12.03.2015 Views

(pre - K) - Reading Rubric

(pre - K) - Reading Rubric

(pre - K) - Reading Rubric

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

READING RUBRIC<br />

EMERGENT (Pre-K)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

1. Demonstrates com<strong>pre</strong>hension of a story through comments, reactions, discussion, and or<br />

drawings.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Flannel board stories<br />

• Puppetry<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

• Small group<br />

• Small group or independent work time<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student participates in discussions of book read<br />

• Student asks questions or adds to a story with relevant comments<br />

• Student responds or reacts appropriately to funny, serious, scary, etc. parts (either verbally or non-verbally)<br />

• Drawing shows com<strong>pre</strong>hension of the story<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

2. Retells a familiar story read to student, with beginning, middle and end, with book support.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Shared reading and retelling<br />

• Choose stories with strong beginning, middle and end (e.g.,<br />

folk tales)<br />

• Anticipating and <strong>pre</strong>dicting events, sequences, outcomes<br />

• Repeated readings of familiar stories<br />

• Sequence pictures of a familiar story<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Retells in own words<br />

• Recognizable beginning, middle and end<br />

• Well-formed story with most of the characters reviewed.<br />

• May refer back to book<br />

• May need prompts, such as “What happened next?” or “What happened at the end?”<br />

(Assesses Listening Com<strong>pre</strong>hension)<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

• MLPP Kindergarten Oral Retelling rubric*<br />

Strategies<br />

3. Holds book and turns pages correctly.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Read-alouds<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Buddy reading with more advanced reader<br />

• Independent book time<br />

• Direct instruction<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Holds book right-side up<br />

• Turns pages from right to left<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Concepts about Print (CAP)*<br />

• Teacher observation during guided reading and<br />

independent reading times<br />

1 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

EMERGENT (Pre-K)<br />

Strategies<br />

4. Demonstrates left to right directional movement.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Buddy reading with more advanced reader<br />

• Interactive writing<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Direct instruction<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> left to right, with return sweep<br />

• Reads left page before right page<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Concepts about Print (CAP)*<br />

• Observations during guided reading and<br />

independent reading time<br />

Strategies<br />

5. Identifies 15-20 of 54 letter names (includes a, g).<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Tracing letters with finger while saying letter (in alphabet<br />

books)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> alphabet charts<br />

• Interactive writing<br />

• Using magnetic letters, clay, sand trays, finger paints, letter<br />

stamps<br />

• Activities with students’ names.<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Identifies letter names when <strong>pre</strong>sented in random order<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Letter Identification checklist*<br />

Strategies<br />

6. Recognizes familiar print such as names or signs.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Instructional use of:<br />

- classroom labels - familiar names<br />

- signs, logos - word walls<br />

- familiar rhymes and songs - pocket chart stories<br />

- print created during daily interactive writing<br />

• Regular opportunities to “Read the Room”<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Child can recognize 5-6 examples of print in the classroom<br />

• Over time, student routinely recognizes names/words in context, e.g.,<br />

- signs in the community (STOP, in/out, exit, Kroger, etc.)<br />

- product labels (Kleenex, Jell-O, etc.)<br />

- room signs/ labels (sink, door, kitchen center, sand table, etc.)<br />

- words from familiar books, charts, word wall<br />

- other students’ names<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

• Observation Survey Word List*<br />

2 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

EMERGENT (Pre-K)<br />

Listening and Speaking<br />

7. Communicates wants and needs verbally.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Class meetings/community circles<br />

• Center time<br />

• Play times<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student tells others when happy, sad or angry<br />

• Student stays on topic during short conversation/discussion<br />

• Student tells an adult of his needs<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Listening and Speaking<br />

8. Has vocabulary to name common objects and discuss everyday experiences.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Discussions during/following read-alouds and shared<br />

reading<br />

• Show and tell<br />

• Class meetings/community circles<br />

• Discussion of pictures<br />

• Guessing games with common objects<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student tells others about things heard and/or experienced<br />

• Student uses specific language (the red truck) rather than general (that thing)<br />

• Student provides two sentences to describe a picture<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

3 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

DEVELOPING (Kindergarten)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

1. Reads books with <strong>pre</strong>dictable text. (End-of-year guided reading target: Level C*)<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books, charts, sentence strips, cut<br />

up poems, songs on transparencies, stories written during<br />

interactive writing) (See Ap<strong>pre</strong>nticeship in Literacy, p. 32.)<br />

