14.03.2015 Views

Polar Wander and Global Tectonics

Polar Wander and Global Tectonics

Polar Wander and Global Tectonics

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

SGI 011<br />

The paper copy of the corrected proofs must be received<br />

by the typographic office before August 28, 2005.<br />

The address is: Grafica Crystal, via Raffaele Paolucci 12/14,<br />

00152 Roma, Italy – graficacristal@mclink.it<br />

Boll. Soc. Geol. It., Volume Speciale n. 5 (2005), 00-00, 8 ff.<br />

<strong>Polar</strong> <strong>W<strong>and</strong>er</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Global</strong> <strong>Tectonics</strong><br />

K.M. STORETVEDT (*)<br />

ABSTRACT<br />

Evidence suggests that irregularly-distributed degassing of the<br />

Earth has produced lateral physico-chemical variations in the mantle<br />

which in turn have instigated changes in the planet’s moments of<br />

inertia. Intermittent events of spatial reorientation of the globe<br />

(polar w<strong>and</strong>er) <strong>and</strong> a mixture of continual <strong>and</strong> episodic changes of<br />

planetary spin rate have ensued. Thus, the developing lithosphere<br />

has time <strong>and</strong> again been subjected to stepwise latitude-dependant<br />

torsion (wrenching) producing fold belts along time-equivalent equators,<br />

with a second set of tectonomagmatic rift belts evolving in<br />

palaeomeridional settings. Due to Earth’s rotational slowing through<br />

time, the rift belts – oriented orthogonal to, <strong>and</strong> breaking away from,<br />

their corresponding palaeoequators – were of much greater significance<br />

in the Precambrian than during the Phanerozoic. However, in<br />

the course of time the global tectonic pattern has changed in concurrence<br />

with events of polar w<strong>and</strong>er – the equatorial bulge <strong>and</strong> associated<br />

fold belt have now <strong>and</strong> then shifted their position across the<br />

globe. The relatively fast-spinning Archaean Earth had approximately<br />

its present spatial setting, but at around the Archaean-Proterozoic<br />

boundary a major event of polar w<strong>and</strong>er took place, heralding<br />

a significant change in Earth history. Inertia-driven continental<br />

rotations, producing the presently-observed discrepancies in palaeomagnetic<br />

polar w<strong>and</strong>er paths, basically dates from the time of the<br />

Alpine climax.<br />

KEY<br />

WORDS: Planetary degassing, Moments of inertia,<br />

<strong>Polar</strong> <strong>W<strong>and</strong>er</strong>, Earth’s rotation rate, Gross pattern of<br />

tectonic belts.<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

It appears that it was the Austrian geologist A.<br />

Damian Kreichgauer who first suggested a dynamic link<br />

between global tectonics <strong>and</strong> the Earth’s rotation (KRE-<br />

ICHGAUER, 1902). Kreichgauer discovered the pole-fleeing<br />

force, i.e. the combined effect of the dynamics of Earth<br />

rotation <strong>and</strong> the principle of isostasy, later named the<br />

Eøtvøs force (EØTVØS, 1913). This equatorward force of<br />

crustal motion, directed away from the poles (Polflucht),<br />

would have produced fold belts in general alignment with<br />

time-equivalent equators, while a second set of tectonomagmatic<br />

belts would have evolved in meridional settings<br />

– owing to the westward directed tidal drag from the Sun<br />

<strong>and</strong> Moon. Based on a straithforward interpretation of<br />

ancient climates derived from rocks <strong>and</strong> fossils, polar<br />

w<strong>and</strong>er seemed a necessity. For dynamical reasons, the<br />

rotational axis had to be aligned along, or to remain in<br />

the vicinity of, the principal axis of inertia: it became,<br />

therefore, an inevitable conclusion that internal axial<br />

shifts had intermittently occurred during the Earth’s history.<br />

In other words, the apparent displacement of the<br />

pole over the surface was a result of the Earth’s body<br />

(*) Institute of Geophysics, University of Bergen, N-5007 Bergen,<br />

Norway – Fax: +47 55 58 98 83; email: karsten@gfi.uib.no<br />

intermittently turning over relative to space. In the mid<br />

1950s the principle of polar w<strong>and</strong>er was confirmed by<br />

palaeomagnetism (CREER et alii, 1954; RUNCORN, 1955).<br />

In the Kreichgauer dynamic system, the required<br />

changes in the Earth’s axes of inertia were brought about<br />

by the equatorward <strong>and</strong> westward displacements of the<br />

entire crust, without significant lateral continental<br />

motions. Changes of the relative position of the palaeoequator<br />

would then have given rise to tectonic belts in<br />

variable orientations across the globe. Thus, by combining<br />

palaeoclimatic observations with the observed global<br />

tectonic system, for different geological epochs, Kreichgauer<br />

was able to draw polar paths that show remarkable<br />

similarities to modern polar w<strong>and</strong>ering curves based on<br />

palaeomagnetic data (STORETVEDT, 1997, 2003). In Kreichgauer’s<br />

scheme, the meridional ‘mountain belts’ were<br />

rifted zones (Strichen) trending at approximately right<br />

angles to their corresponding downfaulted <strong>and</strong> compressed<br />

equatorial seating – the classical geosynclines –<br />

constituting an elongated crustal depression (Äquatormülde)<br />

around the globe. Fig. 1 shows the palaeoequators<br />

for the late Proterozoic (a) <strong>and</strong> late Archaean (b) respectively,<br />

drawn by KREICHGAUER (1902).<br />

Reflecting on the battle surrounding the interpretation<br />

of palaeomagnetic data in the late 1950s, it is difficult<br />

to underst<strong>and</strong> that the prominent English pysicists,<br />

at the principal scenes of fact gathering <strong>and</strong> global geomagnetic<br />

discussion, did not consider seriously (if at all)<br />

the role of inertia effects as the adequate driving force for<br />

continental mobility – to account for intercontinental<br />

palaeomagnetic discrepancies. After all, Kreichgauer’s<br />

global model – explaining prominent aspects such as the<br />

repositioning of the global climate system through time,<br />

the phenomenon of polar w<strong>and</strong>er, <strong>and</strong> the shifting tectonic<br />

configuration since the Precambrian – had in fact a<br />

much greater explanatory power than Wegener’s continental<br />

drift or any other global tectonic model, past <strong>and</strong><br />

present. Regarding palaeoclimatology <strong>and</strong> polar w<strong>and</strong>er<br />

Wegener built extensively on Kreichgauer’s work, but<br />

being a meteorologist he was basically ignorant about<br />

geology <strong>and</strong> tectonics, <strong>and</strong> therefore he overlooked Kreichgauer’s<br />

tectonic scheme. It is important to note that<br />

Kreichgauer’s continental arrangement is still valid to a<br />

good first order approximation, as the needed changes of<br />

continental azimuths, to account for intercontinental<br />

palaeomagnetic discrepancies, are only minor (STO-<br />

RETVEDT, 1990, 1997, 2003). In any case, it certainly<br />

required no deep perception on Wegener’s part to see that<br />

Kreichgauer’s model was at variance with his own pet<br />

idea: lateral continental motions. Thus, preconception<br />

was certainly an important part of the reason why<br />

Wegener rejected much of Kreichgauer’s work, accusing<br />

him of having a muddled underst<strong>and</strong>ing of Earth history.


2 K.M. STORETVEDT<br />

Fig. 1 - Tentative orientation of the palaeoequator for two different<br />

different Precambrian epochs, based on a combination of ancient<br />

climates (from rock evidence) <strong>and</strong> the location of time-equivalent<br />

tectonomagmatic belts: (a) late Proterozoic <strong>and</strong> (b) late Archaean.<br />

Simplified after KREICHGAUER (1902).<br />

But drifting continents clearly provided a more ‘dramatic’<br />

<strong>and</strong> entertaining story than the fairly ‘static’ crustal model<br />

of Kreichgauer, <strong>and</strong> probably for that reason alone,<br />

Wegener’s book was translated into several languages,<br />

including English, while Kreichgauer’s work does not<br />

seem to have reached beyond the German speaking<br />

world. One may wonder what would have been the outcome<br />

had Kreichgauer’s treatise, rather than Wegener’s,<br />

been translated into English <strong>and</strong> then been available to<br />

the British palaeomagnetists in the mid-1950s. After all,<br />

the latitude-dependant inertia forces invoked by Kreichgauer,<br />

would be liable to produce in situ rotations of the<br />

continental lithospheric blocks in recent geological time<br />

[basically of late Cretaceous to early Tertiary age] – providing<br />

the cause of the observed discrepancies between<br />

the established polar w<strong>and</strong>er paths. However, the principal<br />

palaeomagnetic workers of the 1950’s <strong>and</strong> 60’s were<br />

so blinded by Wegenerian-type lateral motion, that they<br />

failed to recognize the alternative inertia-driven mobilistic<br />

system.<br />

The present author has always sheared the view that<br />

the overall pattern of global palaeomagnetic data underpins<br />

the concepts of polar w<strong>and</strong>ering <strong>and</strong> relative continental<br />

