a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua
a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua a comparative study of a Roman frontier province. - Historia Antigua
-374- 2: 3/2: 4 13. Nachtigal 1974,41-44 (4 years drought in 1869); Tripolitania II, 1932, 10 (end of a7 year drought); Ward 1967,55 (5 year drought 1959-1964). 14. Despois 1964,9; Kanter 1967,97-98. 15. Moreau 1947,31-34, in April 1939,72 mm fell in a few hours at Kebili compared to only 20 mm in the entire agricultural year of 1944-45: For flash-floods see, Lyon 1821,61,322; Nachtigal 1974,44; Tripolitania II, 1932,10; Barker and Jones 1981,34 (notably floods of up to 2m in the wadi Beni Ulid); also Vita-Finzi, 1969,38-42; Louis 1975,183-89. 16. Jones and Barker 1980; Barker and Jones 1981,1982. The same technology is still employed in the Gebel, Despois 1935,97-120; Louis 1975,152- 64; 183-89 and there are ancient parallels from Syria, Palestine and Jordan, Evenari et al 1971,95-119; Mayerson 1962; Kennedy 1982. 17. Capot-Rey 1953,36-68. 18. Despois and Raynal 1967,422; Trousset 1974,14-15. 19. Kanter 1967,97; Trousset 1974,15. 20. RSGI 1937,105; Despois 1935,55; Despois and Raynal 1967,422, Polservice 1980, A-89. 21. Trousset 1974,15. 22. Taylor 1960,88-89. 23. Capot Rey 1953,36-37; for the milder effects of heat and fluid loss, see Blanchet 1899,149-50, who abandoned a field survey when the temperature had reached 52°C in the shade. 24. Richardson 1848, II, 443, described a heavy dewfall at Bu Njem. 25. Taylor 1960,89; Denham and Clapperton 1826,502, suffered from Christmas frosts - an experience shared by the Libyan Valleys team in 1980. 26. Pers. comm. M. Bugghar. Despois 1964,14, on snow in the Atlas. 27. Franchetti 1914,66-67; BMA 1947,9; Johnson 1973,14; also pers. experience (unpleasant! ) 28. De Mathuisieulx 1912,69. Such storms do not respect modern vehicles either, as I know from being stuck for several hours in a sand blizzard. 29. Briggs 1960,7.. 2: 4 FLORA AND FAUNA 1. Capot-Rey 1953,91, blamed the action of man for most of the evident diminution and degradation of vegetation and wildlife. For the successful re-establishment of an ancient environment see Evenari et al 1971. in a desert zone 2. Clarke 1960,52; Despois 1964,93-95; Kanter 1967,77-79; Trousset 1974,15-16. 3. Franchetti 1914,203-47; Despois 1935,77-91; Brehony 1960,60; BMA 1947,42,93. 4. Kanter 1967,80-83; Trousset 1974,15-16. 5. Sheik Kilani of Ghirza remembers a time when olive trees still survived in the wadi Ghirza. The export of charcoal from the pre-desert and Gebel was the major cottage industry in the early twentieth century, see Franchetti 1914,371 and fig 210 (a stack of olive wood at least 22 m long by 4m high) and fig 212 (charcoal makers near Garian) ; Johnson 1973,24-28, on Cyrenaican parallels. 6. Beechey and Beechey 1828,508. 7. Denham and Clapperton 1826, XVI, describing the wadi Mimoun. 8. Barth 1857,125-30; Kanter 1967,81-82. 9. Trousset 1974,15-16.
