Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 20<strong>04</strong> • Volume 33 • Number 5<br />
The Monthly Newsletter of the Market Technicians Association, Inc.<br />
The Hidden Order Within Stock Prices<br />
W. Clay Allen,<br />
CFA earned a<br />
Bachelor’s of Science<br />
degree in General<br />
Engineering<br />
from the University<br />
of Oklahoma in<br />
1963. His computer<br />
programming efforts<br />
started in 1962 on<br />
the university mainframes.<br />
Clay’s investment<br />
career began immediately upon his<br />
graduation from college. Later, he completed an<br />
MBA from the University of Denver in 1968, with<br />
an emphasis in Finance and Economics, and<br />
earned his Chartered Financial Analyst designation<br />
in 1971.<br />
Clay has worked in investment analysis and<br />
Portfolio Management since 1964. In his first position,<br />
he worked in a large regional bank trust<br />
department, managing common funds and large<br />
institutional accounts including the City and<br />
County of Denver Employees Retirement Fund.<br />
After that, he worked for 3 years as a long range<br />
planner and economist for a large regional bank<br />
holding company.<br />
From 1980 until 1998, he provided institutional<br />
investment research services to major institutional<br />
investors nationally as a broker for NYSE member<br />
firms. These research activities included P&F<br />
analysis as well as fundamental value modeling,<br />
relative strength studies and portfolio simulations.<br />
During this time, from 1991, Clay was a VP at a<br />
national brokerage firm, with duties as an institutional<br />
broker in the Englewood, Colorado office.<br />
He left that position to focus fully on the development<br />
of Market Dynamics System software in<br />
June 1998. This software is a complete relative<br />
strength point & figure charting service.<br />
To stay focused on the latest research related<br />
to investment management , Clay has taught Economics<br />
and Investments at University of Denver;<br />
Colorado School of Banking at University of Colorado,<br />
Boulder; Regis College MBA program, Denver,<br />
Colorado; and American Institute of Banking,<br />
Denver, Colorado.<br />
Analytical Framework<br />
For more than twenty-five years, Clay’s work<br />
has focused on the 3-point P&F method of tracking<br />
securities prices and interest rates. He began<br />
by using chart services purchased from others,<br />
augmented by some P&F charts that he updated<br />
by hand on a daily basis. He maintained 300 to<br />
500 P&F charts daily for over 25 years.<br />
As data services became come more readily<br />
available and reliable, he has developed computer<br />
programs to facilitate the analysis of stock price<br />
movements utilizing P&F methods. This work includes<br />
P&F applications to relative strength, foreign<br />
market indices, industry groups and other<br />
price filtering methods similar to basic 3-point P&F<br />
charting. P&F can be successfully applied to interest<br />
rates or currencies. Clay has found a box<br />
size of 5-basis points to work well with interest<br />
rates.<br />
It is his opinion that buying decisions for longterm<br />
investors should be about 80% fundamental<br />
and 20% technical. When reviewing fundamentals,<br />
Clay looks for companies with a high return<br />
on total capital (ROTC). In his experience, the top<br />
20% of the S&P 500 will show ROTC greater<br />
than 15%. He likes to see companies with debt<br />
representing less than 40% of the capital, and the<br />
underlying business should be growing as measured<br />
by revenue. He also analyzes cash flow to<br />
ensure that a real company stands behind the stock.<br />
To review a stock’s technical position, Clay<br />
looks at the P&F relative strength chart. These<br />
charts are constructed using a ratio of the stock’s<br />
price to the S&P 500. A standard 3-point reversal<br />
of this ratio graphically depicts a stock’s relative<br />
performance. To be considered for purchase, relative<br />
strength should be above a 45-degree bullish<br />
support line sloping upward to the right from a<br />
recent pivot low and on a triple top buy signal.<br />
P&F relative strength graphs differ significantly<br />
from other relative strength methods. Typically,<br />
relative strength ratios are calculated over a universe<br />
of stocks, and the ratios are then sorted into<br />
percentiles. An example of this technique is the<br />
widely known RS Rank found in Investor’s Business<br />
Daily. The graphic technique favored by Clay<br />
is easier to calculate and is highly responsive to<br />
changes in the stock’s price.<br />
Interestingly, if one is willing to ignore fundamentals,<br />
Clay has identified a useful technique to<br />
take advantage of the parabolic movements commonly<br />
seen in fad stocks. These stocks, such as<br />
Internet stocks in the late-1990s, can deliver gains<br />
of 4-5% per month on the upside. When the relative<br />
strength is more than 25 boxes above the 45-<br />
degree bullish support line, traders should employ<br />
close stops or take profits. While this technique<br />
does not guarantee a trader will avoid the crash<br />
which inevitably follows the fad, it does lessen<br />
the risk.<br />
In his work, selling decisions should be 80%<br />
technical. The P&F relative strength chart will<br />
provide a performance alarm when relative<br />
strength is below a 45-degree bearish resistance<br />
line sloping downward to the right from a recent<br />
pivot high and on a triple bottom sell signal. Clay<br />
treats these alarms as an alert to dig deeper into<br />
the company. Even if he can find nothing in the<br />
financial statements, he recognizes that the market<br />
is usually right and will sell if performance<br />
remains below the resistance line for an extended<br />
period of time.<br />
Clay has found inspiration in the work of<br />
Charles Ellis’ article, “The Loser’s Game” published<br />
in the July/August 1975 Financial Analyst’s<br />
Journal (http://www.aimrpubs.org/faj/issues/<br />
v51n1/pdf/f0510095a.pdf). Ellis pointed out “almost<br />
all of the really big trouble that you’re going<br />
to experience in the next year is in your portfolio<br />
right now...” Ellis demonstrates that the markets<br />
moved from a winner’s game, where one wins by<br />
playing better than his or her opponent, to a loser’s<br />
game, where one wins by making fewer mistakes<br />
than his opponent. Selling underperformers is one<br />
of the easiest ways for a portfolio manager to decrease<br />
their number of mistakes.<br />
Clay’s career covers many different market<br />
conditions and interest rate environments. Economic<br />
conditions have varied from stagflation to<br />
recession to boom and world political conditions<br />
have moved from hot wars to cold wars and inbetween.<br />
Throughout these periods the P&F charts have<br />
proven to be an invaluable guide in the evaluation<br />
of these trends and their reversals. He believes<br />
very strongly that markets function because of<br />
change - not in spite of it. These macro changes<br />
create fundamental changes in the economy and<br />
continued on page 3<br />
WHAT’S INSIDE<br />
NYSE Update ________________________ 3<br />
Member Profile: Hank <strong>Pruden</strong>, Ph.D. _____ 4<br />
E.S.C. Coppock_______________________ 5<br />
Interpreting Coppock Curves ____________ 6<br />
Introduction to Your Personal Home Page _ 8<br />
Southern California Chapter is back ______ 8<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Calendar of Events _______________ 9<br />
An <strong>MTA</strong> Retreat in San Diego ___________ 9<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Retreat Agenda & Reg. Form ____ 10-11
www.mta.org<br />
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
Market Technicians Association, Inc.<br />
74 Main Street • 3rd Floor<br />
Woodbridge, NJ 07095<br />
Phone: 732/596-9399<br />
Fax: 732/596-9392<br />
E-mail: info@mta.org<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Executive Director<br />
John Kirby<br />
jk@mta.org<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Administrative Staff<br />
Shelley Lebeck<br />
shelley@mta.org<br />
Tom MacMahon<br />
tom@mta.org<br />
Marie Penza<br />
marie@mta.org<br />
Cassandra Townes<br />
cassandra@mta.org<br />
Technically Speaking Editor<br />
Mike Carr, CMT<br />
editor@mta.org<br />
