CITY OF BUCHAREST SEISMIC PROFILE: FROM HAZARD ... - apcmr
CITY OF BUCHAREST SEISMIC PROFILE: FROM HAZARD ... - apcmr
CITY OF BUCHAREST SEISMIC PROFILE: FROM HAZARD ... - apcmr
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>SEISMIC</strong> STRENGTHENING <strong>OF</strong> BUILDINGS AND <strong>SEISMIC</strong><br />
INSTRUMENTATION -TWO PRIORITIES FOR <strong>SEISMIC</strong> RISK<br />
REDUCTION IN ROMANIA<br />
D. Lungu 1,2 , A. Aldea 2 , S. Demetriu 2 and I. Craifaleanu 1<br />
Abstract<br />
According to the number of people lost in earthquakes during XX th century as well as<br />
in a single (March 4, 1977) earthquake during this century (1574 people, including 1424 in<br />
Bucharest), Romania can be ranked the 3 rd country in Europe, after Italy and Turkey. Romania<br />
is followed by the former Yugoslavia and by the Greece (Bolt, 1995, Coburn and Spence,<br />
1992).<br />
The World Bank loss estimation after the 1977 earthquake (Report No.P-2240-RO,<br />
1978) indicates that from the total loss (2.05 Billion US $) more than 2/3 was in Bucharest,<br />
where 32 tall buildings collapsed. Half of the total loss was accumulated from buildings<br />
damage. The 1977 direct loss and indirect consequences of loss mark probably the starting<br />
point of economical decay of Romania during the next decade. They also explain the present<br />
concern of civil engineers and Romanian Government for assessment and reduction of<br />
seismic risk in Romania.<br />
The World Map of Natural Hazards prepared by the Münich Re, 1998 indicates for<br />
Bucharest: “Large city with Mexico-city effect”. The map focuses the dangerous phenomenon<br />
of long (1.6s) predominant period of soil vibration in Bucharest during strong Carpathians<br />
Vrancea earthquakes. The Bucharest and Lisbon are the only two European cities falling into<br />
Mexico-city category.<br />
International experts and organizations agreed that Bucharest is the capital city in<br />
Europe characterised by the highest seismic risk.<br />
The paper presents:<br />
Part I, Vrancea Seismic Hazard Assessment in Romania, 1.1 Subcrustal Seismicity of<br />
the Vrancea Region; 1.2 Codes and standards for design of earthquake resistance of structures<br />
1 National Institute for Building Research, Bucharest, Tel.: 0040.21.255.02.70, Fax: 0040.21.255.00.62, E-mail:<br />
lungud@cons.incerc.ro; lungud@incerc2004.ro<br />
2 Technical University of Civil Engineering, Bucharest. Tel.: 0040.21.242.58.04,<br />
E-mail: lungud@mail.utcb.ro
(1940 – 2000); 1.3 Seismic hazard assessment in the draft P 100 2003 seismic code of<br />
Romania.<br />
Part II, Seismic Risk Management, 2.1 The structure of the existing building stock in<br />
Bucharest; 2.2 Fragile residential buildings in Bucharest.<br />
Part I: Vrancea seismic hazard assessment in Romania<br />
1.1 Subcrustal seismicity of the Vrancea region of Romania<br />
The Vrancea region, located where the Carpathians Mountains Arch bends, at about<br />
135 ± 35 km epicentral distance from Bucharest, is a source of subcrustal seismic activity,<br />
which affects ±35 more than 2/3 of the territory of Romania and an important part of the<br />
territories of Republic of Moldova, Bulgaria and Ukraine. The Vrancea source induces the<br />
very high seismic risk in the densely built zones of the South-East of Romania. According to<br />
the 20th century seismicity, the epicentral Vrancea area is confined to a rectangle of<br />
40x80km 2 having the long axis oriented N45E and being centered at about 45.6 o Lat.N and<br />
26.6 o Long. E.<br />
During the last 60 years, Bucharest was threatened by 4 strong Vrancea events: Nov.10,<br />
1940 (moment magnitude M w =7.7, focal depth h=150 km), March 4, 1977 (M w =7.5, h=109<br />
km), Aug 30, 1986 (M w =7.2, h=133km) and May 30/31, 1990 (M w =7.0/6.4, h=91/79 km).<br />
The Catalogues of earthquakes occurred on the territory of Romania were compiled by<br />
Radu (1974, 1980, 1995) and Constantinescu and Marza (1980, 1995).<br />
The most complete Vrancea historical catalogue is Radu Catalogue, even the majority<br />
of significant events are also included in Constantinescu and Marza Catalogue. The Radu<br />
Catalogue is about three times larger than the other Catalogue. The magnitude used in the<br />
Radu catalogue is the Gutenberg-Richter magnitude, M.<br />
Figure 1. Epicenters of earthquakes in Romania, 984 - 2000<br />
For Vrancea subcrustal source, the conversion of Gutenberg-Richter magnitude into<br />
moment magnitude might be approximated by M w = M + 0.3 for 6.5 < M w < 7.8 (Lungu et<br />
al.1999).<br />
From existing catalogues, one may approximately note:<br />
(i) During the time interval 984-1900, one event/century with epicentral intensity<br />
I 0 9.0;
(ii) During the period 1901-2000 the evidence is two events per century of<br />
intensity I 0 9.0 (i.e. M w 7.5), Table 1.<br />
Table 1. 20 th Century catalogue of Vrancea Earthquakes, M GR >6.0<br />
Date<br />
Time<br />
(GMT)<br />
h:m:s<br />
MARZA www.infp.ro<br />
Lat. N o Long. E o RADU Catalogue,<br />
Catalogue, Catalogue,<br />
1994<br />
1980 1998<br />
h, km I 0 M GR M w I 0 M s M w<br />
1903 13 Sept 08:02:7 45.7 26.6 >60 7 6.3 - 6.5 5.7 6.3<br />
1904 6 Feb 02:49:00 45.7 26.6 75 6 5.7 - 6 6.3 6.6<br />
1908 6 Oct 21:39:8 45.7 26.5 150 8 6.8 - 8 6.8 7.1<br />
1912 25 May 18:01:7 45.7 27.2 80 7 6.0 - 7 6.4 6.7<br />
1934 29 March 20:06:51 45.8 26.5 90 7 6.3 - 8 6.3 6.6<br />
1939 5 Sept 06:02:00 45.9 26.7 120 6 5.3 - 6 6.1 6.2<br />
1940 22 Oct 06:37:00 45.8 26.4 122 7 / 8 6.5 - 7 6.2 6.5<br />
1940 10 Nov 01:39:07 45.8 26.7 150 1) 9 7.4 - 9 7.4 7.7<br />
1945 7 Sept 15:48:26 45.9 26.5 75 7 / 8 6.5 - 7.5 6.5 6.8<br />
1945 9 Dec 06:08:45 45.7 26.8 80 7 6.0 - 7 6.2 6.5<br />
1948 29 May 04:48:55 45.8 26.5 130 6 / 7 5.8 - 6.5 6.0 6.3<br />
1977 4 March 2) 19:22:15 45.34 26.30 109 8 / 9 7.2 7.5 9 7.2 7.4<br />
1986 30 Aug 21:28:37 45.53 26.47 133 8 7.0 7.2 - - 7.1<br />
1990 30 May 10:40:06 45.82 26.90 91 8 6.7 7.0 - - 6.9<br />
1990 31 May 00:17:49 45.83 26.89 79 7 6.1 6.4 - - 6.4<br />
The strongest Vrancea earthquake ever occurred is accepted to be the Oct 26, 1802<br />
event (M = 7.5 ….7.7) the most disastrous event is March 4, 1977 earthquake (M=7.2; M w =<br />
7.4 …7.5).<br />
The recurrence-magnitude relationship is determined from Radu’s 20th century<br />
Catalogue of subcrustal magnitudes with threshold lower magnitude M w =6.3. The average<br />
number per year of Vrancea subcrustal earthquakes with magnitude equal to and greater than<br />
M w , as resulting also from Figure 2 is (Lungu, Demetriu, 1995):<br />
log n(>M w ) = 3.76 - 0.73 M w<br />
(1a)<br />
The maximum credible magnitude of the source was estimated using Wells and<br />
Coppersmith (1994) equations. Even those equations are intended for crustal earthquakes, the<br />
experience of recent subcrustal Vrancea events fits approximately the mentioned equations.<br />
According to Romanian geologists Sandulescu & Dinu, in Vrancea subduction zone the<br />
length of the rupture surface is: SRL 150÷200 km and the area of the rupture surface is:<br />
SRA8000 km 2 . Based on this estimation, one might get from Wells and Coppersmith<br />
