28.01.2015 Views

Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com

Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com

Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

EPRI Proprietary Licensed Material<br />

resist<strong>or</strong> string establishes the individual cell voltages. A disadvantage <strong>of</strong> this passive<br />

approach is high self-discharge rate, since the string <strong>of</strong> resist<strong>or</strong>s will discharge the<br />

capacit<strong>or</strong>. A related approach to provide cell balance but without the self-discharge<br />

problem is to use a parallel string <strong>of</strong> Zener diodes. Such devices appear as open circuit<br />

below a specified voltage, and a sh<strong>or</strong>t circuit above that voltage. These methods add cost<br />

and <strong>com</strong>plexity to the system.<br />

There are also active approaches <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> balancing cell voltages where each cell is monit<strong>or</strong>ed.<br />

This in<strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong>mation can be used to rep<strong>or</strong>t over-voltage problems that may occur in series<br />

strings, <strong>or</strong> it may be used to actually control the voltage on each cell by charging <strong>or</strong><br />

discharging individual cells in the string. Active balancing has been used with batteries<br />

and some electrochemical capacit<strong>or</strong>s in the past. It is <strong>of</strong>ten used at the cell level, but<br />

sometimes this balancing is only needed between modules in a multi module system.<br />

Note that balancing is n<strong>or</strong>mally at a low level, that is a few hundred milliamps during<br />

float conditions. If dynamic cell balancing is needed <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> a particular application a much<br />

higher rated leveling circuit will be required <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> the higher currents. This may add<br />

substantial cost to the system. Nevertheless, such an approach can be effective <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> raising<br />

the voltage <strong>of</strong> capacit<strong>or</strong>s in a string to an average value that is closer to the maximum<br />

possible value, increasing energy density and perhaps <strong>of</strong>fsetting the additional cost.<br />

Temperature Variations in a Series String<br />

Even with highly uni<strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong>m cells there are still potential problems when cells are connected<br />

in series that have temperature non-uni<strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong>mities. If a large module is warmer at the<br />

center due to cycling <strong>or</strong> warmer at the perimeter because <strong>of</strong> environmental fact<strong>or</strong>s, a<br />

temperature gradient will exist and could create cell voltage imbalance. This situation is<br />

true <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> all electrochemical capacit<strong>or</strong> designs. The solution to this problem is to engineer<br />

the system so that every cell within the system is held to within some specified<br />

temperature tolerance. Without this consideration, cells that are from a the<strong>or</strong>etically<br />

perfect manufacturing line (no variability) still may have cell voltage balance problems<br />

when operated within a series string.<br />

Power Electronics Requirements<br />

A unique characteristic <strong>of</strong> a capacitive energy st<strong>or</strong>age system is that the state <strong>of</strong> charge <strong>of</strong><br />

the system is always known–it is determined by the voltage. This is very different from<br />

most battery st<strong>or</strong>age systems. It is usual to exploit this feature when charging and<br />

discharging a capacit<strong>or</strong>.<br />

The sloping discharge <strong>of</strong> a capacit<strong>or</strong>, however, does present problems in applications that<br />

demand a constant voltage. In this case, power electronics are needed to boost the<br />

voltage <strong>of</strong> the discharging capacit<strong>or</strong> to a higher, constant value. Generally, a capacit<strong>or</strong><br />

st<strong>or</strong>age system will have very large capacitance, small inductance, and small resistance.<br />

Thus, it can act as its own filter during charge. The single limitation is that self-heating<br />

from its charging source must not create over-temperature conditions in the cells. Heat<br />

dissipation depends on the value <strong>of</strong> the ripple current, the value <strong>of</strong> the charging current,<br />

and the cell equivalent series resistance. Thus, low-cost charging sources can be<br />

employed, ones that are typically unsuited <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> battery charging.<br />

A practical difference between the power source used <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> charging a capacit<strong>or</strong> and that<br />

used <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> charging a battery is the power level. Charging can be much faster <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> a<br />

Electrochemical Capacit<strong>or</strong>s 19

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!