21.01.2015 Views

comparative test: watches with unitas pocket watch caliber

comparative test: watches with unitas pocket watch caliber

comparative test: watches with unitas pocket watch caliber

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

COMPARATIVE TEST: WATCHES WITH UNITAS POCKET WATCH CALIBER<br />

62 WatchTime February 2002


Pocket to Wrist<br />

Sturdy and reliable, the<br />

Unitas <strong>pocket</strong> <strong>watch</strong> <strong>caliber</strong><br />

has become an increasingly<br />

popular choice for hand-wound<br />

wrist<strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong>. WatchTime’s<br />

RÜDIGER BUCHER <strong>test</strong>ed<br />

three models powered<br />

by this the movement.<br />

February 2002 WatchTime 63


COMPARATIVE TEST: WATCHES WITH UNITAS POCKET WATCH CALIBER<br />

Above: On the movement<br />

side of the Chronoswiss<br />

<strong>caliber</strong> C 672, you<br />

can easily see the large,<br />

brass-colored transfer<br />

wheel. This wheel engages<br />

<strong>with</strong> the pinion of<br />

the center arbor, which is<br />

located beneath the additional<br />

bridge.<br />

When a <strong>watch</strong>maker wants to show a layman how a mechanical<br />

movement functions, he often pulls out a Unitas <strong>pocket</strong><br />

<strong>watch</strong> <strong>caliber</strong> 6497 to serve as the classic example. This <strong>caliber</strong><br />

has all of the essential rudimentary components, <strong>with</strong> no complications<br />

or a rotor, or even a date disk to obscure your view. The flow of energy<br />

from the barrel through the center-wheel, third-wheel, fourthwheel,<br />

escape-wheel, and all the accompanying intermediate gears, is<br />

readily visible here in what you might call its "primordial" form. Even an<br />

unpracticed eye finds it relatively easy to comprehend the workings of<br />

the device. In recent years, ever since large-format wrist<strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong> have<br />

once again become popular, the <strong>caliber</strong> 6497 or 6498 which was originally<br />

conceived for <strong>pocket</strong> <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong> has been cropping up inside an<br />

ever-greater number of wrist<strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong>.<br />

Anyone who owns a <strong>watch</strong> <strong>with</strong> a glass back can readily observe<br />

what happens when the <strong>watch</strong> is wound: the crown-wheel turns, propelling<br />

the large toothed wheel affixed to the barrel (known as either<br />

the "winding-wheel" or the "ratchet-wheel") <strong>with</strong> which the crownwheel<br />

meshes; at the same time, the little nosepiece of the click prevents<br />

the winding-wheel from slipping<br />

When a <strong>watch</strong>maker backwards. After these wheels have<br />

turned through a few rotations, the<br />

wants to show a layman<br />

balance begins to move. It soon finds<br />

how a mechanical movement<br />

works, he<br />

pace of five beats per second – a speed<br />

its rhythm and settles into a steady oscillation,<br />

rocking back and forth at a<br />

that is typical of this <strong>watch</strong>-movement,<br />

but rather leisurely compared to<br />

often pulls out a<br />

hand-wound Unitas <strong>pocket</strong><br />

<strong>watch</strong> <strong>caliber</strong>.<br />

the speeds of balances in other movements.<br />

If you look very carefully beneath<br />

the balance’s rim, you can even<br />

find part of the lever, whose little feet<br />

– technically known as "pallets" – tirelessly catch and release the teeth<br />

of the escape-wheel so that the entire clockwork advances at the correct<br />

speed and the fourth-wheel requires exactly one minute to rotate<br />

once around its own axis.<br />

With a diameter of 36 millimeters, the Unitas <strong>caliber</strong> is larger than<br />

many finished <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong>. Its generous dimensions have predestined it for<br />

