a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua

a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua

historiantigua.cl
from historiantigua.cl More from this publisher
04.02.2015 Views

-438- 7: 3 28. Trousset 1978,167-79; 1980a, 936-39; cf. Goetschy 1894,593-98, for an interesting. but idiosyncratic account. 29. Pers. obs. 1982, with G. D. B. Jones and P. Reynolds. 30. Goetschy 1894,595-98. But see Luttwak 1976,68, on the limitations of even Hadrian's Wall as a fighting platform (the parapet there was nearly 2m wide and over 1.5-m high). 31. I know of no published plan of the gate, it seems to have been ruinous in Goetschy's time since he noted only the circular tank which adjoins it (1894,595 and plan). 32. It apparently escaped the attention of Euzennat 1972,21-23; and Trousset 1978,168-69. 33. The plaster rendering of the supposed "parapet walkway" is additional reason for favouring the idea of a cistern catchment. 34. A single example of Hayes 1972, ARS form 23B (with internal rim-roll) was identified. 35. Tissot 1888,690,820; Blanchet 1898; 1899; Donau 1904a. 36. The "Mareth line" of the Axis powers was broken by a British outflanking drive up this corridor in 1943, Moreau 1947,8; Trousset 1974,63-64. 37. Donau 1904a, 472-73, for the latter view and Blanchet 1898,71-74 for the former. See now Trousset 1974,62-67 and pl. 23-24. 38. Baradez 1949a, passim and pers. obs. in Algeria (1979,1980) and Libya (1981). 39. Trousset 1974,64-65 and fig. 8. 40. Donau 1904a, 472-73; 1909a, 32 (for the tomb dedication reused in the wall); Blanchet 1898,72-73; 1899,145-46 (with plan). 41. Trousset 1974,65-67 and fig. 9. 42. Blanchet 1898,73 and 1899,147-48, was quite specific on this point. According to him, the central gate was 6x 10 m and was surrounded by an outer enceinte measuring 15 x 24 m which connected with the clausura. This was still visible in 1982, though partly obscured by Donau's spoil heaps. The new plan is the work of Professor G. D. B. Jones, P. Reynolds and myself. 43. Trousset 1974,62-67; 139-41; Donau 1904a, 475. 44. Only a small quantity was noted but there were three examples of Hayes 1972, ARS form 27/33 or 181 (third century). 45. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396,402; Blanchet 1899,139-45; Hilaire 1901, 100-01; Euzennat 1972,12-13; Trousset 1974,97-102. 46. The discovery of the Skiffa south clausura was made by myself with Prof. G. D. B. Jones and P. Reynolds. 47. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396; Trousset 1974,97. 48. Hilaire 1901,100-01. 49. It presumably lay a few kilometres west of Benia, which as Trousset 1974,96, noted lies on another major east to west route. Several other passes here and in the Gebel Matmata might repay further investigation. 50. Trousset 1974,97 and fig. 29. 51. Pers. obs. 1982. 52. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396; Blanchet 1898,76; 1899,140. 53. Their identification as towers goes back to Blanchet, but was still accepted by Trousset 1974,97. A cemetery containing 7 such tumuli was examined in 1982 on a low ridge just south of Hr Ragoubah (Trousset 1974,98). ARS pottery and flints were noted in the vicinity of the tombs. Another supposed circular tower, at Hr Ragoubah itself proved on examination to be also a tumulus covering a square mausoleum (pers. obs. ). 54. It was not possible for me to visit the northern end in 1982, but there is a ruin plainly visible on my zoom lens photograph.

-438- 7: 3 28. Trousset 1978,167-79; 1980aß 936-39; cf. Goetschy 1894,593-98, for an interesting-but idiosyncratic account. - 29. Pers. obs. 1982, with G. D. H. Jones and P. Reynolds. 30. Goetschy 1894,595-98. But see. Luttwak 1976,68, on the limitations of even Hadrian's Wall as a fighting platform (the parapet there was nearly 2m wide and over 1.5 m high). 31. I know of no published plan of the gate, it seems to have been ruinous in Goetschy's time since he noted only the circular tank which adjoins it (1894,595 and plan). 32. It apparently escaped the attention of Euzennat 1972,21-23; and Trousset 1978,168-69. 33. The plaster rendering of the supposed "parapet walkway" is additional reason for favouring the idea of a cistern catchment. 34. A single example of Hayes 1972, ARS form 23B (with internal rim-roll) was identified. 35. Tissot 1888,690,820; Blanchet 1898; 1899; Donau 1904a. 36. The "Mareth line" of the Axis powers was broken by a British outflanking drive up this corridor in 1943, Moreau 1947,8; Trousset 1974,63-64. 37. Donau 1904a, 472-73, for the latter view and Blanchet 1898,71-74 for the former. See now Trousset 1974,62-67 and pl. 23-24. 38. Baradez 1949a, passim and pers. obs. in Algeria (1979,1980) and Libya (1981). 39. Trousset 1974,64-65 and fig. 8. 40. Donau 1904a, 472-73; 1909a, 32 (for the tomb dedication reused in the wall) ; Blanchet 1898,72-73; 1899,145-46 (with plan). 41. Trousset 1974,65-67 and fig. 9. 42. Blanchet 1898,73 and 1899,147-48, was quite specific on this point. According to him, the central gate was 6x 10 m and was surrounded by an outer enceinte measuring 15 x 24 m which connected with the clausura. This was still visible in 1982, though partly obscured by Donau's spoil heaps. The new plan is the work of Professor G. D. B. Jones, P. Reynolds and myself. 43. Trousset 1974,62-67; 139-41; Donau 1904a, 475. 44. Only a small quantity was noted but there were three examples of Hayes 1972, ARS form 27/33 or 181(third century). 45. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396,402; Blanchet 1899,139-45; Hilaire 1901, 100-01; Euzennat 1972,12-13; Trousset 1974,97-102. 46. The discovery of the Skiffa south clausura was made by myself with Prof. G. D. B. Jones and P. Reynolds. 47. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396; Trousset 1974,97. 48. Hilaire 1901,100-01. 49. It presumably lay a few kilometres west of Benia, which as Trousset 1974,96, noted lies on another major east to west route. Several other passes here and in the Gebel Matmata might repay further investigation. 50. Trousset 1974,97 and fig. 29. 51. Pers. obs. 1982. 52. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396; Blanchet 1898,76; 1899,140. 53. Their identification as towers goes back to Blanchet, but was still accepted by Trousset 1974,97. A cemetery containing 7 such tumuli was examined in 1982 on a low ridge just south of Hr Ragoubah (Trousset 1974,98). ARS pottery and flints were noted in the vicinity of the tombs. Another supposed circular tower, at Hr Ragoubah itself proved on examination to be also a tumulus covering a square mausoleum (pers. obs. ). 54. It was not possible for me to visit the northern end in 1982, but there is a ruin plainly visible on my zoom lens photograph.

