23.03.2015 Views

RSA RETAIL RESEARCH PAPER2 WEB HR.pdf

RSA RETAIL RESEARCH PAPER2 WEB HR.pdf

RSA RETAIL RESEARCH PAPER2 WEB HR.pdf

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

PAPER 2:<br />

THE POWER OF<br />

THE CONSUMER


<strong>RSA</strong>: THE <strong>RETAIL</strong> SERIES –<br />

THE POWER OF THE CONSUMER<br />

We have spent time over the last 18 months developing our<br />

understanding of what Retailers want and the issues they face. We<br />

know the Retail market is forever changing and we are committed<br />

to working with our Retail customers and brokers to continuously<br />

understand their changing needs.<br />

This paper is the second in a series of short papers dedicated to<br />

what we believe are some of the most important challenges and<br />

opportunities facing Retailers.<br />

We hope that you will fi nd it useful and that it will provoke ideas<br />

for your business.<br />

This paper focuses on the Power of the Consumer and has<br />

been produced by <strong>RSA</strong> Global Europe in conjunction with Retail<br />

customers, brokers, experts and researchers in the fi elds covered.<br />

Look out for the next Retail Research Papers on:<br />

• Sustainability Challenges for Retailers<br />

• The Future of Retailing<br />

• <strong>RSA</strong> and Retail Insurance<br />

We hope you will fi nd this series of papers interesting and, as ever,<br />

we would welcome any feedback you have or suggestions for<br />

topics you would like covered in the future.<br />

If you would like to contact us about these Retail Research<br />

papers then please email: smc.europe@uk.rsagroup.com.<br />

C<strong>HR</strong>IS SMITH<br />

Written with the support of Liz Machtynger of Customer Essential.


