a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua
a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua
-394- 4: 2 40. Daniels 1970b, 66; 1971a, 262-65. 41. Daniels 1971a, 267-78; 1973,35-40. 42. Daniels 1971a, 269-70; 1973,36-37. 43. Pliny, NH, V, 35-38. 44. El Bekri (1913 trans), 32-35. 45. See also Jones and Barker 1980,29-34; Burns and Mattingly 1981,27-29; Allan 1980,26. 46. These population figures only take account of those people for whom permanent buildings were provided. Larger numbers could have used the sites as refuges in times of danger. 47. Although polygamy was allegedly widespread among the Libyans (Mela, I, 8,45; Herodotus, IV, 172; Strabo, XVII, 3,19), the monogamous family unit of four is a convenient base for calculation. 48. Cunliffe 1978,279-80; Hogg 1962,22-23 proposed a population of c. 400 people for Garn Boduan. 49. Alcock 1965,194, suggested a population nearer 700 for Garn Boduan. 50. Personal communication, David Coombes; the figure is based on a spatial allowance of 10 m sq a 100 m2 per person. 51. S. Stanford, personal communication, 1982. 52. Jones and Barker 1980,23,29-34; Barker and Jones 1982,3-6. 53. The natural water resources of the Magrusa/Mdhaweb area would have been inadequate to accommodate a population of, for instance, 800 people with flocks on a year round basis. Using figures produced by Barker and Jones 1982,20; the following hypothetical water requirement figures can be proposed. 800 people for one year require 2,000,000+ litres .... 2,000 sheep for one year require .... 1,000,000+ litres TOTAL, over 3,000,000 litres Unless there were springs (now defunct) in antiquity, this total would have had-to be collected as surface run-off, a seemingly impossible total. Winter occupation only, however, would require a fraction of these totals. 54. Plans kindly shown to me at Bu Njem by M. Redde in 1980. See now, Rebuffat 1982c, 198, for a reference to the hilltop village at Bir Zayden. 55. Despois 1935,171-277; Louis 1975,37-125, particularly 46-53 for finds of Roman material from the hilltop village of Chenini. Trousset (pers. comm. ) believes that there are many hillforts of early date in the Gebel Demmer. 56. Trousset 1974, site 89 (p. 87) El Kseir and site 119 (p. 105-6) Djebel Rjinjila are probably hillforts. There are other hillforts, mostly of late date, in the Gafsa and Metlaoui district further north (Trousset, pers, comet. 57. Diodorus Siculus, III, 49,1-3. 58. See note 70, below. 59. See 4: 1, note 26, above. 60. Pliny, NH, V. 35-37. Vivien de St Martin 1863; Duveyrier 1864,445-88, established the fashion for seeking linguistic parallels in the modern Fezzan, Tissot 1888,711-20; Lhote 1954,41-81; Desanges 1957,5-43, looked further afield but some scholars still prefer to limit the scope of the campaign to the Fezzan, Romanelli 1977,429-38; Berthier 1981,94. 61. Ptolemy, IV, 6; Pliny, V, 35-37. 62. Daniels 1975,251; Klitzsch and Baird 1969,73-80. 63. Poncet 1963,278-91, especially 280-82, discussed the foggaras from 28 springs at Kebili. North-west of the oasis there are over 17 km of foggaras and 600,000 m3 of earth was moved by hand in antiquity. 64. Daniels 1973,36. The decision followed the Italian expedition to the Fezzan in 1933-34, whose results were published as Pace, Sergi and Caputo 1951.
