Bachelor of Commerce (Digital Marketing) - Postsecondary ...

Bachelor of Commerce (Digital Marketing) - Postsecondary ... Bachelor of Commerce (Digital Marketing) - Postsecondary ...

19.01.2015 Views

Section 7. Employer Perceptions of Postsecondary Business Programs Employers were invited to share their views about the strengths and weaknesses of business degree programs offered at university, compared to college business degree programs. They were also asked about the need for Fanshawe College to offer business degree programs, in light of business degrees available at area universities, and to continue to offer business diploma programs. University Business Degrees Strengths Employers most frequently identified the breadth and depth of theoretical knowledge that students receive during a university program of study as its key strength. The second most commonly cited strength was the reputation and prestige of a university education, with a few Employers commenting that university faculty are more highly educated than college faculty. Critical thinking skills were another key attribute (with some Employers singling out the business case model for particular mention). This was followed by the belief that university entry‐requirements lead to higher‐calibre graduates, who have demonstrated a commitment to education and received less “hand‐holding” throughout their education than college students. Although mentioned less frequently, other strengths included opportunities for students to gain an international perspective and experience, develop strong writing and communication skills, and engage in networking. University attracts a higher calibre of student. They offer a wider scope and higher level discussion. Lateral thinking, international placements, the non‐business courses that students take before acceptance into the business program leads to broader thinking and understanding which provides a valuable larger context, and university students bring strong writing and communication skills, which is a critical difference from college grads. Reputation (whether it is right or not). In some of the theory there is good depth. Credibility (that's a lot of the strength of university). There is a perception of higher entrance requirements and a perception of higher quality instructors. The higher level thinking and analysis and the expectations of the student. University has higher standards for entry than college and it makes a difference. The individual must be self‐taught, self‐motivated. No hand‐holding. The quality of education at the theoretical level ... the importance of the selection process in determining success. Not just anyone is accepted, and that gives grads a certain status. Weaknesses Employers also identified some weaknesses related to university business degree programs, with most expressing concerns about university students’ lack of hands‐on experience and practical skills. Employers often suggested that universities can be too focused on theoretical knowledge and that graduates do not always know how to apply their knowledge to the workplace. Another significant theme that emerged was that university graduates may have an air of entitlement – even “arrogance” – and often have unrealistic expectations about the positions and the pay that they qualify for. Other less frequently cited weaknesses included lack of co‐op opportunities, the cost of university, the lack of LKSB Degree Program Feasibility Study • 2011 210

specialization opportunities, and the time involved. Two Employers felt there were no weaknesses to a university education. The students sometimes have an "aura of greatness", their practical application skills in the workplace can take a while to get going, they have no training in business execution. Not very realistic and not hands‐on. Too much theory, not enough practical, hands‐on. With general business degrees there's not always opportunities for employment. They lack a specific technical skill. The sense of entitlement and how much they think they should get paid on day one. Affordability for the employer ... grads usually have salary expectations that are out of reach. Grads also aren't looking for entry level positions, they often want to start as management trainees. College Business Degrees Strengths Since many Employers had not hired graduates of college degree programs, most drew on their experiences with graduates of college diploma programs to describe strengths and weaknesses associated with college. A common theme expressed by Employers – and by far the most important strength mentioned – was the focus on hands‐on experience during a college education, which graduates can then apply directly in the workplace. Several Employers described college graduates as “ready to hit the ground running,” with specialized knowledge that allows them to adapt quickly to the workplace. Closely related to hands‐on experience, the mandatory co‐op component was another popular strength. Some Employers felt that college students graduate with more realistic expectations than university graduates, with a few noting that college students have a better attitude and are willing to work harder than university students. The accessibility, affordability, and flexibility of the college model were regarded as important strengths by several Employers. Many Employers also valued the real‐life experiences brought to the classroom by college instructors, and the close interactions between students and instructors in small class settings. Two Employers felt there were no strengths to a college degree. Good knowledge of tactical resources available, a fair bit of current environment information instead of just older theory, better at the digital side of things. I would probably look at a student with college education before a student with a university education. College education at the business level is more realistic. Educators at college have been in business in the real world. An instructor is going to teach not only the course but also how it is in the real world. The students are given realistic expectations. Fanshawe grads are more hands‐on and tech‐ish. They have more realistic expectations in the workplace. They have better discipline about getting things done in a certain timeframe. We hire more Fanshawe grads for this reason. LKSB Degree Program Feasibility Study • 2011 211

specialization opportunities, and the time involved. Two Employers felt there were no weaknesses to a<br />

university education.<br />

The students sometimes have an "aura <strong>of</strong> greatness", their practical application skills in the<br />

workplace can take a while to get going, they have no training in business execution.<br />

Not very realistic and not hands‐on.<br />

Too much theory, not enough practical, hands‐on.<br />

With general business degrees there's not always opportunities for employment. They lack a<br />

specific technical skill.<br />

The sense <strong>of</strong> entitlement and how much they think they should get paid on day one.<br />

Affordability for the employer ... grads usually have salary expectations that are out <strong>of</strong> reach.<br />

Grads also aren't looking for entry level positions, they <strong>of</strong>ten want to start as management<br />

trainees.<br />

College Business Degrees<br />

Strengths<br />

Since many Employers had not hired graduates <strong>of</strong> college degree programs, most drew on their<br />

experiences with graduates <strong>of</strong> college diploma programs to describe strengths and weaknesses<br />

associated with college. A common theme expressed by Employers – and by far the most important<br />

strength mentioned – was the focus on hands‐on experience during a college education, which<br />

graduates can then apply directly in the workplace. Several Employers described college graduates as<br />

“ready to hit the ground running,” with specialized knowledge that allows them to adapt quickly to the<br />

workplace. Closely related to hands‐on experience, the mandatory co‐op component was another<br />

popular strength. Some Employers felt that college students graduate with more realistic expectations<br />

than university graduates, with a few noting that college students have a better attitude and are willing<br />

to work harder than university students. The accessibility, affordability, and flexibility <strong>of</strong> the college<br />

model were regarded as important strengths by several Employers. Many Employers also valued the<br />

real‐life experiences brought to the classroom by college instructors, and the close interactions between<br />

students and instructors in small class settings. Two Employers felt there were no strengths to a college<br />

degree.<br />

Good knowledge <strong>of</strong> tactical resources available, a fair bit <strong>of</strong> current environment information<br />

instead <strong>of</strong> just older theory, better at the digital side <strong>of</strong> things.<br />

I would probably look at a student with college education before a student with a university<br />

education. College education at the business level is more realistic. Educators at college have<br />

been in business in the real world. An instructor is going to teach not only the course but also<br />

how it is in the real world. The students are given realistic expectations.<br />

Fanshawe grads are more hands‐on and tech‐ish. They have more realistic expectations in the<br />

workplace. They have better discipline about getting things done in a certain timeframe. We hire<br />

more Fanshawe grads for this reason.<br />

LKSB Degree Program Feasibility Study • 2011<br />

211

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!