Change of Address<br />
Make changes on your personal home<br />
page of the <strong>MTA</strong> <strong>web</strong>site, or e-mail the<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> office (admin@mta.org)<br />
Website<br />
www.mta.org<br />
Market Professionals Managing Risk<br />
Incorporated 1973<br />
This newsletter is produced by the Market Technicians Association,<br />
Inc., 74 Main Street, 3rd Floor, Woodbridge, NJ<br />
07095. All comments and editorial material do not necessarily<br />
reflect the organization’s opinion nor does it constitute an<br />
endorsement by the Market Technicians Association, Inc., or<br />
any of its officers, of products or services mentioned. Sources<br />
are believed to be reliable at time of publication, but not guaranteed.<br />
The Market Technicians Association, Inc., and its officers,<br />
assume no responsibility for errors or omissions.<br />
Copyright © 20<strong>04</strong> Market Technicians Association, Inc.<br />
All rights are reserved.<br />
From the Editor’s Desk<br />
“All the profits come from the outliers.”<br />
- paraphrased wisdom from longtime<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> member Mike Epstein<br />
For the second time in four months, Clay<br />
Allen appears on the cover of Technically<br />
Speaking. In August, we presented the results<br />
of his study on the distribution of returns for<br />
S&P 500 stocks. In that article, he proved the<br />
wisdom of active market participants and demonstrated<br />
that the outliers do indeed account<br />
for the overwhelming majority of a portfolio’s<br />
profits. This month we look at his work in<br />
more detail.<br />
The basis of Clay’s work is long-term relative<br />
strength P&F charts. In an interesting twist<br />
of fate, Clay references an article by Charles<br />
Ellis which was published in the Financial<br />
Analysts Journal and reprinted in their 50th<br />
anniversary issue. A URL is provided so that<br />
you can read that article. Also available at that<br />
<strong>web</strong> page is an article by Harold. M. Gartley<br />
entitled “Relative Velocity Statistics: Their<br />
Application in Portfolio Analysis” (http://<br />
www.aimrpubs.org/faj/issues/v51n1/pdf/<br />
f0510018a.pdf).<br />
It might be interesting for a CMT candidate<br />
to explore the similarities in the work of<br />
Gartley and Allen. Gartley, the recipient of the<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Annual Award in 1981, brought a unique<br />
insight into the use of relative strength nearly<br />
60 years ago. Clay Allen also offers a unique<br />
insight into relative strength and in doing so<br />
makes a truly significant contribution to technical<br />
analysis.<br />
Also in this issue, we have an in-depth profile<br />
of Dr. Hank <strong>Pruden</strong>. Hank’s longstanding<br />
focus on Wyckoff analysis is unquestionably a<br />
significant contribution to our field. For those<br />
unfamiliar with his work, we are fortunate that<br />
he has been published so frequently in the Journal<br />
of Technical Analysis and its predecessor,<br />
the <strong>MTA</strong>’s Journal of Technical Analysis.<br />
I’m certain you’ll enjoy the short biography<br />
of Sedge Coppock based upon the research<br />
of George Schade and John Carder and I’m<br />
sure you’ll be able to apply the article discussing<br />
the interpretation of Coppock Curves along<br />
with some examples provided by John Carder.<br />
We hope that you’ll enjoy this issue, and<br />
find it to be useful.<br />
Cordially,<br />
Mike Carr, CMT<br />
Technically Speaking Editor<br />
From the President’s Desk<br />
To the <strong>MTA</strong> Membership:<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember,<br />
Fred Meissner<br />
and<br />
Thanksgiving, is fast approaching,<br />
and with it the<br />
holidays and the end of the<br />
year. The <strong>MTA</strong> has a number<br />
of things going on<br />
throughout the next few<br />
months, where people can<br />
participate.<br />
There are various<br />
teaching opportunities for<br />
CMTs in the university system where the <strong>MTA</strong><br />
Educational Foundation is offering classes.<br />
Teaching these classes, or any classes, is one<br />
of the things that I most enjoy – I will be teaching<br />
a few classes as a guest speaker in Texas.<br />
Exposing the students to our craft, and conveying<br />
the excitement of Technical Analysis<br />
is so rewarding! Any CMT who has done this<br />
will confirm this, and you can contact the office<br />
to volunteer in your area.<br />
We are going to be trying some new seminar<br />
ideas out in 2005, one of which is the Retreat<br />
in San Diego which I think looks to be<br />
really exciting. These intensive workshops<br />
promise to be jam packed with ideas and analytical<br />
tools and methods people can use right<br />
away to give perspective on the markets. I am<br />
looking forward to attending some of these<br />
workshops myself. I have seen the San Diego<br />
location and it is conducive to relaxation for<br />
families as well – this should be a great opportunity<br />
to learn and mingle with your <strong>MTA</strong><br />
friends. We look forward to seeing you all<br />
there!<br />
John Kirby mentioned the Body of Knowledge<br />
work recently completed by Linda Montgomery<br />
of the Chauncey Group and dedicated<br />
volunteers. I would like to publicly thank her,<br />
and the volunteers! We could not have done it<br />
without you!<br />
Have a great <strong>Nov</strong>ember!<br />
Sincerely,<br />
M. Frederick Meissner, CMT<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> President<br />
2<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
www.mta.org<br />
John R. Kirby<br />
NYSE Update<br />
Here we go, one more<br />
time around the track. The<br />
group referred in my email<br />
address book as the “April<br />
task force” has worked<br />
tirelessly over the past six<br />
months to make your case<br />
for parity with the CFA<br />
designation to the NYSE<br />
and the NASD.<br />
On October 18, 20<strong>04</strong><br />
another letter went out to<br />
the regulators from Stuart Kaswell our Washington<br />
DC attorney. It presented the test specifications<br />
that were the result of the recent job<br />
analysis that was done by the Chauncey group<br />
and those were compared to the preexisting<br />
specifications that have existed with some<br />
changes since 1988. This letter confirms the<br />
credibility and the efficacy of the CMT designation<br />
since its’ founding, and how it has<br />
changed to meet the needs of the field.<br />
My article is cut short this issue because I<br />
am accompanying the <strong>MTA</strong> contingent going<br />
to the IFTA meeting in Madrid in early <strong>Nov</strong>ember.<br />
Larry Berman is making a report to the<br />
IFTA on the activities of <strong>MTA</strong> in 03-<strong>04</strong>. If<br />
you would like a copy of that report along with<br />
the latest letter to the NYSE NASD, please let<br />
me know. I’ll send it along to you. I’ll report<br />
to you on IFTA when we return.<br />
Cordially,<br />
John R. Kirby,<br />
Executive Director<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Office E-mail Directory<br />
Inquiries Directory<br />
General Questions<br />
info@mta.org<br />
Membership Information admin@mta.org<br />
CMT Information<br />
cmt@mta.org<br />
Technically Speaking editor@mta.org<br />
Journal of Technical Analysis journal@mta.org<br />
People Directory<br />
John Kirby<br />
jk@mta.org<br />
Shelley Lebeck<br />
shelley@mta.org<br />
Tom MacMahon<br />
tom@mta.org<br />
Jeanne Farrelly<br />
jeanne@mta.org<br />
Marie Penza<br />
marie@mta.org<br />
Cassandra Townes<br />
cassandra@mta.org<br />
Barbara Gomperts<br />
Bgomperts@aol.com<br />
Len MacDonell<br />
lmacdonell@mta.org<br />
Fred Meissner<br />
president@mta.org<br />
Hidden Order - continued from page 1<br />
the fortunes of companies that lead to changes in<br />
price trends over the long term. Three-point P&F<br />
charting has proven to be an effective tool to help<br />
track these long term trends throughout his experience.<br />
He has also found that at any given time, approximately<br />
20% of stocks are in strong uptrends,<br />
20% in strong downtrends, and 60% in trading<br />
ranges. Although this general principle holds in<br />
all market environments, in bear markets, the number<br />
in uptrends may be lower and in bull markets,<br />