Left: The Chronoswiss<br />

<strong>watch</strong>, its<br />

two wristbands<br />

and a little container<br />

full of spare<br />

parts are all delivered<br />

inside a spiffy<br />

presentation case<br />

An extra-large<br />

crown protrudes<br />

far from the case<br />

and contributes<br />

to the distinctive<br />

look of the<br />

Timemaster.<br />

64 WatchTime February 2002


service inside big, bold <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong> that emphasize good legibility and<br />

clear-cut designs. Furthermore, the <strong>caliber</strong>’s large size contributes to<br />

the stability of its rate.<br />

Gerd-Rüdiger Lang of Chronoswiss chose this movement for his new<br />

Timemaster, a giant <strong>watch</strong> (44 millimeters) <strong>with</strong> a correspondingly giant<br />

crown that immediately commands attention. As is typical of Lang’s creations,<br />

the Timemaster is less a <strong>watch</strong> than a work of art, one based<br />

DATA PAGE<br />

CHRONOSWISS TIMEMASTER<br />

Manufacturer: Chronoswiss Uhren GmbH,<br />

Elly-Staegmayr-Strasse 12, D-80999<br />

Munich<br />

Model: Timemaster<br />

Reference number: CH 6233<br />

Functions: Hours, minutes, central "sweep"<br />

seconds hand.<br />

Movement: Hand-wound Chronoswiss <strong>caliber</strong><br />

C. 672 (base <strong>caliber</strong> Unitas 6497-1); diameter<br />

= 36.6 mm; height = 5.4 mm; 18 jewels;<br />

18,000 beats per hour; Glucydur beryllium<br />

screw balance; self-compensating Nivarox 1<br />

balance-spring; Incabloc shock absorption;<br />

swan’s neck fine regulation; 50-hour power<br />

reserve (approx. 2 days, as indicated by the<br />

circled numeral "2" on the dial); plate <strong>with</strong><br />

circular graining on both sides; bridges <strong>with</strong><br />

Geneva Waves; stop-seconds function; each<br />

movement is individually numbered.<br />

Case: massive, 22-part, brushed and polished<br />

stainless steel case; fluted bezel rotates <strong>with</strong>out<br />

intervening notches in two directions and is<br />

marked <strong>with</strong> a Superluminova triangle; brushed<br />

case edge; screwed tube for the extra-large,<br />

onion-shaped crown; screwed strap lugs;<br />

patented Autobloc system; matte-black metal<br />

dial; luminous Superluminova C3 material on<br />

the hour-hand, minute-hand, numerals and indices;<br />

antireflective sapphire crystal; fully threaded<br />

screw-in back <strong>with</strong> antireflective viewing<br />

window; water-resistant to 10 atmospheres<br />

(100 meters).<br />

Wristband and clasp: Black crocodile-skin<br />

wristband; rapidly opening and closing clasp;<br />

wristband’s ends are reinforced <strong>with</strong> inner<br />

metal clips; pronged buckle; extra-long<br />

cowhide strap delivered along <strong>with</strong> the <strong>watch</strong>.<br />

Results of running <strong>test</strong> (deviations in<br />

seconds 24 hours):<br />

With/<strong>with</strong>out switched on chronograph function<br />

Dial up: +4<br />

Dial down: +4<br />

Crown up: +3<br />

Crown down: –2<br />

Crown left: +5<br />

Grea<strong>test</strong> deviation of rate: 7<br />

Average deviation: 3<br />

Average amplitude of the balance: 340°<br />

Dimensions: Diameter = 44 mm;<br />

height = 12.3 mm; weight = 101 grams<br />

(130 grams <strong>with</strong> professional wristband).<br />

Variants: Also available <strong>with</strong> luminous dial and<br />

black hands.<br />

Price: $3,750<br />

upon a logical and comprehensive concept.<br />

Conceived as an "outdoor" <strong>watch</strong>, it’s equipped<br />

<strong>with</strong> an extra-long cowhide strap of the sort<br />

found on old-fashioned deck-<strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong>, so that<br />