equations M w,max = 8.0...8.1 (Lungu et al. 1999).<br />
If the source magnitude is limited by an upper bound magnitude M w,max , the recurrence<br />
relationship (1a)can be modified in order to satisfy the property of a probability distribution<br />
(Hwang and Huo 1994). In the case of Vrancea source (Elnashai and Lungu, 1995):<br />
n<br />
1<br />
e<br />
1<br />
e<br />
1.687(8.1M<br />
w<br />
8.6541.687Mw<br />
( M<br />
w<br />
) = e<br />
1.687(8.16.3)<br />
)<br />
(1b)
In Eq.(1), the threshold lower magnitude is M w0 =6.3, the maximum credible magnitude<br />
of the source is M w,max =8.1, and = 3.76 ln10 = 8.654, = 0.73 ln10 =1.687.<br />
1<br />
20 th century Radu's catalogue<br />
Cumulative number, n(>M) per yr<br />
0.1<br />
0.01<br />
n<br />
1.687(8.1<br />
M<br />
1 e<br />
w<br />
8.6541.687M<br />
w<br />
( M w ) = e<br />
1.687(8.1<br />
6.3)<br />
1 e<br />
0.001<br />
6.0 6.3 6.4 6.7 6.8 7.1 7.2 7.5 7.6 7.9 8.38.0<br />
Moment magnitude, M w<br />
)<br />
log n (>M w ) = 3.76 - 0.73M w<br />
M w, m ax = 7.8 8.1<br />
Figure 2. Magnitude recurrence relation for the subcrustal Vrancea source (M w 6.3)<br />
1.2 Codes and standards for design of earthquake resistance of structures (1940 – 2000)<br />
The codes for earthquake resistance of buildings and structures in Romania during the<br />
last 60 years are listed below:<br />
P.I. - 1941 Preliminary instructions (after the 1940 event). Ministry of Public Works and<br />
Communication, Bucharest 1941, 9p.;<br />
I - 1945 Instructions for preventing the damage of buildings due to earthquakes. Ministry<br />
of Public Works and Communication, Bucharest, 1945, 10p.;<br />
P13 - 63 and P13 - 70 Code for (structural) design of buildings in seismic zones. State<br />
Committee for Constructions, Architecture and Urban Planning, CSCAS, Bucharest, 1963,<br />
39p. and 1970, 63p.;<br />
P100 - 78 and P100 - 81 Code for (structural) design of buildings in seismic zones.<br />
Central Institute for Research, Design and Management for Constructions ICCPDC,<br />
Bucharest, 1978, 57p. and 1981, 72p.;<br />
P100 - 90 and P100 - 92 Code for earthquake-resistant design of civil and industrial<br />
buildings. Ministry of Public Works and Land Planning, MLPAT, Bucharest, 1991, 152p. and<br />
1992, 152p (English version 1993, 151p). Chapters 11, 12 were modified in 1996, 50p.<br />
P100 – 2003 - Code for earthquake resistance of buildings and structure (Draft, 2003).
The accompanying standards for seismic zonation of Romania are:<br />
STAS 2923-52 and STAS 2923-63, Macrozonation of the territory of R.S.Romania. State<br />
Office for Standardization, Bucharest, 1952 and 1963;<br />
Decree No. 66/1977 of the Romanian Government, 1977;<br />
STAS 11100/1-77, Macrozonation of the territory of R.S.Romania. Romanian Institute for<br />
Standardization, Bucharest, 1978;<br />
STAS 11100/1-91 and SR 11100/1-93, Macrozonation of the territory of Romania.<br />
Romanian Institute for Standardization, Bucharest, 1991 and 1994.<br />
The contents of the seismic codes and of the standards for seismic zonation of territory<br />
of Romania can be classified in four generations of major developments described in Table 2.<br />
Table 2. Classification of codes for design of earthquake resistance of buildings and<br />
standards for seismic zonation of Romania (1940-2003)<br />
Code for earthquake Seismic<br />
Period<br />
resistance of structures zonation standard*<br />
Prior to the 1940 earthquake<br />
P.I. – 1941<br />
Pre-code,<br />
P.I. - 1941<br />
and<br />
I – 1945<br />
before 1963<br />
I - 1945<br />
Prior to the 1963 code<br />
STAS 2923 - 52<br />
Low-code, Inspired by the Russian P 13 - 63<br />
STAS 2923 - 63<br />
1963-1977<br />
Moderate-code,<br />
1977–1990<br />
Moderate-code to<br />
High-code,<br />
after 1990<br />
seismic practice<br />
After the great 1977<br />
earthquake<br />
After the 1986 and the 1990<br />
earthquakes<br />
P 13 - 70<br />
P 100 - 78<br />
P 100 - 81<br />
P 100 - 90<br />
P 100 - 92<br />
STAS 11100/1 - 77<br />
STAS 11100/1 - 91<br />
SR 11100/1 - 93<br />
High code,<br />
Inspired by Eurocode 8 P100 – 2003 (draft) -<br />
after 2004<br />
*The intensity scale used in Romania is MSK - 64 scale (STAS 3684 - 63, STAS 3684 - 71)<br />
(T )<br />
3.0<br />
2.5<br />
2.0<br />
1.0<br />
0.6<br />
P13-63<br />
7 yr.<br />
0.9/T<br />
0.8/T<br />
3/T<br />
= 0.05<br />
P13-70<br />
6 yr.<br />
P100-78<br />
after March 4, 1977<br />
P100-81<br />
12 yr.<br />
P100-90<br />
after Aug.30, 1986<br />
P100-92<br />
6 yr.<br />
1.0<br />
0.75<br />
0.6<br />
0.0<br />
0 0.3 0.4 0.7 1 1.5 2 2.2 2.5 3 4<br />
Period T , s<br />
Figure 3. Normalised acceleration elastic response spectra in Romanian<br />
seismic codes, from the 1963 to 2002 (Lungu, 1996)<br />
The evolution of normalized acceleration elastic response spectra in design provisions<br />
for earthquake resistance of structures in Bucharest is given in Figure 3 and it is selfexplanatory.<br />
The evolution of seismic design coefficient for computing lateral force (shear) at the<br />
base of building structure in Bucharest is presented in Figure 4. One should note the gap of the
overall coefficient C s for flexible buildings and structures built during the period 1963-1978;<br />
however, even for rigid structures built during that period, the maximum C s was about 2/3 of the<br />
present C s due to reduced MSK intensity (VII) recommended for Bucharest by STAS 2923-63<br />
(Table3).<br />
After the 1977 disaster, ductility rules for reinforced concrete structures were imported<br />
into Romanian codes from American Concrete Institute (ACI) codes of practice. Those<br />
ductility rules were improved in 1990 according to the EUROCODE 8 new requirements.<br />
Evolution of seismic zonation maps in Romania during the last 40 years is illustrated<br />
by Figure 4 and Table 3.<br />
Shear walls<br />
Frames<br />
7.5%<br />
7.5% 7.2%<br />
6.8%<br />
10 %<br />
8%<br />
12.5 %<br />
10%<br />
1.5 s<br />
12<br />
Seismic<br />
design<br />
coefficient<br />
C s , %<br />
5 %<br />
0.3 s<br />
T c =0.4 s<br />
T c =1.5 s<br />
10<br />
8<br />
8-10<br />
6-8<br />
Rigid RIGID 0.1<br />
buildings<br />
0.4<br />
0.7<br />
FLEXIBLE Flexible 1<br />
buildings<br />
buildings<br />
1.3<br />
Building period<br />
T , s<br />
1.6<br />
1.9<br />
1941<br />
1945<br />
2%<br />
1963<br />
2.2%<br />
1.8%<br />
1970<br />
1978<br />
1981<br />
1990<br />
1992<br />
2<br />
0<br />
6<br />
4<br />
Year of code issue<br />
4-6<br />
2-4<br />
Non-ductile buildings<br />
Ductile structures<br />
Figure 4. Evolution of seismic design coefficient in Bucharest during time interval 1940-2000,<br />
(Lungu, Demetriu, 1998)<br />
Table 3. MSK seismic intensity in Bucharest<br />
Time interval Standard MSK intensity<br />
1952 – 1963 STAS 2923-52 VIII<br />
1963 – 1977 STAS 2923-63 VII<br />
1978 – 1991 STAS 11100/1-77 VIII<br />
1991 - present SR 11100/1-91 and 93 VIII<br />
The present conversion of MSK intensity, adopted by Romanian standard SR 11100/1-<br />
93, into peak ground acceleration, a g used by Romanian code for design of earthquake<br />
resistance of structures, is given in Table 4.