• Guided reading (See Guided <strong>Reading</strong> and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 230 and 233)<br />

• Daily opportunities for independent reading of “just right”<br />

books<br />

• Encourage repeated readings of familiar books<br />

• For end-of-year target, see Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 119.<br />

• Developmental <strong>Reading</strong> Assessment (DRA)<br />

(available in every building)<br />

(DRA Level s 1-2; Rigby PM Assessment<br />

Benchmark Level A = Fountas/Pinnell Guided<br />

<strong>Reading</strong> Level A )<br />

• Rigby PM Benchmark Assessment Kit<br />

(available in every building)<br />

(Fountas/Pinnell Guided reading Level C =<br />

Rigby PM Assessment Benchmark Levels 3-4<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Running records*<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• After a book introduction and an opportunity to look over the book, student routinely reads Level C book with 95-<br />

100% accuracy and instructional level com<strong>pre</strong>hension or with 90-94% accuracy and independent or instructional<br />

level com<strong>pre</strong>hension.<br />

November March June<br />

Secure A A C<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

2. Memorizes pattern books, poems and familiar books.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Read-alouds<br />

• Rhyming books<br />

• Fingerplays, poems and songs<br />

• Daily opportunities for students to read big books, familiar<br />

books and posted poems and charts<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student reads/recites pattern books, poems, and familiar books.<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Independent reading<br />

• Teacher observation<br />

4 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

DEVELOPING (Kindergarten)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

3. Retells a familiar story read to student with beginning, middle and end, without book support.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Choose stories with strong beginning, middle and end (e.g.,<br />

folk tales)<br />

• Give many experiences in anticipating and <strong>pre</strong>dicting events<br />

in stories<br />

• Give students practice in sequencing pictures of a familiar<br />

story<br />

• Fold paper into thirds: after reading first third of book, talk<br />

about what happened, have children draw; do same for<br />

middle and end<br />

• Model and have students practice retelling in small groups<br />

• Model and provide students with opportunities to do puppet<br />

and flannel board stories<br />

• Encourage students to tell narratives about personal<br />

experiences; identify beginning, middle and end of narrative<br />

• Model and encourage repeated readings of familiar books<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Retells in own words without referring back to the book<br />

• May need prompts, such as “What happened next?” or “What happened at the end?”<br />

• Recognizable beginning, middle and end<br />

• Well-formed story with most of the characters reviewed<br />

• Kindergarten Oral Retelling rubric*<br />

• Retells story in own words, without book; may<br />

need prompts<br />

• Listen to student’s retelling with puppets or<br />

flannelboard characters.<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

4. Identifies main idea and two facts of informational book read to child without book support.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds (at least once a week selection should be<br />

informational)<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Books from science, social studies kits<br />

• Create charts, webs or other graphic organizers to help<br />

students learn to organize information<br />

• Group discussions<br />

• Direct teaching of structure of informational texts (compare<br />

with story structure)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Information is taken from the text<br />

• Information is related to the main idea<br />

• Teacher observation<br />

• Small group<br />

• Whole group: Identify one student to assess<br />

after reading text selection to the class<br />

• May use prompts such as “What was the main<br />

idea of this book was about?” “What are two<br />

things that you learned about ____ from this<br />

book?”<br />

• Make sure text is about information students are<br />

not likely already to know before reading the<br />

book (check on prior knowledge)<br />

5 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

DEVELOPING (Kindergarten)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

5. Demonstrates personal connection to stories read or heard through comments, reactions,<br />

discussion and/or drawings.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds about school, families, pets, other familiar<br />

topics<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Think-alouds when teacher models making text-to-self<br />

and/or text-to-text connections<br />

• Class discussions with connections to self, other texts<br />

• Class books of innovations on other stories<br />

• Resources: Mosaic of Thought (Chapter 4) and Strategies<br />

that Work (Chapter 6 and page 265)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Students identify how pictures or text remind them of their own life<br />

• Students can identify how current text reminds them of other texts<br />

Strategies<br />

6. Identifies 20-46 of 54 letter names.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Tracing letters with finger while saying letter (e.g., in<br />

alphabet books)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> alphabet charts, books<br />

• Using magnetic letters, clay, sand trays, finger paints, letter<br />

stamps (e.g., ABC center)<br />

• Letter Bingo<br />

• Daily interactive writing<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., letter framing in big books)<br />