motions. But owing to the many apparently unsolvable<br />

complications associated with Wegenerian-type<br />

continental fittings <strong>and</strong> the never-ending flow of ad hoc<br />

provisions in plate tectonic depictions, I was already in the<br />

early 1970s in search for an alternative dynamo-tectonic<br />

framework. By 1989 my long-time speculations regarding<br />

the dynamo-tectonic ‘system of the Earth’ eventually paid<br />

off – a radical recasting of the association of many wellknown<br />

phenomena <strong>and</strong> observations, dismissing all plate<br />

tectonic principles, was about to take shape (STORETVEDT,<br />

1990, 1992). It was the compelling need to find an alternative<br />

way of making sense of global palaeomagnetic data<br />

that ultimately led to a new theory of the Earth – <strong>Global</strong><br />

Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong> (STORETVEDT, 1997, 2003). All of a sudden,<br />

changes of planetary rotation had become a key facor<br />

for underst<strong>and</strong>ing tectonics as well as a range of other<br />

facets about the Earth. WEGENER (1929/1966) had<br />

referred to Kreichgauer’s book, a volume that was not<br />

available at my university, or could be traced elsewhere in<br />

Sc<strong>and</strong>inavia. During a study visit to the Geological Institute<br />

in Innsbruck in May 2000 I had for the first time the<br />

opportunity to read Kreichgauer’s book. To my surprise, I<br />

found that the link between Earth’s rotation <strong>and</strong> global<br />

tectonics, a central element in my <strong>Global</strong> Wrench<br />

<strong>Tectonics</strong>, had already been outlined by him a century ago.<br />

Kreichgauer compared the orientation of tectonomagmatic<br />

belts with time-equivalent equators based on rock<br />

evidence of palaeoclimate. My own starting point had<br />

been a combination of palaeomagnetically-estimated continental<br />

palaeolatitudes <strong>and</strong> kinematics, polar w<strong>and</strong>ering<br />

based on combined fossil climate evidence <strong>and</strong> palaeomagnetism,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the global pattern of tectonomagmatic<br />

belts. To account for the shifting axis of inertia, with associated<br />

polar w<strong>and</strong>er, Kreichgauer adhered to tide-driven<br />

transposition of some outer crystalline layer, assuming<br />

that the Earth’s interior had reached thermo-chemical<br />

equilibrium at an early stage – an assumption that, as<br />

against present evidence, can no longer be supported.<br />

The interior of the Earth must provide the energy<br />

source for its dynamics <strong>and</strong> surface physiographic <strong>and</strong><br />

geological change. In view of the apparent heterogeneous<br />

deep interior inferred from modern mantle tomography –<br />

including deep mantle roots beneath the continents, the<br />

presence of diamonds in chaotic mantle rock assemblages<br />

explosively emplaced into surface levels, the continuous<br />

flow of unoxidized hydrocarbons through the crystalline<br />

crust, <strong>and</strong> the increase in rock porosity with depth in the<br />

crust provide strong evidence for a relatively cold interior<br />

undergoing degassing. In other words, evidence suggests<br />

that the planet’s internal constitution is far from being in<br />

chemical equilibrium, <strong>and</strong> that the body of the Earth has,<br />

since its very beginning, been striving to attain such a<br />

state. Based on this starting point we have a new basis for<br />

underst<strong>and</strong>ing changes in the planet’s moment of inertia,<br />

with aligned polar w<strong>and</strong>ering, <strong>and</strong> above all we have<br />

thereby established an effective driving mechanism to<br />

instigate geological processes.<br />

THE INTERNAL MACHINERY<br />

With regard to the formation of the solar system, the<br />

old idea of the planets having developed from relatively<br />

homogeneous co-rotating nebular disk eddies – the planetesimal<br />

theory – still prevails, even though the many failures<br />

<strong>and</strong> the various ad hoc exceptional provisions surrounding<br />

this scenario (CAMERON, 1962, 1978, 1985;<br />

LEVY, 1987; BOSS, 1990) strongly indicate that an adequate<br />

underst<strong>and</strong>ing of the planetary system’s evolution<br />

has yet to be drafted. An adequate sequence of events may<br />

run as follows (STORETVEDT, 2003):<br />

a) The planets formed from condensation of individual<br />

rotating spherical masses of cold concentrated gas


POLAR WANDER AND GLOBAL TECTONICS 3<br />

<strong>and</strong> mineral dust in variable proportions, expelled from<br />

the contracting <strong>and</strong> rotating protosun. Owing to the turbulent<br />

expulsion forces, the various proto-planetary<br />

objects attained differing angular momenta. Thus.<br />

b) The Earth aggregated from a rotating ‘ball’ of cold<br />

nebula material enriched in mineral constituents – being<br />

transformed into a proto-planet through progressive conglomeration<br />

of essentially micrometer- to smaller-sized<br />

condensates. The transfer of groups of particles within<br />

the relatively dense mineral cloud was affected by<br />

dynamic, gravitational <strong>and</strong> magnetic forces.<br />

c) A significant proportion of heavier elements in the<br />

cold proto-planetary cloud, including radioactive elements<br />

like Thorium <strong>and</strong> Uranium, was forced dynamically<br />

towards the outer geosphere were gradual decay of<br />

unstable isotopes gave rise to heating. On the other h<strong>and</strong>,<br />

magnetic attraction between ferromagnetic particles <strong>and</strong><br />

clusters led to their coalescence into large <strong>and</strong> irregular<br />

bodies upon which gravitational forces outweighed<br />

dynamic ones. Thus, aggregations of magnetized iron<br />

particles expectedly led to the gravitational accretion of<br />

the heavier inner body – gradually building up a central<br />

core dominated by iron or iron alloys.<br />

d) The outcome of this early mass segregation was an<br />

outer region heating up through radioactive decay<br />

processes while the deeper interior remained in its relatively<br />

cold state. However, differential tidal variation<br />

between core <strong>and</strong> mantle is likely to have led to frictional<br />

heating <strong>and</strong> partial melting within the core-mantle<br />

boundary zone – the D” layer, leading to further transfer<br />

of ferromagnetic material into the high-conductivity<br />

outer core, while the bulk of the mantle – due to its lower<br />

thermal conductivity – is likely to have remained in a relatively<br />

cold state with slow chemical reaction rates.<br />

e) Owing to the suggested relatively low temperatures<br />

of at least the bulk of the silica-rich mantle, degassing of<br />

its largely undifferentiated interior – in its run towards<br />

thermo-chemical equilibrium – can be expected to have<br />

been a slow process that is still in progress.<br />

In the new theory of the Earth – <strong>Global</strong> Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong><br />

– it is the slow internal degassing, with its associated<br />

mass transfer processes (see STORETVEDT, 2003),<br />

which provide the ‘engine’ for planetary change. Dynamical<br />

segregation within the inferred relatively fast spinning<br />

pre-consolidated proto-Earth produced a thick pan-global<br />

felsic (anorthositic-dioritic) cover layer without a distinct<br />

lower boundary. There are reasons for believing that,<br />

within the gas-filled protoplanet, coalescence of ferromagnetic<br />

planetesimals – through gravitational <strong>and</strong> magnetic<br />

accretion processes (TUNYI et alii, 2001, 2004) –<br />

gradually led to heavier concretions for which the gravitational<br />

influence outbalanced the centrifugal effect. In<br />

consequence, the heavier iron-rich masses settled inwards<br />

through the relatively less dense gaseous mass, gradually<br />

building up a high-density core. However, as elements<br />

like sulphur, carbon, silicon, hydrogen <strong>and</strong> oxygen easily<br />

dissolve in high pressure metallic mixes (STEVENSON,<br />

1981; HUNT, 1992; OKUCHI, 1997), these lighter constituents<br />

can be expected to have followed iron alloys into<br />

the core. Furthermore, as the gravitational pressure at<br />

depth must have increased as a consequence of iron alloy<br />

migration, any fraction of free hydrogen may have been<br />

turned into a metallic state, adding additional substance<br />

to the inferred well-known density deficit of the core (relative<br />

to expectation). According to GOTTFRIED (1990), the<br />

core must be the host of a significant amount of hydridemetal<br />

compounds while the silicate-rich lower mantle<br />

must include an appreciable volume of silicides, notably<br />

silicon carbide (SiC). As some high pressure form of silica<br />

may be an important constituent of the lower mantle,<br />

TSUCHIDA & YAGI (1989) carried out high pressure studies<br />

of heated α-quartz. The experiments showed that,<br />

under pressure conditions assumed for the lower mantle,<br />

silica transforms to the slightly denser form stishovite or<br />

a similar phase. Thus, in order to attain gravitational stability,<br />

stishovite would have to transform into a much<br />

denser structure, combining for example with MgO to<br />

form perovskite currently believed to be the dominant<br />

mineral in the lower mantle (POIRIER, 2000). In any case,<br />

with the many lighter elements now regarded as possible<br />

constituents of the deep Earth, it is of paramount importance<br />

to consider the geodynamic <strong>and</strong> geological consequences<br />

of buoyant volatiles – including a range of hydrocarbon<br />

compounds – escaping from the Earth’s core.<br />

Owing to its high abundance ratio, silicon may be a<br />

very important element of the core’s metal hydrides, its<br />

low density giving it differential buoyancy. In this manner,<br />

masses of less-dense metal hydrides can ascend in<br />

the mantle, probably representing one of the most important<br />

mechanisms of internal mass reorganization – instigating<br />

planetary change. Following this line of thought,<br />

the interior of the Earth has been subjected to slow<br />

degassing, with associated outwardly directed element<br />

transport, leading to substantial chemical <strong>and</strong> mineralogical<br />

transformation of the primordial felsic incrustation,<br />

along with implantation of the Moho <strong>and</strong> an irregular<br />

asthenospheric layer (STORETVEDT, 2003). In this<br />

process, hydrous fluids caused overpressures within the<br />

outer regions, producing upwardly migrating eclogitization<br />

<strong>and</strong> associated gravitational instability of the transformed<br />

felsic rocks – thereby thinning the lighter cover<br />

layer from the bottom upwards (STORETVEDT, 2003).<br />

According to STEVENSON (1981), the core is not in<br />

equilibrium with the mantle, <strong>and</strong> the presence of an irregular<br />