Table 4<br />
MSK-64 intensity in SR 11100/1-93 9 8 7 6 5<br />
a g /g in P100-92 code 0.32 0.25 and 0.20 (2 zones) 0.16 0.12 0.08<br />
Figure 5. Evolution of seismic zonation of Romania (from 1963 to 1993 and 2002)<br />
It is emphasized that the present seismic code of Romania, P100-92 defines the<br />
earthquake hazard by 50 yr. mean recurrence interval event (MRI=50yr i.e. 63% exceedance<br />
probability in 50 yr). However, since the American loading code ASCE 7-95, 2000 and<br />
EUROCODE 8 for earthquake resistance of structures define the design earthquake by 475 yr.
mean recurrence interval (MRI=475yr i.e. 10% exceedance probability in 50 years) event, the<br />
level of seismic hazard in present seismic code is now under revision.<br />
A comparison of the max. peak ground acceleration for design (MRI = 50yr. and M g RI<br />
= 475 yr.) in Bucharest, Skopje and other 8 cities around the world is presented in Figure 6.<br />
1.0<br />
Peak Ground Acceleration PGA, g<br />
0.9<br />
0.8<br />
0.7<br />
0.6<br />
0.5<br />
0.4<br />
0.3<br />
0.2<br />
0.1<br />
0.0<br />
0.10<br />
0.06<br />
0.20<br />
0.75<br />
Europe Africa Asia America<br />
0.40<br />
0.28<br />
T = 50 yr<br />
0.32<br />
0.12 0.13<br />
Mean recurrence interval<br />
T = 475 yr<br />
0.40<br />
0.13<br />
Rome Bucharest Sofia Skopje Algiers Tehran Katmandu Salvador Santiago Bogota<br />
Figure 6. Seismic hazard around the world – U.N. RADIUS Project,1999<br />
0.33<br />
0.18<br />
0.36<br />
0.14<br />
0.38<br />
0.82<br />
0.30 0.31<br />
0.20<br />
The recorded maximum peak ground acceleration in Romania during in 1977, 1980<br />
and 1990 Vrancea earthquakes in given in Figure 7.<br />
ROMANIA. Maximum peak ground acceleration PGA, cm/s2 recorded during 1977, 1986 and 1990 VRANCEA earthquakes<br />
W<br />
N<br />
S<br />
PGA, cm/s2<br />
#· Epicenters of strong<br />
Vrancea events<br />
(Mw > 6.9)<br />
E<br />
0 - 75<br />
75 - 150<br />
150 - 200<br />
200 - 300<br />
Seismic stations with<br />
free-field records:<br />
# INCERC network<br />
% INFP network<br />
$ GEOTEC network<br />
& R. of Moldova network<br />
& Bulgaria network<br />
March 4, 1977<br />
Mw=7.5<br />
h=109 km<br />
Aug.30, 1986<br />
Mw=7.2<br />
h=133 km<br />
May 30, 1990<br />
Mw=7.0<br />
h=91 km<br />
Mw - moment magnitude<br />
h - focus depth<br />
Lungu, Aldea, 1999<br />
21 22<br />
48<br />
23 24<br />
Ukraine 25 26 27<br />
Figure<br />
Figure 7.<br />
Botosani<br />
#<br />
28 29<br />
Hungary<br />
11.5<br />
Republic of<br />
#<br />
Satu-Mare<br />
Moldova<br />
Moldova<br />
Krasnogorka<br />
Iasi<br />
&<br />
#<br />
Chisinau 82.0<br />
146.4<br />
&<br />
212.8<br />
47<br />
Dochia<br />
#<br />
%<br />
Cris<br />
50.9<br />
Oradea<br />
Cluj-Napoca<br />
#<br />
Bacau<br />
%<br />
132.0<br />
Barlad<br />
Onesti<br />
#<br />
#<br />
Transilvania<br />
232.1 Adjud 168.6<br />
#<br />
86.6<br />
Banat<br />
Cahul<br />
&<br />
Vrancioaia<br />
% 1990<br />
136.6<br />
Mures<br />
157.2 #· #·<br />
46<br />
Focsani<br />
%<br />
Timisoara<br />
Surduc 1940<br />
$<br />
#<br />
97.2 297.1<br />
Muntele Rosu #·<br />
% 1986 Ramnicu Sarat<br />
Vidra Lotru<br />
#<br />
$ Vidraru Arges 79.1<br />
164.0<br />
$<br />
#· 1977 158.6 Carcaliu Tulcea<br />
Valenii de Munte<br />
%<br />
#<br />
14.3<br />
93.6<br />
26.1<br />
186.9 # %<br />
Campina#<br />
Istrita<br />
61.5<br />
# 109.4<br />
Baia<br />
#<br />
45<br />
Pitesti<br />
Ploiesti<br />
#<br />
Valahia 90.8<br />
45.8<br />
Peris<br />
Figure 9 #<br />
Dobrogea<br />
223.8<br />
#<br />
Otopeni 219.8<br />
Bolintin Vale<br />
Fetesti<br />
# Branesti<br />
# #<br />
# Cernavoda<br />
100.4 #<br />
208.6<br />
Craiova<br />
Bucuresti<br />
150.8<br />
107.1<br />
Calarasi<br />
#<br />
#<br />
#<br />
194.9<br />
Constanta<br />
Yugoslavia<br />
Giurgiu114.1<br />
#<br />
44<br />
Danube<br />
Turnu Magurele<br />
& Ruse112.4<br />
#<br />
Shabla 32.9<br />
112.2<br />
&<br />
Kavarna36.2<br />
&<br />
Bulgaria<br />
Varna 33.6<br />
Provadia48.2<br />
&<br />
100 0 100 200 Kilometers<br />
&<br />
Olt<br />
Prut<br />
Black<br />
Sea<br />
ArcView GIS version 3.1, ESRI Inc. CA.<br />
Figure 7
1.3 Draft P 100 2003 seismic code of Romania. Seismic hazard assessment<br />
The present joint map of Vrancea seismic hazard of Romania, Bulgaria and Moldavia.<br />
Figure 8 and Tabel 5 still suggests a need for map improvement by joint regional efforts.<br />
Zaicenco, Lungu, 1999<br />
Figure 8. Seismic zonation maps for countries affected by Vrancea earthquakes<br />
Table 5 for the map in Figure 8.<br />
PGA/g<br />
ROMANIA Rep. of MOLDOVA,<br />
MSK Intensity<br />
BULGARIA<br />
P100-92&<br />
UKRAINE<br />
1987 code<br />
SR 11100/1-93 SNIP II-7-81<br />
IX 0.32 0.40 0.27<br />
VIII<br />
0.25<br />
0.20<br />
0.20 0.15<br />
VII 0.16 0.10 0.10<br />
V<br />
0.12<br />
0.08<br />
- 0.05<br />
Based on the results of probabilistic seismic hazard assessment for Vrancea source<br />
(Lungu et al., 1995...2002) and taking into account the contributions from the crustal seismic<br />
sources around Romania, Figure 8 presents the proposed hazard map for the new code for<br />
design of earthquake resistant buildings in Romania, P100-2003. The map give the design<br />
peak ground acceleration, a g for the MRI=100 yr seismic event.