the wearer can strap the <strong>watch</strong> to the outside of<br />

his jacket’s sleeve. People who prefer a more<br />

civilian look can easily remove the big cowhide<br />

strap and replace it <strong>with</strong> a very well crafted black<br />

crocodile-skin wristband. The <strong>watch</strong> and both<br />

straps are delivered inside a gorgeous box escorted<br />

by a little canister that’s filled <strong>with</strong> vital<br />

components: three insulators for the crown’s<br />

pipe and another one for the case back, as well<br />

as a second winding-stem and a spare balancestaff,<br />

just in case a nasty blow should happen to<br />

break the original ones. There’s also an extra<br />

mainspring, which is nice to have around if your<br />

clumsy gloved fingers should accidentally overwind<br />

the original mainspring until it snaps (not<br />

likely). Whether or not the typical Timemaster<br />

owner would dare to subject his <strong>watch</strong> to such<br />

extreme conditions is debatable, but the fact remains<br />

that so much practical attention to detail<br />

is a source of pleasure. Lang has thought of absolutely<br />

everything. For example, the straps are<br />

equipped <strong>with</strong> elaborately crafted quick-switch<br />

clasps that make it child’s play to change the<br />

wristbands. All you need to do is exert a bit of<br />

pressure and snap them into the lugs. This very<br />

convenient solution comes at a price, however:<br />

the ends of the strap, which are reinforced <strong>with</strong><br />

metal clips, have a fairly large amount of play.<br />

Now and then they tend to get jammed. And<br />

frequent interchanging subjects them to a lot of<br />

wear and tear, which threaten to decrease the<br />

longevity of these excellently crafted wristbands.<br />

Although the crown is large and protrudes<br />

uncommonly far from the edge of the case, you<br />

shouldn’t fear for its safety. Its pipe is firmly<br />

screwed to the case, which gives it plenty of<br />

strength. If it should accidentally break, it can<br />

readily be replaced. Furthermore, three O-ring<br />

insulators are fitted directly onto the pipe: this<br />

not only improves the <strong>watch</strong>’s resistance to penetration<br />

by water or dust, but also mean that the hands move especially<br />

smoothly when the crown is turned to adjust their positions – a very<br />

pleasant experience indeed!<br />

It was only logical to opt for the <strong>caliber</strong> 6497 as the motor for such a<br />

large and nostalgic wrist<strong>watch</strong> <strong>with</strong> such a prominent crown. Lang refined<br />

the original <strong>caliber</strong> by adding a swan’s neck fine regulation mechanism<br />

and decorated the <strong>caliber</strong>’s surfaces <strong>with</strong> various ornamental engravings.<br />

But that’s not all: he also made some<br />

interesting structural modifications. Because he<br />

wanted his Timemaster to offer the best possible<br />

legibility, Lang wasn’t interested in the small<br />

seconds subdial that this Unitas <strong>caliber</strong> typically<br />

supports. A cleverly constructed "detour"<br />

For everyday, indoor<br />

use: crocodile-skin<br />

wristband <strong>with</strong><br />

pronged buckle and<br />

the Chronoswiss<br />

logo (above).<br />

February 2002 WatchTime 65


COMPARATIVE TEST: WATCHES WITH UNITAS POCKET WATCH CALIBER<br />

mechanism transforms the small seconds subdial into a central<br />

"sweep" seconds-hand. To accomplish this modification, the <strong>caliber</strong> is<br />

equipped <strong>with</strong> an additional transfer wheel between the fourth-wheel<br />

and the pinion of the center-wheel. Propelled by the pinion of the thirdwheel,<br />

the transfer wheel rotates once every 7 1/2 minutes. It meshes<br />

<strong>with</strong> the pinion on the fourth-wheel’s staff, to which the seconds-hand<br />

is affixed. The other end of this staff is seated in an additional bridge; its<br />