D” topography (MORELLI & DZIEWONSKI, 1987) is<br />

further evidence of a thermo-chemically active <strong>and</strong> heterogeneous<br />

zone. Due to a combination of chemical <strong>and</strong><br />

tidal heating, it appears likely that buoyant masses arise<br />

from the topographically-elevated segments of the D”<br />

zone. Fig. 2 shows that, when projected onto the Earth’s<br />

surface, regions of the core-mantle layer that st<strong>and</strong> proud<br />

correspond to deep oceanic depressions. This observation<br />

may hint at the possibility that processes at the outer core<br />

<strong>and</strong>/or D” layer release energy as well as buoyant masses<br />

which eventually lead to chemical transformation, crustal<br />

thinning, <strong>and</strong> formation of deep oceanic depressions. The<br />

irregular degassing from the deep Earth ought to produce<br />

systematic differences between continental <strong>and</strong> oceanic<br />

mantles – in composition, temperature <strong>and</strong> porosity – giving<br />

rise to variations in seismic velocities. Thus, the<br />

degassing Earth model seems to readily account for the<br />

seismic evidence for deep continental roots – reflecting a<br />

relatively clear distinction between continental <strong>and</strong><br />

oceanic mantles (MACDONALD, 1964; DZIEWONSKI, 1984;<br />

FORTE et alii, 1995).<br />

On the question of upward transfer of energy from<br />

the core-mantle boundary layer, GREGORI (2001) considered<br />

the potential of ‘topographic’ elevations to initiate<br />

tidal heating. He suggested that electrical currents would


4 K.M. STORETVEDT<br />

that natural diamonds or diamondiferous kimberlites (an<br />

ultrabasic rock of mantle provenance) may contain inclusions<br />

of SiC or unoxidized carbon-bearing fluids<br />

(MELTON & GIARDINI, 1974; LEUNG et alii, 1990), <strong>and</strong> that<br />

methane <strong>and</strong> other hydrocarbons are being emitted continuously<br />

through the crystalline basement (WELHAN &<br />

CRAIG, 1983; MCLAUGHLIN-WEST et alii, 1999; LUPTON et<br />

alii, 1999) provide strong prima facie evidence that the<br />

internal temperature is over all relatively low. Hence,<br />

throughout its history, the Earth must have been out of<br />

thermo-chemical stability. Therefore, in the natural<br />

process of reaching such an equilibrium state, mass reorganization<br />

– aided by buoyant volatiles – must have been<br />

at work since the planet’s very beginning. These operations<br />

have given rise to a progressive reorganization of<br />

interior mass – triggering episodic inertia-driven changes<br />

of planetary rotation, with the associated evolutionary<br />

course of spasmodic geological activity.<br />

CHANGES OF THE EARTH’S ROTATION<br />

Fig. 2 - Diagrams demonstrating topography of the core-mantle<br />

boundary obtained by inversion of PcP residuals (upper), PKP<br />

residuals (middle), <strong>and</strong> the two data sets combined (lower), corrected<br />

for lower mantle heterogeneity. Simplified from MORELLI &<br />

DZIEWONSKI (1987).<br />

concentrate on the top of such ‘bumps’ releasing anomalous<br />

amounts of heat which, due to the presumed low<br />

thermal conductivity of the silicate mantle, does not propagate.<br />

Thus, Gregori described the upward-directed transfer<br />

of energy as electrodynamic rather than thermodynamic,<br />

<strong>and</strong> as resembling an electric soldering iron being<br />

pushed into a block of ice. In the presence of sufficient<br />

concentration of pore spaces – kept open by the high<br />

internal gas pressures – Gregori’s mechanism may provide<br />

an efficient way of mantle degassing <strong>and</strong> internal elemental<br />

reorganization.<br />

Diamonds, the high pressure form of carbon, are neither<br />

stable nor in equilibrium at low pressures, but when<br />

transported rapidly to the surface – driven by the high<br />

internal gas pressures – from their source in the mantle,<br />

diamonds can survive long enough to avoid being converted<br />

into the low-pressure form of graphite. The fact<br />

The moment of inertia of a rotating body is a way of<br />

expressing the concentration of its mass about the centre<br />

of gravity. The greater the concentration of mass, the<br />

greater its moments of inertia, <strong>and</strong> the faster the body will<br />

spin. Thus, any net inward motion of mass increases the<br />

Earth’s moment of inertia <strong>and</strong> therefore increase its rate<br />

of rotation; similarly, any net outward (equatorward)<br />

mass transport decreases the moment of inertia <strong>and</strong><br />

reduces the planet’s spin rate. For example, the gradual<br />

magneto-gravitational accretion of the core referred to<br />

above, interchanging angular momentum between the<br />

proto-core <strong>and</strong> the proto-mantle, would have led to<br />

increasing planetary spin, adding to the ‘preset’ high rotation<br />

rate presumed for the pre-consolidated Earth<br />

(ALFVEN & ARRHENIUS, 1976). An observation supporting<br />

the hypothesis of a relatively faster spin velocity in the<br />

geological past (than now) is that the present Earth has a<br />

certain excess flattening, making its equatorial bulge some<br />

200m larger than that expected. MUNK & MACDONALD<br />

(1960) suggested that this non-hydrostatic bulge is a relic<br />

of a faster rate of rotation in the past, the lag in gaining<br />

hydrostatic equilibrium being ascribed to the high viscosity<br />

of the mantle. However, long-term internal degassing,<br />

producing upward mass transfer, has inevitably caused<br />

planetary slowing, increasing the length of day. Compilation<br />

of growth rings in fossil shells (CREER, 1975) has similarly<br />

unfolded progressive, but variable, slowing of the<br />

Earth’s rotation over the past 500 Ma.<br />

The build-up of high volatile pressures in the outer<br />

shells of the planet evidently has triggered eclogitization –<br />

causing gravitational instability of the chemically transformed<br />

shell – eroding the crustal layer from the bottom<br />

upwards. Therefore, at particular times in the Earth’s history,<br />

periods of crustal uplift, releasing over-pressured<br />

volatiles, alternating with crustal subsidence – the latter<br />

being triggered by the sinking of masses of heavier eclogitized<br />

crustal material to some lower level of the (presumed)<br />

low-viscosity upper mantle – would inevitably<br />

have generated periodic acceleration of the planet’s spin<br />

rate. As shown by CREER (1975) these sharper changes of<br />

rotation rate – break-points for which periods of<br />

enhanced deceleration have alternated with periods of<br />

acceleration – correspond to the well-established global


POLAR WANDER AND GLOBAL TECTONICS 5<br />

tectonic events. According to <strong>Global</strong> Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong> it is<br />

the ‘jerks’ in planetary spin rate that triggers torsion of<br />

the pan-global lithosphere, turning the time-equivalent<br />

palaeoequatorial belts into overall transpressive (or<br />

transtensive) tectonic regimes, along with occasional rifting<br />

along palaeomeridian sections.<br />

As long as the major axis of inertia – the axis of figure<br />

– stays near the astronomical spin axis, the relative pole<br />

will have a fairly stationary position (GOLDREICH &<br />

TOOMRE, 1969). According to the degassing model, however,<br />

suggesting that irregular redistribution of internal<br />

mass has taken place since Archaean times – inevitably<br />

changing the orientation of the inertia axes – it is to be<br />

expected that, from time to time, the Earth’s body must<br />

have turned over relative to the ecliptic. We have already<br />

associated global tectonics per se with changes in the rate<br />

of planetary rotation <strong>and</strong>, in the furtherance of that idea,<br />

it can be predicted that certain palaeoequatorial belts<br />

have been the sites of ancient fold belts, <strong>and</strong> that major<br />

rift structures have evolved in perpendicular (i.e.<br />

palaeomeridional) settings. This extended link between<br />

tectonics <strong>and</strong> the Earth’s palaeorotation may therefore be<br />

the key to solving a basic <strong>and</strong> long-st<strong>and</strong>ing problem in<br />