Figure 9. Peak ground acceleration for design, a g for MRI=100 y., P100-2003 code proposal<br />
The response spectra in Figure 9 is recommended for Romania and Bucharest<br />
locations characterized by various control period of response spectra: T C S0.7s, 0.7s
There is an instrumental evidence, from both the 1977 earthquake and 1986<br />
earthquake that soil condition in Bucharest is characterised by the long predominant period of<br />
ground vibration: T g =1.4-1.6s. That T g explains the long corner period of response spectra<br />
T c =1.6s, in Figure10.<br />
A tentative macrozonation of Tc in Romania teritory is given in Figure 11.<br />
PSD<br />
Densitatea spectrala normalizata<br />
0.35<br />
4 Martie 1977, M=7.2, comp.NS<br />
0.30<br />
30 Aug. 1986, M=7.0, comp. NS<br />
Figure 8. Romania . Control period of response spectra, P100 - 2003<br />
0.25<br />
0.20<br />
0.15<br />
0.10<br />
0.05<br />
p =2 /T p<br />
INCERC Bucuresti<br />
0.00<br />
0 10 20 30 40<br />
Pulsatia , rad/s<br />
Figure 11. INCERC seismic station in Eastern Bucharest. Normalised power spectral density<br />
for the NS comp. of the Mar 4, 1977 and Aug 30, 1986 earthquakes<br />
Figure 12. Romania. Control period of response spectra, P100-2003
Part II. Seismic Risk Management<br />
2.1 The structure of the existing building stock in Bucharest<br />
The structure of the existing building stock in Bucharest is given in Figure 12 and Table<br />
6. The Bucharest population is about 2 million inhabitants. It is almost constant during the last<br />
10 years.<br />
Number of buildings<br />
Number of buildings<br />
35000<br />
30000<br />
25000<br />
20000<br />
15000<br />
10000<br />
5000<br />
0<br />
3000<br />
2500<br />
2000<br />
1500<br />
1000<br />
500<br />
0<br />
Period of construction<br />
Period of construction<br />
Low-rise buildings<br />
(1-2 storeys)<br />
1900 1929 1945 1963 1970 1977 1990<br />
High-rise buildings<br />
(8 storeys)<br />
Number of buildings<br />
2500<br />
2000<br />
1500<br />
1000<br />
1900 1929 1945 1963 1970 1977<br />
500<br />
0<br />
Period of construction<br />
Mid-rise buildings<br />
(3-7 storeys)<br />
1900 1929 1945 1963 1970 1977 1990<br />
Figure 13. Distribution of Bucharest buildings with period of construction<br />
Table 6. Inventory of existing housing units in Bucharest according to the periods of validity of<br />
various Romanian seismic codes.<br />
Seismic code interbenchmark<br />
periods<br />
Housing units built during interbenchmark<br />
periods<br />
% housing units built during interbenchmark<br />
periods<br />
before 1941 168,556 21.95 ~22%<br />
1941-1963 69,702 9.08<br />
1963-1970 110,669 14.42<br />
1970-1978 119,625 15.57 ~39%<br />
1978-1992 292,594 38.09<br />
1992-1995 6,844 0.89 ~ 39%<br />
Total 768,000 100%
PERI<br />
A CADEMIEI<br />
P ITAR MOS<br />
CAVA FII VECHI<br />
SALIGNY A NGHE L - Inginer<br />
DA<br />
REMUS<br />
2.2 Fragile residential buildings in Bucharest<br />
The List of the vulnerable buildings built in the center of Bucharest before 1940 and<br />
identified as having highest risk of collapse in the case of strong earthquake (comparable to<br />
1977 event) contains 115 fragile mid-rise and high-rise buildings (March 2001/ Jan. 2003).<br />
All those tall buildings listed as very vulnerable were located on the city map using<br />
the Geographic Information System (GIS) infrastructure, Figure 13 and Table 5.<br />
In so called “Test area of central Bucharest” the GIS map (1:500) contains the location<br />
and detailed information on the more than 1700 buildings. All those buildings represented on<br />
map were digitised at Karlsruhe University within the technical cooperation between<br />
Technical University of Civil Engineering Bucharest (UTCB) and Karlsruhe University in the<br />
frame of German Science Foundation Project 461 devoted to Vrancea earthquakes.<br />
The Test area in central Bucharest was selected by UTCB in 1997 based on location of<br />
the collapsed buildings during the 1977 earthquake in Bucharest.<br />
Presently, the central Bucharest test area was extended to about 24000 buildings<br />
within European RISK-UE Project at University of Civil Engineering Bucharest, (UTCB) for<br />
including majority of the building listed as seismically vulnerable in Bucharest.<br />
30<br />
# 83 45 N<br />
106<br />
# # #<br />
96<br />
# 42<br />
# #<br />
W<br />
E<br />
56<br />
50<br />
#<br />
11 43<br />
S<br />
90 # #<br />
26<br />
#<br />
107 28<br />
16<br />
#<br />
#<br />
#<br />
#<br />
49 35<br />
#<br />
6 #<br />
18<br />
76<br />
65<br />
#<br />
#<br />
47<br />
# #<br />
#<br />
68<br />
# 103<br />
# 92<br />
48<br />
10<br />
4 #<br />
#<br />
33<br />
73<br />
#<br />
20 # 86 31<br />
#<br />
93<br />
#<br />
#<br />
58<br />
39<br />
78<br />
#<br />
# 24<br />
94<br />
ARON FLORIAN<br />
40<br />
#<br />
#<br />
8 #<br />
95<br />
# 61<br />
46<br />
1<br />
109110<br />
34<br />
# #<br />
# # 15<br />
#<br />
3<br />
#<br />
52<br />
108 62<br />
23<br />
#<br />
#<br />
#<br />
51 #<br />
63 17<br />
22 44<br />
# 14 54 # #<br />
#<br />
#<br />
#<br />
# 70<br />
72<br />
25 100<br />
#<br />
32<br />
#<br />
#<br />
# 7<br />
69<br />
104<br />
105 # 87 102<br />
# #<br />
# 36<br />
75<br />
#<br />
#<br />
79<br />
#<br />
#<br />
#<br />
55<br />
97 98<br />
#<br />
591<br />
13<br />
64<br />
# #<br />
9<br />
101<br />
#<br />
2 #<br />
#<br />
#<br />
#<br />
19<br />
#<br />
85<br />
#<br />
#<br />
71 88<br />
59 74<br />
ROBESCU F.C.<br />
# # #<br />
#<br />
99<br />
38<br />
57<br />
#<br />
ArcView GIS 3.2 - ESRI California<br />
Lungu & Arion, 2000<br />
80<br />
#<br />
#<br />
0.5 0 0.5 1 Kilometers<br />
# 60 53<br />
12 # 67<br />
UMOASA<br />
ZZAVILLAN LUIGI<br />
IGORE -Prof.<br />
LEMNEA<br />
MOXA MIHAIL<br />
AUR ORA<br />
DONA NICOLAE - General<br />
PROGRESULUI<br />
GRADINA CU CAI<br />
SCHITU MAGUREANU<br />
INDEPENDE NTEI<br />
VICTOR IEI<br />
KOGALNICEANU MIHAIL<br />
NATIUNILOR<br />
PUTIUL -CU-PLOPI<br />
AMMAN<br />
IORGA NICOLAE<br />
TOMESCU TOMA - Doctor<br />
SPIRU HARET<br />
SFINTUL SAVA<br />
B ANULUI<br />
LUTERANA<br />
DR.V.SIMION<br />
SIPOTUL FINTINILOR<br />
GUTEMBERG<br />
URSEANU VASILE - Ami ral<br />
N IC OLAE-IORGA<br />
IORGA NICOLA E<br />
RADU-ILIE<br />
VISARION<br />
CRISTIAN TELL -General<br />
BISERICA AMZEI<br />
BISERICA AMZEI<br />
BRE ZOIANU ION<br />
VIGILENTEI SAPIENTEI<br />
BRUTUS M I<br />
BREZOIANU ION<br />
MARCOVICI ALEXANDRU - Doctor<br />
ZALOMIT ION<br />
POLITIE<br />
ORIZONTUL<br />
PIATA-AMZEI<br />
CRETULE SCU NICOLAE<br />
VRACA GEORGE<br />
MIHA I-VODA<br />
ILFOV<br />
ADEREA BASTILIEI<br />
MENDE LEEV D. I.<br />
MATEI MILLO<br />
DOMNITA ANASTASIA<br />
LIPSCA NI<br />
E NESCU GEORGE<br />
EPISCOPIEI<br />
C-TIN-EXARCU<br />
MILLE CONSTA NTIN<br />
EFORIEI<br />
MIHAI VODA<br />
GOLESCU NICOLAE<br />
FRANK LIN BE NJANIM<br />
RIUREANU - Doctor<br />
GIURESCU DIMITRIE - Maior<br />
BELDIMAN ALEXA NDRU<br />