• Word work activities (e.g., those found in Phonics Lessons<br />

and Word Matters)<br />

• Student name activities<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student identifies letter names when <strong>pre</strong>sented with letters in random order.<br />

Strategies<br />

7. Identifies 46-54 of 54 letter names.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Tracing letters with finger while saying letter (e.g., in<br />

alphabet books)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> alphabet charts, books<br />

• Using magnetic letters, clay, sand trays, finger paints, letter<br />

stamps (e.g., ABC center)<br />

• Letter Bingo<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., letter framing in big books)<br />

• Daily interactive writing<br />

• Word work activities (e.g., those found in Word Matters)<br />

• Activities focused on student names<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student identifies letter names when <strong>pre</strong>sented with letters in random order<br />

• Teacher may use such prompts as “Does this<br />

remind you of anything that ever happened to<br />

you?” or “Does this remind you of another book<br />

we have read?”<br />

• Anecdotal notes taken during discussions or as<br />

listening to student conversations<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Letter Identification Checklist*<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Letter Identification Checklist*<br />

6 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


Strategies<br />

8. Rhymes and plays with words.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

READING RUBRIC<br />

DEVELOPING (Kindergarten)<br />

• Daily read-alouds<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Rhyming books<br />

• Fingerplays, rhymes, poems, chants and songs<br />

• Cloze procedures (cover word; what would rhyme with __?)<br />

• Activities taken from Phonics Lessons<br />

• Partner game with rhyming words (have sets of rhyming<br />

words; pass out randomly; students find rhyming partner)<br />

• Provides experiences with segmenting and blending sounds<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Assessing Phonemic Awareness*<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Given a word, the child can generate a rhyme (may be nonsense) with 80% accuracy<br />

• Substitutes sounds (“Willoughby, Wolloughby, Woo”) for rhyming patterns<br />

Strategies<br />

9. Uses information from pictures to construct meaning.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Analyzing pictures, conjecturing what is going on what<br />

might happen next.<br />

• Doing picture walks to <strong>pre</strong>dict what text is about.<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student relates information that is communicated through pictures.<br />

• Student forms a story while attending to pictures.<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Teacher observations and anecdotal records<br />

• Student shares story related to his own drawings<br />

or other artwork/illustrations.<br />

Strategies<br />

10. Uses a sight word vocabulary of 10-15 words in reading/writing contexts.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Word walls<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books, wall charts, sentence strips)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Read song/fingerplay/poetry charts<br />

• Morning message<br />

• Daily interactive writing (e.g., making class books that are<br />

available for students to read)<br />

• Leveled book boxes readily available in the room<br />

• Daily opportunities for independent reading (“just right”<br />

texts) and writing, (e.g., journal writing)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> the Room<br />

• Word work (e.g., activities from Phonics Lessons and Word<br />

Matters)<br />

• Sight word Bingo<br />

• Running Records*<br />

• Writing Vocabulary Observation Sheet*<br />

• Student writing samples<br />

• Observation Survey Word Test*<br />

• MLPP Sight Word/Decodable Word List<br />

• Teacher observation/anecdotal records<br />

• High frequency word lists (e.g., Harris Word<br />

List* or San Diego Quick Assessment)<br />

NOTE: The target is reading and writing words in<br />

context; therefore, assessment should not be<br />

limited to a check of words in isolation.<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• There are at least 10-15 sight words that student can read automatically when reading connected texts.<br />

• There are at least 10-15 sight words that student can write independently when composing messages<br />

7 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

DEVELOPING (Kindergarten)<br />

Strategies<br />

11. Uses at least 20 sounds in reading/writing contexts.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Direct instruction in the use of phonetic cues for identifying<br />

unknown words<br />

• Direct instruction in phonemic segmentation<br />

• Daily interactive writing (e.g., writing about class<br />

experiences and observations, creating class lists and books)<br />

• Daily opportunities for independent writing (e.g., as in<br />

Journals)<br />

• Activities such as those found in Phonics Lessons<br />

• Have children find pictures in magazines that start with a<br />

particular sound<br />

• Have children create alphabet books<br />

• Encourage phonetic spelling in children’s work (while<br />

teaching conventional spelling during word work time)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student demonstrates knowledge of 20 initial sounds in reading or writing contexts<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Hearing and Recording Sounds in Words*<br />

