Federal Court - Christian Aboriginal Infrastructure Developments ...

Federal Court - Christian Aboriginal Infrastructure Developments ... Federal Court - Christian Aboriginal Infrastructure Developments ...

22.01.2015 Views

Page: 38 Fillmore also gave evidence about his meetings with representatives of LPL and SYFC, and exchanges of correspondence, often by email, with them. Some of the communications related to acquiring a THA. He understood that the Plaintiffs were looking for a volume of 200,000 m 3 per year. Further, he understood that this figure was constant and did not change. [152] Mr. Fillmore believed that in order for the Plaintiffs to get a THA, they would have to first 2010 FC 495 (CanLII) prove themselves with demonstrated ability to process timber in the mill. In fact, Mr. Fillmore testified that the Plaintiffs had to demonstrate capacity before they would even be entitled to a 15,000 m 3 CTP. [153] Mr. Fillmore was involved with others in the Department in dealing with requests from the Plaintiffs and others for the delivery of timely information about access to wood. [154] In the course of his work with the Department, Mr. Fillmore was responsible for preparing “Backgrounder” or “Background” documents to be used both for internal information and for the media. He either reviewed the documents as prepared by someone else or he prepared them himself, but in any event, he was the person who approved the text. [155] Mr. Fillmore had a poor memory about some matters including the available volume of timber in the relevant forest management units (“FMU”), that is Y02 and Y03. Additionally, he did not remember what he said to SYFC with respect to what DIAND would expect in order to acquire a THA, the participation of KFR in the joint venture and other relevant matters.

Page: 39 [156] Mr. Fillmore also gave testimony about the regulatory framework for timber licensing, and the concerns of his staff with respect to the conduct of other DIAND employees. [157] Mr. Jeff Monty was the next witness called on behalf of the Defendant. He holds the degree of bachelor of science in forestry and a certificate of public administration. He was employed by 2010 FC 495 (CanLII) DIAND from 1995 to 2001, working from Whitehorse, as the Regional Manager of Forest Resources. His responsibilities included building the forest program. He focused on the concepts of forest renewal, protection, inventory and planning. [158] In the mid to late 1990s, devolution of control of the forest resources from the Federal Government to the YTG was pending. Mr. Monty believed it to be prudent to work collaboratively with the Yukon Government in the area of forest management and planning. A Yukon forest strategy had been developed by the Yukon Forest Commission and Mr. Monty was directed to work with it. [159] While in the Yukon region, Mr. Monty was seconded to the YTG from April 1998 until June, July 1998, working with the Deputy Minister of Natural Resources. His job was to advise on the development of a forest policy prior to devolution.

Page: 38<br />

Fillmore also gave evidence about his meetings with representatives of LPL and SYFC, and<br />

exchanges of correspondence, often by email, with them. Some of the communications related to<br />

acquiring a THA. He understood that the Plaintiffs were looking for a volume of 200,000 m 3 per<br />

year. Further, he understood that this figure was constant and did not change.<br />

[152] Mr. Fillmore believed that in order for the Plaintiffs to get a THA, they would have to first<br />

2010 FC 495 (CanLII)<br />

prove themselves with demonstrated ability to process timber in the mill. In fact, Mr. Fillmore<br />

testified that the Plaintiffs had to demonstrate capacity before they would even be entitled to a<br />

15,000 m 3 CTP.<br />

[153] Mr. Fillmore was involved with others in the Department in dealing with requests from the<br />

Plaintiffs and others for the delivery of timely information about access to wood.<br />

[154] In the course of his work with the Department, Mr. Fillmore was responsible for preparing<br />

“Backgrounder” or “Background” documents to be used both for internal information and for the<br />

media. He either reviewed the documents as prepared by someone else or he prepared them himself,<br />

but in any event, he was the person who approved the text.<br />

[155] Mr. Fillmore had a poor memory about some matters including the available volume of<br />

timber in the relevant forest management units (“FMU”), that is Y02 and Y03. Additionally, he did<br />

not remember what he said to SYFC with respect to what DIAND would expect in order to acquire<br />

a THA, the participation of KFR in the joint venture and other relevant matters.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!