MAGHERU GH EORGHE - Gen.<br />
ROSETTI C.A.<br />
B OTEANU<br />
ARHITECTURII<br />
POSTEI<br />
URALI<br />
MECHELET<br />
DOBRESCU ION<br />
VICTORIA<br />
BIJUTERIEI<br />
CARADA EU GENIU<br />
STA VROPOLEOS<br />
FILITTI C. IO<br />
COMEDIA<br />
MAJES TIC<br />
DOROBANTI<br />
QU INET EDGAR<br />
MANDINESTI<br />
BROSTENI<br />
G-RAL-GH.MAGHERU<br />
13-DEC EMBRIE<br />
LIPSCANI<br />
30 D ECE<br />
EMINESCU MIHAI<br />
PICTOR-VERONA<br />
S ELARI<br />
CONTA VASILE<br />
SMIRDAN<br />
SLAVES TI<br />
GRIGORESCU<br />
ION NISTOR<br />
BALABAN EMIL - Inginer<br />
LUPU DIONISIE<br />
FILIPESCU NICOLAE<br />
BALCESCU NICOLAE<br />
GHICA ION<br />
ARGHEZI TUDOR<br />
DOAMNEI<br />
COVACI<br />
B LANA RI<br />
B ACAN I<br />
POLONA<br />
GABROVENI<br />
FILIPIDE ALEXANDRU<br />
SAHIA ALE X.(CALDERON JEAN L.)<br />
ICOANEI<br />
XENOPO L ALEXANDRU<br />
SCOALEI<br />
BLA NDUZIEI<br />
UNIVERSITATII<br />
B ATISTEI<br />
LIPSCANI<br />
REPUBLICII<br />
BRATIANU I.C.<br />
DUMBRAVA ROSIE<br />
SLANIC<br />
BARA<br />
COLTEI<br />
MAVROGHENI NICOLAE<br />
PA TRASCU VODA<br />
BANIEI<br />
RO SETTI C.A.<br />
IOANID GHE.-pi ctor<br />
LIPSCANI<br />
DIANEI<br />
DROBETA<br />
S FINTUL SPIRIDON<br />
CARAGIALE ION LUCA<br />
ITALIANA<br />
ROSETTI C.A .<br />
SAHIA ALEX.(CALDERON JEAN L.)<br />
TREI SCAUNE<br />
BAIA DE FIE R<br />
ION-Erou<br />
S CHITU DARVARI<br />
DACIA<br />
BOTEZ CORNELIU<br />
BACALOGU EMANOIL-doctor<br />
SF. VINER<br />
ITALIANA<br />
SPERA NTEI<br />
CAIMATEI<br />
LEON IDA<br />
ROSETTI MARIA<br />
SFINTILOR<br />
RUSSO ALECU<br />
ORBESCU DIMITRIE<br />
H.BOTEV<br />
STELEA SPATARUL<br />
SF.MINA<br />
DONICI ALE XANDRU<br />
SAGETII<br />
MOVILA ION<br />
LASC AR VASILE(FOSTA GALATI)<br />
A RCULUI<br />
ZBORULUI<br />
XANDRA<br />
COMANITA<br />
LUMINEI<br />
DONICI ALEXANDRU<br />
L UCA STROICI - L ogofat<br />
PALEOLOGU<br />
ICOANEI<br />
P OPA RUSU<br />
LOG.STROICI<br />
SE RGHIESCU MARIN<br />
ARMENEASCA<br />
CERNICA<br />
CALA RASI<br />
VERMONT - Pictor<br />
CULMEA VECHE<br />
CALOTESTI<br />
AR MENEASCA<br />
O COLULUI<br />
SEVCENCO TARAS<br />
PASULUI<br />
LATINA<br />
N EGU STORI<br />
PALEOLOGU<br />
LICURG<br />
COLUMB ELOR<br />
R ASURI<br />
PACIUREA DIMITRIE<br />
ROSETTI MARIA<br />
VIITORULUI<br />
FRANZELARILOR<br />
LUCHIAN STEFAN - Pictor<br />
MINTULEASA<br />
TOAMNEI<br />
IONE SCU CRISTEA<br />
VER I<br />
POPA SOARE<br />
UDRISTE LOG<strong>OF</strong>AT<br />
SSIMA - Profesor<br />
URSU ION -Prof.<br />
ARMONIEI<br />
SALCIMILOR<br />
S ILVESTRU<br />
SPATARULUI<br />
CERCULUI<br />
CORBENI<br />
DOMNESTI<br />
ROMANO - Pic tor<br />
ROMULUS<br />
RAMULUS<br />
TOPLICENI<br />
LUNII<br />
POPA PETRE<br />
ARDELE NI<br />
P RE CUPETII VECHI<br />
OLTARULUI<br />
VENEREI<br />
RACOVITA DIMITRIE<br />
M INTULESA<br />
PRISTOLULUI<br />
IULIU<br />
TIBANA<br />
MONUMENTULUI<br />
S UVENIR<br />
MALNAS<br />
PREPELITEI<br />
IPATESCU GRIGORE - General<br />
S FINTUL STEFAN<br />
BOBE ICA<br />
VALORII<br />
VIROAGEI<br />
PRE OT-VA SILE-LUCA CI<br />
LAB IRINT<br />
BASARA B MATEI<br />
COBILITEI<br />
ACELARI<br />
IERNII<br />
D RAGOS VODA<br />
ARGE S<br />
ZECE MESE<br />
SECUREI<br />
ONC IUL DIMITRIE<br />
OLARI<br />
PLANTELOR<br />
MIHAILEANU STEFAN<br />
ZEFIRULUI<br />
BURGH EL EA - Docto r<br />
FETITELOR<br />
ENERGIEI<br />
RUMEOARA<br />
REPUBLICII<br />
AVRAM IANCU<br />
CONSTA NTINESCU MITRITA - Pr of.<br />
General<br />
PESTERII<br />
CAV NIC<br />
RADU - Episcopul<br />
MIHAI BRAVU<br />
TRAIAN<br />
S TUPINEI<br />
MOSILO<br />
VASELO<br />
IANCU C<br />
P<br />
IAN CU CAV<br />
Figure 14. Central Bucharest area with buildings built prior to 1945 and identified as<br />
having high risk of collapse in case of a strong earthquake (M w 7.5)
Table 7. Buildings with more than 5 stories built before 1940 located on the two most<br />
important boulevards of central Bucharest and identified as having highest risk of collapse in<br />
case of strong (comparable to 1977) earthquake 8<br />
No<br />
Address<br />
Year of<br />
building<br />
construction<br />
Commercial<br />
occupancy of<br />
groundfloor<br />
Storeys<br />
No. of<br />
Apt.<br />
Total<br />
area<br />
sqm.<br />
Damages after the 1977<br />
earthquake in structural<br />
elements<br />
Repairing work after the<br />
1977 earthquake<br />
Gulkan<br />
Damage<br />
score<br />
1<br />
4<br />
Balcescu 24<br />
(Pherekide)<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
101<br />
A-B<br />
1928 Yes 13 61 12197<br />
1937 Yes 11 61 6111<br />
6 Magheru 20 1935 Yes 10 52 5484<br />
11 Magheru 27 1935 Yes 9.5 36 6405<br />
12<br />
16<br />
20<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
2-4<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
128A<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
112<br />
1928 Yes 9 76 12994<br />
1935 Yes 9 22 6675<br />
1939 Yes 9 27 5210<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
-<br />
-<br />
Light<br />
Light<br />
Light<br />
-<br />
-<br />
Light<br />
Medium<br />
-<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Jacketing of columns<br />
and beams<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections<br />
Mortar injections<br />
Finishes<br />
Jacketing of columns<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections<br />
Mortar injections<br />
100<br />
86<br />
11<br />
Jacketing of columns 14<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Jacketing of columns and<br />
beams<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Jacketing of 4 columns<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections<br />
29<br />
100<br />
100<br />
27<br />
30<br />
61<br />
65<br />
91<br />
92<br />
94<br />
95<br />
100<br />
104<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
208<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
139<br />
Balcescu 25<br />
(Wilson)<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
124<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
25<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
95<br />
Balcescu<br />
32-34<br />
Balcescu<br />
30<br />
Balcescu<br />
7<br />
Calea Victoriei<br />
33-35<br />
1940 Yes 8.5 44 5200<br />
1934 Yes 8 30 1290<br />
1928 Yes 12 93 12287<br />
1900 Yes 6.5 28 3045<br />
1936 Yes 13 49 6078<br />
1938 Yes 10.5 51 4010<br />
1935 Yes 10 41 6996<br />
1936 Yes 9.5 25 2756<br />
1933 Yes 7 15 2730<br />
1930 Yes 6.5 39 4800<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Columns:<br />
Beams :<br />
Masonry:<br />
Extreme<br />
Medium<br />
Extreme<br />
Light<br />
Light<br />
Medium<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
-<br />
-<br />
Light/<br />
Medium<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Extreme<br />
Light/<br />
Medium<br />
Light/<br />
Medium<br />
-<br />
Extreme<br />
-<br />
Medium<br />
Light<br />
Light<br />
Extreme<br />
Medium<br />
Medium<br />
Medium<br />
Jacketing of beams<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Jacketing of columns and<br />