pivot rotates in an 18th jewel (the unmodified 6497 has only 17 jewels).<br />

To ensure that the seconds-hand runs smoothly and <strong>with</strong>out flapping, a<br />

friction spring, which presses the transfer wheel upwards, is installed<br />

DATA PAGE<br />

MAURICE LACROIX MASTERPIECE<br />

Manufacturer: Maurice Lacroix,<br />

Brandschenkestraße 2, CH-8039 Zurich<br />

Model: Masterpiece Jour & Nuit<br />

Reference number: 07769-1602<br />

Functions: Hours, minutes, small seconds; day<br />

and night display.<br />

Movement: Hand-wound ML <strong>caliber</strong> 07, base<br />

<strong>caliber</strong> Unitas 6498-2; diameter = 36.6 mm;<br />

height = 5.6 mm; 17 jewels; 18,000 beats per<br />

hour; Glucydur screw balance; Nivarox 1<br />

balance-spring; Nivaflex 1 mainspring; Incabloc<br />

shock absorption; fine regulation; handdecorated<br />

<strong>with</strong> concentrically circular<br />

engraving, sun pattern and blued screws;<br />

no stop-seconds function.<br />

Case: Stainless steel and 18-karat yellow gold;<br />

sapphire crystal above dial; sapphire case back;<br />

sterling silver dial; blued hands; water-resistant<br />

to 3 atmospheres (30 meters).<br />

Wristband and clasp: Hand-sewn crocodileskin<br />

wristband <strong>with</strong> pronged buckle.<br />

Results of running <strong>test</strong> (deviations in<br />

seconds 24 hours):<br />

With/<strong>with</strong>out switched on chronograph function<br />

Dial up: 0<br />

Dial down: +4<br />

Crown up: +2<br />

Crown down: –3<br />

Crown left: +5<br />

Grea<strong>test</strong> deviation of rate: 8<br />

Average deviation: 2<br />

Average amplitude of the balance: 330°<br />

Dimensions: Diameter = 43 mm;<br />

height = 9 mm; weight = 73 grams<br />

Price: $2,950<br />

Maurice Lacroix<br />

uses the Caliber<br />

6498, which is built<br />

in a hunter-style<br />

construction.<br />

Very well crafted: the handsewn,<br />

crocodile-skin wristband<br />

and the clasp <strong>with</strong> the<br />

ML logo.<br />

By opting not to include a threaded,<br />

screw-in case back, Maurice Lacroix<br />

achieved a strikingly slender height<br />

for the Jour & Nuit.<br />

66 WatchTime February 2002


COMPARATIVE TEST: WATCHES WITH UNITAS POCKET WATCH CALIBER<br />

beneath the bridge. Unlike the movements in the other models that<br />

we’ll discuss later in this article, this Chronoswiss <strong>caliber</strong> is the only one<br />

<strong>with</strong> a stop-seconds function. This useful feature makes it easier to precisely<br />

set the <strong>watch</strong>. It can also be used to stop intervals of time to the<br />

second. The mechanism that supports the central seconds-hand is very<br />

sweet indeed, but there’s a drop of vinegar in the honey: the hand itself<br />

is not coated <strong>with</strong> luminous material. The hours and minutes are readily<br />

legible in the dark, but the owner will have to forego the pleasure of<br />

measuring nighttime intervals <strong>with</strong> to-the-second accuracy. Lang explains<br />

that he opted not to equip the seconds-hand <strong>with</strong> luminous material<br />

because the hand itself is so slender and because glow-in-thedark<br />

coating would have made the seconds-hand so heavy that it<br />

would no longer have run smoothly. For people who insist upon 100%<br />

legibility at all times, a version of the Timemaster is available <strong>with</strong> the<br />

dial completely coated <strong>with</strong> Superluminova, similar to <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong> used by<br />