the number in strong uptrends can be significantly<br />
higher than 20%. This principle held up in a period<br />
of rising prices measured by the 12 months<br />
ending June 20<strong>04</strong>. As detailed in the August 20<strong>04</strong><br />
issue of Technically Speaking (http://<br />
www.mta.org/membership/newsletter/<br />
pdfserver.cfm?filename=x<strong>MTA</strong><strong>04</strong>08.pdf), at least<br />
67 stocks underperformed the S&P 500 by more<br />
than 20 percentage points.<br />
Clay Allen has a written an easy to understand<br />
book explaining every aspect of his portfolio management<br />
philosophy. For more information, please<br />
go to www.clayallen.com. Extensive educational<br />
material about P&F charting is also available at<br />
that <strong>web</strong> site. The Market Dynamics Tutorial is a<br />
free downloadable PDF document that is over 300<br />
pages long and is designed for professional longterm<br />
investors.<br />
The cover of the book depicts a histogram of<br />
price changes. In the book, detailed data on Best<br />
Buy is presented. Over a one-year period, the stock<br />
rose 54% of the time and declined on 46% of<br />
trading days. The histogram shows a bell shaped<br />
curve slightly skewed to the right. The average<br />
daily gain of 0.33% made this stock a big winner,<br />
despite the seemingly random nature of daily price<br />
movements.<br />
Turning to a P&F chart of relative strength,<br />
Clay is able to illustrate the hidden order of price<br />
movements within a stock. The random data of<br />
the histogram is transformed into an orderly progression<br />
of higher highs and lower lows on the<br />
P&F chart. This methodology can be employed to<br />
remove the short-term noise from the price pattern,<br />
while retaining the characteristics of the<br />
longer term trend.<br />
Articles Wanted<br />
Next month, we will publish a biography<br />
of Charles Dow. Any work related to Dow<br />
Theory would be greatly appreciated. Articles<br />
on Dow Theory should be submitted by <strong>Nov</strong>ember<br />
10th.<br />
In January, R. N. Elliott will be featured in<br />
Technically Speaking. Articles related to Elliott<br />
Wave applications should be submitted<br />
by December 10th.<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> 2005 Annual Seminar<br />
MAY 19-22, 2005<br />
HOTEL PENNSYLVANIA, NEW YORK CITY<br />
Complete details will available by December 1. Registration<br />
will begin in January. There will be new additions to<br />
the traditional format. Watch this newsletter for seminar<br />
information as it becomes available.<br />
Technical Analysis Courses at<br />
New York Institute of Finance<br />
Advanced Technical Analysis Workshop<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 29<br />
5:45 pm-8:15 pm<br />
Monday, 4 Evenings Introductory<br />
NYIF HQ<br />
TECH3001<br />
Inst.: John Palicka, CMT $1,250<br />
CPE Credits: 12.0<br />
Instructional Method: Group-Live<br />
Focus on traditional technical tools of charting.<br />
Learn to choose among technical approaches<br />
to produce the most productive trades, given any<br />
investment horizon. Emphasis placed on what information<br />
is needed to pass the CMT Level I Exam<br />
Course suggested for portfolio managers, traders<br />
(especially principal traders), academics wishing<br />
to expand their knowledge in behavioral finance.<br />
Prerequisites: Technical Analysis I or equivalent<br />
knowledge.<br />
Accreditation Report on Latest<br />
CMT Exam Results<br />
The Accreditation Committee reports the following<br />
passing rates for the May 20<strong>04</strong> exams:<br />
CMT 1: 75%<br />
CMT 2: 58%<br />
CMT 3: 27%<br />
While the exam content has not changed significantly<br />
in the last few years, these pass rates compare<br />
to an average pass rate since 2001* for:<br />
CMT 1: 78%<br />
CMT 2: 69%<br />
CMT 3: 63%<br />
*2001 is the last year for which pass rates are available,<br />
also it is the first year that a CMT 3 exam was offered.<br />
Members On The Move<br />
Board member John Kosar has a new email<br />
address:<br />
kosar@dls.net<br />
Ethics & Standards Committee Chair, Neal<br />
Genda, CMT, also has a new e-mail address:<br />
neal.genda@cnb.com<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4 3
www.mta.org<br />
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
Member Profile: <strong>Henry</strong> (Hank) O. <strong>Pruden</strong>, Ph.D.<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
Hank <strong>Pruden</strong> is an internationally-known<br />
educator<br />
and speculator. He is a<br />
professor in the School of<br />
Business at Golden Gate<br />
University in San Francisco,<br />
California where he<br />
has been teaching for 20<br />
years. Hank is more than a<br />
theoretician; having actively traded his own account<br />
for the past 26 years he has placed real<br />
equity at risk based upon the theories he teaches.<br />
His personal involvement in the market ensures<br />
that what he teaches is practical for the trader, and<br />
not only abstract academic theory.<br />
He is also the Executive Director of the Institute<br />
of Technical Market Analysis (ITMA). At<br />
Golden Gate he developed the accredited courses<br />
in technical market analysis in 1976. Since then<br />
the curriculum has expanded to include advanced<br />
topics in technical analysis and trading. In his<br />
courses Hank emphasizes the psychology of trading<br />
as well as the use of technical analysis methods.<br />
He has published extensively in both areas.<br />
Hank has mentored individuals and institutional<br />
traders in the field of technical analysis for many<br />
years. He is currently on the Board of Directors of<br />
the Technical Securities Analysts Association of<br />
San Francisco and is past president of that association.<br />
Hank was also on the Board of Directors<br />
of the <strong>MTA</strong> and has served as Vice Chair of the<br />
Americas with IFTA. For eleven years Hank was<br />
the editor of <strong>MTA</strong> Journal, the premier publication<br />
of technical analysts. From 1982 to 1993 he<br />
was a member of the Board of Trustees of Golden<br />
Gate University.<br />
Hank completed his Ph.D. (with honors), at<br />
Lundquist College of Business, University of Oregon.<br />
He also holds an MBA from the Haas School<br />
of Business, University of California, Berkeley<br />
and a Bachelor’s of Science degree from California<br />
State University, Chico.<br />
Professor <strong>Pruden</strong>, currently on a year-long sabbatical<br />
from Golden Gate University, is a visiting<br />
professor/visiting scholar at Euromed-Marseille<br />
Ecole de Management in Marseille, France. In<br />
collaboration with other professors at Euromed-<br />
Marsaille, Hank has co-authored two articles. With<br />
Dr. Bernard Belletante, Hank published a realtime<br />
test of the Wyckoff method projecting a new<br />
bull move in the DJIA in the IFTA Journal. The<br />
Journal of Technical Analysis published his work<br />
with Dr. Bernard Paranque and Dr. Walter Baets.<br />
While in France, Hank is acting as a roving<br />
ambassador of education for IFTA. He is working<br />
to develop courses and introduce technical analysis<br />
into colleges and universities and to assist individual<br />
technical societies with their educational<br />
offerings at the operational level. His objective is<br />
to identify what needs to be taught at these schools<br />
and how it should be taught in each of the individual<br />
countries, accounting for cultural differences.<br />
Hank will be traveling throughout Europe<br />
and the Middle East in the coming months to meet<br />
these objectives.<br />
The roving ambassadorship is similar to a role<br />
Hank has fulfilled since 2000 in South and Central<br />
America ‘s financial communities. He helped<br />
to launch the Brazilian Technical Society and has<br />
been a keynote speaker in Brazil, Argentina and<br />
Mexico. Bilingual in Spanish, Hank has been able<br />
to address complex and sensitive financial and<br />
intercultural issues without the confusion or misunderstanding<br />
of translation<br />
Educational Philosophy<br />
For over a quarter of a century, Hank has taught<br />
technical analysis at the university level. A popular<br />
scholar, he has won multiple “best teacher and<br />
best scholar” awards based upon his ability to be<br />
