Behavioural Surveillance Surveys - The Wisdom of Whores

Behavioural Surveillance Surveys - The Wisdom of Whores Behavioural Surveillance Surveys - The Wisdom of Whores

wisdomofwhores.com
from wisdomofwhores.com More from this publisher
14.03.2015 Views

Irrespective of the sampling strategy used, the guidance provided earlier concerning numbers of schools and PSU’s also applies to data collection outside of classes. Choosing not less than 10-15 schools and 30 or more “clusters” across sample schools is strongly recommended. Also note that in order for a self-weighted sample to result, the same number of clusters (i.e., either classes/sections or time-location PSU’s) of equal size should be chosen in each sample school. Out of school youth - surveys of youth in the workplace In order to obtain behavioral survey data on out-of-school youth, it will be necessary to first determine where such youth may be found. One possibility is to interview youth at business establishments that typically employ significant numbers of youth. Examples of “workplace” sampling frames for youth in the informal sector would be businesses employing apprentices, helpers of truck/bus/ van drivers, motorcycle taxi drivers and female domestic workers. As the types of businesses/occupations with significant numbers of youth are likely to vary from setting to setting, a generic sampling approach is proposed here. The recommended approach is a cluster sample design, with business establishments employing youth being chosen at the first stage of sample selection. As with most sub-population surveys, the sampling frame development process will begin with consultations with key informants and members of the population themselves, the purpose of which is to determine businesses that employ youth and the number of youth that are typically found at such businesses. Once the sampling frame has been developed, a sample of workplaces can be chosen, as was described in Chapter 4, either with probability proportional to size (PPS) or with equal probability. PPS selection should be used when establishments vary significantly in terms of numbers of youth employees, for example, if some establishments have 3-4 times as many youth workers as smaller establishments. Where the numbers of youth employees associated with establishments are roughly comparable (i.e., vary in size by a factor of less than three), sampling with equal probability will suffice. If the number of workers who may be present at sample establishments is likely to vary from day to day, it is recommended that time-location cluster sampling be used, as described in Chapter 4. Surveys of youth with no fixed residence (street kids) For youth that do not have a fixed place of residence, the sampling approaches described above for other categories of youth will be inappropriate. However, a modified cluster sampling approach in which neighborhoods, city blocks, public parks, and other locations where youth with no fixed residence are known to congregate are used as PSU’s. This application of cluster sampling methods is similar to that for floating populations, described in Chapter 4. The sampling frame development process will consist of “up-front” research to determine the locations within the geographic universe for the survey where such youth can be found, the days and times that are the “peak” and “off-peak” times, and (if possible) the number of youth that might be expected to be B EHAV I OR A L S U R V EI L L A NC E SURV EY S APPEN DI X 3 333

found at the various locations at different times. This last piece of information is needed to help determine the cluster size, that is the number of people it will be possible to sample from each PSU (time-location cluster). Once the information has been gathered, it is then possible to construct a sampling frame consisting of time-location segments, which are used as PSU’s. Parental consent for youth It is worth mentioning that although oral informed consent from respondents is routine practice for BSS surveys, in some settings, when working with young people, under the age of 18 years or so, it is necessary also to obtain parental consent. The necessity for this is highly variable, depending on locally accepted research practices, and the guidelines of those who are funding the research. If parental consent is required, it is important to take steps to minimize the bias that this might potentially cause. At a minimum, even if parents would like to review the contents of the questionnaire before it is administered, it is best if the interview itself be conducted outside the earshot of parents. It is also a good idea to track the refusal rate of parents, in order to assess how much non-response bias might be influencing the results. Obviously in the case of street kids, it will not be possible to obtain parental consent. Mobile populations Mobile populations are of concern for HIV/ AIDS programs because of their potential for engaging in risky behavior. Transportation workers, for example, often spend extended period of time away from home, and the frequency of engaging in casual sexual relationships buying sex from sex workers is probably higher than in the general population in most settings. Migrant laborers also work away from home, in factories, plantations and mining towns, to name a few. Merchants who import and export also travel frequently, both domestically and internationally. The general recommended sampling approach for mobile populations is similar to that of other floating populations. The only major difference lies in the nature of the “sites” to be used as PSU’s for cluster sampling. Appropriate sites or PSU’s for long distance transportation workers could be truck stops, depots or customs checkpoints, hotels where mobile populations congregate in significant numbers. The initial step is the development of a sampling frame of sites where such persons congregate. This will require consultation with key informants and members of the population. In compiling the list of sites, attention should be paid to ensuring that the sampling frame covers all geographic parts of the survey universe. Once a list of establishments has been developed, time location sampling units should be created for use as PSU’s. For example, if 20 truck stops were to be identified and if truck stops were to be open seven days per week, a total of 140 PSU’s would be created. Note, however, that if preliminary research were to indicate that different types of transportation workers frequented truck stops during the daylight hours than at night, PSU’s might be further divided into day-night segments, yielding a total of 280 PSU’s. As for the other subpopulations, the list of PSU’s should be ordered geographically and (if relevant) by type of site prior to sample selection. 334 A PPEN DI X 3 B EHAV I OR A L SURV EI L L A NC E S U R V EY S

