a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua
a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua
-396- 4: 3 CULTURE AND RELIGION 1. Bates 1914,118-141, Dress and ornamentation; 142-171, Material culture and art; 172-209, Religion. See now, Camps 1980,145-92, on the varied acculturation of the Berber peoples, 193-271 on religion. 2. Garnsey 1978,252-54. 3. Benabou 1976, passim; compare the review by Whittaker 1978b, 190-92. 4. Garnsey 1978,254. Janon 1977,474-77, made the same basic point when he referred to the"permeabitE selective" of Roman culture. 5. Beechey and Beechey 1828,504-12. 6. As an example of the wealth of some graves, Daniels 1973,39, records the contents of tomb 17 as follows: a saddle quern and rubber, an incense cup. 11 amphorae, 5 glass bowls, 9 small faience bowls (Egyptian) ; 31 fine red ware bowls and dishes (including Arretine ware). This quantity of grave goods is paralleled in other burials, Ayoub 1967b, 213-19. 7. Moorhead 1960,58, records that Speke's gifts for Mukesa, king of Buganda, included several rifles and guns, a gold watch, a telescope, an iron chair, beads, silk cloths and knives, spoons and forks! 8. Rebuffat 1969,194-95; 1972,322-23. The finds of second century pottery cover an area of 1.5 km2 (the modern oasis is 2 km2). 9. Bates 1914,189-200; Camps 1980,215-20, on the predominant place of Ammon in the pantheon of the Eastern Libyans; see also Leglay 1966, a fundamental work on the religion of the indigenous population of Africa. 10. Herodotus, I, 46; II, 18; 32; III, 25 (Zeus Ammon); IRT. 920 (lovi Hammon); Rebuffat 1967,62-3; 1973b, 135-36. 11. Rebuffat 1970c, 182; Bates 1914,200. The inscription (IRT 920) from Bu Njem celebrates the return of the vexillation. 12. The associations of the Ammon cult and oases are illustrated by Lucan, IX, 522-27. Esse locis superos testatur silva per omnem/sola virens Libyen. Nam quidquid pulvere sicco/separat ardentem tepida Berenicida Lepti/Ignorat frondes; solus nemus abstulit Hammon/Silvarum fons causa loco, qui putria terrae/A1ligat et domitas unda conectit harenas. 13. Bates 1914,191-95, identified Egyptian representations of Amon as a seated and enbalmed figure. The fact that the Nasamones buried their dead in such a seated position (Herodotus, IV, 190) and were celebrated for their practice of ancestor worship (Mela, I, 8,46) are evidence for the significance of this aspect of the Ammon cult. 14. Bates 1914,190-95, listed the chief references to the prophetic powers of Ammon. The importance of the Siwa oracle declined in the Roman period and frequent references suggest that a second, more westerly, oracular centre developed, almost certainly at Augila. (Silius Italicus, III, 6-11; III, 647-714; Lucan IX, 522-27; Procopius, de Aed. VI, 2,15-20). 15. Bates, 1914,190-95; Rebuffat 1970c, 181-87; Augila, see 4: 2 note 74; Bu Njem (Gholaia), Rebuffat 1967,62-3; 1970b, 135-36 and Fig 5, p. 162; Ras el-Haddagia (Breviglieri) Goodchild 1951b/1976.79-84, Levi Della Vida 1951,65-68; Arae Philaenorum Goodchild 1952d, 159,167; Ad Ammonem (16 Roman miles west of Sabratha), Tab Peut, Seg VII; also Ptolemy, IV, 3,42 for a site somewhere in the Tripolitanian hinterland; in Benghazi there is a hill still called Tel Amun. 16. Corippus, III, 77-155, on the visit of the father of Antalas to the oracle of Ammon to learn his son's destiny; VI, 145-187, on the oracle sought by Carcasan and then used to excite opposition to Byzantium; VI, 556; VII, 515-520; VIII, 252, all reiterate the importance of the oracle to the cohesion of the Laguatan confederation. Other significant religious references are, II, 109-112; III, 158-70; VI, 116-18. 17. Frend 1971. 18. Gellner 1969,31-34. 19. Gellner 1969,8-9.