submarine crews. The black hands, numerals and indices contrast clearly<br />

against the brightly luminous background.<br />

At Maurice Lacroix too, the <strong>watch</strong>makers weren’t content to use<br />

the standard Unitas <strong>caliber</strong> <strong>with</strong>out making a few changes of their<br />

own. The 6498 is built in so-called "savonnette" or "hunter" style,<br />

which means that the seconds stand at right angles to the crown. The<br />

people at Maurice Lacroix have modified the 6498 so that the hourwheel<br />

rotates only half as fast as it ordinarily does. Because it has twice<br />

as many teeth, it requires 24 hours to rotate once around its own axis.<br />

The result is a <strong>watch</strong> <strong>with</strong> an aesthetically successful 24-hour display.<br />

It takes some time to get used to it, but once you’ve grown accustomed<br />

to its face, you’ll be able to read it easily and instantly. The<br />

hour-hand extends in two directions from its central axis. One end<br />

bears a tiny sun, the other carries a little moon for the nighttime hours.<br />

The semi-circular hours scale spans the upper half of the solid silver<br />

dial and runs from 6 to 6. For example, when the sun-tipped end of<br />

the hand points to the 8, it’s eight o’-<br />

clock in the morning; if the moontipped<br />

end is above the 3, it’s three<br />

The dimensions of the<br />

Unitas (36 mm) have predestined<br />

it for service in-<br />

o’clock in the morning. At six p.m.,<br />

when the sun is leaving the 6 on the<br />

right-hand end calibrated scale, the<br />

side big, bold <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong><br />

moon is simultaneously arriving at the<br />

6 on the left-hand side.<br />

that emphasize legibility<br />

The design of the Masterpiece Jour<br />

and clear-cut designs.<br />

& Nuit (French for "day & night") differs<br />

radically from the design of the<br />

other two candidates. This <strong>watch</strong> isn’t<br />

meant to look sporty or to cope <strong>with</strong> rough blows. Aesthetics and<br />

style are the paramount factors here. The bicolor case <strong>with</strong> the solid<br />

gold bezel, the little onion-shaped crown <strong>with</strong> the golden cap, and<br />

above all the elegant design of the dial are the principal ingredients<br />

that combine to create the typical Maurice Lacroix Masterpiece look,<br />

which invariably suggests horological complications. The snap-on<br />

glass back helps to keep the <strong>watch</strong> beautifully slim and invites you to<br />

admire the movement, which boasts individually blued screws, goldplated<br />

faux chatons, and concentrically circular engravings on the<br />

bridges and cocks. The depression milled into the plate to accept the<br />

balance has been embellished <strong>with</strong> an attractive sun pattern. The<br />

<strong>watch</strong> makes do <strong>with</strong>out bridles because the movement fits snugly inside<br />

the case, all the way to the edge, where it’s held in place from behind<br />

by a pair of little screws. The screw balance oscillates at the standard<br />

pace of five beats per second.<br />

Panerai has made no structural modifications in the Unitas <strong>caliber</strong>.<br />

Nonetheless, the movement inside the Luminor Marina has some special<br />

attractions all its own. Whereas the majority of brands that use<br />

the Unitas 6497 or 6498 opt for the<br />

The Chronoswiss Timemaster<br />

is the only one of the<br />

<strong>caliber</strong> in its best-known form (<strong>with</strong><br />

an oscillating rate of 18,000 beats per<br />

hour), Panerai chose the variant <strong>with</strong><br />

three <strong>with</strong> a stop-seconds the speedier oscillation of 21,600<br />

beats per hour. In general, a fasterpaced<br />

balance tends to produce a<br />

function – a useful feature<br />

<strong>watch</strong> that runs at a more stable rate.<br />

that makes it easier to precisely<br />

set the <strong>watch</strong> this is the only one of our <strong>test</strong> candi-<br />

