Selected Editorials - The Sikh Bulletin
Selected Editorials - The Sikh Bulletin
Selected Editorials - The Sikh Bulletin
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Sikh</strong> religious scripture is unique among world’s religious Granths in more ways than one. This is the only<br />
Granth that has the authentic, original, unadulterated writings of the authors. <strong>The</strong>y were recorded by the<br />
authors themselves. Not only that, in addition to the writings of six Gurus, it also includes the writings of<br />
Bhagats, both Hindu and Muslim, and Bhats in its 1430 pages, including Ragmala. It goes without saying<br />
that only those writings of Bhagats and Bhats are included that are compatible with the message of Guru<br />
Nanak. Ragmala is a controversial entry. Yet another controversy is about some banis attributed to<br />
Mardana by some scholars while others contend Mardana is not the author of those banis. Perhaps that<br />
explains the discrepancy in number of banis attributed to Bhagats in various sources.<br />
Substantial sums of money are being spent over this celebration but the celebration would be more<br />
meaningful if at the same time attempts are made to translate SGGS into other languages of the world,<br />
just as the Bible has been translated. This writer is familiar only with the English language and has<br />
examined at least four different translations of SGGS in this language. <strong>The</strong>y all fall short of conveying the<br />
real meaning of Gurbani. One reason could be that they are attempts by individuals and very literal. What<br />
is needed is a cooperative effort by several scholars expert in English and languages used in SGGS,<br />
expertise in grammar of SGGS, ability to translate poetry in one language into prose in another language<br />
and mastery at conveying the real ‘meaning’ of a word or phrase rather than ‘literal’ translation that<br />
makes ‘gur gur meetha deena’ mean ‘God gave me molasses’.<br />
Thanks to the efforts by S. Harcharan Singh, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief of <strong>Sikh</strong> Virsa in Calgary, this<br />
writer also got an opportunity to participate in one such seminar on 300 th anniversary celebrations. That<br />
paper and two papers from two other participants are included in this issue. In addition to his paper on the<br />
subject of SGGS, S. Gurcharan Singh Brar’s article ‘Awpxw Awpxw ipMf sMBwlo’ deserves a special<br />
mention. Of all the people who got involved with the Singh Sabha International movement that began at<br />
Roseville, California, he is the only person who, with the help of a few dedicated associates, has carried<br />
on the torch to spread the message of Guru Nanak. In cooperation with the Missionary College in<br />
Ludhiana that supplies qualified missionaries, his group, Singh Sabha International Canada, matches the<br />
missionaries with those generous <strong>Sikh</strong>s in Diaspora who wish to fund the cost for the benefit of their<br />
villages. We urge you to support this effort financially.<br />
Hardev Singh Shergill<br />
*****<br />
EDITORIAL<br />
NANKIAN PHILOSOPHY<br />
[Editorial from January-February 2009 <strong>Sikh</strong> <strong>Bulletin</strong>]<br />
“Guru Nanak (1469-1539 CE) originated a unique philosophy and challenged the existing concepts<br />
about God, heaven/hell, reincarnation/transmigration, idol worship, caste system, astrology,<br />
mantra systems, etc. in Southeast Asia.” Amen! Halleluiah! This quote came to me from a <strong>Sikh</strong> scholar<br />
who is doing a great service to the cause of <strong>Sikh</strong>i and I could not help but compliment him and told him<br />
that I agreed with his quote whole heartedly.<br />
To that I added, that Guru Nanak was not a prophet in the sense of Biblical or Muslim prophets who<br />
claimed to speak to or spoken to by God, directly as in the case of Moses or indirectly, as in the case of<br />
Mohammed who had an Angel as an intermediary. When Bani talks about 'dhur-ki-bani' it is not God<br />
talking to Nanak; <strong>Sikh</strong>i is not a 'revealed' religion; it is born out of Guru’s life experience; it is Guru's<br />
own inspiration and thought process that inspires him to seek and speak fundamental truths. He wrote<br />
back that he was pleased to read my response but observed, “No <strong>Sikh</strong> scholar could dare to say what<br />
you have said.” He is right and therein lies the tragedy. I am not afraid to say it precisely because I am<br />
not a scholar. <strong>The</strong> tragedy is that <strong>Sikh</strong> scholars are too fearful of consequences if they break with the<br />
47