• Checklists<br />

• Writing samples<br />

• Running Records<br />

• Beginning and Ending Sound check*<br />

Strategies<br />

12. Uses 1:1 correspondence to track print.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared reading, modeling that message is in the print,<br />

demonstrating one-to-one correspondence between spoken<br />

and written words<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> sticks/pointers<br />

• Framing words<br />

• Cutting apart sentences, matching words to sentences<br />

• Counting, graphing words on each page<br />

• Provide opportunities for student to read with older/more<br />

advanced reader, with younger student following along in<br />

the text with her finger<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student uses finger to track text with 1-to-1 correspondence<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Concepts about Print (CAP)*<br />

• Running Records*<br />

• Teacher observation/anecdotal records<br />

8 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

DEVELOPING (Kindergarten)<br />

Strategies<br />

13. Uses print and illustrations to problem solveº text.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Modeling during shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Picture walks to <strong>pre</strong>dict what text will be about<br />

• Direct instruction in the use of pictures to help identify<br />

unknown words<br />

• Encouraging children to use illustrations to <strong>pre</strong>dict what<br />

might happen next<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

Developmental <strong>Reading</strong> Assessment (DRA)<br />

(available in every building)<br />

(Fountas/Pinnell Guided <strong>Reading</strong> Level C =<br />

DRA Level 3)<br />

• Student/teacher conferences<br />

• Teacher observation/anecdotal during guided<br />

reading<br />

• Running records*<br />

º NOTE: “Problem solving text” refers to (1)<br />

identifying the word and (2) com<strong>pre</strong>hending its<br />

meaning.)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student uses illustrations to <strong>pre</strong>dict meaning as well as particular words, with level C (end-of-year target) books.<br />

Listening and Speaking<br />

14. Gives detailed description of needs, wants and events.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Class meetings/discussions<br />

• Recess<br />

• Modeling through role plays, dramatization<br />

• Some children will need ongoing direct instruction to meet<br />

this outcome<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student uses words to communicate what s/he wants, needs and what happened<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Listening and Speaking<br />

15. Listens to others without interrupting.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Class meetings/discussions<br />

• Small group discussions<br />

• Direct teaching and demonstration of conversational turntaking.<br />

• Direct teaching of active listening techniques.<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student shows attentiveness through his body language when others are speaking.<br />

• Student makes relevant comments about what others have to say.<br />

• Student asks questions of others for clarification or for more information.<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

9 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

BEGINNING (Grade 1)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

1. Reads and com<strong>pre</strong>hends books at Level I (End-of-year guided reading target*)<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books, charts, sentence strips, cut<br />

up poems, songs on transparencies, stories written during<br />

interactive writing) (See Ap<strong>pre</strong>nticeship in Literacy, p. 32.)<br />

• Daily opportunities for independent reading of “just right”<br />

books<br />

• Peer/buddy reading<br />

• Guided reading (See Guided <strong>Reading</strong> and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 230 and 233)<br />

• Encourage repeated readings<br />

• For end-of-year target, see Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 125.<br />

• Developmental <strong>Reading</strong> Assessment (DRA)<br />

(available in every building)<br />

• Rigby PM Benchmark Assessment Kit<br />

(available in every building)<br />

(Fountas/Pinnell Guided reading Level I =<br />

Rigby PM Assessment Benchmark Level 15-16.)<br />

• Running records*<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> logs<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Audiotaping/videotaping (for portfolio)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• After a book introduction and an opportunity to look over the book, student routinely reads Level I book with 95-<br />

100% accuracy and instructional level com<strong>pre</strong>hension or with 90-94% accuracy and independent or instructional<br />

level com<strong>pre</strong>hension.<br />

November March June<br />

Secure D G I<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

2. Reads aloud with fluency and ex<strong>pre</strong>ssion.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Read-alouds (discussing and modeling fluent and<br />

ex<strong>pre</strong>ssive reading)<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., mini-lesson with a big book)<br />

• Partner reading<br />

• Do “echo reading” to work on fluency and ex<strong>pre</strong>ssion<br />

• Do readers’ theater and choral reading to work on fluency<br />

• Author’s chair (students practice reading by selecting<br />

familiar print to share with an outside audience)<br />

• Listening centers<br />

• Audio tape student reading and provide feedback as you<br />

listen to it together<br />

• See Word Matters, p. 10 and Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 150<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Reads smoothly, using appropriate ex<strong>pre</strong>ssion and pauses<br />

