Haase_UZ_x007E_DTh (2).pdf - South African Theological Seminary

Haase_UZ_x007E_DTh (2).pdf - South African Theological Seminary Haase_UZ_x007E_DTh (2).pdf - South African Theological Seminary

satsonline.org
from satsonline.org More from this publisher
20.01.2015 Views

40 Existentialism Romanticism inevitably gave way to another wave of modernity, another resurgence of humanistic rationalism, materialism and naturalism -- the pendulum swinging back the other way, as it always seems to do. Once again, life became mechanistic and devoid of ontological significance. It had less meaning, romance, feeling and sense of greater purpose, or raison d’être. Predictably, a new wave of frustration with modernity arose and with it came another romantic reaction: existentialism. Existentialism makes a significant contribution to postmodernism and with Nihilism, is closely related to it. Grenz and various others acknowledge the contribution of Heidegger (e.g., the father of German Existentialism) to postmodern thinking (1996:103- 104). While Veith (1994:19, 37-38, 42, 73, etc.) and Erickson (2001:75-84, 93-96, 131, 310), give considerable attention to making the historical-philosophical connection. Veith says, for example: “Existentialism provides the rationale for contemporary relativism. Since everyone creates his or her own meaning, every meaning is equally valid” (Veith, 1994:38). And, “Existentialism is the philosophical basis for postmodernism” (ibid, 38). Existentialism -- like the far more radical postmodernism -- is a movement of frustration, an attempt to find the individual self, to find meaning and purpose in life, beyond some mechanistically determined existence. Both existentialism and postmodernism are difficult to define. Practitioners from both camps are diverse, sometimes unified, though just as often diverse. Modernity produces people who feel trapped, unable to see, think, or feel beyond the natural limits imposed upon them. Mankind then wonders: is there no more to life than this Is this all there is Existentialism is in part a protest movement against modern, mass society. The organization of industry, technology, politics and bureaucracy tend to stifle individual thought and action and cultivate conformist mediocrity (Brown, 1968:184). University of Zululand, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa

41 Existentialism understandably emerged after horrors WWI in Europe, called the ‘war to end all wars.’ In the wake of this great insanity came a time when people were forced to face as never before, the new horrors man had unleashed upon itself. It “sprang up in Germany after the First World War; it flourished in France immediately after the second” (Brown, 1968:181). Existentialism eventually made its way to North America, though it is still primarily considered a Continental philosophy. There are two kinds of existentialism, Christian and atheistic, though both streams reject the modernist agenda with its assumptions about a Newtonian or perfectly ordered universe. Existentialists in general proposed that truth was relative, subjective and personal; that ultimate truth was either unknowable, or nonexistent. Thus, individuals must create their own truth, or reality, in this vast meaningless universe in which we live. This truth-relativism is a primary characteristic of both existentialism and postmodernism. Existentialism, especially in its atheistic form, acknowledged science as an objective discipline, but refused to attribute to it the ability to answer questions of ultimate meaning. In fact, nearly all existentialists have long argued that science could not provide answers about humanity’s greater purpose -- our raison d'être. Many religionists suggested some notion about mankind’s greater purpose and gave some ethereal hope, or expectation for the future. Yet, ‘inevitable progress’ via technological advancement was modernity’s eschatology and the great driving force behind Western civilization. Existentialism is neither a religion, nor a belief construct. Like postmodernism, it offers no answers, establishes no ethics, nor provides any real enlightenment, or guidance. “Existentialism is not a philosophy but a label for several widely different revolts against traditional philosophy” (Kaufmann, 1975:11). It is not a school of thought, as it were, nor is it reducible to a set of tenets. Existentialism both identifies and promotes the anguish, or angst, and helplessness that inevitably leads to loneliness, despair, and nihilism. The existentialist is typically very distrustful and sceptical, though certainly not to the degree the postmodernist is. Existentialism says that a “proposition or truth is said to be existential when I cannot apprehend or assent to it from the standpoint of a mere spectator but only on the ground of my total existence” (Brown, 1968:182). University of Zululand, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa

40<br />

Existentialism<br />

Romanticism inevitably gave way to another wave of modernity, another resurgence of<br />

humanistic rationalism, materialism and naturalism -- the pendulum swinging back the<br />

other way, as it always seems to do. Once again, life became mechanistic and devoid of<br />

ontological significance. It had less meaning, romance, feeling and sense of greater<br />

purpose, or raison d’être. Predictably, a new wave of frustration with modernity arose<br />

and with it came another romantic reaction: existentialism.<br />

Existentialism makes a significant contribution to postmodernism and with Nihilism,<br />

is closely related to it. Grenz and various others acknowledge the contribution of<br />

Heidegger (e.g., the father of German Existentialism) to postmodern thinking (1996:103-<br />

104). While Veith (1994:19, 37-38, 42, 73, etc.) and Erickson (2001:75-84, 93-96, 131,<br />

310), give considerable attention to making the historical-philosophical connection.<br />

Veith says, for example: “Existentialism provides the rationale for contemporary<br />

relativism. Since everyone creates his or her own meaning, every meaning is equally<br />

valid” (Veith, 1994:38). And, “Existentialism is the philosophical basis for<br />

postmodernism” (ibid, 38).<br />

Existentialism -- like the far more radical postmodernism -- is a movement of<br />

frustration, an attempt to find the individual self, to find meaning and purpose in life,<br />

beyond some mechanistically determined existence. Both existentialism and<br />

postmodernism are difficult to define. Practitioners from both camps are diverse,<br />

sometimes unified, though just as often diverse.<br />

Modernity produces people who feel trapped, unable to see, think, or feel beyond the<br />

natural limits imposed upon them. Mankind then wonders: is there no more to life than<br />

this Is this all there is<br />

Existentialism is in part a protest movement<br />

against modern, mass society. The<br />

organization of industry, technology, politics<br />

and bureaucracy tend to stifle individual<br />

thought and action and cultivate conformist<br />

mediocrity (Brown, 1968:184).<br />

University of Zululand, KwaZulu-Natal, <strong>South</strong> Africa

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!