And a stable rate is essential, because<br />

dates that has been officially<br />

C.O.S.C.-certified as a chronometer.<br />

In our <strong>test</strong> on the Witschi timing machine,<br />

the Panerai <strong>watch</strong> outdid its competitors, albeit only by a nose.<br />

It was interesting to see that the <strong>caliber</strong> <strong>with</strong> 21,600 beats per hour<br />

showed the same characteristics as the one <strong>with</strong> 18,000 beats. Like<br />

the Chronoswiss and Maurice Lacroix timepieces, the Luminor Marina<br />

slipped into the "minus" ballpark when <strong>test</strong>ed in the "crown down"<br />

position. And like its two competitors, the Panerai <strong>watch</strong> ran fas<strong>test</strong><br />

ahead in the "crown left" position. The average amplitude (320°) remained<br />

relatively high, although not quite as high as in the other two<br />

models.<br />

The extravagance of the case’s design continues in the finissage of<br />

the movement. Rather than opting for classical Geneva Waves, the<br />

bridges and cocks are decorated <strong>with</strong> the word "Panerai" in a repetitious<br />

scheme that’s reminiscent of the one used by Cartier <strong>with</strong> its characteristic<br />

"C." Gold-plated faux chatons and blued screws round out<br />

the picture which, unfortunately, remains largely hidden to the casual<br />

observer because there’s no viewing window in the twelve-sided,<br />

screw-in back.<br />

Although Panerai cautiously approached the new launch in 1993<br />

and, after its takeover by the Richemont Concern, has partly focused its<br />

attention on limited-edition <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong>, the timepiece that’s colloquially<br />

known as "The Panerai" quickly established itself as a cult <strong>watch</strong>. In the<br />

<strong>watch</strong>’s Italian homeland, as well as in many other countries around the<br />

world, numerous fan clubs have been formed. Watch-lovers who join<br />

these clubs supply one another <strong>with</strong> detailed information about the science<br />

and technology embodied in current and historical models, and<br />

also draw up tables describing all of the models that Panerai ever produced.<br />

It was in 1936 that Mussolini commissioned the Florentine firm<br />

of Officine Panerai to produce highly (or rather "deeply") water-resistant<br />

<strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong> for the Italian navy. In addition to being suitable for underwater<br />

use, Il Duce’s list of specifications also insisted that the <strong>watch</strong>-<br />

68 WatchTime February 2002


COMPARATIVE TEST: WATCHES WITH UNITAS POCKET WATCH CALIBER<br />

es offer optimal legibility, both in the dark and underwater. The hands<br />

and dials of the earliest Panerai <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong> were coated <strong>with</strong> strongly radioactive<br />

materials. These were soon replaced <strong>with</strong> less radioactive but<br />

nonetheless luminous tritium, and the<br />

name was correspondingly changed Because it has twice as<br />

from Radiomir to Luminor.<br />

many teeth, the Maurice<br />

The contemporary models combine<br />

the historical frogman myth <strong>with</strong> Lacroix’s hour-wheel requires<br />

24 hours to rotate<br />

urbane Italian elegance. This newly<br />

elegant role coincides <strong>with</strong> the delivery<br />

of a natural brown calfskin wristband<br />

along <strong>with</strong> the more military-<br />

once around its own axis.<br />

looking rubber strap. Because the The result is a 24-hour<br />

strap lugs are screwed, a tiny <strong>watch</strong>maker’s<br />

screwdriver is delivered inside<br />

display.<br />

the lacquered cherry wood box.<br />

Before pulling out the crown to adjust the hands, you must first release<br />

the safety lever and pivot it open. It’s also a good idea to release<br />

the lever before winding the <strong>watch</strong>. When the lever has been returned<br />