-375- 2: 4 10. Penrose et al, 1970; Polservice 1980, B-1. 11. Allan 1969,6" Bronson 1982, gives the current rate of usage at m 600,000,000 per year, with replenishment of only 140,000,000 m3 per year. Hydrologists predict the exhaustion of the supply and a massive saline intrusion within forty years. 12. De Mathuisieulx 1912,196-200; Franchi 1912. 13. The re-introduction of olives south of the Lesser Syrtes has proved successful despite initial doubts, Poncet 1963,284. 14. Despois 1935,97-120; Franchetti 1914,433-55; Taylor 1960,88-99; Louis 1975,158-75. See also Lyon 1821,30-31; Barth 1857,63-64, for figs, olives, vines, almonds, pomegranates, grain and saffron being cultivated in the region in the nineteenth century. 15. Despois 1935,121-25, described cereal cultivation as a lottery. Modern wheat yields (1974 and 1978) of between 327-344 Kg/ha (Polservice 1980) are well below figures for other Mediterranean countries published in 1938 in the international Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics 1922-38. Egypt headed the list (1710 kg/ha), whilst Tunisia (400 kg/ha) and Algeria (540 kg/ha) were the lowest along with Libya. 16. Franchetti 1914,374-415. 17. Despois 1935,109,116-19. 18. Despois 1935,109-111. 19. Bronson 1982, states that there is a 20% total crop failure rate in this kind of marginal cultivation. 20. Lyon 1821,35; Nachtigal 1974,42-43; Beechey and Beechey 1828,507, on the impact made by Beni Ulid on early explorers. Bronson 1982, urges modern research on the olive cultivar growing at Beni Ulid, which must be a particularly drought resistant species. 21. Bates 1914,9-12 (Augila oasis, 116,000 palms; Siwa, 163,000; Dakhla, 200,000); Moreau 1947,125 (the Nefzaoua oases contain over 700,000 trees); RSGI 1931,579 (Fezzan, 900,000). 22. Barth 1857,90; Lyon 1821,270-73; RSGS 1931; 579. 23. As note 22. Also Lyon 1821,72-73; Briggs 1960,8-14. The list includes turnips, beans, peas, carrots, onions, peppers, garlic, tomatoes, melons, olives, figs, apples, peaches, apricots, grapes, mint, tobacco, herbs. 24. BMA 1947,36; Holmboe 1933,27-29 mentions seeing jackals and hyenas close to the Syrtic coast. 25. Holmboe 1933,29, claimed to have spotted a leopard also. Capot-Rey 1953,91, referred to the extinction of ostriches in Tunisia (1790) and Algeria (1845) but Daumas 1850/1971, devoted a chapter of his book on the Saharan nomads to ostrich hunting (50-62). 26. Capot-Rey 1953,9; Bovill 1968,6-9; Kanter 1967,105. 27. Kanter 1967,104. Since 1960 the numbers of camels have decreased but those of other species have increased, Polservice 1980, B-27. 28. Moreau 1947,166. 29. Briggs 1960,17-33; Johnson 1969,7-10; 1973,40-47; Evenari et al 1971, 301-323. 30. Bronson 1982; Johnson 1973,41-43; see also Franchetti 1914,519-597, who includes phhtographs of the principal types of livestock. 31. Evenari et al 1971,308-9; Johnson 1973,44,59-66. 32. Barker 1981,131-45 and 1983,1-49, discusses different traditional pastoral systems in antiquity, without perhaps giving this fact due weight. cf. Strabo XVII, 3,19, on the importance of horse breeding in antiquity.
- Page 1 and 2: TRIP0LITANIA: a comparative study o
- Page 3 and 4: -367- FOOTNOTES Chapter 1: Introduc
- Page 5 and 6: -369- 1: 2 /1: 3 14. Benabou 1976,
- Page 7 and 8: -371- CHAPTER 2: GEOGRAPHY AND CLIM
- Page 9: -373- 2: 2/2: 3 45. Capot-Rey 1953,
- Page 13 and 14: -377- 2: 5/2: 6 34. On the lotus, s
- Page 15 and 16: -379- 2: 7 the basis of the mileage
- Page 17 and 18: -381- 2: 7 64. Goodchild 1954 b and
- Page 19 and 20: -383- 7 3: 1/3: 2 17. An example of
- Page 21 and 22: -385- 3: 2/3: 3 46. Frezouls 1957,6
- Page 23 and 24: -387- 3: 3 tribes which cumulativel
- Page 25 and 26: -389- 3: 3 75. There were at least
- Page 27 and 28: -391- 4: 1 21. Johnson 1969,1-3. 22
- Page 29 and 30: -393- 4: 2 13. Sallust, BJ, XCII, 1
- Page 31 and 32: -395- 4: 2 65. For Saniat Gebril, s
- Page 33 and 34: -397- 4: 3j4; 4 20. Camps 1960,279-
- Page 35 and 36: -399- 4: 5 12. See above note 7. Ma
- Page 37 and 38: I -401- CHAPTER 5 FRONTIER THEORY A
- Page 39 and 40: -403- 5: 1 36. A few examples from
- Page 41 and 42: -405- 5: 1 66. On Byzantine frontie
- Page 43 and 44: -407- 5: 2 15. Desanges 1957,5-43.
- Page 45 and 46: -409- 5: 2 intervention and when Ca
- Page 47 and 48: -411- 5: 3 12. The evidence has bee
- Page 49 and 50: -413- 5: 3 50. See note 49, above.