THE POWER<br />

OF THE CONSUMER<br />

UNDERSTANDING THE CONSUMER IS AN<br />

ONGOING JOURNEY FOR US ALL.<br />

Many external factors lead to changes in consumer behaviour,<br />

meaning research papers and journals from a year ago rarely<br />

scratch the surface of the Retailing challenges of today. This paper<br />

is drawn from a number of recent sources and papers particularly<br />

focused on the European marketplace.<br />

The paper is split into the following fi ve themes:<br />

1. The world is getting smaller<br />

2. The changing face of our consumer population<br />

3. Economic challenges and the impact on consumers<br />

4. Do consumers really care where they buy?<br />

5. Which Retailers are consumers voting for?<br />

A SNAPSHOT OF THE CHANGING CONSUMER<br />

There have been some major changes over the past fi ve years that<br />

have led to a different set of consuming habits worldwide:<br />

• The population has seen a shift in the shape of family units<br />

and a move to more urban living.<br />

• People are living much longer than before, in particular<br />

in Europe.<br />

• Females are playing a much more important role and have<br />

more fi nancial control than ever before.<br />

• The fi nancial situation is volatile worldwide and across Europe.<br />

These pressures are having a direct impact on the way that<br />

consumers are spending on basic necessities and is reducing any<br />

discretionary spend they may have.<br />

• Consumers choose to buy from Retailers based upon their own<br />

priorities. Their priorities are more strongly focused than ever<br />

before on ‘value for money’ and ‘quality’ of their purchases.<br />

• Retailers wishing to hold on to their consumer base need to<br />

work hard to build trust and deliver consistently across the<br />

channels they operate in.<br />

• Consumers are more demanding in both product selection and<br />

service delivery. It is of paramount importance, therefore, that<br />

Retailers stay connected with their consumers to keep on top<br />

of their priorities.<br />

The power of the consumer to change the way they spend and<br />

the way they communicate with others about their purchases has<br />

never been clearer.<br />

“Today the consumer has power like never before. Facilitated<br />

by technology, the humble shopper can reach an audience of<br />

thousands – or even millions – to praise, complain or merely<br />

muse about the service or products they get from Retailers.<br />

For the Retailer this makes brand reputation a challenge.<br />

Indeed, such is the power of consumers that a Retail brand<br />

is no longer what a Retailer says it is, it’s defi ned by what<br />

consumers feel and say about it. Naturally, all of this means<br />

speed of response, appropriateness of response and visibility<br />

of response are now critical.<br />

Across most of the Western world Retail is a mature business,<br />

and like most mature businesses that means it is competitive.<br />

This ultimately gives the consumer choice. In recent years,<br />

thanks to the Internet, this choice has been expanded beyond<br />

national boundaries and shoppers can use Retailers from<br />

around the world. With choice comes power. It is easier than<br />

ever to punish Retailers that get it wrong by simply taking<br />

custom elsewhere. The result is that all have had to up their<br />

game, become more nimble and reinvent their organisations<br />

to be truly customer centric.”<br />

Neil Saunders<br />

Managing Director of Conlumino Retail experts


THE WORLD IS GETTING SMALLER –<br />

WHO IS OUR CONSUMER?<br />

AN INTERESTING QUESTION...<br />

The world’s population has reached more than 7 billion, meaning<br />

we are increasingly getting closer in distance, and as consumers,<br />

technology and travel are making change move even faster.<br />