-397- 4: 3j4; 4 20. Camps 1960,279-95; 1980,220-24. 21. Camps 1960,283-84; RIL, no. 2 (temple of Massinissa et Dougga); J. G. Fevrier 1951,139-50 (dedication of shrine to Micipsa at Cherchel). 22. Corippus, loh, III, 77-155. 23. loh, III, 158-70. 24. loh, II, 109-12. 25. loh, V, 22-31. 26. loh, V, 495-502. 27. Ioh, VI, 145-187; 556; VII, 515-20; VIII, 252. 28. Gellner 1969,26-28; Camps 1980,309-10. 29. Gellner 1969,26. 30. Gellner 1969,4; Duclos 1973,217-229. 4: 4 WARFARE 1. Herodotus, IV, 183; Law 1967,181-83; Graziosi 1969,3-20. 2. Law 1967,181. 3. Silius Italicus I, 215-19, described Numidian cavalry who did not use a bridle, but guided their horses with a switch and were famed for their guile. The same was evidently still true in the fourth century A. D.. Ammianus Marcellinus, XXIX, 5, described the Moorish cavalry as hostis discursator et repentinus, insidisque potius clandestinus quarr praeliorum stabilitate confidens. 4. Livy, XLV, 13,13-14, on Numidian cavalry serving with Rome in Macedonia; XXIX, 34,4-7, on Carthaginian recruitment of Numidian cavalry as the best in Africa; XXXV, 11,4-13 is a detailed account of a notable victory for 800 Numidian horsemen in Spain in 193 B. C. Lucan, IV, 715-87, described Curio's defeat by Juba in an ambush that underline the value of his light armed cavalry and skirmishers. 5. Livy, XXIV, 48,3-8. 6. Lucan, IV, 677-83, "Autotoles, Numidaeque vagi semperque paratus Inculto Gaetulus equo, tum concolor Indo Maurus, inops Nasamon, mixti Garamantae perusto Marmaridae volucres, aequaturusque sagittas Medorum, tremulum cum torsit missile Mazax Et gens quae nudo residens Massylia dorso Ora levi flectit frenorum nescia virga. " 7. Silius Italicus, II, 56-57. The passage is an interesting one, as the tribal contingents were led by Asbyte, daughter of Hiarbas, the Garamantian, who was reputed to be the son of Ammon and whose power extended over the other tribes. Some of Asbyte's followers are depicted riding in two-horse chariots, others were on horseback (11,82-83). 8. Silius Italicus, V, 185; IX, 220-223; note also XV. 672f, concerning Nabis, an Armonian chieftain fighting on horseback. 9. Strabo, XVII, 3,19. Compare horse-breeding in more recent times, Daumas, 1850/1968, passim. 10. Silius Italicus, III, 287-93. 11. Caesar, BAf, XIV, described an engagement with Juba. The interaction between cavalry and infantry was designed to break-up the Roman battle order and at the same time prevent the Romans fully engaging battle. 12. Herodotus, VII, 71; Strabo, XVII, 3,7; Caesar, BAf, XIV; Silius Italicus, IV, 445 (tells Garamantica pubes); III, 275-77 (on the Macae who used a barbed spear, the cateia); Diodorus Siculus, III, 49,5. 13. Bates 1914,144. 14. Diodorus Siculus, III, 49,5. 15. Bates 1914,146. 16. Daumas 1850/1971,25-43.