- Page 51 and 52: -415- 5: 4 43. Rebuffat 1981,213-22
- Page 53 and 54: -417- FOOTNOTES CHAPTER 6 TRIPODITA
- Page 55 and 56: -419- 6: 1 53. Romanelli 1939,110-1
- Page 57 and 58: -421- 6: 2 9. The case has been con
- Page 59 and 60: -423- 6: 2 /6: 3 presented each one
-374-<br />
2: 3/2: 4<br />
13. Nachtigal 1974,41-44 (4 years drought in 1869); Tripolitania II, 1932,<br />
10 (end <strong>of</strong> a7 year drought); Ward 1967,55 (5 year drought 1959-1964).<br />
14. Despois 1964,9; Kanter 1967,97-98.<br />
15. Moreau 1947,31-34, in April 1939,72 mm fell in a few hours at Kebili<br />
compared to only 20 mm in the entire agricultural year <strong>of</strong> 1944-45:<br />
For flash-floods see, Lyon 1821,61,322; Nachtigal 1974,44; Tripolitania<br />
II, 1932,10; Barker and Jones 1981,34 (notably floods <strong>of</strong> up to 2m<br />
in the wadi Beni Ulid); also Vita-Finzi, 1969,38-42; Louis 1975,183-89.<br />
16. Jones and Barker 1980; Barker and Jones 1981,1982. The same technology<br />
is still employed in the Gebel, Despois 1935,97-120; Louis 1975,152-<br />
64; 183-89 and there are ancient parallels from Syria, Palestine and<br />
Jordan, Evenari et al 1971,95-119; Mayerson 1962; Kennedy 1982.<br />
17. Capot-Rey 1953,36-68.<br />
18. Despois and Raynal 1967,422; Trousset 1974,14-15.<br />
19. Kanter 1967,97; Trousset 1974,15.<br />
20. RSGI 1937,105; Despois 1935,55; Despois and Raynal 1967,422,<br />
Polservice 1980, A-89.<br />
21. Trousset 1974,15.<br />
22. Taylor 1960,88-89.<br />
23. Capot Rey 1953,36-37; for the milder effects <strong>of</strong> heat and fluid loss,<br />
see Blanchet 1899,149-50, who abandoned a field survey when the<br />
temperature had reached 52°C in the shade.<br />
24. Richardson 1848, II, 443, described a heavy dewfall at Bu Njem.<br />
25. Taylor 1960,89; Denham and Clapperton 1826,502, suffered from<br />
Christmas frosts - an experience shared by the Libyan Valleys team in<br />
1980.<br />
26. Pers. comm. M. Bugghar. Despois 1964,14, on snow in the Atlas.<br />
27. Franchetti 1914,66-67; BMA 1947,9; Johnson 1973,14; also<br />
pers. experience (unpleasant! )<br />
28. De Mathuisieulx 1912,69. Such storms do not respect modern vehicles<br />
either, as I know from being stuck for several hours in a sand blizzard.<br />
29. Briggs 1960,7..<br />
2: 4 FLORA AND FAUNA<br />
1. Capot-Rey 1953,91, blamed the action <strong>of</strong> man for most <strong>of</strong> the evident<br />
diminution and degradation <strong>of</strong> vegetation and wildlife. For the<br />
successful re-establishment <strong>of</strong> an ancient environment<br />
see Evenari et al 1971.<br />
in a desert<br />
zone<br />
2. Clarke 1960,52; Despois 1964,93-95; Kanter 1967,77-79; Trousset<br />
1974,15-16.<br />
3. Franchetti 1914,203-47; Despois 1935,77-91; Brehony 1960,60;<br />
BMA 1947,42,93.<br />
4. Kanter 1967,80-83; Trousset 1974,15-16.<br />
5. Sheik Kilani <strong>of</strong> Ghirza remembers a time when olive trees still survived<br />
in the wadi Ghirza. The export <strong>of</strong> charcoal from the pre-desert and<br />
Gebel was the major cottage industry in the early twentieth century,<br />
see Franchetti 1914,371 and fig 210 (a stack <strong>of</strong> olive wood at least<br />
22 m long by 4m high) and fig 212 (charcoal makers near Garian) ;<br />
Johnson 1973,24-28,<br />
on Cyrenaican parallels.<br />
6. Beechey and Beechey 1828,508.<br />
7. Denham and Clapperton 1826, XVI, describing the wadi Mimoun.<br />
8. Barth 1857,125-30; Kanter 1967,81-82.<br />
9. Trousset 1974,15-16.