Ref. Google – World Population<br />

The number of households is growing, in some countries more<br />

rapidly than others, mainly due to emigration and changes in the<br />

typical size of family units (outlined later).<br />

NUMBER OF HOUSEHOLDS IN WESTERN EUROPE IN 000S.<br />

UK<br />

Turkey<br />

Switzerland<br />

Sweden<br />

Spain<br />

Portugal<br />

Norway<br />

Netherlands<br />

Italy<br />

Ireland<br />

Greece<br />

Germany<br />

France<br />

Finland<br />

Denmark<br />

Belgium<br />

Austria<br />

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000<br />

1990<br />

2010<br />

Ref. European marketing statistics Euromonitor.<br />

Typical habits and consuming trends are becoming more global<br />

as we see Retailers growing their presence in multiple countries<br />

and the media opens up the world to sharing. We know, however<br />

that there are still some substantial differences in the way that<br />

consumers behave between continents and countries, and even<br />

regions within countries. History and culture play a role in driving<br />

some of these differences through religion, beliefs and language.<br />

For the consumer, a trip to another country usually still offers<br />

a different experience or set of products, even though the<br />

differences are much less pronounced than they were 10 years ago<br />

or more.<br />

Local stores have maintained more of this difference than those in<br />

the high streets or main streets across Europe, where international<br />

brands have become the norm.<br />

Consumers across Europe often buy online, particularly in the UK,<br />

Germany and France in Western Europe, and growing in Eastern<br />

Europe, specifi cally Russia, Poland and the Czech Republic. These<br />

purchases are often from international Retailers.<br />

2010 INTERNET SALES $US BILLION<br />

UK<br />

Turkey<br />

Switzerland<br />

Sweden<br />

Spain<br />

Portugal<br />

Norway<br />

Netherlands<br />

Luxembourg<br />

Italy<br />

Ireland<br />

Greece<br />

Germany<br />

France<br />

Finland<br />

Denmark<br />

Belgium<br />

Austria<br />

TO SUMMARISE…<br />

0 10 20 30 40<br />

$US BILLION<br />

Ref. European marketing statistics Euromonitor.<br />

• Global consumers are becoming more alike with a big increase<br />

in buying via the Internet.<br />

• Niche and local businesses are retaining some cultural and<br />

personalised strengths that consumers welcome.


THE CHANGING FACE<br />

OF OUR POPULATION<br />

There have been some signifi cant changes in our world population<br />

over the past 5 – 10 years – too many to talk about in detail. There<br />

are some highlights that have already had a real affect on the<br />

consumer and the way in which Retail operates today.<br />

A ‘FAMILY’ IS NOT WHAT IT USED TO BE<br />

• On average approx. 30% or more of households in Europe have<br />

only one person living in them.<br />

• Almost 8% of households in the UK and France, 5% in Germany<br />

are single parent.<br />

• 41% of households in the UK have a female head.<br />

• 43% of households are headed by someone who is 60 years of<br />

age or more.<br />

• In Turkey 20% of heads of household are less than 29 years<br />

of age.<br />

Ref. Euromonitor 2012<br />

WE ARE LIVING IN CITIES MORE<br />

There are clear differences across Europe in the balance between<br />

city and rural dwellings, but the trends are moving towards<br />

urban living.<br />

URBAN RURAL SPLIT EXAMPLES:<br />

UK:<br />

90.1%<br />

9.9%<br />

URBAN<br />

RURAL<br />

FRANCE:<br />

79.3%<br />

URBAN<br />

20.7%<br />

RURAL<br />

Ref. Euromonitor 2012<br />

This shift is making the urban Retail arena more interesting, and<br />

Retailers are investing in stores in the more urban locations. Retail<br />

real estate in prime locations is in demand.