- Page 1 and 2: TRIP0LITANIA: a comparative study o
- Page 3 and 4: -367- FOOTNOTES Chapter 1: Introduc
- Page 5 and 6: -369- 1: 2 /1: 3 14. Benabou 1976,
- Page 7 and 8: -371- CHAPTER 2: GEOGRAPHY AND CLIM
- Page 9 and 10: -373- 2: 2/2: 3 45. Capot-Rey 1953,
- Page 11 and 12: -375- 2: 4 10. Penrose et al, 1970;
- Page 13 and 14: -377- 2: 5/2: 6 34. On the lotus, s
- Page 15 and 16: -379- 2: 7 the basis of the mileage
- Page 17 and 18: -381- 2: 7 64. Goodchild 1954 b and
- Page 19 and 20: -383- 7 3: 1/3: 2 17. An example of
- Page 21 and 22: -385- 3: 2/3: 3 46. Frezouls 1957,6
- Page 23 and 24: -387- 3: 3 tribes which cumulativel
- Page 25 and 26: -389- 3: 3 75. There were at least
- Page 27 and 28: -391- 4: 1 21. Johnson 1969,1-3. 22
- Page 29 and 30: -393- 4: 2 13. Sallust, BJ, XCII, 1
- Page 31: -395- 4: 2 65. For Saniat Gebril, s
- Page 35 and 36: -399- 4: 5 12. See above note 7. Ma
- Page 37 and 38: I -401- CHAPTER 5 FRONTIER THEORY A
- Page 39 and 40: -403- 5: 1 36. A few examples from
- Page 41 and 42: -405- 5: 1 66. On Byzantine frontie
- Page 43 and 44: -407- 5: 2 15. Desanges 1957,5-43.
- Page 45 and 46: -409- 5: 2 intervention and when Ca
- Page 47 and 48: -411- 5: 3 12. The evidence has bee
- Page 49 and 50: -413- 5: 3 50. See note 49, above.
- Page 51 and 52: -415- 5: 4 43. Rebuffat 1981,213-22
- Page 53 and 54: -417- FOOTNOTES CHAPTER 6 TRIPODITA
- Page 55 and 56: -419- 6: 1 53. Romanelli 1939,110-1
- Page 57 and 58: -421- 6: 2 9. The case has been con
- Page 59 and 60: -423- 6: 2 /6: 3 presented each one
- Page 61 and 62: -425- 6: 3 Tillibari (Ramada); Then
- Page 63 and 64: -427- 6: 3 have been a nzanerus col
- Page 65 and 66: -429- 6: 4 9. Rebuffat 1977,402-14;
- Page 67 and 68: -431- 7: 1 26. See Jones et al 1983
- Page 69 and 70: -433- 7; 1/7; 2 81. Cagnat 1913,542
- Page 71 and 72: 7: 2 -435- 45. The survey of the si
- Page 73 and 74: -437- 7; 3 2. See Pringle 1981,96 a
- Page 75 and 76: -438- 7: 3 28. Trousset 1978,167-79
- Page 77 and 78: -440- 7: 4 V1CI 1. The study of vic
- Page 79 and 80: -442- 7; 4 53. But one should note
- Page 81 and 82: -444- 8: 1 26. Dore 1983,54-57. Als
-396-<br />
4: 3 CULTURE AND RELIGION<br />
1. Bates 1914,118-141, Dress and ornamentation; 142-171, Material culture<br />
and art; 172-209, Religion. See now, Camps 1980,145-92, on the varied<br />
acculturation <strong>of</strong> the Berber peoples, 193-271 on religion.<br />
2. Garnsey 1978,252-54.<br />
3. Benabou 1976, passim; compare the review by Whittaker 1978b, 190-92.<br />
4. Garnsey 1978,254. Janon 1977,474-77, made the same basic point when<br />
he referred to the"permeabitE selective" <strong>of</strong> <strong>Roman</strong> culture.<br />
5. Beechey and Beechey 1828,504-12.<br />
6. As an example <strong>of</strong> the wealth <strong>of</strong> some graves, Daniels 1973,39, records<br />
the contents <strong>of</strong> tomb 17 as follows: a saddle quern and rubber, an<br />
incense cup. 11 amphorae, 5 glass bowls, 9 small faience bowls<br />
(Egyptian) ; 31 fine red ware bowls and dishes (including Arretine ware).<br />
This quantity <strong>of</strong> grave goods is paralleled in other burials, Ayoub 1967b,<br />
213-19.<br />
7. Moorhead 1960,58, records that Speke's gifts for Mukesa, king <strong>of</strong><br />