beams<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections<br />
Mortar injections<br />
Finishes<br />
*partially collapsed in 1977<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
86<br />
29<br />
105<br />
37<br />
Jacketing of 6 columns<br />
Epoxy resins injections 100<br />
Jacketing of columns and<br />
beams 100<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
42.5<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections 64<br />
Finishes<br />
Masonry Repairs<br />
Epoxy resins injections 36<br />
Jacketing of columns<br />
Masonry Repairs 50<br />
* Classification of damage in 1977 follows vulnerability classes of HAZUS methodology, 1998, (see Lungu, D.,<br />
et al., 2000. Advanced Structural Analysis, Conspress, UTCB, 177p.);
Balcescu 24(Pherekide) Calea Victoriei 101 A-B Magheru 20<br />
Magheru 27 Calea Victoriei 2-4 Calea Victoriei 128A<br />
Calea Victoriei 112 Calea Victorie 208 Calea Victoriei 139<br />
Balcescu 25 (Wilson) Calea Victoriei 124 Calea Victoriei 25
Calea Victoriei 95 Balcescu 32-34 Balcescu 30<br />
Figure 15<br />
Seismic vulnerability class 1<br />
buildings on the most<br />
important two boulevards in<br />
central Bucharest<br />
Balcescu 7 Calea Victoriei 33-35<br />
The damage score for the fragile building structures from the list of 115 buildings in<br />
Bucharest was computed with a simplified version of the damage methodology proposed by<br />
Gulkan (1994), Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey.<br />
The calculation of damage score, SD for a building is based on the level of damage of<br />
the structural members at the most severely damaged story of the buildings (usually the<br />
groundfloor). The damage level of structural member is classified as follows:<br />
No damage MD score = 0 Moderate damage MD score = 2<br />
Light damage MD score = 1 Extreme damage MD score = 4.<br />
The importance factor for structural elements, is selected as follows (Gulkan, 1994):<br />
Columns =2; Beams =1; Infill masonry =0.5.<br />
The building structure damage score, SD can be computed as follows:<br />
SD =<br />
( MD) columns<br />
+ ( MD) beams<br />
+ ( MD)<br />
4 ( ) + ( ) + ( )<br />
[ ]<br />
columns<br />
beams<br />
inf ills<br />
inf ills<br />
100<br />
SD varies from 0 to 100. The vulnerability classes can be selected based on SD score.<br />
The simple criteria might confirm the hierarchy of actual vulnerability of the fragile<br />
buildings in Bucharest in the case of a strong earthquake:<br />
(i) Presence of visible damage after the 1977 earthquake as well as the presence of<br />
visible local repairing made after that earthquake;
(ii) Presence of the soft ground floor due to commercial use of that floor (no<br />
infilled masonry walls);<br />
(iii) Number of storeys of building (taller the building, higher the risk);<br />
(iv) Lack of vertical and horizontal symmetry of the building (setbacks,<br />
asymmetrical architecture of the corner buildings)<br />
as well as unintended local structural damage due to occupancy changes and activities,<br />
corrosion of the reinforcement, low strength concrete (mean compressive strength 100-200<br />
daN/cm 2 ). etc.<br />
Table 5 and Figure 14 give the characteristics and the photos of 17 buildings seismic<br />
vulnerability class 1 located on the two most important boulevards of Bucharest. All of them<br />
were built before WWII (1940).<br />
Seismic "risk class” in present Romanian seismic code (P100-92) is actually seismic<br />
vulnerability class!<br />
That is why the seismic risk matrix presented in Table 8 should be used for the<br />
classification of actual seismic risk of vulnerable buildings in Romania.<br />
Table 8. Seismic risk classes<br />
Seismic<br />
Vulnerability/or I<br />
fragility Essential<br />
class<br />
facilities<br />
Importance and exposure class<br />
II<br />
Hazardous buildings<br />
III<br />
General buildings<br />
IV<br />
Minor buildings<br />
1 1 1 1&2 3<br />
2 1&2 2 3 3<br />
3 3<br />
Recently (Dec 2002/Jan 2003), 42 pre-1977 buildings built during the time interval<br />
1945- 1977 were included into the most dangerous seismic vulnerability class 1 buildings in<br />
Bucharest, Table 9 and Figure 16.<br />
They are tall RC buildings characterised by soft groundfloor located on soft soil<br />
condition of Bucharest city.<br />
Table 9. Fragile tall RC buildings having flexible groundfloor, built prior to 1977 earthquake<br />
in Bucharest<br />
No. Name of street<br />
No. of<br />
buildings<br />
No. of stories Address of buildings<br />
1<br />
Calea Grivitei<br />
18<br />
B * +GF+ (7......12)S No. 3-5, 134, 139, 148,<br />
156, 158, 163, 164, 169,<br />
196, 198, 200, 206, 236,<br />
2<br />
Stefan cel Mare<br />
11<br />
238, 395, 398, 399<br />
B+GF+ (6...8)S No. 5, 15. 17, 27, 28, 31,<br />
33, 40, 42, 128, 188<br />
3 Bd. Mihalache (1 Mai) 4 B+GF+(8...10)S No. 170, 172, 174, 399<br />
4 Gara de Nord 3 B+GF+8S No. 2-4, 6-8, no.2 Piata<br />
5 Dinicu Golescu Bd., 1 B+GF+9S No. 23-25<br />
6 Piata Chibrit –C 1 B+GF+8S<br />
7 Piata Amzei 1 B+GF+7S No. 12-22<br />
8 Bd. N. Balcescu 1 B+GF+9S No. 33<br />
Dorobanti/Stefan cel Mare<br />
B+GF+12S<br />
Blocul Perla<br />
9<br />
1<br />
corner<br />
10 Sos. Mihai Bravu, 1 B+GF+8S No. 107-119<br />
* B – basement. GF – groundfloors, S - stories
Figure 16. Fragile tall RC buildings having flexible groundfloor, built<br />
prior to 1977 earthquake in Bucharest<br />
Table10. List of cities with hospital buildings requiring strengthening work<br />
City<br />
Number of hospitals buildings<br />
Severely damaged. Having a Approved<br />
Requiring immediate technical project for<br />
technical assessment report retrofitting<br />
Retrofitting in<br />
work<br />
Bacau 3<br />
Bucharest 13 16 6 10<br />
Buzau 9<br />
Constanta 7<br />
Craiova 4<br />
Focsani 2<br />
Galati 6 2 1<br />
Giurgiu 1<br />
Iasi 21 17 2 5<br />
Pitesti 2 7<br />
Ploiesti 2<br />
Sibiu 1<br />
Targu-<br />
2<br />
Mures<br />
Vaslui 4 1<br />
Barlad 2
Table 11<br />
Churches damaged by major historical earthquakes in Bucharest<br />
No. Name Address 1802<br />
event<br />
Level of damage<br />
1838 1940<br />
event event<br />
1977<br />
event<br />
1 Manastirea Plumbuita, “de<br />
la Podul Colentinei”<br />
2<br />
Manastirea Marcuta<br />
3 Doamnei (fosta manastire)<br />
4<br />
5<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
Sf. Gheorghe-Nou<br />
Manastirea Antim<br />
Sf. Elefterie-Vechi<br />
Oborul-Vechi<br />
Sf. Pantelimon<br />
Popa Rusu<br />
Precupetii Noi<br />
Doamna Ghica-Tei<br />
12 Manastirea<br />
Sf. Spiridon-Nou<br />
13<br />
Sf, Nicolae Tabacu<br />
14 Sf. Nicolae-Selari<br />
15<br />
Sf. Mina (Vergului)<br />
16 Herastrau-Sfintii Apostoli<br />
Petru si Pavel<br />
17<br />
18<br />
Dobroteasa<br />
Amzei<br />
19 Biserica si Scoala<br />
Sf. Silvestru<br />
20<br />
Boteanu (cu Bradu)<br />
21 Popa Nan<br />
Str. Plumbuita 58<br />
Str. Gentianei din Sos. Pantelimon<br />