CULTURES ARE MIXED UP<br />

There has been a surge in migration activity in the past 10 years,<br />

with the ability to travel and work across the EU. This has meant<br />

that many countries have changed in cultural mix. This has brought<br />

many opportunities and challenges for countries across Europe.<br />

CITIES WITH 100,000 OR MORE FOREIGN-BORN RESIDENTS<br />

Ref. MPI


‘LIFELONG’ IS FOR LONGER<br />

Improvements in healthcare mean that people are living longer,<br />

which also means that they are consuming for longer. People are<br />

also more dependent on their pensions and public sector support<br />

later in life.<br />

There is a marked age difference with some other parts of<br />

the world:<br />

The median age in Europe is 40+<br />

The median age in Africa is 20+<br />

EUROPE IS MORE FEMALE<br />

Most countries in Europe have more women than men by one<br />

or two percentage points. Turkey, Cyprus, Iceland, Albania, and<br />

Macedonia have a slightly higher percentage of males.<br />

And women have a higher life expectancy than men overall.<br />

TO SUMMARISE…<br />

• Families are now all different shapes and sizes with the<br />

extended family unit often broken up.<br />

• People are living more in urban environments and moving<br />

across country borders.<br />

• People are living longer across Europe, much longer than Africa<br />

or South America.<br />

• Europe is more female.<br />

Ref. Google


ECONOMIC CHALLENGES AND<br />

CONSUMER CONFIDENCE<br />

CONSUMERS HAVE HAD TO RETHINK THEIR FINANCES<br />

The economic stresses of this century, so far, have changed the<br />

world forever and have had a massive impact on consuming<br />

habits. Consumers have experienced a credit crunch, recession<br />

and practical collapse of the fi nancial system. The Euro has come<br />

under great pressure as a result and there may still be more<br />

economic turmoil across Europe. Some countries such as Greece<br />

and Spain are struggling to turnaround major defi cits. This has had<br />

a major impact on the day to day lives of the inhabitants of those<br />

countries. Consumers have seen rising bills, rising taxation, rising<br />

unemployment and reductions in public services.<br />

For many of the countries across Europe, Retail prices have either<br />

been reducing or going up only steadily. In the UK and Germany,<br />

prices have begun to go up on core products.<br />

For Retailers across Europe, there have been visible changes to<br />

sales volumes with, on the whole, steady declines.<br />

<strong>RETAIL</strong> SALES 2009 – 2010<br />

% Growth PA<br />

10%<br />

5%<br />

0%<br />

-5%<br />

-10%<br />

-15%<br />

-20%<br />

Russia<br />

Luxembourg<br />

Poland<br />

Sweden<br />

Turkey<br />

Austria<br />

France<br />

UK<br />

Switzerland<br />

Norway<br />

Finland<br />

Belgium<br />

Italy<br />

Eurozone<br />

Germany<br />

Portugal<br />

Czech Republic<br />

Denmark<br />

Netherlands<br />

Hungary<br />

Ireland<br />

Spain<br />

Slovenia<br />

Slovakia<br />

Bulgaria<br />

Romania<br />

Greece<br />

Estonia<br />

Lithuania<br />

Latvia<br />

Ref. Cushman & Wakefi eld, Oxford Economics<br />

According to the statistics, previous recessions have seen food<br />

category sales least affected; this time round this category has also<br />

seen an impact, showing how tough things have been<br />

for consumers.<br />

Consumers once trusted fi nancial institutions almost above all<br />

others. This trust has vanished and there is widespread distrust of<br />

fi nancial institutions in general. There is also now less willingness<br />

or ability to invest for the future. There are major concerns as we<br />

write this for further recession and for further impacts of defi cit<br />

in the Euro.<br />

POVERTY IS A GROWING ISSUE WORLDWIDE<br />

Nearly half of the world (48%) lives in poverty.<br />

Poverty is pronounced deprivation in well-being, and comprises<br />

many dimensions. It includes low incomes and the inability to<br />

acquire the basic goods and services necessary for survival<br />

with dignity. Poverty also encompasses low levels of health and<br />

education, poor access to clean water and sanitation, inadequate<br />

physical security, lack of voice, and insuffi cient capacity and<br />

opportunity to better one’s life.<br />

World Bank[5]<br />

The poorest countries are growing at the quickest rate. This makes<br />

a large shift away from poverty very diffi cult.<br />

POPULATION CLOCK 2011<br />

World<br />

More Developed<br />

Countries<br />

Less Developed<br />

Countries<br />

Population 6,986,951,000 1,241,580,000 5,745,371,000<br />

Births per Year 139,558,000 14,070,000 125,488,000<br />

Day 382,351 38,548 343,803<br />

Minute 266 27 239<br />

Deaths per Year 56,611,000 12,201,000 44,410,000<br />

Day 155,099 33,427 121,671<br />

Minute 108 23 84<br />

Natural increase<br />

Natural increase<br />

Year 82,947,000 1,869,000 81,078,000<br />

(births-deaths)per Day 227,252 5,121 222,132<br />

Minute 158 4 154<br />

Infant deaths per Year 6,078,000 77,000 6,001,000<br />

Day 16,652 211 16,441<br />

Minute 12 0.1 11<br />

Ref. Population reference bureau<br />

Some areas within Europe are also poor and getting poorer as the<br />

economic situation worsens.<br />

SPENDING POWER HAS BECOME MORE FEMALE<br />

Spending power for females has increased, although in many cases<br />

there is still a difference in earnings with male counterparts.<br />

Some examples within Europe:<br />

• In Switzerland 61% of females are economically active vs<br />

74% of males.<br />

• In comparison, in Iraq only 14% of females are economically<br />

active vs 19% of males.