to its closed position, the crown is pressed about two millimeters<br />

Panerai has hidden its beautiful, chronometer-certified movement<br />

beneath a steel back.<br />

DATA PAGE<br />

PANERAI LUMINOR MARINA<br />

Manufacturer: Officine Panerai<br />

Model: Luminor Marina<br />

Reference number: PAM 00001<br />

Functions: Hours, minutes, small seconds.<br />

Movement: Hand-wound base <strong>caliber</strong> Unitas<br />

6497-2; diameter = 36 mm; height = 4.5 mm;<br />

21,600 beats per hour; 17 jewels; 41-hour<br />

power reserve; monometallic smooth-rimmed<br />

Glucydur balance; Incabloc shock absorption;<br />

decorated <strong>with</strong> "PANERAI" insignia; no stopseconds<br />

function; <strong>test</strong>ed chronometer <strong>with</strong><br />

C.O.S.C. certificate.<br />

Case: AISI 316 steel, polished; domed 3.5-mmthick<br />

antireflective sapphire crystal; black dial;<br />

hands, numerals and indices are all coated <strong>with</strong><br />

tritium; crown <strong>with</strong> locking lever; screw-down<br />

back; water-resistant to 300 meters; <strong>test</strong>ed to a<br />

maximum of 400 meters depth.<br />

Wristband and clasp: Brown calfskin <strong>with</strong><br />

pronged buckle.<br />

Results of running <strong>test</strong> (deviations in<br />

seconds 24 hours):<br />

Dial up: 2<br />

Dial down: 1<br />

Crown up: 2<br />

Crown down: –1<br />

Crown left: 5<br />

Grea<strong>test</strong> deviation of rate: 6<br />

Average deviation: 2<br />

Average amplitude of the balance: 320°<br />

Dimensions: Diameter = 44 mm;<br />

height = 16.8 mm; weight = 135 grams<br />

Special features: The model is also available for<br />

left-handers <strong>with</strong> its crown beside the "9."<br />

Price: $2,700<br />

The Luminor Marina<br />

can be recognized<br />

by the prominent<br />

protective lever<br />

that covers the<br />

crown. You need to<br />

unlatch the lever<br />

before you can set<br />

the <strong>watch</strong>’s hands.<br />

Sleek elegance: the<br />

Panerai wristband<br />

is made of natural<br />

brown calfskin.<br />

70 WatchTime February 2002


deeper into the case. This additional pressure makes a significant contribution<br />

to the <strong>watch</strong>’s ability to resist penetration by water: it’s water-resistant<br />

to 30 atmospheres. The slightly domed sapphire crystal is<br />

likewise crafted for deep submersion: it’s fully 3.5 millimeters thick.<br />

Although the no-nonsense Panerai looks quite massive, it’s relatively<br />

lightweight and quite pleasant to wear on its leather wristband. The<br />

case is painstakingly crafted: although it’s entirely <strong>with</strong>out sharp edges,<br />

it’s nonetheless clearly structured. Unfortunately, the glass overlaps a<br />

wee bit. If you’re puzzled about the meaning of the letters and numbers<br />

on the case back, here’s the answer, reading from top to bottom:<br />

the identification number of the case; the serial number of the <strong>watch</strong>;<br />

the number in the annual production; and the maximal atmospheric<br />

pressure (or depth) to which the <strong>watch</strong> remains water-resistant.<br />

The clearly designed dial and the decision to do <strong>with</strong>out a minutescircle,<br />

the hefty shape of the case, the obviously thick crystal, and last<br />

but not least, the distinctive locking lever over the crown struck a<br />

chord <strong>with</strong> <strong>watch</strong>-lovers when the Panerai was revived in the late<br />

1990s, and its continued popularity comes as no surprise.<br />

TEST RESULTS<br />

CHRONOSWISS TIMEMASTER<br />

Wristband and clasp (max. 10 points): 8<br />

Very good materials and craftsmanship; too<br />

much play in the band’s terminal inner clips;<br />

possibility of wearing out early.<br />

Operation (5): 5<br />

Optimal, even <strong>with</strong> gloves; setting the hands is<br />

an ultra-smooth experience.<br />

Case (10): 9<br />

Very high quality in all details, just as one<br />

always finds on Chronoswiss cases.<br />

Design (15): 13<br />

Unusual yet logical; successful combination of<br />

Chronoswiss design <strong>with</strong> the look of a deck<strong>watch</strong>.<br />