geology: the temporally shifting position of large-scale<br />

zones of structural deformation <strong>and</strong> magmatic activity<br />

across the globe.<br />

ORIGIN OF FUNDAMENTAL FRACTURE SYSTEMS<br />

Based on the consideration above, it can be assumed<br />

that in the early Archaean heating from combined radiogenic,<br />

tidal <strong>and</strong> chemical processes gave rise to an effective<br />

degassing of the outer few hundred kilometres of the<br />

Earth, accompanied by the installation of partial melt<br />

pockets at upper mantle levels – representing the embryonic<br />

stage of the present-day irregular asthenospheric<br />

zone – while the deeper parts of the planetary body are<br />

likely to have maintained largely their original low temperatures.<br />

Aided by buoyant volatiles, the outer regions of<br />

the geosphere – including present-day upper mantle –<br />

were depleted of a number of incompatible <strong>and</strong> other elements,<br />

to be correspondingly enriched in the surface<br />

layer, resulting in mineralization, plutonism, greenstone<br />

belt volcanism, <strong>and</strong> pervasive potassium (metasomatic)<br />

granitization of the crust. These processes were particularly<br />

momentous in Upper Archaean <strong>and</strong> earliest Proterozoic<br />

times, probably having impressed strong <strong>and</strong> widespread<br />

remobilization <strong>and</strong> isotopic age resetting of older<br />

rocks. Furthermore, by late Archaean times, the Earth’s<br />

surface regions had apparently cooled significantly;<br />

hence, the hot <strong>and</strong> ductile state of the early-mid Archaean<br />

outer shell had been replaced by more brittle conditions.<br />

Increasing solidification of the outer layers, combined<br />

with cooling <strong>and</strong> sustained planetary degassing, then led<br />

to brittle fracturing. First of all, cooling gave rise to a<br />

minor amount of planetary shrinking which, in turn,<br />

catalysed deep great-circle contraction dislocations – the<br />

disrupted remnants of which one of them are to be seen<br />

in the present-day peri-Pacific Benioff system.<br />

Evidence suggests that the relatively fast-spinning<br />

cooling Archaean Earth (undergoing a minor degree of<br />

contraction) had approximately its present spatial orientation<br />

(STORETVEDT, 2003), <strong>and</strong> therefore one would<br />

expect to observe clear differences in structure of the<br />

Benioff zone between the present-day eastern <strong>and</strong> western<br />

Pacific borders – at low to intermediate latitudes.<br />

Thus, a fast-spinning late Archaean Earth, with an outer<br />

crystalline layer being subjected to westward-directed<br />

inertia drag, would be liable to produce a compressive<br />

<strong>and</strong> relatively shallow-inclined cooling fracture in the<br />

direction of planetary rotation (i.e. as per the present-day<br />

eastern Pacific), while tensional conditions <strong>and</strong> a relatively<br />

steeply inclined cooling fracture would result in the<br />

wake of that motion (corresponding to the western<br />

Pacific). These predictions are fully confirmed by the distinct<br />

differences in structure <strong>and</strong> seismotectonics<br />

observed between eastern <strong>and</strong> western Pacific Benioff<br />

planes.<br />

With the progressive build-up of upper mantle gas<br />

pressures, producing a certain pan-global extensional<br />

‘surface’ regime, along with the increasing brittleness of<br />

the cooling late Archaean crust, the time was ripe for<br />

implantation of tension fractures. It is suggested that<br />

these conditions set the scene for the development of the<br />

omnipresent orthogonal fracture systems which formed<br />

along palaeomeridians <strong>and</strong> palaeolatitudes, respectively.<br />

Thus, the development of this orthogonal rupture system<br />

expectedly had a close connection with planetary rotation;<br />

on the basis of a relatively fast spinning Archaean<br />

Earth, it is reasonable to think that outgassing was<br />

strongest along the palaeoequatorial belt (owing to the<br />

maximum centrifugal effect along that ‘plane’) <strong>and</strong> that<br />

the orthogonal rupture system exp<strong>and</strong>ed from that zone<br />

towards higher palaeolatitudes. Thus, a simple pan-global<br />

tectonic fabric was established – inculcating a structural<br />

anisotropy of ultimate importance for subsequent geological<br />

development. Once formed, these fractures would be<br />

prone to repeated rejuvenation <strong>and</strong> intensification<br />

throughout the Earth’s dynamo-tectonic history – the latter<br />

being controlled by more distinct changes in planetary<br />

rotation instigating lithospheric wrenching.<br />

The combined gas pressure build-up – causing surface<br />

upheaval – <strong>and</strong> subsequent sub-crustal attenuation in<br />

association with upper mantle gas release leading to<br />

crustal subsidence, must have produced a distinct ‘expansion-contraction’<br />

pulsation of the globe. Moreover, the<br />

preset fracture network would affect the architecture of<br />

subsequent fold belts. Following the theory of <strong>Global</strong><br />

Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong>, the most extensive tectonic belts have<br />

developed along their time-equavalent palaeoequators.<br />

Therefore, segments of such belts that fall along one of<br />

the two fundamental fracture sets will be expected to display<br />

relatively smooth elongate geometries, while those<br />

parts of the tectonic belt that cut across the preset elongate<br />

fracture network will form a ruptured en echelon<br />

structure.<br />

According to the new theory of the Earth, the most<br />

important phase of wrench deformation of the outer layers<br />

– including relative in situ rotations of the remaining<br />

continental masses (i.e. those parts of the surface layer<br />

that had not been significantly affected by ‘oceanization’<br />

processes) – took place in Alpine time. Therefore, by<br />

applying world-wide joint orientation data established by<br />

Adrian Scheidegger <strong>and</strong> numerous coworkers (SCHEIDEG-<br />

GER, 1995, for a review), correcting them for Alpine-age<br />

continental rotations established by palaeomagnetic data<br />

(STORETVEDT, 1990, 1992, 1997), it should be possible to<br />

retrace the spatial palaeo-setting of the globe <strong>and</strong> the initial<br />

orientation of the conjugate orthogonal fracture sets.


6 K.M. STORETVEDT<br />

tectonomagmatic belts gradually replaced the Archaean<br />

greenstone belts (WINDLEY, 1995).<br />

THE WRENCH TECTONIC SYSTEM DURING<br />

THE PROTEROZOIC<br />

Fig. 3 - Strike directions for one of the characteristic orthogonal joint<br />

axes as established on different continents. Plots are on a Mercator<br />

projection <strong>and</strong> after correction for Alpine age in situ continental<br />

rotations, but without altering continental azimuths. These corrected<br />

joint trends will intersect close to the present geographic<br />

poles, thus defining a system of longitudes. Similarly, the nearly E-W<br />

striking orthogonal set of fractures will specify a system of parallels.<br />

In other words, the original configuration of the ubiquitous orthogonal<br />

joint sets formed a simple global pattern – representing a system<br />

of palaeogrids probably implanted during the Upper Archaean.<br />

From STORETVEDT (2003).<br />

The outcome of such an exercise is shown in fig. 3,<br />

depicting the inferred strike directions of one of the characteristic<br />

orthogonal joint axes. When extended across<br />

the globe, these corrected joint trends will intersect close<br />

to the present geographic poles, defining a system of longitudes.<br />

The similarity with Kreichgauer’s late Archaean<br />

palaeoequator (fig. 1b) is striking. Similarly, the nearly<br />

east-west striking orthogonal set of joints (not displayed<br />

in the diagram) will specify a system of parallels.<br />

The Upper Archaean was the time of formation of the<br />

greenstone belts, <strong>and</strong> the massive amount of magmatism<br />

associated with these elongate zones of depression – having<br />

developed along particular zones of weakness, corresponding<br />

to the already established network of orthogonal<br />

fractures – suggests that upper mantle upwelling <strong>and</strong><br />

interior mass reorganization was at force. Therefore, at<br />

some stage, the maximum axis of inertia would have<br />

changed sufficiently to bring about an inevitable spatial<br />

reorientation of the planet. Such a resetting of the equatorial<br />

bulge, along with a greater polar flattening due to a<br />

faster spin velocity at that time, would have produced<br />

extensional conditions, notably in the new intermediatelow<br />

palaeolatitude regions, giving rise to intrusions into<br />

the preset orthogonal fracture network. Attendant<br />

increase in the exhalation of water vapour, carbon-dioxide<br />

<strong>and</strong> hydro-carbon gases (in association with<br />

organometallics, eventually depositing ore concentrations)<br />

would naturally result.<br />

There are reasons for believing that such a profound<br />

change in global dynamics took place at around the<br />

Archaean-Proterozoic boundary, loosely dated at ca. 2.5<br />

Ga, heralding a major change in Earth history. From then<br />

on, carbonate deposits became more widespread, life<br />

became more abundant, major sedimentary basins with<br />

b<strong>and</strong>ed iron formations developed, <strong>and</strong> more modern-type<br />