easily understood by motivated beginners in finance<br />
and by experienced professional investors.<br />
Exposure to investment professionals during that<br />
time resulted in feedback as to what works best,<br />
resulting in continuous improvements in the curriculum.<br />
Getting students to progress from the<br />
definition level of instruction to application of<br />
theory has proven to be the greatest educational<br />
challenge during that time.<br />
Hank discovered that the same approaches cannot<br />
be applied at both beginning and advanced<br />
levels. Over the years Hank has taken his own<br />
academic theories and secondary research to develop<br />
the innovative, workable model, the AC-<br />
TION SEQUENCE METHOD for building the<br />
skills and knowledge of intermediate learners of<br />
technical analysis. (The ACTION SEQUENCE is<br />
fully explained in the Journal of Technical Analysis<br />
article, “System States of Pedagogy and the<br />
Action Sequence Model” (Issue 58, Summer-Autumn<br />
2002). While the Action Sequence Model<br />
may be very roughly thought of as paper trading,<br />
the model includes extensive feedback and replays<br />
the original sequence incorporating lessons learned<br />
from the previous experience. Hank emphasizes<br />
that the replay portion of the model is critical. In<br />
this way, the student is being trained to react appropriately<br />
to future market circumstances. As a<br />
consequence of the efforts of Hank and his<br />
colleague’s in the San Francisco financial community,<br />
Golden Gate University has the only academically<br />
accredited graduate certificate program<br />
in technical market analysis in the world.<br />
Analytical Framework<br />
Being a teacher, Hank is able to define complex<br />
issues in simple terms. Applying this skill to<br />
trading, he found that traders like to use analogies<br />
to explain their world and to help them capture a<br />
deeper understanding of what it takes to be a complete,<br />
high performer. A favorite field from which<br />
to draw analogies is competitive athletics. One<br />
attractive analogy for the three part skills of the<br />
complete trader is the “triple threat” notion in football.<br />
In the early 1950s, TIME magazine ran a cover<br />
story on the then Princeton University All-American<br />
Dick Kazmier. The cover story was titled “A<br />
Triple Threat from a Single Wing.” Princeton’s<br />
football team operated out of a “single wing” formation.<br />
Kazmier personified the complete football<br />
player of his era: he was outstanding at the<br />
run, the pass and the kick. These three complementary<br />
talents, combined into one individual,<br />
made Kazmier an awesome competitor and an All-<br />
American performer. Applying this analogy to<br />
trading, Hank found that the 3-in-1 Trader must<br />
seek to develop a “triple threat” skill set. It is not<br />
running, passing and kicking, but rather:<br />
1. Systems building<br />
2. Pattern recognition<br />
3. Mental state management<br />
These three decision frameworks, illustrated<br />
in Figure 1, interact with each other and build on<br />
each other in a natural order of progression. A<br />
behavioral finance framework for system building<br />
provides the structure for integrating and interpreting<br />
indicators organized along the key dimensions<br />
of price, time, volume, and sentiment.<br />
A pattern recognition scheme for discretionary<br />
trading, such as the Wyckoff Method of chart reading<br />
and of technical analysis furnishes the trader<br />
with an almost ideal set of laws and principles<br />
that the trader can use as general guidelines to<br />
interpret chart patterns and to take action. A model<br />
of trader psychology for mental state control is<br />
needed for success in system or discretionary trading.<br />
Hank’s collaborative research with Dr. Van<br />
K. Tharp led to “The Ten Tasks of Top Trading,”<br />
a series of discrete contexts for selecting appropriate<br />
mental states and providing a logical and<br />
comprehensive sequence of tasks for the successful<br />
trader to follow. Pertinent papers can be found<br />
at http://www.hankpruden.com/tentasks.pdf<br />
Hank relies primarily on the Wyckoff Method<br />
of technical analysis. He likens this approach to<br />
Woody Hayes’ football philosophy at Ohio State<br />
- “three yards and a cloud of dust.” Although neither<br />
approach is fancy, both are effective and both<br />
produce winners.<br />
Richard Wyckoff was a trader in the early-tomid<br />
1900’s. He tried to understand the logic be-<br />
4<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4
hind market action. Like Hank <strong>Pruden</strong>, Wyckoff<br />
was able to explain complex issue in understandable<br />
terms, such as “Are you riding a dead horse?<br />
Get off and get a live one.” (from Fourteen Methods<br />
of Operating in the Stocks Market, 1909/24,<br />
as quoted by John Bollinger, CFA, CMT in Capital<br />
Growth Topics, May 18, 2001)<br />
By studying the actions of Jesse Livermore,<br />
James Keen, J.P. Morgan, and other stock operators<br />
of his day, Wyckoff developed a trading system<br />
which sought to explain the boom and bust<br />
cycle in stocks. The Wyckoff Method uses price<br />
charts and volume studies to analyze and forecast<br />
the stock market. It also takes into account investor<br />
psychology and provides insight into why professional<br />
traders buy and sell stocks. Wyckoff<br />
emphasized the placement of stops and the importance<br />
of controlling the risk of any particular<br />
trade. Successful implementation of his model allowed<br />
Wyckoff to own a mansion in the Hamptons.<br />
A successful trader from Lebanon introduced<br />
Hank to this approach. After much study and practice,<br />
he realized this approach made a lot of sense<br />
to him, and it has been at the core of his analysis<br />
ever since. Hank also finds that teaching reinforces<br />
the concepts of the Wyckoff Method, and<br />
he has also found that most students who study<br />
this method are able to profitably employ it, given<br />
sufficient study and practice.<br />
Hank has also sought to expand upon<br />
Wyckoff’s work. To this end, he has added some<br />
definition to several concepts. As an example, he<br />
has refined a checklist to identify market turning<br />
points during periods of consolidation. He has also<br />
added to the body of knowledge by creating a<br />
checklist to assess whether or not that consolidation<br />
will lead to a resumption of the prior trend.<br />
To obtain an overview of this investment tactic,<br />
readers may refer to Hank’s articles, “Wyckoff<br />
Laws: A Market Test” in the 20<strong>04</strong> issue of the<br />
IFTA Journal and “Wyckoff Tests: Nine Classic<br />
Tests and Nine New Tests” which appeared in the<br />
Spring-Summer 2000 issue of the <strong>MTA</strong> Journal.<br />
This article is available at http://<br />
www.hankpruden.com/nineclassic.pdf<br />
Hank also has been working with Cusp Theory<br />
to study market behavior. In the Winter-Spring<br />
20<strong>04</strong> issue of The Journal of Technical Analysis,<br />
Hank co-authors an article entitled, “Interpreting<br />
Data from an Experiment on Irrational Exuberance:<br />
Applying a Cusp Catastrophe Model and<br />
Technical Analysis Rules” which explains this<br />
effort. His co-authors Paranque and Baets are at<br />
the Euromed-Marseille Ecole de Management.<br />
Cusp Theory is useful to explain the tools of<br />
technical analysis, and may provide the mathematical<br />
tools to explain why the Wyckoff Method<br />
works. In the experiment described in the Journal<br />
article, Hank and his co-researchers observed that<br />
a collective irrationality drove members of the<br />
group. Others chose not to participate in a clearly<br />
overvalued market, and thus had no chance of<br />
winning. However, disinterested, outside observers<br />
would have been able to spot the awaiting<br />
calamity just by watching the price patterns<br />
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
emerge. While technical analysis captures the patterns<br />
of human behavior, Cusp Theory explains<br />
that behavior. Hank feels that this may be among<br />
the greatest contributions of Cusp Theory – reinforcing<br />
the fact that despite a human tendency to<br />
seek complex answers, simple information such<br />