YOUNG PEOPLE ARE STRUGGLING TO GET<br />

ON THE LADDER<br />

Younger people are struggling to get their feet on the work ladder<br />

and this is having an impact on debt levels for this age group.<br />

COUNTRIES WITH THE YOUNGEST AND OLDEST<br />

POPULATIONS 2011<br />

YOUNGEST % AGES


DO CONSUMERS REALLY<br />

CARE WHERE THEY BUY?<br />

WE TALK ABOUT ‘THE CONSUMER’, HOWEVER,<br />

IT IS MUCH MORE COMPLEX THAN THAT.<br />

Consumers have varying needs and wants at different times and<br />

depending on how and why they are purchasing. However, there<br />

are some trends that can be clearly seen from various research<br />

papers and individual Retailer successes or failures. These are<br />

forming invaluable reference points for the development of the<br />

Retail proposition.<br />

WILL THEY DELIVER VALUE FOR MONEY?<br />

Consumers have always ranked value for their money pretty highly<br />

in research surveys for Retailers, now it is a clear winner for many.<br />

All indications are that consumers with disposable income are<br />

making much more serious decisions about where they spend<br />

it. ‘The basics’ are coming fi rst for product purchases, and many<br />

‘value’ brands are going from strength to strength as a result. Those<br />

endeavouring to show that they have ‘best prices’ or ‘best packages’<br />

or ‘added value’ are picking up more regular consumers.<br />

But it is not all about having the cheapest price.<br />

A survey of 2,210 UK consumers conducted by Retail Eyes has<br />

found that less than one in fi ve people (17 per cent) intend to<br />

make purchasing decisions based on the lowest possible price.<br />

Tim Ogle, CEO of Retail Eyes, says that rock bottom pricing is<br />

not necessarily the best way to attract, and retain, customers.<br />

“Our research has shown that 83% of shoppers are looking for<br />

added value for their money. Obviously with their margins being<br />

squeezed by rising costs, Retailers need to fi nd cost effective<br />

ways to add value – one of which is through exceptional<br />

customer service”.<br />

Ref. Retail Eyes Jan 2011<br />

Dealing and negotiating are absolutely on the agenda for the<br />

consumer today. With increasing price comparison possibilities<br />

through the use of the web, and encouragement from the media<br />

and social media, consumers are becoming more courageous. In<br />

some countries, consumers now see the face-to-face Retail store<br />

as a way of bringing out their bargaining power. Some Retail brands<br />

are encouraging this further with ‘money back guarantees’ where<br />

lower prices can be found.<br />

The categories customers are spending on are changing too,<br />

refl ecting the more diffi cult fi nancial situations that consumers fi nd<br />

themselves in. Consumers are spending much more on things they<br />

need rather than things they want.<br />

CAN I JUSTIFY THIS PURCHASE?<br />

For a number of years there has been growing spending on ‘luxury’<br />

items, or things that consumers want e.g. the new iPhone or iPad,<br />

the expensive car or the designer handbag.<br />

The implications of the fi nancial crisis and economic impacts have<br />

meant a change in these patterns. This has not stopped consumers<br />

buying luxury items, but it has, in many cases, resulted in a more<br />

serious and discerning consumer selecting carefully their purchases<br />

based on the perceived value and timeless nature of the item<br />

they buy.<br />

Consumers are thinking more carefully about their spending<br />

on different categories and where they would prioritise their<br />

own budgets.<br />

ALLOCATION OF MONTHLY BUDGET<br />

EXPAND<br />

(10% INCREASE IN BUDGET)<br />

Travel/Vacation 29%<br />

Savings/Investments 25%<br />

Recreation/Entertainment 20%<br />

Dining Out 15%<br />

Electronics & Appliances 14%<br />

Apparel 11%<br />

Medical 10%<br />

Education 9%<br />

Transportation 6%<br />

Communication Services 5%<br />

Food & Beverage 5%<br />

Housing 1%<br />

-2% Medical<br />

-3% Housing<br />

-6% Education<br />

-7% Transportation<br />

-8% Food & Beverage<br />

-10% Communication Services<br />

-10% Savings/Investments<br />

-12% Recreation/Entertainment<br />

-12% Travel/Vacation<br />

-14% Electronics & Appliances<br />

-18% Dining Out<br />

-21% Apparel<br />

CONTRACT<br />

(10% DECREASE IN BUDGET)<br />

Ref. Neilsen Global Online Consumer Confi dence Survey, Q3 2011<br />

This research by Neilsen shows where, if consumers had a<br />

contraction in their budget by 10% or an expansion of about 10%,<br />

they would spend or reduce their budget.