Buganda, included several rifles and guns, a gold watch, a telescope,<br />
an iron chair, beads, silk cloths and knives, spoons and forks!<br />
8. Rebuffat 1969,194-95; 1972,322-23. The finds <strong>of</strong> second century<br />
pottery cover an area <strong>of</strong> 1.5 km2 (the modern oasis is 2 km2).<br />
9. Bates 1914,189-200; Camps 1980,215-20, on the predominant place <strong>of</strong><br />
Ammon in the pantheon <strong>of</strong> the Eastern Libyans; see also Leglay 1966,<br />
a fundamental work on the religion <strong>of</strong> the indigenous population <strong>of</strong><br />
Africa.<br />
10. Herodotus, I, 46; II, 18; 32; III, 25 (Zeus Ammon); IRT. 920<br />
(lovi Hammon); Rebuffat 1967,62-3; 1973b, 135-36.<br />
11. Rebuffat 1970c, 182; Bates 1914,200. The inscription (IRT 920)<br />
from Bu Njem celebrates the return <strong>of</strong> the vexillation.<br />
12. The associations <strong>of</strong> the Ammon cult and oases are illustrated by Lucan,<br />
IX, 522-27. Esse locis superos testatur silva per omnem/sola virens<br />
Libyen. Nam quidquid pulvere sicco/separat ardentem tepida Berenicida<br />
Lepti/Ignorat frondes; solus nemus abstulit Hammon/Silvarum fons causa<br />
loco, qui putria terrae/A1ligat et domitas unda conectit harenas.<br />
13. Bates 1914,191-95, identified Egyptian representations <strong>of</strong> Amon as a<br />
seated and enbalmed figure. The fact that the Nasamones buried their<br />
dead in such a seated position (Herodotus, IV, 190) and were celebrated<br />
for their practice <strong>of</strong> ancestor worship (Mela, I, 8,46) are evidence<br />
for the significance <strong>of</strong> this aspect <strong>of</strong> the Ammon cult.<br />
14. Bates 1914,190-95, listed the chief references to the prophetic powers<br />
<strong>of</strong> Ammon. The importance <strong>of</strong> the Siwa oracle declined in the <strong>Roman</strong><br />
period and frequent references suggest that a second, more westerly,<br />
oracular centre developed, almost certainly at Augila. (Silius Italicus,<br />
III, 6-11; III, 647-714; Lucan IX, 522-27; Procopius, de Aed. VI, 2,15-20).<br />
15. Bates, 1914,190-95; Rebuffat 1970c, 181-87; Augila, see 4: 2 note 74;<br />
Bu Njem (Gholaia), Rebuffat 1967,62-3; 1970b, 135-36 and Fig 5, p. 162;<br />
Ras el-Haddagia (Breviglieri) Goodchild 1951b/1976.79-84, Levi Della<br />
Vida 1951,65-68; Arae Philaenorum Goodchild 1952d, 159,167;<br />
Ad Ammonem (16 <strong>Roman</strong> miles west <strong>of</strong> Sabratha), Tab Peut, Seg VII;<br />
also Ptolemy, IV, 3,42 for a site somewhere in the Tripolitanian<br />
hinterland; in Benghazi there is a hill still called Tel Amun.<br />
16. Corippus, III, 77-155, on the visit <strong>of</strong> the father <strong>of</strong> Antalas to the<br />
oracle <strong>of</strong> Ammon to learn his son's destiny; VI, 145-187, on the oracle<br />
sought by Carcasan and then used to excite opposition to Byzantium;<br />
VI, 556; VII, 515-520; VIII, 252, all reiterate the importance <strong>of</strong> the<br />
oracle to the cohesion <strong>of</strong> the Laguatan confederation. Other significant<br />
religious references are, II, 109-112; III, 158-70; VI, 116-18.<br />
17. Frend 1971.<br />
18. Gellner 1969,31-34.<br />
19. Gellner 1969,8-9.