as trendlines may be highly predictive of future<br />
price movements.<br />
Current Views<br />
At this time, Hank believes that the major trend<br />
indicators, such as classic Dow Theory and 200-<br />
day moving averages of the major indices, are the<br />
keys to understanding the current market. His<br />
Wyckoff analysis gave major signs of accumulation<br />
followed by the start of a cyclic bull market<br />
in 2002-2003. Adding cyclic analysis to the equation,<br />
he finds that we are in a dominant bull trend<br />
with expectable corrections until a top is reached,<br />
most likely in 2005. In “Wyckoff Laws: A Market<br />
Test,” published in the 20<strong>04</strong> issue of the IFTA<br />
Journal, Hank and Professor Belletante of<br />
Euromed-Marseille projected a target of 14,400<br />
on the DJIA, expected to occur in 2005. Thereafter,<br />
as he explained in a May-June 20<strong>04</strong> presentation<br />
in Mexico City, he anticipates a trading-range<br />
market reminiscent of the 1970s.<br />
Closing Advice<br />
Hank firmly believes that in knowledge, there<br />
is power. Those seeking to master technical analysis<br />
need to attain basic knowledge and practical<br />
skills of the field before risking their assets. Investors<br />
at all levels often underestimate the level<br />
of skill required in this profession. Hank encourages<br />
newcomers to read the books written by John<br />
Murphy and Martin Pring as a starting point. He<br />
also considers Edwin LeFevre’s classic “Reminiscences<br />
of a Stock Operator” to be required reading.<br />
Experiential learning is also valuable in this<br />
field; well guided experience can save a great deal<br />
of time and losses for new traders.<br />
For the past seven years, Hank has been in<br />
demand worldwide, addressing professional societies<br />
and portfolio managers in Japan, Australia,<br />
Sweden, Singapore, Iceland, Italy, the Netherlands,<br />
Denmark, Germany and Canada. He also counsels<br />
investors in his offices in San Francisco and<br />
in their home countries. For more information<br />
about Hank’s work, please see www.hank<br />
pruden.com<br />
Hank welcomes the opportunity to discuss introducing<br />
technical analysis into European and<br />
Middle Eastern universities. While working in<br />
Paris over the next year, he is available to meet<br />
with representatives of the academic community<br />
or any IFTA society to discuss appropriate tactics.<br />
Articles Wanted<br />
Send your articles to editor@mta.org<br />
Sedge Coppock at the <strong>MTA</strong><br />
Annual Seminar, May 1989,<br />
Naples, FL. Photo by Bill Doane<br />
www.mta.org<br />
Edwin Sedgwick Chittenden<br />
Coppock<br />
George Schade, CMT & John Carder, CMT<br />
When Sedge<br />
Coppock received the<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Annual Award<br />
in 1989, those fortunate<br />
enough to be in<br />
the audience that<br />
evening at the Registry<br />
Resort in Naples,<br />
Florida were treated<br />
to a moving and<br />
memorable event.<br />
Mr. Coppock’s acceptance<br />
speech was<br />
so insightful and educational<br />
that after more than an hour, the audience<br />
still demanded more and he was asked to return<br />
and continue the lecture, which he did, the next<br />
morning at 9 a.m. He was then 83 years old, and<br />
five months later he passed away.<br />
Coppock founded the Trendex Research Group<br />
in San Antonio, Texas. He published the weekly<br />
Stock Market Trendex, Texas Trader’s Relative<br />
Strength Trendex, Mutual Funds Performance<br />
Trendex, and the Commodity Trendex.<br />
His work has been described by one observer<br />
as “analyzing the patterns of human emotions in<br />
the stock market.” Coppock himself called his<br />
work “Emotional Indexing.” By “figuring people’s<br />
behaviors into economic trends,” Coppock identified<br />
“future stock market winners.”<br />
Coppock is best known for his studies on relative<br />
strength and the indicator originally known<br />
as Coppock’s “Very Long Term Investor’s Buying<br />
Guide” but today known for short as “VLT<br />
Momentum.” It is also know as the Coppock<br />
Curve, or more correctly reflecting the terminology<br />
he employed in a Barron’s article, the Coppock<br />
Guide.<br />
Relative Strength<br />
In 1957, Coppock wrote a monograph titled<br />
Practical Relative Strength Charting (republished<br />
in Investors Intelligence Encyclopedia of Stock<br />
Market Techniques, 1971). His work was based<br />
upon the Dow Jones 65-Stock Composite as the<br />
comparative index, and he used 8-week and 30-<br />
week moving averages (Coppock thought the use<br />
of 10-week MA was “intellectual laziness”). He<br />
found relative strength to be especially useful for<br />
intermediate and long term trading.<br />
Coppock possessed a rare ability to distill the<br />
complexity of his work into plain English. Relative<br />
strength “shows with great clarity which of<br />
the securities in question possesses the greater investment<br />
attraction,” and among its attributes are:<br />
“It permits dispassionate selection through making<br />
possible factual comparisons. It reveals at a glance<br />
the character of the current trend performance of a<br />
security. It shows when a trend that has persisted<br />
for a certain time is reaching exhaustion. It shows<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4 5
www.mta.org<br />
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
the start of new trends. It permits the long term<br />
investor to select future market leaders at the start<br />
of a major general market trend reversal.”<br />
Again demonstrating an ability to clearly explain<br />
his work, Coppock found that the RS line<br />
above its 18-week MA was bullish, under its 18-<br />
week MA was bearish. Renowned market analyst<br />
Marc Chaikin has confirmed this finding.<br />
VLT Momentum<br />
Coppock introduced his VLT Investor’s Buying<br />
Guide in an October 1962 Barron’s article. He<br />
wrote that this indicator was “A simple technique<br />
for evaluating emotional influences on the stock<br />
market...” and presented a “...picture of the emotional<br />
factor.” According to Coppock, “Time and<br />
change are the basic elements of a technique for<br />
evaluating trends influenced by emotional action.”<br />
To calculate the Coppock Guide:<br />
1. Calculate 11- and 14-month relative momentum.<br />
Relative momentum is the ratio of the<br />
current value to the old value. For example,<br />
11-month relative momentum is given by:<br />
RM11 = AverageCurrentAverageCurrent-11<br />
2. Average the 11- and 14-month relative momentums<br />
to obtain an average momentum.<br />
3. Smooth the average momentum with a 10-<br />
month front weighted moving average<br />
(FWMA). To do this, first multiply the current<br />
average momentum by 10, the previous average<br />
momentum by 9, the prior average momentum<br />
by 8, etc. Add the ten products and<br />
divide that sum by the sum of the weights,<br />
10+9+8+...+2+1, or 55.<br />
In words, the Coppock Guide is a front<br />
weighted moving average of average momentum.<br />
Because of the front weighting, the Coppock Guide<br />
reacts faster than a smoothed momentum indicator.<br />
Because of the moving average (and because<br />
it is applied to an average of two momentums), it<br />
does not whipsaw as much as momentum.<br />
Coppock used monthly closing prices, but he<br />
encouraged variations such as using average<br />
monthly prices, weekly data or a broader composite<br />
index. Steve Leuthold, in a 1988 <strong>MTA</strong> Journal<br />
article, found that closing prices work as well, or<br />
better, than average monthly prices.<br />
The Coppock Guide is designed to identify the<br />
commencement of bull markets. Interpretation of<br />
this indicator, according to Coppock, was “extremely<br />
simple.” He felt that investors should “Do<br />
major long-term buying of strong stocks when the<br />
curve first turns upward from a position below the<br />
zero line.” It “is best to think of the curve as a<br />
very-long-term buying guide. Its formula was devised<br />
for that type of use.” Coppock cautioned the<br />
VLT “is of no value whatever to an in-and-out<br />
trader.” The indicator is suitable for use on any<br />
major market index or average.<br />
Coppock found that the indicator had never<br />
failed since 1949. Steve Leuthold went back to<br />