-395- 4: 2 65. For Saniat Gebril, see Daniels 1971a, 264-65; 1971b, 6-7, a single large building of mud-brick occupied an area approaching 800 sq. m and the three phases of occupation dated from the first to third centuries A. D. For Old Germa/Garama see, Ayoub 1962,12-20; 1967a, 12-26; Daniels 1971a, 264-65; 1973,36-37. 66. Daniels 1971a, 264-65. 67. See above, Chapter 4: 1, also Daniels 1970a, 36-44. The number of graves in the Wadi el -Agial is now thought to be several times in excess of 60,000; Daniels 1975,249-51. 68. Trousset 1974,41-50, site no. 1, oasis of Bechri; 3, village of Negga; 4, oasis of Rabta; 5, oasis of Mannsoura; 6, oasis of Telmine, 7, oasis of Kebili; 8, environs of Kebili; 9, Kedouat Johala; 10, oasis of Bechili; 11, oasis of Djemna; 12, village of Galaa; 13, oasis of Douz; 14, oasis of Nouil; 15, spring of Ghedema; 16, oasis of Sabria; 17, wells at Bir el Hachana. 69. Personal observation, Easter 1982. 70. ILAf 655 and AE, 1910, no. 21 - CIL 8.83. Also recorded as Turris Tamalleni in the Antonine Itinerary (74). 71. Trousset 1976,21-33; 1980b, 135-54. ' 72. Rebuff at 1969,194-95; 1972,322-23; 1975,498-99; also concerning the Roman period tombs at Ghadames, see Mercier 1953,17-47; Coro 1956, 3-26. See below 4: 3, note 8. A wealth of ethnographic material has been recorded on the extraordinary caravan town of Ghadames, see inter alia, Duveyrier 1864,249-54; Richardson 1848,92-384. 73. Rebuffat 1972,323-24 records second century pottery and native fortifications at the Sinaouen, Tfelfel, Materes and Chawan oases to the east and north-east of Ghadames. 74. Rebuffat 1970c, 181-87; 1970d, 1-20. The evidence is mainly historical for Augila, the series of linked oases being described as a tribal centre in several sources, Herodotus, IV, 190; Mela, I, 8,46; Procopius, de aed, VI, 2,14-20. See also Bates 1914 8-10. 75. Rebuffat 1970c, 181-87; 1972,324-26; 1975,498. 76. Rebuffat 1972,324-26. 77. For Bu Njem (Gholaia) see, Rebuffat 1973b, 121-34; 1973c, 135-45. The work of the ULVP at Gheriat el-Garbia revealed the existence of a small promontory fort above the spring, on the west side of the wadi. The construction of the rampart, using two rough faces of limestone slabs set of edge is reminiscent of the native construction at Magrusa, Jones et al 1983. 78. Euzennat and Trousset 1975,66, have suggested that Tillibari and Talalati may correspond with Cillibaris and Alele, named by Pliny, V, 35. Louis 1975,42-45, mentions surviving traces from the oases settlement (which certainly outlived the Roman fort, Corippus II, 79-80). 79. Ward Perkins and Goodchild 1949,1976,29 (Mizda); The pivotal position of the double oasis at Mizda between the zone of pre-desert agriculture and Phazania is suggestive of an early importance for the site. There are extensive traces of ancient ruins around the oases (Barth 1857,99-104) and the original focus of settlement probably lay beneath the western oasis. The important wells of Schegegeh mark the southern end of the transhumance corridor controlled by the Hadd Hajar clausura. The ancient wells and other traces of ancient settlement have apparently been obliterated by recent development, (personal observation). 80. Brogan 1965b, 57-64; Rebuffat 1975c, 499-500. 81. As has been the practice since antiquity in Nefzaoua, Fezzan and the North Sahara. Briggs 1960,3-12.