• Reads primarily in larger meaningful phrases<br />

• Few word-by-word slow downs or re-readings for problem solving<br />

• Ex<strong>pre</strong>ssive inter<strong>pre</strong>tation is evident throughout the reading<br />

• Shows awareness of punctuation and uses it for phrasing, pacing and meaning<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Oral <strong>Reading</strong> Fluency <strong>Rubric</strong>*<br />

• Running records*<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

10 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

BEGINNING (Grade 1)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

3. Retells stories independently read to reflect sequence, setting, characters, problem and resolution.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big book)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Use of graphic organizers to model story elements included<br />

in retelling<br />

• Use of dramatizations, puppets, flannel boards and story<br />

boards<br />

• 5-finger retelling<br />

• Modeling during interactive writing<br />

• Students’ Oral or Written Retelling <strong>Rubric</strong>,<br />

grades one and two*<br />

• 5-finger retelling<br />

• Use of story map, web or story board<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Retelling contains a clear restatement of most story elements (main characters, setting, problem, major events, and<br />

resolution) and their connection to one another.<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

4. Identifies main idea and two supporting details of informational text read independently.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds (at least once a week selection should be<br />

informational)<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books, transparencies, Time for<br />

Kids)<br />

• Guided reading of informational books<br />

• Use of leveled trade books related to science and social<br />

studies units<br />

• Create charts, webs or other graphic organizers to help<br />

students learn to organize information<br />

• Group discussions<br />

• Direct teaching of structure of informational texts (compare<br />

with story structure)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Information is taken from the text<br />

• Information is related to the main idea<br />

• Student may refer back to the book<br />

• Teacher observation in the following settings<br />

- <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

- Class discussions<br />

- Guided reading<br />

• May use prompts such as “What was the main<br />

idea of this book was about?” “What are two<br />

things that you learned about ____ from this<br />

book?”<br />

• NOTE: Make sure text is about information<br />

students are not likely already to know before<br />

reading the book (check on prior knowledge)<br />

11 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

BEGINNING (Grade 1)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

5. Makes connections to other authors, books and personal experiences.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds (e.g., including topics familiar to students)<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Think-alouds with teacher modeling making text-to-self<br />

and/or text-to-text connections<br />

• Class discussions with connections to self, other texts<br />

• Graphic organizers (comparing/contrasting, Venn diagrams,<br />

webs)<br />

• Science and social studies kit books<br />

• Comparing fiction/nonfiction books (e.g., Steck/Vaughn<br />

fiction/nonfiction series)<br />

• Comparing different versions of same story<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> several books by the same author<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> several books of the same genre or topic<br />

• Resources: Mosaic of Thought (Chapter 4) and Strategies<br />

that Work (Chapter 6 and page 265)<br />

• Graphic organizers<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records made<br />

during class discussions, reading conferences or<br />

as listening to student conversations<br />

• Class or small group discussions<br />

• Student written responses<br />

• Mosaic of Thought, p. 228<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student makes connections supported by the text:<br />

- identifies how text reminds him/her of his/her own life<br />

- identifies how current text reminds him/her of other texts or authors<br />

• Teacher may use such prompts as “Does this remind you of anything that ever happened to you?” or “Does this<br />

remind you of another book we have read?”<br />

Strategies<br />

6. Uses visual cues.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Cloze activities<br />

• Using think-alouds and modeling<br />

• Placing key words on word wall<br />

• Word work (e.g., from Phonics Lessons and Word Matters)<br />

• Modeling and guided practice during interactive writing<br />

• Direct teaching of this cueing strategy<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Running records* (M/S/V<br />

[Meaning/Structure/Visual] analysis)<br />

(See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 89 and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 113 and 222)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Uses knowledge of letter-sound relationships to <strong>pre</strong>dict, then checks for accuracy, i.e.,<br />

- Connects knowledge of the visual features of letters and words with the way letters and words sound when<br />

spoken as sources of information to read and self-correct.<br />

• Easily recalls sight words as they appear in text.<br />

12 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

BEGINNING (Grade 1)<br />

Strategies<br />

7. Uses structure cues (e.g., word roots, <strong>pre</strong>fixes, suffixes, word chunks).<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Cloze activities<br />