1897, with excellent results, finding only one signal<br />
failure in August, 1931, but that failure disappears<br />
when average monthly prices are used for<br />
the calculation. In 1988, Leuthold wrote, “This<br />
technique has an almost perfect record in identifying<br />
low risk long term buying points. It doesn’t<br />
provide signals very often (only 12 since 1949),<br />
but when it does, it pays to pay attention.”<br />
This article is based upon the research of George A.<br />
Schade, Jr., CMT, and John Carder, CMT. Parts of it<br />
have been extracted from Topline’s Encyclopedia of<br />
Historical Charts, Volume 16 - Coppock Curves<br />
Interpreting Coppock Curves<br />
John Carder, CMT<br />
Edwin Sedgwick Chittenden (Sedge) Coppock<br />
published the formula for the Coppock Curve (or<br />
Coppock Guide) in Barron’s in 1962. He applied<br />
a front-weighted smoothing to an average of two<br />
momentums to produce an oscillator that was designed<br />
to identify significant bottoms in the stock<br />
market. It has proven to be remarkably resistant<br />
to whipsaws, and is fairly easy to use.<br />
Buy and Sell Signals<br />
In practice, there are two commonly accepted<br />
ways of interpreting a Coppock Curve.<br />
1. The first is to trade on reversals from extremes.<br />
When the indicator was published in Barron’s,<br />
it was intended to generate buy signals in the<br />
6<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
www.mta.org<br />
losing their money. As prices fall, they fear further<br />
losses, and sell stocks, accelerating the decline,<br />
and creating the spike bottom. Stock market<br />
tops tend to be much more gradual affairs. As<br />
stocks get more overvalued, companies are only<br />
too happy to satisfy demand by issuing more paper.<br />
The supply of stocks gradually overwhelms<br />
demand.<br />
Commodity markets<br />
Commodity markets tend to have the opposite<br />
behavior, with spike tops and rounding bottoms.<br />
Consequently, the Coppock Curve is better at identifying<br />
tops in commodities than bottoms. In commodity<br />
markets, the fear is that of commodity buyers<br />
(who typically produce added-value products<br />
from the commodity). Those buyers fear that they<br />
won’t be able to obtain sufficient supplies - a shortage.<br />
A cereal manufacturer would much rather<br />
pay more for corn than not have enough corn to<br />
make corn flakes. An oil refiner marks up the cost<br />
of crude when selling gasoline. The refiner would<br />
rather pay more for crude and charge more for<br />
gasoline than shut down the refinery.<br />
Currency markets<br />
Currencies tend to fall in the middle, since<br />
they’re symmetrical markets. Buyers and sellers<br />
are the same groups, they just have different nationalities.<br />
Consequently, reversals tend to be<br />
sharp, but the parabolic blow-offs of commodities<br />
and waterfall declines of stocks are not typical<br />
of currency markets. The Coppock Curve can<br />
be an excellent indicator for currencies, signaling<br />
both buys and sells. Because currency markets<br />
don’t often reach the one-sided, emotional extremes<br />
of stock and commodity markets, reversals<br />
in currency markets signaled by the Coppock<br />
Curve may not be as enduring as those in other<br />
markets.<br />
This article has been reprinted from Topline’s<br />
Encyclopedia of Historical Charts, Volume 16<br />
- Coppock Curves (http://www.chartguy.com/<br />
Encyclopedia/volume16listing.htm) with the<br />
permission of John Carder, CMT. For more<br />
information, please go http://<br />
www.chartguy.com/default.htm<br />
S&P 500 only, and the suggested signal was an<br />
upturn in the Coppock Curve from an extreme<br />
low. John Carder recalls that Tim Hayes suggested<br />
waiting for a decline of 0.065 after a<br />
peak above 1.15 to generate a sell signal. This<br />
combines elements of both methods, requiring<br />
a reversal from an extreme of sufficient magnitude.<br />
By waiting for a 0.065 decline, it also<br />
postpones the sell signal, improving performance<br />
in the stock market. Hayes’ suggestion<br />
appeared in his article, “The Coppock Guide,”<br />
in the March 1993 issue of Technical Analysis<br />
of Stocks and Commodities.<br />
2. The second interpretation involves divergence<br />
analysis. The initial thrust off of a low in the<br />
stock market is often accompanied by the highest<br />
Coppock Curve reading (peak momentum).<br />
Subsequent advances tend to be accompanied<br />
by diminishing momentum (lower peaks on the<br />
Coppock Curve). That combination of a higher<br />
peak in price accompanied by a lower peak in<br />
the Coppock Curve creates a bearish divergence.<br />
Those signals warn of a weakening, aging<br />
advance, but often precede the ultimate top.<br />
Coppock Curves and Sentiment in<br />
Different Markets<br />
Stock markets<br />
E.S. Coppock designed the indicator to identify<br />
significant lows in the stock market. The<br />
Coppock Curve is very good at discriminating<br />
between bear market rallies and true bottoms in<br />
the stock market. Stock markets tend to make spike<br />
bottoms and rounding tops. That is a result of the<br />
fact that fear is a stronger emotion than greed. At<br />
the end of a bear market in stocks, investors fear<br />
Late Breaking News<br />
Ross Lein<strong>web</strong>er, CMT<br />
Jason Goepfert of Sundial Capital Research,<br />
Inc. in Minnesota was selected by the judging<br />
panel on October 19th as the winner of the<br />
20<strong>04</strong> Charles H. Dow Award.<br />
His paper is entitled, “Mutual Fund Cash<br />
Reserves, the Risk Free Rate, and Stock Market<br />
Performance.”<br />
A copy of his paper is available in pdf format<br />
on the <strong>MTA</strong> <strong>web</strong>site: www.mta.org<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4 7
www.mta.org<br />
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
M T A B U S I N E S S<br />
Introduction to Your <strong>MTA</strong> Personal Home Page<br />
Tom MacMahon<br />
We would like to see more members and<br />
affiliates becoming familiar with their personal<br />
home page on the <strong>MTA</strong> <strong>web</strong>site. Therefore,<br />
over the next several issues, we will be<br />
introducing the various functions and features<br />
of one of the most valuable pieces of real<br />
estate which you personally own.<br />
First of all, to log in to your personal home<br />
page, go to our <strong>web</strong>site: www.mta.org<br />
Listed in the illustration are 4 key areas on<br />
your personal home page:<br />
Your Personal Records<br />
All your personal information is available<br />
for you to review and update<br />
Your Menu Choices<br />
Every program offered by the <strong>MTA</strong> is available<br />
for you can take advantage<br />
Current Events<br />
Links to information about regional meetings,<br />
<strong>web</strong>casts and special presentations are<br />
one click away!<br />
News & Announcements<br />
All the latest initiatives and information<br />
about what is happening in the <strong>MTA</strong>.<br />
Try out your personal home page right now<br />
and see for yourself just how much you can<br />
gain by using this incredible tool.<br />
Each month additional features will be discussed...<br />
stay tuned.<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Southern California Chapter<br />
The Southern California Chapter of the <strong>MTA</strong><br />
is back in business! Thanks go to Kirstin Hetzer<br />
for taking on the task of getting things back on<br />
track. If you are a Southern California member/<br />
affiliate or there on business, please make plans<br />
to attend and show your support.<br />
DATE: Tuesday, <strong>Nov</strong>ember 16, 20<strong>04</strong><br />
TIME:<br />
5:30 p.m. cocktails (cash bar)<br />
6:30 p.m. dinner<br />
7:00 p.m. Guest Speaker,<br />
Fred Meissner and technician roundtable<br />
LOCATION:<br />
Spagatini’s Italian Grill and Jazz Club,<br />
Seal Beach (405 Freeway, Seal Beach<br />
Boulevard)<br />
COST:<br />
$45 per person/<strong>MTA</strong> member/affiliate,<br />
$55 per person non <strong>MTA</strong><br />
RSVP REQUIRED:<br />
Kristin Hetzer, 562/495-5580,<br />
kvph@cox.net<br />
OR Phil Caruso, 805/658-7938<br />
pay at the door<br />
8<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
www.mta.org<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Calendar of Events<br />
