Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com

Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com

28.01.2015 Views

EPRI Proprietary Licensed Material Table 2 VRB Technology Status Technology/Company Status Funding Organization Sumitomo Early Publicly traded commercial company Vantech Pre-commercial Publicly traded company Major Demonstrations Lessons Learned Development Trends/Plans Sumitomo Densetsu, 100 kW / 8h (Feb 2000) Institute of Applied Energy, 170kW / 6h (Mar 2001) Tottori SANYO Electric, 1500kW / 1h (Apr 2001) Obayashi Corp., 30kW / 8h (Apr 2001) Kwansei Gakuin Univ., 500kW / 10h (Jul 200l) CESI, 42kW / 2h (Nov 2001) Univ. of Stellenbosch, 250 kW / 2 h (Aug 2001) PacifiCorp, 250 kW / 8 h (Planned 2002) Construction and utility interconnection experience Experience with multiple applications (wind, PV, peak shaving, power quality) Developed capabilities to scale up to large power levels Market expansion worldwide Larger, scaled up systems Standardized product lines Issues Systems not safety or performance certified (e.g., UL listing) Long term cycling experience lacking Large footprint Little ongoing maintenance experience Cellenium Developmental Private funding in Thailand King Island, 200 kW / 4 h (Planned 2003) Three units, each 1 kW (Planned 2002) Proven series flow concept Vanadium sulfate fuel cell IP rights uncertain “Inductionless” power conversion technology Funding for commercial development Vanadium Redox Battery 20

EPRI Proprietary Licensed Material 3. Applications 3.1. Applications Overview. Due to its relative mechanical complexity and economies of scale, the VRB is most suited for utility-scale power systems in the 100 kW – 100 MW size range in applications having low power/energy ratios (long discharge durations). The principle T&D applications with these characteristics include: • DR/Peak Shaving • Spinning Reserve • Windfarm Stabilization & Dispatch It is generally accepted that the viability of electricity storage is dependent upon cases in which multiple operating modes – and multiple economic benefits – can be exploited. For example, peak shaving economics is driven primarily by the benefit of local T&D peaking capacity that the storage system provides. However, dispatch during peak times also reduces the import power requirements from the generation sources, thereby reducing generation costs. In this example, the economic benefits of the two applications are combined. While the VRB (and other storage technologies) can be used in a wide variety of applications, it is not always possible to combine them. For example, energy storage allocated for spinning reserve could not be “spent” for energy arbitrage since, in a depleted state, energy would not available if called upon for reserve 2 . Table 3 presents an overall summary of the applications requirements. The remainder of this section covers the applications in additional detail. 2 On the other hand, energy dispatched by the system operator for reserve power may result in incidental “arbitrage” benefits, depending upon the conditions of the performance contract and the market rules. This benefit would be small since the timing of the dispatch would not necessarily occur during optimal arbitrage conditions. It is worth noting that available energy capacity could be operationally “partitioned” to separately serve spinning reserve and arbitrage functions. Vanadium Redox Battery 21

EPRI Proprietary Licensed Material<br />

3. Applications<br />

3.1. Applications Overview.<br />

Due to its relative mechanical <strong>com</strong>plexity and economies <strong>of</strong> scale, the VRB is most<br />

suited <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> utility-scale power systems in the 100 kW – 100 MW size range in applications<br />

having low power/energy ratios (long discharge durations). The principle T&D<br />

applications with these characteristics include:<br />

• DR/Peak Shaving<br />

• Spinning Reserve<br />

• Windfarm Stabilization & Dispatch<br />

It is generally accepted that the viability <strong>of</strong> electricity st<strong>or</strong>age is dependent upon cases in<br />

which multiple operating modes – and multiple economic benefits – can be exploited.<br />

F<strong>or</strong> example, peak shaving economics is driven primarily by the benefit <strong>of</strong> local T&D<br />

peaking capacity that the st<strong>or</strong>age system provides. However, dispatch during peak times<br />

also reduces the imp<strong>or</strong>t power requirements from the generation sources, thereby<br />

reducing generation costs. In this example, the economic benefits <strong>of</strong> the two applications<br />

are <strong>com</strong>bined.<br />

While the VRB (and other st<strong>or</strong>age technologies) can be used in a wide variety <strong>of</strong><br />

applications, it is not always possible to <strong>com</strong>bine them. F<strong>or</strong> example, energy st<strong>or</strong>age<br />

allocated <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> spinning reserve could not be “spent” <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> energy arbitrage since, in a<br />

depleted state, energy would not available if called upon <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> reserve 2 .<br />

Table 3 presents an overall summary <strong>of</strong> the applications requirements. The remainder <strong>of</strong><br />

this section covers the applications in additional detail.<br />

2 On the other hand, energy dispatched by the system operat<strong>or</strong> <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> reserve power may result in incidental<br />

“arbitrage” benefits, depending upon the conditions <strong>of</strong> the per<strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong>mance contract and the market rules. This<br />

benefit would be small since the timing <strong>of</strong> the dispatch would not necessarily occur during optimal<br />

arbitrage conditions. It is w<strong>or</strong>th noting that available energy capacity could be operationally “partitioned”<br />

to separately serve spinning reserve and arbitrage functions.<br />

Vanadium Redox Battery 21

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!