WILL THEY HAVE THE RIGHT PRODUCTS/PACKAGE FOR ME?<br />

The pressures of time and fi nances mean that the fundamental<br />

need to fi nd products quickly and get them delivered or picked up<br />

as soon as possible remain crucial to the success of a Retailer.<br />

The benchmarks set by some<br />

global Retailers such as Amazon<br />

(in product range and delivery)<br />

have set expectations for<br />

the consumer. There is no doubt that Retailers combining their<br />

understanding of their consumer with their mechandising and<br />

logistics and warehousing strategies are currently winning through.<br />

ARE THEY A <strong>RETAIL</strong>ER I CAN TRUST?<br />

Who consumers trust to deliver the right thing for the right price<br />

and in the right way is a major challenge. If we look at the research<br />

available on ‘trust’, Retailers have made some headway.<br />

Financial Services<br />

Banking<br />

Insurance<br />

Media<br />

Brewing & Spirits<br />

OTC pers Healthcare<br />

Consumer packaged goods<br />

Energy<br />

Pharmaceuticals<br />

Entertainment<br />

Retail<br />

Biotechnology<br />

Food and Beverage<br />

Telecommunications<br />

Automotive<br />

Technology<br />

50%<br />

51%<br />

52%<br />

54%<br />

57%<br />

57%<br />

59%<br />

62%<br />

63%<br />

63%<br />

65%<br />

65%<br />

66%<br />

68%<br />

69%<br />

81%<br />

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%<br />

Ref. Edelman.com research 2011<br />

Major investments are being made by Retailers worldwide to build<br />

brand visibility and trust. Retailers are investing in putting their<br />

brands at the forefront of the consumer’s mind when they come<br />

to making their purchasing decision. The elements that build trust<br />

for a consumer are often, however, about getting the basics right:<br />

• Doing what you promise<br />

• Consistently<br />

• With no major errors<br />

• And a turnaround strategy if you do things wrong.<br />

Also, the removal of any major risks for the customer are also<br />

key tools in building trust with your brand in the consumers’ eyes,<br />

e.g. taking care of their data, dealing with payments securely etc.<br />

Managing PR and negative stories relating to the Retailer are of<br />

paramount importance in ensuring that trust is not eroded.<br />

The importance of trust is becoming ever more important for<br />

consumers where they are physically removed from the Retailer<br />

and buying from them on the web or through mobile. Will they<br />

buy from an E-Retailer they do not know fi rst time?<br />

The network of people and communities that consumers place<br />

their trust in are becoming more important in this context. Family<br />

or friends’ experience of previous purchases in the fi rst line, then<br />

communities they have joined and trust to provide guidance on<br />

specifi c purchase decisions. Social media and the Internet are<br />

making these communities broader (sometimes international) and<br />

more responsive than before.<br />

This research shows the level of trust that consumers stated they<br />

had with specifi c industries.<br />

This could be, in part, due to the higher profi le comparisons being<br />

made with other industries and the way that they have treated<br />

their markets and customers e.g. banks.