20<strong>04</strong>-2005<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 9: Boston Chapter Meeting<br />
Contact: Chuck Dukas, chuck@trend<br />
advisor.com<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 10<br />
Technically Speaking submissions due to<br />
market.strategist@wyowbi.com<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 11: Cincinnati Chapter Meeting<br />
Contact: Ron Brandt, 513/622-5421,<br />
traderon@aol.com<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 14: Minneapolis Chapter Meeting<br />
Contact: Pat McGrath, 612/671-9809,<br />
tradinpat@hotmail.com<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 15: New York Chapter Meeting<br />
Contact: Cassandra Townes, admin@mta.org<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 16: Los Angeles (reopened chapter)<br />
Contact: Kristin Hutzer, kvph@cox.net<br />
<strong>Nov</strong>ember 17: Chicago Chapter Meeting<br />
Contact: Ross Lein<strong>web</strong>er, rlein<strong>web</strong>er@<br />
lakeshoretrading.com<br />
2005<br />
January 21-22: Mid-Winter Retreat<br />
The <strong>MTA</strong> is introducing an annual mid-year<br />
Retreat at the Sheraton San Diego Hotel &<br />
Marina, San Diego, CA. Complete details<br />
will be available on pages 9-11.<br />
March 11: <strong>MTA</strong> @ MIT<br />
Marriott Cambridge Hotel, Cambridge, MA<br />
details in the December issue of Technically<br />
Speaking.<br />
May 19-22: <strong>MTA</strong> Annual Seminar<br />
Hotel Pennsylvania, New York City.<br />
Complete details will be available by the first<br />
of the year.<br />
For the latest information on chapter meeting<br />
times and locations, log into www.mta.org/<br />
membership/meetings/<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Board Minutes<br />
Minutes from <strong>MTA</strong> Board of Directors meetings<br />
are available from your personal home page<br />
of the <strong>web</strong>site, click on Meeting Minutes from<br />
left hand menu.<br />
Complete Retreat Brochure available: www.mta.org/seminars<br />
Market Technicians Association, Inc.<br />
You are cordially invited to the<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Mid-Winter Retreat<br />
21-22 January 2005, San Diego, CA<br />
Please join us at this unique coming together<br />
of the best minds in technical analysis.<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> members and affiliates, IFTA colleagues<br />
and other professionals will gather<br />
to share research, data and new ideas in a<br />
relaxed and creative atmosphere. The best<br />
of the best in our business will reflect on the<br />
progress made in technical analysis over the<br />
last few years as well as exchange their latest<br />
insights into new developments in the<br />
field.<br />
The Retreat experience will be a concentrated<br />
distilling of the very best technical<br />
thinking available anywhere. New and classical<br />
technical tools and approaches will be<br />
examined in depth through years of experience<br />
and accumulated wisdom. Total participation<br />
on the part of every attendee will<br />
be ensured through the skills of the facilitators.<br />
Each facilitator will be an experienced<br />
technician dedicated to furthering the understanding<br />
and use of technical analysis in their<br />
area of specialization.<br />
This may be your once-in-a-lifetime opportunity<br />
to sit down and discuss all the<br />
apsects of technical analysis with the best in<br />
our industry.<br />
RSVP by December 23<br />
www.mta.org/seminars<br />
SM<br />
An <strong>MTA</strong> Retreat at a<br />
perfect San Diego retreat....<br />
For the Mid-Winter Retreat, the <strong>MTA</strong><br />
has chosen the Sheraton San Diego Hotel &<br />
Marina on Harbor Island in San Diego, CA.<br />
It is the perfect setting – this hotel puts the<br />
“treat” in Retreat.<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Retreat 2005: where <strong>MTA</strong> Members/Affiliates<br />
and IFTA Colleagues will<br />
come together to have the opportunity to<br />
interact with each other, to rekindle longtime<br />
relationships and to share groundbreaking<br />
ideas with their colleagues – all in<br />
a relaxed, informal atmosphere. These ideas<br />
will be the core of the Retreat experience<br />
and each attendee will be encouraged to participate<br />
in all discussions. The format will<br />
be highly interactive and extremely participatory<br />
– sessions facilitated by experts in<br />
the subject area being discussed – sharing<br />
the latest, the newest and the most-advanced<br />
techniques.<br />
Attendance will be limited to the first<br />
100 who register ... with only 25 attending<br />
each session. There will be 8 subjects from<br />
which to choose and each attendee will be<br />
able to participate in 4 sessions – 2 on Friday<br />
and Saturday. These choices must be<br />
pre-registered.<br />
Fees (see fees section on the registration<br />
form on page 5) for the weekend include<br />
hotel room for Thursday and Friday nights,<br />
breakfast and lunch on Friday and Saturday<br />
and a cocktail reception on Friday evening.<br />
There is a rate for those who live in the San<br />
Diego area and do not require a hotel room.<br />
Spouses and guests are cordially invited to<br />
attend all the meal functions at a special<br />
rate. Attendees are invited to arrive early<br />
and stay later at the Retreat room rate – check<br />
the appropriate box on the Registration Form<br />
and reservations will be made.<br />
Complete details are available on<br />
www.mta.org/seminars. Agenda and Registration<br />
Form on Pages 10-11.<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4 9
www.mta.org<br />
Richard Russell<br />
T E C H N I C A L L Y S P E A K I N G<br />
Agenda - <strong>MTA</strong> Mid-Winter Retreat2005<br />
THURSDAY, 20 JANUARY<br />
3:00 6:00 Registration<br />
Jordan Kotick, CMT<br />
Phil Roth, CMT<br />
Gabe Wisdom<br />
Chris Ruspi, CMT<br />
John Bollinger, CFA, CMT<br />
Ken Tower, CMT<br />
Jeanette Young, CFP, CMT<br />
Rick Bensignor<br />
Mike Epstein<br />
FRIDAY, 21 JANUARY<br />
7:30 9:00 Registration<br />
7:30 8:45 Breakfast<br />
9:00 11:30 Four Sessions - choose one<br />
Managing Portfolios Using Technical Analysis: A discussion of the principals for using TA in the real world<br />
Facilitator: Christopher M. Ruspi CMT, President, Applied Financial Wisdom<br />
Tom DeMark Models – does trading success come from using his work scientifically, artistically or both?<br />
Facilitator: Rick Bensignor, Chief Technical Strategist, Morgan Stanley<br />
Point & Figure Charting – ancient methods in modern markets<br />
Facilitator: Kenneth Tower, CMT, Chief Market Strategist, CyberTrader, Inc.<br />
Sentiment Indicators – why investors make bottoms and traders make tops<br />
Facilitator: Philip Roth, CMT, Chief Technical Analyst, Miller Tabak + Co.<br />
11:30 1:30 Lunch and speaker: John Bollinger, CFA, CMT, BollingerBands.com<br />
1:30 4:00 Four Sessions - choose one<br />
Modern Portfolio Theory & Technical Analysis – technical analysis goes to college<br />
Facilitator: Mike Epstein, Visiting Scholar, MIT Laboratory for Financial Engineering<br />
Elliott Wave Theory – navigating the markets<br />
Facilitator: Jordan Kotick, CMT, Head of Technical Analysis, Barclays Capital<br />
Advanced Trading Techniques – how losses are turned into gains and how to spread futures<br />
Facilitator: Jeanette Young, CFP, CMT, Floor Broker/Trader, New York Board of Trade<br />
Presidential Politics and the Markets – the 4-year cycle lives<br />
Facilitator: Gabriel Wisdom, Managing Director, American Money Management LLC<br />
5:00 6:30 Reception<br />
SATURDAY, 22 JANUARY<br />
7:30 8:45 Breakfast<br />
9:00 11:30 Four Sessions - choose one<br />
Modern Portfolio Theory & Technical Analysis – technical analysis goes to college<br />
Facilitator: Mike Epstein, Visiting Scholar, MIT Laboratory for Financial Engineering<br />
Elliott Wave Theory – navigating the markets<br />
Facilitator: Jordan Kotick, CMT, Head of Technical Analysis, Barclays Capital<br />
Advanced Trading Techniques – how losses are turned into gains and how to spread futures<br />
Facilitator: Jeanette Young, CFP, CMT, Floor Broker/Trader, New York Board of Trade<br />
Presidential Politics and the Markets – the 4-year cycle lives<br />
Facilitator: Gabriel Wisdom, Managing Director, American Money Management LLC<br />