• Using think-alouds and modeling<br />

• Placing key words on word wall<br />

• Word work (e.g., from Phonics Lessons and Word Matters)<br />

• Modeling and guided practice during interactive writing<br />

• Direct teaching of this cueing strategy<br />

• Running records* (M/S/V<br />

[Meaning/Structure/Visual] analysis)<br />

(See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 89, Phonics Lessons<br />

and Word Matters, pp. 113 and 222)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Uses structure (syntax) of language to <strong>pre</strong>dict, then checks for accuracy, i.e.,<br />

- Uses implicit knowledge of the way the grammar of the language works as sources of information to read and<br />

self-correct.<br />

• Uses knowledge of known words to get to unknown words (e.g., “I know that the word is ‘start’ because I see the<br />

word ‘art’.”)<br />

• Uses knowledge of syntax to read with phrasing.<br />

Strategies<br />

8. Uses meaning cues.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Cloze activities<br />

• Using think-alouds and modeling<br />

• Direct teaching of this cueing strategy<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Running records* (M/S/V<br />

[Meaning/Structure/Visual] analysis)<br />

(See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 89 and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 113 and 222)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Uses context of sentence to <strong>pre</strong>dict, then checks for accuracy.<br />

- Uses story background, information from a picture and meaning in the sentence as sources of information to read<br />

and self-correct.<br />

Strategies<br />

9. Self corrects miscues that affect meaning.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Shared <strong>Reading</strong><br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Mini-lessons and think-alouds to regularly models this<br />

strategy<br />

• Encourage student to use multiple sources of information to<br />

self-correct (direct instruction and modeling)<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Running records* (M/S/V<br />

[Meaning/Structure/Visual] analysis)<br />

(See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 89 and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 113 and 222)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Notices mismatches, searches for additional information, makes another attempt that results in a match that restores<br />

meaning.<br />

• Cross-checks one source of information against another (Does it look right? Sound right? Make sense?)<br />

• Self-corrects two out of three errors that affect meaning.<br />

13 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

BEGINNING (Grade 1)<br />

Strategies<br />

10. Uses multiple strategies automatically as needed to problem solve text.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., for instruction, modeling and guided<br />

practice)<br />

• Think-alouds<br />

• Mini-lessons<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Daily independent reading with “just right” books<br />

• Cloze activities<br />

• See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p 149<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student automatically uses appropriate/successful cues to word solve.<br />

• Student knows which strategy to use to help himself.<br />

• Running records* (M/S/V<br />

[Meaning/Structure/Visual] analysis)<br />

(See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 89 and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 113 and 222)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Listening and Speaking<br />

11. Responds to others using complete sentences.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Class meetings<br />

• Book sharing<br />

• Author’s chair<br />

• Direct instruction<br />

• Provide opportunity for students to have conversation with<br />

others.<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Child takes turns in conversation setting.<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Listening and Speaking<br />

12. Uses questions and statements in appropriate contexts.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Class meetings<br />

• Book sharing<br />

• Author’s chair<br />

• Direct instruction<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Differentiates between questions and statements, e.g., When asked “Are there any questions?” responds with an<br />

appropriate questions. When are asked “Are there any comments?” responds with an appropriate statement?”<br />

• Asks appropriate questions of guest speakers and peers<br />

14 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

EXPANDING (Grade 2)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

1. Reads, with fluency and com<strong>pre</strong>hension, Level M books. (End-of-year guided reading target*)<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Guided reading (See Guided <strong>Reading</strong> and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 230 and 233)<br />

• Literature circles<br />

• Book discussions<br />

• Shared reading<br />

• Daily opportunities for independent reading of “just right”<br />

books<br />

• Peer/buddy reading<br />

• Encourage repeated readings<br />

• Encourage reading books in a series (e.g., Henry and<br />

Mudge, Arthur, Nate-the-Great, Cam Jansen series)<br />

• Listening centers<br />

• For end-of-year target, see Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 129.<br />

• Rigby PM Benchmark Kit (Fountas/Pinnell<br />

Guided <strong>Reading</strong> Level M = Rigby Benchmark<br />

Kit Level 22.)<br />

• Running records*<br />

• Teacher observation/Anecdotal records<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> logs<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> response journals (rubric*)<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Audiotaping/videotaping (for portfolio)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• After a book introduction and an opportunity to look over the book, student routinely reads Level M book with 95-<br />