DOES THIS <strong>RETAIL</strong>ER SUPPORT SOMETHING<br />

I CARE ABOUT?<br />

It is becoming increasingly important to identify Retailers that<br />

stand out in a busy market environment. Some customers will<br />

differentiate and make their choices based on the Retailer’s ethics<br />

and approach to doing business.<br />

There are some key areas where consumers would like to feel<br />

that they too are contributing to the right cause in spending<br />

their money:<br />

IKEA Named as One of the ‘World’s<br />

Most Ethical Companies’ for Fourth<br />

Consecutive Year in 2010<br />

“IKEA’s promotion of a sound ethical environment shines within<br />

its industry and shows a clear understanding that operating<br />

under the highest standards for business behaviour goes beyond<br />

goodwill and ‘lip-service’ and is intimately linked to performance<br />

and profi tability,” said Alex Brigham, Executive Director of the<br />

Ethisphere Institute.<br />

Environmental Impact<br />

Sustainability and a ‘greener’ product set or way of working is an<br />

area we will cover in a later paper in this series. For consumers,<br />

it is almost the beginning of the journey. Many are keen to make<br />

a difference in this area, however, fewer are making purchasing<br />

decisions driven by this issue. There are some Retailers beginning<br />

to make green consumer choices easier for the consumer. Marks<br />

& Spencer is one European Retailer that has been working on<br />

its own sustainability agenda for the past 7 years and has been<br />

applauded by the consumer for driving sustainable market<br />

behaviours such as reducing plastic bags and cutting delivery miles.<br />

DO THEY OFFER A GOOD SHOPPING EXPERIENCE?<br />

There has been much written about the customer experience<br />

and the need for Retailers to produce an improved approach<br />

to ‘in-store experience’ in order to retain customers. Many<br />

consumers have switched their shopping habits to an online<br />

environment, and usually due to:<br />

• Convenience<br />

• Price<br />

• Choice (perceived in some cases)<br />

• Information<br />

• Increased confi dence in security<br />

The in-store experience can offer some amazing additional<br />

benefi ts, for example:<br />

“We’re doing this because it’s what you want us to do. It’s also the<br />

right thing to do. We’re calling it Plan A because we believe it’s now<br />

the only way to do business.<br />

There is no Plan B.”<br />

CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY<br />

Retailers with ethical or charitable causes are also respected for<br />

their work with local communities and beyond. IKEA Sweden is<br />

one such Retailer, having received recognition as a high-ranking<br />

ethical company from Ethisphere a research based international<br />

think tank.<br />

• Engaging interaction – a consumer can touch/feel/try<br />

the product<br />

• Informative – a consumer can be guided to things you had<br />

not previously considered<br />

• Surprising – a consumer can be taken into an experience<br />

or trial situation<br />

• Human – they can interact with another person.<br />

Online, mobile and even in-store processes must form part of<br />

an overarching multi-channel strategy to ensure that all channels<br />

are coherent with the brand in question and that they provide a<br />

consistently high quality experience, allowing customers to easily<br />

purchase what they want, when they want and through whatever<br />

method they want.<br />

Ref. Webcredible report on retail customer experience, Nov 2011.<br />

www.webcredible.co.uk


WILL THEY OFFER ME A BENEFIT FOR BUYING<br />

THERE BEFORE?<br />

Some consumers will look for those Retailers where they will be<br />

offered a benefi t as a returning customer.<br />

Most Retailers offer programs to drive more retention and loyalty<br />

to their customer base e.g.:<br />

• Tesco’s loyalty card, a points-based system offering vouchers and<br />

rewards based on points collected through purchases in store<br />

and online.<br />

• Voucher systems offered to customers buying up to<br />

certain thresholds.<br />

• Body Shop sales events for customers, and reminder system.<br />

• Starbucks targeted location offers for customers holding a card.<br />

• The Sainsbury’s Nectar card – a loyalty points-based system<br />

shared by multiple companies including Retailers.<br />

There are also consumers who are loyal to a brand. They return to<br />

buy at the same Retailer on a regular basis because they see it as<br />

‘their supermarket’ or ‘their clothes brand’. For these consumers,<br />

the social media context has added an additional way to become<br />

connected to their Retailer of choice, as well as other consumers<br />

who feel the same way.<br />

“The number of customers in the DIY sector<br />

continues to grow despite the diffi cult economic<br />

conditions. However, the average shopping basket<br />

has decreased over the last couple of years with the exception of<br />

customers who own loyalty cards. Customers with a loyalty card<br />

can represent up to 50% of some of our branches’ turnover.”<br />

Elise Boudet, Insurance Manager – Adeo Services<br />

DO THEY HAVE THE LATEST OR NEW IDEAS?<br />

New ideas and products attract some consumers. They will look<br />

for Retailers consistently searching for and offering new items or<br />

services. They will search these Retailers out.<br />

Expert prediction.<br />

“The next few years will see consumers much more focused on<br />

value, in the home and out of it. After years of travelling all over the<br />

world, many consumers will retreat to enjoying themselves more<br />

at home and in their own country, helped by the Internet not<br />

just to obtain better value, but also to entertain themselves more<br />

cheaply – and their children will do the same, as the smartphoneaccessed<br />

Internet provides them with hours of endless fun and<br />

bans boredom, as well as providing the key to successful shopping<br />

for themselves and their parents, through mobile applications.<br />

Worries about the environment may have receded a little, though<br />

they will return, with the relentless rise in oil and raw material<br />

prices reminding consumers that the human race does have to<br />

worry about resources. Nonetheless, the outlook for Retailers may<br />

not be gloomy, as many consumers spend at home rather than<br />

going abroad”.<br />

Prof. Merlin Stone,<br />

Universities of Demontfort, Oxford Brookes and Portsmouth,<br />

Research Director The Customer Framework.<br />

TO SUMMARISE….<br />

• The consumer selects a Retailer based upon their<br />

own priorities.<br />

• Value for money and ensuring that the consumer feels they<br />

have made a correct decision are more important than<br />

ever before.<br />

• Finding the right product selection remains important for<br />

the consumer.<br />

• Retailers must consider the key ways to build trust with their<br />

consumer base through consistency of delivery in the key<br />

elements of their proposition.<br />

• The customer experience enables the Retailer to stand out<br />

for the customer, it is crucial to deliver it well across all channels.<br />

• Consumers are more aware of sustainability and community<br />

needs and are noticing the Retailers that are investing in<br />

these areas.


