Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com
Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com
Handbook of Energy Storage for Transmission or ... - W2agz.com
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
EPRI Proprietary Licensed Material<br />
resist<strong>or</strong> string establishes the individual cell voltages. A disadvantage <strong>of</strong> this passive<br />
approach is high self-discharge rate, since the string <strong>of</strong> resist<strong>or</strong>s will discharge the<br />
capacit<strong>or</strong>. A related approach to provide cell balance but without the self-discharge<br />
problem is to use a parallel string <strong>of</strong> Zener diodes. Such devices appear as open circuit<br />
below a specified voltage, and a sh<strong>or</strong>t circuit above that voltage. These methods add cost<br />
and <strong>com</strong>plexity to the system.<br />
There are also active approaches <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> balancing cell voltages where each cell is monit<strong>or</strong>ed.<br />
This in<strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong>mation can be used to rep<strong>or</strong>t over-voltage problems that may occur in series<br />
strings, <strong>or</strong> it may be used to actually control the voltage on each cell by charging <strong>or</strong><br />
discharging individual cells in the string. Active balancing has been used with batteries<br />
and some electrochemical capacit<strong>or</strong>s in the past. It is <strong>of</strong>ten used at the cell level, but<br />
sometimes this balancing is only needed between modules in a multi module system.<br />
Note that balancing is n<strong>or</strong>mally at a low level, that is a few hundred milliamps during<br />
float conditions. If dynamic cell balancing is needed <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> a particular application a much<br />
higher rated leveling circuit will be required <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> the higher currents. This may add<br />
substantial cost to the system. Nevertheless, such an approach can be effective <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> raising<br />
the voltage <strong>of</strong> capacit<strong>or</strong>s in a string to an average value that is closer to the maximum<br />
possible value, increasing energy density and perhaps <strong>of</strong>fsetting the additional cost.<br />
Temperature Variations in a Series String<br />
Even with highly uni<strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong>m cells there are still potential problems when cells are connected<br />
in series that have temperature non-uni<strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong>mities. If a large module is warmer at the<br />
center due to cycling <strong>or</strong> warmer at the perimeter because <strong>of</strong> environmental fact<strong>or</strong>s, a<br />
temperature gradient will exist and could create cell voltage imbalance. This situation is<br />
true <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> all electrochemical capacit<strong>or</strong> designs. The solution to this problem is to engineer<br />
the system so that every cell within the system is held to within some specified<br />
temperature tolerance. Without this consideration, cells that are from a the<strong>or</strong>etically<br />
perfect manufacturing line (no variability) still may have cell voltage balance problems<br />
when operated within a series string.<br />
Power Electronics Requirements<br />
A unique characteristic <strong>of</strong> a capacitive energy st<strong>or</strong>age system is that the state <strong>of</strong> charge <strong>of</strong><br />
the system is always known–it is determined by the voltage. This is very different from<br />
most battery st<strong>or</strong>age systems. It is usual to exploit this feature when charging and<br />
discharging a capacit<strong>or</strong>.<br />
The sloping discharge <strong>of</strong> a capacit<strong>or</strong>, however, does present problems in applications that<br />
demand a constant voltage. In this case, power electronics are needed to boost the<br />
voltage <strong>of</strong> the discharging capacit<strong>or</strong> to a higher, constant value. Generally, a capacit<strong>or</strong><br />
st<strong>or</strong>age system will have very large capacitance, small inductance, and small resistance.<br />
Thus, it can act as its own filter during charge. The single limitation is that self-heating<br />
from its charging source must not create over-temperature conditions in the cells. Heat<br />
dissipation depends on the value <strong>of</strong> the ripple current, the value <strong>of</strong> the charging current,<br />
and the cell equivalent series resistance. Thus, low-cost charging sources can be<br />
employed, ones that are typically unsuited <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> battery charging.<br />
A practical difference between the power source used <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> charging a capacit<strong>or</strong> and that<br />
used <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> charging a battery is the power level. Charging can be much faster <strong>f<strong>or</strong></strong> a<br />
Electrochemical Capacit<strong>or</strong>s 19