Irrespective <strong>of</strong> the sampling strategy used,<br />

the guidance provided earlier concerning<br />

numbers <strong>of</strong> schools and PSU’s also applies to<br />

data collection outside <strong>of</strong> classes. Choosing<br />

not less than 10-15 schools and 30 or more<br />

“clusters” across sample schools is strongly<br />

recommended. Also note that in order for<br />

a self-weighted sample to result, the same<br />

number <strong>of</strong> clusters (i.e., either classes/sections<br />

or time-location PSU’s) <strong>of</strong> equal size should<br />

be chosen in each sample school.<br />

Out <strong>of</strong> school youth - surveys <strong>of</strong> youth in the<br />

workplace<br />

In order to obtain behavioral survey data<br />

on out-<strong>of</strong>-school youth, it will be necessary to<br />

first determine where such youth may be<br />

found. One possibility is to interview youth at<br />

business establishments that typically employ<br />

significant numbers <strong>of</strong> youth. Examples <strong>of</strong><br />

“workplace” sampling frames for youth in<br />

the informal sector would be businesses<br />

employing apprentices, helpers <strong>of</strong> truck/bus/<br />

van drivers, motorcycle taxi drivers and female<br />

domestic workers.<br />

As the types <strong>of</strong> businesses/occupations<br />

with significant numbers <strong>of</strong> youth are likely to<br />

vary from setting to setting, a generic sampling<br />

approach is proposed here. <strong>The</strong> recommended<br />

approach is a cluster sample design, with<br />

business establishments employing youth<br />

being chosen at the first stage <strong>of</strong> sample<br />

selection. As with most sub-population<br />

surveys, the sampling frame development<br />

process will begin with consultations with key<br />

informants and members <strong>of</strong> the population<br />

themselves, the purpose <strong>of</strong> which is to<br />

determine businesses that employ youth and<br />

the number <strong>of</strong> youth that are typically found<br />

at such businesses.<br />

Once the sampling frame has been<br />

developed, a sample <strong>of</strong> workplaces can be<br />

chosen, as was described in Chapter 4, either<br />

with probability proportional to size (PPS) or<br />

with equal probability. PPS selection should<br />

be used when establishments vary significantly<br />

in terms <strong>of</strong> numbers <strong>of</strong> youth employees, for<br />

example, if some establishments have 3-4<br />

times as many youth workers as smaller<br />

establishments. Where the numbers <strong>of</strong> youth<br />

employees associated with establishments are<br />

roughly comparable (i.e., vary in size by a<br />

factor <strong>of</strong> less than three), sampling with equal<br />

probability will suffice.<br />

If the number <strong>of</strong> workers who may be<br />

present at sample establishments is likely to<br />

vary from day to day, it is recommended that<br />

time-location cluster sampling be used,<br />

as described in Chapter 4.<br />

<strong>Surveys</strong> <strong>of</strong> youth with no fixed residence<br />

(street kids)<br />

For youth that do not have a fixed place <strong>of</strong><br />

residence, the sampling approaches described<br />

above for other categories <strong>of</strong> youth will be<br />

inappropriate. However, a modified cluster<br />

sampling approach in which neighborhoods,<br />

city blocks, public parks, and other locations<br />

where youth with no fixed residence are<br />

known to congregate are used as PSU’s.<br />

This application <strong>of</strong> cluster sampling methods<br />

is similar to that for floating populations,<br />

described in Chapter 4.<br />

<strong>The</strong> sampling frame development process<br />

will consist <strong>of</strong> “up-front” research to determine<br />

the locations within the geographic universe<br />

for the survey where such youth can be<br />

found, the days and times that are the “peak”<br />

and “<strong>of</strong>f-peak” times, and (if possible) the<br />

number <strong>of</strong> youth that might be expected to be<br />

B EHAV I OR A L S U R V EI L L A NC E SURV EY S APPEN DI X 3<br />

333

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!