ENGAGING <strong>RETAIL</strong> BRANDS –<br />

VOTED BY CONSUMERS<br />

DOES ALL OF THIS MATTER?<br />

There is no clear measure of consumer feedback across all<br />

markets, although there are some messages in the research papers<br />

available showing that consumers are less happy with Retailers.<br />

The reasons for this could be many e.g. the fi nancial crisis making<br />

consumers more aware of pricing, the in-store experience not<br />

standing out in ways consumers would expect.<br />

Similarly we cannot rely on Retailers’ performance reports as<br />

an indicator of consumer preference, as there are so many<br />

diffi cult external factors that will have an impact on market share,<br />

profi tability etc.<br />

“ORC International, announced in January 2011, research fi ndings<br />

that showed that half of UK consumers are likely to encounter<br />

poor customer service in an average month. The worst culprit<br />

for poor service was the Retail sector, with 17% of respondents<br />

unimpressed with their experiences. Closely following were<br />

broadband suppliers and banks, with 16% and 15% respectively.”<br />

Ref. Prof Merlin Stone – The Death Of Customer Service In Retail<br />

TOP <strong>RETAIL</strong> BRANDS<br />

# Brand Brand Value<br />

$M<br />

Brand<br />

Contribution<br />

Brand<br />

Momentum<br />

Brand Value<br />

Change<br />

1 Walmart 39,421 2 8 -4%<br />

2 Amazon 27,459 4 9 29%<br />

3 Tesco 25,741 5 4 12%<br />

4 Carrefour 14,980 5 7 0%<br />

5 Target 12,148 4 7 -1%<br />

6 eBay 9,328 3 7 -28%<br />

7 Home Depot 8,971 2 3 -3%<br />

8 ALDI 8,747 1 6 1%<br />

9 Auchan 7,848 4 7 NA<br />

10 Lowe’s 7,008 2 5 10%<br />

11 Best Buy 5,807 3 8 18%<br />

12 IKEA 5,710 3 8 -15%<br />

13 Marks & Spencer 5,699 5 3 -5%<br />

14 Asda 4,922 3 7 -9%<br />

15 Kohl’s 4,371 4 5 12%<br />

16 Lidl 4,102 1 5 -1%<br />

17 Costco 3,875 1 4 -26%<br />

18 Sam’s Club 3,255 1 6 -7%<br />

19 Safeway 3,173 2 4 -8%<br />

20 Sainsbury’s 2,728 5 4 -4%<br />

Consumers will vote with their money. The fi nancial crisis has<br />

clearly impacted consumer spending with a slight increase or<br />

remaining the same across Europe. Those Retailers showing clearly<br />

improved fi nancial performance are ‘value’ brands and those having<br />

‘own brand’ goods such as Walmart, and some high-end luxury<br />

brands such as Mulberry Group.<br />

The brand ranking research database BrandZ, places Walmart,<br />

Carrefour, Aldi and Tesco in their top 20 brands globally.<br />

TO SUMMARISE...<br />

Ref. Millward Brown Optimer including data from BrandZ,<br />

Datamonitor and Bloomberg<br />

Understanding consumer preference and priorities and adapting<br />

to the pressures in the market at present are crucial for the<br />

survival of Retailers.<br />

Consumers are fi nancially pressured and voting for value. They<br />

are looking for ways that are meaningful to them to differentiate<br />

between Retailers, and moving seamlessly between channels<br />

to do so.<br />

Retailers are working with a rapidly changing set of consumers but<br />

must remember to keep their focus on the basics of product range<br />

and service across the channels they operate.


APPENDIX<br />

List of Useful Sources<br />

• Euromonitor European Marketing Data and Statistics 2012<br />

• Symphony IRI Group Topline report H1 2011<br />

• Edelman Trustbarometer 2011<br />

• The Death of Personal Service in Retail –<br />

Prof Merlin Stone, March 2011.<br />

http://blog.thecustomerframework.com/Portals/48635/docs/thedeath-of-customer-service-in%20retail_v1.4.<strong>pdf</strong><br />

• Satmetrix NPS report 2011 Europe. http://www.satmetrix.com<br />

• BrandZ 100 2011<br />

• RIS store systems study 2011 (Holman & Buzek)<br />

• Interbrand best retail brands 2011<br />

• Cushman & Wakefi eld European Retail Report Q4 2011<br />

• Population Reference Bureau 2011 World Population<br />

Data Sheet<br />

• OECD report: Working paper 285.The Emerging Middle Class<br />

in Developing Countries:<br />

http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/12/52/44457738.<strong>pdf</strong><br />

• Google Public data<br />

• The Guardian Datablog:<br />

http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog<br />

• Nielsen Global Online Confi dence Concerns and Spending<br />

Intentions Q3 2011<br />

• Mulitchannel Retail Customer Experience Report 2011<br />

• Journal of Retailing Vol 68 Number 4 1992<br />

• Retail Eyes customer intelligence, Marketforce blog. Nov 2011<br />

http://www.retaileyes.co.uk<br />

• Ethisphere: http://ethisphere.com<br />

• ASCI Index: http://www.theacsi.org<br />

• Polulation Reference Bureau: http://www.prb.org<br />

• Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org<br />

• Interviews with Prof. Merlin Stone<br />

• Interview with Neil Saunders, Conlumino Retail Experts.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!