Legibility (5): 4<br />

We decided to subtract one point because<br />

the seconds-hand lacks tritium.<br />

Wearing comfort (10): 8<br />

Good; the large crown scarcely interferes.<br />

Movement (20): 14<br />

Intelligently improved, large-series <strong>caliber</strong><br />

<strong>with</strong> appealing embellishments.<br />

Results of running <strong>test</strong> (10): 8<br />

Good results <strong>with</strong> a very slight tendency to run<br />

fast.<br />

Overall value (15): 12<br />

Not inexpensive, but the price is justifiable for<br />

an extravagant <strong>watch</strong> <strong>with</strong> plenty of appealing<br />

extras.<br />

TOTAL: 81 points<br />

★★★★<br />

MAURICE LACROIX MASTERPIECE<br />

JOUR & NUIT<br />

Wristband and clasp (max. 10 points): 9<br />

Very well crafted, fully padded crocodile-skin<br />

wristband <strong>with</strong> typical bicolor ML clasp<br />

Operation (5): Good operation; the crown isn’t<br />

very large. 4<br />

Case (10): 8<br />

Well crafted, slender construction; the holes<br />

for the strap’s crosspieces are drilled very close<br />

at the ends of the lugs.<br />

Design (15): 12<br />

Typically elegant Masterpiece design <strong>with</strong> a<br />

stylish aura.<br />

Legibility (5): 3<br />

Takes some time to get used to, but after<br />

wards the owner can readily tell the time while<br />

the uninitiated remain pleasingly perplexed.<br />

Wearing comfort (10): 10<br />

Lies perfectly on the wrist; light weight and<br />

<strong>with</strong>out any sharp corners.<br />

Movement (20): 13<br />

Technically modified <strong>pocket</strong> <strong>watch</strong> <strong>caliber</strong> <strong>with</strong><br />

tasteful embellishment.<br />

Results of running <strong>test</strong> (10): 8<br />

Good, comparable <strong>with</strong> those achieved by the<br />

Chronoswiss <strong>watch</strong>.<br />

Overall value (15): 12<br />

A little pricey, but a rather unusual design.<br />

TOTAL: 79 points<br />

★★★<br />

PANERAI LUMINOR MARINA<br />

Wristband and clasp (max. 10 points): 8<br />

Strikingly wide wristband is sporty yet elegant.<br />

Operation (5): 5<br />

Simple and pleasant; locking lever is easy to<br />

open.<br />

Case (10): 8<br />

Massive and elaborately crafted, polished to a<br />

high-gloss finish.<br />

Design (15): 14<br />

Consistent, successful, readily recognizable; a<br />

trendsetter that will elicit admiration.<br />

Legibility (5): 4<br />

It’s difficult to read the minutes <strong>with</strong> precision,<br />

but the dial is perfectly legible in the dark.<br />

Wearing comfort (10): 8<br />

The <strong>watch</strong> is large and hefty, but not as heavy as<br />

it looks; no sharp corners; a good fit on the<br />

wrist.<br />

Movement (20): 12<br />

Few modifications have been made to the<br />

Unitas base <strong>caliber</strong>; chronometer quality;<br />

idiosyncratic decorative embellishment.<br />

Results of running <strong>test</strong> (10): 8<br />

Similar to but slightly better than those achieved<br />

by the Chronoswiss and ML <strong><strong>watch</strong>es</strong>.<br />

Overall value (15): 12<br />

An aficionado’s <strong>watch</strong> at an excellent price.<br />

TOTAL: 79 points<br />

★★★<br />

February 2002 WatchTime 71

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!