br />

Reply-To: Lorraine and Glenn Waring lgwaring@yahoo.com<br />

I strongly support the <strong>re</strong>newal of a new bottle depot on Savary Island. I have<br />

voluntee<strong>re</strong>d at the p<strong>re</strong>vious depot for the past 15 years along with several others<br />

and the benefits <strong>to</strong> the community have been significant. We have raised on<br />

average 12k which has been used for ext<strong>re</strong>mely important projects such as<br />

purchasing equipment for the Savary Island Volunteer Fi<strong>re</strong> Department. In<br />

addition in the one year we have not had a depot the<strong>re</strong> has been a<br />

noticeable inc<strong>re</strong>ase in the number of beer cans and wine bottles left as garbage<br />

throughout the Island. Please pursue the opportunity of finding another site which<br />

will <strong>re</strong>sult in the funding of needed community projects and ensuring the littering<br />

of can and bottles is minimal.<br />

Regards,<br />

Glenn Waring<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

4.<br />

From: Elizabeth Verwoord


Date: January 25, 2012 8:18:12 PM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Bottle depot<br />

To Whom it May Concern,<br />

I am writing this letter <strong>to</strong> show my support for the <strong>re</strong>cent initiatives taken by <strong>ASIC</strong><br />

<strong>to</strong> <strong>re</strong>locate and establish a functioning bottle depot. It is ext<strong>re</strong>mely important that<br />

Savary Island continue this wonderful fund raiser and <strong>re</strong>cycling<br />

of bottles through volunteer efforts. It seems that the <strong>committee</strong> has taken in<strong>to</strong><br />

consideration every possible concern with the new proposed location and it<br />

cannot get much better than this.<br />

Many thanks,<br />

Liz and Rob Verwoord<br />

3056 Vancouver Boulevard<br />

Savary Island<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

3.<br />

From: Mary-Ellen Bergvinson <br />

Date: January 25, 2012 6:52:24 PM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: bottle depot<br />

To Whom It May Concern,<br />

I am in favour of the proposed bottle depot on the corner of Savary Island Rd and<br />

Vancouver Blvd.<br />

Mary-Ellen Bergvinson<br />

Savary Island Property owner<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

2.<br />

From: sandra cherkosh <br />

Date: January 25, 2012 6:09:50 PM MST<br />

To: "<strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca" <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

To whom it may concern, I am in favour of having an on <strong>island</strong> bottle


depot <strong>to</strong> support local initiatives.<br />

Thank you,Sandra Cherkosh<br />

1148 Herchmer Rd. Savary Island<br />

*********************************************************************<br />

1.<br />

From: Bob Russell <br />

Date: January 25, 2012 3:02:07 PM MST<br />

To: <strong>savary</strong><strong>island</strong><strong>committee</strong>@shaw.ca<br />

Subject: Savary Island Bottle Depot<br />

To whom it may concern,<br />

I support the bottle depot on Savary Island as <strong>re</strong>cently proposed (by <strong>ASIC</strong>). It is<br />

an ext<strong>re</strong>mely important initiative in<br />

my opinion.<br />

Thanks, Bob Russell<br />

*********************************************************************

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!