-438-<br />

7: 3<br />

28. Trousset 1978,167-79; 1980a, 936-39; cf. Goetschy 1894,593-98,<br />

for an interesting. but idiosyncratic account.<br />

29. Pers. obs. 1982, with G. D. B. Jones and P. Reynolds.<br />

30. Goetschy 1894,595-98. But see Luttwak 1976,68, on the limitations<br />

<strong>of</strong> even Hadrian's Wall as a fighting platform (the parapet there was<br />

nearly 2m wide and over 1.5-m high).<br />

31. I know <strong>of</strong> no published plan <strong>of</strong> the gate, it seems to have been ruinous<br />

in Goetschy's time since he noted only the circular tank which adjoins<br />

it (1894,595 and plan).<br />

32. It apparently escaped the attention <strong>of</strong> Euzennat 1972,21-23; and<br />

Trousset 1978,168-69.<br />

33. The plaster rendering <strong>of</strong> the supposed "parapet walkway" is additional<br />

reason for favouring the idea <strong>of</strong> a cistern catchment.<br />

34. A single example <strong>of</strong> Hayes 1972, ARS form 23B (with internal rim-roll)<br />

was identified.<br />

35. Tissot 1888,690,820; Blanchet 1898; 1899; Donau 1904a.<br />

36. The "Mareth line" <strong>of</strong> the Axis powers was broken by a British outflanking<br />

drive up this corridor in 1943, Moreau 1947,8; Trousset 1974,63-64.<br />

37. Donau 1904a, 472-73, for the latter view and Blanchet 1898,71-74 for<br />

the former. See now Trousset 1974,62-67 and pl. 23-24.<br />

38. Baradez 1949a, passim and pers. obs. in Algeria (1979,1980) and<br />

Libya (1981).<br />

39. Trousset 1974,64-65 and fig. 8.<br />

40. Donau 1904a, 472-73; 1909a, 32 (for the tomb dedication reused in the<br />

wall); Blanchet 1898,72-73; 1899,145-46 (with plan).<br />

41. Trousset 1974,65-67 and fig. 9.<br />

42. Blanchet 1898,73 and 1899,147-48, was quite specific on this point.<br />

According to him, the central gate was 6x 10 m and was surrounded by<br />

an outer enceinte measuring 15 x 24 m which connected with the<br />

clausura. This was still visible in 1982, though partly obscured<br />

by Donau's spoil heaps. The new plan is the work <strong>of</strong> Pr<strong>of</strong>essor G. D. B.<br />

Jones, P. Reynolds and myself.<br />

43. Trousset 1974,62-67; 139-41; Donau 1904a, 475.<br />

44. Only a small quantity was noted but there were three examples <strong>of</strong><br />

Hayes 1972, ARS form 27/33 or 181 (third century).<br />

45. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396,402; Blanchet 1899,139-45; Hilaire 1901,<br />

100-01; Euzennat 1972,12-13; Trousset 1974,97-102.<br />

46. The discovery <strong>of</strong> the Skiffa south clausura was made by myself with<br />

Pr<strong>of</strong>. G. D. B. Jones and P. Reynolds.<br />

47. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396; Trousset 1974,97.<br />

48. Hilaire 1901,100-01.<br />

49. It presumably lay a few kilometres west <strong>of</strong> Benia, which as Trousset<br />

1974,96, noted lies on another major east to west route.<br />

Several other passes here and in the Gebel Matmata might repay further<br />

investigation.<br />

50. Trousset 1974,97 and fig. 29.<br />

51. Pers. obs. 1982.<br />

52. Lecoy de la Marche 1894,396; Blanchet 1898,76; 1899,140.<br />

53. Their identification as towers goes back to Blanchet, but was still<br />

accepted by Trousset 1974,97. A cemetery containing 7 such tumuli<br />

was examined in 1982 on a low ridge just south <strong>of</strong> Hr Ragoubah (Trousset<br />

1974,98). ARS pottery and flints were noted in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> the<br />

tombs. Another supposed circular tower, at Hr Ragoubah itself<br />

proved on examination to be also a tumulus covering a square<br />

mausoleum (pers. obs. ).<br />

54. It was not possible for me to visit the northern end in 1982, but<br />

there is a ruin plainly visible on my zoom lens photograph.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!