The question arises as to the spatial position in which<br />

the Earth eventually settled after the inferred dynamic<br />

instability around the Archaean-Proterozoic boundary. In<br />

principle, palaeomagnetic data should provide adequate<br />

information to this question, but unfortunately published<br />

results for these early times constitute a jungle of inconsistent<br />

<strong>and</strong> undoubtedly unreliable data. Remagnetization<br />

<strong>and</strong> unresolved multi-component remanences are likely<br />

to feature prominently in older rocks – as can be judged<br />

from the unjustified disparities in shape of the pre-Lower<br />

Palaeozoic polar paths for the Atlantic-bordering continents.<br />

Nevertheless, one may wonder whether the predicted<br />

turning over of the Earth’s body at around 2.5 Ga<br />

ago occurred in a single event or had a more protracted<br />

stepwise progression. In this regard, Neoproterozoic<br />

palaeomagnetic poles from the northern cratonic regions<br />

define reasonable clusters at antipodal positions of ca.<br />

65ºE, 20ºN <strong>and</strong> 115ºW, 20ºS respectively (STORETVEDT,<br />

1997). With the continental masses in their pre-Alpine<br />

azimuthal orientations this late Precambrian palaeoequator<br />

runs along Arctic Canada <strong>and</strong> Labrador Sea (fig. 4),<br />

further along present-day Central <strong>and</strong> South Atlantic (fig.<br />

5), it ‘touches’ present-day Antarctica, cuts through Australia,<br />

continues across north-western Pacific, before<br />

rejoining the Arctic Canada branch. This Upper Precambrian<br />

palaeoequator, defined by palaeomagnetic evidence,<br />

is surprisingly similar to the one proposed by KREI-<br />

CHGAUER (1902) on a completely different basis (fig. 1a).<br />

It should not come as a great surprise if this palaeoequator<br />

actually had remained relatively unchanged for the<br />

entire Proterozoic. The rational behind that prediction is<br />

that, during the Precambrian, the rate of internal mass<br />

reorganization apparently was relatively slow making<br />

polar w<strong>and</strong>er a rare phenomenon. In fact, it is thought<br />

that the inferred Proterozoic palaeoequator remained relatively<br />

unchanged until around mid-Ordovician times<br />

during which another major event of polar w<strong>and</strong>er<br />

occurred, providing a fundamental shift of the tectonic<br />

pattern across the globe.<br />

The Proterozoic-Lower Palaeozoic palaeoequator can<br />

be linked to many important tectonic features. Thus,<br />

many elongate mobile zones with a spread of late Precambrian<br />

to Lower Palaeozoic ages, exposed on presentday<br />

continents, show overall near-perpendicular orientations<br />

with respect to the inferred palaeoequator,<br />

suggesting that they originated as ensialic transtensivetranspressive<br />

crustal b<strong>and</strong>s in response to changes of<br />

planetary spin rate. However, the palaeo-equatorial girdle,<br />

with its aligned fold belt, is largely positioned in present-day<br />

oceanic regions, having been disrupted by later<br />

events of crustal thinning <strong>and</strong> ‘basification’ processes <strong>and</strong><br />

concealed eventually by oceanic sediment <strong>and</strong> water<br />

masses. In fact, the late Precambrian to early Palaeozoic<br />

equatorial zone (with its aligned fold belt) is only exposed<br />

in the Arctic Canada to Labrador Sea sector <strong>and</strong> through<br />

Central Australia – the latter transect comprising the Adelaide<br />

Geosyncline <strong>and</strong> Warburton-Georgina-Bonaparte<br />

basins.


POLAR WANDER AND GLOBAL TECTONICS 7<br />

Fig. 4 - The (late) Proterozoic to Lower Palaeozoic (pre-450 Ma)<br />

equator seen in conjunction with recognized Grenvillian (ca. 1 Ga)<br />

<strong>and</strong> Cadomian (ca. 600 Ma) tectonic provinces of the Arctic <strong>and</strong><br />

North Atlantic regions. The l<strong>and</strong> masses are in their pre-Alpine<br />

azimuthal orientations. Apart from the insular region of Arctic<br />

Canada, the palaeoequator-aligned (circum-globe) fold belt is<br />

located within present-day oceanic regions, but a range of late Proterozoic<br />

metamorphics have been recovered from the Central<br />

Atlantic Ridge (see STORETVEDT, 1997, 2003 for data base). Note<br />

that the principal Arctic-North American lithotectonic belts have<br />

near-perpendicular orientations with respect to their time-equivalent<br />

equator, indicating that they formed through rifting <strong>and</strong> shearing<br />

during events of global lithospheric torsion. This latitude-dependent<br />

wrench deformation, which has its maximum effect along the<br />

(palaeo)equator, is indicated by curved solid arrows. Abbreviations<br />

are: G.P., Grenville Province; M.R., Mid-continent Rift; W.C., Western<br />

Cordillera; F.I., Franklin-Innutian Belt; E.G., Ellesmerian-North<br />

Greenl<strong>and</strong> Belt; S.N., Sveco-Norwegian Belt.<br />

A substantial proportion of the Proterozoic anorogenic<br />

magmatic rocks in the world occur in a broad belt<br />

across the North American continent, from Labrador to<br />

southern California (EMSLIE, 1985). In the wrench tectonic<br />

system, this magabelt – dated to around 1.4 Ga<br />

(GOWER et alii, 1990) – would be connected to a transtensional<br />

regime brought about by one or more events of<br />

planetary deceleration (STORETVEDT, 2003). Such tectonically<br />

rather quiet conditions apparently came to a close at<br />

around 1.3-1 Ga after which time renewed planetary<br />

acceleration gave rise to enhanced wrench deformation,<br />

reactivating many pre-existing rifts. The most famous of<br />

these major late Proterozoic lithotectonic zones is the<br />

Grenville Province, the main deformation of which<br />

occurred around 1 Ga (SCHAERER & GOWER, 1988),<br />

extending from coastal Labrador to south-western USA.<br />

With the time-equivalent equator passing across the Arctic<br />

Canada-Labrador Sea region (fig. 4), the present NE-<br />

SW striking set of fundamental crustal discontinuities,<br />

originally oriented approximately N-S, was in line for<br />

strong reactivation. The Grenvillian phase of rifting <strong>and</strong><br />

associated shearing may indeed have affected the entire<br />

Fig. 5 - The inferred Proterozoic to Lower Palaeozoic equator seen in<br />

conjunction with the main segments of the Pan-African <strong>and</strong> Brazilian<br />

tectonomagmatic provinces. The continents are in their pre-Alpine<br />

setting. Abbreviations are: A.B., Amazon Belt; M.B., Mauritanides<br />

Belt; C.A.B., Central African Belt; D.B., Damaran Belt; C.B., Cape<br />

Belt. Other specifications are as for fig. 4. After STORETVEDT (2003).<br />

North American craton, extending west beyond the present-day<br />

Canadian Cordillera (COOK, 1995). If the<br />

Grenville Province became transpressively deformed in<br />

response to planetary acceleration (eastward), the evolving<br />

tectonic belt ought to have a western west-directed<br />

thrust front. Such a western frontal upthrust is indeed a<br />

characteristic feature of the Grenville Province, <strong>and</strong><br />

COCORP seismic profiling across the tectonic zone of the<br />

Grenville Front (GREEN et alii, 1988; CULOTTA et alii,<br />

1990) has revealed a 30 km wide frontal zone dipping ca.<br />

30º to the south-east <strong>and</strong> extending at least to Moho<br />

depths.<br />

With the Grenvillian event having affected the whole<br />

of present-day North America, thous<strong>and</strong>s of kilometres<br />

away from the actual palaeoequator, it would be logical<br />

to think that it also contributed similar large-scale<br />

ensialic rifting into the opposite palaeohemisphere – cutting<br />

across the present-day North Atlantic, which formerly<br />

was a continental domain. Following this line of<br />

thought the late Precambrian to Lower Palaeozoic segments<br />

of the Pan-African <strong>and</strong> Brazilian lithotectonic belts<br />

(fig. 5) can be readily accounted for; the embryonic East<br />

African Rift <strong>and</strong> the Trans-Antarctic belt can be similarly<br />

explained.<br />

Nowadays, it is generally believed that the Sveco-Norwegian<br />

tectonic sector in southern Sc<strong>and</strong>inavia represents<br />

a direct continuation of the Grenville belt proper<br />

(STARMER, 1993; ANDERSEN, 1997), but such a close


8 K.M. STORETVEDT<br />

Fig. 6 - Palaeoclimatically based equators for three differents time<br />

intervals: Carboniferous (C), Permian (P) <strong>and</strong> Lower Tertiary (LT).<br />

Based on descriptions by KREICHGAUER (1902) <strong>and</strong> WEGENER (1929).<br />

lithotectonic correlation does not necessarily apply. In<br />

fact, during Grenville time, global wrenching not only<br />

affected Europe along the Sveco-Norwegian sector, but<br />

also the basement of south-western Engl<strong>and</strong>, the Channel<br />

Isl<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> of the European Alps were all subjected to<br />

strong tectonomagmatic reactivation at that time<br />

(NEUBAUER et alii, 1989; POWER et alii, 1990). In particular,<br />

the European sector of the deep great-circle<br />

Archaean-age contraction dislocation – along which the<br />

Tethyan Basin <strong>and</strong>, finally, the Alpine-Himalayan belt<br />

developed – would have been prone to repeated rifting<br />

<strong>and</strong> wrench deformation in Proterozoic <strong>and</strong> Lower<br />