11:30 1:30 Lunch and speaker: Richard Russell, Dow Theory Letter<br />
1:30 4:00 Four Sessions - choose one<br />
Managing Portfolios Using Technical Analysis: A discussion of the principals for using TA in the real world<br />
Facilitator: Christopher M. Ruspi CMT, President, Applied Financial Wisdom<br />
Tom DeMark Models – does trading success come from using his work scientifically, artistically or both?<br />
Facilitator: Rick Bensignor, Chief Technical Strategist, Morgan Stanley<br />
Point & Figure Charting – ancient methods in modern markets<br />
Facilitator: Kenneth Tower, CMT, Chief Market Strategist, CyberTrader, Inc.<br />
Sentiment Indicators – why investors make bottoms and traders make tops<br />
Facilitator: Philip Roth, CMT, Chief Technical Analyst, Miller Tabak + Co.<br />
10<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4
Please register T E C H online: N I C A L L Y S www.mta.org/seminars<br />
P E A K I N G<br />
Retreat Registration Form<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Mid-Winter Retreat • San Diego, CA • 21 - 22 January 2005<br />
www.mta.org<br />
First Name<br />
Last Name<br />
Company<br />
Street Address<br />
City<br />
Post Code/Zip Code<br />
Office Phone<br />
Office Fax<br />
State/Province<br />
Country<br />
Office E-mail<br />
Home E-mail<br />
Please pre-register for the following<br />
Friday Morning Session Friday Afternoon Session Saturday Morning Session Saturday Afternoon Session<br />
■ TA in Portfolio Management ■ TA & Modern Portfolio Theory ■ TA & Modern Portfolio Theory ■ TA in Portfolio Management<br />
■ Tom DeMark Models ■ Elliott Wave Theory ■ Elliott Wave Theory ■ Tom DeMark Models<br />
■ Point & Figure Charting ■ Advanced Trading Techniques ■ Advanced Trading Techniques ■ Point & Figure Charting<br />
■ Sentiment Indicators ■ Politics and the Markets ■ Politics and the Markets ■ Sentiment Indicators<br />
Fees<br />
■ $US 950 <strong>MTA</strong> Member/Affiliate or IFTA Colleague (Retreat, meals, hotel)<br />
■ $US 1,150 Non-<strong>MTA</strong> Member/Affiliate or Non-IFTA Colleague (Retreat, meals, hotel)<br />
■ $US 750 <strong>MTA</strong> Member/Affiliate or IFTA Colleague – No Hotel (Retreat, meals)<br />
■ $US 950 Non-<strong>MTA</strong> Member/Affiliate or IFTA Colleague – No Hotel (Retreat, meals)<br />
■ $US 175 Spouse/Guest<br />
■ $US 209 Room Rate for extra nights (Wednesday, Saturday, Sunday) X _________ nights<br />
Arrival Date: ______________________________ Departure Date: ___________________________<br />
Room Style: ■ King bed ■ 2 Double beds<br />
Smoking: ■ Smoking ■ Non-Smoking<br />
DEADLINES<br />
● The Retreat is limited to the first 100 registrants only.<br />
● Retreat registration closes Thursday, December 23.<br />
●<br />
●<br />
Cancellation / Refund Policy<br />
All cancellation requests must be made in writing<br />
to the Hansen Management office.<br />
No refund if cancelled after December 23. Before<br />
December 23 refund subject to another attendee<br />
filling your space.<br />
Payment<br />
Please debit my: ■ VISA ■ MasterCard ■ American Express<br />
Card Number:<br />
$US Total Amount:<br />
Exp. Date:<br />
Name on Card:<br />
Billing Address:<br />
City:<br />
Country:<br />
State/Province:<br />
Zip/Postal Code:<br />
■ Check Payment. Amount $______________ Please enclose along with your registration form and payment (payable to Hansen Management in U.S.$ on a U.S. bank) and<br />
mail to Hansen Management, 151 Herricks Road, Suite 101, Garden City Park, NY 11<strong>04</strong>0<br />
Air Reservations: <strong>MTA</strong> has a discount plan through American Airlines. Please call: 800-433-1790 to make your reservation and mention code: 4415AJ to receive the discounted<br />
price.<br />
Car Rental: Discount arrangements have been made with Avis Car Rental. Call 1-800-331-1600 or online at www.avis.com/AvisWeb/html/meetings/go.html?2838 and use the<br />
AWD #D087878 to receive the discounted rate. Rates include unlimited free mileage and rates are available from January 13-30th.<br />
Questions about the seminar are answered by e-mailing retreat@mta.org<br />
N O V E M B E R 2 0 0 4 11
www.mta.org<br />
T E C H N I C A L L Y<br />
S P E A K I N G<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> Regional Chapters Need Your Help<br />
If you are visiting any of these chapter areas over the next several months and might be willing to make a presentation to the local group,<br />
please contact the regional chapter chair as noted to work something out. Some are long-standing chapters, some are trying to get<br />
started, but ALL of them are in need of speakers now and then.<br />
Atlanta Tim Snavely 4<strong>04</strong>/926-5473 tim_snavely@rhco.com<br />
Austin Sean Mackie 512/517-6506 sean_mackie@amat.com<br />
Baltimore Bernard Kavanagh 410/454-4078 bjkavanagh@leggmason.com<br />
Boston Chuck Dukas 508/366-6102 chuck@trendadvisor.com<br />
Chicago Ross Lein<strong>web</strong>er 847/849-8236 Rlein<strong>web</strong>er@lakeshoretrading.com<br />
Cincinnati Ron Brandt 513/622-5421 traderon@aol.com<br />
DC/Northern Virginia Cary Greenspan 703/442-9225 greenspanc@aol.com<br />
Denver Lyle Dokken 970/226-4707 klyledokken@yahoo.com<br />
Houston Randi Shea randi@prismtrading.com<br />
Las Vegas Dennis Costarakis 702/733-9030 dennis.costarakis@agedwards.com<br />
Minneapolis Pat McGrath 612/671-9809 tradinpat@hotmail.com<br />
New York City Jeanette Young optnqueen@aol.com<br />
Portland, Oregon Leonard H. Smith lensmith@teleport.com (Under Construction)<br />
San Antonio Duke Jones 210/213-7813 duke.jones@sectorrotationfund.com<br />
San Diego Julia Bussie 858/350-8101 jebussie@aol.com<br />
Virginia/SE Dave Clemens 757/229-6111 DRClemens@LeggMason.com<br />
If you have any questions about the regional chapters, please contact the Regions Chairperson, Tim Snavely, 4<strong>04</strong>/926-5473; tim_snavely@rhco.com<br />
Board of Directors<br />
Director: President<br />
Frederick Meissner, Jr., CMT<br />
4<strong>04</strong>/875-3733<br />
fmeissner@mta.org<br />
Director: Vice President<br />
Jordan Kotick, CMT<br />
212/412-1137<br />
jordan.kotick@barcap.com<br />
Director: Treasurer<br />
John Kosar, CMT<br />
847/3<strong>04</strong>-1511, fax 847/3<strong>04</strong>-1749<br />
kosar@dls.net<br />
Director: Secretary<br />
David Clemens, CMT<br />
757/239-6111, Fax: 757/239-6535<br />
dave.clemens@cox.net<br />
Director: Past President<br />
Ralph Acampora, CMT<br />
212/778-2273, Fax: 212/778-1208<br />
ralph_acampora@prusec.com<br />
Directors:<br />
Mike Epstein<br />
617/253-3784<br />
mepstein@mit.edu<br />
<strong>MTA</strong> 20<strong>04</strong>-2006 Board of Directors and Committee Chairs<br />
Philip Roth, CMT<br />
212/370-0<strong>04</strong>0, Fax: 212/697-7106<br />
proth@millertabak.com<br />
Michael Kahn<br />
516/647-7466<br />
michaelkahn@lycos.com<br />
Jon S. (Duke) Jones, CMT<br />
210/213-7813<br />
duke.jones@sectorrotationfund.com<br />
Committee Chairs<br />
Academic Liaison, Journal<br />
Charles Kirkpatrick II, CMT<br />
970/884-0821, Fax: 970/884-0823<br />
kirkco@capecod.net<br />
Accreditation<br />
Les Williams, CMT<br />
817/571-8332, Fax: 817/571-5889<br />
capitalmgt@hotmail.com<br />
Admissions<br />
Andrew Bekoff<br />
646/576-2748, Fax: 646/576-2755<br />
abekoff@bloomberg.net<br />
Body of Knowledge<br />
Frederick Meissner, Jr., CMT<br />
4<strong>04</strong>/875-3733<br />
fmeissner@mta.org<br />
Education, Library, and<br />
Distance Learning<br />
Philip Roth, CMT<br />
212/370-0<strong>04</strong>0, Fax: 212/697-7106<br />
proth@millertabak.com<br />
Ethics & Standards<br />
Neal Genda, CMT<br />
310/888-6416, Fax: 310/888-6388<br />
neal.genda@cnb.com<br />
Foundation<br />
Mike Epstein<br />
617/876-5615<br />
mepstein@mit.edu<br />
IFTA Liaison<br />
Larry Berman, CFA, CMT<br />
416/594-8067<br />
larry.berman@cibc.ca<br />
Internship<br />
Mark Eidem, CMT<br />
415/296-7831<br />
alaskatrader78@yahoo.com<br />
Marketing<br />
Membership<br />
Newsletter<br />
Mike Carr, CMT<br />
307/632-3027<br />
editor@mta.org<br />
Placement<br />
Programs (NY)<br />
Jeanette Young, CMT<br />
optnqueen@aol.com<br />
Regions<br />
Timothy Snavely, CMT<br />
4<strong>04</strong>/926-5473, Fax: 4<strong>04</strong>/926-5946<br />
tim_snavely@rhco.com<br />
Rules<br />
Charles Comer, CMT<br />
516/883-9375, Fax: 516/883-9371<br />
chascomer@mindspring.com<br />
Seminar<br />
David Clemens, CMT<br />
757/229-6111, Fax: 757/229-6535<br />
dave.clemens@cox.net<br />
CMT is a service mark of the<br />
Market Technicians Association, Inc.