Intr. Bis. Doamnei 3,<br />
Calea Victoriei 28<br />
Bd. Bratianu 27<br />
Str. Mitropolitul Antim Ivireanu 29<br />
severe<br />
severe<br />
medium<br />
light<br />
medium<br />
Str. Sf. Elefterie 15C medium medium<br />
Str. Traian 204 medium medium<br />
Str. Iancu Capitanu 24<br />
Str. Popa Rusu 13-17<br />
Str. G-ral Ernest Brosteanu 12<br />
Str. Doamna Ghica 2<br />
Calea Serban Voda 29<br />
medium<br />
severe<br />
medium<br />
medium<br />
medium<br />
Calea Victoriei 180 medium medium<br />
Str. Blanari 16 /<br />
Intr. Selari<br />
Str. C. F. Robescu 18A<br />
Str. Nicolae Caranfil 28<br />
Bd. Mircea – Voda 35B<br />
collapse<br />
medium<br />
medium<br />
medium<br />
Str. Biserica Amzei 12 light medium<br />
Str. Silvestru 36<br />
medium<br />
Str. Boteanu 8 medium severe<br />
Str. Popa Nan 47 bis si<br />
Str. Gh. Costa-Foru 5<br />
severe<br />
severe<br />
22 Sfantul Apostol Andrei-<br />
Chitila II<br />
Sos. Chitilei 138<br />
severe<br />
23 Aparatorii Patriei II Str. Lunca Barzesti 3 medium
Hospitals requiring technical assessment and retrofitting works (design, construction,<br />
financing) in various Romanian counties are listed in Figure 17 and Table 10.<br />
Various orthodox churches damaged by major historical earthquake in Bucharest are<br />
listed in Table 11 and in Figure18.<br />
Figure 17<br />
Figure 18
There is a certitude that, for about 50 years recurrence interval Vrancea earthquake,<br />
several dozens of pre-WWII tall RC buildings in Bucharest will collapse (there are about 60-<br />
100 pers/bldg). More than half of those buildings and several pre - 1977, framed RC<br />
structures in are already identified by licensed experts as “seismic risk class 1” buildings.<br />
The governmental action of identification of dangerous buildings in Romania started<br />
in 1994.<br />
In 2001, a new Government Order stated that the Government will 100% advance the<br />
necessary payment, for strengthening of the buildings, to the private owners of apartments in<br />
“seismic risk class 1” buildings (more than 95%of housing units are private in Romania!).<br />
If the owner salary is less then national average, he have to pay back(to the state) nothing. If it<br />
is not, he has to pay the money back in 25 years, with 5% interest.<br />
Anyway, the owner has to agree on the strengthening of its apartment, in case he has<br />
to leave the housing unit during the construction work.<br />
Of course, the owners do not like leaving and the necessity buildings for temporary housing<br />
during strengthening are not yet implemented.<br />
Moreover, if one apartment owner does not like/agree on strengthening of its<br />
apartment, the strengthening of the whole building can not be done!!!<br />
There is a promise of the Ministry of Public Works, during a May, 2003 Seminar, for<br />
promoting a new official act which will make compulsory the strengthening of the building<br />
structure if the majority of private owners will accept the strengthening(in spite of several<br />
owners who would not like to allow strengthening of their apartments).<br />
Distribution per counties of residential buildings, hospital buildings and school<br />
buildings, requiring strengthening/retrofitting works in Romania is presented in Figure 19.<br />
Present stage of construction work of the first 8 buildings under<br />
retrofitting/strengthening in Bucharest is given in Table 12.<br />
Table 12.<br />
Building 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8<br />
Total area<br />
(sqm)<br />
6050 1831 1615 1750 12313 2013 3706 2271<br />
Height B+GF+8S B+GF+6S B+GF+6S B+GF+6S B+GF+11S B+GF+5S B+GF+8S B+GF+5S<br />
1 ) Present stage of retrofitting work, 20÷70%;<br />
2) Cost of structure strengthening 50 - 150€/ sqm,<br />
3) Duration of construction, 8÷12 month<br />
Figure 19
Seismic instrumentation of Romania and Bucharest<br />
Based on deep recognizance of the extraordinary importance of seismic records for<br />
understanding of the strong motion characteristics, Romania installed in the last 2 years about<br />
50 digital K2 and ETNA, Kinemetrics instruments.<br />
The present seismic instrumentation of Romania is summarized in Table 13 and in the<br />
maps in Figure 20.<br />
Table 13. Seismic networks of Romania, 2003<br />
New digital networks,<br />
installed in 2003<br />
Existing seismic<br />
networks, in 2002<br />
Name of network<br />
INCERC & ISC, State<br />
Inspectorate for<br />
Construction<br />
CNRRS & JICA, Japan<br />
International<br />
Cooperation Agency<br />
Project 1<br />
INCERC<br />
INFP/SFB 461 German<br />
Science Foundation<br />
Project at University of<br />
Karlsruhe<br />
Bucharest<br />
7 ETNA 31 ETNA<br />
11 K2<br />
21 instruments:<br />
-10 SMA-1 (analog)<br />
-9 ADS (digital)<br />
-2 digital stations for<br />
continuous monitoring<br />
15 K2 41 K2<br />
Romania<br />
(including Bucharest)<br />
16 instruments:<br />
-11 K2;<br />
- 5 ETNA<br />
70 instruments:<br />
-58 SMA-1(analog)<br />
-9 ADS (digital)<br />
3 digital station for<br />
continuous monitoring<br />
TOTAL 54 digital instruments 158 instruments<br />
100 digital<br />
1) UTCB & INCERC are partner institutions with CNRRS.<br />
Figure 20
The table indicates 100 Kinemetrics digital instruments in Romania, 54 in Bucharest, as<br />
well as more than 100 instruments in INCERC seismic network, (45 digital) and 41 Kinemetrics<br />
digital instruments in the joint seismic network of SFB 461- Project on Vrancea earthquakes at<br />
Karlsruhe University, and INFP, National Institute for Earth Physics, Bucharest.<br />
The Japan-Romanian Project on Seismic Risk Reduction in Romania, implemented by<br />
JICA & CNRRS in partnership with UTCB & INCERC, installed in 2003 16 instruments in<br />
Romania i.e.:<br />
(i) 7 K2 stations at 7 locations in Bucharest, each with 3 sensors: 1 free field and 2 in<br />
deep boreholes (-30.0 m ÷ -180.0 m);<br />
(ii) 5 ETNA accelerometers outside Bucharest;<br />
(iii) 4 K2 station in four significant buildings in Bucharest.<br />
In addition to the Romanian-Japanese and Romanian-German seismic cooperation<br />
projects, State Inspectorate for Construction of Romania provided 31 ETNA Kinemetrics digital<br />
instruments, which are operated by INCERC in partnership with ISC (10 instruments, still to be<br />
installed).<br />
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT<br />
We would like acknowledge our deep gratitude to:<br />
- ISC, State Inspectorate for Construction, Romania;<br />
- JICA, Japan International Cooperation Agency and<br />
- UTCB, Technical University for Civil Engineering Bucharest and CNRRS,<br />
National Centre for Seismic Risk Reduction joint instrumentation team,<br />
- INCERC seismic network laboratory,<br />
- SFB 461- Project on Vrancea Earthquake at Karlsruhe University<br />
for their sustained efforts during years to complete the present stage of digital seismic<br />
instrumentation of Romania and Bucharest.