Palaeozoic times. This is equivalent to the prolonged Proterozoic<br />

<strong>and</strong> younger tectonic history of the western<br />

Cordillera of North America (STORETVEDT, 2003).<br />

From Grenville time onwards, the Earth is presumed<br />

to have experienced several changes in its rate of rotation.<br />

An example of such a predicted change may have<br />

occurred in Vendian to Middle Ordovician time when the<br />

protracted Cadomian deformation phase developed, in<br />

consequence of which belts of Grenvillian age around the<br />

world would have been liable to repeated overprintings,<br />

encompassing both transpressive <strong>and</strong> transtensive events.<br />

In the Humber Zone of Newfoundl<strong>and</strong>, for example,<br />

Grenvillian basement units occur as significant discrete<br />

massifs, <strong>and</strong> rocks from late Precambrian rifting in that<br />

region (diabase <strong>and</strong> granite intrusions) give radiometric<br />

ages of around 600 Ma (WALDRON et alii, 1998). In the<br />

European sector, polyphase magmatism, deformation<br />

<strong>and</strong> metamorphism have similarly been reported (NEU-<br />

BAUER et alii, 1989; BROWN et alii, 1990; DALLMEYER et<br />

alii, 1992).<br />

EVENTS OF PHANEROZOIC POLAR WANDER<br />

AND ASSOCIATED FOLD BELTS<br />

The Earth’s spatial orientation was apparently quite<br />

steady during the Proterozoic <strong>and</strong> well into the Lower<br />

Palaeozoic, but recurrent tectonic activity during this ca. 2<br />

Ga long period suggests that progressive degassing gave<br />

rise to shorter-term oscillations of the planet’s rotation<br />

rate. Therefore, it would only be a matter of time before<br />

the consequent transformation of the Earth’s interior mass<br />

would have changed the moment of inertia sufficiently to<br />

propel an event of polar w<strong>and</strong>er. Such a geodynamic revolution<br />

took place at around mid-Ordovician time during<br />

which the Earth’s setting, relative to the ecliptic, changed<br />

by about 70º. Since the Silurian, the Earth has experienced<br />

a number of progressive polar shifts – the palaeoequators<br />

having formed a age-progressive southward system oriented<br />

at right angles to the present Greenwich meridian,<br />

defining two regions of mutual intersection at the present<br />

equator, at around 90ºW <strong>and</strong> 90ºE (STORETVEDT, 1997,<br />

2003, <strong>and</strong> references therein). A simple presentation of this<br />

palaeoequatorial/polar w<strong>and</strong>er system, without correction<br />

for the moderate in situ continental rotations that occurred<br />

in Alpine time, is delineated in fig. 6. However, before the<br />

Earth had settled into this simple time-progressive<br />

arrangement, there was – according to palaeomagnetic evidence<br />

(STORETVEDT, 1997) – a specific transition period in<br />

the Upper Ordovician; during this period, the palaeoequator<br />

had a more northerly trend, passing along the northern<br />

North Atlantic <strong>and</strong> Barents Sea regions with a south-easterly<br />

continuation across Central Siberia.<br />

Degassing in a rotating Earth would have produced<br />

certain concentrations of fluid flow along palaeo-equatorial<br />

belts giving rise to more effective sub-crustal erosion<br />

<strong>and</strong> the formation of coaxially-aligned sedimentary<br />

troughs (geosynclines). In the European sector, the late<br />

Ordovician (Taconic) equator was sufficiently separated<br />

from the ‘Devonian’ (Acadian) equator to form two separate<br />

Caledonian segments: an Arctic branch <strong>and</strong> a north<br />

central European division. In the North American sector,<br />

however, the two palaeoequators were much closer<br />

together <strong>and</strong>, therefore, they merged into a united elongated<br />

geosyncline-tectonic zone.<br />

The orientation of the linear Lower-Middle Palaeozoic<br />

sedimentary trough that evolved along the eastern<br />

seaboard of North America was clearly predetermined by<br />

the prevailing north-easterly structural grain (i.e. present –<br />

post-Alpine – azimuthal orientation). It formed along, <strong>and</strong><br />

the developing tectonic processes interfered, in part, with<br />

the Grenville Province proper which – within a different<br />

palaeotectonic setting – had formed some 800-600 Ma earlier.<br />

According to the fossil ‘clock’ data compiled by CREER<br />

(1975), the Lower-Middle Ordovician was a time of planetary<br />

deceleration which, theoretically, should have produced<br />

overall transtensional conditions within the worldencircling<br />

Appalachian-Caledonian tectonic belt, thereby<br />

paving the way for increased regional magmatic activity.<br />

Thereafter, from the latest Ordovician <strong>and</strong> throughout the<br />

Devonian, the Earth seems to have experienced overall<br />

acceleration. Hence, the associated forces of inertia would<br />

have led to overall transpressive conditions along the<br />

palaeoequatorial geosyncline, providing adequate explanations<br />

for both the Taconic <strong>and</strong> Acadian phases of deformation.<br />

However, the compressive forces were not strong<br />

enough to produce anything but insignificant crustal thickening<br />

– in other words, the amount of sub-crustal thinning<br />

that led to formation of the Appalachian-Caledonian geosyncline<br />

was not compensated for by the transpressive<br />

processes that turned the sedimentary trough into a mobile<br />

belt. This lack of tectonic crustal thickening along fold<br />

belts is well demontrated by seismic profiling across the<br />

Newfoundl<strong>and</strong> Appalachians (JACKSON et alii, 1998).<br />

Sectors of the globe-girdling belt that fall along one of<br />

the preset orthogonal fracture lineaments would naturally


POLAR WANDER AND GLOBAL TECTONICS 9<br />

attain a relatively smooth outline. On the other h<strong>and</strong>, in<br />

regions where the palaeoequator cuts across the actual<br />

conjugate system of fractures, the evolving tectonic zone<br />

would not attain a smooth equator-aligned construction,<br />

but rather develop an en echelon structure, occasionally<br />

taking more marked offshots, as rifted zones, along one<br />

of the fundamental fracture systems. This is apparently<br />

the explanation of the East Greenl<strong>and</strong>-Svalbard branch(es)<br />

of the Caledonides, as they take on more northerly excursions<br />

away from the north-easterly course of the timeequivalent<br />

equator.<br />

Fig. 7 depicts the pre-Alpine reconfiguration of the<br />

present northern continents, along with the late Precambrian<br />

<strong>and</strong> mid-Palaeozoic equators. One notes that the<br />

Appalachian <strong>and</strong> trans-European tectonic belts line up with<br />

the Middle Palaeozoic equator suggesting a common tectonic<br />

history at least in Acadian time. According to CREER<br />

(1975), the Siluro-Devonian time was one of acceleration,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the associated inertia effects may therefore be related<br />

to the Salinic-Acadian phases of crustal-lithospheric deformation.<br />

The thick curved arrows in fig. 7 demonstrate the<br />

resulting inertial motions, with clockwise torsion in the<br />

northern palaeohemisphere <strong>and</strong> counter clockwise torsion<br />

in the southern palaeohemisphere. This dynamo-tectonic<br />

system readily explains major fault zones that run parallel<br />

or sub-parallel to many fold belts, e.g. the North Anatolia<br />

Fault Zone in the Alpine belt, <strong>and</strong> the Great Glen <strong>and</strong> Cabot<br />

faults in the Caledonian-Appalachian tectonic system. The<br />

mid-Palaeozoic wrench deformation would naturally have<br />

led to strong reactivation of the fundamental conjugate<br />

fracture system of eastern North America (originally oriented<br />

approximately N-S, but upon the Alpine-age lithospheric<br />

wrenching it has acquired a NE-SW axis), <strong>and</strong> it is<br />

likely that the north-easterly trending zonation within the<br />

Newfoundl<strong>and</strong> Appalachians primarily owes its origin to<br />

extensive strike-slip motions along the tectonic belt at that<br />

time. The several kilometres of Moho offset, seen across the<br />

north-eastern extension of the Dover Fault (separating the<br />

Newfoundl<strong>and</strong> Appalachian belt from the Precambrian<br />

Avalon block to the south), suggests that the extended<br />

Dover Fault represents a major strike-slip fracture. Within<br />

the overall transpressive regime of the Acadian deformation<br />

belt, one might expect that stress-induced remelting would<br />

have occurred in places, <strong>and</strong> that associated intrusive activity<br />

would have developed in areas of localized transtension<br />

(MILLER et alii, 2001; STORETVEDT, 2003).<br />

At later stages of Earth history, notably from the late<br />

Jurassic onwards, attenuation <strong>and</strong> basification processes<br />

(‘oceanization’) of the original dioritic-felsic crust advanced<br />

more rapidly than before so that, by the early Tertiary, the<br />

deep oceanic depressions were approaching their present<br />

global distribution. In concert with the pronounced<br />

mechanical weakening associated with the major crustallithospheric<br />

thinning, the ensuing geodynamic event – the<br />

Alpine revolution – pitched the Earth into a tectonic<br />

calamity. During this period, inertia-driven relative continental<br />

rotations occurred for the first time in the Earth’s<br />

history, producing significant deformation <strong>and</strong> faulting<br />

within the thin <strong>and</strong> mechanically weak oceanic crust.<br />

In the pre-Alpine azimuthal orientation of the continents<br />

(STORETVEDT, 1997, 2003), the southward extension<br />

of the Caledonian-Appalachian fold belt runs<br />

through southern Mexico, cuts into the north-western tip<br />

of the South American Andes, continues along a main<br />

segment of the present East Pacific Rise, further along<br />

Fig. 7 - Pre-Alpine configuration of the North Atlantic depicting the<br />

position of the Grenville/Sveco-Norwegian terranes <strong>and</strong> the<br />