- Page 1 and 2: TRIP0LITANIA: a comparative study o
- Page 3 and 4: -367- FOOTNOTES Chapter 1: Introduc
- Page 5 and 6: -369- 1: 2 /1: 3 14. Benabou 1976,
- Page 7 and 8: -371- CHAPTER 2: GEOGRAPHY AND CLIM
- Page 9 and 10: -373- 2: 2/2: 3 45. Capot-Rey 1953,
- Page 11 and 12: -375- 2: 4 10. Penrose et al, 1970;
- Page 13 and 14: -377- 2: 5/2: 6 34. On the lotus, s
- Page 15 and 16: -379- 2: 7 the basis of the mileage
- Page 17 and 18: -381- 2: 7 64. Goodchild 1954 b and
- Page 19 and 20: -383- 7 3: 1/3: 2 17. An example of
- Page 21 and 22: -385- 3: 2/3: 3 46. Frezouls 1957,6
- Page 23 and 24: -387- 3: 3 tribes which cumulativel
- Page 25 and 26: -389- 3: 3 75. There were at least
- Page 27 and 28: -391- 4: 1 21. Johnson 1969,1-3. 22
- Page 29: -393- 4: 2 13. Sallust, BJ, XCII, 1
- Page 33 and 34: -397- 4: 3j4; 4 20. Camps 1960,279-
- Page 35 and 36: -399- 4: 5 12. See above note 7. Ma
- Page 37 and 38: I -401- CHAPTER 5 FRONTIER THEORY A
- Page 39 and 40: -403- 5: 1 36. A few examples from
- Page 41 and 42: -405- 5: 1 66. On Byzantine frontie
- Page 43 and 44: -407- 5: 2 15. Desanges 1957,5-43.
- Page 45 and 46: -409- 5: 2 intervention and when Ca
- Page 47 and 48: -411- 5: 3 12. The evidence has bee
- Page 49 and 50: -413- 5: 3 50. See note 49, above.
- Page 51 and 52: -415- 5: 4 43. Rebuffat 1981,213-22
- Page 53 and 54: -417- FOOTNOTES CHAPTER 6 TRIPODITA
- Page 55 and 56: -419- 6: 1 53. Romanelli 1939,110-1
- Page 57 and 58: -421- 6: 2 9. The case has been con
- Page 59 and 60: -423- 6: 2 /6: 3 presented each one
- Page 61 and 62: -425- 6: 3 Tillibari (Ramada); Then
- Page 63 and 64: -427- 6: 3 have been a nzanerus col
- Page 65 and 66: -429- 6: 4 9. Rebuffat 1977,402-14;
- Page 67 and 68: -431- 7: 1 26. See Jones et al 1983
- Page 69 and 70: -433- 7; 1/7; 2 81. Cagnat 1913,542
- Page 71 and 72: 7: 2 -435- 45. The survey of the si
- Page 73 and 74: -437- 7; 3 2. See Pringle 1981,96 a
- Page 75 and 76: -438- 7: 3 28. Trousset 1978,167-79
- Page 77 and 78: -440- 7: 4 V1CI 1. The study of vic
- Page 79 and 80: -442- 7; 4 53. But one should note
-395-<br />
4: 2<br />
65. For Saniat Gebril, see Daniels 1971a, 264-65; 1971b, 6-7, a single<br />
large building <strong>of</strong> mud-brick occupied an area approaching 800 sq. m<br />
and the three phases <strong>of</strong> occupation dated from the first to third<br />
centuries A. D. For Old Germa/Garama see, Ayoub 1962,12-20; 1967a,<br />
12-26; Daniels 1971a, 264-65; 1973,36-37.<br />
66. Daniels 1971a, 264-65.<br />
67. See above, Chapter 4: 1, also Daniels 1970a, 36-44. The number <strong>of</strong> graves<br />
in<br />
the Wadi el -Agial<br />
is now thought to be several times in excess <strong>of</strong><br />
60,000; Daniels 1975,249-51.<br />
68. Trousset 1974,41-50, site no. 1, oasis <strong>of</strong> Bechri; 3, village <strong>of</strong> Negga;<br />
4, oasis <strong>of</strong> Rabta; 5, oasis <strong>of</strong> Mannsoura; 6, oasis <strong>of</strong> Telmine, 7, oasis<br />
<strong>of</strong> Kebili; 8, environs <strong>of</strong> Kebili; 9, Kedouat Johala; 10, oasis <strong>of</strong><br />
Bechili; 11, oasis <strong>of</strong> Djemna; 12, village <strong>of</strong> Galaa; 13, oasis <strong>of</strong> Douz;<br />