100% accuracy and instructional level com<strong>pre</strong>hension or with 90-94% accuracy and independent or instructional<br />

level com<strong>pre</strong>hension.<br />

November March June<br />

Secure J L M<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

2. Reads and com<strong>pre</strong>hends a variety of materials with guidance (e.g., folktales, poetry, biography,<br />

informational material, historical fiction, mystery).<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books, charts, transparencies)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Genre wheels<br />

• Direct teaching of text structures<br />

• Science and social studies kits<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> logs<br />

• Checklists<br />

• Genre wheels<br />

• Teacher observations/Anecdotal records<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> response journals<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Demonstrates ability to read and com<strong>pre</strong>hend 5-6 different genres.<br />

• Uses strategies appropriate for nature of material read, e.g.,<br />

- reads novels from beginning to end<br />

- rereads poetry to focus on the rhythm of the language, phrasing for meaning<br />

- is selective about informational text, reading sections that address questions the reader brings to the task<br />

15 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

EXPANDING (Grade 2)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

3. Makes inferences that can be supported by the text.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• Read-alouds to model and provide whole-group practice<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Literature circles<br />

• Junior Great Books<br />

• Graphic organizers to help students understand text<br />

structure (e.g., sequencing, cause and effect)<br />

• Directly teaching inferencing strategies (See Mosaic of<br />

Thought, Chapter 8 and Strategies that Work, Chapter 8.)<br />

• Make certain that students have opportunities to make<br />

<strong>pre</strong>dictions – backed by evidence – in other content areas<br />

(e.g., math [also estimations], science investigations, social<br />

studies)<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Ask students questions such as, <strong>pre</strong>dicting<br />

“What will happen next?” and “Why do you<br />

think that?, “Why did the character do that?”<br />

• Rigby PM Benchmark Kit, com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

questions on the back of the Running Record<br />

sheet<br />

• Teacher observations in the following settings:<br />

– Individual reading conferences<br />

– Literature Circles<br />

– Classroom discussions<br />

– Guided reading groups<br />

– Junior Great Book groups<br />

• Response Journals<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student uses background knowledge and information from the text.<br />

• Student develops <strong>pre</strong>dictions, inter<strong>pre</strong>tations, and/or conclusions, using evidence from the text to support their<br />

thinking.<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

4. Identifies topic, main ideas and supporting details of informational text read by student.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read-alouds (at least once a week selection should be<br />

informational)<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., big books, transparencies, Time for<br />

Kids, National Geographic)<br />

• Use of resources such as the internet, informational videos<br />

• Guided reading of informational books<br />

• Use of leveled trade books related to science and social<br />

studies units<br />

• Create charts, webs or other graphic organizers to help<br />

students learn to organize information<br />

• Group discussions<br />

• Direct teaching of structure of informational texts (compare<br />

with story structure)<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Information is taken from the text.<br />

• Details are related to the main idea.<br />

• Student may refer back to the book<br />

• Teacher observation in the following settings<br />

- <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

- Class discussions<br />

- Guided reading<br />

• May use prompts such as “What was the main<br />

idea of this book was about?” “What are two<br />

things that you learned about ____ from this<br />

book?”<br />

• NOTE: Make sure text is about information<br />

students are not likely already to know before<br />

reading the book (check on prior knowledge)<br />

16 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

EXPANDING (Grade 2)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

5. Makes connections, with guidance, to books and personal experiences.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Read alouds (Choose stories with obvious connections)<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Literature circles<br />

• Junior Great Books<br />

• Graphic organizers (e.g., charts and webs)<br />

• Folk tales unit (social studies)<br />

• Trade books in science kit<br />

• Think-alouds with teacher modeling making text-to-self<br />

and/or text-to-text connections<br />

• Class or small group brainstorms connections<br />

• Behavior-over-time-graphs<br />

• Comparing fiction/nonfiction books (e.g., Steck/Vaughn<br />

fiction/nonfiction series)<br />

• Comparing different versions of same story<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> several books by the same author<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> several books of the same genre or topic<br />

• Resources: Mosaic of Thought (Chapter 4) and Strategies<br />

that Work (Chapter 6 and page 265)<br />

• Rigby PM Benchmark Kit, com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

questions on the back of the Running Record<br />

sheet<br />

• Teacher observations in the following settings:<br />

- Individual reading conferences<br />

- Literature Circles<br />

- Classroom discussions<br />

- Guided reading groups<br />

- Junior Great Books groups<br />

• Student written responses<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Relates background knowledge/experience to their reading of a text<br />