Appalachian/North-Central European Caledonides. The corresponding<br />

palaeoequators are shown for comparison. Note again that the<br />

late Precambrian to early Palaeozoic equator (1) has a near-orthogonal<br />

setting in relation to the Grenville <strong>and</strong> Sveco-Norwegian<br />

provinces, suggesting that they are segments of megascale rift zones.<br />

On the other h<strong>and</strong>, the mid-Palaeozoic palaeoequator (2) is closely<br />

aligned to the mid-Palaeozoic branches of the trans-Atlantic<br />

Appalachian/Caledonian fold belt. Note that the Sveco-Norwegian<br />

Province occurs at asimilar distance from the Precambrian equator<br />

(1) as the ‘westernmost’ extension of the Grenville Province proper.<br />

Solid arrows demonstrate the global wrenching in mid-Palaeozoic<br />

time, giving rise to the palaeoequator aligned Appalachian/North-<br />

Central Caledonian belt. From STORETVEDT (2003).<br />

Fig. 8 - In the pre-Alpine azimuthal orientation of Australia, the late<br />

Proterozoic equator becomes co-linear with the Adelaidean lithotectonic<br />

zone (A.B.), but is cut in turn by the younger Tasman belt<br />

(T.B.) which represents a segment of the globe-girdling, palaeoequator-aligned<br />

Caledonian/Appalachian tectonic structure. In this<br />

consideration, the Tasman-Adelaidean tectonic junction has its<br />

antipodal counterpart in the tectonic junction of the Newfounl<strong>and</strong><br />

region depicted in fig. 7. From STORETVEDT (2003).<br />

the Tasman fold belt in Australia, proceeds across Asia<br />

before finally linking up with its Arctic <strong>and</strong> North Atlantic<br />

segments discussed above. Thus, in the pre-Alpine continental<br />

arrangement, the Caledonian-Appalachian belt<br />

runs in close agreement with the early-mid Palaeozoic<br />

equatorial zone. Fig. 8 delineates the locations of the late


10 K.M. STORETVEDT<br />

Precambrian <strong>and</strong> mid-Palaeozoic equators viewed in conjunction<br />

with the pre-Alpine orientation of Australia.<br />

Note that these palaeoequators fall along the Adelaidean<br />

<strong>and</strong> Tasman fold belts respectively. The Tasman-Adelaidean<br />

tectonic junction has its antipodal counterpart in<br />

the Newfoundl<strong>and</strong> region where the late Precambrian to<br />

early Palaeozoic equator intersects the mid-Palaeozoic<br />

equatorial zone at a fairly steep angle (fig. 7).<br />

According to the global tectonic system advanced<br />

here, the principal tectonomagmatic belts are to be found<br />

in two palaeogeographic settings: either as deformed geosynclines,<br />

running approximately along time-equivalent<br />

equators, or as rift zones breaking out at steep angles<br />

from their respective palaeoequators. The principal operating<br />

forces in the formation of these structural belts are<br />

a combination of the centrifugal force of rotation, the<br />

pole-fleeing force, the Coriolis force, <strong>and</strong> the tidal effects<br />

of the Moon <strong>and</strong> Sun. Thus, the tectonic arrangement<br />

versus geological time has, generally speaking, followed<br />

the shifting relative position of the equatorial bulge; i.e.<br />

the phenomenon of polar w<strong>and</strong>er is intimately associated<br />

with both regional <strong>and</strong> global tectonic development.<br />

Inferentially, the Precambrian Earth had a rotation<br />

rate that was a good deal faster than it is now <strong>and</strong>, as a<br />

thin <strong>and</strong> mechanically weak oceanic crust had not yet<br />

been formed, the surface layer must have been relatively<br />

brittle in the context of mechanical forces. For these reasons,<br />

the late Precambrian rift zones – exemplified by the<br />

Grenville Province, the Pan-African belts, <strong>and</strong> the East<br />

African Rift System – are all of relatively large dimension<br />

compared to their post-Precambrian relatives, such as the<br />

Oslo Graben, North Sea Graben <strong>and</strong> Rhine Graben.<br />

CONCLUDING REMARKS<br />

The new global tectonic framework – <strong>Global</strong> Wrench<br />

<strong>Tectonics</strong> – submits that the principal tectonomagmatic<br />

belts on Earth, with their temporally shifting locations,<br />

are intimately related to changes of planetary rotation,<br />

being the product of both variations in spin velocity <strong>and</strong><br />

shifts in the planet’s spatial orientation (with respect to<br />

the ecliptic). In essence, all tectonomagmatic structures<br />

around the globe seem to have developed through intermittent<br />

processes of lithospheric torsion (wrenching)<br />

associated with planetary degassing <strong>and</strong> related internal<br />

reorganization of mass. The main tectonic structures<br />

have defined either (a) globe-encircling mobile belts running<br />

in close alignment with time-equivalent equators, or<br />

(b) rift structures (or grabens) oriented at steep angles to<br />

– <strong>and</strong> spreading away from – these palaeoequators. The<br />

scale of these rift structures has diminished through geological<br />

time, in concert with the protracted slowing of the<br />

Earth’s rotation.<br />

REFERENCES<br />

ALFVEN H. & ARRHENIUS G. (1976) - Evolution of the Solar System.<br />

National Aeronautics <strong>and</strong> Space Adminstration, Washington D.C.<br />

ANDERSEN T. (1997) - Radiogenic isotope systematics of the Herefoss<br />

granite, South Norway: an indicator of Sveconorwegian (Grenvillian)<br />

crustal evolution in the Baltic Shield. Chem. Geol., 135,<br />

139-158.<br />

BOSS A.P. (1990) - Solar Nebula Models: Implications for Earth<br />

Origin. In Origin of the Earth, Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford.<br />

BROWN M., POWER G.M., COPLEY C.G. & D’LEMOS R.S. (1990) -<br />

Cadomian magmatism in the North American Massif. In The<br />

Cadomian Orogeny, Geol. Soc., London.<br />

CAMERON A.G.W. (1962) - The formation of the Sun <strong>and</strong> Planets.<br />

Icarus, 1, 13-69.<br />

CAMERON A.G.W. (1978) - Physics of primitive solar nebula <strong>and</strong> giant<br />

gaseous protoplanets. In Protostars <strong>and</strong> Planets, Univ. of Arizona<br />

Press, Tucson.<br />

CAMERON A.G.W. (1985) - Formation <strong>and</strong> evolution of the primitive<br />

solar nebula. In Protostars <strong>and</strong> Planets II, Univ. of Arizona<br />

Press, Tucson.<br />

COOK F.A. (1995) - Lithospheric processes <strong>and</strong> products in the southern<br />

Canadian Cordillera: a Lithoprobe perspective. Can. J. Earth<br />

Sci., 32, 1803-1825.<br />

CREER K.M. (1975). On a tentative correlation between changes in a<br />

geomagnetic polarity bias <strong>and</strong> reversal frequency <strong>and</strong> the Earth’s<br />

rotation through Phanerozoic time. In Growth Rhythms <strong>and</strong> The<br />

History of the Earth’s rotation. John Wiley, London.<br />

CREER K.M., IRVING E. & RUNCORN S.K. (1954). The direction of the<br />

geomagnetic field in remote epochs in Great Britain. J. Geomag.<br />

Geoelect., 6, 163-168.<br />

CULOTTA R.C., PRATT T. & OLIVER J. (1990) - A tale of two sutures:<br />

COCORP’s deep seismic surveys of the Grenville Province in the<br />

east US midcontinent. Geology, 18, 646-649.<br />

DALLMEYER R.D., D’LEMOS R.S. & STRACHAN R.A. (1992) - Timing of<br />

post-tectonic Cadomian magmatism on Guersey,Channel Isl<strong>and</strong>s:<br />

evidence from Ar-40/Ar-39 mineral ages. J. Geol. Soc. Lond., 149,<br />

139-147.<br />

DZIEWONSKI A.M. (1984) - Mapping the lower mantle: determination<br />

of lateral heterogeneity in P velocity up to degree <strong>and</strong> order 6. J.<br />