14, oasis <strong>of</strong> Nouil; 15, spring <strong>of</strong> Ghedema; 16, oasis <strong>of</strong> Sabria; 17, wells<br />
at Bir<br />
el Hachana.<br />
69. Personal observation, Easter 1982.<br />
70. ILAf 655 and AE, 1910, no. 21 - CIL 8.83. Also recorded as Turris<br />
Tamalleni in the Antonine Itinerary (74).<br />
71. Trousset 1976,21-33; 1980b, 135-54. '<br />
72. Rebuff at 1969,194-95; 1972,322-23; 1975,498-99; also concerning the<br />
<strong>Roman</strong> period tombs at Ghadames, see Mercier 1953,17-47; Coro 1956,<br />
3-26. See below 4: 3, note 8. A wealth <strong>of</strong> ethnographic material has<br />
been recorded on the extraordinary caravan town <strong>of</strong> Ghadames, see inter<br />
alia, Duveyrier 1864,249-54; Richardson 1848,92-384.<br />
73. Rebuffat 1972,323-24 records second century pottery and native<br />
fortifications at the Sinaouen, Tfelfel, Materes and Chawan oases to<br />
the east and north-east <strong>of</strong> Ghadames.<br />
74. Rebuffat 1970c, 181-87; 1970d, 1-20. The evidence is mainly historical<br />
for Augila, the series <strong>of</strong> linked oases being described as a tribal<br />
centre in several sources, Herodotus, IV, 190; Mela, I, 8,46; Procopius,<br />
de aed, VI, 2,14-20. See also Bates 1914 8-10.<br />
75. Rebuffat 1970c, 181-87; 1972,324-26; 1975,498.<br />
76. Rebuffat 1972,324-26.<br />
77. For Bu Njem (Gholaia) see, Rebuffat 1973b, 121-34; 1973c, 135-45. The<br />
work <strong>of</strong> the ULVP at Gheriat el-Garbia revealed the existence <strong>of</strong> a small<br />
promontory fort above the spring, on the west side <strong>of</strong> the wadi. The<br />
construction <strong>of</strong> the rampart, using two rough faces <strong>of</strong> limestone slabs<br />
set <strong>of</strong> edge is reminiscent <strong>of</strong> the native construction at Magrusa,<br />
Jones et al 1983.<br />
78. Euzennat and Trousset 1975,66, have suggested that Tillibari and Talalati<br />
may correspond with Cillibaris and Alele, named by Pliny, V, 35.<br />
Louis 1975,42-45, mentions surviving traces from the oases settlement<br />
(which certainly outlived the <strong>Roman</strong> fort, Corippus II, 79-80).<br />
79. Ward Perkins and Goodchild 1949,1976,29 (Mizda); The pivotal<br />
position <strong>of</strong> the double oasis at Mizda between the zone <strong>of</strong> pre-desert<br />
agriculture and Phazania is suggestive <strong>of</strong> an early importance for the<br />
site. There are extensive traces <strong>of</strong> ancient ruins around the oases<br />
(Barth 1857,99-104) and the original focus <strong>of</strong> settlement probably<br />
lay beneath the western oasis. The important wells <strong>of</strong> Schegegeh mark<br />
the southern end <strong>of</strong> the transhumance corridor controlled by the Hadd<br />
Hajar clausura. The ancient wells and other traces <strong>of</strong> ancient settlement<br />
have apparently been obliterated by recent development, (personal<br />
observation).<br />
80. Brogan 1965b, 57-64; Rebuffat 1975c, 499-500.<br />
81. As has been the practice since antiquity in Nefzaoua, Fezzan and the<br />
North Sahara. Briggs 1960,3-12.