• Makes connections between and among authors and texts read, seeing similarities and differences<br />

• Teacher may use such prompts as “Does this remind you of anything that ever happened to you?” or “Does this<br />

remind you of another book we have read?”<br />

Strategies<br />

6. Uses multiple strategies automatically as needed (using book levels J-M).<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Shared reading (e.g., for instruction, modeling and guided<br />

practice)<br />

• Think-alouds<br />

• Mini-lessons<br />

• Guided reading<br />

• Daily independent reading with “just right” books<br />

• Cloze activities<br />

• See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p 149<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Independently checks to make sure that reading makes sense, sounds right, looks right.<br />

• Automatically uses multiple strategies to figure out words while focusing on meaning<br />

• Simultaneously processes meaning, structural and visual cues.<br />

• Running records* (M/S/V<br />

[Meaning/Structure/Visual] analysis)<br />

(See Guided <strong>Reading</strong>, p. 89 and Word Matters,<br />

pp. 113 and 222)<br />

• Analysis of running record<br />

• <strong>Reading</strong> conferences<br />

• Teacher observations/anecdotal records<br />

17 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004


READING RUBRIC<br />

EXPANDING (Grade 2)<br />

Com<strong>pre</strong>hension<br />

7. Uses tables of contents, captions, glossaries and indices to locate and gather information.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Shared reading of books in science and social studies kits<br />

• Shared reading of informational periodicals<br />

• Guided reading of material containing the above graphic<br />

aids<br />

• Make class books with Table of Contents and Index<br />

• Play “search and find” games, e.g.,<br />

- Who can find the page with information about ______?<br />

- On what page does chapter 3 begin?<br />

• Teacher observation in the following settings:<br />

- Individual reading conferences<br />

- Guided reading sessions<br />

- Class discussions<br />

- While gathering information for written reports<br />

and projects<br />

• Student has authentic opportunities to use table of<br />

contents and indices to locate information he/she<br />

has a genuine interest in finding.<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Student locates information with the help of a table of contents.<br />

• Student locates information with the help of an index.<br />

• Student accurately gathers information communicated in captions and the graphics they accompany.<br />

• Student uses a glossary to determine the meaning of a word or phrase.<br />

• Student uses these tools on numerous occasions<br />

Strategies<br />

8. Effectively and efficiently analyzes longer words.<br />

Opportunities to Teach and Learn Include<br />

• 30 minutes of word work , daily (Word Matters, Phonics<br />

Lessons)<br />

• Use mini-lessons to teach strategies for solving words<br />

(Word Matters, p. 152, Phonics Lessons)<br />

• Use a structured, but flexible, word study system that builds<br />

on what students already know (See Word Matters, p. 171,<br />

Phonics Lessons)<br />

• Teach about syllables, root words, <strong>pre</strong>fixes and suffixes<br />

Opportunities to Assess Include<br />

• Running records*<br />

• Individual reading conferences<br />

• Writing samples<br />

• Teacher observation/anecdotal records<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Uses understanding of word structure to identify multi-syllabic words.<br />

• Figures out partially known words by making connections, analogies and using context.<br />

• Sounds out part of a word and links the part to known words or parts of words.<br />

• Is able to use the dictionary as a tool.<br />

• Student demonstrates this skill by reading fluently in meaningful phrases.<br />

Listening and Speaking<br />

9. Develops and elaborates ideas clearly, using supportive and relevant details.<br />

Opportunities to Teach Include:<br />

• Class meetings/community circles<br />

• Explaining solutions and thinking (EDM)<br />

• Generating and answering questions<br />

• Literature circles<br />

Secure Behaviors Include<br />

• Explains own ideas clearly.<br />

• Supports main idea with related details.<br />

• Ideas ex<strong>pre</strong>ssed are related to the topic being discussed<br />

Opportunities to Assess Includes:<br />

• Teacher observation in the following settings:<br />

- Individual reading conferences<br />

- Guided reading sessions<br />

- Literature circles<br />

- Community circles/class meetings<br />

- Class discussions<br />

- Students sharing information with a peer<br />

18 *See Section 3, “Helpful Assessment Forms” Revised October 2004

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!