Geophys. Res., 89, 5929-5952.<br />

EMSLIE R.F. (1985) - Proterozoic anorthosite massifs. In The Deep<br />

Proterozoic Crust in the North Atlantic Provinces, Dordrecht<br />

(Reidel).<br />

EØTVØS R. (1913) - In Verh<strong>and</strong>lungen der 17. Allgemeinen Konferenz<br />

der Internationalen Erdmessung, Part I.<br />

FORTE A.M., DZIEWONSKI A.M. & O’CONNELL R.J. (1995) - Continent-ocean<br />

chemical heterogeneity in the mantle based on seismic<br />

tomography. Science, 268, 368-388.<br />

GOLDREICH P. & TOOMRE A. (1969) - Some remarks on polar w<strong>and</strong>ering.<br />

J. Geophys. Res., 74, 2555-2567.<br />

GOTTFRIED R. (1990) - Origin <strong>and</strong> evolution of the Earth - chemical<br />

<strong>and</strong> physical verifications. In Critical Aspects of the Plate <strong>Tectonics</strong><br />

Theory II, Theophrastus Publ., Athens (Greece).<br />

GOWER C.F., RYAN A.B. & RIVERS T. (1990) - Mid-Proterozoic Laurentia-Baltica:<br />

an overview of its geological evolution. In Mid-Proterozoic<br />

Laurentia-Baltica, Geol. Assoc. Can.<br />

GREEN A.G., MILKEREIT B., DAVIDSON A. et alii (1988) - Crustal<br />

structure of the Grenville Front <strong>and</strong> adjacent terranes. Geology,<br />

16, 788-792.<br />

GREGORI G. (2001) - The origin of the magnetic field <strong>and</strong> the endogeneous<br />

energy of the Earth <strong>and</strong> planetary objects (extended<br />

abstract). Int. Workshop on <strong>Global</strong> Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong>, Oslo 9-11<br />

May, 2001.<br />

HUNT C.W. (1992) - Exp<strong>and</strong>ing Geospheres. Energy <strong>and</strong> Mass Transfers<br />

from Earth’s Interior. <strong>Polar</strong> Publishing, Calgary.<br />

JACKSON H.R., MARILLIER F. & HALL J. (1998). Seismic refraction<br />

data in the Gulf of Saint Lawrence: implications for the lowercrustal<br />

blocks. Can. J. Earth Sci., 35, 1222-1237.<br />

KREICHGAUER P.D. (1902) - Die Äquatorfrage in der Geologie. Missionsdruckerei,<br />

Steyl.<br />

LEUNG I., GUO W., FRIEDMAN I. & GLEASON J. (1990) - Natural<br />

occurrences of silicon carbide in a diamondiferous kimberlite<br />

from Fuxian. Nature, 346, 352-354.<br />

LEVY E.H. (1987) - Energetics of chondrules formation. In Meteorites,<br />

Univ. of Arizona Press, Tucson.<br />

LUPTON J., BAKER E., EMBLY R., GREENE R. & EVANS L. (1999) -<br />

Anomalous helium <strong>and</strong> heat signatures associated with the 1998<br />

axial volcano event, Juan de Fuca Ridge. Geophys. Res. Lett., 26,<br />

3449-3452.<br />

MACDONALD G.J.F. (1964) - The deep structure of continents. Science,<br />

143, 921-929.


POLAR WANDER AND GLOBAL TECTONICS 11<br />

MCLAUGHLIN-WEST E.A., OLSON E.J., LILLEY M.D., RESING J.A.,<br />

LUPTON J.E. & BAKER E.T. (1999) - Variations in hydrothermal<br />

methane <strong>and</strong> hydrogen concentrations following the 1998 eruptions<br />

at Axial Volcano. Geophys. Res. Lett., 26, 3453-3456.<br />

MELTON C.E. & GIARDINI A.A. (1974) - The composition <strong>and</strong> significance<br />

of gas released from natural diamonds from Afrika <strong>and</strong><br />

Brazil. Am. Mineraligist, 59, 775-782.<br />

MILLER H.G., STORETVEDT K.M. & SCHEIDEGGER A.E. (2001) - The<br />

main structural trends of Newfoundl<strong>and</strong>: interpretation within a<br />

new dynamo-tectonic framework. Proc. Int. Workshop on <strong>Global</strong><br />

Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong>, Oslo 9-11 May, 2001.<br />

MORELLI A. & DZIEWONSKI A.M. (1987) - Topography of the coremantle<br />

boundary <strong>and</strong> lateral homogeneity of the liquid core.<br />

Nature, 325, 678-683.<br />

MUNK W.H. & MACDONALD G.J.F. (1960) - The Rotation of the Earth.<br />

Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge.<br />

NEUBAUER F., FRISCH W., SCHMEROLD R. & SCHLÖSER H. (1989) -<br />

Metamorphosed <strong>and</strong> dismembered ophiolite suites in the basement<br />

units of the Eastern Alps. Tectonophysics, 164, 49-62.<br />

OKUCHI T. (1997) - Hydrogen partitioning into molten iron at high<br />

pressure: implications for Earth’s core. Science, 278, 1781-1784.<br />

POIRIER J.-P. (2000) - Introduction to the Physics of the Earth’s Interior.<br />

Cambridge Univ. Press.<br />

POWER G.M., BREWER T., BROWN M. & GIBBONS W. (1990) - Late<br />

Precambrian foliated plutonic complexes of the Channel Isl<strong>and</strong>s<br />

<strong>and</strong> La Hague: early Cadomian plutonism. In The Cadomian<br />

Orogeny, Geol. Soc. London.<br />

RUNCORN S.K. (1955) - Rock magnetism – geophysical aspects. Adv.<br />

in Physics, 4, 244-291.<br />

SCHAERER U. & GOWER C.F. (1988) - Crustal evolution in eastern<br />

Labrador: constraints from precise U-Pb ages. Precamb. Res., 38,<br />

404-421.<br />

SCHEIDEGGER A.E. (1995) - Geojoints <strong>and</strong> geostresses. In Mechanics<br />

of Jointed <strong>and</strong> Faulted Rock, Balkema, Rotterdam.<br />

STARMER I.C. (1993) - The Sveconorwegian orogeny in southern Norway,<br />

relative to deep crustal structures <strong>and</strong> events in the North<br />

Atlantic Proterozoic Supercontinent. Norsk Geol. Tidsskr., 73,<br />

109-132.<br />

STEVENSON D.J. (1981) - Models of the Earth’s core. Science, 214,<br />

611-619.<br />

STORETVEDT K.M. (1990) - The Tethys Sea <strong>and</strong> the Alpine-Himalayan<br />

orogenic belt; megaelements in a new global tectonic system.<br />

Phys. Earth Planet. Inter., 62, 141-184.<br />

STORETVEDT K.M. (1992) - Rotating plates: new concept of global tectonics.<br />

In New Concepts in <strong>Global</strong> <strong>Tectonics</strong>, Texas Tech. Univ.<br />

Press, Lubbock.<br />

STORETVEDT K.M. (1997) - Our Evolving Planet. Alma Mater (Fagbokforlaget),<br />

Bergen.<br />

STORETVEDT K.M. (2003) - <strong>Global</strong> Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong>. Fagbokforlaget,<br />

Bergen.<br />

TSUCHIDA Y. & YAGI T. (1989) - A new post-stishovite high-pressure<br />

polymorph of silica. Nature, 340, 217-220.<br />

TÚNYI I., GUBA P., ROTH L.E. & TIMKO M. (2001) - Shock magnetic<br />

field <strong>and</strong> origin of the Earth <strong>and</strong> the planets (extended<br />

abstract). Int. Workshop on <strong>Global</strong> Wrench <strong>Tectonics</strong>, Oslo 9-<br />

11, 2001.<br />

TÚNYI I., GUBA P., ROTH, L.E. & TIMKO M. (2004) - Electric Discharges<br />

in the Protoplanetary Nebula as a Source of Impulse Magnetic<br />

Fields to Promote Dust Aggregation. Earth, Moon <strong>and</strong> Planets,<br />

93, 65-74.<br />

WALDRON J.W.F., ANDERSON S.D., CAWOOD P.A., GOODWIN L.B. &<br />

HALL J. et alii (1998) - Evolution of the Appalachian Laurentian<br />

margin: Lithoprobe results in western Newfoundl<strong>and</strong>. Can. J.<br />

Earth Sci., 35, 1271-1287.<br />

WEGENER A.L. (1929, translated <strong>and</strong> reprinted 1966) - The Origin of<br />

Continents <strong>and</strong> Oceans. Dover, New York.<br />

WELHAN J.A. & CRAIG H. (1983) - Methane, hydrogen <strong>and</strong> helium in<br />

hydrothermal fluids at 21º N on the East Pacific Rise. In<br />

Hydrothermal Processes at Seafloor Spreading Centres, Plenum<br />

Press, New York.<br />

WINDLEY B.F. (1995) - The Evolving Continents. John Wiley & Sons,<br />

Chichester (UK).

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!