14.11.2012 Views

A POSTCAPITALIST PARADIGM: THE COMMON GOOD OF ...

A POSTCAPITALIST PARADIGM: THE COMMON GOOD OF ...

A POSTCAPITALIST PARADIGM: THE COMMON GOOD OF ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

tween concern for social justice, respect for nature and political organization<br />

(cited by E. Gudynas, 2011, 9). The economist Pedro Páez, former<br />

Minister of Finance and member of the UN Stiglitz Commission on<br />

the international financial crisis, speaks of “living life to the full” (Pedro<br />

Páez, 2011, 7).<br />

As can be seen, in these discourses there is a considerable amount of<br />

interpretation in light of contemporary concerns, as well as the use of a<br />

vocabulary that differs from that used by the indigenous people. It indicates<br />

that the functions of the concept go beyond the work of recovering<br />

memory.<br />

If we turn to the notion of suma qamaña of the Aymaras of Bolivia, we<br />

can also cite various authors. David Chopquehuanca refers to the contrast<br />

between ‘vivir bien’ (living well) and “vivir mejor” (better living)<br />

which, because of its desire to consume always more, has brought<br />

about the deviations of the capitalist system. In contrast, the suma qamaña<br />

represents social complementariness, refusing exclusion and discrimination,<br />

and seeking the harmony of humanity with ‘Mother Earth’,<br />

respecting the laws of nature. All this constitutes a culture of life, rather<br />

than a culture of death (D. Choquehuanca, 2010, 57-74). For Simón Yamparo,<br />

this notion is part of the Aymara philosophy that demands harmony<br />

between the material and the spiritual, integral well-being, a holistic and<br />

harmonious conception of life (text of 2001, cited by E. Gudynas, 2011,<br />

6). Maria Eugenia Choque Quispe used another concept: suma jakaña<br />

which concentrates on dietary satisfaction, ensuring by the control of<br />

production, the fulfilment of life to its utmost and the development of<br />

the peoples (text of 2010, cited by E. Gudynas, 2011, 6).<br />

The main theoretician of suma qamaña is without doubt the anthropologist<br />

Xabier Abo, S.J., for whom it means “to live together well” (and<br />

not to live better than others). It is not only a question of material goods,<br />

but also spiritual ones. It is first necessary to satisfy local needs, living<br />

together with Mother Earth and with reciprocity and affection for others.<br />

“Vivir bien implies access and use of material goods in harmony with<br />

211

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!