REFERENCES<br />
ASCE 7-98, 2000. ASCE Standard: Minimum design loads for buildings and other structures. American Society<br />
of Civil Engineers, New-York, ASCE, SEI<br />
Bolt B., (1995), Earthquakes, W.H. Freeman and Company, New York, 331 p.<br />
Coburn, A., Spence, R., (1992), Earthquake protection, John Wiley & Sons., New York, 355p.<br />
Constantinescu, L, Marza, V., (1980), A computer-compiled and computer-oriented catalogue of Romania’s<br />
earthquakes during a millenium (984-1979), Géophysique, Tome 24, No2, Bucharest, p.193-206.<br />
Elnashai A., Lungu D., 1995. Zonation as a tool for retrofit and design of new facilities. Report of the Session<br />
A.1.2. 5th International Conference on Seismic Zonation, Nice, France, Oct. 16-19, Proceedings Vol.3,<br />
Ouest Editions, Preses Academiques, p.2057-2082.<br />
Eurocode 8 - Design provisions for earthquake resistance of structures, 1994. Part 1-1: General rules - Seismic<br />
actions and general requirements for structures. CEN, European Committee for Standardization, Oct.<br />
Hwang H.H.M., Huo J.R., 1994. Generation of hazard-consistent fragility curves for seismic loss estimation<br />
studies. Technical Report NCEER-94-0015. National Center for Earthquake Engineering Research,<br />
State University of New York at Buffalo, Aug.<br />
Lungu D., Aldea A., Arion, C., Demetriu S.,Cornea T., 2000. Microzonage Sismique de la ville de Bucarest -<br />
Roumanie, Cahier Technique de l’Association Française du Génie Parasismique, No.20, p.31-63<br />
Lungu, D., Vacareanu, R., Aldea, A., Arion, C., 2000. Advanced Structural Analysis, Conspress, UTCB, 177p.<br />
Lungu, D., Arion, C., Baur, M., Aldea, A., 2000. Vulnerability of existing building stock in Bucharest, 6ICSZ Sixth<br />
International Conference on Seismic Zonation, Palm Springs, California, USA, Nov.12-15, p.837-846<br />
Lungu, D., Aldea, A., Arion, C., 2000. "Engineering, state & insurance efforts for reduction of seismic risk in<br />
Romania" In: Proceedings of the 12th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Auckland, New<br />
Zealand, Jan/Feb.<br />
Lungu D., 1999. Seismic hazard and countermeasures in Bucharest-Romania, Bulletin of the International<br />
Institute of Seismology and Earthquake Engineering IISEE, Tsukuba, Japan, Vol.33, p.341- 373.<br />
Lungu, D. & Aldea, A., 1999. Understanding Urban Risk Around the World. United Nations RADIUS Project at<br />
Geohazards Int., Ca., USA. Document City of Bucharest Seismic Profile, 29p.+25p.+8p.<br />
Lungu, D., Arion, C., Aldea, A., Demetriu, S., 1999, “Assessment of seismic hazard in Romania based on 25 years<br />
of strong ground motion instrumentation”, NATO ARW Conference on strong motion instrumentation for<br />
civil engineering structures, Istanbul, Turkey, June 2-5, 1999.<br />
Lungu, D., Aldea, A., Arion, C., Cornea, T., 1998. "Seismic hazard zonation in Eastern Europe", Second<br />
International Conference on Earthquake Hazard and Seismic Risk Reduction, September 15-21,<br />
Yerevan, Armenia , Kluwer Academic Publisher, 2000, p281-289.<br />
Lungu, D., Demetriu, S., Arion, C. 1998. Seismic vulnerability of buildings exposed to Vrancea earthquakes in<br />
Romania. In Vrancea Earthquakes. Tectonics, Hazard and Risk Mitigation, Kluwer Academic Publishers,<br />
Wenzel F., Lungu D., editors, Proc. of First International Workshop on Vrancea Earthquakes, p.215-224.<br />
Lungu D., Cornea T., Nedelcu C., 1998. Probabilistic hazard assessment and site-dependent response for<br />
Vrancea earthquakes. In Vrancea Earthquakes. Tectonics, Hazard and Risk Mitigation, Kluwer<br />
Academic publishers b.v., Wenzel F., Lungu D., editors, p.251-268<br />
Marza, V.I., Kijko, A., Mäntyniemi, P., (1991), Estimate of earthquake hazard in the Vrancea (Romania) region,<br />
Pageoph, Vol.136, No.1, Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel, p.143-154.<br />
Munich Re, 1998. World Map of Natural Hazards<br />
Radu C. manuscripts, 1994. Catalogues of earthquakes occurred on Romanian territory during the periods 984-<br />
1990 and 1901-1994.<br />
Zanfir A., 2000. Assessment of damage buildings (Master thesis, in Romanian), UTCB, 75p.<br />
Wells D.L., Coppersmith K.J., 1994. New empirical relations among magnitude, rupture length, rupture width,<br />
rupture area, and surface displacement. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, Vol.84, No 4,<br />
p. 974-1002.<br />
Cornea T., Vacareanu R. and Lungu D., 2000 Technical Report for Collaborative Research Center (CRC)<br />
461 of SFB, Germany: “Strong Earthquakes: A Challenge for Geosciences and Civil Engineering”, Karlsruhe<br />
University, 64 p.<br />
HAZUS – Technical Manual 1997. Earthquake Loss Estimation Methodology, 3 Vol.<br />
Newmark, N. M., and Hall, W. J. (1982). Earthquake Spectra and Design. Berkeley, Calif. Earthquake<br />
Engineering Research Inst.<br />
V]c]reanu R., Cornea T., Lungu D. Evaluation of seismic fragility of buildings, Earthquake Hazard and<br />
Countermeasures for Existing Fragile Buildings, Editors: Lungu D. & Saito T., Independent Film, Bucharest<br />
Romania.